{"schema": 1, "generated": "2026-11-01", "notes": ["A link means two things occur in the same segment. It does not mean agreement, endorsement or a ruling.", "Segments with a guest speaker are excluded from entity citation edges and entity counts; they still count for topics.", "Every edge lists the segments it comes from. Counts are the length of that list."], "counts": {"recordings": 259, "segments": 1904, "topics": 188, "entities": 2140, "nodes": 2587, "edges": 20083, "guest_segments_excluded_from_citations": 431}, "node_types": ["book", "event", "hadith", "org", "person", "principle", "quran", "recording", "scholar", "term", "topic"], "entity_types": ["book", "event", "hadith", "org", "person", "principle", "quran", "scholar", "term"], "edge_kinds": ["cited_on", "cites", "co_occurs", "discusses"], "years": {"min": "2014", "max": "2025"}, "nodes": [{"id": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "label": "Arabic poetry and men of letters", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 7, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/book-lounge", "label": "Book Lounge and book reviews", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:arts/film-and-popular-culture", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/film-and-popular-culture", "label": "Film and popular culture", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "label": "Persian and Sufi poetry", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "label": "Philosophy and ideas", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 3, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 11, "2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "label": "Language and semiotics", "parent": "arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas", "Philosophy and ideas"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "label": "Narrative and story", "parent": "arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas", "Philosophy and ideas"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:arts/poetry-and-the-mind", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/poetry-and-the-mind", "label": "Poetry, quotes and the mind", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/science-and-the-universe", "label": "Science, the universe and big questions", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "type": "topic", "key": "arts/urdu-poetry", "label": "Urdu poetry", "parent": "arts", "crumbs": ["Books, poetry and ideas"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2019": 4, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:belief/afterlife", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/afterlife", "label": "The afterlife", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "label": "The grave and the barzakh", "parent": "belief/afterlife", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "The afterlife"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "label": "Paradise and hell", "parent": "belief/afterlife", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "The afterlife"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "label": "Ahmadiyya and false messiahs", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 6, "2020": 8, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "label": "Atheism and the existence of God", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 4, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "label": "Creed and the schools of theology", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 53, "recordings": 28, "years": {"2018": 15, "2019": 5, "2020": 15, "2021": 14, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 53}}, {"id": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/dreams-and-visions", "label": "Dreams and visions", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:belief/eschatology", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/eschatology", "label": "End times and the Day of Judgement", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "label": "Dajjal, Mahdi and the signs", "parent": "belief/eschatology", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "End times and the Day of Judgement"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2018": 15, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 17}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "label": "The second coming of Jesus", "parent": "belief/eschatology", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "End times and the Day of Judgement"], "segments": 95, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2018": 35, "2020": 5, "2021": 55}, "tiers": {"machine": 95}}, {"id": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/free-will-and-destiny", "label": "Free will and destiny", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2020": 5, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/god-and-attributes", "label": "God and the divine attributes", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 13, "2021": 7, "2022": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "label": "Evil and suffering", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "label": "Prophethood and miracles", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 50, "recordings": 27, "years": {"2018": 9, "2019": 6, "2020": 19, "2021": 13, "2025": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 50}}, {"id": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/reason-and-revelation", "label": "Reason and revelation", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 83, "recordings": 32, "years": {"2016": 2, "2017": 4, "2018": 32, "2019": 9, "2020": 19, "2021": 14, "2023": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 83}}, {"id": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "label": "Salvation and non-Muslims", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 5, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "label": "Sects, sectarianism and takfir", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 47, "recordings": 29, "years": {"2015": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 12, "2019": 3, "2020": 10, "2021": 17, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 47}}, {"id": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "label": "Salafism and Wahhabism", "parent": "belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "Sects, sectarianism and takfir"], "segments": 38, "recordings": 26, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 5, "2020": 14, "2021": 11, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 38}}, {"id": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "label": "Soul, nafs and consciousness", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2020": 8, "2021": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "label": "Spiritual experience and psychedelics", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2020": 11, "2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "topic:belief/sufism", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/sufism", "label": "Sufism and tasawwuf", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 6, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "label": "Ibn Arabi", "parent": "belief/sufism", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "Sufism and tasawwuf"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "label": "Tawhid and shirk", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 8, "2021": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/unseen-beings", "label": "Jinn, angels and the devil", "parent": "belief", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology"], "segments": 23, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2017": 5, "2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 7, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "label": "Jinn possession", "parent": "belief/unseen-beings", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "Jinn, angels and the devil"], "segments": 61, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 25, "2018": 17, "2019": 1, "2020": 16, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 61}}, {"id": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "type": "topic", "key": "belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "label": "Magic, the evil eye and superstition", "parent": "belief/unseen-beings", "crumbs": ["Belief and theology", "Jinn, angels and the devil"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 15, "2019": 1, "2020": 17, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "label": "Atheists and polemicists", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 27, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 18, "2020": 5, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "label": "Christians and other faiths", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 51, "recordings": 31, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 12, "2019": 8, "2020": 19, "2021": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 51}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "label": "Debate challenges and reviews", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 39, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 2, "2020": 14, "2021": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 39}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/guest-conversations", "label": "Guest conversations", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 141, "recordings": 18, "years": {"2016": 7, "2017": 14, "2020": 91, "2021": 15, "2025": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 141}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/responses-to-critics", "label": "Responses to critics", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 102, "recordings": 33, "years": {"2018": 52, "2019": 11, "2020": 9, "2021": 30}, "tiers": {"machine": 102}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "label": "Exchanges with Yasir Qadhi", "parent": "dialogue/responses-to-critics", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses", "Responses to critics"], "segments": 90, "recordings": 19, "years": {"2018": 17, "2019": 12, "2020": 14, "2021": 47}, "tiers": {"machine": 90}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "label": "Sunni-Shia dialogue", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 27, "recordings": 18, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 4, "2020": 11, "2021": 9, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "label": "The Mufti and the channel", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 65, "recordings": 33, "years": {"2014": 4, "2015": 5, "2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 7, "2020": 12, "2021": 35}, "tiers": {"machine": 65}}, {"id": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "type": "topic", "key": "dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "label": "Views on contemporary scholars", "parent": "dialogue", "crumbs": ["Dialogue and responses"], "segments": 113, "recordings": 56, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 6, "2019": 15, "2020": 48, "2021": 38, "2022": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 113}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/animals-and-pets", "label": "Animals and pets", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/divorce", "label": "Divorce", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 4, "2020": 5, "2021": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "label": "Dress and appearance", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 26, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 2, "2017": 4, "2018": 8, "2019": 3, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 26}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "label": "Beard, moustache and hair", "parent": "fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Dress and appearance"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2014": 5, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "label": "Jewellery, gold and silk for men", "parent": "fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Dress and appearance"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 10, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/entertainment", "label": "Entertainment, sport and leisure", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/entertainment/music", "label": "Music", "parent": "fiqh/entertainment", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Entertainment, sport and leisure"], "segments": 25, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 13, "2020": 2, "2021": 8, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 25}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting", "label": "Fasting", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "label": "Who is excused from fasting", "parent": "fiqh/fasting", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Fasting"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "label": "Making up, fidya and kaffarah", "parent": "fiqh/fasting", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Fasting"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "label": "Taraweeh, i'tikaf and Laylat al-Qadr", "parent": "fiqh/fasting", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Fasting"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "label": "Fasting times, moon sighting and the calendar", "parent": "fiqh/fasting", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Fasting"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "label": "What breaks the fast", "parent": "fiqh/fasting", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Fasting"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "label": "Non-Muslim festivals and greetings", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/finance", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/finance", "label": "Money and finance", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "label": "Riba, mortgages and loans", "parent": "fiqh/finance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Money and finance"], "segments": 31, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 13, "2020": 13, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/food", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/food", "label": "Food and drink", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "label": "Funerals and burial", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/gender-interaction", "label": "Interaction between men and women", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 26, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2014": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 13, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 26}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "label": "Hajj and umrah", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "label": "Hijab and niqab", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 23, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2014": 4, "2018": 1, "2019": 4, "2020": 6, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/inheritance", "label": "Inheritance", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "label": "Intoxicants and substances", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 5, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "label": "Psychedelics", "parent": "fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Intoxicants and substances"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2020": 8, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/legal-theory", "label": "Legal theory and method", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 81, "recordings": 47, "years": {"2014": 3, "2015": 6, "2016": 2, "2017": 10, "2018": 11, "2019": 13, "2020": 19, "2021": 12, "2022": 1, "2023": 2, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 81}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "label": "Schools of law and following them", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 21, "years": {"2014": 10, "2015": 1, "2017": 5, "2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "label": "The Hanafi school and Imam Abu Hanifa", "parent": "fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Schools of law and following them"], "segments": 45, "recordings": 22, "years": {"2015": 2, "2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 19, "2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 45}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/maliki-school", "label": "The Maliki school", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 67, "recordings": 37, "years": {"2014": 10, "2015": 5, "2017": 10, "2018": 7, "2019": 5, "2020": 11, "2021": 14, "2022": 1, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 67}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "label": "The Muwatta and the Mudawwana", "parent": "fiqh/maliki-school", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "The Maliki school"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "label": "The Risalah and the Ashmawiya", "parent": "fiqh/maliki-school", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "The Maliki school"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/marriage-contracts", "label": "The marriage contract", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 8, "2019": 11, "2020": 5, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/medical-ethics", "label": "Medical questions", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "label": "Polygamy and mut'ah", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 6, "2021": 4, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/prayer", "label": "Prayer", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2017": 13, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 6, "2021": 5, "2022": 2, "2025": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "label": "Conditions of a valid prayer", "parent": "fiqh/prayer", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Prayer"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "label": "Congregation, Friday and Eid prayer", "parent": "fiqh/prayer", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Prayer"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "label": "Missed prayers", "parent": "fiqh/prayer", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Prayer"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "label": "Public law and governance", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 30, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2015": 2, "2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 18, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 30}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "label": "Apostasy and blasphemy", "parent": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Public law and governance"], "segments": 28, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2018": 14, "2019": 3, "2020": 5, "2021": 5, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "label": "Caliphate", "parent": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Public law and governance"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 4, "2018": 6, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "label": "Hudud and punishments", "parent": "fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice", "Public law and governance"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2020": 9, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/purification", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/purification", "label": "Purification", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 8, "2022": 1, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/sexual-ethics", "label": "Sexual ethics", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 41, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 22, "2021": 12, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 41}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "label": "Speech and everyday conduct", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 8, "2018": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/work-and-study-life", "label": "Work, study and daily routine", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "type": "topic", "key": "fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "label": "Zakat and charity", "parent": "fiqh", "crumbs": ["Fiqh and daily practice"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/authentication", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/authentication", "label": "Authenticating hadith", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 28, "recordings": 19, "years": {"2017": 7, "2018": 12, "2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "label": "Narrator criticism", "parent": "hadith/authentication", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies", "Authenticating hadith"], "segments": 59, "recordings": 32, "years": {"2018": 24, "2019": 4, "2020": 7, "2021": 22, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 59}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "label": "Text criticism, reason and the Quran", "parent": "hadith/authentication", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies", "Authenticating hadith"], "segments": 66, "recordings": 36, "years": {"2018": 41, "2019": 1, "2020": 10, "2021": 12, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 66}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/bukhari", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari (BukhariGate)", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 89, "recordings": 40, "years": {"2017": 6, "2018": 42, "2019": 4, "2020": 12, "2021": 22, "2022": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 89}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/collections-and-compilation", "label": "Hadith collections and their history", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 13, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/false-and-fabricated", "label": "False and fabricated hadith", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 24, "years": {"2018": 14, "2019": 2, "2020": 6, "2021": 9, "2022": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "label": "Reports that disrespect the Prophet", "parent": "hadith/false-and-fabricated", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies", "False and fabricated hadith"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2018": 18, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "label": "Reports demeaning women", "parent": "hadith/false-and-fabricated", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies", "False and fabricated hadith"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 12, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "label": "Hadith in legal reasoning and hadith absolutism", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2014": 3, "2017": 6, "2018": 13, "2020": 5, "2021": 4, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "label": "Individual hadith explained", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 30, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 1, "2016": 2, "2017": 6, "2018": 8, "2019": 2, "2020": 7, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "label": "Mutawatir and certainty", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2018": 14, "2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 12, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/quran-only-movement", "label": "Quran-only movement", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 58, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 23, "2021": 5, "2025": 28}, "tiers": {"machine": 58}}, {"id": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "type": "topic", "key": "hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "label": "Sunnah versus hadith", "parent": "hadith", "crumbs": ["Hadith studies"], "segments": 41, "recordings": 27, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 7, "2019": 2, "2020": 10, "2021": 9, "2023": 6, "2025": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 41}}, {"id": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "type": "topic", "key": "history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "label": "Al-Andalus and the Maghrib", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "type": "topic", "key": "history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "label": "The ancient Near East and scripture", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 30, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 7, "2020": 10, "2021": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 30}}, {"id": "topic:history/companions", "type": "topic", "key": "history/companions", "label": "The companions", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 34, "recordings": 22, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 5, "2019": 8, "2020": 9, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 34}}, {"id": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "type": "topic", "key": "history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "label": "Succession and the first civil wars", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 16, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "type": "topic", "key": "history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "label": "Karbala", "parent": "history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "Succession and the first civil wars"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "type": "topic", "key": "history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "label": "'The Foundations of Islam' by Qadi Iyad", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:history/human-origins", "type": "topic", "key": "history/human-origins", "label": "Human origins", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "type": "topic", "key": "history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "label": "Modern reformers and movements", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "type": "topic", "key": "history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "label": "Orthodoxy and how Islam spread", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 26, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 4, "2020": 6, "2021": 4, "2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 26}}, {"id": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "type": "topic", "key": "history/pre-islamic-arabia", "label": "Pre-Islamic Arabia", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 10, "2020": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "type": "topic", "key": "history/scholars-and-imams", "label": "Scholars and imams of the past", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 46, "recordings": 31, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 3, "2017": 7, "2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 7, "2021": 16, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 46}}, {"id": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "type": "topic", "key": "history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "label": "Imam Malik", "parent": "history/scholars-and-imams", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "Scholars and imams of the past"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 3, "2023": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "topic:history/sirah", "type": "topic", "key": "history/sirah", "label": "The life of the Prophet", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 32, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2017": 10, "2018": 8, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 5, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 32}}, {"id": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "type": "topic", "key": "history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "label": "The age of Aisha", "parent": "history/sirah", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "The life of the Prophet"], "segments": 27, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 2, "2020": 14, "2021": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "type": "topic", "key": "history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "label": "Replies to attacks on the Prophet", "parent": "history/sirah", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "The life of the Prophet"], "segments": 23, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2018": 12, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "type": "topic", "key": "history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "label": "Isra and Mi'raj", "parent": "history/sirah", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "The life of the Prophet"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "type": "topic", "key": "history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "label": "The wives of the Prophet", "parent": "history/sirah", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life", "The life of the Prophet"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2018": 17, "2020": 10, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "type": "topic", "key": "history/strength-in-stories", "label": "Strength in Stories and why history matters", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:history/subcontinent", "type": "topic", "key": "history/subcontinent", "label": "The Indian subcontinent", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "type": "topic", "key": "history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "label": "Umayyads and Abbasids", "parent": "history", "crumbs": ["History and the Prophet's life"], "segments": 22, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 14, "2021": 2, "2022": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}}, {"id": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/arabic-language", "label": "Quranic Arabic", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 27, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2014": 1, "2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 6, "2020": 11, "2021": 4, "2024": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/hermeneutics", "label": "How to read the Quran", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 89, "recordings": 29, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 12, "2019": 15, "2020": 44, "2021": 11, "2022": 1, "2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 89}}, {"id": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "label": "Memorisation and recitation", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "label": "Preservation and variant readings", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 64, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 15, "2020": 42, "2021": 1, "2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 64}}, {"id": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/quran-and-science", "label": "Quran and science", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 2, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "label": "Quran and evolution", "parent": "quran/quran-and-science", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Quran and science"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 9, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "label": "Quranic guidance for living", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "label": "Stories of the prophets", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 40, "recordings": 19, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 8, "2019": 11, "2020": 13, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 40}}, {"id": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "label": "Adam and the creation of humans", "parent": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Stories of the prophets"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 5, "2021": 7, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "label": "Jesus in the Quran", "parent": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Stories of the prophets"], "segments": 37, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 5, "2020": 7, "2021": 16, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 37}}, {"id": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "label": "Moses", "parent": "quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Stories of the prophets"], "segments": 23, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 6, "2020": 3, "2021": 7, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "topic:quran/tafsir", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/tafsir", "label": "Tafsir and verse study", "parent": "quran", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir"], "segments": 61, "recordings": 33, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 3, "2018": 9, "2019": 7, "2020": 24, "2021": 8, "2022": 1, "2025": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 61}}, {"id": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "label": "Contested verses", "parent": "quran/tafsir", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Tafsir and verse study"], "segments": 35, "recordings": 18, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 16, "2020": 9, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 35}}, {"id": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "type": "topic", "key": "quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "label": "Reflections on short surahs", "parent": "quran/tafsir", "crumbs": ["Quran and tafsir", "Tafsir and verse study"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "label": "Friendship and social life", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/love-and-romance", "label": "Love and romance", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "label": "Love stories from history", "parent": "relationships/love-and-romance", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Love and romance"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/marriage", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/marriage", "label": "Marriage", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 4, "2018": 6, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "label": "Abuse in marriage", "parent": "relationships/marriage", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Marriage"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "label": "Choosing a spouse", "parent": "relationships/marriage", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Marriage"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/marriage/intimacy", "label": "Intimacy in marriage", "parent": "relationships/marriage", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Marriage"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "label": "Masculinity and gender roles", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/parents-and-children", "label": "Parents, children and family", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "label": "Abusive and difficult parents", "parent": "relationships/parents-and-children", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Parents, children and family"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "label": "Raising children", "parent": "relationships/parents-and-children", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family", "Parents, children and family"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 3, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "type": "topic", "key": "relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "label": "Sexuality and orientation", "parent": "relationships", "crumbs": ["Relationships and family"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 7, "2020": 1, "2021": 4, "2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "type": "topic", "key": "society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "label": "Blasphemy, insult and free speech", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 8, "2021": 1, "2022": 11, "2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "type": "topic", "key": "society/converts-and-newcomers", "label": "Converts and newcomers", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 5, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "type": "topic", "key": "society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "label": "Cults, clergy and religious abuse", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 42, "recordings": 19, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 9, "2020": 18, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 42}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events", "label": "Current events commentary", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 31, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 18, "2021": 9, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/britain", "label": "Britain", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2015": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/covid-19", "label": "Covid-19", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "label": "India and Hindutva", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "label": "Middle East and the wider world", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 37, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2015": 2, "2020": 22, "2021": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 37}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/pakistan", "label": "Pakistan", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2020": 12, "2021": 3, "2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "type": "topic", "key": "society/current-events/palestine", "label": "Palestine and Gaza", "parent": "society/current-events", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Current events commentary"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 7, "2021": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "type": "topic", "key": "society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "label": "Dawah and debate culture", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 44, "recordings": 29, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 7, "2019": 7, "2020": 14, "2021": 5, "2022": 1, "2023": 6, "2024": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 44}}, {"id": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "type": "topic", "key": "society/education-and-madrasas", "label": "Education, madrasas and seminaries", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 10, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "type": "topic", "key": "society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "label": "How to study Islam", "parent": "society/education-and-madrasas", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Education, madrasas and seminaries"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2014": 1, "2016": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 8, "2021": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "type": "topic", "key": "society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "label": "Extremism, crime and justice", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 37, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2015": 10, "2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2020": 11, "2021": 6, "2022": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 37}}, {"id": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "type": "topic", "key": "society/islam-and-modernity", "label": "Islam and modernity", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 70, "recordings": 36, "years": {"2015": 5, "2016": 5, "2017": 11, "2018": 5, "2019": 7, "2020": 21, "2021": 15, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 70}}, {"id": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "type": "topic", "key": "society/race-and-identity", "label": "Race, nation and identity", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2015": 2, "2016": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "type": "topic", "key": "society/technology-and-media", "label": "Technology and media", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "type": "topic", "key": "society/technology-and-media/social-media", "label": "Social media", "parent": "society/technology-and-media", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Technology and media"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 6, "2019": 4, "2020": 12, "2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "type": "topic", "key": "society/women-and-gender", "label": "Women in Islam", "parent": "society", "crumbs": ["Current events and society"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2014": 2, "2016": 1, "2017": 3, "2018": 7, "2019": 4, "2020": 5, "2021": 13, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "type": "topic", "key": "society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "label": "Women in worship and mosques", "parent": "society/women-and-gender", "crumbs": ["Current events and society", "Women in Islam"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 5, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "label": "Anger and forgiveness", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "label": "Character and virtue", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 31, "recordings": 25, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 4, "2020": 4, "2021": 5, "2022": 4, "2023": 4, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "label": "Facing death", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "label": "Depression and anxiety", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "label": "Gratitude, giving and contentment", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2023": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/grief", "label": "Grief and loss", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/health-and-fitness", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/health-and-fitness", "label": "Health and the body", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "label": "Islamic psychology", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "label": "Mindfulness and presence", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "label": "Motivation and purpose", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 4, "2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "label": "Goals, habits and willpower", "parent": "wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing", "Motivation and purpose"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "label": "Negative thoughts and mindset", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/personal-stories", "label": "Personal stories and reflections", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 10, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "label": "Religious guilt and scrupulosity", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 7, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "label": "Resilience in hardship", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "label": "Self-esteem, ego and confidence", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "label": "Tawakkul and trust in God", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "type": "topic", "key": "wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "label": "Trauma and healing", "parent": "wellbeing", "crumbs": ["Psychology, grief and wellbeing"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:adab-al-muallimin", "type": "book", "key": "adab-al-muallimin", "label": "Adab al-Mu'allimin [?]", "labels": ["Adab al-Mu'allimin [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "type": "book", "key": "ahkam-al-quran", "label": "Ahkam al-Quran", "labels": ["Ahkam al-Quran"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:aina-kamalat-i-islam", "type": "book", "key": "aina-kamalat-i-islam", "label": "A'ina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam [?]", "labels": ["A'ina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-ansab", "type": "book", "key": "al-ansab", "label": "al-Ansab", "labels": ["al-Ansab"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "type": "book", "key": "al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "label": "al-Aqida al-Wasitiyya [?]", "labels": ["al-Aqida al-Wasitiyya", "al-Aqida al-Wasitiyya [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:al-ashmawiyyah", "type": "book", "key": "al-ashmawiyyah", "label": "al-Ashmawiyyah", "labels": ["al-Ashmawiyyah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "type": "book", "key": "al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "label": "al-Bayan wa'l-Tahsil", "labels": ["al-Bayan wa'l-Tahsil"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-fazl", "type": "book", "key": "al-fazl", "label": "Al-Fazl [?]", "labels": ["Al-Fazl [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "type": "book", "key": "al-fiqh-al-akbar", "label": "al-Fiqh al-Akbar [?]", "labels": ["al-Fiqh al-Akbar [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "type": "book", "key": "al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "label": "al-Fisal fi al-Milal (Ibn Hazm)", "labels": ["al-Fisal fi al-Milal (Ibn Hazm)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "type": "book", "key": "al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "label": "al-Qari's treatise on al-Khidr [?]", "labels": ["al-Qari's treatise on al-Khidr [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-hamasa", "type": "book", "key": "al-hamasa", "label": "al-Hamasa of Abu Tammam", "labels": ["al-Hamasa of Abu Tammam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-hidayah", "type": "book", "key": "al-hidayah", "label": "al-Hidayah", "labels": ["al-Hidayah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-ilal-ahmad", "type": "book", "key": "al-ilal-ahmad", "label": "al-'Ilal of Imam Ahmad [?]", "labels": ["al-'Ilal of Imam Ahmad [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-itisam", "type": "book", "key": "al-itisam", "label": "al-I'tisam [?] (al-Shatibi)", "labels": ["al-I'tisam [?] (al-Shatibi)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "type": "book", "key": "al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "label": "al-Jami al-Sahih (Ibadi hadith collection) [?]", "labels": ["al-Jami al-Sahih (Ibadi hadith collection) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "type": "book", "key": "al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "label": "al-Jami of Ibn Yunus [?]", "labels": ["al-Jami of Ibn Yunus [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "type": "book", "key": "al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "label": "al-Kafi fi Fiqh Ahl al-Madinah [?] (Ibn Abd al-Barr)", "labels": ["al-Kafi fi Fiqh Ahl al-Madina", "al-Kafi fi Fiqh Ahl al-Madinah [?] (Ibn Abd al-Barr)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "type": "book", "key": "al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "label": "al-Kamil fi Du'afa al-Rijal (Ibn Adi)", "labels": ["al-Kamil fi Du'afa al-Rijal (Ibn Adi)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-kashshaf", "type": "book", "key": "al-kashshaf", "label": "al-Kashshaf", "labels": ["al-Kashshaf"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-kitab-sibawayh", "type": "book", "key": "al-kitab-sibawayh", "label": "al-Kitab of Sibawayh [?]", "labels": ["al-Kitab of Sibawayh [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-mabsut", "type": "book", "key": "al-mabsut", "label": "al-Mabsut (al-Sarakhsi)", "labels": ["al-Mabsut (al-Sarakhsi)", "al-Mabsut [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:al-mudawwana", "type": "book", "key": "al-mudawwana", "label": "al-Mudawwana", "labels": ["al-Mudawwana", "al-Mudawwana [?]"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 3, "2021": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "book:al-muhalla", "type": "book", "key": "al-muhalla", "label": "al-Muhalla (Ibn Hazm)", "labels": ["al-Muhalla (Ibn Hazm)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "type": "book", "key": "al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "label": "al-Muharrar al-Wajiz of Ibn Atiyya [?]", "labels": ["al-Muharrar al-Wajiz of Ibn Atiyya [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-mujam-al-awsat", "type": "book", "key": "al-mujam-al-awsat", "label": "al-Mu'jam al-Awsat of al-Tabarani [?]", "labels": ["al-Mu'jam al-Awsat of al-Tabarani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "type": "book", "key": "al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "label": "al-Munfaridat wa'l-Wuhdan [?]", "labels": ["al-Munfaridat wa'l-Wuhdan [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "type": "book", "key": "al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "label": "al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error)", "labels": ["al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "type": "book", "key": "al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "label": "al-Muqaddimat al-Mumahhidat (Ibn Rushd al-Jadd)", "labels": ["al-Muqaddimat al-Mumahhidat (Ibn Rushd al-Jadd)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-murshid-al-muin", "type": "book", "key": "al-murshid-al-muin", "label": "al-Murshid al-Mu'in [?]", "labels": ["al-Murshid al-Mu'in [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-mustadrak", "type": "book", "key": "al-mustadrak", "label": "al-Mustadrak (al-Hakim)", "labels": ["al-Mustadrak (al-Hakim)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:al-muwafaqat", "type": "book", "key": "al-muwafaqat", "label": "al-Muwafaqat", "labels": ["al-Muwafaqat", "al-Muwafaqat (al-Shatibi)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "type": "book", "key": "al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "label": "al-Qawa'id al-Arba'a (the four principles of shirk) [?]", "labels": ["al-Qawa'id al-Arba'a (the four principles of shirk) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-risalah", "type": "book", "key": "al-risalah", "label": "al-Risalah", "labels": ["al-Risalah", "al-Risalah [?]", "al-Risalah of Ibn Abi Zayd al-Qayrawani"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2015": 3, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "book:al-shamail", "type": "book", "key": "al-shamail", "label": "the Shama'il [?]", "labels": ["the Shama'il [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-shifa", "type": "book", "key": "al-shifa", "label": "al-Shifa (Qadi Iyad)", "labels": ["al-Shifa (Qadi Iyad)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:al-sultaniyya", "type": "book", "key": "al-sultaniyya", "label": "the Sultaniyya edition of Sahih al-Bukhari", "labels": ["the Sultaniyya edition of Sahih al-Bukhari"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:al-tabsira", "type": "book", "key": "al-tabsira", "label": "al-Tabsira of al-Lakhmi [?]", "labels": ["al-Tabsira of al-Lakhmi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "type": "book", "key": "al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "label": "al-Tahrir wa al-Tanwir (Ibn Ashur's tafsir)", "labels": ["al-Tahrir wa al-Tanwir (Ibn Ashur's tafsir)", "al-Tahrir wa al-Tanwir (Ibn Ashur's tafsir) [?]", "al-Tahrir wa al-Tanwir (Ibn Ashur's tafsir, \"in 30 volumes\")"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "type": "book", "key": "al-ulama-al-uzzab", "label": "al-Ulama al-Uzzab alladhina atharu al-ilm ala al-zawaj (the unmarried scholars) [?]", "labels": ["al-Ulama al-Uzzab alladhina atharu al-ilm ala al-zawaj (the unmarried scholars) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-utbiyya", "type": "book", "key": "al-utbiyya", "label": "al-'Utbiyya", "labels": ["al-'Utbiyya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:al-yuniniyya", "type": "book", "key": "al-yuniniyya", "label": "the Yuniniyya recension of Sahih al-Bukhari", "labels": ["the Yuniniyya recension of Sahih al-Bukhari"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "type": "book", "key": "aqidah-tahawiyya", "label": "al-Aqidah al-Tahawiyya", "labels": ["al-Aqidah al-Tahawiyya", "al-Aqidah al-Tahawiyya [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "type": "book", "key": "aridat-al-ahwadhi", "label": "Aridat al-Ahwadhi (Ibn al-Arabi's commentary on al-Tirmidhi) [?]", "labels": ["Aridat al-Ahwadhi (Ibn al-Arabi's commentary on al-Tirmidhi) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:asas-al-balagha", "type": "book", "key": "asas-al-balagha", "label": "Asas al-Balagha [?]", "labels": ["Asas al-Balagha [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:avesta", "type": "book", "key": "avesta", "label": "Avesta", "labels": ["Avesta"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:banat-suad", "type": "book", "key": "banat-suad", "label": "Banat Su'ad (the ode of Ka'b ibn Zuhayr)", "labels": ["Banat Su'ad (the ode of Ka'b ibn Zuhayr)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:bible", "type": "book", "key": "bible", "label": "the Bible", "labels": ["the Bible", "the Bible (Genesis)"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 4, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "type": "book", "key": "bidayat-al-mujtahid", "label": "Bidayat al-Mujtahid [?]", "labels": ["Bidayat al-Mujtahid [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:book-of-isaiah", "type": "book", "key": "book-of-isaiah", "label": "Book of Isaiah", "labels": ["Book of Isaiah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:book-of-jeremiah", "type": "book", "key": "book-of-jeremiah", "label": "Book of Jeremiah [?]", "labels": ["Book of Jeremiah [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:book-of-judges", "type": "book", "key": "book-of-judges", "label": "Book of Judges [?]", "labels": ["Book of Judges [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:bulugh-al-maram", "type": "book", "key": "bulugh-al-maram", "label": "Bulugh al-Maram", "labels": ["Bulugh al-Maram"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:code-of-hammurabi", "type": "book", "key": "code-of-hammurabi", "label": "Code of Hammurabi", "labels": ["Code of Hammurabi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:consciousness-beyond-life", "type": "book", "key": "consciousness-beyond-life", "label": "Consciousness Beyond Life: The Science of the Near-Death Experience", "labels": ["Consciousness Beyond Life: The Science of the Near-Death Experience"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:darwins-cathedral", "type": "book", "key": "darwins-cathedral", "label": "Darwin's Cathedral", "labels": ["Darwin's Cathedral"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:deuteronomy", "type": "book", "key": "deuteronomy", "label": "Deuteronomy", "labels": ["Deuteronomy"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:early-inquisitions-in-islam", "type": "book", "key": "early-inquisitions-in-islam", "label": "Early Inquisitions in Islam [?]", "labels": ["Early Inquisitions in Islam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "type": "book", "key": "early-islamic-qiblas", "label": "Early Islamic Qiblas [?]", "labels": ["Early Islamic Qiblas [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:fath-al-bari", "type": "book", "key": "fath-al-bari", "label": "Fath al-Bari", "labels": ["Fath al-Bari", "Fath al-Bari (Ibn Hajar's commentary on al-Bukhari)"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "book:gharami-sahih", "type": "book", "key": "gharami-sahih", "label": "the hadith-terminology love poem 'Gharami sahih' (Ibn Farah al-Ishbili) [?]", "labels": ["the hadith-terminology love poem 'Gharami sahih' (Ibn Farah al-Ishbili) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:gospel-of-john", "type": "book", "key": "gospel-of-john", "label": "Gospel of John", "labels": ["Gospel of John"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:gospel-of-luke", "type": "book", "key": "gospel-of-luke", "label": "Gospel of Luke", "labels": ["Gospel of Luke"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "book:gospel-of-mark", "type": "book", "key": "gospel-of-mark", "label": "Gospel of Mark", "labels": ["Gospel of Mark"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "type": "book", "key": "gospel-of-matthew", "label": "Gospel of Matthew", "labels": ["Gospel of Matthew"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "type": "book", "key": "gospel-of-thomas", "label": "Gospel of Thomas", "labels": ["Gospel of Thomas"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:guru-granth-sahib", "type": "book", "key": "guru-granth-sahib", "label": "Guru Granth Sahib", "labels": ["Guru Granth Sahib"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "type": "book", "key": "hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "label": "Hujjat Allah al-Baligha", "labels": ["Hujjat Allah al-Baligha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:in-gods-path", "type": "book", "key": "in-gods-path", "label": "In God's Path (Robert Hoyland)", "labels": ["In God's Path (Robert Hoyland)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "type": "book", "key": "infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "label": "Infancy Gospel of Thomas", "labels": ["Infancy Gospel of Thomas"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:injil", "type": "book", "key": "injil", "label": "Injil (Gospel)", "labels": ["Injil (Gospel)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:kashti-nuh", "type": "book", "key": "kashti-nuh", "label": "Kashti-e-Nuh (The Ark of Noah)", "labels": ["Kashti-e-Nuh (The Ark of Noah)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:kitab-al-bariyya", "type": "book", "key": "kitab-al-bariyya", "label": "Kitab al-Bariyya", "labels": ["Kitab al-Bariyya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "type": "book", "key": "kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "label": "Kitab al-Hujja ala Ahl al-Madina", "labels": ["Kitab al-Hujja ala Ahl al-Madina"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:kitab-al-tawhid", "type": "book", "key": "kitab-al-tawhid", "label": "Kitab al-Tawhid", "labels": ["Kitab al-Tawhid"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:kitab-al-tawwabin", "type": "book", "key": "kitab-al-tawwabin", "label": "Kitab al-Tawwabin [?]", "labels": ["Kitab al-Tawwabin [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:kitab-al-zahra", "type": "book", "key": "kitab-al-zahra", "label": "Kitab al-Zahra [?]", "labels": ["Kitab al-Zahra [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:maa-al-nas", "type": "book", "key": "maa-al-nas", "label": "Ma'a al-Nas (al-Buti's question-and-answer books) [?]", "labels": ["Ma'a al-Nas (al-Buti's question-and-answer books) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:majmu-al-fatawa", "type": "book", "key": "majmu-al-fatawa", "label": "Majmu' al-Fatawa (Ibn Taymiyya) [?]", "labels": ["Majmu' al-Fatawa (Ibn Taymiyya) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "type": "book", "key": "maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "label": "Maqasid al-Shari'ah al-Islamiyyah (Ibn Ashur)", "labels": ["Maqasid al-Shari'ah al-Islamiyyah (Ibn Ashur)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:maratib-al-ijma", "type": "book", "key": "maratib-al-ijma", "label": "Maratib al-Ijma' (Ibn Hazm) [?]", "labels": ["Maratib al-Ijma' (Ibn Hazm) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:mathnawi", "type": "book", "key": "mathnawi", "label": "Mathnawi of Rumi", "labels": ["Mathnawi of Rumi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:midnights-children", "type": "book", "key": "midnights-children", "label": "Midnight's Children", "labels": ["Midnight's Children"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "type": "book", "key": "mizan-al-itidal", "label": "Mizan al-I'tidal", "labels": ["Mizan al-I'tidal"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "type": "book", "key": "mukhtasar-khalil", "label": "Mukhtasar Khalil", "labels": ["Mukhtasar Khalil", "Mukhtasar Khalil [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "type": "book", "key": "muntaqa-al-akhbar", "label": "Muntaqa al-Akhbar", "labels": ["Muntaqa al-Akhbar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:muqaddimah", "type": "book", "key": "muqaddimah", "label": "al-Muqaddimah (Ibn Khaldun)", "labels": ["al-Muqaddimah (Ibn Khaldun)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "type": "book", "key": "musnad-abi-yala", "label": "Musnad Abi Ya'la", "labels": ["Musnad Abi Ya'la"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:musnad-ahmad", "type": "book", "key": "musnad-ahmad", "label": "Musnad Ahmad", "labels": ["Musnad Ahmad", "Musnad Ahmad [?]"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 14, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "type": "book", "key": "musnad-al-bazzar", "label": "Musnad al-Bazzar", "labels": ["Musnad al-Bazzar"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "type": "book", "key": "musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "label": "the Ibadi hadith collection al-Jami' al-Sahih (Musnad al-Rabi' ibn Habib) [?]", "labels": ["the Ibadi hadith collection al-Jami' al-Sahih (Musnad al-Rabi' ibn Habib) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:muwatta", "type": "book", "key": "muwatta", "label": "al-Muwatta", "labels": ["Muwatta", "Muwatta of Imam Malik", "al-Muwatta"], "segments": 25, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 9, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3, "2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 25}}, {"id": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "type": "book", "key": "nasb-al-majaniq", "label": "Nasb al-Majaniq li-Nasf Qissat al-Gharaniq [?]", "labels": ["Nasb al-Majaniq li-Nasf Qissat al-Gharaniq [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "type": "book", "key": "nayl-al-awtar", "label": "Nayl al-Awtar", "labels": ["Nayl al-Awtar"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "type": "book", "key": "nuskhat-ibn-saada", "label": "the Ibn Sa'ada manuscript of Sahih al-Bukhari (al-Shaykha) [?]", "labels": ["the Ibn Sa'ada manuscript of Sahih al-Bukhari (al-Shaykha) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:old-testament", "type": "book", "key": "old-testament", "label": "the Old Testament", "labels": ["the Old Testament"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:on-the-genealogy-of-morals", "type": "book", "key": "on-the-genealogy-of-morals", "label": "On the Genealogy of Morals", "labels": ["On the Genealogy of Morals"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:plato-republic", "type": "book", "key": "plato-republic", "label": "Plato's Republic", "labels": ["Plato's Republic"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:puranas", "type": "book", "key": "puranas", "label": "the Puranas [?]", "labels": ["the Puranas [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:quranic-geography", "type": "book", "key": "quranic-geography", "label": "Quranic Geography [?]", "labels": ["Quranic Geography [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:qut-al-qulub", "type": "book", "key": "qut-al-qulub", "label": "Qut al-Qulub", "labels": ["Qut al-Qulub"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "book:rig-veda", "type": "book", "key": "rig-veda", "label": "Rig Veda", "labels": ["Rig Veda"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:ruhani-khazain", "type": "book", "key": "ruhani-khazain", "label": "Ruhani Khaza'in (Spiritual Treasures)", "labels": ["Ruhani Khaza'in (Spiritual Treasures)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "type": "book", "key": "sahih-al-bukhari", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari", "Sahih al-Bukhari [?]"], "segments": 142, "recordings": 67, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2, "2017": 12, "2018": 58, "2019": 17, "2020": 14, "2021": 34, "2022": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 142}}, {"id": "book:sahih-muslim", "type": "book", "key": "sahih-muslim", "label": "Sahih Muslim", "labels": ["Sahih Muslim", "Sahih Muslim (a Maliki commentary on it) [?]"], "segments": 56, "recordings": 36, "years": {"2014": 3, "2015": 1, "2017": 10, "2018": 23, "2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 11, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 56}}, {"id": "book:sapiens", "type": "book", "key": "sapiens", "label": "Sapiens", "labels": ["Sapiens"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:sharh-al-umda", "type": "book", "key": "sharh-al-umda", "label": "Sharh al-Umda of Ibn Taymiyya [?]", "labels": ["Sharh al-Umda of Ibn Taymiyya [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "type": "book", "key": "sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "label": "Sharh 'Ilal al-Tirmidhi [?]", "labels": ["Sharh 'Ilal al-Tirmidhi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "type": "book", "key": "sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "label": "Sharh Mushkil al-Athar [?] (al-Tahawi)", "labels": ["Sharh Mushkil al-Athar [?] (al-Tahawi)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "type": "book", "key": "sinaat-al-fatwa", "label": "Sina'at al-Fatwa [?] (Abdullah bin Bayyah)", "labels": ["Sina'at al-Fatwa [?] (Abdullah bin Bayyah)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "type": "book", "key": "siyar-alam-al-nubala", "label": "Siyar A'lam al-Nubala", "labels": ["Siyar A'lam al-Nubala"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-abi-dawud", "label": "Sunan Abi Dawud", "labels": ["Sunan Abi Dawud", "Sunan Abi Dawud [?]"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2018": 15, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-al-darimi", "label": "Sunan al-Darimi [?]", "labels": ["Sunan al-Darimi", "Sunan al-Darimi [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-al-nasai", "label": "Sunan al-Nasa'i", "labels": ["Sunan al-Nasa'i"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-al-tirmidhi", "label": "Sunan al-Tirmidhi", "labels": ["Sunan al-Tirmidhi"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-ibn-majah", "label": "Sunan Ibn Majah", "labels": ["Sunan Ibn Majah"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "type": "book", "key": "sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "label": "Sunan Said ibn Mansur", "labels": ["Sunan Said ibn Mansur"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tafsir-al-manar", "type": "book", "key": "tafsir-al-manar", "label": "Tafsir al-Manar", "labels": ["Tafsir al-Manar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "type": "book", "key": "tafsir-al-mazhari", "label": "Tafsir al-Mazhari [?]", "labels": ["Tafsir al-Mazhari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tafsir-al-samani", "type": "book", "key": "tafsir-al-samani", "label": "Tafsir al-Sam'ani", "labels": ["Tafsir al-Sam'ani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tafsir-al-tabari", "type": "book", "key": "tafsir-al-tabari", "label": "Tafsir al-Tabari", "labels": ["Tafsir al-Tabari"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tahafut-al-falasifa", "type": "book", "key": "tahafut-al-falasifa", "label": "Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers)", "labels": ["Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tahafut-al-tahafut", "type": "book", "key": "tahafut-al-tahafut", "label": "Tahafut al-Tahafut (The Incoherence of the Incoherence)", "labels": ["Tahafut al-Tahafut (The Incoherence of the Incoherence)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "type": "book", "key": "tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "label": "Tahqiqat wa Anzar [?] (Ibn Ashur)", "labels": ["Tahqiqat wa Anzar [?] (Ibn Ashur)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "type": "book", "key": "tartib-al-madarik", "label": "Tartib al-Madarik [?]", "labels": ["Tartib al-Madarik", "Tartib al-Madarik [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "type": "book", "key": "tawq-al-hamama", "label": "Tawq al-Hamama (The Ring of the Dove)", "labels": ["Tawq al-Hamama", "Tawq al-Hamama (The Ring of the Dove)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:the-cosmic-serpent", "type": "book", "key": "the-cosmic-serpent", "label": "The Cosmic Serpent", "labels": ["The Cosmic Serpent"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-formation-of-the-sunni-schools-of-law", "type": "book", "key": "the-formation-of-the-sunni-schools-of-law", "label": "The Formation of the Sunni Schools of Law", "labels": ["The Formation of the Sunni Schools of Law"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-foundations-of-islam", "type": "book", "key": "the-foundations-of-islam", "label": "The Foundations of Islam (Qadi Iyad)", "labels": ["The Foundations of Islam (Qadi Iyad)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-future-of-an-illusion", "type": "book", "key": "the-future-of-an-illusion", "label": "The Future of an Illusion (Freud)", "labels": ["The Future of an Illusion (Freud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-knowledge-illusion", "type": "book", "key": "the-knowledge-illusion", "label": "The Knowledge Illusion (called 'the illusion of knowledge') [?]", "labels": ["The Knowledge Illusion (called 'the illusion of knowledge') [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-sanaa-palimpsest", "type": "book", "key": "the-sanaa-palimpsest", "label": "The Sana'a Palimpsest (Asma Hilali) [?]", "labels": ["The Sana'a Palimpsest (Asma Hilali) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-satanic-verses", "type": "book", "key": "the-satanic-verses", "label": "The Satanic Verses (novel)", "labels": ["The Satanic Verses", "The Satanic Verses (novel)"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "book:the-study-quran", "type": "book", "key": "the-study-quran", "label": "The Study Quran", "labels": ["The Study Quran"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "type": "book", "key": "the-third-chimpanzee", "label": "The Third Chimpanzee", "labels": ["The Third Chimpanzee"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "book:the-wealth-of-nations", "type": "book", "key": "the-wealth-of-nations", "label": "The Wealth of Nations", "labels": ["The Wealth of Nations"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "book:torah", "type": "book", "key": "torah", "label": "Torah", "labels": ["Torah"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "type": "book", "key": "urwat-al-wuthqa", "label": "Tafsir Urwat al-Wuthqa [?] (Abdul Karim Athari)", "labels": ["Tafsir Urwat al-Wuthqa [?] (Abdul Karim Athari)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "book:zabur", "type": "book", "key": "zabur", "label": "Zabur (Psalms of Dawud)", "labels": ["Zabur (Psalms of Dawud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "type": "event", "key": "arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "label": "the arrest of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (2020)", "labels": ["the arrest of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (2020)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "type": "event", "key": "assassination-of-uthman", "label": "assassination of Uthman", "labels": ["assassination of Uthman", "the murder of Uthman"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "type": "event", "key": "attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "label": "the attack on Salman Rushdie in New York (August 2022)", "labels": ["the attack on Salman Rushdie in New York (August 2022)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "type": "event", "key": "babri-masjid-dispute", "label": "the Babri Masjid", "labels": ["the Babri Masjid"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:babylonian-exile", "type": "event", "key": "babylonian-exile", "label": "the Israelites in Babylon", "labels": ["the Israelites in Babylon"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:banu-qurayza", "type": "event", "key": "banu-qurayza", "label": "the Banu Qurayza incident", "labels": ["the Banu Qurayza incident"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-al-harrah", "label": "the event of al-Harrah", "labels": ["Yazid's army against Medina (al-Harrah)", "the event of al-Harrah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-awtas", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-awtas", "label": "the battle of Awtas [?]", "labels": ["the battle of Awtas [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-badr", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-badr", "label": "the battle of Badr", "labels": ["the battle of Badr"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "label": "the campaign against Banu al-Mustaliq", "labels": ["the campaign against Banu al-Mustaliq"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-khaybar", "label": "the campaign of Khaybar", "labels": ["Battle of Khaybar [?]", "Khaybar", "Khaybar [?]", "the battle of Khaybar", "the battle of Khaybar [?] (the name is garbled in the transcript)", "the campaign of Khaybar"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-siffin", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-siffin", "label": "the battle of Siffin", "labels": ["the battle of Siffin"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-the-camel", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-the-camel", "label": "the battle of the Camel", "labels": ["the battle of the Camel"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-the-trench", "label": "the coalition against Madinah (al-Ahzab)", "labels": ["the Battle of the Trench (al-Ahzab)", "the coalition against Madinah (al-Ahzab)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:battle-of-uhud", "type": "event", "key": "battle-of-uhud", "label": "the battle of Uhud", "labels": ["the battle of Uhud"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:bayat-al-ridwan", "type": "event", "key": "bayat-al-ridwan", "label": "the pledge of Ridwan", "labels": ["the pledge of Ridwan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "type": "event", "key": "birmingham-quran-manuscript", "label": "the Birmingham Quran manuscript", "labels": ["the Birmingham Quran manuscript"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "type": "event", "key": "birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "label": "Birmingham road blockade protest for Palestine (May 2021)", "labels": ["Birmingham road blockade protest for Palestine (May 2021)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:black-death", "type": "event", "key": "black-death", "label": "the plague (the Black Death) [?]", "labels": ["the Black Death", "the plague (the Black Death) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "type": "event", "key": "black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "label": "the Black Lives Matter protests (2020)", "labels": ["the Black Lives Matter protests (2020)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "type": "event", "key": "break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "label": "Break-in at the host's home (May 2021)", "labels": ["Break-in at the host's home (May 2021)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "type": "event", "key": "british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "label": "the fatwa of six British imams against ISIS (September 2014)", "labels": ["the fatwa of six British imams against ISIS (September 2014)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:british-raj", "type": "event", "key": "british-raj", "label": "the British Raj", "labels": ["the British Raj"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "type": "event", "key": "conquest-of-constantinople", "label": "the conquest of Constantinople", "labels": ["conquest of Constantinople", "the conquest of Constantinople"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "type": "event", "key": "conquest-of-makkah", "label": "the conquest of Makkah", "labels": ["the conquest of Makkah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "type": "event", "key": "council-of-nicaea-325", "label": "the Council of Nicaea (325)", "labels": ["the Council of Nicaea (325)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "type": "event", "key": "covid-19-pandemic", "label": "the COVID-19 pandemic", "labels": ["COVID-19 pandemic", "the COVID-19 pandemic", "the Covid-19 pandemic", "the Covid-19 pandemic (2020)", "the coronavirus pandemic"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "type": "event", "key": "crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "label": "the Crusader capture of Jerusalem (1099)", "labels": ["the Crusader capture of Jerusalem (1099)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts", "type": "event", "key": "discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts", "label": "the discovery of the Sana'a manuscripts (1970s)", "labels": ["the discovery of the Sana'a manuscripts (1970s)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:eleusinian-mysteries", "type": "event", "key": "eleusinian-mysteries", "label": "the Eleusinian mysteries", "labels": ["the Eleusinian mysteries"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:european-colonialism", "type": "event", "key": "european-colonialism", "label": "European colonisation of the Muslim world", "labels": ["European colonisation of the Muslim world"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:exodus", "type": "event", "key": "exodus", "label": "the Exodus", "labels": ["the Exodus"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:farewell-pilgrimage", "type": "event", "key": "farewell-pilgrimage", "label": "the farewell Hajj", "labels": ["the farewell Hajj"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:founding-of-baghdad", "type": "event", "key": "founding-of-baghdad", "label": "the building of Baghdad", "labels": ["the building of Baghdad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "type": "event", "key": "france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "label": "the case of a woman refused French citizenship over her refusal to shake hands (2018)", "labels": ["the case of a woman refused French citizenship over her refusal to shake hands (2018)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "type": "event", "key": "france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "label": "the reported French move to ban headscarves for girls under 18 (2021)", "labels": ["the reported French move to ban headscarves for girls under 18 (2021)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:golden-calf", "type": "event", "key": "golden-calf", "label": "the golden calf of the Israelites", "labels": ["the golden calf of the Israelites"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:great-flood", "type": "event", "key": "great-flood", "label": "the flood of Nuh", "labels": ["the flood of Nuh"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "type": "event", "key": "hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "label": "the reconversion of the Hagia Sophia to a mosque", "labels": ["the reconversion of the Hagia Sophia to a mosque"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 16}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "event:hijrah", "type": "event", "key": "hijrah", "label": "the hijrah to Madinah", "labels": ["the Hijrah", "the hijrah to Madinah"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "event:hurricane-katrina-2005", "type": "event", "key": "hurricane-katrina-2005", "label": "Hurricane Katrina", "labels": ["Hurricane Katrina"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:incident-of-the-ifk", "type": "event", "key": "incident-of-the-ifk", "label": "the incident of the ifk (the slander of Aisha)", "labels": ["the incident of the ifk (the slander of Aisha)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:industrial-revolution", "type": "event", "key": "industrial-revolution", "label": "the industrial revolution", "labels": ["the industrial revolution"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "type": "event", "key": "islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "label": "the Hindu temple (mandir) in Islamabad", "labels": ["the Hindu temple (mandir) in Islamabad"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:isra-and-miraj", "type": "event", "key": "isra-and-miraj", "label": "the night journey (al-Isra)", "labels": ["the Isra and Mi'raj", "the night journey (al-Isra)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "event:karbala", "type": "event", "key": "karbala", "label": "Karbala", "labels": ["Karbala"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "type": "event", "key": "khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "label": "Khomeini's fatwa against Salman Rushdie (1989)", "labels": ["Khomeini's fatwa against Salman Rushdie (1989)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "type": "event", "key": "mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "label": "Mehdi Hasan and Richard Dawkins debate (Oxford)", "labels": ["Mehdi Hasan and Richard Dawkins debate (Oxford)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:migration-to-abyssinia", "type": "event", "key": "migration-to-abyssinia", "label": "the migration to Abyssinia", "labels": ["the migration to Abyssinia"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:mihna", "type": "event", "key": "mihna", "label": "the dispute over the created Quran (mihna)", "labels": ["the Mihna", "the dispute over the created Quran (mihna)", "the inquisition over the created Quran (mihna)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "event:mongol-invasions", "type": "event", "key": "mongol-invasions", "label": "the Mongol invasions", "labels": ["the Mongol invasions"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "type": "event", "key": "mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "label": "the Mongol destruction of Baghdad (1258)", "labels": ["the Mongol destruction of Baghdad (1258)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "type": "event", "key": "murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "label": "the killing of the teacher Samuel Paty in France (2020)", "labels": ["the killing of Samuel Paty (2020)", "the killing of the teacher Samuel Paty in France (2020)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "type": "event", "key": "nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "label": "the allegations against Nouman Ali Khan (2017)", "labels": ["the allegations against Nouman Ali Khan (2017)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:oj-simpson-trial-1995", "type": "event", "key": "oj-simpson-trial-1995", "label": "the O.J. Simpson trial (1995)", "labels": ["the O.J. Simpson trial (1995)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:pagan-gate-2020", "type": "event", "key": "pagan-gate-2020", "label": "'Pagan-gate': the row over Omar Suleiman and a libation ritual at a border protest (2020)", "labels": ["'Pagan-gate': the row over Omar Suleiman and a libation ritual at a border protest (2020)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "type": "event", "key": "palestinian-crisis-2021", "label": "The Palestinian crisis (May 2021)", "labels": ["The Palestinian crisis (May 2021)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "event:peacock-throne", "type": "event", "key": "peacock-throne", "label": "the Mughal Peacock Throne", "labels": ["the Mughal Peacock Throne"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "type": "event", "key": "peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "label": "Peshawar courtroom killing (2020)", "labels": ["Peshawar courtroom killing (2020)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:protestant-reformation", "type": "event", "key": "protestant-reformation", "label": "the Protestant Reformation", "labels": ["the Protestant Reformation"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "type": "event", "key": "rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "label": "Rashid Rida's visit to India and Deoband", "labels": ["Rashid Rida's visit to India and Deoband"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:reconquista", "type": "event", "key": "reconquista", "label": "the Reconquista", "labels": ["the Reconquista"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "type": "event", "key": "reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "label": "the Wall Street battle between hedge funds and Reddit traders (2021)", "labels": ["the Wall Street battle between hedge funds and Reddit traders (2021)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:ridda-wars", "type": "event", "key": "ridda-wars", "label": "the ridda wars (refusal of zakah after the Prophet)", "labels": ["the Ridda wars", "the ridda wars (refusal of zakah after the Prophet)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "type": "event", "key": "rohingya-genocide-2017", "label": "the Rohingya genocide", "labels": ["the Rohingya genocide"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:sack-of-madinah", "type": "event", "key": "sack-of-madinah", "label": "sack of Madinah (al-Harra)", "labels": ["sack of Madinah (al-Harra)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:salem-witch-trials", "type": "event", "key": "salem-witch-trials", "label": "the Salem witch trials", "labels": ["the Salem witch trials"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:saqifa-of-banu-saida", "type": "event", "key": "saqifa-of-banu-saida", "label": "the Saqifa of Banu Sa'ida", "labels": ["the Saqifa of Banu Sa'ida"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "type": "event", "key": "seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "label": "the seizure of the Grand Mosque in Mecca (1979)", "labels": ["the seizure of the Grand Mosque in Makkah (1979)", "the seizure of the Grand Mosque in Mecca (1979)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:september-11-attacks", "type": "event", "key": "september-11-attacks", "label": "the September 11 attacks", "labels": ["the September 11 attacks"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:siege-of-madinah", "type": "event", "key": "siege-of-madinah", "label": "the siege of Madinah (battle of the trench)", "labels": ["the siege of Madinah (battle of the trench)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:silk-road", "type": "event", "key": "silk-road", "label": "the Silk Road", "labels": ["the Silk Road"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:soviet-afghan-war", "type": "event", "key": "soviet-afghan-war", "label": "the Soviet-Afghan war (1979-1989)", "labels": ["the Soviet-Afghan war (1979-1989)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:spanish-inquisition", "type": "event", "key": "spanish-inquisition", "label": "the Spanish Inquisition", "labels": ["the Spanish Inquisition"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:splitting-of-the-moon", "type": "event", "key": "splitting-of-the-moon", "label": "the splitting of the moon", "labels": ["the splitting of the moon"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "type": "event", "key": "sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "label": "Sudan's legal reforms (2020)", "labels": ["Sudan's legal reforms (2020)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:taif-journey", "type": "event", "key": "taif-journey", "label": "the Prophet's journey to Ta'if", "labels": ["the Prophet's journey to Ta'if"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "type": "event", "key": "treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "label": "the treaty of Hudaybiyya", "labels": ["the treaty of Hudaybiyya"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "type": "event", "key": "trojan-horse-affair-2014", "label": "the Trojan Horse affair (Birmingham schools, 2014)", "labels": ["the Trojan Horse affair (Birmingham schools, 2014)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "type": "event", "key": "uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "label": "the UAE-Israel normalisation deal (2020)", "labels": ["the UAE-Israel normalisation deal (2020)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "event:year-of-sorrow", "type": "event", "key": "year-of-sorrow", "label": "the year of sorrow", "labels": ["The year of sorrow", "the year of sorrow"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "event:younger-dryas", "type": "event", "key": "younger-dryas", "label": "the Younger Dryas event", "labels": ["the Younger Dryas event"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:137", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:137", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 137 as cited (the Prophet slept until he could be heard breathing deeply and prayed without wudu) [?]", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 137 as cited (the Prophet slept until he could be heard breathing deeply and prayed without wudu) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:2655", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:2655", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 2655 (he reminded me of a verse I had forgotten)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 2655 (he reminded me of a verse I had forgotten)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:2819", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:2819", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 2819 (Sulayman: tonight I will go to a hundred women)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 2819 (Sulayman: tonight I will go to a hundred women)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:3093", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:3093", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 3093", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 3093"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:3104", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:3104", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 3104 (the fitna is here, pointing to Aisha's house)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 3104 (the fitna is here, pointing to Aisha's house)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:3242", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:3242", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 3242 (the woman beside Umar's palace in paradise) [?]", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 3242 (the woman beside Umar's palace in paradise) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:3431", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:3431", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 3431 (no child is born without Shaytan touching him, except Mary and her son)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 3431 (no child is born without Shaytan touching him, except Mary and her son)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:364", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:364", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 364 (carrying stones for the Kaaba with the izar on his shoulders)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 364 (carrying stones for the Kaaba with the izar on his shoulders)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:3663", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:3663", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 3663 (the wolf and the cow that spoke)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 3663 (the wolf and the cow that spoke)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:4428", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 4428 (I still feel the pain of the food I ate; the poison cutting my aorta)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 4428 (I still feel the pain of the food I ate; the poison cutting my aorta)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:4431", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:4431", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 4431 (bring me something to write on; is he speaking deliriously?)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 4431 (bring me something to write on; is he speaking deliriously?)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:4594", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:4594", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 4594", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 4594"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:4725", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:4725", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 4725 (Musa and al-Khidr, Book of Tafsir; the collection's name is garbled in the transcript) [?]", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 4725 (Musa and al-Khidr, Book of Tafsir)", "Sahih al-Bukhari 4725 (Musa and al-Khidr, Book of Tafsir; the collection's name is garbled in the transcript) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5127", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5127", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5127 (Aisha: marriage in the Jahiliyyah was of four kinds)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5127 (Aisha: marriage in the Jahiliyyah was of four kinds)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5133", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5133", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5133", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5133"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5136", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5136", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5136", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5136"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5255", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5255", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5255", "Sahih al-Bukhari 5255 (give yourself to me; does a queen give herself to a commoner)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5492", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5492", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5492", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5492"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:5765", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:5765", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 5765", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 5765"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:6639", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:6639", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 6639", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 6639"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:6830", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 6830 (Umar's speech on the verse of stoning)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 6830 (Umar's speech on the verse of stoning)", "Sahih al-Bukhari 6830 (Umar's speech: the pledge to Abu Bakr was a falta; do not repeat it without consultation)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:bukhari:7517", "type": "hadith", "key": "bukhari:7517", "label": "Sahih al-Bukhari 7517 (the night journey; al-Jabbar drew near and came down)", "labels": ["Sahih al-Bukhari 7517 (the night journey; al-Jabbar drew near and came down)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0058fc99", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0058fc99", "label": "report: shave all of it or leave all of it (unresolved; the child with a patch of hair, al-Nasa'i and Abu Dawud)", "labels": ["report: shave all of it or leave all of it (unresolved; the child with a patch of hair, al-Nasa'i and Abu Dawud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:03b390a1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:03b390a1", "label": "report: two men disputed an animal and the prophet cast lots between them", "labels": ["report: two men disputed an animal and the prophet cast lots between them"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:04750067", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:04750067", "label": "report: if musa was alive today he would be following the revelation (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: if musa was alive today he would be following the revelation (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0508e283", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0508e283", "label": "report: if there were a prophet after me it would be umar", "labels": ["report: if there were a prophet after me it would be umar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:054ae057", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:054ae057", "label": "report: fatima is a part of me whoever angers her angers me (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: fatima is a part of me whoever angers her angers me (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0576bb02", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0576bb02", "label": "report: when one of you strikes he should avoid the face", "labels": ["report: when one of you strikes he should avoid the face"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0607111e", "label": "report: whoever eats such dates will not be harmed by poison or magic", "labels": ["report: whoever eats such dates will not be harmed by poison or magic"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:061599d0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:061599d0", "label": "report: i stood at the gate of jahannam and most of those who entered were women", "labels": ["report: i stood at the gate of jahannam and most of those who entered were women"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:06746893", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:06746893", "label": "report: monkeys stoned a monkey that had committed adultery", "labels": ["report: monkeys stoned a monkey that had committed adultery"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0783df04", "label": "report: ayyuma imraatin istatarat fa marrat ala qawmin li yajidu rihaha fa hiya zaniya", "labels": ["report: ayyuma imraatin istatarat fa marrat ala qawmin li yajidu rihaha fa hiya zaniya", "report: ayyuma imraatin istatarat fa marrat ala qawmin li yajidu rihaha fa hiya zaniya (with the variant every eye is a fornicator)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:07a1c5d0", "label": "report: the nikah with the least burden has the most barakah", "labels": ["report: the nikah with the least burden has the most barakah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:07d42a1a", "label": "report: the dog licking the vessel and malik said we do not know its reality", "labels": ["report: the dog licking the vessel and malik said we do not know its reality"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:07f4ecd1", "label": "report: the prophet was given a handkerchief and he did not want it (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, vowelling disputed)", "labels": ["report: the prophet was given a handkerchief and he did not want it (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, vowelling disputed)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:085f3d75", "label": "report: tilka al-gharaniq al-ula wa inna shafaatahunna laturtaja (the alleged satanic verses [?]; called false by the host)", "labels": ["report: tilka al-gharaniq al-ula wa inna shafaatahunna laturtaja (the alleged satanic verses [?]; called false by the host)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:08774c1f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:08774c1f", "label": "report: the whole earth has been made a masjid for me", "labels": ["report: the whole earth has been made a masjid for me"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:087f9cf3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:087f9cf3", "label": "report: khaluf fam al-saim atyab inda allah min rih al-misk (the odour of the fasting person's mouth is better to Allah than musk)", "labels": ["report: khaluf fam al-saim atyab inda allah min rih al-misk (the odour of the fasting person's mouth is better to Allah than musk)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:091fe423", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:091fe423", "label": "report: ten actions are from the fitrah (unresolved; includes letting the beard grow)", "labels": ["report: ten actions are from the fitrah (unresolved; includes letting the beard grow)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0a236306", "label": "report: whoever changes his religion kill him", "labels": ["report: whoever changes his religion kill him", "report: whoever changes his religion kill him (man baddala dinahu faqtuluhu; unresolved, Sahih al-Bukhari and others, number not stated)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0a86cf97", "label": "report: if a woman passes in front of you your prayer becomes invalid", "labels": ["report: if a woman passes in front of you your prayer becomes invalid"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0adfcf34", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0adfcf34", "label": "report: if you do not find me come to abu bakr (the woman told to return; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: if you do not find me come to abu bakr (the woman told to return; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0da2986c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0da2986c", "label": "report: allahumma ijal al-dunya fi aydina wa la tajalha fi qulubina", "labels": ["report: allahumma ijal al-dunya fi aydina wa la tajalha fi qulubina"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0daa52d4", "label": "report: a woman related that her grandfather brought an afflicted child and the prophet said come out enemy of allah", "labels": ["report: a woman related that her grandfather brought an afflicted child and the prophet said come out enemy of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0e110483", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0e110483", "label": "report: o fatima pierce the ears of hasan and husayn", "labels": ["report: o fatima pierce the ears of hasan and husayn"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0e6517d3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0e6517d3", "label": "report: the prophet heard a flute blocked his ears and asked ibn umar to tell him when it stopped", "labels": ["report: the prophet heard a flute blocked his ears and asked ibn umar to tell him when it stopped"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:0ef3fb30", "label": "report: da ma yaribuka ila ma la yaribuk", "labels": ["report: da ma yaribuka ila ma la yaribuk"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:10e8ca76", "label": "report: make things easy and do not make them difficult give good tidings and do not drive people away", "labels": ["report: make things easy and do not make them difficult give good tidings and do not drive people away"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:11191dca", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:11191dca", "label": "report: i went to visit him while still a young man and at that time i had two earrings in my ear when i studied hadith", "labels": ["report: i went to visit him while still a young man and at that time i had two earrings in my ear when i studied hadith"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1153b02b", "label": "report: yala ibn murra and the child from whom the prophet drove out a demon on a journey", "labels": ["report: yala ibn murra and the child from whom the prophet drove out a demon on a journey"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:116de08d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:116de08d", "label": "report: idha dakhala ramadan sulsilat al-shayatin (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)", "labels": ["report: idha dakhala ramadan sulsilat al-shayatin (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:11824c16", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:11824c16", "label": "report: a wife may not refuse her husband when he calls her to his bed", "labels": ["report: a wife may not refuse her husband when he calls her to his bed"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:127763c2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:127763c2", "label": "report: idha shahidat ihdakunna al-isha al-akhira fa la tamassa tiban (Zaynab al-Thaqafiyya; Sahih Muslim and al-Nasa'i, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: idha shahidat ihdakunna al-isha al-akhira fa la tamassa tiban (Zaynab al-Thaqafiyya; Sahih Muslim and al-Nasa'i, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:13ca57c0", "label": "report: man shariba al-khamr lam tuqbal lahu salat arbain sabahan", "labels": ["report: man shariba al-khamr lam tuqbal lahu salat arbain sabahan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:144726cc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:144726cc", "label": "report: i entered upon ruqayya with a comb in her hand and she said the prophet has just left (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, Musnad Ahmad and al-Mustadrak, numbers not stated)", "labels": ["report: i entered upon ruqayya with a comb in her hand and she said the prophet has just left (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, Musnad Ahmad and al-Mustadrak, numbers not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:14945522", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:14945522", "label": "report: the black dog is a devil", "labels": ["report: the black dog is a devil"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1652a026", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1652a026", "label": "report: fatima was angry with abu bakr over the inheritance", "labels": ["report: fatima was angry with abu bakr over the inheritance"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:16737f93", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:16737f93", "label": "report: the moon was split in two in the time of the prophet", "labels": ["report: the moon was split in two in the time of the prophet"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:16ab3584", "label": "report: ali said he found it difficult to retain the quran and the prophet taught him to pray four rakahs on the night of friday and a dua so it would stick", "labels": ["report: ali said he found it difficult to retain the quran and the prophet taught him to pray four rakahs on the night of friday and a dua so it would stick"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:17a84e78", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:17a84e78", "label": "report: let him drink your milk so that he becomes your mahram", "labels": ["report: let him drink your milk so that he becomes your mahram"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:17da26fe", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:17da26fe", "label": "report: umar it is the jizya call it what you want but send it on time (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: umar it is the jizya call it what you want but send it on time (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:17fbddbc", "label": "report: i was among the ten standing when husayn fell he looked left and right and his two earrings were shaking", "labels": ["report: i was among the ten standing when husayn fell he looked left and right and his two earrings were shaking"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:185e7f9a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:185e7f9a", "label": "report: i will not cut it for i saw the prophet hold you by it (unresolved; the braid of Anas ibn Malik, Abu Dawud)", "labels": ["report: i will not cut it for i saw the prophet hold you by it (unresolved; the braid of Anas ibn Malik, Abu Dawud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1903b957", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1903b957", "label": "report: najd will always cause problems", "labels": ["report: najd will always cause problems"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:19b27380", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:19b27380", "label": "report: revelation came to me while i was under the blanket of aisha", "labels": ["report: revelation came to me while i was under the blanket of aisha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:19b3f804", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:19b3f804", "label": "report: the prophet forbade every carnivorous animal with fangs and every predatory bird (abu hurayra, in the muwatta, unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the prophet forbade every carnivorous animal with fangs and every predatory bird (abu hurayra, in the muwatta, unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1a24a8a4", "label": "report: the sea its water is pure and its dead are lawful", "labels": ["report: the sea its water is pure and its dead are lawful"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1bc19689", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1bc19689", "label": "report: sunnu bihim sunnata ahl al-kitab (treat the Zoroastrians as the People of the Book; al-Muwatta, numbered 631 in his edition)", "labels": ["report: sunnu bihim sunnata ahl al-kitab (treat the Zoroastrians as the People of the Book; al-Muwatta, numbered 631 in his edition)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1dc479f7", "label": "report: wudu from whatever fire has touched", "labels": ["report: wudu from whatever fire has touched"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:1fd6f410", "label": "report: be different to the jews and the christians and pray in your shoes", "labels": ["report: be different to the jews and the christians and pray in your shoes"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:206b1939", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:206b1939", "label": "report: do not say i am better than yunus (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: do not say i am better than yunus (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:20a83804", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:20a83804", "label": "report: i do not shake hands with women", "labels": ["report: i do not shake hands with women"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2154cd27", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2154cd27", "label": "report: you will see a woman travel from al-hira to makkah and circumambulate the kaba fearing none but allah (Adi ibn Hatim; in Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: you will see a woman travel from al-hira to makkah and circumambulate the kaba fearing none but allah (Adi ibn Hatim; in Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:21c47c81", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:21c47c81", "label": "report: in every living creature there is a reward", "labels": ["report: in every living creature there is a reward"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:24232b79", "label": "report: jesus passed a pig and said pass by in peace", "labels": ["report: jesus passed a pig and said pass by in peace"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:24469dbc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:24469dbc", "label": "report: he who attributes a lie to me let him prepare for damnation (unresolved; he calls it sahih)", "labels": ["report: he who attributes a lie to me let him prepare for damnation (unresolved; he calls it sahih)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:246187ac", "label": "report: the prophet tested ibn sayyad with a hidden word and he answered dukh", "labels": ["report: the prophet tested ibn sayyad with a hidden word and he answered dukh"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:24eaf1ba", "label": "report: ma bal aqwam what is the matter with people who do such and such", "labels": ["report: ma bal aqwam what is the matter with people who do such and such"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:25681cd0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:25681cd0", "label": "report: lift your hand and read the whole verse (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: lift your hand and read the whole verse (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:25953135", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:25953135", "label": "report: whoever keeps a dog loses a qirat of his reward every day", "labels": ["report: whoever keeps a dog loses a qirat of his reward every day"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:25dd70c6", "label": "report: a girl is not married until she is consulted", "labels": ["report: a girl is not married until she is consulted"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:266d2083", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:266d2083", "label": "report: know that your lord is not one-eyed (on the dajjal, unresolved)", "labels": ["report: know that your lord is not one-eyed (on the dajjal, unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2741e4cd", "label": "report: the dajjal emerges from the jews of isbahan (aisha)", "labels": ["report: the dajjal emerges from the jews of isbahan (aisha)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:27af0dd7", "label": "report: whoever kills a lizard with the first strike has a hundred rewards it blew on the fire of ibrahim", "labels": ["report: whoever kills a lizard with the first strike has a hundred rewards it blew on the fire of ibrahim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:29cf1793", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:29cf1793", "label": "report: umar ibn abd al-aziz used to listen to music before he became khalifah", "labels": ["report: umar ibn abd al-aziz used to listen to music before he became khalifah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:29d1db38", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:29d1db38", "label": "report: malik studied with rabia while still bursting with youth and he had an earring in his ear", "labels": ["report: malik studied with rabia while still bursting with youth and he had an earring in his ear"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2a4080d4", "label": "report: indeed allah is beautiful", "labels": ["report: indeed allah is beautiful"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2b141ddc", "label": "report: begin with yourself then those you are responsible for (the principle he cites, as paraphrased)", "labels": ["report: begin with yourself then those you are responsible for (the principle he cites, as paraphrased)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2c98b2b9", "label": "report: if the deen were by opinion the bottom of the khuff would deserve wiping more than the top", "labels": ["report: if the deen were by opinion the bottom of the khuff would deserve wiping more than the top"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2ea15ea5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2ea15ea5", "label": "report: abu hurayra narration on killing the apostate (unresolved; content not quoted)", "labels": ["report: abu hurayra narration on killing the apostate (unresolved; content not quoted)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:2f256513", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:2f256513", "label": "report: yad allah maa al-jamaah the hand of god is with the congregation (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: yad allah maa al-jamaah the hand of god is with the congregation (unresolved)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:309a93b6", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:309a93b6", "label": "report: akhriju al-yahud wa al-nasara min jazirat al-arab", "labels": ["report: akhriju al-yahud wa al-nasara min jazirat al-arab"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:32d192a5", "label": "report: al-din yusr the religion is ease", "labels": ["report: al-din yusr the religion is ease"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:336fe573", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:336fe573", "label": "report: the messenger of allah gave us the choice and we chose him", "labels": ["report: the messenger of allah gave us the choice and we chose him"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:34e916d2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:34e916d2", "label": "report: my ummah will not agree upon misguidance", "labels": ["report: my ummah will not agree upon misguidance"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3530749e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3530749e", "label": "report: the prophet rode out on a horse without a saddle to check a loud noise at night and returned (Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the prophet rode out on a horse without a saddle to check a loud noise at night and returned (Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:35db4e1f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:35db4e1f", "label": "report: nothing remains of prophethood except good dreams", "labels": ["report: nothing remains of prophethood except good dreams"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3635d5d3", "label": "report: the prophet married aisha at six and consummated the marriage at nine", "labels": ["report: the prophet married aisha at six and consummated the marriage at nine"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:37195d28", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:37195d28", "label": "report: the prophet told the sick to drink camel urine", "labels": ["report: the prophet told the sick to drink camel urine"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:37b7d106", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:37b7d106", "label": "report: three men claimed one child in yemen and ali cast lots between them and the prophet laughed until his molars showed", "labels": ["report: three men claimed one child in yemen and ali cast lots between them and the prophet laughed until his molars showed"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:386fa7b1", "label": "report: the prophet did not return the greeting until he wiped on the wall i disliked to mention allah except in a state of purity", "labels": ["report: the prophet did not return the greeting until he wiped on the wall i disliked to mention allah except in a state of purity"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:38a17c20", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:38a17c20", "label": "report: abu hurayra from khaybar we took no spoils except clothing cattle and sheep", "labels": ["report: abu hurayra from khaybar we took no spoils except clothing cattle and sheep"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3a3f2709", "label": "report: the prophet thought the dajjal was a jew and said i will take care of him", "labels": ["report: the prophet thought the dajjal was a jew and said i will take care of him"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3b2452f7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3b2452f7", "label": "report: allah has made these two gold and silk haram upon the males of my ummah (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: allah has made these two gold and silk haram upon the males of my ummah (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3b47a683", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3b47a683", "label": "report: yala ibn murra said i saw three things from the prophet including that he said to a boy come out enemy of allah i am the messenger of allah", "labels": ["report: yala ibn murra said i saw three things from the prophet including that he said to a boy come out enemy of allah i am the messenger of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3c0ad21e", "label": "report: al-arwah junud mujannada fa ma taarafa minha italafa (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)", "labels": ["report: al-arwah junud mujannada fa ma taarafa minha italafa (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3c5e20fc", "label": "report: abu sufyan asked the prophet to marry his daughter umm habibah", "labels": ["report: abu sufyan asked the prophet to marry his daughter umm habibah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3c7da8ed", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3c7da8ed", "label": "report: i saw sufyan ibn uyayna as a young man carrying his tablets sitting in the class of amr ibn dinar with an earring in his ear", "labels": ["report: i saw sufyan ibn uyayna as a young man carrying his tablets sitting in the class of amr ibn dinar with an earring in his ear"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3cceb4d9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3cceb4d9", "label": "report: hamza al-aslami narration on killing the apostate (unresolved; content not quoted)", "labels": ["report: hamza al-aslami narration on killing the apostate (unresolved; content not quoted)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3e31381a", "label": "report: be different to the mushrikin trim the moustaches and let the beards grow", "labels": ["report: be different to the mushrikin trim the moustaches and let the beards grow"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3e965d16", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3e965d16", "label": "report: the prophet hid behind palm trees to overhear ibn sayyad and his mother warned him (sahih muslim with a variant in bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the prophet hid behind palm trees to overhear ibn sayyad and his mother warned him (sahih muslim with a variant in bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3ec20135", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3ec20135", "label": "report: killing the apostate (content not quoted; called fabricated)", "labels": ["report: killing the apostate (content not quoted; called fabricated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3efddf38", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3efddf38", "label": "report: cursed is he who has intercourse with his wife in her anus (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: cursed is he who has intercourse with his wife in her anus (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3fce18c1", "label": "report: women are the majority of the people of hell and lacking in intellect and faith (in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: women are the majority of the people of hell and lacking in intellect and faith (in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:3ff18220", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:3ff18220", "label": "report: will we have intercourse in paradise dahman dahman [?]", "labels": ["report: will we have intercourse in paradise dahman dahman [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:40f60e96", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:40f60e96", "label": "report: seventy two virgins in paradise (number called fabricated or extremely weak)", "labels": ["report: seventy two virgins in paradise (number called fabricated or extremely weak)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:41c0b9f9", "label": "report: the divorce of one who is coerced is not a divorce (transmitted by Malik through Ibn Abbas; unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the divorce of one who is coerced is not a divorce (transmitted by Malik through Ibn Abbas; unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:428fe918", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:428fe918", "label": "report: my example and yours with this man is like a man whose horse ran away (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: my example and yours with this man is like a man whose horse ran away (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:42fd73b8", "label": "report: be different to the jews and the christians and dye your hair", "labels": ["report: be different to the jews and the christians and dye your hair"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:43b54f5f", "label": "report: a woman may not travel except with a mahram (Ibn Umar, Abu Hurayra, Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, Ibn Abbas; numbers not stated)", "labels": ["report: a woman may not travel except with a mahram (Ibn Umar, Abu Hurayra, Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, Ibn Abbas; numbers not stated)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:43b7f583", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:43b7f583", "label": "report: idha sallaytum ala al-mayyit fa-akhlisu lahu al-dua (as recited by the speaker; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: idha sallaytum ala al-mayyit fa-akhlisu lahu al-dua (as recited by the speaker; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:444310bc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:444310bc", "label": "report: when you conquer constantinople the dajjal will come out", "labels": ["report: when you conquer constantinople the dajjal will come out"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:46d4d9c4", "label": "report: the prophet tried to touch a woman and told her to give herself to him", "labels": ["report: the prophet tried to touch a woman and told her to give herself to him"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:47a536df", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:47a536df", "label": "report: menstruation is a thing allah has decreed for the daughters of adam (in Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: menstruation is a thing allah has decreed for the daughters of adam (in Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:47be092d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:47be092d", "label": "report: if i were to order anyone to prostrate to another i would order the wife to prostrate to her husband (called not authentic)", "labels": ["report: if i were to order anyone to prostrate to another i would order the wife to prostrate to her husband (called not authentic)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:48d2fb97", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:48d2fb97", "label": "report: two companions recited differently and the prophet said both are correct the quran is read in several ways", "labels": ["report: two companions recited differently and the prophet said both are correct the quran is read in several ways"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:49364277", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:49364277", "label": "report: aisha and umm sulaym carrying water skins to the wounded at uhud", "labels": ["report: aisha and umm sulaym carrying water skins to the wounded at uhud"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4a9d4173", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4a9d4173", "label": "report: constantinople will be conquered by an army of my ummah", "labels": ["report: constantinople will be conquered by an army of my ummah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4abab576", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4abab576", "label": "report: no human can ever conceptualise jannah", "labels": ["report: no human can ever conceptualise jannah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4accedcd", "label": "report: if the dajjal comes while i am among you i will contend with him on your behalf", "labels": ["report: if the dajjal comes while i am among you i will contend with him on your behalf"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4aee676f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4aee676f", "label": "report: a dog a donkey or a woman passing in front invalidates the prayer", "labels": ["report: a dog a donkey or a woman passing in front invalidates the prayer"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4bbbe027", "label": "report: the prophet recited surat al-najm and prostrated and everyone present prostrated muslims and mushrikin (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the prophet recited surat al-najm and prostrated and everyone present prostrated muslims and mushrikin (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4c9707e2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4c9707e2", "label": "report: madinah is better for them if only they knew", "labels": ["report: madinah is better for them if only they knew"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4d5b5008", "label": "report: allah did not send down a disease without sending down its cure those who know it know it and those who do not do not", "labels": ["report: allah did not send down a disease without sending down its cure those who know it know it and those who do not do not"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4d734d1d", "label": "report: if the hour comes while one of you is planting let him carry on planting", "labels": ["report: if the hour comes while one of you is planting let him carry on planting"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:4e196f83", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:4e196f83", "label": "report: the prophet had four plaits (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the prophet had four plaits (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:517e74fc", "label": "report: the evil eye is real", "labels": ["report: the evil eye is real"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:51d6c137", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:51d6c137", "label": "report: lam yakun al-nabi fahishan wa la sabbaban wa la laanan (Anas, in al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: lam yakun al-nabi fahishan wa la sabbaban wa la laanan (Anas, in al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:526d7260", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:526d7260", "label": "report: speak to people according to what they know; do you want allah and his messenger to be denied", "labels": ["report: speak to people according to what they know; do you want allah and his messenger to be denied"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5334d346", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5334d346", "label": "report: it is sadaqah for them and a gift for us (unresolved; the meat given as sadaqah, collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: it is sadaqah for them and a gift for us (unresolved; the meat given as sadaqah, collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:54f5da0f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:54f5da0f", "label": "report: when a boy is born on the seventh day he is given an earring to wear", "labels": ["report: when a boy is born on the seventh day he is given an earring to wear"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:55c8a02f", "label": "report: as far back as i can remember my parents practised islam abu bakr set out to migrate to abyssinia", "labels": ["report: as far back as i can remember my parents practised islam abu bakr set out to migrate to abyssinia"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:563127df", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:563127df", "label": "report: the angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog", "labels": ["report: the angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:566be7a1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:566be7a1", "label": "report: abu musa al-ashari had a woman of his tribe comb through his hair while on hajj", "labels": ["report: abu musa al-ashari had a woman of his tribe comb through his hair while on hajj"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:57dd2ee7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:57dd2ee7", "label": "report: umar said i would write the verse of stoning if people would not say he added to the book of allah", "labels": ["report: umar said i would write the verse of stoning if people would not say he added to the book of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:58780d20", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:58780d20", "label": "report: inna allaha yuhibbu an yura athara nimatihi ala abdihi (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)", "labels": ["report: inna allaha yuhibbu an yura athara nimatihi ala abdihi (paraphrased by the host; unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:58c43d93", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:58c43d93", "label": "report: ibn sayyad asked the prophet do you testify that i am the messenger of allah (unresolved; cited without being accepted)", "labels": ["report: ibn sayyad asked the prophet do you testify that i am the messenger of allah (unresolved; cited without being accepted)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:59b6539e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:59b6539e", "label": "report: one man can be the jamaah as long as he is upon the truth (unresolved; quoted as a Salafi argument)", "labels": ["report: one man can be the jamaah as long as he is upon the truth (unresolved; quoted as a Salafi argument)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5aa3d58c", "label": "report: i know that you love to pray with me but your prayer in your room is better for you than your prayer in my mosque (Umm Humayd)", "labels": ["report: i know that you love to pray with me but your prayer in your room is better for you than your prayer in my mosque (Umm Humayd)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5bbe2f3e", "label": "report: nothing stops musa bathing with us except a swollen testicle the rock ran away with his clothes", "labels": ["report: nothing stops musa bathing with us except a swollen testicle the rock ran away with his clothes"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5cfe6af1", "label": "report: were it not for jihad and hajj and kindness to my mother i would love to die a slave (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: were it not for jihad and hajj and kindness to my mother i would love to die a slave (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5d1281b0", "label": "report: the prophet forgot verses of the quran", "labels": ["report: the prophet forgot verses of the quran"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5eee3c4d", "label": "report: do not travel except to three mosques", "labels": ["report: do not travel except to three mosques"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5f1d2c6c", "label": "report: no one alive on earth tonight will be alive a hundred years from now", "labels": ["report: no one alive on earth tonight will be alive a hundred years from now"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:5faffb9e", "label": "report: whoever saw an evil must change it with his hand", "labels": ["report: whoever saw an evil must change it with his hand"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:60bcb4ee", "label": "report: cursed the one who tattoos and the one tattooed and the woman who plucks eyebrows changing the creation of allah", "labels": ["report: cursed the one who tattoos and the one tattooed and the woman who plucks eyebrows changing the creation of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:613960b2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:613960b2", "label": "report: the women would leave the fajr prayer and could not be recognised because of the darkness (cited as in al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the women would leave the fajr prayer and could not be recognised because of the darkness (cited as in al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:615032d4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:615032d4", "label": "report: uthman ibn abi al-as said i struggle with the quran and the prophet struck his chest and said go and lead your people", "labels": ["report: uthman ibn abi al-as said i struggle with the quran and the prophet struck his chest and said go and lead your people"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:61e009d9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:61e009d9", "label": "report: the prophet stood for the funeral of a jewish woman and said is it not a soul (as told by the host; unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the prophet stood for the funeral of a jewish woman and said is it not a soul (as told by the host; unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:620896d2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:620896d2", "label": "report: three men vowed to pray all night fast every day and never marry and the prophet condemned them", "labels": ["report: three men vowed to pray all night fast every day and never marry and the prophet condemned them"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6214b4e1", "label": "report: the dead seek news of their living relatives and pray for them (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the dead seek news of their living relatives and pray for them (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:62207cac", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:62207cac", "label": "report: the prophet sacrificed on behalf of himself his family and his ummah", "labels": ["report: the prophet sacrificed on behalf of himself his family and his ummah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:623f97e7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:623f97e7", "label": "report: nothing of the harmala seed emerges without an angel tied to it and in its seed is a cure for seventy two ailments", "labels": ["report: nothing of the harmala seed emerges without an angel tied to it and in its seed is a cure for seventy two ailments"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6271346a", "label": "report: ibn masud the christians claim jesus will return and after the destruction allah sends down a fluid from beneath the throne like the sperm of men from which the dead regrow", "labels": ["report: ibn masud the christians claim jesus will return and after the destruction allah sends down a fluid from beneath the throne like the sperm of men from which the dead regrow"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:63460405", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:63460405", "label": "report: leave him alone the bedouin who urinated in the mosque (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: leave him alone the bedouin who urinated in the mosque (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:64e37134", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:64e37134", "label": "report: the mahdi will fill the earth with justice", "labels": ["report: the mahdi will fill the earth with justice"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:64f7a13d", "label": "report: the woman with epilepsy who asked the prophet to pray for her and chose patience so long as she would not be uncovered", "labels": ["report: the woman with epilepsy who asked the prophet to pray for her and chose patience so long as she would not be uncovered"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6546db09", "label": "report: the prophet died with his shield pledged to a jewish man for bags of wheat (unresolved; cited as in Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the prophet died with his shield pledged to a jewish man for bags of wheat (unresolved; cited as in Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:65670e76", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:65670e76", "label": "report: present them three options embrace islam stay where you are as muslims or pay the jizya (unresolved; the hadith of Burayda, collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: present them three options embrace islam stay where you are as muslims or pay the jizya (unresolved; the hadith of Burayda, collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:65d7a81e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:65d7a81e", "label": "report: la tukthir al-dahik fa inna kathrat al-dahik tumit al-qalb (paraphrased by the host: laugh much and your heart becomes saddened)", "labels": ["report: la tukthir al-dahik fa inna kathrat al-dahik tumit al-qalb (paraphrased by the host: laugh much and your heart becomes saddened)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:664cc2c3", "label": "report: ibn abbas said seven things are from the sunnah for the boy on the seventh day he is named circumcised and his ear is pierced", "labels": ["report: ibn abbas said seven things are from the sunnah for the boy on the seventh day he is named circumcised and his ear is pierced"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6897f8ca", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6897f8ca", "label": "report: the most god fearing man i met in my life wore an earring", "labels": ["report: the most god fearing man i met in my life wore an earring"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:68a420f4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:68a420f4", "label": "report: killing geckos is rewarded (unresolved; cited as an example of hadith dogmatism)", "labels": ["report: killing geckos is rewarded (unresolved; cited as an example of hadith dogmatism)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:695244ce", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:695244ce", "label": "report: trials like pieces of the dark night", "labels": ["report: trials like pieces of the dark night"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:69859410", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:69859410", "label": "report: aisha married at seven", "labels": ["report: aisha married at seven"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:69a65512", "label": "report: command your children to pray at seven discipline them at ten and separate them in their beds", "labels": ["report: command your children to pray at seven discipline them at ten and separate them in their beds"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6b3b4416", "label": "report: jibril asks the prophet about iman and the signs of the hour", "labels": ["report: jibril asks the prophet about iman and the signs of the hour", "report: jibril asks the prophet about iman and the signs of the hour [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6cc10484", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6cc10484", "label": "report: antum al-yawm ala iddati ashabi talut (Abu Musa, via Ghunaym, in Ahmad)", "labels": ["report: antum al-yawm ala iddati ashabi talut (Abu Musa, via Ghunaym, in Ahmad)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6db69aaf", "label": "report: the parents of the prophet are in the fire", "labels": ["report: the parents of the prophet are in the fire"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6dede3f3", "label": "report: abu bakr said one side of my izar hangs down unless i attend to it and the prophet said you are not one of those who do it out of arrogance", "labels": ["report: abu bakr said one side of my izar hangs down unless i attend to it and the prophet said you are not one of those who do it out of arrogance"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6e606353", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6e606353", "label": "report: a man built a house and people said if only he had placed the door elsewhere", "labels": ["report: a man built a house and people said if only he had placed the door elsewhere"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6e8a4bfd", "label": "report: the life and blood of one muslim is more valuable than the kaaba", "labels": ["report: the life and blood of one muslim is more valuable than the kaaba"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6ed8eaaf", "label": "report: the days are three yesterday which has gone tomorrow which you do not know whether you will reach and today in which you are so act (he says probably not authentic as a hadith)", "labels": ["report: the days are three yesterday which has gone tomorrow which you do not know whether you will reach and today in which you are so act (he says probably not authentic as a hadith)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6ef44327", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6ef44327", "label": "report: what allah was silent about is pardoned and allah was not forgetful (cited as in Abu Dawud [?])", "labels": ["report: what allah was silent about is pardoned and allah was not forgetful (cited as in Abu Dawud [?])"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6efd403c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6efd403c", "label": "report: lan yudkhila ahadan amaluhu al-janna (no one enters paradise by his deeds)", "labels": ["report: lan yudkhila ahadan amaluhu al-janna (no one enters paradise by his deeds)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:6ff2ecf8", "label": "report: ibn umar presented at uhud at fourteen and refused presented at fifteen and accepted", "labels": ["report: ibn umar presented at uhud at fourteen and refused presented at fifteen and accepted"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:700a667a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:700a667a", "label": "report: the difference between our fasting and that of the people of the book is the suhur (unresolved; Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the difference between our fasting and that of the people of the book is the suhur (unresolved; Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:706285e0", "label": "report: tamim al-dari the island and the jassasa", "labels": ["report: tamim al-dari the island and the jassasa"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:71fcade0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:71fcade0", "label": "report: muawiya i do not deny that ali is more virtuous than me (cited as in Sahih Muslim, unverified)", "labels": ["report: muawiya i do not deny that ali is more virtuous than me (cited as in Sahih Muslim, unverified)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:72540d63", "label": "report: the hadith of al-irbad ibn sariya in abu dawud (unresolved; content not stated, called weak)", "labels": ["report: the hadith of al-irbad ibn sariya in abu dawud (unresolved; content not stated, called weak)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:72d55de9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:72d55de9", "label": "report: did you split open his heart (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: did you split open his heart (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:74385080", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:74385080", "label": "report: ibn abbas there is no riba except in nasi'a (unresolved; in Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: ibn abbas there is no riba except in nasi'a (unresolved; in Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:74b1d15f", "label": "report: umm haram bint milhan would comb the prophets hair and prepare his food and he would nap at her house", "labels": ["report: umm haram bint milhan would comb the prophets hair and prepare his food and he would nap at her house"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:75de6857", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:75de6857", "label": "report: women are the counterparts of men (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: women are the counterparts of men (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:76d23e12", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:76d23e12", "label": "report: man yamnauka minni (who will protect you from me)", "labels": ["report: man yamnauka minni (who will protect you from me)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:773e83d8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:773e83d8", "label": "report: umm atiyya said the prophet stretched out his hand and we stretched out our hands at the pledge", "labels": ["report: umm atiyya said the prophet stretched out his hand and we stretched out our hands at the pledge"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:77e47ac0", "label": "report: i saw the prophet trim his beard (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: i saw the prophet trim his beard (unresolved)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:79be7eb2", "label": "report: ali said execute them chop the head off throw them off a cliff burn them (unresolved; five differing narrations)", "labels": ["report: ali said execute them chop the head off throw them off a cliff burn them (unresolved; five differing narrations)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7a70bdbe", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7a70bdbe", "label": "report: ibn umar rebuked his son who said he would prevent his wife from going to the mosque (cited as in Sahih Muslim)", "labels": ["report: ibn umar rebuked his son who said he would prevent his wife from going to the mosque (cited as in Sahih Muslim)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7a76ff4c", "label": "report: o allah if this band perishes you will not be worshipped on earth", "labels": ["report: o allah if this band perishes you will not be worshipped on earth"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7b34dd38", "label": "report: married her when she was six and consummated the marriage when she was nine", "labels": ["report: married her when she was six and consummated the marriage when she was nine"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7b9f7f05", "label": "report: all the children of adam are sinners", "labels": ["report: all the children of adam are sinners"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7cef7cb5", "label": "report: whoever has intercourse with his wife in her anus allah will not look at him on the day of judgement (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: whoever has intercourse with his wife in her anus allah will not look at him on the day of judgement (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7dfd2715", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7dfd2715", "label": "report: whoever of you sees an evil let him change it with his hand", "labels": ["report: whoever of you sees an evil let him change it with his hand"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:7ef9c7d8", "label": "report: yanzilu fikum ibn maryam hakaman adlan", "labels": ["report: yanzilu fikum ibn maryam hakaman adlan"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:80b1af85", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:80b1af85", "label": "report: the prophet told the women not to raise their heads from sujud until the men had sat because their izars were tight", "labels": ["report: the prophet told the women not to raise their heads from sujud until the men had sat because their izars were tight"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:80ebd445", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:80ebd445", "label": "report: do not prevent the female servants of allah from the mosques of allah", "labels": ["report: do not prevent the female servants of allah from the mosques of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:814474b9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:814474b9", "label": "report: the best of your vinegar is the vinegar of your alcohol", "labels": ["report: the best of your vinegar is the vinegar of your alcohol"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:838663a8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:838663a8", "label": "report: aisha would have removed excessive facial hair from the daughters of abd al-rahman", "labels": ["report: aisha would have removed excessive facial hair from the daughters of abd al-rahman"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:871f66b9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:871f66b9", "label": "report: if ibrahim had lived he would have been a prophet", "labels": ["report: if ibrahim had lived he would have been a prophet"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8737fe17", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8737fe17", "label": "report: the prophet came out to a gathering and said leave the goatee and be different to them", "labels": ["report: the prophet came out to a gathering and said leave the goatee and be different to them"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:87a6618e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:87a6618e", "label": "report: safiyya came with her eye bruised and said kinana beat me because i dreamt a moon fell into my lap", "labels": ["report: safiyya came with her eye bruised and said kinana beat me because i dreamt a moon fell into my lap"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:89fbbe22", "label": "report: la tuqbalu salatu imraatin tatayyabat lil-masjid hatta taghtasila ghuslaha min al-janaba (Abu Hurayra; Abu Dawud and Ahmad, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: la tuqbalu salatu imraatin tatayyabat lil-masjid hatta taghtasila ghuslaha min al-janaba (Abu Hurayra; Abu Dawud and Ahmad, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8a304df1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8a304df1", "label": "report: tadawaw seek medicine (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: tadawaw seek medicine (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8a8fcaa3", "label": "report: wiping over leather socks for three days when travelling", "labels": ["report: wiping over leather socks for three days when travelling"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8a99943b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8a99943b", "label": "report: the dayyuth who has no protective jealousy over his women (called fabricated [?])", "labels": ["report: the dayyuth who has no protective jealousy over his women (called fabricated [?])"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8b0c9176", "label": "report: on the day of judgement people will be raised naked and some of my companions will be turned away and i will say as the righteous slave said", "labels": ["report: on the day of judgement people will be raised naked and some of my companions will be turned away and i will say as the righteous slave said"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8ba24dc2", "label": "report: aisha married at six and the marriage consummated at nine", "labels": ["report: aisha married at six and the marriage consummated at nine"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8bb1ef7b", "label": "report: the single rider is a devil two riders are two devils and three are a company (in the Muwatta, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the single rider is a devil two riders are two devils and three are a company (in the Muwatta, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8c289e7a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8c289e7a", "label": "report: la nurathu ma taraknahu sadaqah (we prophets do not leave inheritance; what we leave is charity; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: la nurathu ma taraknahu sadaqah (we prophets do not leave inheritance; what we leave is charity; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8ca2f04b", "label": "report: at the end of time people will consider maazif permissible (Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: at the end of time people will consider maazif permissible (Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:8e1abb62", "label": "report: three came to him at the kaaba and took him on the night journey before he was a prophet", "labels": ["report: three came to him at the kaaba and took him on the night journey before he was a prophet"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:904edb83", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:904edb83", "label": "report: allah will send for this ummah one who will renew its religion", "labels": ["report: allah will send for this ummah one who will renew its religion"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:90dd1daf", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:90dd1daf", "label": "report: if the prophet had seen what the women do now he would have prevented them from the mosque (Aisha)", "labels": ["report: if the prophet had seen what the women do now he would have prevented them from the mosque (Aisha)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:90dfbb22", "label": "report: you will know them when they are wrong (as paraphrased) [?]", "labels": ["report: you will know them when they are wrong (as paraphrased) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:91926944", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:91926944", "label": "report: do not sit at a table where wine is served", "labels": ["report: do not sit at a table where wine is served"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:91a4639f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:91a4639f", "label": "report: the houses in those days had no lamps (Aisha)", "labels": ["report: the houses in those days had no lamps (Aisha)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:91d7502c", "label": "report: if a dog licks the bowl wash it seven times", "labels": ["report: if a dog licks the bowl wash it seven times", "report: the dog licking the vessel and malik said we do not know its reality"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:91e93693", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:91e93693", "label": "report: man rama musliman bi shayin yuridu shaynahu bihi habasahu allah ala jisri jahannam (Abu Dawud, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: man rama musliman bi shayin yuridu shaynahu bihi habasahu allah ala jisri jahannam (Abu Dawud, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:92ce9938", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:92ce9938", "label": "report: the prophet forbade mutah and the meat of domestic donkeys", "labels": ["report: the prophet forbade mutah and the meat of domestic donkeys"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:94283449", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:94283449", "label": "report: satan flows through the son of adam like blood", "labels": ["report: satan flows through the son of adam like blood"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:943d2716", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:943d2716", "label": "report: the camel stumbled and the prophet covered safiyya with his cloak", "labels": ["report: the camel stumbled and the prophet covered safiyya with his cloak"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:94440e0b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:94440e0b", "label": "report: the shaytan flows in the son of adam like blood said when two men saw the prophet with safiyya", "labels": ["report: the shaytan flows in the son of adam like blood said when two men saw the prophet with safiyya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:94531d95", "label": "report: if the prophet veiled safiyya she was a wife and if not she was what his right hand possessed", "labels": ["report: if the prophet veiled safiyya she was a wife and if not she was what his right hand possessed"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:955dafe4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:955dafe4", "label": "report: whoever drags his garment out of arrogance allah will not look at him on the day of judgment", "labels": ["report: whoever drags his garment out of arrogance allah will not look at him on the day of judgment"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:95ed3e02", "label": "report: we are more deserving of doubt than ibrahim", "labels": ["report: we are more deserving of doubt than ibrahim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9780ca35", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9780ca35", "label": "report: the night of the jinn ibn masud carried nabidh and saw figures that did not cross the line while the prophet slept with his head in his lap", "labels": ["report: the night of the jinn ibn masud carried nabidh and saw figures that did not cross the line while the prophet slept with his head in his lap"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:97a63e0b", "label": "report: whoever kills a gecko in the first strike has a hundred rewards", "labels": ["report: whoever kills a gecko in the first strike has a hundred rewards"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9a6d7eff", "label": "report: the dajjal melts like salt in water when he sees jesus", "labels": ["report: the dajjal melts like salt in water when he sees jesus"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9a6e8d05", "label": "report: i wish the prophet had explained riba to us before he passed away (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: i wish the prophet had explained riba to us before he passed away (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9ac3373f", "label": "report: they recited poetry with the prophet through the night and then he said now read quran (Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: they recited poetry with the prophet through the night and then he said now read quran (Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9ae25c07", "label": "report: i have been commanded to fight the people until they testify that there is no god but allah (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, wording of Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: i have been commanded to fight the people until they testify that there is no god but allah (unresolved; Abu Hurayra, wording of Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9b193bf2", "label": "report: the prophet taught a dua to be said against tiyara omens", "labels": ["report: the prophet taught a dua to be said against tiyara omens"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9bbc1d36", "label": "report: whoever does the action of the people of lut (unresolved; Abu Dawud, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: whoever does the action of the people of lut (unresolved; Abu Dawud, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9c7f9d0b", "label": "report: al-fadl ibn abbas kept looking at a woman and the prophet turned his face away", "labels": ["report: al-fadl ibn abbas kept looking at a woman and the prophet turned his face away"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:9d01b67f", "label": "report: abu hurayra guarded the zakat wealth and let a thief go three nights until the thief taught him ayat al-kursi and the prophet said that was a devil who told the truth", "labels": ["report: abu hurayra guarded the zakat wealth and let a thief go three nights until the thief taught him ayat al-kursi and the prophet said that was a devil who told the truth"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a15c3e92", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a15c3e92", "label": "report: asked about the hour the prophet said what have you prepared for it", "labels": ["report: asked about the hour the prophet said what have you prepared for it"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a1bd50ab", "label": "report: if allegiance is given to two caliphs kill the latter of them (unresolved; called fabricated by the host)", "labels": ["report: if allegiance is given to two caliphs kill the latter of them (unresolved; called fabricated by the host)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a44612d9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a44612d9", "label": "report: the prophet offered asma bint abi bakr to ride behind him on his camel and she declined", "labels": ["report: the prophet offered asma bint abi bakr to ride behind him on his camel and she declined"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a58d8940", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a58d8940", "label": "report: the prophet said shall i marry you to her he said yes he said i have married her to you and there were no witnesses", "labels": ["report: the prophet said shall i marry you to her he said yes he said i have married her to you and there were no witnesses"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a5cdcded", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a5cdcded", "label": "report: the closest a person is to allah is when he is in sujud", "labels": ["report: the closest a person is to allah is when he is in sujud"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a63dafe9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a63dafe9", "label": "report: i do not know of a greater shirk than one who says jesus is her lord", "labels": ["report: i do not know of a greater shirk than one who says jesus is her lord"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a66e3532", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a66e3532", "label": "report: say bismillah eat with your right hand and eat from what is in front of you (unresolved; Umar ibn Abi Salama, Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: say bismillah eat with your right hand and eat from what is in front of you (unresolved; Umar ibn Abi Salama, Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a6bf32eb", "label": "report: the dajjal cannot enter madinah (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the dajjal cannot enter madinah (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a72ed1ed", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a72ed1ed", "label": "report: if a dog licks the vessel of one of you wash it seven times", "labels": ["report: if a dog licks the vessel of one of you wash it seven times"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a8af5be2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a8af5be2", "label": "report: whoever sleeps through a prayer or forgets it let him pray it when he awakens or remembers", "labels": ["report: whoever sleeps through a prayer or forgets it let him pray it when he awakens or remembers"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a8c001c0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a8c001c0", "label": "report: ya ibna adam maridtu fa lam taudni (God is found with the sick and the hungry)", "labels": ["report: ya ibna adam maridtu fa lam taudni (God is found with the sick and the hungry)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a8f03a5c", "label": "report: idha istayqazta fa-salli (when you wake up, pray)", "labels": ["report: idha istayqazta fa-salli (when you wake up, pray)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:a9513bc7", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:a9513bc7", "label": "report: what intoxicates in large amounts a small amount of it is haram (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: what intoxicates in large amounts a small amount of it is haram (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:aabca51a", "label": "report: if you destroyed the kaaba and rebuilt it and destroyed it that is not as great as harming the honour of a muslim", "labels": ["report: if you destroyed the kaaba and rebuilt it and destroyed it that is not as great as harming the honour of a muslim"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:aca4730d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:aca4730d", "label": "report: a woman's prayer in her makhda' is better than her prayer in her room", "labels": ["report: a woman's prayer in her makhda' is better than her prayer in her room"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ace50479", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ace50479", "label": "report: kab was teaching me from the torah and i was teaching him what the prophet said", "labels": ["report: kab was teaching me from the torah and i was teaching him what the prophet said"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ae3e7bbf", "label": "report: bashshiru wa la tunaffiru yassiru wa la tuassiru", "labels": ["report: bashshiru wa la tunaffiru yassiru wa la tuassiru"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:aea19cc5", "label": "report: men holding the tails of cows and women dressed yet naked paradise forbidden for them though its scent reaches five hundred years", "labels": ["report: men holding the tails of cows and women dressed yet naked paradise forbidden for them though its scent reaches five hundred years"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:aebb3191", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:aebb3191", "label": "report: abdullah ibn al-zubayr owned singing girls", "labels": ["report: abdullah ibn al-zubayr owned singing girls"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:afa4bcd9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:afa4bcd9", "label": "report: aisha playing with dolls the horse with two wings", "labels": ["report: aisha playing with dolls the horse with two wings"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b0a8648b", "label": "report: allah created adam in his image", "labels": ["report: allah created adam in his image"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b192ec8e", "label": "report: i heard people saying something so i said it", "labels": ["report: i heard people saying something so i said it"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b339bf83", "label": "report: umar threatened to beat abu hurayra for transmitting so much", "labels": ["report: umar threatened to beat abu hurayra for transmitting so much"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b3bd592a", "label": "report: trim the moustache and release the beard and be different to the majus", "labels": ["report: trim the moustache and release the beard and be different to the majus"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b3e70d55", "label": "report: wisdom is the lost property of the believer wherever he finds it", "labels": ["report: wisdom is the lost property of the believer wherever he finds it"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b517bd19", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b517bd19", "label": "report: the imam has been placed that you may follow him", "labels": ["report: the imam has been placed that you may follow him"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b6104c86", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b6104c86", "label": "report: prayer in this mosque of mine is better than a thousand prayers elsewhere except al-masjid al-haram", "labels": ["report: prayer in this mosque of mine is better than a thousand prayers elsewhere except al-masjid al-haram"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b6561480", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b6561480", "label": "report: when jesus descends lions graze with camels children play with snakes and jesus kills the pig", "labels": ["report: when jesus descends lions graze with camels children play with snakes and jesus kills the pig"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b802c2a5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b802c2a5", "label": "report: ali burned books (unresolved; a narration of Ahmad through Ikrima)", "labels": ["report: ali burned books (unresolved; a narration of Ahmad through Ikrima)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b97a2c7f", "label": "report: when the muslims conquer constantinople the dajjal appears and jesus descends in damascus", "labels": ["report: when the muslims conquer constantinople the dajjal appears and jesus descends in damascus"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b98a5cc4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b98a5cc4", "label": "report: we are an unlettered nation we do not write and we do not calculate", "labels": ["report: we are an unlettered nation we do not write and we do not calculate"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:b9d6a17d", "label": "report: jesus descends at the white minaret east of damascus", "labels": ["report: jesus descends at the white minaret east of damascus"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bb5fdb57", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bb5fdb57", "label": "report: whoever does not thank people does not thank allah", "labels": ["report: whoever does not thank people does not thank allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bbe9b820", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bbe9b820", "label": "report: bayt la tamr fihi jiyaa ahluhu", "labels": ["report: bayt la tamr fihi jiyaa ahluhu"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bc9a2ac5", "label": "report: you have restricted something vast, the mercy of allah", "labels": ["report: you have restricted something vast, the mercy of allah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bca2b93a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bca2b93a", "label": "report: gold for gold silver for silver wheat for wheat barley for barley dates for dates salt for salt like for like hand to hand (unresolved; in al-Bukhari and Muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: gold for gold silver for silver wheat for wheat barley for barley dates for dates salt for salt like for like hand to hand (unresolved; in al-Bukhari and Muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bd2ddd7d", "label": "report: do not oppress or wrong your brother", "labels": ["report: do not oppress or wrong your brother"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bd89c283", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bd89c283", "label": "report: aqilu dhawi al-hayat atharatihim forgive people of standing their slips", "labels": ["report: aqilu dhawi al-hayat atharatihim forgive people of standing their slips"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:be25f934", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:be25f934", "label": "report: the prophet sent ali to kill the man accused with the slave girl and he found him castrated", "labels": ["report: the prophet sent ali to kill the man accused with the slave girl and he found him castrated"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:be4605d1", "label": "report: the prophet struck the chest of a man and blew on him to drive out the devil", "labels": ["report: the prophet struck the chest of a man and blew on him to drive out the devil"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bef7f59e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bef7f59e", "label": "report: the prophet permitted al-zubayr and abd al-rahman ibn awf to wear silk because of an itch (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: the prophet permitted al-zubayr and abd al-rahman ibn awf to wear silk because of an itch (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:bf23b2da", "label": "report: do not tell a people a hadith their intellects cannot grasp or it becomes a trial for some of them", "labels": ["report: do not tell a people a hadith their intellects cannot grasp or it becomes a trial for some of them"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c0b608bd", "label": "report: the prophet prayed carrying a child (Umama)", "labels": ["report: the prophet prayed carrying a child (Umama)", "report: the prophet prayed carrying a child (unresolved)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c1643a4a", "label": "report: a female captive need only observe one menstrual cycle before marriage (awtas)", "labels": ["report: a female captive need only observe one menstrual cycle before marriage (awtas)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c26c7d53", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c26c7d53", "label": "report: no people gather in a house of the houses of allah reciting the book of allah and studying it among themselves except that tranquillity descends upon them", "labels": ["report: no people gather in a house of the houses of allah reciting the book of allah and studying it among themselves except that tranquillity descends upon them"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c2ba830a", "label": "report: the prophet tried to end his life on several occasions", "labels": ["report: the prophet tried to end his life on several occasions"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c3087e67", "label": "report: when jesus descends the people are offered islam or the sword", "labels": ["report: when jesus descends ill feeling is lifted from the earth and the people are offered islam or the sword", "report: when jesus descends the people are offered islam or the sword"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c39d4ab5", "label": "report: a man who leaves islam and goes out to wage war against allah and his messenger (unresolved; narrated from Aisha)", "labels": ["report: a man who leaves islam and goes out to wage war against allah and his messenger (unresolved; narrated from Aisha)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c485a5bc", "label": "report: singing brings hypocrisy in the heart as water gives rise to vegetation", "labels": ["report: singing brings hypocrisy in the heart as water gives rise to vegetation"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c538564d", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c538564d", "label": "report: dua is the marrow of worship (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: dua is the marrow of worship (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c54df7f0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c54df7f0", "label": "report: make dua in sujud for it is more deserving to be accepted", "labels": ["report: make dua in sujud for it is more deserving to be accepted"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c55bd513", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c55bd513", "label": "report: i was sent only to perfect good character", "labels": ["report: i was sent only to perfect good character"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c61312ab", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c61312ab", "label": "report: aisha was ten years younger than asma", "labels": ["report: aisha was ten years younger than asma"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c731c3f4", "label": "report: not a single human could ever conceptualise the afterlife", "labels": ["report: not a single human could ever conceptualise the afterlife"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c8516683", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c8516683", "label": "report: there will be no one left who believes in allah (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: there will be no one left who believes in allah (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:c92486c9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:c92486c9", "label": "report: i stood at the gate of jannah and most of those who entered were the poor while the rich were held back", "labels": ["report: i stood at the gate of jannah and most of those who entered were the poor while the rich were held back"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ca03ed2b", "label": "report: every prophet warned his ummah about the deceiver and a time of deception will come", "labels": ["report: every prophet warned his ummah about the deceiver and a time of deception will come"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:cd7aae33", "label": "report: aisha was a jariyah playing when the verse was revealed", "labels": ["report: aisha was a jariyah playing when the verse was revealed"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:cdce764b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:cdce764b", "label": "report: the prophet kissed his children; a man said he had not kissed any of his and was told whoever shows no mercy is shown none", "labels": ["report: the prophet kissed his children; a man said he had not kissed any of his and was told whoever shows no mercy is shown none"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ced425d4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ced425d4", "label": "report: we were commanded to place our right hands over our left hands in prayer (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: we were commanded to place our right hands over our left hands in prayer (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:cf08cbd1", "label": "report: umm aban's grandfather brought a child to the prophet who said come out enemy of allah", "labels": ["report: umm aban's grandfather brought a child to the prophet who said come out enemy of allah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:cf232df3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:cf232df3", "label": "report: the best prayer of a woman is in the darkest part of her house (Abu Hurayra, Ibn Khuzayma)", "labels": ["report: the best prayer of a woman is in the darkest part of her house (Abu Hurayra, Ibn Khuzayma)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:cfd72a49", "label": "report: the water of zamzam is for whatever it is drunk for (unresolved; collection not stated)", "labels": ["report: the water of zamzam is for whatever it is drunk for (unresolved; collection not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d00cf9c1", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d00cf9c1", "label": "report: the honour of a muslim is greater than the kaaba", "labels": ["report: the honour of a muslim is greater than the kaaba"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d056a27c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d056a27c", "label": "report: fatima asked the prophet for a servant and he taught her a dhikr instead (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: fatima asked the prophet for a servant and he taught her a dhikr instead (unresolved; Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d333f073", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d333f073", "label": "report: a person who establishes his salah his rizq increases (unresolved; cited without a reference)", "labels": ["report: a person who establishes his salah his rizq increases (unresolved; cited without a reference)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d490f6bb", "label": "report: the harshest of my ummah against the dajjal will be banu tamim", "labels": ["report: the harshest of my ummah against the dajjal will be banu tamim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d4e2def8", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d4e2def8", "label": "report: i have reached eighty years and met the companions none of them had this mark on the forehead have the foreheads become heavier or has the earth become harsher", "labels": ["report: i have reached eighty years and met the companions none of them had this mark on the forehead have the foreheads become heavier or has the earth become harsher"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d4f7745a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d4f7745a", "label": "report: they are the people whose companion is not deprived", "labels": ["report: they are the people whose companion is not deprived"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d574a07a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d574a07a", "label": "report: the prophet said to the woman give yourself to me", "labels": ["report: the prophet said to the woman give yourself to me"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d6df088f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d6df088f", "label": "report: there will be twelve caliphs all from quraysh (unresolved; called fabricated by the host)", "labels": ["report: there will be twelve caliphs all from quraysh (unresolved; called fabricated by the host)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d760391a", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d760391a", "label": "report: the mahdi army will come with the black flags", "labels": ["report: the mahdi army will come with the black flags"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d8ee1bfe", "label": "report: give glad tidings and do not frighten people away", "labels": ["report: give glad tidings and do not frighten people away"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:d938d7f6", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:d938d7f6", "label": "report: o allah there is no omen but your omen and no good but your good and no god but you", "labels": ["report: o allah there is no omen but your omen and no good but your good and no god but you"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:da54f8d2", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:da54f8d2", "label": "report: aisha said of mariya people spoke of the ifk that out of his love for a child he claimed another man child", "labels": ["report: aisha said of mariya people spoke of the ifk that out of his love for a child he claimed another man child"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:da792624", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:da792624", "label": "report: it is better for an iron rod to be driven into your head than to touch a woman not permitted to you", "labels": ["report: it is better for an iron rod to be driven into your head than to touch a woman not permitted to you"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:db4e34c0", "label": "report: when isa descends the dajjal melts like salt in water", "labels": ["report: when isa descends the dajjal melts like salt in water"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:dbe8e4ae", "label": "report: a woman performs hajj on behalf of her aged father who cannot ride", "labels": ["report: a woman performs hajj on behalf of her aged father who cannot ride"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:dd36e1dd", "label": "report: isa passed by pigs and said pass in peace", "labels": ["report: isa passed by pigs and said pass in peace"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:de76def6", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:de76def6", "label": "report: allah has not sent down a disease without sending its cure known to those who know it", "labels": ["report: allah has not sent down a disease without sending its cure known to those who know it"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:df71d13f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:df71d13f", "label": "report: umar said i would have restrained him and tried to bring him back (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: umar said i would have restrained him and tried to bring him back (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:df734495", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:df734495", "label": "report: whoever has anal intercourse has disbelieved in what was revealed to muhammad (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: whoever has anal intercourse has disbelieved in what was revealed to muhammad (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e02d6353", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e02d6353", "label": "report: singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetation (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetation (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e142e95b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e142e95b", "label": "report: i know that you are a stone you cannot cause me any harm or benefit but i saw the prophet kiss you (unresolved; Umar and the Black Stone)", "labels": ["report: i know that you are a stone you cannot cause me any harm or benefit but i saw the prophet kiss you (unresolved; Umar and the Black Stone)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e16705ba", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e16705ba", "label": "report: the woman who poisoned the food said if you were a prophet you would find out and the prophet said allah would not let you do that", "labels": ["report: the woman who poisoned the food said if you were a prophet you would find out and the prophet said allah would not let you do that"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e17cbcb0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e17cbcb0", "label": "report: the companions discussed the poetry of the jahiliyya in the mosque of the prophet (cited as in al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the companions discussed the poetry of the jahiliyya in the mosque of the prophet (cited as in al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e180f02c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e180f02c", "label": "report: the prophet forbade qaza (unresolved; Ibn Umar, Sahih Muslim and Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: the prophet forbade qaza (unresolved; Ibn Umar, Sahih Muslim and Sahih al-Bukhari, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e4357cc0", "label": "report: people will not find anyone more knowledgeable than the scholar of madinah", "labels": ["report: people will not find anyone more knowledgeable than the scholar of madinah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e4777bc0", "label": "report: do not obey a creature in disobedience to the creator", "labels": ["report: do not obey a creature in disobedience to the creator"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e4df847f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e4df847f", "label": "report: the woman prays in her wardrobe (content not quoted; called weak and false)", "labels": ["report: the woman prays in her wardrobe (content not quoted; called weak and false)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e592ec95", "label": "report: musa ran naked so that people could see he had no hernia", "labels": ["report: musa ran naked so that people could see he had no hernia"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e668f0cc", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e668f0cc", "label": "report: whoever wears silk in this world is deprived of it in jannah (unresolved)", "labels": ["report: whoever wears silk in this world is deprived of it in jannah (unresolved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e7000a50", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e7000a50", "label": "report: anas the night journey took place three years before prophethood", "labels": ["report: anas the night journey took place three years before prophethood"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:e92689a3", "label": "report: magic was done on the prophet and he became impotent", "labels": ["report: magic was done on the prophet and he became impotent"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ea6d7eac", "label": "report: buyer and seller may cancel the sale while they have not parted", "labels": ["report: buyer and seller may cancel the sale while they have not parted"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ea6d857b", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ea6d857b", "label": "report: khayr dinikum aysaruhu the best of your religion is the easiest of it", "labels": ["report: khayr dinikum aysaruhu the best of your religion is the easiest of it"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:eaaebf3c", "label": "report: uthman ibn abi al-as said i struggle with the quran and the prophet struck his chest and told him to lead his people", "labels": ["report: uthman ibn abi al-as said i struggle with the quran and the prophet struck his chest and told him to lead his people"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:eb4693f0", "label": "report: drink the urine and milk of the camels", "labels": ["report: drink the urine and milk of the camels"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:eb88e4e6", "label": "report: two men disputed an inheritance without evidence and the prophet told them to divide it and cast lots", "labels": ["report: two men disputed an inheritance without evidence and the prophet told them to divide it and cast lots"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ebce1887", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ebce1887", "label": "report: the prophet laid a cloth on the camel and put out his knee for safiyya to step on and mount", "labels": ["report: the prophet laid a cloth on the camel and put out his knee for safiyya to step on and mount"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ecbe3efd", "label": "report: the prophet sent ali to kill a man accused with mariya and he was found to have no penis", "labels": ["report: the prophet sent ali to kill a man accused with mariya and he was found to have no penis"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ee4de6d9", "label": "report: the tree crying for the prophet", "labels": ["report: the tree crying for the prophet"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:ef524ec4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:ef524ec4", "label": "report: this son of mine will bring two great factions together", "labels": ["report: this son of mine will bring two great factions together"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f204a3cd", "label": "report: maymuna married the prophet while he was in ihram", "labels": ["report: maymuna married the prophet while he was in ihram"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f45113be", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f45113be", "label": "report: allah created the soil on saturday and the creation over six days", "labels": ["report: allah created the soil on saturday and the creation over six days"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f5b8c382", "label": "report: jibril asked the prophet what is iman", "labels": ["report: jibril asked the prophet what is iman"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f6cdbddf", "label": "report: ibn sayyad swelled with anger until he filled the street (sahih muslim, number not stated)", "labels": ["report: ibn sayyad swelled with anger until he filled the street (sahih muslim, number not stated)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f942d247", "label": "report: if a woman refuses her husband's bed the angels curse her", "labels": ["report: if a woman refuses her husband's bed the angels curse her"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f9b6111f", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f9b6111f", "label": "report: the earth has been made a place of prostration for me", "labels": ["report: the earth has been made a place of prostration for me"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f9e49159", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f9e49159", "label": "report: the man who lost his camel in the desert said o allah you are my servant and i am your lord", "labels": ["report: the man who lost his camel in the desert said o allah you are my servant and i am your lord"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:f9eac639", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:f9eac639", "label": "report: when you wake up pray said to a companion whose wife complained he did not pray fajr", "labels": ["report: when you wake up pray said to a companion whose wife complained he did not pray fajr"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:fb13a1a4", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:fb13a1a4", "label": "report: if you leave a tenth of what you are commanded you will be destroyed; a time will come when whoever holds to a tenth will be saved", "labels": ["report: if you leave a tenth of what you are commanded you will be destroyed; a time will come when whoever holds to a tenth will be saved"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "type": "hadith", "key": "fp:fbb17a0e", "label": "report: isa will descend break the cross and kill the pigs", "labels": ["report: isa will descend break the cross and kill the pigs"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:5pillars", "type": "org", "key": "5pillars", "label": "5Pillars (news site) [?]", "labels": ["5Pillars", "5Pillars (news site) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:abbasids", "type": "org", "key": "abbasids", "label": "the Abbasids", "labels": ["Abbasids", "the Abbasids"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2022": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "org:ahmadiyya", "type": "org", "key": "ahmadiyya", "label": "Ahmadiyya", "labels": ["Ahmadiyya", "Ahmadiyya (Qadianis)", "the Ahmadiyya (Qadianis) [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "org:al-azhar", "type": "org", "key": "al-azhar", "label": "al-Azhar", "labels": ["al-Azhar"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "type": "org", "key": "al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "label": "al-Jama'a al-Salafiyya al-Muhtasiba", "labels": ["al-Jama'a al-Salafiyya al-Muhtasiba"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:al-maghrib-institute", "type": "org", "key": "al-maghrib-institute", "label": "AlMaghrib Institute", "labels": ["AlMaghrib Institute"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "type": "org", "key": "al-mahdi-institute", "label": "Al-Mahdi Institute", "labels": ["Al-Mahdi Institute"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:al-qaeda", "type": "org", "key": "al-qaeda", "label": "al-Qaeda", "labels": ["al-Qaeda"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:al-saud", "type": "org", "key": "al-saud", "label": "the Saud family (Al Saud)", "labels": ["the Saud family (Al Saud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:al-zaytuna", "type": "org", "key": "al-zaytuna", "label": "al-Zaytuna", "labels": ["al-Zaytuna"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:almohads", "type": "org", "key": "almohads", "label": "the Almohads (al-Muwahhidun)", "labels": ["the Almohads (al-Muwahhidun)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:almoravids", "type": "org", "key": "almoravids", "label": "the Almoravids (al-Murabitun)", "labels": ["the Almoravids (al-Murabitun)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:ansar", "type": "org", "key": "ansar", "label": "the Ansar", "labels": ["the Ansar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:banu-hashim", "type": "org", "key": "banu-hashim", "label": "Banu Hashim", "labels": ["Banu Hashim"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "org:banu-nadir", "type": "org", "key": "banu-nadir", "label": "Banu Nadir [?]", "labels": ["Banu Nadir", "Banu Nadir [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:banu-tamim", "type": "org", "key": "banu-tamim", "label": "Banu Tamim", "labels": ["Banu Tamim"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:banu-udhra", "type": "org", "key": "banu-udhra", "label": "Banu Udhra [?]", "labels": ["Banu Udhra [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:bayt-al-hikma", "type": "org", "key": "bayt-al-hikma", "label": "the house of wisdom (Bayt al-Hikma), which he calls Dar al-Hikmah", "labels": ["the house of wisdom (Bayt al-Hikma), which he calls Dar al-Hikmah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:bjp", "type": "org", "key": "bjp", "label": "BJP", "labels": ["BJP"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "type": "org", "key": "board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "label": "Board of Ulama and Mashaykh for Protecting the Beliefs of Islam (Bradford) [?]", "labels": ["Board of Ulama and Mashaykh for Protecting the Beliefs of Islam (Bradford) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:boko-haram", "type": "org", "key": "boko-haram", "label": "Boko Haram", "labels": ["Boko Haram"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:british-empire", "type": "org", "key": "british-empire", "label": "the British Empire", "labels": ["the British Empire"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:byzantine-empire", "type": "org", "key": "byzantine-empire", "label": "the Byzantine Empire", "labels": ["Byzantine Empire", "the Byzantine Empire"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "org:catholic-church", "type": "org", "key": "catholic-church", "label": "Catholic Church", "labels": ["Catholic Church", "Roman Catholic Church"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:charity-commission", "type": "org", "key": "charity-commission", "label": "the Charity Commission (England and Wales)", "labels": ["the Charity Commission (England and Wales)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:charlie-hebdo", "type": "org", "key": "charlie-hebdo", "label": "Charlie Hebdo", "labels": ["Charlie Hebdo"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:chishti-order", "type": "org", "key": "chishti-order", "label": "the Chishti tariqa [?]", "labels": ["the Chishti tariqa [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:cia", "type": "org", "key": "cia", "label": "the CIA", "labels": ["the CIA"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:dar-al-mustafa", "type": "org", "key": "dar-al-mustafa", "label": "Dar al-Mustafa (Tarim, Yemen)", "labels": ["Dar al-Mustafa (Tarim, Yemen)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:darussalam", "type": "org", "key": "darussalam", "label": "Darussalam (publisher)", "labels": ["Darussalam (publisher)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "type": "org", "key": "european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "label": "the European fatwa council [?] (as he names it, the Islamic fatwa council of Europe)", "labels": ["the European fatwa council [?] (as he names it, the Islamic fatwa council of Europe)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:fatimids", "type": "org", "key": "fatimids", "label": "the Fatimids [?]", "labels": ["the Fatimids [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:ghassanids", "type": "org", "key": "ghassanids", "label": "the Ghassanids", "labels": ["the Ghassanids"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:green-lane-masjid", "type": "org", "key": "green-lane-masjid", "label": "Green Lane Masjid (Birmingham)", "labels": ["Green Lane Masjid (Birmingham)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:hamas", "type": "org", "key": "hamas", "label": "Hamas", "labels": ["Hamas"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:harvard-university", "type": "org", "key": "harvard-university", "label": "Harvard University", "labels": ["Harvard University"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:himyar", "type": "org", "key": "himyar", "label": "Himyar", "labels": ["Himyar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "type": "org", "key": "hizb-ut-tahrir", "label": "Hizb ut-Tahrir", "labels": ["Hizb ut-Tahrir", "Hizb ut-Tahrir [?]"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "org:house-of-karen", "type": "org", "key": "house-of-karen", "label": "the House of Karen", "labels": ["the House of Karen"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:ipci", "type": "org", "key": "ipci", "label": "IPCI (Islamic Propagation Centre International)", "labels": ["IPCI (Islamic Propagation Centre International)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:isis", "type": "org", "key": "isis", "label": "ISIS", "labels": ["ISIS"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2015": 3, "2018": 7, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "type": "org", "key": "islamic-university-of-madinah", "label": "Islamic University of Madinah", "labels": ["Islamic University of Madinah"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:jamaat-e-islami", "type": "org", "key": "jamaat-e-islami", "label": "Jamaat-e-Islami", "labels": ["Jamaat-e-Islami"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:jamia-binoria", "type": "org", "key": "jamia-binoria", "label": "Jamia Binoria", "labels": ["Jamia Binoria"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:jamia-faruqiya", "type": "org", "key": "jamia-faruqiya", "label": "Jamia Faruqiya", "labels": ["Jamia Faruqiya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:khuzaa", "type": "org", "key": "khuzaa", "label": "Khuza'a [?]", "labels": ["Khuza'a [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:kingdom-of-aksum", "type": "org", "key": "kingdom-of-aksum", "label": "the Aksumite kingdom", "labels": ["the Aksumite kingdom"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:knowledge-revival", "type": "org", "key": "knowledge-revival", "label": "Knowledge Revival [?]", "labels": ["Knowledge Revival [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:lakhmids", "type": "org", "key": "lakhmids", "label": "the Lakhmids", "labels": ["the Lakhmids"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:levites", "type": "org", "key": "levites", "label": "the Levites", "labels": ["the Levites"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:loreal", "type": "org", "key": "loreal", "label": "L'Oreal", "labels": ["L'Oreal"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:metropolitan-police", "type": "org", "key": "metropolitan-police", "label": "Metropolitan Police", "labels": ["Metropolitan Police"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:mossad", "type": "org", "key": "mossad", "label": "Mossad", "labels": ["Mossad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:mughal-empire", "type": "org", "key": "mughal-empire", "label": "the Mughal Empire", "labels": ["the Mughal Empire"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:nabataeans", "type": "org", "key": "nabataeans", "label": "the Nabataeans", "labels": ["the Nabataeans"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "org:naqshbandi", "type": "org", "key": "naqshbandi", "label": "the Naqshbandi order", "labels": ["the Naqshbandi order"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:open-university", "type": "org", "key": "open-university", "label": "The Open University", "labels": ["The Open University"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:ottoman-empire", "type": "org", "key": "ottoman-empire", "label": "the Ottoman Empire", "labels": ["the Ottoman Empire", "the Ottomans"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "org:pharisees", "type": "org", "key": "pharisees", "label": "the Pharisees", "labels": ["the Pharisees"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:prevent-programme", "type": "org", "key": "prevent-programme", "label": "Prevent (UK counter-radicalisation programme)", "labels": ["Prevent (UK counter-radicalisation programme)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:qaramita", "type": "org", "key": "qaramita", "label": "the Qaramita (Carmathians)", "labels": ["the Qaramita (Carmathians)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:quraysh", "type": "org", "key": "quraysh", "label": "Quraysh", "labels": ["Quraysh"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 4, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "org:roman-empire", "type": "org", "key": "roman-empire", "label": "Roman Empire", "labels": ["Roman Empire"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "type": "org", "key": "ruet-e-hilal-committee", "label": "Ruet-e-Hilal (moon-sighting) committee, Pakistan [?]", "labels": ["Ruet-e-Hilal (moon-sighting) committee, Pakistan [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:sasanians", "type": "org", "key": "sasanians", "label": "the Sasanians", "labels": ["the Sasanians"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "type": "org", "key": "saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "label": "the Saudi board of fatwa (al-Lajna al-Da'ima) [?]", "labels": ["the Saudi board of fatwa (al-Lajna al-Da'ima) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "type": "org", "key": "sharia-councils-uk", "label": "Sharia councils in the UK", "labels": ["Sharia councils in the UK"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:sipah-e-sahaba", "type": "org", "key": "sipah-e-sahaba", "label": "Sipah-e-Sahaba [?]", "labels": ["Sipah-e-Sahaba [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:skt", "type": "org", "key": "skt", "label": "SKT (charity)", "labels": ["SKT (charity)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:sunni-defence", "type": "org", "key": "sunni-defence", "label": "Sunni Defence (YouTube channel)", "labels": ["Sunni Defence (YouTube channel)"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 17, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "type": "org", "key": "tablighi-jamaat", "label": "Tablighi Jamaat", "labels": ["Tablighi Jamaat", "Tablighi Jamaat [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:taliban", "type": "org", "key": "taliban", "label": "Taliban", "labels": ["Taliban"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:the-mad-mamluks", "type": "org", "key": "the-mad-mamluks", "label": "the Mad Mamluks podcast [?]", "labels": ["the Mad Mamluks podcast [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:twitter", "type": "org", "key": "twitter", "label": "Twitter", "labels": ["Twitter"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "org:ubaydids", "type": "org", "key": "ubaydids", "label": "the Ubaydids [?] (name garbled in the transcript)", "labels": ["the Ubaydids [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:umayyads", "type": "org", "key": "umayyads", "label": "the Umayyads", "labels": ["Banu Umayya", "Umayyads", "the Umayyad dynasty", "the Umayyads"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 8, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "org:united-nations", "type": "org", "key": "united-nations", "label": "United Nations", "labels": ["United Nations", "the United Nations"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "org:united-nations-security-council", "type": "org", "key": "united-nations-security-council", "label": "United Nations Security Council", "labels": ["United Nations Security Council"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:wayfair", "type": "org", "key": "wayfair", "label": "Wayfair", "labels": ["Wayfair"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "type": "org", "key": "wuhan-institute-of-virology", "label": "the Wuhan laboratory (Wuhan Institute of Virology)", "labels": ["the Wuhan laboratory (Wuhan Institute of Virology)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "org:yaqeen-institute", "type": "org", "key": "yaqeen-institute", "label": "Yaqeen Institute", "labels": ["Yaqeen Institute"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "org:zanata", "type": "org", "key": "zanata", "label": "the Zanata (Amazigh tribe)", "labels": ["the Zanata (Amazigh tribe)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "org:zaytuna-college", "type": "org", "key": "zaytuna-college", "label": "Zaytuna College", "labels": ["Zaytuna College"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "type": "person", "key": "abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "label": "al-Abbas ibn Abd al-Muttalib", "labels": ["al-Abbas ibn Abd al-Muttalib"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "type": "person", "key": "abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "label": "Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan", "labels": ["Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "type": "person", "key": "abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "label": "Abd al-Rahman ibn Mu'awiya (al-Dakhil)", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman ibn Mu'awiya (al-Dakhil)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "type": "person", "key": "abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "label": "Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Bakr", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Bakr"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "type": "person", "key": "abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "label": "Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ash'ath [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ash'ath [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abd-al-rahman-iii", "type": "person", "key": "abd-al-rahman-iii", "label": "Abd al-Rahman III", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman III"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdul-hameed-adam", "type": "person", "key": "abdul-hameed-adam", "label": "Abdul Hameed Adam", "labels": ["Abdul Hameed Adam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-al-andalusi", "label": "Abdullah al-Andalusi", "labels": ["Abdullah al-Andalusi"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "label": "Abdullah ibn Abi Sarh", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Abi Sarh", "Abdullah ibn Abi Sarh [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "label": "Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr", "Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr [?]"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "label": "Abdullah ibn Hudhafa [?] (name garbled in the transcript)", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Hudhafa [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-ibad", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-ibad", "label": "Abdullah ibn Ibad", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Ibad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "label": "Abdullah ibn Sa'd ibn Abi Sarh [?]", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Sa'd ibn Abi Sarh [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-salam", "label": "Abdullah ibn Salam", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Salam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "label": "Abdullah ibn Ubayy", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Ubayy"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-kunde", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-kunde", "label": "Abdullah Kunde [?]", "labels": ["Abdullah Kunde [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-sameer", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-sameer", "label": "Abdullah Sameer", "labels": ["Abdullah Sameer"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "type": "person", "key": "abdullah-yusuf-ali", "label": "Abdullah Yusuf Ali", "labels": ["Abdullah Yusuf Ali"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abla", "type": "person", "key": "abla", "label": "Abla (Antara's beloved)", "labels": ["Abla (Antara's beloved)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abraha", "type": "person", "key": "abraha", "label": "Abraha", "labels": ["Abraha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "type": "person", "key": "abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "label": "Abu al-As ibn al-Rabi'", "labels": ["Abu al-As ibn al-Rabi'"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-bakr", "type": "person", "key": "abu-bakr", "label": "Abu Bakr", "labels": ["Abu Bakr", "Abu Bakr [?]"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 3, "2020": 9, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "type": "person", "key": "abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "label": "Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi", "labels": ["Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-hurayra", "type": "person", "key": "abu-hurayra", "label": "Abu Hurayra", "labels": ["Abu Hurayra", "Abu Hurayra [?]"], "segments": 31, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 16, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 9, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "type": "person", "key": "abu-jafar-al-mansur", "label": "al-Mansur (Abbasid caliph)", "labels": ["al-Mansur (Abbasid caliph)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-jahl", "type": "person", "key": "abu-jahl", "label": "Abu Jahl", "labels": ["Abu Jahl"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "type": "person", "key": "abu-musa-al-ashari", "label": "Abu Musa al-Ash'ari", "labels": ["Abu Musa al-Ash'ari"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "type": "person", "key": "abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "label": "Abu Muslim al-Khurasani", "labels": ["Abu Muslim al-Khurasani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-nuwas", "type": "person", "key": "abu-nuwas", "label": "Abu Nuwas", "labels": ["Abu Nuwas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "type": "person", "key": "abu-said-al-khudri", "label": "Abu Sa'id al-Khudri", "labels": ["Abu Sa'id al-Khudri"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "person:abu-sufyan", "type": "person", "key": "abu-sufyan", "label": "Abu Sufyan", "labels": ["Abu Sufyan"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:abu-talib", "type": "person", "key": "abu-talib", "label": "Abu Talib", "labels": ["Abu Talib"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:abu-tammam", "type": "person", "key": "abu-tammam", "label": "Abu Tammam", "labels": ["Abu Tammam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "type": "person", "key": "abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "label": "Abu Yasir ibn Akhtab [?]", "labels": ["Abu Yasir ibn Akhtab [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:adam", "type": "person", "key": "adam", "label": "Adam", "labels": ["Adam"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2020": 8, "2021": 10, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "person:adam-smith", "type": "person", "key": "adam-smith", "label": "Adam Smith", "labels": ["Adam Smith"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:adi-ibn-hatim", "type": "person", "key": "adi-ibn-hatim", "label": "Adi ibn Hatim", "labels": ["Adi ibn Hatim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:adnan", "type": "person", "key": "adnan", "label": "Adnan", "labels": ["Adnan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:adolf-hitler", "type": "person", "key": "adolf-hitler", "label": "Adolf Hitler", "labels": ["Adolf Hitler"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ahmad-faraz", "type": "person", "key": "ahmad-faraz", "label": "Ahmad Faraz", "labels": ["Ahmad Faraz"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:aisha", "type": "person", "key": "aisha", "label": "Aisha", "labels": ["Aisha"], "segments": 46, "recordings": 30, "years": {"2018": 17, "2019": 5, "2020": 12, "2021": 11, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 46}}, {"id": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "type": "person", "key": "akbar-allahabadi", "label": "Akbar Allahabadi [?]", "labels": ["Akbar Allahabadi", "Akbar Allahabadi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:akhenaten", "type": "person", "key": "akhenaten", "label": "Akhenaten", "labels": ["Akhenaten"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-amin", "type": "person", "key": "al-amin", "label": "al-Amin", "labels": ["al-Amin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-asha", "type": "person", "key": "al-asha", "label": "al-A'sha [?] (the poet)", "labels": ["al-A'sha [?] (the poet)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "type": "person", "key": "al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "label": "al-Fadl ibn Abbas", "labels": ["al-Fadl ibn Abbas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-farazdaq", "type": "person", "key": "al-farazdaq", "label": "al-Farazdaq", "labels": ["al-Farazdaq"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "type": "person", "key": "al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "label": "al-Hajjaj ibn Yusuf", "labels": ["al-Hajjaj ibn Yusuf", "al-Hajjaj ibn Yusuf [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:al-mamun", "type": "person", "key": "al-mamun", "label": "al-Ma'mun", "labels": ["al-Ma'mun"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "type": "person", "key": "al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "label": "al-Mughira ibn Shu'ba", "labels": ["al-Mughira ibn Shu'ba"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:al-mutanabbi", "type": "person", "key": "al-mutanabbi", "label": "al-Mutanabbi", "labels": ["al-Mutanabbi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:albert-einstein", "type": "person", "key": "albert-einstein", "label": "Albert Einstein", "labels": ["Albert Einstein"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "type": "person", "key": "ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "label": "Ali ibn Abdullah ibn Abbas", "labels": ["Ali ibn Abdullah ibn Abbas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "type": "person", "key": "ali-ibn-abi-talib", "label": "Ali ibn Abi Talib", "labels": ["Ali ibn Abi Talib"], "segments": 37, "recordings": 24, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 8, "2019": 6, "2020": 10, "2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 37}}, {"id": "person:amena-khan", "type": "person", "key": "amena-khan", "label": "Amena Khan (Pearl Daisy)", "labels": ["Amena Khan (Pearl Daisy)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:amir-ibn-rabia", "type": "person", "key": "amir-ibn-rabia", "label": "Amir ibn Rabi'a", "labels": ["Amir ibn Rabi'a"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:amir-khan", "type": "person", "key": "amir-khan", "label": "Amir Khan", "labels": ["Amir Khan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "type": "person", "key": "amr-ibn-al-as", "label": "Amr ibn al-As", "labels": ["Amr ibn al-As"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "type": "person", "key": "anas-ibn-malik", "label": "Anas ibn Malik", "labels": ["Anas ibn Malik"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "person:anil-kapoor", "type": "person", "key": "anil-kapoor", "label": "Anil Kapoor", "labels": ["Anil Kapoor"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "type": "person", "key": "anis-ahmed-rushdie", "label": "Anis Ahmed Rushdie", "labels": ["Anis Ahmed Rushdie"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "type": "person", "key": "antara-ibn-shaddad", "label": "Antara ibn Shaddad", "labels": ["Antara ibn Shaddad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:aristotle", "type": "person", "key": "aristotle", "label": "Aristotle", "labels": ["Aristotle"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "person:arthur-c-clarke", "type": "person", "key": "arthur-c-clarke", "label": "Arthur C. Clarke", "labels": ["Arthur C. Clarke"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "type": "person", "key": "asadullah-al-andalusi", "label": "Asadullah al-Andalusi [?]", "labels": ["Asadullah al-Andalusi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:asim-qureshi", "type": "person", "key": "asim-qureshi", "label": "Asim Qureshi [?]", "labels": ["Asim Qureshi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "type": "person", "key": "asma-bint-abi-bakr", "label": "Asma bint Abi Bakr", "labels": ["Asma bint Abi Bakr"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:ayyub", "type": "person", "key": "ayyub", "label": "Ayyub (Job)", "labels": ["Ayyub (Job)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:aziz-mian", "type": "person", "key": "aziz-mian", "label": "Aziz Mian", "labels": ["Aziz Mian"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:barack-obama", "type": "person", "key": "barack-obama", "label": "Barack Obama", "labels": ["Barack Obama"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:basil-mitchell", "type": "person", "key": "basil-mitchell", "label": "Basil Mitchell", "labels": ["Basil Mitchell", "Basil Mitchell (philosopher of religion)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:benjamin-netanyahu", "type": "person", "key": "benjamin-netanyahu", "label": "Benjamin Netanyahu", "labels": ["Benjamin Netanyahu"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:bertrand-russell", "type": "person", "key": "bertrand-russell", "label": "Bertrand Russell", "labels": ["Bertrand Russell"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:bilal-ibn-rabah", "type": "person", "key": "bilal-ibn-rabah", "label": "Bilal", "labels": ["Bilal"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:binyamin", "type": "person", "key": "binyamin", "label": "Binyamin (Benjamin)", "labels": ["Binyamin (Benjamin)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "type": "person", "key": "bishr-ibn-al-bara", "label": "Bishr ibn al-Bara' [?]", "labels": ["Bishr ibn al-Bara' [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:blaise-pascal", "type": "person", "key": "blaise-pascal", "label": "Blaise Pascal", "labels": ["Blaise Pascal"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:boris-johnson", "type": "person", "key": "boris-johnson", "label": "Boris Johnson", "labels": ["Boris Johnson"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:buddha", "type": "person", "key": "buddha", "label": "the Buddha", "labels": ["the Buddha"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:burayda", "type": "person", "key": "burayda", "label": "Burayda [?]", "labels": ["Burayda [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:charlemagne", "type": "person", "key": "charlemagne", "label": "Charlemagne", "labels": ["Charlemagne"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:charles-darwin", "type": "person", "key": "charles-darwin", "label": "Charles Darwin", "labels": ["Charles Darwin"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:charles-martel", "type": "person", "key": "charles-martel", "label": "Charles Martel", "labels": ["Charles Martel"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:christopher-hitchens", "type": "person", "key": "christopher-hitchens", "label": "Christopher Hitchens", "labels": ["Christopher Hitchens"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:colin-humphreys", "type": "person", "key": "colin-humphreys", "label": "Colin Humphreys", "labels": ["Colin Humphreys"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:confucius", "type": "person", "key": "confucius", "label": "Confucius", "labels": ["Confucius"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:conor-mcgregor", "type": "person", "key": "conor-mcgregor", "label": "Conor McGregor", "labels": ["Conor McGregor"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:dagh-dehlvi", "type": "person", "key": "dagh-dehlvi", "label": "Dagh Dehlvi", "labels": ["Dagh Dehlvi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:dal-babu", "type": "person", "key": "dal-babu", "label": "Dal Babu, former Chief Superintendent, Metropolitan Police [?]", "labels": ["Dal Babu, former Chief Superintendent, Metropolitan Police [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:dan-gibson", "type": "person", "key": "dan-gibson", "label": "Dan Gibson", "labels": ["Dan Gibson"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "person:daniel", "type": "person", "key": "daniel", "label": "Daniel (prophet)", "labels": ["Daniel (prophet)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:daniel-brubaker", "type": "person", "key": "daniel-brubaker", "label": "Daniel Brubaker", "labels": ["Daniel Brubaker"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "type": "person", "key": "daniel-haqiqatjou", "label": "Daniel Haqiqatjou", "labels": ["Daniel Haqiqatjou", "Daniel Haqiqatjou [?]"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2019": 4, "2020": 7, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "person:dante-alighieri", "type": "person", "key": "dante-alighieri", "label": "Dante", "labels": ["Dante"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:dave-chappelle", "type": "person", "key": "dave-chappelle", "label": "Dave Chappelle", "labels": ["Dave Chappelle"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:david-ray-griffin", "type": "person", "key": "david-ray-griffin", "label": "David Ray Griffin", "labels": ["David Ray Griffin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:david-sloan-wilson", "type": "person", "key": "david-sloan-wilson", "label": "David Sloan Wilson", "labels": ["David Sloan Wilson"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:david-wood", "type": "person", "key": "david-wood", "label": "David Wood", "labels": ["David Wood"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 9, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "person:dawah-man", "type": "person", "key": "dawah-man", "label": "Dawah Man", "labels": ["Dawah Man", "Dawah Man [?]"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "person:dawud", "type": "person", "key": "dawud", "label": "Dawud (David)", "labels": ["David (Dawud)", "Dawud (David)"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "person:derren-brown", "type": "person", "key": "derren-brown", "label": "Derren Brown", "labels": ["Derren Brown"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "type": "person", "key": "dihya-al-kalbi", "label": "Dihya al-Kalbi", "labels": ["Dihya al-Kalbi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:diogenes", "type": "person", "key": "diogenes", "label": "Diogenes", "labels": ["Diogenes"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:donald-trump", "type": "person", "key": "donald-trump", "label": "Donald Trump", "labels": ["Donald Trump"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "person:elon-musk", "type": "person", "key": "elon-musk", "label": "Elon Musk", "labels": ["Elon Musk"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:emile-durkheim", "type": "person", "key": "emile-durkheim", "label": "Emile Durkheim", "labels": ["Emile Durkheim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:emmanuel-macron", "type": "person", "key": "emmanuel-macron", "label": "Emmanuel Macron", "labels": ["Emmanuel Macron"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:erik-erikson", "type": "person", "key": "erik-erikson", "label": "Erik Erikson", "labels": ["Erik Erikson"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ezekiel", "type": "person", "key": "ezekiel", "label": "Ezekiel (prophet)", "labels": ["Ezekiel (prophet)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ezra", "type": "person", "key": "ezra", "label": "Ezra", "labels": ["Ezra"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:farid", "type": "person", "key": "farid", "label": "Farid [?]", "labels": ["Farid [?]"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 8, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "person:fatima", "type": "person", "key": "fatima", "label": "Fatima", "labels": ["Fatima"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "person:fatima-bint-malik", "type": "person", "key": "fatima-bint-malik", "label": "Fatima, Imam Malik's daughter", "labels": ["Fatima, Imam Malik's daughter"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:firas-zahabi", "type": "person", "key": "firas-zahabi", "label": "Firas Zahabi [?]", "labels": ["Firas Zahabi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:firawn", "type": "person", "key": "firawn", "label": "Pharaoh", "labels": ["Pharaoh", "Pharaoh (Fir'awn)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:francis-bacon", "type": "person", "key": "francis-bacon", "label": "Francis Bacon", "labels": ["Francis Bacon"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:frans-de-waal", "type": "person", "key": "frans-de-waal", "label": "Frans de Waal", "labels": ["Frans de Waal"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:frederic-bartlett", "type": "person", "key": "frederic-bartlett", "label": "Frederic Bartlett (psychologist)", "labels": ["Frederic Bartlett (psychologist)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:friedrich-nietzsche", "type": "person", "key": "friedrich-nietzsche", "label": "Friedrich Nietzsche", "labels": ["Friedrich Nietzsche"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:galileo-galilei", "type": "person", "key": "galileo-galilei", "label": "Galileo", "labels": ["Galileo"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:george-w-bush", "type": "person", "key": "george-w-bush", "label": "George W. Bush", "labels": ["George W. Bush"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ghislaine-maxwell", "type": "person", "key": "ghislaine-maxwell", "label": "Ghislaine Maxwell", "labels": ["Ghislaine Maxwell"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:gilgamesh", "type": "person", "key": "gilgamesh", "label": "Gilgamesh", "labels": ["Gilgamesh"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:gordon-wasson", "type": "person", "key": "gordon-wasson", "label": "R. Gordon Wasson", "labels": ["R. Gordon Wasson"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:graham-hancock", "type": "person", "key": "graham-hancock", "label": "Graham Hancock", "labels": ["Graham Hancock"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:habil", "type": "person", "key": "habil", "label": "Habil (Abel)", "labels": ["Habil (Abel)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:hajar", "type": "person", "key": "hajar", "label": "Hajar", "labels": ["Hajar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "type": "person", "key": "hamza-ali-abbasi", "label": "Hamza Ali Abbasi", "labels": ["Hamza Ali Abbasi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "type": "person", "key": "hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "label": "Hamza al-Aslami [?]", "labels": ["Hamza al-Aslami [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "type": "person", "key": "hamza-tzortzis", "label": "Hamza Tzortzis", "labels": ["Hamza Tzortzis", "Hamza Tzortzis [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "type": "person", "key": "hani-ibn-thubayt", "label": "Hani ibn Thubayt al-Hadrami [?]", "labels": ["Hani ibn Thubayt al-Hadrami [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:hani-ibn-urwa", "type": "person", "key": "hani-ibn-urwa", "label": "Hani (ibn Urwa)", "labels": ["Hani (ibn Urwa)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:harris-sultan", "type": "person", "key": "harris-sultan", "label": "Harris Sultan [?]", "labels": ["Harris Sultan", "Harris Sultan [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:harun", "type": "person", "key": "harun", "label": "Harun (Aaron)", "labels": ["Harun (Aaron)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:harun-al-rashid", "type": "person", "key": "harun-al-rashid", "label": "Harun al-Rashid", "labels": ["Harun al-Rashid"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:harun-yahya", "type": "person", "key": "harun-yahya", "label": "Harun Yahya (Adnan Oktar)", "labels": ["Harun Yahya (Adnan Oktar)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "type": "person", "key": "hasan-ibn-ali", "label": "Hasan ibn Ali", "labels": ["Hasan ibn Ali"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "person:hawwa", "type": "person", "key": "hawwa", "label": "Hawwa (Eve)", "labels": ["Eve (Hawwa)", "Hawwa (Eve)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:heraclius", "type": "person", "key": "heraclius", "label": "Heraclius (referred to, not named)", "labels": ["Heraclius (referred to, not named)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:herod-the-great", "type": "person", "key": "herod-the-great", "label": "Herod the Great", "labels": ["Herod the Great"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "type": "person", "key": "hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "label": "Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman", "labels": ["Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "type": "person", "key": "husayn-ibn-ali", "label": "Husayn ibn Ali", "labels": ["Husayn ibn Ali", "Husayn ibn Ali (the Prophet's grandson, referred to)"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 4, "2020": 13, "2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "type": "person", "key": "huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "label": "Huyayy ibn Akhtab", "labels": ["Huyayy ibn Akhtab"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:ibn-abbas", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-abbas", "label": "Ibn Abbas", "labels": ["Ibn Abbas", "Ibn Abbas [?]"], "segments": 32, "recordings": 26, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 10, "2019": 6, "2020": 6, "2021": 6, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 32}}, {"id": "person:ibn-al-awwam", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-al-awwam", "label": "Ibn al-Awwam [?]", "labels": ["Ibn al-Awwam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ibn-al-haytham", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-al-haytham", "label": "Ibn al-Haytham (Alhazen)", "labels": ["Ibn al-Haytham (Alhazen)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ibn-masud", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-masud", "label": "Ibn Mas'ud", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Mas'ud", "Ibn Mas'ud", "Ibn Mas'ud [?]"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "person:ibn-muljam", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-muljam", "label": "Ibn Muljam", "labels": ["Ibn Muljam"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:ibn-sayyad", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-sayyad", "label": "Ibn Sayyad", "labels": ["Ibn Sayyad", "Ibn Sayyad [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:ibn-umar", "type": "person", "key": "ibn-umar", "label": "Ibn Umar", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn Umar", "Ibn Umar", "Ibn Umar [?]"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "person:ibrahim", "type": "person", "key": "ibrahim", "label": "Ibrahim (Abraham)", "labels": ["Ibrahim", "Ibrahim (Abraham)"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 9, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "type": "person", "key": "ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "label": "Ibrahim, brother of al-Nafs al-Zakiyya [?]", "labels": ["Ibrahim, brother of al-Nafs al-Zakiyya [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "type": "person", "key": "ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "label": "Ibrahim, the son of the Prophet", "labels": ["Ibrahim, the son of the Prophet"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:ilyas", "type": "person", "key": "ilyas", "label": "Ilyas (Elijah)", "labels": ["Ilyas (Elijah)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:immanuel-kant", "type": "person", "key": "immanuel-kant", "label": "Immanuel Kant", "labels": ["Immanuel Kant"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:imran-ibn-husayn", "type": "person", "key": "imran-ibn-husayn", "label": "Imran ibn Husayn", "labels": ["Imran ibn Husayn"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:imran-khan", "type": "person", "key": "imran-khan", "label": "Imran Khan", "labels": ["Imran Khan"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:imru-al-qais", "type": "person", "key": "imru-al-qais", "label": "Imru' al-Qais", "labels": ["Imru' al-Qais"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:isa", "type": "person", "key": "isa", "label": "Isa (Jesus)", "labels": ["Isa (Jesus)", "Jesus (Isa)"], "segments": 60, "recordings": 31, "years": {"2018": 17, "2019": 11, "2020": 7, "2021": 24, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 60}}, {"id": "person:ishaq", "type": "person", "key": "ishaq", "label": "Ishaq", "labels": ["Ishaq"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ismail", "type": "person", "key": "ismail", "label": "Ismail", "labels": ["Isma'il", "Ismail"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "type": "person", "key": "jabir-ibn-abdullah", "label": "Jabir ibn Abdullah", "labels": ["Jabir ibn Abdullah"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "type": "person", "key": "jalal-al-din-akbar", "label": "Jalal al-Din Akbar", "labels": ["Jalal al-Din Akbar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jared-diamond", "type": "person", "key": "jared-diamond", "label": "Jared Diamond", "labels": ["Jared Diamond"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:jay-smith", "type": "person", "key": "jay-smith", "label": "Jay Smith", "labels": ["Jay Smith"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:jean-jacques-rousseau", "type": "person", "key": "jean-jacques-rousseau", "label": "Jean-Jacques Rousseau", "labels": ["Jean-Jacques Rousseau"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:jeffrey-epstein", "type": "person", "key": "jeffrey-epstein", "label": "Jeffrey Epstein", "labels": ["Jeffrey Epstein"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jeffrey-lang", "type": "person", "key": "jeffrey-lang", "label": "Dr Jeffrey Lang", "labels": ["Dr Jeffrey Lang"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:jephthah", "type": "person", "key": "jephthah", "label": "Jephthah", "labels": ["Jephthah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jeremy-bentham", "type": "person", "key": "jeremy-bentham", "label": "Jeremy Bentham", "labels": ["Jeremy Bentham"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jethro", "type": "person", "key": "jethro", "label": "Jethro (biblical)", "labels": ["Jethro (biblical)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jibril", "type": "person", "key": "jibril", "label": "Jibril", "labels": ["Jibril", "Jibril (Gabriel)"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "person:joe-biden", "type": "person", "key": "joe-biden", "label": "Joe Biden", "labels": ["Joe Biden"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:joe-rogan", "type": "person", "key": "joe-rogan", "label": "Joe Rogan", "labels": ["Joe Rogan"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:john-cobb", "type": "person", "key": "john-cobb", "label": "John Cobb", "labels": ["John Cobb"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:john-locke", "type": "person", "key": "john-locke", "label": "John Locke", "labels": ["John Locke"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:jordan-peterson", "type": "person", "key": "jordan-peterson", "label": "Jordan Peterson", "labels": ["Jordan Peterson"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:joseph-husband-of-mary", "type": "person", "key": "joseph-husband-of-mary", "label": "Joseph, husband of Mary", "labels": ["Joseph, husband of Mary"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:juan-cole", "type": "person", "key": "juan-cole", "label": "Juan Cole", "labels": ["Juan Cole"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "type": "person", "key": "jubayr-ibn-mutim", "label": "Jubayr ibn Mut'im [?]", "labels": ["Jubayr ibn Mut'im [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:juha", "type": "person", "key": "juha", "label": "Juha", "labels": ["Juha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "type": "person", "key": "juhayman-al-utaybi", "label": "Juhayman al-Utaybi", "labels": ["Juhayman al-Utaybi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:junaid-jamshed", "type": "person", "key": "junaid-jamshed", "label": "Junaid Jamshed", "labels": ["Junaid Jamshed"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:justinian-i", "type": "person", "key": "justinian-i", "label": "Justinian I", "labels": ["Justinian I"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:kab-al-ahbar", "type": "person", "key": "kab-al-ahbar", "label": "Ka'b al-Ahbar", "labels": ["Ka'b al-Ahbar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:kab-ibn-zuhayr", "type": "person", "key": "kab-ibn-zuhayr", "label": "Ka'b ibn Zuhayr", "labels": ["Ka'b ibn Zuhayr"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:kanye-west", "type": "person", "key": "kanye-west", "label": "Kanye West", "labels": ["Kanye West"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:karl-popper", "type": "person", "key": "karl-popper", "label": "Karl Popper (as named on air)", "labels": ["Karl Popper (as named on air)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:kawthar", "type": "person", "key": "kawthar", "label": "Kawthar, slave of al-Amin [?]", "labels": ["Kawthar, slave of al-Amin [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:khabib-nurmagomedov", "type": "person", "key": "khabib-nurmagomedov", "label": "Khabib Nurmagomedov", "labels": ["Khabib Nurmagomedov"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:khadijah", "type": "person", "key": "khadijah", "label": "Khadijah", "labels": ["Khadijah"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "type": "person", "key": "khadim-hussain-rizvi", "label": "Khadim Hussain Rizvi [?]", "labels": ["Khadim Hussain Rizvi", "Khadim Hussain Rizvi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:khawla-bint-hakim", "type": "person", "key": "khawla-bint-hakim", "label": "Khawla bint Hakim [?]", "labels": ["Khawla bint Hakim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:khidr", "type": "person", "key": "khidr", "label": "al-Khidr", "labels": ["al-Khidr", "al-Khidr (referred to, not named: the one who kills the boy)", "al-Khidr (the servant of Allah; name garbled in the transcript) [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "person:kilab-ibn-murra", "type": "person", "key": "kilab-ibn-murra", "label": "Kilab", "labels": ["Kilab"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "type": "person", "key": "kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "label": "Kinana ibn al-Rabi' [?] (Safiyya's husband)", "labels": ["Kinana ibn al-Rabi' [?] (Safiyya's husband)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:lawrence-krauss", "type": "person", "key": "lawrence-krauss", "label": "Lawrence Krauss", "labels": ["Lawrence Krauss"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:leo-tolstoy", "type": "person", "key": "leo-tolstoy", "label": "Leo Tolstoy", "labels": ["Leo Tolstoy"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:leonardo-da-vinci", "type": "person", "key": "leonardo-da-vinci", "label": "Leonardo da Vinci", "labels": ["Leonardo da Vinci"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:lilith", "type": "person", "key": "lilith", "label": "Lilith", "labels": ["Lilith"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:lupe-fiasco", "type": "person", "key": "lupe-fiasco", "label": "Lupe Fiasco", "labels": ["Lupe Fiasco"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:lut", "type": "person", "key": "lut", "label": "Lut", "labels": ["Lut", "Lut (Lot)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:mahira-khan", "type": "person", "key": "mahira-khan", "label": "Mahira Khan", "labels": ["Mahira Khan"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:mahmud-ibn-maslama", "type": "person", "key": "mahmud-ibn-maslama", "label": "Mahmud ibn Maslama", "labels": ["Mahmud ibn Maslama"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:manu", "type": "person", "key": "manu", "label": "Manu (Hindu tradition)", "labels": ["Manu (Hindu tradition)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "type": "person", "key": "mariya-al-qibtiyya", "label": "Mariya al-Qibtiyya", "labels": ["Mariya al-Qibtiyya"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "person:martin-luther", "type": "person", "key": "martin-luther", "label": "Martin Luther", "labels": ["Martin Luther"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "type": "person", "key": "marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "label": "Marwan ibn al-Hakam", "labels": ["Marwan ibn al-Hakam"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:maryam", "type": "person", "key": "maryam", "label": "Maryam (Mary)", "labels": ["Maryam (Mary)"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "person:matt-hancock", "type": "person", "key": "matt-hancock", "label": "Matt Hancock", "labels": ["Matt Hancock"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:matt-walsh", "type": "person", "key": "matt-walsh", "label": "Matt Walsh", "labels": ["Matt Walsh"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:mehmed-ii", "type": "person", "key": "mehmed-ii", "label": "Sultan Mehmed al-Fatih", "labels": ["Sultan Mehmed al-Fatih"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:michael-cook", "type": "person", "key": "michael-cook", "label": "Michael Cook [?]", "labels": ["Michael Cook [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:michel-foucault", "type": "person", "key": "michel-foucault", "label": "Michel Foucault", "labels": ["Michel Foucault"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mike-tyson", "type": "person", "key": "mike-tyson", "label": "Mike Tyson", "labels": ["Mike Tyson"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mir-faizal", "type": "person", "key": "mir-faizal", "label": "Professor Mir Faizal [?]", "labels": ["Professor Mir Faizal [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mir-taqi-mir", "type": "person", "key": "mir-taqi-mir", "label": "Mir [?]", "labels": ["Mir [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mirza-ghalib", "type": "person", "key": "mirza-ghalib", "label": "Ghalib (the poet) [?]", "labels": ["Ghalib (the poet) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mohammed-hijab", "type": "person", "key": "mohammed-hijab", "label": "Mohammed Hijab", "labels": ["Mohammed Hijab"], "segments": 39, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2018": 9, "2019": 10, "2020": 11, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 39}}, {"id": "person:muawiya", "type": "person", "key": "muawiya", "label": "Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan", "labels": ["Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "type": "person", "key": "muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "label": "Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan", "labels": ["Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan", "Mu'awiya ibn Abi Sufyan [?]"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 12, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "label": "Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya", "labels": ["Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya", "Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ali-jinnah", "label": "Muhammad Ali Jinnah", "labels": ["Muhammad Ali Jinnah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-from-god", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-from-god", "label": "Br Muhammad (MFG, MuhammadFromGod channel)", "labels": ["Br Muhammad (MFG, MuhammadFromGod channel)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "label": "Muhammad ibn al-Hanafiyya", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn al-Hanafiyya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "label": "Muhammad ibn al-Qasim [?]", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn al-Qasim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "label": "Muhammad ibn Jami al-Saydalani (Ibn Zukhruf) [?]", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Jami al-Saydalani (Ibn Zukhruf) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ibn-malik", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ibn-malik", "label": "Muhammad, Imam Malik's son [?]", "labels": ["Muhammad, Imam Malik's son [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "type": "person", "key": "muhammad-ibn-maslama", "label": "Muhammad ibn Maslama", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Maslama"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:muhammadi-begum", "type": "person", "key": "muhammadi-begum", "label": "Muhammadi Begum", "labels": ["Muhammadi Begum"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "type": "person", "key": "mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "label": "al-Mukhtar al-Thaqafi", "labels": ["al-Mukhtar al-Thaqafi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:mullah-omar", "type": "person", "key": "mullah-omar", "label": "Mullah Omar", "labels": ["Mullah Omar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:musa", "type": "person", "key": "musa", "label": "Musa (Moses)", "labels": ["Moses (Musa)", "Musa", "Musa (Moses)"], "segments": 36, "recordings": 24, "years": {"2018": 11, "2019": 10, "2020": 3, "2021": 11, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "person:musaylima", "type": "person", "key": "musaylima", "label": "Musaylima", "labels": ["Musaylima"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:muslim-ibn-aqil", "type": "person", "key": "muslim-ibn-aqil", "label": "Muslim ibn Aqil", "labels": ["Muslim ibn Aqil"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:nadr-ibn-anas", "type": "person", "key": "nadr-ibn-anas", "label": "al-Nadr, Imam Malik's brother", "labels": ["al-Nadr, Imam Malik's brother"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:nawf-al-bikali", "type": "person", "key": "nawf-al-bikali", "label": "Nawf al-Bikali", "labels": ["Nawf al-Bikali"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "type": "person", "key": "nawwas-ibn-saman", "label": "al-Nawwas ibn Sam'an", "labels": ["al-Nawwas ibn Sam'an"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:nelson-mandela", "type": "person", "key": "nelson-mandela", "label": "Nelson Mandela", "labels": ["Nelson Mandela"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "type": "person", "key": "nicolaus-copernicus", "label": "Copernicus", "labels": ["Copernicus"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:noam-chomsky", "type": "person", "key": "noam-chomsky", "label": "Noam Chomsky", "labels": ["Noam Chomsky"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:norman-finkelstein", "type": "person", "key": "norman-finkelstein", "label": "Norman Finkelstein", "labels": ["Norman Finkelstein"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:nuh", "type": "person", "key": "nuh", "label": "Nuh (Noah)", "labels": ["Nuh (Noah)"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "person:numan-ibn-bashir", "type": "person", "key": "numan-ibn-bashir", "label": "Nu'man ibn Bashir", "labels": ["Nu'man ibn Bashir"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:nusrat-fateh-ali-khan", "type": "person", "key": "nusrat-fateh-ali-khan", "label": "Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan", "labels": ["Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:oliver-sacks", "type": "person", "key": "oliver-sacks", "label": "Oliver Sacks", "labels": ["Oliver Sacks", "Oliver Sacks (neurologist)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:osama-bin-laden", "type": "person", "key": "osama-bin-laden", "label": "Osama bin Laden", "labels": ["Osama bin Laden"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:osiris", "type": "person", "key": "osiris", "label": "Osiris", "labels": ["Osiris"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:pandora", "type": "person", "key": "pandora", "label": "Pandora (Greek myth)", "labels": ["Pandora (Greek myth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:patricia-crone", "type": "person", "key": "patricia-crone", "label": "Patricia Crone", "labels": ["Patricia Crone"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "person:paul", "type": "person", "key": "paul", "label": "St Paul", "labels": ["St Paul"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:pervez-hoodbhoy", "type": "person", "key": "pervez-hoodbhoy", "label": "Pervez Hoodbhoy [?]", "labels": ["Pervez Hoodbhoy [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:piri-reis", "type": "person", "key": "piri-reis", "label": "Piri Reis [?]", "labels": ["Piri Reis [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:plato", "type": "person", "key": "plato", "label": "Plato", "labels": ["Plato"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "person:plotinus", "type": "person", "key": "plotinus", "label": "Plotinus", "labels": ["Plotinus"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:prince-andrew", "type": "person", "key": "prince-andrew", "label": "Prince Andrew", "labels": ["Prince Andrew"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:prometheus", "type": "person", "key": "prometheus", "label": "Prometheus (Greek myth)", "labels": ["Prometheus (Greek myth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ptolemy", "type": "person", "key": "ptolemy", "label": "Ptolemy", "labels": ["Ptolemy"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:qabil", "type": "person", "key": "qabil", "label": "Qabil (Cain)", "labels": ["Qabil (Cain)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:qaboos-bin-said", "type": "person", "key": "qaboos-bin-said", "label": "Sultan Qaboos", "labels": ["Sultan Qaboos"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:qahtan", "type": "person", "key": "qahtan", "label": "Qahtan", "labels": ["Qahtan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:qandeel-baloch", "type": "person", "key": "qandeel-baloch", "label": "Qandeel Baloch", "labels": ["Qandeel Baloch"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:queen-of-sheba", "type": "person", "key": "queen-of-sheba", "label": "the Queen of Sheba", "labels": ["the Queen of Sheba"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "type": "person", "key": "qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "label": "Qurayba bint Abi Umayya", "labels": ["Qurayba bint Abi Umayya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "type": "person", "key": "qusayy-ibn-kilab", "label": "Qusayy ibn Kilab", "labels": ["Qusayy ibn Kilab", "Qusayy ibn Kilab [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:rabia-ibn-haram", "type": "person", "key": "rabia-ibn-haram", "label": "Rabi'a, Qusayy's stepfather [?]", "labels": ["Rabi'a, Qusayy's stepfather [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:raja-dahir", "type": "person", "key": "raja-dahir", "label": "Raja Dahir [?]", "labels": ["Raja Dahir [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "type": "person", "key": "recep-tayyip-erdogan", "label": "Recep Tayyip Erdogan", "labels": ["Recep Tayyip Erdogan"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "person:rene-descartes", "type": "person", "key": "rene-descartes", "label": "Rene Descartes", "labels": ["Rene Descartes"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:richard-dawkins", "type": "person", "key": "richard-dawkins", "label": "Richard Dawkins", "labels": ["Richard Dawkins"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:robert-hoyland", "type": "person", "key": "robert-hoyland", "label": "Robert Hoyland", "labels": ["Robert Hoyland"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ruqayya", "type": "person", "key": "ruqayya", "label": "Ruqayya bint Muhammad", "labels": ["Ruqayya bint Muhammad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "type": "person", "key": "safiyya-bint-huyayy", "label": "Safiyya", "labels": ["Safiyya", "Safiyya [?]", "Safiyya bint Huyayy"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 15, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "type": "person", "key": "safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "label": "Safwan ibn al-Mu'attal [?]", "labels": ["Safwan ibn al-Mu'attal", "Safwan ibn al-Mu'attal [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "type": "person", "key": "sahl-ibn-hunayf", "label": "Sahl ibn Hunayf", "labels": ["Sahl ibn Hunayf"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "type": "person", "key": "sahla-bint-suhayl", "label": "Sahla bint Suhayl [?]", "labels": ["Sahla bint Suhayl [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:saint-george", "type": "person", "key": "saint-george", "label": "St George", "labels": ["St George"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sajah", "type": "person", "key": "sajah", "label": "Sajah", "labels": ["Sajah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "type": "person", "key": "salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "label": "Salah al-Din al-Ayyubi", "labels": ["Salah al-Din al-Ayyubi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "type": "person", "key": "salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "label": "Salim, of the household of Abu Hudhayfa [?]", "labels": ["Salim, of the household of Abu Hudhayfa [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:salman-al-farisi", "type": "person", "key": "salman-al-farisi", "label": "Salman al-Farisi", "labels": ["Salman al-Farisi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:salman-rushdie", "type": "person", "key": "salman-rushdie", "label": "Salman Rushdie", "labels": ["Salman Rushdie"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "person:salman-taseer", "type": "person", "key": "salman-taseer", "label": "Salman Taseer", "labels": ["Salman Taseer"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:samuel-paty", "type": "person", "key": "samuel-paty", "label": "Samuel Paty", "labels": ["Samuel Paty"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:sana-khan", "type": "person", "key": "sana-khan", "label": "Sana Khan", "labels": ["Sana Khan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sathya-sai-baba", "type": "person", "key": "sathya-sai-baba", "label": "Sathya Sai Baba", "labels": ["Sathya Sai Baba"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:satya-sai-baba", "type": "person", "key": "satya-sai-baba", "label": "Satya Sai Baba", "labels": ["Satya Sai Baba"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sawda-bint-zama", "type": "person", "key": "sawda-bint-zama", "label": "Sawda bint Zam'a", "labels": ["Sawda bint Zam'a"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:shabbir-ahmed", "type": "person", "key": "shabbir-ahmed", "label": "Dr Shabbir Ahmed [?]", "labels": ["Dr Shabbir Ahmed [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:shady-nasser", "type": "person", "key": "shady-nasser", "label": "Shady Nasser", "labels": ["Shady Nasser"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "type": "person", "key": "shah-rukh-khan", "label": "Shah Rukh Khan", "labels": ["Shah Rukh Khan"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:shuayb", "type": "person", "key": "shuayb", "label": "Shu'ayb", "labels": ["Shu'ayb"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sigmund-freud", "type": "person", "key": "sigmund-freud", "label": "Sigmund Freud", "labels": ["Sigmund Freud"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:socrates", "type": "person", "key": "socrates", "label": "Socrates", "labels": ["Socrates"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "person:sonny-bill-williams", "type": "person", "key": "sonny-bill-williams", "label": "Sonny Bill Williams", "labels": ["Sonny Bill Williams"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sulayman", "type": "person", "key": "sulayman", "label": "Sulayman (Solomon)", "labels": ["Solomon (Sulayman)", "Sulayman", "Sulayman (Solomon)"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 8, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "person:suleiman-the-magnificent", "type": "person", "key": "suleiman-the-magnificent", "label": "Sultan Suleiman al-Qanuni (the Magnificent)", "labels": ["Sultan Suleiman al-Qanuni (the Magnificent)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:sultan-qaboos", "type": "person", "key": "sultan-qaboos", "label": "Sultan Qaboos of Oman", "labels": ["Sultan Qaboos of Oman"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:t-e-lawrence", "type": "person", "key": "t-e-lawrence", "label": "Lawrence of Arabia", "labels": ["Lawrence of Arabia"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:talut", "type": "person", "key": "talut", "label": "Talut", "labels": ["Talut"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:tamim-al-dari", "type": "person", "key": "tamim-al-dari", "label": "Tamim al-Dari", "labels": ["Tamim al-Dari"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:tariq-ramadan", "type": "person", "key": "tariq-ramadan", "label": "Tariq Ramadan", "labels": ["Tariq Ramadan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "type": "person", "key": "ted-kaptchuk", "label": "Ted Kaptchuk", "labels": ["Ted Kaptchuk", "Ted Kaptchuk (placebo researcher)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:thomas-aquinas", "type": "person", "key": "thomas-aquinas", "label": "Thomas Aquinas", "labels": ["Thomas Aquinas"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:thomas-hobbes", "type": "person", "key": "thomas-hobbes", "label": "Thomas Hobbes", "labels": ["Thomas Hobbes"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:thrasymachus", "type": "person", "key": "thrasymachus", "label": "Thrasymachus", "labels": ["Thrasymachus", "Thrasymachus [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:tommy-robinson", "type": "person", "key": "tommy-robinson", "label": "Tommy Robinson", "labels": ["Tommy Robinson"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "type": "person", "key": "ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "label": "Ubaydullah ibn Ziyad", "labels": ["Ubaydullah ibn Ziyad"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "type": "person", "key": "ubayy-ibn-kab", "label": "Ubayy ibn Ka'b", "labels": ["Ubayy ibn Ka'b"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "type": "person", "key": "umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "label": "Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz", "labels": ["Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umar-ibn-abi-salama", "type": "person", "key": "umar-ibn-abi-salama", "label": "Umar ibn Abi Salama [?]", "labels": ["Umar ibn Abi Salama [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "type": "person", "key": "umar-ibn-al-khattab", "label": "Umar ibn al-Khattab", "labels": ["Umar ibn al-Khattab"], "segments": 40, "recordings": 27, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 8, "2019": 8, "2020": 9, "2021": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 40}}, {"id": "person:umar-ibn-sad", "type": "person", "key": "umar-ibn-sad", "label": "Umar ibn Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas", "labels": ["Umar ibn Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:umm-aban", "type": "person", "key": "umm-aban", "label": "Umm Aban [?]", "labels": ["Umm Aban [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umm-atiyya", "type": "person", "key": "umm-atiyya", "label": "Umm Atiyya", "labels": ["Umm Atiyya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "type": "person", "key": "umm-haram-bint-milhan", "label": "Umm Haram bint Milhan", "labels": ["Umm Haram bint Milhan"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:umm-humayd", "type": "person", "key": "umm-humayd", "label": "Umm Humayd [?]", "labels": ["Umm Humayd [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "type": "person", "key": "umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "label": "Umm Kulthum bint Jarwal [?]", "labels": ["Umm Kulthum bint Jarwal [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umm-salama", "type": "person", "key": "umm-salama", "label": "Umm Salama [?]", "labels": ["Umm Salama [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:umm-sulaym", "type": "person", "key": "umm-sulaym", "label": "Umm Sulaym [?]", "labels": ["Umm Sulaym [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:usama-ibn-zayd", "type": "person", "key": "usama-ibn-zayd", "label": "Usama ibn Zayd", "labels": ["Usama ibn Zayd"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "type": "person", "key": "uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "label": "Uthman ibn Abi al-As al-Thaqafi", "labels": ["Uthman ibn Abi al-As al-Thaqafi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "type": "person", "key": "uthman-ibn-affan", "label": "Uthman ibn Affan", "labels": ["Uthman ibn Affan", "Uthman ibn Affan [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 4, "2020": 8, "2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "person:vasco-da-gama", "type": "person", "key": "vasco-da-gama", "label": "Vasco da Gama", "labels": ["Vasco da Gama"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:vishnu", "type": "person", "key": "vishnu", "label": "Vishnu (Hindu tradition)", "labels": ["Vishnu (Hindu tradition)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:william-shakespeare", "type": "person", "key": "william-shakespeare", "label": "William Shakespeare", "labels": ["William Shakespeare"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:yahya", "type": "person", "key": "yahya", "label": "Yahya (John)", "labels": ["Yahya (John)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:yahya-ibn-malik", "type": "person", "key": "yahya-ibn-malik", "label": "Yahya, Imam Malik's son", "labels": ["Yahya, Imam Malik's son"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "type": "person", "key": "yala-ibn-murra", "label": "Ya'la ibn Murra [?]", "labels": ["Ya'la ibn Murra", "Ya'la ibn Murra [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:yaqub", "type": "person", "key": "yaqub", "label": "Ya'qub (Jacob)", "labels": ["Ya'qub (Jacob)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "type": "person", "key": "yaqub-al-mansur", "label": "Abu Yusuf Ya'qub al-Mansur [?]", "labels": ["Abu Yusuf Ya'qub al-Mansur [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "type": "person", "key": "yazid-ibn-muawiya", "label": "Yazid ibn Mu'awiya", "labels": ["Yazid ibn Mu'awiya", "Yazid ibn Muawiya"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "person:yunus", "type": "person", "key": "yunus", "label": "Yunus (Jonah)", "labels": ["Yunus (Jonah)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "type": "person", "key": "yusha-ibn-nun", "label": "Yusha ibn Nun (Joshua)", "labels": ["Yusha ibn Nun (Joshua)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "person:yusuf", "type": "person", "key": "yusuf", "label": "Yusuf (Joseph)", "labels": ["Yusuf (Joseph)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "person:yuval-noah-harari", "type": "person", "key": "yuval-noah-harari", "label": "Yuval Noah Harari", "labels": ["Yuval Noah Harari"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zakariya", "type": "person", "key": "zakariya", "label": "Zakariya", "labels": ["Zakariya"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:zakariyya", "type": "person", "key": "zakariyya", "label": "Zakariyya (Zechariah)", "labels": ["Zakariyya (Zechariah)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zarathustra", "type": "person", "key": "zarathustra", "label": "Zarathustra", "labels": ["Zarathustra"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "type": "person", "key": "zayd-ibn-ali", "label": "Zayd ibn Ali (son of Zayn al-Abidin)", "labels": ["Zayd ibn Ali (son of Zayn al-Abidin)", "Zayd ibn Ali [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "type": "person", "key": "zayd-ibn-haritha", "label": "Zayd ibn Haritha", "labels": ["Zayd ibn Haritha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zayd-ibn-thabit", "type": "person", "key": "zayd-ibn-thabit", "label": "Zayd ibn Thabit", "labels": ["Zayd ibn Thabit"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "type": "person", "key": "zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "label": "Zaynab al-Thaqafiyya", "labels": ["Zaynab al-Thaqafiyya"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "type": "person", "key": "zaynab-bint-jahsh", "label": "Zaynab bint Jahsh", "labels": ["Zaynab bint Jahsh"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "person:zaynab-bint-muhammad", "type": "person", "key": "zaynab-bint-muhammad", "label": "Zaynab, daughter of the Prophet", "labels": ["Zaynab, daughter of the Prophet"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zeus", "type": "person", "key": "zeus", "label": "Zeus (Greek myth)", "labels": ["Zeus (Greek myth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:ziyad-ibn-abihi", "type": "person", "key": "ziyad-ibn-abihi", "label": "Ziyad (ibn Abihi)", "labels": ["Ziyad (ibn Abihi)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "type": "person", "key": "zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "label": "Zuhayr ibn Abi Sulma", "labels": ["Zuhayr ibn Abi Sulma"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "person:zuhra-ibn-kilab", "type": "person", "key": "zuhra-ibn-kilab", "label": "Zuhra, Qusayy's brother [?]", "labels": ["Zuhra, Qusayy's brother [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:build-on-certainty", "type": "principle", "key": "build-on-certainty", "label": "build on certainty when in doubt", "labels": ["build on certainty when in doubt", "certainty is not overturned by doubt (applied to the sanctity of life)", "certainty is removed only by certainty (al-yaqin la yazulu illa bi-yaqin)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "type": "principle", "key": "clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "label": "a clear text overrides an ambiguous one", "labels": ["a clear text overrides an ambiguous one"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "type": "principle", "key": "commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "label": "al-amr bil-ma'ruf wa al-nahy an al-munkar (commanding good and forbidding evil)", "labels": ["al-amr bil-ma'ruf wa al-nahy an al-munkar (commanding good and forbidding evil)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "label": "compare the hadith an imam relied on with the hadith quoted, not the imam's fatwa with the hadith", "labels": ["compare the hadith an imam relied on with the hadith quoted, not the imam's fatwa with the hadith"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:consent", "type": "principle", "key": "consent", "label": "consent as the basis of a valid marriage", "labels": ["consent", "consent as the basis of a valid marriage"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "consistency-in-applying-hadith", "label": "reports with the same wording must be applied consistently", "labels": ["reports with the same wording must be applied consistently"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:context-of-revelation", "type": "principle", "key": "context-of-revelation", "label": "reading a command in the circumstances it addressed", "labels": ["reading a command in the circumstances it addressed", "reading a verse in the context of its revelation"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:critical-review-of-tradition", "type": "principle", "key": "critical-review-of-tradition", "label": "the tradition lacks, and needs, critical review", "labels": ["the tradition lacks, and needs, critical review"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:criticism-is-not-insult", "type": "principle", "key": "criticism-is-not-insult", "label": "freedom to criticise is not freedom to insult", "labels": ["freedom to criticise is not freedom to insult"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "type": "principle", "key": "culture-versus-religion", "label": "culture versus religion", "labels": ["culture versus religion", "what counts as effeminate dress is a cultural matter, not a religious one"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:custom-and-convention", "type": "principle", "key": "custom-and-convention", "label": "custom and convention ('urf)", "labels": ["custom and convention ('urf)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "type": "principle", "key": "deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "label": "everything of the deen and its rituals was taught by the Prophet (attributed to Imam Malik)", "labels": ["everything of the deen and its rituals was taught by the Prophet (attributed to Imam Malik)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:default-permissibility", "type": "principle", "key": "default-permissibility", "label": "everything is permissible by default until proven otherwise (al-asl al-ibaha)", "labels": ["everything is permissible by default until proven otherwise (al-asl al-ibaha)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "type": "principle", "key": "everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "label": "from everyone one may accept and reject, except the Prophet (Imam Malik)", "labels": ["from everyone one may accept and reject, except the Prophet (Imam Malik)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:faith-not-creed", "type": "principle", "key": "faith-not-creed", "label": "the Prophet taught faith (iman), not a formal creed (aqidah)", "labels": ["the Prophet taught faith (iman), not a formal creed (aqidah)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "type": "principle", "key": "god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "label": "the 'god of the gaps' fallacy, here the 'jinn of the gaps'", "labels": ["the 'god of the gaps' fallacy, here the 'jinn of the gaps'"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "type": "principle", "key": "hadith-absolutism", "label": "hadith absolutism", "labels": ["hadith absolutism", "hadith absolutism (hadith dogmatism)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 3, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "type": "principle", "key": "hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "label": "A report is rejected if it contradicts reason, the Quran or an established principle", "labels": ["A report is rejected if it contradicts reason, the Quran or an established principle"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "type": "principle", "key": "hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "label": "a hadith must not contradict reason, the Quran and established Sunnah, or uproot a principle of Islam", "labels": ["a hadith must not contradict reason, the Quran and established Sunnah, or uproot a principle of Islam", "a hadith must not contradict reason, the Quran and transmitted sources, or an Islamic principle", "a hadith that clashes with reason, the Quran or established principles is not accepted", "a hadith that goes against reason may be questioned", "a report is rejected where it contradicts reason, the Quran, established practice or the principles of Islam", "the religion is built on reason; reports contrary to reason are problematic"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2018": 15, "2021": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "principle:hadith-relativism", "type": "principle", "key": "hadith-relativism", "label": "hadith relativism", "labels": ["hadith relativism"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "historical-context-of-hadith", "label": "reading a hadith in its historical context", "labels": ["reading a hadith in its historical context"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "type": "principle", "key": "hudud-change-with-the-age", "label": "the hudud change with the age", "labels": ["punishments change to reflect their age (attributed to al-Burzuli) [?]", "the hudud change with the age"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "type": "principle", "key": "khabar-wahid-not-creed", "label": "single-transmitter reports do not establish creed", "labels": ["single-transmitter reports do not establish creed"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "type": "principle", "key": "living-tradition-as-source", "label": "The deen reaches us through continuous living practice", "labels": ["The deen reaches us through continuous living practice", "living tradition as a source", "the living tradition", "the living tradition as a source"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "principle:matn-criticism", "type": "principle", "key": "matn-criticism", "label": "judging a report by its content (matn)", "labels": ["judging a report by its content (matn)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "principle:might-is-right", "type": "principle", "key": "might-is-right", "label": "might is right (the law of Thrasymachus), rejected", "labels": ["might is right (the law of Thrasymachus), rejected"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "type": "principle", "key": "miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "label": "miracles never defy God's laws; they have causes within nature", "labels": ["miracles never defy God's laws; they have causes within nature"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "type": "principle", "key": "narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "label": "narrator criticism is man-made, not divine, and so open to revision", "labels": ["narrator criticism is man-made, not divine, and so open to revision"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "type": "principle", "key": "no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "label": "no takfir of the people of the qibla", "labels": ["no takfir of the people of the qibla"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "type": "principle", "key": "no-taqlid-in-creed", "label": "creed cannot be blind-followed", "labels": ["creed cannot be blind-followed", "no taqlid in matters of creed"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "type": "principle", "key": "one-standard-for-all-religions", "label": "one set of standards: judge Islam's claims by the same test applied to other religions", "labels": ["one set of standards: judge Islam's claims by the same test applied to other religions", "one standard for all religions"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "type": "principle", "key": "only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "label": "only Allah and His Messenger are authorities in matters of religion", "labels": ["only Allah and His Messenger are authorities in matters of religion"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "type": "principle", "key": "only-allah-declares-haram", "label": "no one may declare haram what Allah has not declared haram", "labels": ["no one may declare haram what Allah has not declared haram"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "type": "principle", "key": "ontology-of-religion", "label": "the 'ontology of religion': preconceptions of what religion must be shape how Islam is read", "labels": ["the 'ontology of religion': preconceptions of what religion must be shape how Islam is read"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "principle:prevention-of-harm", "type": "principle", "key": "prevention-of-harm", "label": "prevention of harm", "labels": ["prevention of harm"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "type": "principle", "key": "prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "label": "a prophetic prohibition explained by the circumstances of the early community", "labels": ["a prohibition tied to the circumstances of its time", "a prophetic prohibition explained by the circumstances of the early community"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "type": "principle", "key": "quran-addresses-the-imagination", "label": "Quranic imagery draws on the imagination of its listeners and is not a report of fact", "labels": ["Quranic imagery draws on the imagination of its listeners and is not a report of fact"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "label": "The Quran takes precedence over an isolated hadith", "labels": ["The Quran takes precedence over an isolated hadith"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 5, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "type": "principle", "key": "refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "label": "a refutation must rest on categorical evidence from the Quran and Sunnah", "labels": ["a refutation must rest on categorical evidence from the Quran and Sunnah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "type": "principle", "key": "resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "label": "prohibition explained by resemblance to a non-Muslim religious practice", "labels": ["prohibition explained by resemblance to a non-Muslim religious practice"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "type": "principle", "key": "ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "label": "a ruling does not continue when its cause has ceased", "labels": ["a ruling does not continue when its cause has ceased"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:sources-of-knowledge", "type": "principle", "key": "sources-of-knowledge", "label": "knowledge comes from textual, rational, experiential and cultural sources", "labels": ["knowledge comes from textual, rational, experiential and cultural sources"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "label": "the Sunnah is distinguished from hadith: embrace the Sunnah, be critical of hadith", "labels": ["the Sunnah is distinguished from hadith: embrace the Sunnah, be critical of hadith"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "type": "principle", "key": "sunnah-versus-hadith", "label": "distinction between sunnah and hadith", "labels": ["distinction between sunnah and hadith", "sunnah distinguished from hadith"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 3, "2023": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "type": "principle", "key": "trajectory-hermeneutics", "label": "trajectory hermeneutics", "labels": ["trajectory hermeneutics"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement", "type": "principle", "key": "transmission-is-not-endorsement", "label": "A scholar transmitting from a narrator does not declare him reliable", "labels": ["A scholar transmitting from a narrator does not declare him reliable"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "type": "principle", "key": "truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "label": "hadith grading is not a democracy; the majority does not decide", "labels": ["hadith grading is not a democracy; the majority does not decide", "truth is not a democracy; the number of scholars does not decide it"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "type": "principle", "key": "what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "label": "what set right the first of this umma will set right its last (Imam Malik)", "labels": ["what set right the first of this umma will set right its last (Imam Malik)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:105:1", "type": "quran", "key": "105:1", "label": "Quran 105:1 (have you not seen how your Lord dealt with the people of the elephant)", "labels": ["Quran 105:1 (have you not seen how your Lord dealt with the people of the elephant)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:109:1-6", "type": "quran", "key": "109:1-6", "label": "Quran 109:1-6 (Surah al-Kafirun: to you your religion and to me mine)", "labels": ["Quran 109:1-6 (Surah al-Kafirun: to you your religion and to me mine)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:109:2-5", "type": "quran", "key": "109:2-5", "label": "Quran 109:2-5", "labels": ["Quran 109:2-5"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:10:57", "type": "quran", "key": "10:57", "label": "Quran 10:57 (a cure for what is in the hearts)", "labels": ["Quran 10:57 (a cure for what is in the hearts)", "Quran 10:57 (a cure for what is in the hearts) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:10:99", "type": "quran", "key": "10:99", "label": "Quran 10:99 (would you compel people to become believers?)", "labels": ["Quran 10:99", "Quran 10:99 (would you compel people to become believers?)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:112:1-4", "type": "quran", "key": "112:1-4", "label": "Quran 112 (Surat al-Ikhlas)", "labels": ["Quran 112 (Surat al-Ikhlas)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:113:1-5", "type": "quran", "key": "113:1-5", "label": "Quran 113:1-5 (Surat al-Falaq)", "labels": ["Quran 113:1-5 (Surat al-Falaq)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:113:4", "type": "quran", "key": "113:4", "label": "Quran 113:4 (from the evil of those who blow on knots)", "labels": ["Quran 113:4 (from the evil of those who blow on knots)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:114:1-6", "type": "quran", "key": "114:1-6", "label": "Quran 114 (Surat al-Nas)", "labels": ["Quran 114 (Surat al-Nas)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:11:44", "type": "quran", "key": "11:44", "label": "Quran 11:44 (O sky, hold back your water)", "labels": ["Quran 11:44 (O sky, hold back your water)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:11:7", "type": "quran", "key": "11:7", "label": "Quran 11:7 (His throne was upon the water)", "labels": ["Quran 11:7 (His throne was upon the water)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:12:2", "type": "quran", "key": "12:2", "label": "Quran 12:2 [?]", "labels": ["Quran 12:2 (we sent it down as an Arabic Quran) [?]", "Quran 12:2 [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:12:3", "type": "quran", "key": "12:3", "label": "Quran 12:3 (We relate to you the best of stories)", "labels": ["Quran 12:3 (We relate to you the best of stories)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:12:31", "type": "quran", "key": "12:31", "label": "Quran 12:31", "labels": ["Quran 12:31"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:12:41", "type": "quran", "key": "12:41", "label": "Quran 12:41 (one of you will pour wine for his master)", "labels": ["Quran 12:41 (one of you will pour wine for his master)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:12:58-68", "type": "quran", "key": "12:58-68", "label": "Quran 12:58-68 (Yusuf's brothers in Egypt; Jacob's advice on the gates)", "labels": ["Quran 12:58-68 (Yusuf's brothers in Egypt; Jacob's advice on the gates)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:12:76", "type": "quran", "key": "12:76", "label": "Quran 12:76", "labels": ["Quran 12:76", "Quran 12:76 (above every person of knowledge is one more knowing) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:14:22", "type": "quran", "key": "14:22", "label": "Quran 14:22 (Satan: I had no power over you)", "labels": ["Quran 14:22 (Satan: I had no power over you)", "Quran 14:22 (Satan: I had no power over you, I only invited you)", "Quran 14:22 (Shaytan on the Day of Judgement: I had no authority over you except that I called you)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:14:4", "type": "quran", "key": "14:4", "label": "Quran 14:4 (We sent no messenger except in the tongue of his people)", "labels": ["Quran 14:4 (We sent no messenger except in the tongue of his people)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:14:7", "type": "quran", "key": "14:7", "label": "Quran 14:7 (if you are grateful, I will increase you)", "labels": ["Quran 14:7 (if you are grateful, I will increase you)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:15:27", "type": "quran", "key": "15:27", "label": "Quran 15:27 (the jinn created before from the fire of scorching wind)", "labels": ["Quran 15:27 (the jinn We created before from scorching fire) [?]", "Quran 15:27 (the jinn created before from the fire of scorching wind)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:16:116", "type": "quran", "key": "16:116", "label": "Quran 16:116 (do not say this is halal and this is haram, attributing falsehood to Allah)", "labels": ["Quran 16:116 (do not say this is halal and this is haram, attributing falsehood to Allah)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:16:89", "type": "quran", "key": "16:89", "label": "Quran 16:89 (a clarification of all things)", "labels": ["Quran 16:89 (a clarification of all things)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:17:47", "type": "quran", "key": "17:47", "label": "Quran 17:47 (you follow only a bewitched man; also 25:8; verse not numbered by him) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 17:47 (you follow only a bewitched man; also 25:8; verse not numbered by him) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:17:82", "type": "quran", "key": "17:82", "label": "Quran 17:82 (we send down of the Quran what is a shifa) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 17:82 (we send down of the Quran what is a shifa) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:17:90-93", "type": "quran", "key": "17:90-93", "label": "Quran 17:90-93 (Quraysh demand springs and signs; say: am I anything but a human messenger?), paraphrased", "labels": ["Quran 17:90-93 (Quraysh demand springs and signs; say: am I anything but a human messenger?), paraphrased"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:18:29", "type": "quran", "key": "18:29", "label": "Quran 18:29 (whoever wishes, let him believe, and whoever wishes, let him disbelieve)", "labels": ["Quran 18:29", "Quran 18:29 (whoever wishes, let him believe, and whoever wishes, let him disbelieve)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:18:46", "type": "quran", "key": "18:46", "label": "Quran 18:46 (wealth and sons are the adornment of this life) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 18:46 (wealth and sons are the adornment of this life) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:18:50", "type": "quran", "key": "18:50", "label": "Quran 18:50 (Iblis was of the jinn)", "labels": ["Quran 18:50 (Iblis was of the jinn)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:18:60", "type": "quran", "key": "18:60", "label": "Quran 18:60 (Musa sets out for the meeting of the two seas)", "labels": ["Quran 18:60 (Musa sets out for the meeting of the two seas)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:18:60-82", "type": "quran", "key": "18:60-82", "label": "Quran 18:60-82 (Musa and the servant of Allah)", "labels": ["Quran 18:60-82 (Musa and the servant of Allah)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:18:77", "type": "quran", "key": "18:77", "label": "Quran 18:77", "labels": ["Quran 18:77"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:19:16-22", "type": "quran", "key": "19:16-22", "label": "Quran 19:16-22 (the annunciation to Mary)", "labels": ["Quran 19:16-22 (the annunciation to Mary)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:19:27-33", "type": "quran", "key": "19:27-33", "label": "Quran 19:27-33 (Mary brings Jesus to her people; he speaks from the cradle)", "labels": ["Quran 19:27-33 (Mary brings Jesus to her people; he speaks from the cradle)", "Quran 19:27-33 (Mary brings him to her people; how can we speak to one in the cradle)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:19:29", "type": "quran", "key": "19:29", "label": "Quran 19:29 (how can we speak to one who is in the cradle, a child)", "labels": ["Quran 19:29 (how can we speak to one who is in the cradle, a child)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:19:5-6", "type": "quran", "key": "19:5-6", "label": "Quran 19:5-6 (Zakariya: grant me an heir who will inherit from me)", "labels": ["Quran 19:5-6 (Zakariya: grant me an heir who will inherit from me)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:20:115", "type": "quran", "key": "20:115", "label": "Quran 20:115 (We made a covenant with Adam, but he forgot, and We found in him no resolve)", "labels": ["Quran 20:115 (We made a covenant with Adam, but he forgot, and We found in him no resolve)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:20:17-18", "type": "quran", "key": "20:17-18", "label": "Quran 20:17-18", "labels": ["Quran 20:17-18"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:20:5", "type": "quran", "key": "20:5", "label": "Quran 20:5 (the Most Merciful established Himself over the throne) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 20:5 (the Most Merciful established Himself over the throne) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:20:59", "type": "quran", "key": "20:59", "label": "Quran 20:59 (the meeting at forenoon on the day of the festival)", "labels": ["Quran 20:59 (the meeting at forenoon on the day of the festival)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:20:66", "type": "quran", "key": "20:66", "label": "Quran 20:66 (their ropes seemed to him to move by their magic; verse not numbered by him)", "labels": ["Quran 20:66 (their ropes and sticks seemed to him to move)", "Quran 20:66 (their ropes seemed to him to move by their magic; verse not numbered by him)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:20:67", "type": "quran", "key": "20:67", "label": "Quran 20:67 (Musa sensed fear within himself; verse not numbered by him)", "labels": ["Quran 20:67 (Musa sensed fear within himself; verse not numbered by him)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:21:107", "type": "quran", "key": "21:107", "label": "Quran 21:107 (a mercy to the worlds)", "labels": ["Quran 21:107", "Quran 21:107 (a mercy to the worlds)", "Quran 21:107 (a mercy to the worlds) [?]", "Quran 21:107 (we sent you only as a mercy for the worlds)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2022": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "quran:21:30", "type": "quran", "key": "21:30", "label": "Quran 21:30 (the heavens and earth were one; every living thing from water)", "labels": ["Quran 21:30 (every living thing from water)", "Quran 21:30 (the heavens and earth were one; every living thing from water)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:21:34", "type": "quran", "key": "21:34", "label": "Quran 21:34 (we gave no human before you eternal life)", "labels": ["Quran 21:34", "Quran 21:34 (we gave no human before you eternal life)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:21:68-71", "type": "quran", "key": "21:68-71", "label": "Quran 21:68-71 (burn him; O fire be cool; we saved him and Lut)", "labels": ["Quran 21:68-71 (burn him; O fire be cool; we saved him and Lut)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:21:76-77", "type": "quran", "key": "21:76-77", "label": "Quran 21:76-77 (Nuh called and we saved him) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 21:76-77 (Nuh called and we saved him) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:21:96", "type": "quran", "key": "21:96", "label": "Quran 21:96", "labels": ["Quran 21:96"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:22:32", "type": "quran", "key": "22:32", "label": "Quran 22:32 [?]", "labels": ["Quran 22:32 [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:22:37", "type": "quran", "key": "22:37", "label": "Quran 22:37", "labels": ["Quran 22:37"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:22:40-41", "type": "quran", "key": "22:40-41", "label": "Quran 22:40-41 (Surah al-Hajj)", "labels": ["Quran 22:40-41 (Surah al-Hajj)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "quran:22:46", "type": "quran", "key": "22:46", "label": "Quran 22:46 (it is not the eyes that are blind but the hearts; he names Surah al-Hajj without the verse number) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 22:46 (it is not the eyes that are blind but the hearts; he names Surah al-Hajj without the verse number) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:22:52", "type": "quran", "key": "22:52", "label": "Quran 22:52 (Satan cast into the prophet's wish, then God annulled it)", "labels": ["Quran 22:52 (Satan cast into the prophet's wish, then God annulled it)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:23:12-13", "type": "quran", "key": "23:12-13", "label": "Quran 23:12-13 (insan from an extract of clay, then a drop in a stable place)", "labels": ["Quran 23:12-13 (insan from an extract of clay, then a drop in a stable place)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:23:12-14", "type": "quran", "key": "23:12-14", "label": "Quran 23:12-14 (insan from an extract of clay, then a drop in a firm lodging, then the stages of the embryo)", "labels": ["Quran 23:12-14 (insan from an extract of clay, then a drop in a firm lodging, then the stages of the embryo)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:24:11-20", "type": "quran", "key": "24:11-20", "label": "Quran 24:11-20 (the ifk verses of Surat al-Nur)", "labels": ["Quran 24:11-20 (the ifk verses of Surat al-Nur)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:24:31", "type": "quran", "key": "24:31", "label": "Quran 24:31 (let them draw their khimars over their jayb)", "labels": ["Quran 24:31 (let them draw their khimars over their jayb)", "Surah al-Nur (his video on it) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:24:35", "type": "quran", "key": "24:35", "label": "Quran 24:35", "labels": ["Quran 24:35", "Quran 24:35 (Allah is the light of the heavens and the earth)", "Quran 24:35 (the verse of light)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:24:4", "type": "quran", "key": "24:4", "label": "Quran 24:4 (those who accuse chaste women without four witnesses)", "labels": ["Quran 24:4 (those who accuse chaste women without four witnesses)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:16", "type": "quran", "key": "27:16", "label": "Quran 27:16 (Sulayman inherited from Dawud)", "labels": ["Quran 27:16 (Sulayman inherited from Dawud)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:18", "type": "quran", "key": "27:18", "label": "Quran 27:18 (the ant)", "labels": ["Quran 27:18 (the ant)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:20-21", "type": "quran", "key": "27:20-21", "label": "Quran 27:20-21 (why do I not see the hudhud; I will punish or slaughter him)", "labels": ["Quran 27:20-21 (why do I not see the hudhud; I will punish or slaughter him)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:22-24", "type": "quran", "key": "27:22-24", "label": "Quran 27:22-24 (the hudhud's report from Saba)", "labels": ["Quran 27:22-24 (the hudhud's report from Saba)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:23", "type": "quran", "key": "27:23", "label": "Quran 27:23 (I found a woman ruling over them, given of everything, with a mighty throne)", "labels": ["Quran 27:23 (I found a woman ruling over them, given of everything, with a mighty throne)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:27", "type": "quran", "key": "27:27", "label": "Quran 27:27 (we will see whether you are truthful or among the liars)", "labels": ["Quran 27:27 (we will see whether you are truthful or among the liars)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:34", "type": "quran", "key": "27:34", "label": "Quran 27:34 (kings, when they enter a town, ruin it)", "labels": ["Quran 27:34 (kings, when they enter a town, ruin it)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:38-39", "type": "quran", "key": "27:38-39", "label": "Quran 27:38-39 (which of you will bring me her throne; an 'ifrit of the jinn said I will)", "labels": ["Quran 27:38-39 (which of you will bring me her throne; an 'ifrit of the jinn said I will)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:40", "type": "quran", "key": "27:40", "label": "Quran 27:40 (one with knowledge of the Book: before your glance returns)", "labels": ["Quran 27:40 (one with knowledge of the Book: before your glance returns)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:41", "type": "quran", "key": "27:41", "label": "Quran 27:41 (disguise her throne)", "labels": ["Quran 27:41 (disguise her throne)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:42", "type": "quran", "key": "27:42", "label": "Quran 27:42 (is your throne like this? it is as though it were)", "labels": ["Quran 27:42 (is your throne like this? it is as though it were)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:44", "type": "quran", "key": "27:44", "label": "Quran 27:44 (enter the palace; she thought it a pool and uncovered her shins)", "labels": ["Quran 27:44 (enter the palace; she thought it a pool and uncovered her shins)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:80-84", "type": "quran", "key": "27:80-84", "label": "Quran 27:80-84", "labels": ["Quran 27:80-84"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:27:82", "type": "quran", "key": "27:82", "label": "Quran 27:82 (we will bring out for them a creature from the earth)", "labels": ["Quran 27:82 (we will bring out for them a creature from the earth)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:29:14", "type": "quran", "key": "29:14", "label": "Quran 29:14", "labels": ["Quran 29:14"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:29:20", "type": "quran", "key": "29:20", "label": "Quran 29:20 (walk the earth and see how He began creation; he names Surah al-Ankabut without the verse number) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 29:20 (walk the earth and see how He began creation; he names Surah al-Ankabut without the verse number) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:29:41", "type": "quran", "key": "29:41", "label": "Quran 29:41 (the weakest of homes is the spider's; verse not numbered by him) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 29:41 (the weakest of homes is the spider's; verse not numbered by him) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:102", "type": "quran", "key": "2:102", "label": "Quran 2:102", "labels": ["Quran 2:102", "Quran 2:102 (Harut and Marut in Babylon; verse not numbered by him)", "Quran 2:102 (Harut and Marut)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:2:127", "type": "quran", "key": "2:127", "label": "Quran 2:127 (Ibrahim and Ismail raising the foundations of the House)", "labels": ["Quran 2:127 (Ibrahim and Ismail raising the foundations of the House)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:158", "type": "quran", "key": "2:158", "label": "Quran 2:158 (Safa and Marwa are among the symbols of Allah)", "labels": ["Quran 2:158 (Safa and Marwa are among the symbols of Allah)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:2:177", "type": "quran", "key": "2:177", "label": "Quran 2:177", "labels": ["Quran 2:177"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:184", "type": "quran", "key": "2:184", "label": "Quran 2:184 (those who are able to fast may give fidya)", "labels": ["Quran 2:184 (those who are able to fast may give fidya)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:221", "type": "quran", "key": "2:221", "label": "Quran 2:221 (do not marry mushrik women until they believe)", "labels": ["Quran 2:221 (do not marry mushrik women until they believe)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:229", "type": "quran", "key": "2:229", "label": "Quran 2:229 (retain in kindness or release with grace)", "labels": ["Quran 2:229 (retain in kindness or release with grace)", "Quran 2:229 (retain in kindness or release with grace), quoted in passing"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:234", "type": "quran", "key": "2:234", "label": "Quran 2:234 (widows wait four months and ten days)", "labels": ["Quran 2:234 (widows wait four months and ten days)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:248", "type": "quran", "key": "2:248", "label": "Quran 2:248", "labels": ["Quran 2:248"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:253", "type": "quran", "key": "2:253", "label": "Quran 2:253 (we gave him clear signs and helped him with the Holy Spirit)", "labels": ["Quran 2:253 (we gave him clear signs and helped him with the Holy Spirit)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:255", "type": "quran", "key": "2:255", "label": "Quran 2:255 (Ayat al-Kursi)", "labels": ["Quran 2:255 (Ayat al-Kursi)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:256", "type": "quran", "key": "2:256", "label": "Quran 2:256 (there is no compulsion in religion)", "labels": ["Quran 2:256", "Quran 2:256 (no compulsion in religion)", "Quran 2:256 (no compulsion in religion), alluded to", "Quran 2:256 (no compulsion in religion), paraphrased", "Quran 2:256 (there is no compulsion in religion)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "quran:2:26", "type": "quran", "key": "2:26", "label": "Quran 2:26 (the example of a mosquito or what is above it)", "labels": ["Quran 2:26 (the example of a mosquito or what is above it)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:260", "type": "quran", "key": "2:260", "label": "Quran 2:260 (the four birds)", "labels": ["Quran 2:260 (my Lord, show me how You give life to the dead; verse not numbered by him) [?]", "Quran 2:260 (the four birds)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:275", "type": "quran", "key": "2:275", "label": "Quran 2:275 (like one whom Shaytan has driven to madness by his touch)", "labels": ["Quran 2:275 (Allah has permitted sale and forbidden riba)", "Quran 2:275 (like one whom Shaytan has driven to madness by his touch)", "Quran 2:275 (those who consume riba stand as one struck by Satan)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "quran:2:276", "type": "quran", "key": "2:276", "label": "Quran 2:276 (Allah destroys riba and increases sadaqat)", "labels": ["Quran 2:276 (Allah destroys riba and increases sadaqat)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:279", "type": "quran", "key": "2:279", "label": "Quran 2:279 (be informed of a war from Allah)", "labels": ["Quran 2:279 (be informed of a war from Allah)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:2:282", "type": "quran", "key": "2:282", "label": "Quran 2:282 (be mindful of God and God will teach you), alluded to [?]", "labels": ["Quran 2:282 (be mindful of God and God will teach you), alluded to [?]", "Quran 2:282 (two women witnesses for a debt, so that if one errs the other reminds her)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:2:29", "type": "quran", "key": "2:29", "label": "Quran 2:29 (He created for you everything in the earth)", "labels": ["Quran 2:29 (He created for you everything in the earth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:2:30", "type": "quran", "key": "2:30", "label": "Quran 2:30 (I will place a khalifa on the earth)", "labels": ["Quran 2:30 (I will place a khalifa on the earth)", "Quran 2:30 (I will place a khalifah on the earth; verse not numbered by him)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:2:87", "type": "quran", "key": "2:87", "label": "Quran 2:87 (we helped him with the Holy Spirit)", "labels": ["Quran 2:87 (we helped him with the Holy Spirit)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:30:41", "type": "quran", "key": "30:41", "label": "Quran 30:41 (corruption has appeared on land and sea), alluded to as a joke", "labels": ["Quran 30:41 (corruption has appeared on land and sea), alluded to as a joke"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:33:21", "type": "quran", "key": "33:21", "label": "Quran 33:21", "labels": ["Quran 33:21"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:33:28-29", "type": "quran", "key": "33:28-29", "label": "Quran 33:28-29 (the choice given to the Prophet's wives)", "labels": ["Quran 33:28-29 (the choice given to the Prophet's wives)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:33:40", "type": "quran", "key": "33:40", "label": "Quran 33:40", "labels": ["Quran 33:40"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:33:53", "type": "quran", "key": "33:53", "label": "Quran 33:53 (addressing the Prophet's wives from behind a screen; not marrying them after him)", "labels": ["Quran 33:53 (addressing the Prophet's wives from behind a screen; not marrying them after him)", "Quran 33:53 (the Prophet's dinner guests)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:33:56", "type": "quran", "key": "33:56", "label": "Quran 33:56 (Allah and His angels perform salah upon the Prophet) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 33:56 (Allah and His angels perform salah upon the Prophet) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:33:6", "type": "quran", "key": "33:6", "label": "Quran 33:6 (his wives are their mothers)", "labels": ["Quran 33:6 (his wives are their mothers)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:35:43", "type": "quran", "key": "35:43", "label": "Quran 35:43 (you will never find any change in the way of God) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 35:43 (you will never find any change in the way of God) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:36:1-83", "type": "quran", "key": "36:1-83", "label": "Surah Ya Sin", "labels": ["Surah Ya Sin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:36:68", "type": "quran", "key": "36:68", "label": "Quran 36:68 (whoever We grant long life, We reverse in creation)", "labels": ["Quran 36:68 (whoever We grant long life, We reverse in creation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:37:102", "type": "quran", "key": "37:102", "label": "Quran 37:102 (my son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you)", "labels": ["Quran 37:102 (my son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:37:103-107", "type": "quran", "key": "37:103-107", "label": "Quran 37:103-107 (O Ibrahim, you have fulfilled the vision; this was indeed the clear trial; we ransomed him with a great sacrifice)", "labels": ["Quran 37:103-107 (O Ibrahim, you have fulfilled the vision; this was indeed the clear trial; we ransomed him with a great sacrifice)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:37:142", "type": "quran", "key": "37:142", "label": "Quran 37:142 (the fish swallowed him while he was blameworthy)", "labels": ["Quran 37:142 (the fish swallowed him while he was blameworthy)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:37:145", "type": "quran", "key": "37:145", "label": "Quran 37:145 (We cast him onto the open shore while he was sick)", "labels": ["Quran 37:145 (We cast him onto the open shore while he was sick)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:37:65", "type": "quran", "key": "37:65", "label": "Quran 37:65 (its shoots are like the heads of devils)", "labels": ["Quran 37:65 (its shoots are like the heads of devils)", "Quran 37:65 (the tree of Jahannam, its fruit like the heads of devils)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:38:41", "type": "quran", "key": "38:41", "label": "Quran 38:41 (Ayyub: Satan has touched me with hardship)", "labels": ["Quran 38:41 (Ayyub: Satan has touched me with hardship)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:14", "type": "quran", "key": "3:14", "label": "Quran 3:14 (made pleasing to men is the love of desires, women and sons)", "labels": ["Quran 3:14 (made pleasing to men is the love of desires, women and sons)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:155", "type": "quran", "key": "3:155", "label": "Quran 3:155 (Shaytan caused them to slip) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 3:155 (Shaytan caused them to slip) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:173", "type": "quran", "key": "3:173", "label": "Quran 3:173 (God is sufficient for us)", "labels": ["Quran 3:173 (God is sufficient for us)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:185", "type": "quran", "key": "3:185", "label": "Quran 3:185 (every soul shall taste death)", "labels": ["Quran 3:185 (every soul shall taste death)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:45", "type": "quran", "key": "3:45", "label": "Quran 3:45 (a word from Him, the Messiah Jesus son of Mary; he cites it as 3:43) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 3:45 (a word from Him, the Messiah Jesus son of Mary; he cites it as 3:43)", "Quran 3:45 (a word from Him, the Messiah Jesus son of Mary; he cites it as 3:43) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:3:46", "type": "quran", "key": "3:46", "label": "Quran 3:46 (he will speak to people in the cradle and in maturity)", "labels": ["Quran 3:46", "Quran 3:46 (he will speak to people in the cradle and as a kahl; the phrase also occurs in 5:110)", "Quran 3:46 (he will speak to people in the cradle and in maturity)"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "quran:3:50", "type": "quran", "key": "3:50", "label": "Quran 3:50", "labels": ["Quran 3:50"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:55", "type": "quran", "key": "3:55", "label": "Quran 3:55", "labels": ["Quran 3:55", "Quran 3:55 (I will give you death and raise you to me) [?]", "Quran 3:55 (inni mutawaffika: I will take you / give you death)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:3:59", "type": "quran", "key": "3:59", "label": "Quran 3:59 (the likeness of Jesus is that of Adam)", "labels": ["Quran 3:59", "Quran 3:59 (the likeness of Jesus is that of Adam)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:3:64", "type": "quran", "key": "3:64", "label": "Quran 3:64 (People of the Book, come to a common word)", "labels": ["Quran 3:64 (People of the Book, come to a common word)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:7", "type": "quran", "key": "3:7", "label": "Quran 3:7 (clear and ambiguous verses)", "labels": ["Quran 3:7 (clear and ambiguous verses)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:93", "type": "quran", "key": "3:93", "label": "Quran 3:93 [?] (what Israel made unlawful for itself)", "labels": ["Quran 3:93 [?] (what Israel made unlawful for itself)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:3:97", "type": "quran", "key": "3:97", "label": "Quran 3:97 (pilgrimage to the House is a duty owed to Allah by people)", "labels": ["Quran 3:97 (pilgrimage to the House is a duty owed to Allah by people)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:41:53", "type": "quran", "key": "41:53", "label": "Quran 41:53 (We will show them Our signs until it becomes clear that it is the truth)", "labels": ["Quran 41:53 (We will show them Our signs until it becomes clear that it is the truth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:43:59", "type": "quran", "key": "43:59", "label": "Quran 43:59 (he is only a slave whom we favoured and made an example for the children of Israel)", "labels": ["Quran 43:59", "Quran 43:59 (he is only a slave whom we favoured and made an example for the children of Israel)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:43:61", "type": "quran", "key": "43:61", "label": "Quran 43:61", "labels": ["Quran 43:61", "Quran 43:61 (and he is knowledge of the hour)", "Quran 43:61 (he is a sign, or knowledge, of the Hour)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:45:32", "type": "quran", "key": "45:32", "label": "Quran 45:32 (we only think it is conjecture and we are not certain)", "labels": ["Quran 45:32 (we only think it is conjecture and we are not certain)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:47:19", "type": "quran", "key": "47:19", "label": "Quran 47:19 (know that there is no god but Allah; verse not numbered by him) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 47:19 (know that there is no god but Allah; verse not numbered by him) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:48:10", "type": "quran", "key": "48:10", "label": "Quran 48:10 (the hand of Allah is over their hands)", "labels": ["Quran 48:10 (the hand of Allah is over their hands)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:48:29", "type": "quran", "key": "48:29", "label": "Quran 48:29 (their mark is on their faces from the trace of prostration) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 48:29 (their mark is on their faces from the trace of prostration) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:49:13", "type": "quran", "key": "49:13", "label": "Quran 49:13 (We created you from male and female)", "labels": ["Quran 49:13 (We created you from male and female)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:49:17", "type": "quran", "key": "49:17", "label": "Quran 49:17 (they consider it a favour to you that they have embraced Islam) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 49:17 (they consider it a favour to you that they have embraced Islam) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:1", "type": "quran", "key": "4:1", "label": "Quran 4:1 (created you from a single self) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 4:1 (created you from a single self) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:11", "type": "quran", "key": "4:11", "label": "Quran 4:11 (God instructs you concerning your children)", "labels": ["Quran 4:11 (God instructs you concerning your children)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:129", "type": "quran", "key": "4:129", "label": "Quran 4:129", "labels": ["Quran 4:129"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:157-158", "type": "quran", "key": "4:157-158", "label": "Quran 4:157-158", "labels": ["Quran 4:157-158", "Quran 4:157-158 (they did not kill him nor crucify him; God raised him to Himself)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:4:159", "type": "quran", "key": "4:159", "label": "Quran 4:159", "labels": ["Quran 4:159", "Quran 4:159 (as cited in a chat question)", "Quran 4:159 (none of the People of the Book but will believe in him before his death)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "quran:4:171", "type": "quran", "key": "4:171", "label": "Quran 4:171 (the Messiah, messenger of Allah and His word; he cites it as 4:170) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 4:171 (the Messiah, His word)", "Quran 4:171 (the Messiah, messenger of Allah and His word; he cites it as 4:170)", "Quran 4:171 (the Messiah, messenger of Allah and His word; he cites it as 4:170) [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:4:19", "type": "quran", "key": "4:19", "label": "Quran 4:19 (live with them in kindness)", "labels": ["Quran 4:19 (live with them in kindness)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:24", "type": "quran", "key": "4:24", "label": "Quran 4:24 (al-muhsanat, the married women)", "labels": ["Quran 4:24 (al-muhsanat, the married women)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:4:28", "type": "quran", "key": "4:28", "label": "Quran 4:28 (man was created weak)", "labels": ["Quran 4:28 (man was created weak)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:3", "type": "quran", "key": "4:3", "label": "Quran 4:3", "labels": ["Quran 4:3"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:43", "type": "quran", "key": "4:43", "label": "Quran 4:43 (aw lamastum al-nisa; the phrase also in 5:6)", "labels": ["Quran 4:43 (aw lamastum al-nisa; the phrase also in 5:6)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:6", "type": "quran", "key": "4:6", "label": "Quran 4:6", "labels": ["Quran 4:6"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:82", "type": "quran", "key": "4:82", "label": "Quran 4:82 (do they not ponder the Quran) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 4:82 (do they not ponder the Quran) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:4:86", "type": "quran", "key": "4:86", "label": "Quran 4:86 (when you are greeted, return a better greeting or return it)", "labels": ["Quran 4:86 (when you are greeted, return a better greeting or return it)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:50:19", "type": "quran", "key": "50:19", "label": "Quran 50:19 (the stupor of death brings the truth)", "labels": ["Quran 50:19 (the stupor of death brings the truth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:50:22", "type": "quran", "key": "50:22", "label": "Quran 50:22 (your sight this day is sharp)", "labels": ["Quran 50:22 (your sight this day is sharp)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:51:49", "type": "quran", "key": "51:49", "label": "Quran 51:49 (of everything We created pairs; verse not numbered by him) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 51:49 (of everything We created pairs; verse not numbered by him) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:51:56", "type": "quran", "key": "51:56", "label": "Quran 51:56 (I did not create jinn and humans except to worship Me), paraphrased", "labels": ["Quran 51:56 (I did not create jinn and humans except to worship Me), paraphrased"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:53:1-4", "type": "quran", "key": "53:1-4", "label": "Quran 53:1-4 (by the star; your companion has not strayed, nor does he speak from desire)", "labels": ["Quran 53:1-4 (by the star; your companion has not strayed, nor does he speak from desire)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:53:19-20", "type": "quran", "key": "53:19-20", "label": "Quran 53:19-20 (al-Lat, al-Uzza and Manat)", "labels": ["Quran 53:19-20 (al-Lat, al-Uzza and Manat)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:53:8", "type": "quran", "key": "53:8", "label": "Quran 53:8 (then he drew near and came down)", "labels": ["Quran 53:8 (then he drew near and came down)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:54:1", "type": "quran", "key": "54:1", "label": "Quran 54:1 (the Hour has drawn near and the moon has split)", "labels": ["Quran 54:1 (the Hour has drawn near and the moon has split)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:57:13", "type": "quran", "key": "57:13", "label": "Quran 57:13", "labels": ["Quran 57:13"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:57:16", "type": "quran", "key": "57:16", "label": "Quran 57:16 (has the time not come for those who believe)", "labels": ["Quran 57:16 (has the time not come for those who believe)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:58:22", "type": "quran", "key": "58:22", "label": "Quran 58:22 (strengthened them with a spirit from Him)", "labels": ["Quran 58:22 (strengthened them with a spirit from Him)", "Quran 58:22 (you will not find believers loving those who oppose Allah and His Messenger) [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:59:6-7", "type": "quran", "key": "59:6-7", "label": "Quran 59:6-7 (what God gave His Messenger without war; the categories of fay')", "labels": ["Quran 59:6-7 (what God gave His Messenger without war; the categories of fay')"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:59:7", "type": "quran", "key": "59:7", "label": "Quran 59:7 (so that wealth does not circulate only among the rich among you) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 59:7 (so that wealth does not circulate only among the rich among you) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:110", "type": "quran", "key": "5:110", "label": "Quran 5:110", "labels": ["Quran 5:110", "Quran 5:110 (God's favours upon Jesus enumerated)", "Quran 5:110 (O Jesus, remember my blessing; I helped you with the Holy Spirit; captioned as verse 115)", "Quran 5:110 (O Jesus, remember my blessings; I helped you with the Holy Spirit; he cites it as 5:115) [?]", "Quran 5:110 (remember my blessings upon you)", "Quran 5:110 (you spoke to people in the cradle and in maturity)"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "quran:5:112-115", "type": "quran", "key": "5:112-115", "label": "Quran 5:112-115 (the table asked for by the disciples)", "labels": ["Quran 5:112-115 (the table asked for by the disciples)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:5:116-118", "type": "quran", "key": "5:116-118", "label": "Quran 5:116-118 (did you tell people to take you and your mother as lords?)", "labels": ["Quran 5:116-118", "Quran 5:116-118 (did you tell people to take you and your mother as lords?)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:5:117", "type": "quran", "key": "5:117", "label": "Quran 5:117", "labels": ["Quran 5:117", "Quran 5:117 (when You took me, You were the watcher over them)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:5:2", "type": "quran", "key": "5:2", "label": "Quran 5:2 (help one another in goodness)", "labels": ["Quran 5:2 (help one another in goodness)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:27-31", "type": "quran", "key": "5:27-31", "label": "Quran 5:27-31", "labels": ["Quran 5:27-31"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:31", "type": "quran", "key": "5:31", "label": "Quran 5:31", "labels": ["Quran 5:31"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:32", "type": "quran", "key": "5:32", "label": "Quran 5:32 (whoever kills a soul, it is as if he has killed all mankind)", "labels": ["Quran 5:32 (whoever kills a soul, it is as if he has killed all mankind)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:33", "type": "quran", "key": "5:33", "label": "Quran 5:33 (the punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger)", "labels": ["Quran 5:33 (the punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:38", "type": "quran", "key": "5:38", "label": "Quran 5:38 (the thief's hand)", "labels": ["Quran 5:38 (the thief's hand)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:4-5", "type": "quran", "key": "5:4-5", "label": "Quran 5:4-5 (the food and chaste women of the People of the Book are lawful)", "labels": ["Quran 5:4-5 (the food and chaste women of the People of the Book are lawful)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:45", "type": "quran", "key": "5:45", "label": "Quran 5:45", "labels": ["Quran 5:45"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:5", "type": "quran", "key": "5:5", "label": "Quran 5:5 (permission to marry women of the People of the Book)", "labels": ["Quran 5:5 (permission to marry women of the People of the Book)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:5:67", "type": "quran", "key": "5:67", "label": "Quran 5:67 (Allah will protect you from the people; verse not numbered by him)", "labels": ["Quran 5:67 (Allah will protect you from the people; verse not numbered by him)", "Quran 5:67 (Allah will protect you from the people; verse not numbered by him) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:5:75", "type": "quran", "key": "5:75", "label": "Quran 5:75 (the Messiah was only a messenger; they both ate food)", "labels": ["Quran 5:75", "Quran 5:75 (the Messiah was only a messenger; they both ate food)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:5:96", "type": "quran", "key": "5:96", "label": "Quran 5:96", "labels": ["Quran 5:96"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:60:10", "type": "quran", "key": "60:10", "label": "Quran 60:10 (they are not lawful for them, nor are they lawful for them)", "labels": ["Quran 60:10 (do not hold on to ties with disbelieving women)", "Quran 60:10 (they are not lawful for them, nor are they lawful for them)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:63:1-11", "type": "quran", "key": "63:1-11", "label": "Surah al-Munafiqun", "labels": ["Surah al-Munafiqun"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:65:1", "type": "quran", "key": "65:1", "label": "Quran 65:1 (when you divorce women, divorce them for their iddah; do not expel them from their homes)", "labels": ["Quran 65:1 (when you divorce women, divorce them for their iddah; do not expel them from their homes)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:65:2", "type": "quran", "key": "65:2", "label": "Quran 65:2 (retain them or part with them with kindness, and call witnesses; whoever fears Allah, He makes a way out)", "labels": ["Quran 65:2 (retain them or part with them with kindness, and call witnesses; whoever fears Allah, He makes a way out)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:65:3", "type": "quran", "key": "65:3", "label": "Quran 65:3 (He provides from where one does not expect; whoever relies on Allah, He is sufficient)", "labels": ["Quran 65:3 (He provides from where one does not expect; whoever relies on Allah, He is sufficient)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:65:4", "type": "quran", "key": "65:4", "label": "Quran 65:4 (those who have despaired of menstruation, if you are in doubt, their iddah is three months, and those who have not menstruated; the pregnant until they give birth)", "labels": ["Quran 65:4 (those who have despaired of menstruation, if you are in doubt, their iddah is three months, and those who have not menstruated; the pregnant until they give birth)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "quran:66:1", "type": "quran", "key": "66:1", "label": "Quran 66:1 (why do you forbid what Allah has made lawful for you, seeking to please your wives)", "labels": ["Quran 66:1 (why do you forbid what Allah has made lawful for you, seeking to please your wives)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:66:12", "type": "quran", "key": "66:12", "label": "Quran 66:12 (Mary who guarded her chastity; we breathed into it of our spirit)", "labels": ["Quran 66:12 (Mary who guarded her chastity; we breathed into it of our spirit)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:67:2", "type": "quran", "key": "67:2", "label": "Quran 67:2 (He created death and life to test which of you is best in deeds)", "labels": ["Quran 67:2 (He created death and life to test which of you is best in deeds)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:68:4", "type": "quran", "key": "68:4", "label": "Quran 68:4 (you are of a great character)", "labels": ["Quran 68:4 (you are of a great character)", "Quran 68:4 (you are of a great character) [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:68:51", "type": "quran", "key": "68:51", "label": "Quran 68:51 (they would almost make you slip with their eyes)", "labels": ["Quran 68:51 (they would almost make you slip with their eyes)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:69:44-46", "type": "quran", "key": "69:44-46", "label": "Quran 69:44-46 (had he invented sayings against Us, We would have seized him and cut his aorta; he cites verses 44 to 46 without naming the surah)", "labels": ["Quran 69:44-46 (had he invented sayings against Us, We would have seized him and cut his aorta; he cites verses 44 to 46 without naming the surah)", "Quran 69:44-46 (had he invented sayings against Us, We would have seized him)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:6:101", "type": "quran", "key": "6:101", "label": "Quran 6:101 (how can He have a child when He has no companion)", "labels": ["Quran 6:101 (how can He have a child when He has no companion)", "Quran 6:101 (how can He have a child when He has no companion; he calls it Medinan)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:6:145", "type": "quran", "key": "6:145", "label": "Quran 6:145 (I do not find in what was revealed to me anything forbidden to eat except ...)", "labels": ["Quran 6:145 (I do not find in what was revealed to me anything forbidden ...)", "Quran 6:145 (I do not find in what was revealed to me anything forbidden to eat except ...)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "quran:6:158", "type": "quran", "key": "6:158", "label": "Quran 6:158 (faith will not benefit a soul that did not believe before)", "labels": ["Quran 6:158 (faith will not benefit a soul that did not believe before)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:6:38", "type": "quran", "key": "6:38", "label": "Quran 6:38 (We have not neglected anything in the Book)", "labels": ["Quran 6:38 (We have not neglected anything in the Book)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:6:85-87", "type": "quran", "key": "6:85-87", "label": "Quran 6:85-87 (Zakariya, Yahya, Isa ... and their fathers)", "labels": ["Quran 6:85-87 (Zakariya, Yahya, Isa ... and their fathers)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:71:14", "type": "quran", "key": "71:14", "label": "Quran 71:14 (He created you in stages)", "labels": ["Quran 71:14 (He created you in stages)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:71:17", "type": "quran", "key": "71:17", "label": "Quran 71:17 (Allah grew you from the earth like plants)", "labels": ["Quran 71:17 (Allah grew you from the earth like plants)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:74:42-46", "type": "quran", "key": "74:42-46", "label": "Quran 74:42-46 (what brought you to Saqar? We were not of those who prayed ... we used to deny)", "labels": ["Quran 74:42-46 (what brought you to Saqar? We were not of those who prayed ... we used to deny)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:7:116", "type": "quran", "key": "7:116", "label": "Quran 7:116 (they bewitched the eyes of the people; verse not numbered by him)", "labels": ["Quran 7:116 (they bewitched the eyes of the people and terrified them)", "Quran 7:116 (they bewitched the eyes of the people; verse not numbered by him)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:7:138", "type": "quran", "key": "7:138", "label": "Quran 7:138", "labels": ["Quran 7:138"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:7:189-190", "type": "quran", "key": "7:189-190", "label": "Quran 7:189-190 (the single self and its partner; they committed shirk)", "labels": ["Quran 7:189-190 (the single self and its partner; they committed shirk)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:7:43", "type": "quran", "key": "7:43", "label": "Quran 7:43", "labels": ["Quran 7:43"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:88:17-18", "type": "quran", "key": "88:17-18", "label": "Quran 88:17-18 (do they not look at the camel, how it was created, and at the sky)", "labels": ["Quran 88:17-18 (do they not look at the camel, how it was created, and at the sky)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:88:17-20", "type": "quran", "key": "88:17-20", "label": "Quran 88:17-20 (do they not look at the camel, the sky, the mountains and the earth), paraphrased", "labels": ["Quran 88:17-20 (do they not look at the camel, the sky, the mountains and the earth), paraphrased"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:89:27-30", "type": "quran", "key": "89:27-30", "label": "Quran 89:27-30 (O soul at peace, return to your Lord)", "labels": ["Quran 89:27-30 (O soul at peace, return to your Lord)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:94:4", "type": "quran", "key": "94:4", "label": "Quran 94:4", "labels": ["Quran 94:4"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:96:15", "type": "quran", "key": "96:15", "label": "Quran 96:15 (we will seize him by the forelock)", "labels": ["Quran 96:15 (lanasfa'an bil-nasiyah)", "Quran 96:15 (we will seize him by the forelock)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "quran:9:1-3", "type": "quran", "key": "9:1-3", "label": "Quran 9:1-3 (a declaration of bara'a from Allah and His Messenger towards those who broke the covenant) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 9:1-3 (a declaration of bara'a from Allah and His Messenger towards those who broke the covenant) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:9:30", "type": "quran", "key": "9:30", "label": "Quran 9:30", "labels": ["Quran 9:30"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "quran:9:31", "type": "quran", "key": "9:31", "label": "Quran 9:31", "labels": ["Quran 9:31"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:9:37", "type": "quran", "key": "9:37", "label": "Quran 9:37 (the nasi verse) [?]", "labels": ["Quran 9:37 (the nasi verse) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:9:38", "type": "quran", "key": "9:38", "label": "Quran 9:38 (why do you cling to the earth when told to go forth)", "labels": ["Quran 9:38 (why do you cling to the earth when told to go forth)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:9:92", "type": "quran", "key": "9:92", "label": "Quran 9:92 (those who came to you to be carried, i.e. given mounts)", "labels": ["Quran 9:92 (those who came to you to be carried, i.e. given mounts)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "quran:9:97-99", "type": "quran", "key": "9:97-99", "label": "Quran 9:97-99", "labels": ["Quran 9:97-99"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "label": "Abd al-Fattah Abu Ghudda [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Fattah Abu Ghudda", "Abd al-Fattah Abu Ghudda [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "label": "Shaykh Abd al-Ghani al-Daqr [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh Abd al-Ghani al-Daqr [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "label": "Abd al-Hamid ibn Abi Uways [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Hamid ibn Abi Uways [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "label": "Abd al-Haqq al-Ishbili [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Haqq al-Ishbili [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "label": "Abd al-Karim ibn Abi al-Mukhariq [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Karim ibn Abi al-Mukhariq [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "label": "Ibn Habib al-Maliki", "labels": ["Ibn Habib al-Maliki"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "label": "Abd al-Rahman al-Sa'di [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman al-Sa'di [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "label": "Abd al-Rahman al-Sudais", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman al-Sudais"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "label": "Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi al-Zinad [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi al-Zinad [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "label": "Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf", "labels": ["Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf", "Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "label": "Abd al-Razzaq al-Kashani", "labels": ["Abd al-Razzaq al-Kashani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "label": "Abd al-Razzaq al-San'ani", "labels": ["Abd al-Razzaq al-San'ani"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-sabur-shahin", "label": "Abd al-Sabur Shahin [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Sabur Shahin [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "type": "scholar", "key": "abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "label": "Abd al-Samad [?]", "labels": ["Abd al-Samad [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdal-hakim-murad", "label": "Abdal Hakim Murad", "labels": ["Abdal Hakim Murad"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdalhaqq-bewley", "label": "Abdalhaqq Bewley", "labels": ["Abdalhaqq Bewley"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdalqadir-as-sufi", "label": "Shaykh Abdalqadir as-Sufi", "labels": ["Shaykh Abdalqadir as-Sufi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdul-karim-athari", "label": "Abdul Karim Athari [?]", "labels": ["Abdul Karim Athari", "Abdul Karim Athari [?]", "Maulana Abdul Karim Athari [?]"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 6, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "scholar:abdul-majid", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdul-majid", "label": "Shaykh Abdul Majid [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh Abdul Majid [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abdul-qavi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdul-qavi", "label": "Mufti Abdul Qavi", "labels": ["Mufti Abdul Qavi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdul-rahman-hassan", "label": "Abdul Rahman Hassan", "labels": ["Abdul Rahman Hassan"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdullah-abdul-majid", "label": "Dr Abdullah Abdul Majid [?]", "labels": ["Dr Abdul Majid", "Dr Abdullah Abdul Majid [?]"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdullah-al-judai", "label": "Abdullah al-Judai [?]", "labels": ["Abdullah al-Judai [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdullah-bin-bayyah", "label": "Shaykh Abdullah bin Bayyah", "labels": ["Abdullah bin Bayyah", "Shaykh Abdullah bin Bayyah"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "label": "Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak [?]", "labels": ["Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak", "Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak [?]"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "type": "scholar", "key": "abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "label": "Mufti Abdur-Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera", "labels": ["Mufti Abdur-Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-aliya", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-aliya", "label": "Abu al-Aliya [?]", "labels": ["Abu al-Aliya [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-darda", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-darda", "label": "Abu al-Darda [?]", "labels": ["Abu al-Darda [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "label": "Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani", "labels": ["Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "label": "Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari", "labels": ["Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "label": "al-Sam'ani [?]", "labels": ["al-Sam'ani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-suud", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-suud", "label": "Abu al-Su'ud", "labels": ["Abu al-Su'ud"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-yaman", "label": "Abu al-Yaman", "labels": ["Abu al-Yaman"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-al-zubayr", "label": "Abu al-Zubayr", "labels": ["Abu al-Zubayr"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-amr-al-dani", "label": "Abu Amr al-Dani", "labels": ["Abu Amr al-Dani"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-asim-al-nabil", "label": "Abu Asim [?] (al-Darimi's teacher, of Basra)", "labels": ["Abu Asim [?] (al-Darimi's teacher, of Basra)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-bakr-al-samani", "label": "Abu Bakr al-Sam'ani", "labels": ["Abu Bakr al-Sam'ani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "label": "Abu Bakr ibn Abi Dawud al-Sijistani [?]", "labels": ["Abu Bakr ibn Abi Dawud al-Sijistani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "label": "Qadi Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi", "labels": ["Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi", "Qadi Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi", "Qadi Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi [?]"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "label": "Abu Bakr ibn Hazm [?]", "labels": ["Abu Bakr ibn Hazm [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-dawud", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-dawud", "label": "Abu Dawud", "labels": ["Abu Dawud", "Abu Dawud [?]"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "label": "Abu Dawud al-Tayalisi [?]", "labels": ["Abu Dawud al-Tayalisi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-hanifa", "label": "Abu Hanifa", "labels": ["Abu Hanifa", "Imam Abu Hanifa"], "segments": 71, "recordings": 43, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 4, "2016": 3, "2017": 2, "2018": 20, "2019": 4, "2020": 7, "2021": 13, "2022": 13, "2023": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 71}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-hatim-al-razi", "label": "Abu Hatim al-Razi", "labels": ["Abu Hatim al-Razi", "Abu Hatim al-Razi [?]"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "label": "Abu Hayyan al-Andalusi", "labels": ["Abu Hayyan al-Andalusi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "label": "Abu Ibraheem Husnayn", "labels": ["Abu Ibraheem Husnayn"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-ibrahim", "label": "Abu Ibrahim [?] (online critic)", "labels": ["Abu Ibrahim [?] (online critic)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "label": "Abu Ishaq al-Huwayni [?]", "labels": ["Abu Ishaq al-Huwayni [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "label": "Abu Ishaq [?]", "labels": ["Abu Ishaq [?]", "Abu Ishaq al-Sabi'i", "Abu Ishaq al-Sabi'i [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-mushir", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-mushir", "label": "Abu Mushir", "labels": ["Abu Mushir"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "label": "Abu Muslim al-Isfahani [?]", "labels": ["Abu Muslim al-Isfahani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-sad-al-samani", "label": "Abu Sa'd al-Sam'ani [?]", "labels": ["Abu Sa'd al-Sam'ani", "Abu Sa'd al-Sam'ani [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-salih", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-salih", "label": "Abu Salih [?]", "labels": ["Abu Salih [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-talib-al-makki", "label": "Abu Talib al-Makki", "labels": ["Abu Talib al-Makki"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-yala", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-yala", "label": "Abu Ya'la al-Hanbali [?]", "labels": ["Abu Ya'la al-Hanbali [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-yala-al-farra", "label": "Abu Ya'la al-Farra [?] (Hanbali)", "labels": ["Abu Ya'la al-Farra [?] (Hanbali)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-yala-al-mawsili", "label": "Abu Ya'la al-Mawsili", "labels": ["Abu Ya'la al-Mawsili"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-yusuf", "label": "Abu Yusuf", "labels": ["Abu Yusuf"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-zahra", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-zahra", "label": "Muhammad Abu Zahra", "labels": ["Muhammad Abu Zahra", "Muhammad Abu Zahra [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:abu-zura", "type": "scholar", "key": "abu-zura", "label": "Abu Zur'a", "labels": ["Abu Zur'a", "Abu Zur'a [?]", "Abu Zur'a al-Razi"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "type": "scholar", "key": "abul-kalam-azad", "label": "Abul Kalam Azad", "labels": ["Abul Kalam Azad"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:adis-duderija", "type": "scholar", "key": "adis-duderija", "label": "Adis Duderija [?]", "labels": ["Adis Duderija [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "type": "scholar", "key": "adnan-ibrahim", "label": "Adnan Ibrahim", "labels": ["Adnan Ibrahim", "Adnan Ibrahim [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmad-al-tayyib", "label": "Shaykh al-Azhar Ahmad al-Tayyib [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh al-Azhar Ahmad al-Tayyib [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmad-amin", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmad-amin", "label": "Ahmad Amin", "labels": ["Ahmad Amin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "label": "Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal", "labels": ["Ahmad ibn Hanbal", "Imam Ahmad", "Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal", "Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal [?]"], "segments": 34, "recordings": 28, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 10, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 12, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 34}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmad-shakir", "label": "Ahmad Shakir", "labels": ["Ahmad Shakir"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmad-umar-hashim", "label": "Ahmad Umar Hashim [?]", "labels": ["Ahmad Umar Hashim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ahmed-deedat", "type": "scholar", "key": "ahmed-deedat", "label": "Ahmed Deedat", "labels": ["Ahmed Deedat"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:aisha-bewley", "type": "scholar", "key": "aisha-bewley", "label": "Aisha Bewley", "labels": ["Aisha Bewley"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "type": "scholar", "key": "akram-nadwi", "label": "Shaykh Akram Nadwi", "labels": ["Akram Nadwi", "Shaykh Akram Nadwi", "Shaykh Akram Nadwi [?]"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 9, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:al-abhari", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-abhari", "label": "al-Abhari [?]", "labels": ["al-Abhari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-albani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-albani", "label": "al-Albani", "labels": ["al-Albani", "al-Albani [?]"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2021": 4, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "scholar:al-alusi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-alusi", "label": "al-Alusi", "labels": ["al-Alusi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-amash", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-amash", "label": "al-A'mash", "labels": ["al-A'mash", "al-A'mash [?]", "al-Amash"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:al-asili", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-asili", "label": "Abu Muhammad al-Asili [?]", "labels": ["Abu Muhammad al-Asili [?]", "al-Asili"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-awni", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-awni", "label": "Shaykh al-Awni [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh al-Awni [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-awzai", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-awzai", "label": "al-Awza'i [?]", "labels": ["al-Awza'i [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-baghawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-baghawi", "label": "al-Baghawi [?]", "labels": ["al-Baghawi", "al-Baghawi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-baji", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-baji", "label": "Abu al-Walid al-Baji [?]", "labels": ["Abu al-Walid al-Baji", "Abu al-Walid al-Baji [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:al-bajuri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-bajuri", "label": "al-Bajuri", "labels": ["al-Bajuri"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-baqillani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-baqillani", "label": "al-Baqillani [?] (name garbled in the transcript)", "labels": ["Abu Bakr al-Baqillani [?]", "al-Baqillani [?]", "al-Baqillani [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-bara-ibn-azib", "label": "al-Bara ibn Azib [?]", "labels": ["al-Bara ibn Azib [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-barzanji", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-barzanji", "label": "al-Barzanji", "labels": ["al-Barzanji"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-baydawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-baydawi", "label": "al-Baydawi [?]", "labels": ["al-Baydawi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-bayhaqi", "label": "al-Bayhaqi", "labels": ["al-Bayhaqi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-bazdawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-bazdawi", "label": "al-Bazdawi", "labels": ["al-Bazdawi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-bukhari", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-bukhari", "label": "Imam al-Bukhari", "labels": ["Imam al-Bukhari", "al-Bukhari"], "segments": 48, "recordings": 30, "years": {"2016": 2, "2018": 17, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 21, "2022": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 48}}, {"id": "scholar:al-burzuli", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-burzuli", "label": "al-Burzuli [?]", "labels": ["Abu al-Qasim al-Burzuli", "al-Burzuli [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-dahhak", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-dahhak", "label": "al-Dahhak [?]", "labels": ["al-Dahhak [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-daraqutni", "label": "al-Daraqutni", "labels": ["al-Daraqutni", "al-Daraqutni [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-darimi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-darimi", "label": "al-Darimi", "labels": ["al-Darimi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-dasuqi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-dasuqi", "label": "al-Dasuqi [?]", "labels": ["al-Dasuqi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-dawudi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-dawudi", "label": "al-Dawudi [?]", "labels": ["al-Dawudi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-daylami", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-daylami", "label": "al-Daylami [?]", "labels": ["al-Daylami [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-dhahabi", "label": "al-Dhahabi", "labels": ["al-Dhahabi", "al-Dhahabi [?]"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2018": 9, "2019": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "scholar:al-dimyati", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-dimyati", "label": "al-Hafiz al-Dimyati [?]", "labels": ["al-Hafiz al-Dimyati [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "label": "al-Fadl ibn al-Husayn al-Bajali al-Naysaburi (d. 280s AH) [?]", "labels": ["al-Fadl ibn al-Husayn al-Bajali al-Naysaburi (d. 280s AH) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-fakihani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-fakihani", "label": "al-Fakihani [?]", "labels": ["al-Fakihani [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-farabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-farabi", "label": "al-Farabi", "labels": ["al-Farabi", "al-Farabi [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-firabri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-firabri", "label": "al-Firabri (referred to, not named: the sole transmitter of Sahih al-Bukhari)", "labels": ["al-Firabri (referred to, not named: the sole transmitter of Sahih al-Bukhari)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-ghazali", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-ghazali", "label": "al-Ghazali", "labels": ["al-Ghazali", "al-Ghazali [?]"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "scholar:al-hakam", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-hakam", "label": "al-Hakam [?]", "labels": ["al-Hakam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "label": "al-Hakim al-Naysaburi", "labels": ["al-Hakim al-Naysaburi", "al-Hakim al-Naysaburi [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:al-hallaj", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-hallaj", "label": "Mansur al-Hallaj [?]", "labels": ["Mansur al-Hallaj [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-harawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-harawi", "label": "al-Harawi", "labels": ["al-Harawi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-hasan-al-halwani", "label": "al-Hasan al-Halwani [?]", "labels": ["al-Hasan al-Halwani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-hasan-ibn-salih", "label": "al-Hasan ibn Salih [?]", "labels": ["al-Hasan ibn Salih [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "label": "al-Husayn ibn al-Fadl al-Bajali al-Naysaburi [?]", "labels": ["al-Husayn ibn al-Fadl al-Bajali [?]", "al-Husayn ibn al-Fadl al-Bajali al-Naysaburi", "al-Husayn ibn al-Fadl al-Bajali al-Naysaburi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "label": "al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam [?]", "labels": ["al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-jahiz", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-jahiz", "label": "al-Jahiz [?]", "labels": ["al-Jahiz", "al-Jahiz [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-jayyani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-jayyani", "label": "al-Jayyani [?]", "labels": ["al-Jayyani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-jurjani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-jurjani", "label": "al-Jurjani", "labels": ["al-Jurjani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-juwayni", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-juwayni", "label": "Imam al-Haramayn al-Juwayni", "labels": ["Imam al-Haramayn al-Juwayni"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-kasani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-kasani", "label": "al-Kasani [?]", "labels": ["al-Kasani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "label": "al-Khalil ibn Ahmad al-Farahidi [?]", "labels": ["al-Khalil ibn Ahmad al-Farahidi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "label": "al-Khatib al-Baghdadi", "labels": ["al-Khatib al-Baghdadi", "al-Khatib al-Baghdadi [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:al-khattabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-khattabi", "label": "al-Khattabi", "labels": ["al-Khattabi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-kindi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-kindi", "label": "al-Kindi [?]", "labels": ["al-Kindi", "al-Kindi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-kushmihani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-kushmihani", "label": "al-Kushmihani", "labels": ["al-Kushmihani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-lakhmi", "label": "al-Lakhmi", "labels": ["al-Lakhmi", "al-Lakhmi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-layth-ibn-sad", "label": "al-Layth ibn Sa'd", "labels": ["al-Layth ibn Sa'd"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:al-maraghi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-maraghi", "label": "Mustafa al-Maraghi", "labels": ["Mustafa al-Maraghi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-marwazi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-marwazi", "label": "al-Marwazi", "labels": ["al-Marwazi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-mazari", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-mazari", "label": "al-Mazari [?]", "labels": ["al-Mazari", "al-Mazari [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-mazini", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-mazini", "label": "al-Mazini (the grammarian)", "labels": ["al-Mazini (the grammarian)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-minhal-ibn-amr", "label": "al-Minhal ibn Amr [?]", "labels": ["al-Minhal ibn Amr [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-mustaghfiri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-mustaghfiri", "label": "al-Mustaghfiri [?]", "labels": ["al-Mustaghfiri [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-mustamli", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-mustamli", "label": "al-Mustamli", "labels": ["al-Mustamli"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-nasafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-nasafi", "label": "al-Nasafi [?]", "labels": ["al-Nasafi", "al-Nasafi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-nasai", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-nasai", "label": "al-Nasa'i", "labels": ["al-Nasa'i", "al-Nasa'i [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-nawawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-nawawi", "label": "al-Nawawi", "labels": ["al-Nawawi", "al-Nawawi [?]", "al-Nawawi [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2015": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "scholar:al-nuwayri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-nuwayri", "label": "al-Nuwayri [?]", "labels": ["al-Nuwayri [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qabisi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qabisi", "label": "al-Qabisi [?]", "labels": ["al-Qabisi", "al-Qabisi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qaffal", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qaffal", "label": "al-Qaffal [?]", "labels": ["al-Qaffal [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qarafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qarafi", "label": "al-Qarafi [?]", "labels": ["al-Qarafi", "al-Qarafi [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qasim", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qasim", "label": "al-Qasim [?]", "labels": ["al-Qasim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qasim-al-shatibi", "label": "al-Shatibi (author of the Shatibiyya) [?]", "labels": ["al-Shatibi (author of the Shatibiyya) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "label": "al-Qasim ibn Muhammad", "labels": ["al-Qasim ibn Muhammad"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qastallani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qastallani", "label": "al-Qastallani [?]", "labels": ["al-Qastallani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qurtubi", "label": "al-Qurtubi", "labels": ["al-Qurtubi", "al-Qurtubi [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:al-qushayri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-qushayri", "label": "al-Qushayri [?]", "labels": ["al-Qushayri [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "label": "al-Rabi' ibn Sulayman", "labels": ["al-Rabi' ibn Sulayman"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-ruyani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-ruyani", "label": "al-Ruyani [?]", "labels": ["al-Ruyani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-sadafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-sadafi", "label": "al-Sadafi", "labels": ["al-Sadafi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-safarini", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-safarini", "label": "al-Safarini [?]", "labels": ["al-Safarini", "al-Safarini [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-saghani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-saghani", "label": "al-Saghani [?]", "labels": ["al-Saghani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-sakhawi", "label": "al-Sakhawi", "labels": ["al-Sakhawi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-samarqandi", "label": "Abu al-Layth al-Samarqandi", "labels": ["Abu al-Layth al-Samarqandi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-sarakhsi", "label": "al-Sarakhsi", "labels": ["al-Sarakhsi", "al-Sarakhsi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:al-shabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-shabi", "label": "al-Sha'bi", "labels": ["al-Sha'bi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-shafii", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-shafii", "label": "al-Shafi'i", "labels": ["Imam al-Shafi'i", "al-Shafi'i", "al-Shafi'i [?]", "al-Shafii"], "segments": 28, "recordings": 23, "years": {"2015": 2, "2017": 3, "2018": 9, "2020": 8, "2021": 4, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}}, {"id": "scholar:al-sharawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-sharawi", "label": "Muhammad Mutawalli al-Sha'rawi", "labels": ["Muhammad Mutawalli al-Sha'rawi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-shatibi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-shatibi", "label": "al-Shatibi", "labels": ["al-Shatibi", "al-Shatibi [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:al-shawkani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-shawkani", "label": "al-Shawkani", "labels": ["al-Shawkani", "al-Shawkani [?]"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 12, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "scholar:al-suyuti", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-suyuti", "label": "al-Suyuti", "labels": ["al-Suyuti"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:al-tabarani", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-tabarani", "label": "al-Tabarani", "labels": ["al-Tabarani", "al-Tabarani [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:al-tabari", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-tabari", "label": "al-Tabari", "labels": ["al-Tabari", "al-Tabari [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:al-tahawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-tahawi", "label": "al-Tahawi", "labels": ["Imam al-Tahawi", "al-Tahawi", "al-Tahawi [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2020": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:al-thaalibi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-thaalibi", "label": "al-Tha'alibi [?]", "labels": ["al-Tha'alibi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-thalabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-thalabi", "label": "al-Tha'labi [?]", "labels": ["al-Tha'labi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-tibi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-tibi", "label": "al-Tibi [?]", "labels": ["al-Tibi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-tirmidhi", "label": "al-Tirmidhi", "labels": ["al-Tirmidhi", "al-Tirmidhi [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-walid-ibn-muslim", "label": "al-Walid ibn Muslim", "labels": ["al-Walid ibn Muslim"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-zamakhshari", "label": "al-Zamakhshari", "labels": ["al-Zamakhshari"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:al-zanati", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-zanati", "label": "al-Zanati [?]", "labels": ["al-Zanati [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "label": "al-Zubayr ibn al-Awwam [?]", "labels": ["al-Zubayr ibn al-Awwam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:al-zuhri", "type": "scholar", "key": "al-zuhri", "label": "al-Zuhri", "labels": ["Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri", "Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri [?]", "al-Zuhri", "al-Zuhri [?]"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 9, "2019": 1, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "type": "scholar", "key": "ali-ibn-al-madini", "label": "Ali ibn al-Madini", "labels": ["Ali ibn al-Madini", "Ali ibn al-Madini [?]"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ali-ibn-asim", "label": "Ali ibn Asim [?]", "labels": ["Ali ibn Asim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ali-khamenei", "type": "scholar", "key": "ali-khamenei", "label": "Ayatollah Khamenei", "labels": ["Ayatollah Khamenei"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ali-laraki", "type": "scholar", "key": "ali-laraki", "label": "Ali Laraki [?]", "labels": ["Ali Laraki [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ammar-nakshawani", "type": "scholar", "key": "ammar-nakshawani", "label": "Ammar Nakshawani", "labels": ["Ammar Nakshawani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "type": "scholar", "key": "amr-ibn-dinar", "label": "Amr ibn Dinar [?]", "labels": ["Amr ibn Dinar", "Amr ibn Dinar [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "type": "scholar", "key": "anwar-shah-kashmiri", "label": "Anwar Shah Kashmiri", "labels": ["Anwar Shah Kashmiri"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "type": "scholar", "key": "arif-abdulhussain", "label": "Shaykh Arif [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh Arif [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ashraf-ali-thanwi", "label": "Mawlana Ashraf Ali Thanwi [?]", "labels": ["Ashraf Ali Thanwi [?]", "Mawlana Ashraf Ali Thanwi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "type": "scholar", "key": "asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "label": "Asim ibn Ubaydullah", "labels": ["Asim ibn Ubaydullah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:asma-hilali", "type": "scholar", "key": "asma-hilali", "label": "Asma Hilali", "labels": ["Asma Hilali"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "type": "scholar", "key": "asrar-rashid", "label": "Shaykh Asrar Rashid [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh Asrar Rashid [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:assim-al-hakeem", "type": "scholar", "key": "assim-al-hakeem", "label": "Assim al-Hakeem", "labels": ["Assim al-Hakeem"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "label": "Shaykh Atabek", "labels": ["Shaykh Atabek", "Shaykh Atabek [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "type": "scholar", "key": "ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "label": "Ayyub al-Sakhtiyani", "labels": ["Ayyub al-Sakhtiyani"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "type": "scholar", "key": "bakr-abu-zayd", "label": "Bakr Abu Zayd", "labels": ["Bakr Abu Zayd"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "type": "scholar", "key": "bashar-awwad-maruf", "label": "Bashar Awwad Ma'ruf [?]", "labels": ["Bashar Awwad Ma'ruf [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "type": "scholar", "key": "behnam-sadeghi", "label": "Behnam Sadeghi [?]", "labels": ["Behnam Sadeghi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:busr-ibn-said", "type": "scholar", "key": "busr-ibn-said", "label": "Busr ibn Sa'id [?]", "labels": ["Busr ibn Sa'id [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:christopher-melchert", "type": "scholar", "key": "christopher-melchert", "label": "Christopher Melchert", "labels": ["Christopher Melchert"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:dawud-al-zahiri", "type": "scholar", "key": "dawud-al-zahiri", "label": "Dawud al-Zahiri", "labels": ["Dawud al-Zahiri"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:edip-yuksel", "type": "scholar", "key": "edip-yuksel", "label": "Edip Yuksel", "labels": ["Edip Yuksel"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:elisabeth-puin", "type": "scholar", "key": "elisabeth-puin", "label": "Elisabeth Puin [?]", "labels": ["Elisabeth Puin [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "type": "scholar", "key": "fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "label": "Fakhr al-Din al-Razi", "labels": ["Fakhr al-Din al-Razi", "Fakhr al-Din al-Razi [?]", "al-Razi [?]"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:farabri", "type": "scholar", "key": "farabri", "label": "Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Farabri", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Farabri", "Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Farabri [?]"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 10, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "scholar:faruq-khan", "type": "scholar", "key": "faruq-khan", "label": "Maulana Faruq Khan [?]", "labels": ["Maulana Faruq Khan [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:fethullah-gulen", "type": "scholar", "key": "fethullah-gulen", "label": "Fethullah Gulen", "labels": ["Fethullah Gulen"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:gerd-puin", "type": "scholar", "key": "gerd-puin", "label": "Gerd Puin [?]", "labels": ["Gerd Puin [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays", "type": "scholar", "key": "ghunaym-ibn-qays", "label": "Ghunaym ibn Qays", "labels": ["Ghunaym ibn Qays"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "label": "Habib al-Rahman Kandhlawi [?]", "labels": ["Habib al-Rahman Kandhlawi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "type": "scholar", "key": "hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "label": "Hammad ibn Abi Sulayman [?]", "labels": ["Hammad ibn Abi Sulayman [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "type": "scholar", "key": "hammad-ibn-salama", "label": "Hammad ibn Salama", "labels": ["Hammad ibn Salama"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir", "type": "scholar", "key": "hammad-ibn-shakir", "label": "Hammad ibn Shakir", "labels": ["Hammad ibn Shakir"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "type": "scholar", "key": "hamza-al-kattani", "label": "Hamza al-Kattani [?]", "labels": ["Hamza al-Kattani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "type": "scholar", "key": "hamza-maqbool", "label": "Hamza Maqbool", "labels": ["Hamza Maqbool"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "type": "scholar", "key": "hamza-yusuf", "label": "Hamza Yusuf", "labels": ["Hamza Yusuf"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "type": "scholar", "key": "harmala-ibn-yahya", "label": "Harmala ibn Yahya", "labels": ["Harmala ibn Yahya"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "type": "scholar", "key": "hasan-al-basri", "label": "Hasan al-Basri", "labels": ["Hasan al-Basri"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "type": "scholar", "key": "hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "label": "Hasan Farhan al-Maliki", "labels": ["Hasan Farhan al-Maliki"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:hassan-ali", "type": "scholar", "key": "hassan-ali", "label": "Shaykh Hassan Ali", "labels": ["Shaykh Hassan Ali"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "type": "scholar", "key": "hisham-ibn-urwa", "label": "Hisham ibn Urwa", "labels": ["Hisham ibn Urwa", "Hisham ibn Urwa [?]"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "type": "scholar", "key": "humayd-al-tawil", "label": "Humayd al-Tawil", "labels": ["Humayd al-Tawil"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abd-al-barr", "label": "Ibn Abd al-Barr", "labels": ["Ibn Abd al-Barr", "Ibn Abd al-Barr [?]"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-al-dunya", "label": "Ibn Abi al-Dunya", "labels": ["Ibn Abi al-Dunya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-dhib", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-dhib", "label": "Ibn Abi Dhi'b [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Abi Dhi'b [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-hatim", "label": "Ibn Abi Hatim", "labels": ["Ibn Abi Hatim"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-layla", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-layla", "label": "Ibn Abi Layla", "labels": ["Ibn Abi Layla"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-shayba", "label": "Ibn Abi Shayba [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Abi Shayba [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "label": "Ibn Abi Zayd al-Qayrawani", "labels": ["Ibn Abi Zayd al-Qayrawani"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2015": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-abidin", "label": "Ibn Abidin", "labels": ["Ibn Abidin", "Ibn Abidin [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-adi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-adi", "label": "Ibn Adi", "labels": ["Ibn Adi"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-humam", "label": "Kamal al-Din ibn al-Humam [?]", "labels": ["Kamal al-Din ibn al-Humam", "Kamal al-Din ibn al-Humam [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-jallab", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-jallab", "label": "Ibn al-Jallab [?]", "labels": ["Ibn al-Jallab [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-jarud", "label": "Ibn al-Jarud [?]", "labels": ["Ibn al-Jarud [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-jawzi", "label": "Ibn al-Jawzi", "labels": ["Ibn al-Jawzi", "Ibn al-Jawzi [?]"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-jazari", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-jazari", "label": "Ibn al-Jazari [?]", "labels": ["Ibn al-Jazari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-qasim", "label": "Ibn al-Qasim", "labels": ["Ibn al-Qasim", "Ibn al-Qasim [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-qattan", "label": "Ibn al-Qattan [?]", "labels": ["Ibn al-Qattan [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-qayyim", "label": "Ibn al-Qayyim [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya [?]", "Ibn al-Qayyim", "Ibn al-Qayyim [?]", "Ibn al-Qayyim [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-sakan", "label": "Ibn al-Sakan", "labels": ["Ibn al-Sakan"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-al-salah", "label": "Ibn al-Salah", "labels": ["Ibn al-Salah", "Ibn al-Salah [?]"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-arabi", "label": "Ibn Arabi", "labels": ["Ibn Arabi", "Ibn Arabi (Muhyi al-Din) [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-arafa", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-arafa", "label": "Ibn Arafa [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Arafa [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-ashur", "label": "Ibn Ashur", "labels": ["Ibn Ashur", "Ibn Ashur [?]"], "segments": 33, "recordings": 17, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 14, "2019": 3, "2020": 4, "2021": 10, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-atiyya", "label": "Ibn Atiyya [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Atiyya [?]", "Ibn Atiyya al-Andalusi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-azraq", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-azraq", "label": "Ibn Azraq [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Azraq [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-bashkuwal", "label": "Ibn Bashkuwal [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Bashkuwal [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-baz", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-baz", "label": "Ibn Baz", "labels": ["Ibn Baz"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-faris", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-faris", "label": "Ibn Faris [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Faris [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-ghalbun", "label": "Ibn Ghalbun [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Ghalbun [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-ghanim", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-ghanim", "label": "Ibn Ghanim [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Ghanim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-hajar", "label": "Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani", "labels": ["Ibn Hajar", "Ibn Hajar [?]", "Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani"], "segments": 32, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 17, "2019": 1, "2021": 5, "2022": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 32}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "label": "Ibn Hajar al-Haytami", "labels": ["Ibn Hajar al-Haytami"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-hazm", "label": "Ibn Hazm", "labels": ["Ibn Hazm", "Ibn Hazm [?]"], "segments": 24, "recordings": 18, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 8, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 8, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-hibban", "label": "Ibn Hibban", "labels": ["Ibn Hibban", "Ibn Hibban [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-hurmuz", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-hurmuz", "label": "Ibn Hurmuz", "labels": ["Ibn Hurmuz"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-ishaq", "label": "Ibn Ishaq", "labels": ["Ibn Ishaq"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-jurayj", "label": "Ibn Jurayj", "labels": ["Ibn Jurayj"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-kathir", "label": "Ibn Kathir", "labels": ["Ibn Kathir", "Ibn Kathir [?]"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-khaldun", "label": "Ibn Khaldun", "labels": ["Ibn Khaldun", "Ibn Khaldun [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "label": "Ibn Khuwayz Mindad [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Khuwayz Mindad [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-khuzayma", "label": "Ibn Khuzayma", "labels": ["Ibn Khuzayma"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-lubaba", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-lubaba", "label": "Ibn Lubaba [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Lubaba [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-main", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-main", "label": "Yahya ibn Ma'in", "labels": ["Yahya ibn Ma'in", "Yahya ibn Ma'in [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-makula", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-makula", "label": "Ibn Makula", "labels": ["Ibn Makula"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-malik", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-malik", "label": "Ibn Malik (the grammarian)", "labels": ["Ibn Malik (the grammarian)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-mujahid", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-mujahid", "label": "Abu Bakr ibn Mujahid", "labels": ["Abu Bakr ibn Mujahid"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-qudama", "label": "Ibn Qudama", "labels": ["Ibn Qudama", "Ibn Qudama [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "label": "Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali", "labels": ["Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali", "Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-rushayd", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-rushayd", "label": "Ibn Rushayd [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Rushayd [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-rushd", "label": "Ibn Rushd (Averroes)", "labels": ["Ibn Rushd", "Ibn Rushd (Averroes)", "Ibn Rushd (Averroes) [?]", "Ibn Rushd [?]"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 10, "2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "label": "Ibn Rushd al-Jadd", "labels": ["Ibn Rushd [?]", "Ibn Rushd al-Jadd", "Ibn Rushd al-Jadd (the grandfather)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "label": "Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri", "labels": ["Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-sina", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-sina", "label": "Ibn Sina", "labels": ["Ibn Sina", "Ibn Sina [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-sirin", "label": "Ibn Sirin [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Sirin", "Ibn Sirin [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-tahir", "label": "Ibn Tahir [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Tahir [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-taymiyya", "label": "Ibn Taymiyya", "labels": ["Ibn Taymiyya", "Ibn Taymiyya [?]"], "segments": 28, "recordings": 21, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 7, "2019": 4, "2020": 3, "2021": 7, "2022": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-tufayl", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-tufayl", "label": "Ibn Tufayl [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Tufayl [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-ulayya", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-ulayya", "label": "Ibn Ulayya [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Ulayya [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-uthaymin", "label": "Ibn Uthaymin", "labels": ["Ibn Uthaymin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-waddah", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-waddah", "label": "Ibn Waddah [?]", "labels": ["Ibn Waddah [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-wahb", "label": "Ibn Wahb", "labels": ["Ibn Wahb"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "label": "Abu Bakr ibn Yunus al-Siqilli", "labels": ["Abu Bakr ibn Yunus al-Siqilli"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibrahim-al-halabi", "label": "Ibrahim al-Halabi", "labels": ["Ibrahim al-Halabi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibrahim-al-harbi", "label": "Ibrahim al-Harbi [?]", "labels": ["Ibrahim al-Harbi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibrahim-al-nakhai", "label": "Ibrahim al-Nakha'i [?]", "labels": ["Ibrahim al-Nakha'i [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "label": "Ibrahim ibn Ma'qil al-Nasafi [?]", "labels": ["Ibrahim ibn Ma'qil al-Nasafi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:ikrima", "type": "scholar", "key": "ikrima", "label": "Ikrima", "labels": ["Ikrima"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:imam-malik", "type": "scholar", "key": "imam-malik", "label": "Imam Malik", "labels": ["Imam Malik", "Imam Malik [?]"], "segments": 170, "recordings": 82, "years": {"2014": 5, "2015": 6, "2016": 1, "2017": 10, "2018": 45, "2019": 23, "2020": 17, "2021": 36, "2022": 6, "2023": 20, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 170}}, {"id": "scholar:imam-muslim", "type": "scholar", "key": "imam-muslim", "label": "Imam Muslim", "labels": ["Imam Muslim", "Muslim"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:imran-hosein", "type": "scholar", "key": "imran-hosein", "label": "Shaykh Imran Hosein", "labels": ["Shaykh Imran Hosein"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "type": "scholar", "key": "imran-ibn-hittan", "label": "Imran ibn Hittan [?]", "labels": ["Imran ibn Hittan", "Imran ibn Hittan [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:inayatullah-athari", "type": "scholar", "key": "inayatullah-athari", "label": "Inayatullah Athari [?]", "labels": ["Inayatullah Athari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:islam-al-buhayri", "type": "scholar", "key": "islam-al-buhayri", "label": "Islam al-Buhayri [?]", "labels": ["Islam al-Buhayri [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ismail-al-qadi", "label": "Qadi Isma'il (Isma'il ibn Ishaq al-Qadi)", "labels": ["Qadi Isma'il (Isma'il ibn Ishaq al-Qadi)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "type": "scholar", "key": "ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "label": "Isma'il ibn Abi Uways", "labels": ["Isma'il [?] (narrator in the chain)", "Isma'il ibn Abi Uways"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:ismail-patel", "type": "scholar", "key": "ismail-patel", "label": "Shaykh Ismail Patel", "labels": ["Shaykh Ismail Patel"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "type": "scholar", "key": "israil-ibn-yunus", "label": "Isra'il [?]", "labels": ["Isra'il [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "type": "scholar", "key": "jabir-ibn-zayd", "label": "Jabir ibn Zayd", "labels": ["Jabir ibn Zayd"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "type": "scholar", "key": "jafar-al-sadiq", "label": "Imam Jafar al-Sadiq", "labels": ["Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq", "Imam Jafar al-Sadiq"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:jamal-al-banna", "type": "scholar", "key": "jamal-al-banna", "label": "Jamal al-Banna", "labels": ["Jamal al-Banna"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:jaun-elia", "type": "scholar", "key": "jaun-elia", "label": "Jaun Elia", "labels": ["Jaun Elia"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "type": "scholar", "key": "javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "label": "Javed Ahmad Ghamidi", "labels": ["Javed Ahmad Ghamidi", "Javed Ahmad Ghamidi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "type": "scholar", "key": "jonathan-brown", "label": "Jonathan Brown", "labels": ["Jonathan Brown"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:joseph-lumbard", "type": "scholar", "key": "joseph-lumbard", "label": "Joseph Lumbard", "labels": ["Joseph Lumbard"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "type": "scholar", "key": "junayd-al-baghdadi", "label": "Junayd al-Baghdadi", "labels": ["Junayd al-Baghdadi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:khalid-al-jundi", "type": "scholar", "key": "khalid-al-jundi", "label": "Khalid al-Jundi [?]", "labels": ["Khalid al-Jundi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "type": "scholar", "key": "khalid-al-madaini", "label": "Khalid al-Madaini [?]", "labels": ["Khalid [?], a known forger", "Khalid al-Madaini [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "type": "scholar", "key": "khalil-ibn-ishaq", "label": "Khalil ibn Ishaq", "labels": ["Khalil ibn Ishaq"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "type": "scholar", "key": "khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "label": "Khuzayma ibn Thabit [?]", "labels": ["Khuzayma ibn Thabit [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "type": "scholar", "key": "ludwig-wittgenstein", "label": "Ludwig Wittgenstein", "labels": ["Ludwig Wittgenstein"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:mahmud-ashur", "type": "scholar", "key": "mahmud-ashur", "label": "Mahmud Ashur [?] (former deputy of al-Azhar)", "labels": ["Mahmud Ashur [?] (former deputy of al-Azhar)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "type": "scholar", "key": "mahmud-shaltut", "label": "Mahmud Shaltut", "labels": ["Mahmud Shaltut", "Mahmud Shaltut [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:maimonides", "type": "scholar", "key": "maimonides", "label": "Maimonides", "labels": ["Maimonides"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "type": "scholar", "key": "majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "label": "Majd al-Din Ibn Taymiyya [?] (Ibn Taymiyya's grandfather; name garbled in the transcript)", "labels": ["Majd al-Din Ibn Taymiyya [?] (Ibn Taymiyya's grandfather; name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "type": "scholar", "key": "mamar-ibn-rashid", "label": "Ma'mar ibn Rashid [?]", "labels": ["Ma'mar ibn Rashid [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mayyara", "type": "scholar", "key": "mayyara", "label": "Mayyara [?]", "labels": ["Mayyara [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad", "type": "scholar", "key": "mirza-bashir-ahmad", "label": "Mirza Bashir Ahmad [?], author of the biography", "labels": ["Mirza Bashir Ahmad [?], author of the biography"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "type": "scholar", "key": "mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "label": "Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad [?]", "labels": ["Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "type": "scholar", "key": "mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "label": "Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian", "labels": ["Mirza Ghulam Ahmad", "Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 5, "2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan", "type": "scholar", "key": "mishrah-ibn-haan", "label": "Mishrah ibn Ha'an [?]", "labels": ["Mishrah ibn Ha'an [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "type": "scholar", "key": "mohamed-fizazi", "label": "Mohamed al-Fizazi [?]", "labels": ["Mohamed al-Fizazi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "type": "scholar", "key": "mohsen-goudarzi", "label": "Mohsen Goudarzi [?]", "labels": ["Mohsen Goudarzi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:mufti-menk", "type": "scholar", "key": "mufti-menk", "label": "Mufti Menk", "labels": ["Mufti Menk"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-abduh", "label": "Muhammad Abduh", "labels": ["Muhammad Abduh"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "label": "Muhammad al-Aziz Ju'ayt [?], Grand Maliki Mufti of Tunis", "labels": ["Muhammad al-Aziz Ju'ayt [?], Grand Maliki Mufti of Tunis"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-al-baqir", "label": "Imam Muhammad al-Baqir", "labels": ["Imam Muhammad al-Baqir", "Muhammad al-Baqir"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-al-ghazali", "label": "Muhammad al-Ghazali", "labels": ["Muhammad al-Ghazali"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "label": "Muhammad al-Hasan Ould al-Dedew", "labels": ["Muhammad al-Hasan Ould al-Dedew", "Shaykh Dedew [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "label": "Shaykh Muhammad al-Yaqoubi", "labels": ["Shaykh Muhammad al-Yaqoubi"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 7, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ali-mirza", "label": "Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza", "labels": ["Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "label": "Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "label": "Muhammad ibn Abdullah al-Ansari [?]", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Abdullah al-Ansari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "label": "Imam Muhammad (al-Shaybani)", "labels": ["Imam Muhammad (al-Shaybani)", "Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Shaybani"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "label": "Muhammad ibn Dawud al-Zahiri", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Dawud al-Zahiri"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "label": "Muhammad ibn Sahnun [?]", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Sahnun [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "label": "Muhammad ibn Yahya al-Dhuhli", "labels": ["Muhammad ibn Yahya al-Dhuhli", "Muhammad ibn Yahya al-Dhuhli [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-iqbal", "label": "Allama Muhammad Iqbal", "labels": ["Allama Muhammad Iqbal"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-naeem", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-naeem", "label": "Mufti Naeem [?]", "labels": ["Mufti Naeem [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muhammad-nizami", "type": "scholar", "key": "muhammad-nizami", "label": "Shaykh Muhammad Nizami [?]", "labels": ["Shaykh Muhammad Nizami [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mujahid", "type": "scholar", "key": "mujahid", "label": "Mujahid ibn Jabr", "labels": ["Mujahid ibn Jabr"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "type": "scholar", "key": "mulla-ali-al-qari", "label": "Mulla Ali al-Qari", "labels": ["Mulla Ali al-Qari"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "type": "scholar", "key": "muqbil-al-wadii", "label": "Muqbil al-Wadi'i [?]", "labels": ["Muqbil al-Wadi'i [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:musab-al-zubayri", "type": "scholar", "key": "musab-al-zubayri", "label": "Mus'ab al-Zubayri [?]", "labels": ["Mus'ab al-Zubayri [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "type": "scholar", "key": "muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "label": "Muslim ibn Ibrahim [?]", "labels": ["Muslim ibn Ibrahim [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "type": "scholar", "key": "mustafa-al-maraghi", "label": "Mustafa al-Maraghi", "labels": ["Mustafa al-Maraghi", "Mustafa al-Maraghi [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "type": "scholar", "key": "mustafa-al-zarqa", "label": "Mustafa al-Zarqa [?]", "labels": ["Mustafa al-Zarqa [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:mustafa-bin-hamza", "type": "scholar", "key": "mustafa-bin-hamza", "label": "Mustafa Bin Hamza [?]", "labels": ["Mustafa Bin Hamza [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:nafi", "type": "scholar", "key": "nafi", "label": "Nafi'", "labels": ["Nafi'"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "type": "scholar", "key": "nouman-ali-khan", "label": "Nouman Ali Khan", "labels": ["Nouman Ali Khan"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:nuh-keller", "type": "scholar", "key": "nuh-keller", "label": "Nuh Ha Mim Keller", "labels": ["Nuh Ha Mim Keller"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "type": "scholar", "key": "omar-suleiman", "label": "Omar Suleiman", "labels": ["Omar Suleiman"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 9, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "type": "scholar", "key": "pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "label": "Pir Naseeruddin Naseer Gilani [?]", "labels": ["Pir Naseeruddin Naseer Gilani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "type": "scholar", "key": "qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "label": "Qadi Abd al-Jabbar", "labels": ["Qadi Abd al-Jabbar"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "type": "scholar", "key": "qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "label": "Qadi Abd al-Wahhab [?]", "labels": ["Qadi Abd al-Wahhab [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "type": "scholar", "key": "qadi-iyad", "label": "Qadi Iyad", "labels": ["Qadi Iyad", "Qadi Iyad [?]"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 1, "2018": 9, "2019": 1, "2022": 5, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "scholar:qadi-khan", "type": "scholar", "key": "qadi-khan", "label": "Qadi Khan", "labels": ["Qadi Khan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:qatada", "type": "scholar", "key": "qatada", "label": "Qatada", "labels": ["Qatada", "Qatada [?]"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "type": "scholar", "key": "qutayba-ibn-said", "label": "Qutayba ibn Said", "labels": ["Qutayba ibn Sa'id", "Qutayba ibn Said", "Qutayba ibn Said [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "type": "scholar", "key": "rabia-al-ray", "label": "Rabi'a al-Ra'y", "labels": ["Rabi'a al-Ra'y"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:rami-nsour", "type": "scholar", "key": "rami-nsour", "label": "Rami Nsour [?]", "labels": ["Rami Nsour [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:rashad-khalifa", "type": "scholar", "key": "rashad-khalifa", "label": "Rashad Khalifa", "labels": ["Rashad Khalifa"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:rashid-rida", "type": "scholar", "key": "rashid-rida", "label": "Rashid Rida", "labels": ["Rashid Rida"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "type": "scholar", "key": "ruhollah-khomeini", "label": "Ayatollah Khomeini", "labels": ["Ayatollah Khomeini"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:rumi", "type": "scholar", "key": "rumi", "label": "Rumi", "labels": ["Rumi"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "type": "scholar", "key": "sad-ibn-ibrahim", "label": "Sa'd ibn Ibrahim", "labels": ["Sa'd ibn Ibrahim", "Sa'd ibn Ibrahim [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:sahnun", "type": "scholar", "key": "sahnun", "label": "Sahnun", "labels": ["Sahnun"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "type": "scholar", "key": "said-ibn-al-musayyib", "label": "Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib", "labels": ["Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "type": "scholar", "key": "said-ibn-jubayr", "label": "Sa'id ibn Jubayr", "labels": ["Sa'id ibn Jubayr", "Sa'id ibn Jubayr [?] (the student of Ibn Abbas)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "type": "scholar", "key": "said-ramadan-al-buti", "label": "Sa'id Ramadan al-Buti [?]", "labels": ["Sa'id Ramadan al-Buti", "Sa'id Ramadan al-Buti [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "type": "scholar", "key": "salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "label": "Salah al-Din al-Idlibi [?]", "labels": ["Salah al-Din al-Idlibi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "type": "scholar", "key": "salek-bin-siddina", "label": "Shaykh Salek bin Siddina", "labels": ["Shaykh Salek bin Siddina"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:sanaullah-amritsari", "type": "scholar", "key": "sanaullah-amritsari", "label": "Sanaullah Amritsari [?]", "labels": ["Sanaullah Amritsari [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "type": "scholar", "key": "saqib-shaami", "label": "Shaykh Saqib Shaami", "labels": ["Pir Saqib Shaami [?]", "Shaykh Saqib Shaami"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "type": "scholar", "key": "sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "label": "Sayf al-Din al-Amidi [?]", "labels": ["Sayf al-Din al-Amidi [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:shabir-ally", "type": "scholar", "key": "shabir-ally", "label": "Dr Shabir Ally", "labels": ["Dr Shabir Ally"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "type": "scholar", "key": "shadee-elmasry", "label": "Shadee Elmasry", "labels": ["Shadee Elmasry", "Shaykh Shadee Elmasry [?]"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:shady-nasser", "type": "scholar", "key": "shady-nasser", "label": "Shady Hekmat Nasser", "labels": ["Shady Hekmat Nasser"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "type": "scholar", "key": "shah-wali-allah", "label": "Shah Wali Allah al-Dihlawi", "labels": ["Shah Wali Allah al-Dihlawi"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:shehzad-saleem", "type": "scholar", "key": "shehzad-saleem", "label": "Dr Shehzad Saleem", "labels": ["Dr Shehzad Saleem"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "type": "scholar", "key": "sherman-jackson", "label": "Sherman Jackson", "labels": ["Sherman Jackson"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "type": "scholar", "key": "shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "label": "Shu'ayb ibn Abi Hamza", "labels": ["Shu'ayb ibn Abi Hamza"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:shuba", "type": "scholar", "key": "shuba", "label": "Shu'ba", "labels": ["Shu'ba"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:sibawayh", "type": "scholar", "key": "sibawayh", "label": "Sibawayh", "labels": ["Sibawayh", "Sibawayh [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "type": "scholar", "key": "siddiq-hasan-khan", "label": "Siddiq Hasan Khan", "labels": ["Siddiq Hasan Khan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "type": "scholar", "key": "sufyan-al-thawri", "label": "Sufyan al-Thawri", "labels": ["Sufyan al-Thawri"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2016": 2, "2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "type": "scholar", "key": "sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "label": "Sufyan ibn Uyayna", "labels": ["Sufyan [?]", "Sufyan ibn Uyayna", "Sufyan ibn Uyayna [?]"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "scholar:suhaib-webb", "type": "scholar", "key": "suhaib-webb", "label": "Suhaib Webb [?]", "labels": ["Suhaib Webb [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar", "type": "scholar", "key": "sulayman-ibn-yasar", "label": "Sulayman ibn Yasar", "labels": ["Sulayman ibn Yasar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "type": "scholar", "key": "tamanna-imadi", "label": "Tamanna Imadi [?]", "labels": ["Tamanna Imadi [?]"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki", "type": "scholar", "key": "taqi-al-din-al-subki", "label": "Taqi al-Din al-Subki", "labels": ["Taqi al-Din al-Subki"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:taqi-usmani", "type": "scholar", "key": "taqi-usmani", "label": "Mufti Taqi Usmani [?]", "labels": ["Mufti Taqi Usmani [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "type": "scholar", "key": "tariq-jamil", "label": "Maulana Tariq Jamil", "labels": ["Maulana Tariq Jamil"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:tariq-masood", "type": "scholar", "key": "tariq-masood", "label": "Mufti Tariq Masood", "labels": ["Mufti Tariq Masood"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:tawus", "type": "scholar", "key": "tawus", "label": "Tawus [?]", "labels": ["Tawus", "Tawus [?]"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "type": "scholar", "key": "thabit-al-bunani", "label": "Thabit al-Bunani", "labels": ["Thabit al-Bunani"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:thabit-ibn-umara", "type": "scholar", "key": "thabit-ibn-umara", "label": "Thabit ibn Umara", "labels": ["Thabit ibn Umara"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "type": "scholar", "key": "ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "label": "Ubayd, client of Abu Ruhm [?]", "labels": ["Ubayd, client of Abu Ruhm [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ubaydullah", "type": "scholar", "key": "ubaydullah", "label": "Ubaydullah [?]", "labels": ["Ubaydullah [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "type": "scholar", "key": "ubaydullah-sindhi", "label": "Ubaydullah Sindhi [?]", "labels": ["Ubaydullah Sindhi [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah", "type": "scholar", "key": "umar-faruq-abdullah", "label": "Dr Umar Faruq Abdullah", "labels": ["Dr Umar Faruq Abdullah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "type": "scholar", "key": "umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "label": "Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz", "labels": ["Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "type": "scholar", "key": "urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "label": "Urwa ibn al-Zubayr", "labels": ["Urwa ibn al-Zubayr"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:usama-canon", "type": "scholar", "key": "usama-canon", "label": "Usama Canon [?]", "labels": ["Usama Canon [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "type": "scholar", "key": "wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "label": "Wuhayb [?]", "labels": ["Wuhayb [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "type": "scholar", "key": "yahya-ibn-adam", "label": "Yahya ibn Adam [?]", "labels": ["Yahya ibn Adam [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham", "type": "scholar", "key": "yahya-ibn-aktham", "label": "Yahya ibn Aktham [?]", "labels": ["Yahya ibn Aktham [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "type": "scholar", "key": "yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "label": "Yahya ibn Sa'id al-Qattan", "labels": ["Yahya ibn Sa'id al-Qattan"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "type": "scholar", "key": "yasir-qadhi", "label": "Yasir Qadhi", "labels": ["Yasir Qadhi", "Yasir Qadhi [?]", "Yasir Qadhi [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 76, "recordings": 22, "years": {"2018": 18, "2019": 11, "2020": 17, "2021": 30}, "tiers": {"machine": 76}}, {"id": "scholar:yasmin-amin", "type": "scholar", "key": "yasmin-amin", "label": "Yasmin Amin", "labels": ["Yasmin Amin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:yasser-al-habib", "type": "scholar", "key": "yasser-al-habib", "label": "Yasser al-Habib [?]", "labels": ["Yasser al-Habib [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "type": "scholar", "key": "yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "label": "Yazid [?] (narrator who went blind)", "labels": ["Yazid [?] (narrator who went blind)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:yunini", "type": "scholar", "key": "yunini", "label": "Sharaf al-Din al-Yunini", "labels": ["Sharaf al-Din al-Yunini"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "type": "scholar", "key": "yunus-ibn-yazid", "label": "Yunus ibn Yazid al-Ayli [?]", "labels": ["Yunus ibn Yazid al-Ayli [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "type": "scholar", "key": "yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "label": "Yunus ibn Yazid al-Ayli", "labels": ["Yunus ibn Yazid al-Ayli"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "type": "scholar", "key": "yusuf-al-qaradawi", "label": "Yusuf al-Qaradawi [?] (name garbled in the transcript)", "labels": ["Yusuf al-Qaradawi", "Yusuf al-Qaradawi [?] (name garbled in the transcript)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "scholar:zaid-shakir", "type": "scholar", "key": "zaid-shakir", "label": "Imam Zaid Shakir [?]", "labels": ["Imam Zaid Shakir [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "type": "scholar", "key": "zakaullah-saleem", "label": "Maulana Zakaullah Saleem [?] (imam at Green Lane Masjid; named in the video description)", "labels": ["Maulana Zakaullah Saleem [?] (imam at Green Lane Masjid; named in the video description)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "scholar:zakir-naik", "type": "scholar", "key": "zakir-naik", "label": "Zakir Naik", "labels": ["Zakir Naik"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "type": "scholar", "key": "zayn-al-abidin", "label": "Ali Zayn al-Abidin", "labels": ["Ali Zayn al-Abidin"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "scholar:zufar", "type": "scholar", "key": "zufar", "label": "Zufar", "labels": ["Zufar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:adab", "type": "term", "key": "adab", "label": "adab", "labels": ["adab"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:adalat-al-sahaba", "type": "term", "key": "adalat-al-sahaba", "label": "'adala of the sahaba (probity of the companions)", "labels": ["'adala of the sahaba (probity of the companions)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:adhab", "type": "term", "key": "adhab", "label": "'adhab (punishment)", "labels": ["'adhab (punishment)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:adhan", "type": "term", "key": "adhan", "label": "adhan", "labels": ["adhan"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:ahad", "type": "term", "key": "ahad", "label": "khabar al-ahad", "labels": ["khabar al-ahad", "khabar al-ahad (isolated reports)", "khabar al-ahad [?]"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:ahd-dhihni", "type": "term", "key": "ahd-dhihni", "label": "al-'ahd al-dhihni (definite article referring to a known thing)", "labels": ["al-'ahd al-dhihni (definite article referring to a known thing)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "type": "term", "key": "ahl-al-bayt", "label": "Ahl al-Bayt", "labels": ["Ahl al-Bayt", "Ahl al-Bayt (the household of the Prophet)", "ahl al-bayt (the family of the Prophet)", "descendants of the Prophet"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:ahl-al-hadith", "type": "term", "key": "ahl-al-hadith", "label": "ahl al-hadith mentality [?]", "labels": ["ahl al-hadith mentality [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "type": "term", "key": "ahl-al-kitab", "label": "Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book)", "labels": ["Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:ahl-al-ray", "type": "term", "key": "ahl-al-ray", "label": "the school of reason (ahl al-ra'y)", "labels": ["the school of reason (ahl al-ra'y)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ahl-al-sunnah", "type": "term", "key": "ahl-al-sunnah", "label": "Ahl al-Sunnah", "labels": ["Ahl al-Sunnah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:akhirah", "type": "term", "key": "akhirah", "label": "akhirah", "labels": ["akhirah"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:al-andalus", "type": "term", "key": "al-andalus", "label": "al-Andalus", "labels": ["Muslim Spain (al-Andalus)", "al-Andalus", "al-Andalus (Muslim Spain)", "al-Andalus (the Iberian peninsula)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:al-ayn", "type": "term", "key": "al-ayn", "label": "al-'ayn (the evil eye)", "labels": ["al-'ayn (the evil eye)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:al-insan-madani", "type": "term", "key": "al-insan-madani", "label": "al-insan madani (man is a social being)", "labels": ["al-insan madani (man is a social being)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:al-kitab", "type": "term", "key": "al-kitab", "label": "kitab (scripture)", "labels": ["kitab (scripture)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:al-lat", "type": "term", "key": "al-lat", "label": "al-Lat", "labels": ["al-Lat"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:al-rahman-al-rahim", "type": "term", "key": "al-rahman-al-rahim", "label": "al-Rahman al-Rahim", "labels": ["al-Rahman al-Rahim"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:al-razzaq", "type": "term", "key": "al-razzaq", "label": "al-Razzaq (the Provider)", "labels": ["al-Razzaq (the Provider)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:al-wala-wal-bara", "type": "term", "key": "al-wala-wal-bara", "label": "al-wala wal-bara (loyalty and disavowal)", "labels": ["al-wala wal-bara (loyalty and disavowal)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:almah", "type": "term", "key": "almah", "label": "almah (young maiden)", "labels": ["almah (young maiden)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:am", "type": "term", "key": "am", "label": "'am (year)", "labels": ["'am (year)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:amah", "type": "term", "key": "amah", "label": "amah (slave woman)", "labels": ["amah (slave woman)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "type": "term", "key": "amal-ahl-al-madinah", "label": "the practice of the people of Madinah", "labels": ["'amal ahl al-Madinah (practice of Madinah)", "'amal ahl al-madinah (the practice of the people of Madinah)", "amal ahl al-Madinah (the practice of Madinah)", "amal ahl al-Madinah (the practice of Medina)", "practice of the people of Medina", "the practice of the people of Madinah"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "term:amanita-muscaria", "type": "term", "key": "amanita-muscaria", "label": "Amanita muscaria", "labels": ["Amanita muscaria"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "type": "term", "key": "ambiguous-picture-effect", "label": "the ambiguous picture effect (the host's term)", "labels": ["the ambiguous picture effect (the host's term)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:amir-al-muminin", "type": "term", "key": "amir-al-muminin", "label": "amir al-mu'minin", "labels": ["amir al-mu'minin"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:ansar", "type": "term", "key": "ansar", "label": "Ansar", "labels": ["Ansar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:aphantasia", "type": "term", "key": "aphantasia", "label": "aphantasia", "labels": ["aphantasia"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:aqidah", "type": "term", "key": "aqidah", "label": "aqidah", "labels": ["aqidah", "aqidah (creed)"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:aqiqah", "type": "term", "key": "aqiqah", "label": "aqiqah", "labels": ["aqiqah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:aql", "type": "term", "key": "aql", "label": "aql (reason)", "labels": ["'aql (reason)", "aql (intellect)", "aql (reason)"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "term:arafah", "type": "term", "key": "arafah", "label": "Arafah", "labels": ["Arafah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:asbab", "type": "term", "key": "asbab", "label": "asbab (causes)", "labels": ["asbab (causes)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:asbab-al-nuzul", "type": "term", "key": "asbab-al-nuzul", "label": "asbab al-nuzul (occasions of revelation)", "labels": ["asbab al-nuzul (occasions of revelation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ashari", "type": "term", "key": "ashari", "label": "Ash'ari", "labels": ["Ash'ari", "Ash'ari school"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "term:ashrat-al-saah", "type": "term", "key": "ashrat-al-saah", "label": "ashrat al-sa'ah (signs of the Hour)", "labels": ["ashrat al-sa'ah (signs of the Hour)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:ashura", "type": "term", "key": "ashura", "label": "Ashura (the tenth of Muharram)", "labels": ["Ashura (the tenth of Muharram)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:athari", "type": "term", "key": "athari", "label": "Athari", "labels": ["Athari"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:awrah", "type": "term", "key": "awrah", "label": "'awrah", "labels": ["'awrah"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:ayahuasca", "type": "term", "key": "ayahuasca", "label": "ayahuasca", "labels": ["ayahuasca"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ayat-al-kursi", "type": "term", "key": "ayat-al-kursi", "label": "Ayat al-Kursi", "labels": ["Ayat al-Kursi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:azariqa", "type": "term", "key": "azariqa", "label": "Azariqa [?]", "labels": ["Azariqa [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:baalshamin", "type": "term", "key": "baalshamin", "label": "Baalshamin [?]", "labels": ["Baalshamin [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:backfire-effect", "type": "term", "key": "backfire-effect", "label": "the backfire effect", "labels": ["the backfire effect"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:bala", "type": "term", "key": "bala", "label": "bala (trial)", "labels": ["bala (trial)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:balagha", "type": "term", "key": "balagha", "label": "balagha (rhetoric) [?]", "labels": ["balagha (rhetoric)", "balagha (rhetoric) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:bani-israil", "type": "term", "key": "bani-israil", "label": "Bani Isra'il (the Israelites)", "labels": ["Bani Isra'il", "Bani Isra'il (the Israelites)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:bara", "type": "term", "key": "bara", "label": "bara'a (disavowal, detachment of association)", "labels": ["bara'a (disavowal, detachment of association)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:barakah", "type": "term", "key": "barakah", "label": "barakah", "labels": ["barakah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:barelvi", "type": "term", "key": "barelvi", "label": "Barelvi", "labels": ["Barelvi"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:barzakh", "type": "term", "key": "barzakh", "label": "barzakh", "labels": ["barzakh"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:bashar", "type": "term", "key": "bashar", "label": "bashar", "labels": ["bashar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:batil-and-fasid", "type": "term", "key": "batil-and-fasid", "label": "batil and fasid (void and defective contracts)", "labels": ["batil and fasid (void and defective contracts)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:bayah", "type": "term", "key": "bayah", "label": "bay'ah", "labels": ["bay'ah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:bayt-al-mal", "type": "term", "key": "bayt-al-mal", "label": "bayt al-mal (the public treasury)", "labels": ["bayt al-mal (the public treasury)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:bidah", "type": "term", "key": "bidah", "label": "bid'ah (innovation in religion)", "labels": ["bid'ah", "bid'ah (innovation in religion)", "bid'ah (innovation)", "bid'ah (the adhan over loudspeakers, in passing)"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2015": 6, "2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:bimaristan", "type": "term", "key": "bimaristan", "label": "bimaristan (medieval hospital)", "labels": ["bimaristan (medieval hospital)", "bimaristan (medieval hospital) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:bismillah", "type": "term", "key": "bismillah", "label": "bismillah", "labels": ["bismillah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:cannabis", "type": "term", "key": "cannabis", "label": "cannabis (marijuana)", "labels": ["cannabis (marijuana)", "cannabis (marijuana, hashish)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:capgras-delusion", "type": "term", "key": "capgras-delusion", "label": "Capgras delusion", "labels": ["Capgras delusion"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "type": "term", "key": "charles-bonnet-syndrome", "label": "Charles Bonnet syndrome", "labels": ["Charles Bonnet syndrome"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:collective-consciousness", "type": "term", "key": "collective-consciousness", "label": "collective consciousness", "labels": ["collective consciousness", "collective unconscious"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:daif", "type": "term", "key": "daif", "label": "da'if", "labels": ["da'if", "da'if (weak)", "da'if (weak); du'afa'"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:dajjal", "type": "term", "key": "dajjal", "label": "Dajjal", "labels": ["Dajjal", "Dajjal (the Antichrist)"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "term:dalk", "type": "term", "key": "dalk", "label": "dalk (rubbing the limbs while washing)", "labels": ["dalk (rubbing the limbs while washing)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dar-al-harb", "type": "term", "key": "dar-al-harb", "label": "Dar al-Harb", "labels": ["Dar al-Harb"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:dar-al-ifta", "type": "term", "key": "dar-al-ifta", "label": "dar al-ifta (fatwa institution)", "labels": ["dar al-ifta (fatwa institution)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dar-al-islam", "type": "term", "key": "dar-al-islam", "label": "Dar al-Islam", "labels": ["Dar al-Islam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dawah", "type": "term", "key": "dawah", "label": "dawah", "labels": ["da'wah", "dawah"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:deen", "type": "term", "key": "deen", "label": "deen", "labels": ["deen"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:deobandi", "type": "term", "key": "deobandi", "label": "Deobandi", "labels": ["Deobandi"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "term:dhabiha", "type": "term", "key": "dhabiha", "label": "dhabiha (ritual slaughter)", "labels": ["dhabiha", "dhabiha (ritual slaughter)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:dhikr", "type": "term", "key": "dhikr", "label": "dhikr", "labels": ["dhikr"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "type": "term", "key": "dhul-qarnayn", "label": "Dhul Qarnayn", "labels": ["Dhul Qarnayn", "Dhul Qarnayn [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:dinar", "type": "term", "key": "dinar", "label": "dinar", "labels": ["dinar"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dirham", "type": "term", "key": "dirham", "label": "dirham", "labels": ["dirham"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "type": "term", "key": "dissociative-identity-disorder", "label": "dissociative identity disorder (multiple personality)", "labels": ["dissociative identity disorder (multiple personality)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:diya", "type": "term", "key": "diya", "label": "diya (blood money)", "labels": ["diya (blood money)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dmt", "type": "term", "key": "dmt", "label": "DMT", "labels": ["5-MeO-DMT", "DMT", "DMT (dimethyltryptamine)"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:dome-of-the-rock", "type": "term", "key": "dome-of-the-rock", "label": "Dome of the Rock", "labels": ["Dome of the Rock"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:dua", "type": "term", "key": "dua", "label": "dua", "labels": ["du'a", "dua"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:dunya", "type": "term", "key": "dunya", "label": "dunya", "labels": ["dunya"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:dushara", "type": "term", "key": "dushara", "label": "Dushara [?]", "labels": ["Dushara [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:el", "type": "term", "key": "el", "label": "El (Canaanite deity name)", "labels": ["El (Canaanite deity name)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:electromagnetic-spectrum", "type": "term", "key": "electromagnetic-spectrum", "label": "electromagnetic spectrum", "labels": ["electromagnetic spectrum"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:entheogen", "type": "term", "key": "entheogen", "label": "entheogen", "labels": ["entheogen"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:ergot", "type": "term", "key": "ergot", "label": "ergot", "labels": ["ergot"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:evolution", "type": "term", "key": "evolution", "label": "evolution", "labels": ["evolution"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fadak", "type": "term", "key": "fadak", "label": "Fadak", "labels": ["Fadak"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 7, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:fajr", "type": "term", "key": "fajr", "label": "Fajr", "labels": ["Fajr"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fana", "type": "term", "key": "fana", "label": "fana fillah (annihilation in God)", "labels": ["fana fillah (annihilation in God)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:faqih", "type": "term", "key": "faqih", "label": "fuqaha", "labels": ["fuqaha"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fard", "type": "term", "key": "fard", "label": "fard (the obligatory prayers)", "labels": ["fard", "fard (the obligatory prayers)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:fard-kifayah", "type": "term", "key": "fard-kifayah", "label": "fard kifayah (communal obligation)", "labels": ["fard kifayah (communal obligation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fatayat", "type": "term", "key": "fatayat", "label": "fatayat (young women)", "labels": ["fatayat (young women)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fatwa", "type": "term", "key": "fatwa", "label": "fatwa", "labels": ["fatwa"], "segments": 23, "recordings": 22, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 1, "2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 4, "2020": 4, "2021": 5, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "term:fay", "type": "term", "key": "fay", "label": "fay' (property gained without fighting)", "labels": ["fay' (property gained without fighting)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:female-genital-mutilation", "type": "term", "key": "female-genital-mutilation", "label": "female genital mutilation", "labels": ["female genital mutilation"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fidya", "type": "term", "key": "fidya", "label": "fidya", "labels": ["fidya"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:fiqh", "type": "term", "key": "fiqh", "label": "fiqh", "labels": ["fiqh"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "term:fitnah", "type": "term", "key": "fitnah", "label": "fitnah", "labels": ["fitnah"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:fitrah", "type": "term", "key": "fitrah", "label": "fitrah", "labels": ["fitrah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "type": "term", "key": "foreign-accent-syndrome", "label": "foreign accent syndrome", "labels": ["foreign accent syndrome"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:gharaniq", "type": "term", "key": "gharaniq", "label": "gharaniq (the 'exalted ones' of the alleged verses)", "labels": ["gharaniq (the 'exalted ones' of the alleged verses)", "the 'Satanic Verses' (gharaniq) incident", "the Satanic Verses incident (gharaniq)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:ghayb", "type": "term", "key": "ghayb", "label": "ghayb (the unseen)", "labels": ["ghayb (the unseen)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:ghina", "type": "term", "key": "ghina", "label": "ghina (singing, music)", "labels": ["ghina (singing, music)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ghuluw", "type": "term", "key": "ghuluw", "label": "ghuluw (extremism in religion)", "labels": ["ghuluw (extremism in religion)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ghusl", "type": "term", "key": "ghusl", "label": "ghusl", "labels": ["ghusl"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:god-of-the-gaps", "type": "term", "key": "god-of-the-gaps", "label": "god of the gaps (and the 'jinn of the gaps')", "labels": ["god of the gaps (and the 'jinn of the gaps')"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hadith", "type": "term", "key": "hadith", "label": "hadith", "labels": ["hadith"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:hadiyya", "type": "term", "key": "hadiyya", "label": "hadiyya (gift)", "labels": ["hadiyya (gift)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hadra", "type": "term", "key": "hadra", "label": "hadra", "labels": ["hadra"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hajar-al-aswad", "type": "term", "key": "hajar-al-aswad", "label": "al-Hajar al-Aswad (the Black Stone)", "labels": ["al-Hajar al-Aswad (the Black Stone)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:hajj", "type": "term", "key": "hajj", "label": "hajj", "labels": ["Hajj", "hajj"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:halal", "type": "term", "key": "halal", "label": "halal", "labels": ["halal"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:halala", "type": "term", "key": "halala", "label": "halala", "labels": ["halala"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hanafi", "type": "term", "key": "hanafi", "label": "Hanafi school", "labels": ["Hanafi", "Hanafi school", "Hanafis"], "segments": 45, "recordings": 39, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 3, "2018": 9, "2019": 7, "2020": 8, "2021": 12, "2022": 3, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 45}}, {"id": "term:hanbali", "type": "term", "key": "hanbali", "label": "Hanbali school", "labels": ["Hanbali", "Hanbali creed", "Hanbali scholars [?]", "Hanbali school", "Hanbalis"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 18, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2019": 5, "2020": 4, "2021": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "term:haram", "type": "term", "key": "haram", "label": "haram", "labels": ["haram"], "segments": 31, "recordings": 22, "years": {"2014": 3, "2015": 2, "2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 9, "2020": 5, "2021": 5, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "term:harmala", "type": "term", "key": "harmala", "label": "harmala (Peganum harmala, Syrian rue)", "labels": ["harmala (Peganum harmala, Syrian rue)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:hasad", "type": "term", "key": "hasad", "label": "hasad (envy)", "labels": ["hasad (envy)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:haya", "type": "term", "key": "haya", "label": "haya (modesty)", "labels": ["haya (modesty)", "modesty"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:hayd", "type": "term", "key": "hayd", "label": "hayd (menstruation)", "labels": ["hayd (menstruation)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:heisenberg-uncertainty-principle", "type": "term", "key": "heisenberg-uncertainty-principle", "label": "the Heisenberg uncertainty principle", "labels": ["the Heisenberg uncertainty principle"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hemispatial-neglect", "type": "term", "key": "hemispatial-neglect", "label": "hemispatial neglect", "labels": ["hemispatial neglect"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hifz", "type": "term", "key": "hifz", "label": "hifz (memorisation of the Quran)", "labels": ["hifz", "hifz (memorisation of the Quran)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:hijab", "type": "term", "key": "hijab", "label": "hijab", "labels": ["hijab"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 5, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "term:hijama", "type": "term", "key": "hijama", "label": "hijama (cupping)", "labels": ["hijama (cupping)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hijrah", "type": "term", "key": "hijrah", "label": "hijrah", "labels": ["hijrah"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:hikmah", "type": "term", "key": "hikmah", "label": "hikmah (wisdom)", "labels": ["hikmah (wisdom)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:hinduism", "type": "term", "key": "hinduism", "label": "Hinduism", "labels": ["Hinduism"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:hirz", "type": "term", "key": "hirz", "label": "hirz (guarded property)", "labels": ["hirz (guarded property)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hisbah", "type": "term", "key": "hisbah", "label": "hisbah (ahkam al-hisbah, the rulings of accountability)", "labels": ["hisbah (ahkam al-hisbah, the rulings of accountability)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:hiyal", "type": "term", "key": "hiyal", "label": "hiyal (legal stratagems, loopholes)", "labels": ["hiyal (legal stratagems)", "hiyal (legal stratagems, loopholes)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:hubal", "type": "term", "key": "hubal", "label": "Hubal [?]", "labels": ["Hubal [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:hudhud", "type": "term", "key": "hudhud", "label": "hudhud (hoopoe)", "labels": ["hudhud (hoopoe)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:hudud", "type": "term", "key": "hudud", "label": "hudud (prescribed punishments)", "labels": ["hadd", "hudud", "hudud (prescribed punishments)", "hudud (prescribed punishments); hadd"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:hunafa", "type": "term", "key": "hunafa", "label": "hunafa (pre-Islamic monotheists)", "labels": ["hunafa (pre-Islamic monotheists)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ibadi", "type": "term", "key": "ibadi", "label": "Ibadi", "labels": ["Ibadi"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:ibaha", "type": "term", "key": "ibaha", "label": "ibaha (permissibility)", "labels": ["ibaha (permissibility)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:iddah", "type": "term", "key": "iddah", "label": "iddah (waiting period after divorce)", "labels": ["'iddah (waiting period after divorce)", "'iddah (waiting period)", "iddah (waiting period after divorce)", "iddah (waiting period)"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 5, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:idraj", "type": "term", "key": "idraj", "label": "idraj", "labels": ["idraj"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:idtirab", "type": "term", "key": "idtirab", "label": "idtirab (turbulence in transmission)", "labels": ["idtirab (irreconcilable conflict between narrations) [?]", "idtirab (turbulence in the reports)", "idtirab (turbulence in transmission)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:ifrit", "type": "term", "key": "ifrit", "label": "'ifrit", "labels": ["'ifrit"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ihram", "type": "term", "key": "ihram", "label": "ihram", "labels": ["ihram"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ihtimal", "type": "term", "key": "ihtimal", "label": "ihtimal (openness to interpretation)", "labels": ["ihtimal (openness to interpretation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ijazah", "type": "term", "key": "ijazah", "label": "ijazah (authorisation to teach, with a chain)", "labels": ["ijazah (authorisation to teach)", "ijazah (authorisation to teach, with a chain)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:ijma", "type": "term", "key": "ijma", "label": "ijma'", "labels": ["ijma", "ijma'"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 6, "2021": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "term:ijtihad", "type": "term", "key": "ijtihad", "label": "ijtihad", "labels": ["ijtihad"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:ikhtilaf", "type": "term", "key": "ikhtilaf", "label": "ikhtilaf (difference of opinion)", "labels": ["ikhtilaf (difference of opinion)", "ikhtilaf (scholarly disagreement)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2014": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:ilal", "type": "term", "key": "ilal", "label": "'ilal (hidden defects in a chain)", "labels": ["'ilal (hidden defects in a chain)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:ilgha", "type": "term", "key": "ilgha", "label": "cancellation (ilgha') of a defective rak'ah [?]", "labels": ["cancellation (ilgha') of a defective rak'ah [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:illah", "type": "term", "key": "illah", "label": "'illah (the operative cause of a ruling)", "labels": ["'illah (the operative cause of a ruling)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:illiyyin", "type": "term", "key": "illiyyin", "label": "Illiyyin", "labels": ["Illiyyin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:imam", "type": "term", "key": "imam", "label": "imam", "labels": ["imam"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:imamah", "type": "term", "key": "imamah", "label": "imamah (turban)", "labels": ["imamah (turban)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:iman", "type": "term", "key": "iman", "label": "iman", "labels": ["iman", "iman (faith)"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 5, "2021": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "term:insan", "type": "term", "key": "insan", "label": "insan (human being)", "labels": ["insan", "insan (human being)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:iradah", "type": "term", "key": "iradah", "label": "iradah (will)", "labels": ["iradah (will)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:isaf-and-naila", "type": "term", "key": "isaf-and-naila", "label": "Isaf and Na'ila [?]", "labels": ["Isaf and Na'ila [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:isbal", "type": "term", "key": "isbal", "label": "isbal (garments below the ankle)", "labels": ["isbal (garments below the ankle)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:isha", "type": "term", "key": "isha", "label": "Isha (the night prayer)", "labels": ["Isha (the night prayer)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ismaili", "type": "term", "key": "ismaili", "label": "Ismaili", "labels": ["Isma'ili", "Ismaili"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:isnad", "type": "term", "key": "isnad", "label": "isnad", "labels": ["isnad", "isnad (chain of transmission)"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:isra", "type": "term", "key": "isra", "label": "Isra (the night journey)", "labels": ["Isra (the night journey)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:israiliyyat", "type": "term", "key": "israiliyyat", "label": "Israiliyyat", "labels": ["Israiliyyat"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:istikhara", "type": "term", "key": "istikhara", "label": "istikhara", "labels": ["istikhara"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:istishab", "type": "term", "key": "istishab", "label": "istishab [?] (the presumption of continuity)", "labels": ["istishab [?] (the presumption of continuity)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:istitabah", "type": "term", "key": "istitabah", "label": "istitabah (asking the apostate to repent)", "labels": ["istitabah (asking the apostate to repent)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:izar", "type": "term", "key": "izar", "label": "izar", "labels": ["izar", "izar (wrapped lower garment)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:jahannam", "type": "term", "key": "jahannam", "label": "Jahannam", "labels": ["Jahannam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:jahil", "type": "term", "key": "jahil", "label": "jahil (ignorant person)", "labels": ["jahil", "jahil (ignorant person)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:jahiliyya", "type": "term", "key": "jahiliyya", "label": "jahiliyya", "labels": ["jahiliyya"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:jam", "type": "term", "key": "jam", "label": "jam' (combining prayers)", "labels": ["jam' (combining prayers)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:janazah", "type": "term", "key": "janazah", "label": "janazah (funeral prayer)", "labels": ["janazah (funeral prayer)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:jannah", "type": "term", "key": "jannah", "label": "jannah (Paradise)", "labels": ["jannah", "jannah (Paradise)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "type": "term", "key": "jarh-wa-tadil", "label": "ilm al-rijal (narrator criticism, jarh wa ta'dil)", "labels": ["ilm al-rijal (narrator criticism, jarh wa ta'dil)", "jarh wa ta'dil", "jarh wa ta'dil (narrator criticism)", "jarh wa tadil"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:jariyah", "type": "term", "key": "jariyah", "label": "jariyah (girl approaching adolescence)", "labels": ["jariyah (girl approaching adolescence)", "jariyah (girl)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:jayb", "type": "term", "key": "jayb", "label": "jayb (the chest opening of a garment)", "labels": ["jayb (the chest opening of a garment)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:jihad", "type": "term", "key": "jihad", "label": "jihad", "labels": ["battles of the Prophet", "jihad"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:jinn", "type": "term", "key": "jinn", "label": "jinn", "labels": ["jinn"], "segments": 29, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 9, "2018": 9, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "term:jizya", "type": "term", "key": "jizya", "label": "jizya", "labels": ["jizya"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:jubbah", "type": "term", "key": "jubbah", "label": "jubbah [?]", "labels": ["jubbah [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:jumuah", "type": "term", "key": "jumuah", "label": "jumu'ah", "labels": ["jumu'ah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:juz", "type": "term", "key": "juz", "label": "juz'", "labels": ["juz", "juz'"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:kaaba", "type": "term", "key": "kaaba", "label": "Ka'bah", "labels": ["Ka'bah", "Kaaba"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 4, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "term:kaffarah", "type": "term", "key": "kaffarah", "label": "kaffarah (expiation) [?]", "labels": ["kaffarah (expiation) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kafir", "type": "term", "key": "kafir", "label": "kafir", "labels": ["kafir"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:kahl", "type": "term", "key": "kahl", "label": "kahl", "labels": ["kahl"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:kalam", "type": "term", "key": "kalam", "label": "kalam", "labels": ["kalam", "the mutakallimun (theologians)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:kalam-allah", "type": "term", "key": "kalam-allah", "label": "kalam Allah (God's speech)", "labels": ["kalam Allah (God's speech)", "kalam Allah (eternal speech, al-kalam al-azali)", "kalam Allah (the speech of Allah)", "kalam Allah (the speech of God)", "kalam Allah (the uncreated Quran)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:kalam-lafzi", "type": "term", "key": "kalam-lafzi", "label": "kalam lafzi (worded speech)", "labels": ["kalam lafzi (worded speech)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kalam-nafsi", "type": "term", "key": "kalam-nafsi", "label": "kalam nafsi (inner speech)", "labels": ["kalam nafsi (inner speech)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kalimat-allah", "type": "term", "key": "kalimat-allah", "label": "kalimat Allah (the Word of God)", "labels": ["kalimat Allah (Jesus as the word of God)", "kalimat Allah (the Word of God)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:karamah", "type": "term", "key": "karamah", "label": "karama (saintly miracle)", "labels": ["karama (saintly miracle)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:kashmir", "type": "term", "key": "kashmir", "label": "Kashmir", "labels": ["Kashmir"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khalifah", "type": "term", "key": "khalifah", "label": "khilafah", "labels": ["khalifah", "khalifah (caliphate)", "khilafah"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:khamr", "type": "term", "key": "khamr", "label": "alcohol (khamr)", "labels": ["alcohol (khamr)", "khamr"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:khars", "type": "term", "key": "khars", "label": "khars (estimating dates on the tree) [?]", "labels": ["khars (estimating dates on the tree) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "type": "term", "key": "khatam-al-nabiyyin", "label": "khatam al-nabiyyin (seal of the prophets)", "labels": ["khatam al-nabiyyin (seal of the prophets)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "type": "term", "key": "khatm-al-nubuwwa", "label": "finality of prophethood", "labels": ["finality of prophethood"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khawarij", "type": "term", "key": "khawarij", "label": "Khawarij", "labels": ["Khawarij"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 15, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 4, "2021": 5, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "term:khazz", "type": "term", "key": "khazz", "label": "khazz (silk mixed with other fibres) [?]", "labels": ["khazz (silk mixed with other fibres) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khimar", "type": "term", "key": "khimar", "label": "khimar (head covering)", "labels": ["khimar (head covering)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khul", "type": "term", "key": "khul", "label": "khul'", "labels": ["khul'"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khuntha", "type": "term", "key": "khuntha", "label": "khuntha (hermaphrodite, intersex person)", "labels": ["khuntha (hermaphrodite, intersex person)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:khususiyya", "type": "term", "key": "khususiyya", "label": "khususiyya (a ruling specific to the Prophet)", "labels": ["khususiyya (a ruling specific to the Prophet)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:khutbah", "type": "term", "key": "khutbah", "label": "khutbah", "labels": ["khutbah", "khutbah (khatib)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:khuyala", "type": "term", "key": "khuyala", "label": "khuyala (arrogance)", "labels": ["khuyala (arrogance)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kibr", "type": "term", "key": "kibr", "label": "kibr (arrogance)", "labels": ["kibr (arrogance)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kohl", "type": "term", "key": "kohl", "label": "kohl (surma)", "labels": ["kohl (surma)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:kufr", "type": "term", "key": "kufr", "label": "kufr", "labels": ["kufr", "kufr (declaring people kafir)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:kun-fayakun", "type": "term", "key": "kun-fayakun", "label": "kun fa-yakun (be, and it is)", "labels": ["kun fa-yakun (be, and it is)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:kunya", "type": "term", "key": "kunya", "label": "kunya", "labels": ["kunya"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:kutub-al-sittah", "type": "term", "key": "kutub-al-sittah", "label": "the six books", "labels": ["the six books"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:lataif", "type": "term", "key": "lataif", "label": "lata'if (spiritual centres) [?]", "labels": ["lata'if (spiritual centres) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:lihyah", "type": "term", "key": "lihyah", "label": "lihyah (beard)", "labels": ["lihyah (beard)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:lsd", "type": "term", "key": "lsd", "label": "LSD", "labels": ["LSD"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:luti", "type": "term", "key": "luti", "label": "Luti (the term used for homosexuals in the literature)", "labels": ["Luti (the term used for homosexuals in the literature)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "type": "term", "key": "ma-malakat-aymanukum", "label": "ma malakat aymanukum (what the right hand possesses)", "labels": ["ma malakat aymanukum (what the right hand possesses)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:maazif", "type": "term", "key": "maazif", "label": "ma'azif (musical instruments; read as 'entertainment')", "labels": ["ma'azif (musical instruments; read as 'entertainment')"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:madhhab", "type": "term", "key": "madhhab", "label": "madhhab", "labels": ["madhhab"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2014": 4, "2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:madinah", "type": "term", "key": "madinah", "label": "Madinah", "labels": ["Madinah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:madrasa", "type": "term", "key": "madrasa", "label": "madrasa", "labels": ["madrasa"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:mahdi", "type": "term", "key": "mahdi", "label": "Mahdi", "labels": ["Mahdi"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "term:mahid", "type": "term", "key": "mahid", "label": "mahid (menstruation)", "labels": ["mahid (menstruation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mahr", "type": "term", "key": "mahr", "label": "mahr", "labels": ["mahr"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:mahram", "type": "term", "key": "mahram", "label": "mahram", "labels": ["mahram"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:majhul", "type": "term", "key": "majhul", "label": "majhul (unknown narrator)", "labels": ["majhul (unknown narrator)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:majus", "type": "term", "key": "majus", "label": "Majus (Zoroastrians)", "labels": ["Majus (Zoroastrians)", "Majus (Zoroastrians) [?]"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:makhda", "type": "term", "key": "makhda", "label": "makhda' (inner chamber)", "labels": ["makhda' (inner chamber)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:makhluq", "type": "term", "key": "makhluq", "label": "makhluq (created)", "labels": ["makhluq (created)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:makkah", "type": "term", "key": "makkah", "label": "Makkah", "labels": ["Makkah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:makruh", "type": "term", "key": "makruh", "label": "makruh", "labels": ["makruh", "makruh / makruh tahrimi"], "segments": 13, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 6, "2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "term:malaika", "type": "term", "key": "malaika", "label": "mala'ika (angels)", "labels": ["mala'ika (angels)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:maliki", "type": "term", "key": "maliki", "label": "Maliki school", "labels": ["Maliki", "Maliki (the school of Medina)", "Maliki judges", "Maliki scholars", "Maliki school", "Maliki school (the school of Madinah)"], "segments": 72, "recordings": 46, "years": {"2014": 6, "2015": 3, "2017": 4, "2018": 11, "2019": 8, "2020": 12, "2021": 23, "2022": 1, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 72}}, {"id": "term:mandub", "type": "term", "key": "mandub", "label": "mandub (recommended; mustahab)", "labels": ["mandub (recommended; mustahab)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "type": "term", "key": "manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "label": "al-manzila bayn al-manzilatayn (the position between the two positions)", "labels": ["al-manzila bayn al-manzilatayn (the position between the two positions)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mao-inhibitor", "type": "term", "key": "mao-inhibitor", "label": "MAO inhibitor", "labels": ["MAO inhibitor"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:maqasid", "type": "term", "key": "maqasid", "label": "maqasid al-shari'ah", "labels": ["maqasid", "maqasid (aims of the Sharia)", "maqasid al-shari'a", "maqasid al-shari'ah", "maqasid al-shari'ah [?]", "maqasid al-shariah (objectives of the Sharia)"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2, "2017": 3, "2018": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "term:marja", "type": "term", "key": "marja", "label": "marja' (Shia religious authority)", "labels": ["marja' (Shia religious authority)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:masala", "type": "term", "key": "masala", "label": "mas'ala (legal question)", "labels": ["mas'ala (legal question)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "type": "term", "key": "mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "label": "mash over the khuff (wiping over leather socks)", "labels": ["mash over the khuff (wiping over leather socks)", "wiping over the socks (mash ala al-khuffayn)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "type": "term", "key": "masjid-al-aqsa", "label": "al-Masjid al-Aqsa", "labels": ["al-Masjid al-Aqsa", "al-Masjid al-Aqsa (or the Dome of the Rock)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:masjid-al-haram", "type": "term", "key": "masjid-al-haram", "label": "al-Masjid al-Haram (the Haram in Makkah)", "labels": ["al-Masjid al-Haram (the Haram in Makkah)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "type": "term", "key": "masjid-al-nabawi", "label": "al-Masjid al-Nabawi (the Prophet's mosque)", "labels": ["al-Masjid al-Nabawi (the Prophet's mosque)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:maslaha", "type": "term", "key": "maslaha", "label": "maslaha (public welfare)", "labels": ["maslaha", "maslaha (public welfare)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:matam", "type": "term", "key": "matam", "label": "matam (ritual mourning)", "labels": ["matam (ritual mourning)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:matn", "type": "term", "key": "matn", "label": "matn (text of a report)", "labels": ["matn (text of a report)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:maturidi", "type": "term", "key": "maturidi", "label": "Maturidi", "labels": ["Ash'ari and Maturidi creed", "Maturidi", "Maturidi school"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:maulana", "type": "term", "key": "maulana", "label": "maulana", "labels": ["maulana"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:mawadda", "type": "term", "key": "mawadda", "label": "mawadda (mutual love)", "labels": ["mawadda (mutual love)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mawali", "type": "term", "key": "mawali", "label": "mawali (clients, freed slaves and their descendants)", "labels": ["mawali (clients, freed slaves and their descendants)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mawdu", "type": "term", "key": "mawdu", "label": "fabrication (mawdu')", "labels": ["fabrication (mawdu')"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mawlid", "type": "term", "key": "mawlid", "label": "mawlid", "labels": ["mawlid"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:maysir", "type": "term", "key": "maysir", "label": "gambling (maysir)", "labels": ["gambling (maysir)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:minbar", "type": "term", "key": "minbar", "label": "minbar", "labels": ["minbar"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mirath", "type": "term", "key": "mirath", "label": "mirath (inheritance)", "labels": ["mirath (inheritance)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:miswak", "type": "term", "key": "miswak", "label": "miswak", "labels": ["miswak"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:muallaqat", "type": "term", "key": "muallaqat", "label": "the Mu'allaqat", "labels": ["Mu'allaqat", "the Mu'allaqat"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:muawwidhatayn", "type": "term", "key": "muawwidhatayn", "label": "al-mu'awwidhatayn (the two surahs of seeking refuge)", "labels": ["al-mu'awwidhatayn (the two surahs of seeking refuge)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mubahala", "type": "term", "key": "mubahala", "label": "mubahala", "labels": ["mubahala"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mubham", "type": "term", "key": "mubham", "label": "mubham (an unnamed narrator)", "labels": ["mubham (an unnamed narrator)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mufassirun", "type": "term", "key": "mufassirun", "label": "mufassirun", "labels": ["mufassirun", "mufassirun (exegetes)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:mufti", "type": "term", "key": "mufti", "label": "mufti", "labels": ["mufti"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:muhajirun", "type": "term", "key": "muhajirun", "label": "Muhajirun", "labels": ["Muhajirun"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:muhdath", "type": "term", "key": "muhdath", "label": "muhdath (generated)", "labels": ["muhdath (generated)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mujizah", "type": "term", "key": "mujizah", "label": "mu'jizah (miracle)", "labels": ["mu'jizah (miracle)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mukallaf", "type": "term", "key": "mukallaf", "label": "mukallaf (legally responsible)", "labels": ["mukallaf (legally responsible)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:munafiqun", "type": "term", "key": "munafiqun", "label": "munafiqun (hypocrites)", "labels": ["munafiqun (hypocrites)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:munkar", "type": "term", "key": "munkar", "label": "munkar (rejected report)", "labels": ["munkar", "munkar (rejected report)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:murid", "type": "term", "key": "murid", "label": "murid (disciple)", "labels": ["murid (disciple)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:murjia", "type": "term", "key": "murjia", "label": "Murji'a", "labels": ["Murji'a"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mursal", "type": "term", "key": "mursal", "label": "mursal", "labels": ["mursal"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:mushaf", "type": "term", "key": "mushaf", "label": "mushaf", "labels": ["mushaf", "the Uthmanic mushaf"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:mushkil", "type": "term", "key": "mushkil", "label": "mushkil", "labels": ["mushkil"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mushrikin", "type": "term", "key": "mushrikin", "label": "mushrikin", "labels": ["mushrik (pl. mushrikin)", "mushrikin"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:mutah", "type": "term", "key": "mutah", "label": "mut'ah (temporary marriage)", "labels": ["mut'ah", "mut'ah (temporary marriage)", "mut'ah (temporary marriage) [?]"], "segments": 12, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 4, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "term:mutakallimun", "type": "term", "key": "mutakallimun", "label": "mutakallimun (the theologians)", "labels": ["mutakallimun (the theologians)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:mutashabih", "type": "term", "key": "mutashabih", "label": "mutashabih (ambiguous text)", "labels": ["mutashabih (ambiguous text)", "mutashabihat (ambiguous texts)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:mutawatir", "type": "term", "key": "mutawatir", "label": "mutawatir", "labels": ["mutawatir"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "term:mutazila", "type": "term", "key": "mutazila", "label": "Mu'tazila", "labels": ["Mu'tazila"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 6, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "term:nabi", "type": "term", "key": "nabi", "label": "nabi", "labels": ["nabi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:nabidh", "type": "term", "key": "nabidh", "label": "nabidh", "labels": ["nabidh"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 5, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:nafl", "type": "term", "key": "nafl", "label": "nafl (voluntary prayer)", "labels": ["nafl (voluntary prayer)", "nafl (voluntary worship)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:nafs", "type": "term", "key": "nafs", "label": "nafs (self)", "labels": ["nafs (self)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:najasa", "type": "term", "key": "najasa", "label": "najasa (impurity)", "labels": ["najasa (impurity)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:nasi", "type": "term", "key": "nasi", "label": "nasi (the intercalary month)", "labels": ["nasi (the intercalary month)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:naskh", "type": "term", "key": "naskh", "label": "naskh (abrogation)", "labels": ["naskh (abrogation)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:nawazil", "type": "term", "key": "nawazil", "label": "nawazil", "labels": ["nawazil"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:nazar", "type": "term", "key": "nazar", "label": "nazar (reasoned contemplation, in theology)", "labels": ["nazar (reasoned contemplation, in theology)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:neo-traditionalism", "type": "term", "key": "neo-traditionalism", "label": "neo-traditionalism", "labels": ["neo-traditionalism"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:neoplatonism", "type": "term", "key": "neoplatonism", "label": "neoplatonism", "labels": ["neoplatonism"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ney", "type": "term", "key": "ney", "label": "ney (reed flute)", "labels": ["ney (reed flute)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:nifas", "type": "term", "key": "nifas", "label": "nifas (postnatal bleeding)", "labels": ["nifas (postnatal bleeding)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:nikah", "type": "term", "key": "nikah", "label": "nikah", "labels": ["nikah"], "segments": 20, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 5, "2019": 6, "2020": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}}, {"id": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "type": "term", "key": "nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "label": "nikah bi-niyyat al-talaq (marriage with a hidden intention to divorce)", "labels": ["nikah bi-niyyat al-talaq (marriage with a hidden intention to divorce)", "nikah bi-niyyat al-talaq (marriage with the intention of divorce)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:nikah-misyar", "type": "term", "key": "nikah-misyar", "label": "nikah misyar [?]", "labels": ["nikah misyar [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:niqab", "type": "term", "key": "niqab", "label": "niqab (face veil)", "labels": ["niqab (face veil)", "niqab (worn by men against the sand)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:nisa", "type": "term", "key": "nisa", "label": "nisa (women)", "labels": ["nisa (women)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:nisab", "type": "term", "key": "nisab", "label": "nisab", "labels": ["nisab"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:nocebo-effect", "type": "term", "key": "nocebo-effect", "label": "nocebo effect", "labels": ["nocebo effect"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:non-propositional-faith", "type": "term", "key": "non-propositional-faith", "label": "non-propositional faith (Basil Mitchell)", "labels": ["non-propositional faith", "non-propositional faith (Basil Mitchell)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:nun-al-tawkid", "type": "term", "key": "nun-al-tawkid", "label": "nun al-tawkid (the emphatic nun)", "labels": ["nun al-tawkid (the emphatic nun)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:oppositional-defiant-disorder", "type": "term", "key": "oppositional-defiant-disorder", "label": "oppositional defiant disorder", "labels": ["oppositional defiant disorder"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:palimpsest", "type": "term", "key": "palimpsest", "label": "palimpsest (the Sana'a palimpsest)", "labels": ["palimpsest (the Sana'a palimpsest)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:palinopsia", "type": "term", "key": "palinopsia", "label": "palinopsia (persistent after-images)", "labels": ["palinopsia (persistent after-images)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:petra-thesis", "type": "term", "key": "petra-thesis", "label": "the Petra thesis", "labels": ["the Petra thesis"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:phantom-pregnancy", "type": "term", "key": "phantom-pregnancy", "label": "phantom pregnancy (pseudocyesis)", "labels": ["phantom pregnancy (pseudocyesis)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:pir", "type": "term", "key": "pir", "label": "pir (Sufi shaykh, subcontinent usage)", "labels": ["pir", "pir (Sufi shaykh, subcontinent usage)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:placebo-effect", "type": "term", "key": "placebo-effect", "label": "placebo effect", "labels": ["placebo effect"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:polygamy", "type": "term", "key": "polygamy", "label": "polygamy", "labels": ["polygamy", "polygamy (ta'addud al-zawjat)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:propinquity-effect", "type": "term", "key": "propinquity-effect", "label": "propinquity effect", "labels": ["propinquity effect"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:prosopagnosia", "type": "term", "key": "prosopagnosia", "label": "prosopagnosia (face blindness)", "labels": ["prosopagnosia (face blindness)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:psilocybin", "type": "term", "key": "psilocybin", "label": "psilocybin", "labels": ["psilocybin"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:qabd", "type": "term", "key": "qabd", "label": "qabd (folding the arms) [?]", "labels": ["qabd (folding the arms)", "qabd (folding the arms) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:qada", "type": "term", "key": "qada", "label": "qada (making up a missed fast)", "labels": ["qada (making up a missed fast)", "qada (making up a missed fast) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:qadar", "type": "term", "key": "qadar", "label": "qadar (destiny)", "labels": ["qadar (destiny)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:qadhf", "type": "term", "key": "qadhf", "label": "qadhf (accusation of zina)", "labels": ["qadhf (accusation of zina)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:qadi", "type": "term", "key": "qadi", "label": "qadi (judge)", "labels": ["qadi (judge)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:qati", "type": "term", "key": "qati", "label": "qat'i (conclusive)", "labels": ["qat'i (conclusive)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:qaza", "type": "term", "key": "qaza", "label": "qaza'", "labels": ["qaza'"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:qiblah", "type": "term", "key": "qiblah", "label": "qiblah", "labels": ["qiblah"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 4, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:qiraat", "type": "term", "key": "qiraat", "label": "qira'at (the seven or ten readings)", "labels": ["qira'at", "qira'at (the seven or ten readings)", "qira'at (the variant readings)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:qiyas", "type": "term", "key": "qiyas", "label": "qiyas (analogy)", "labels": ["qiyas (analogy)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:qunut", "type": "term", "key": "qunut", "label": "qunut (the supplication Ibn Mas'ud took for Quran)", "labels": ["qunut (the supplication Ibn Mas'ud took for Quran)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:qura", "type": "term", "key": "qura", "label": "qur'a (casting lots)", "labels": ["qur'a (casting lots)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:quran", "type": "term", "key": "quran", "label": "Quran (recitation)", "labels": ["Quran (recitation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:quranist", "type": "term", "key": "quranist", "label": "Quranist (Quran-only)", "labels": ["Quran-only (Quranist)", "Quranist (Quran-only)"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 5, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:rabb", "type": "term", "key": "rabb", "label": "rabb (lord, master)", "labels": ["rabb (lord, master)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:rada", "type": "term", "key": "rada", "label": "rada' (breastfeeding)", "labels": ["rada' (breastfeeding)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "type": "term", "key": "raf-al-yadayn", "label": "raf' al-yadayn (raising the hands in prayer)", "labels": ["raf' al-yadayn (raising the hands in prayer)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:rakah", "type": "term", "key": "rakah", "label": "rak'ah", "labels": ["rak'ah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:ramadan", "type": "term", "key": "ramadan", "label": "Ramadan", "labels": ["Ramadan"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:raqi", "type": "term", "key": "raqi", "label": "raqi (one who performs ruqya; exorcist)", "labels": ["raqi (one who performs ruqya; exorcist)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:rashidun", "type": "term", "key": "rashidun", "label": "al-Khulafa al-Rashidun (the rightly guided caliphs)", "labels": ["al-Khulafa al-Rashidun (the rightly guided caliphs)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:rasm-uthmani", "type": "term", "key": "rasm-uthmani", "label": "rasm (the orthography of the mushaf)", "labels": ["rasm (the orthography of the mushaf)", "rasm uthmani (the Uthmanic consonantal text)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:riba", "type": "term", "key": "riba", "label": "riba", "labels": ["riba"], "segments": 22, "recordings": 10, "years": {"2017": 13, "2018": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}}, {"id": "term:riba-al-fadl", "type": "term", "key": "riba-al-fadl", "label": "riba al-fadl (riba of excess)", "labels": ["riba al-fadl (riba of excess)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:riba-al-jahiliyyah", "type": "term", "key": "riba-al-jahiliyyah", "label": "riba al-jahiliyyah", "labels": ["riba al-jahiliyyah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:riba-al-nasia", "type": "term", "key": "riba-al-nasia", "label": "riba al-nasi'a (riba of delay)", "labels": ["riba al-nasi'a (riba of delay)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:riddah", "type": "term", "key": "riddah", "label": "riddah (apostasy)", "labels": ["riddah (apostasy)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:rijal", "type": "term", "key": "rijal", "label": "rijal (men)", "labels": ["rijal (men)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "type": "term", "key": "riwaya-bil-mana", "label": "riwaya bil-ma'na (transmission by meaning)", "labels": ["riwaya bil-ma'na (transmission by meaning)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:rizq", "type": "term", "key": "rizq", "label": "rizq (provision)", "labels": ["rizq (provision)", "rizq halal (lawful earnings)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:ruh", "type": "term", "key": "ruh", "label": "ruh (soul) as consciousness", "labels": ["ruh", "ruh (soul)", "ruh (soul) as consciousness"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "type": "term", "key": "ruh-al-qudus", "label": "ruh al-qudus (the Holy Spirit)", "labels": ["ruh al-qudus (the Holy Spirit)", "ruh al-qudus (the holy spirit)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:rukhsah", "type": "term", "key": "rukhsah", "label": "rukhsah (dispensation)", "labels": ["rukhsah (dispensation)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:ruqya", "type": "term", "key": "ruqya", "label": "ruqya (reading Quran over the afflicted)", "labels": ["ruqya", "ruqya (reading Quran over the afflicted)"], "segments": 10, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "term:ruya", "type": "term", "key": "ruya", "label": "ru'ya (dream vision)", "labels": ["ru'ya (dream vision)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:sadaqah", "type": "term", "key": "sadaqah", "label": "sadaqah", "labels": ["sadaqah"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:sadl", "type": "term", "key": "sadl", "label": "sadl (arms hanging)", "labels": ["sadl (arms hanging)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:sahaba", "type": "term", "key": "sahaba", "label": "sahaba (companions)", "labels": ["sahaba (companions)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:sahabah", "type": "term", "key": "sahabah", "label": "sahabah (companions)", "labels": ["Sahabah", "sahabah (companions)"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:sahih", "type": "term", "key": "sahih", "label": "sahih", "labels": ["sahih"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:sakinah", "type": "term", "key": "sakinah", "label": "sakinah", "labels": ["sakinah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:salaf", "type": "term", "key": "salaf", "label": "salaf", "labels": ["salaf", "the Salaf"], "segments": 18, "recordings": 16, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2, "2018": 4, "2019": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "term:salafi", "type": "term", "key": "salafi", "label": "Salafi", "labels": ["Salafi", "Salafi (Wahhabi)", "Salafi movement", "Wahhabi (Najdi)"], "segments": 76, "recordings": 43, "years": {"2018": 17, "2019": 11, "2020": 14, "2021": 32, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 76}}, {"id": "term:salah", "type": "term", "key": "salah", "label": "salah", "labels": ["salah"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 14, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "term:sama", "type": "term", "key": "sama", "label": "sama' (transmission by hearing)", "labels": ["sama' (transmission by hearing)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sana", "type": "term", "key": "sana", "label": "sana (year)", "labels": ["sana (year)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "type": "term", "key": "sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "label": "Sapir-Whorf hypothesis", "labels": ["Sapir-Whorf hypothesis"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sard-al-hadith", "type": "term", "key": "sard-al-hadith", "label": "sard al-hadith (rapid continuous narration)", "labels": ["sard al-hadith (rapid continuous narration)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sarih", "type": "term", "key": "sarih", "label": "sarih (explicit)", "labels": ["sarih (explicit)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sawm", "type": "term", "key": "sawm", "label": "sawm (fasting)", "labels": ["sawm (fasting)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:shafaah", "type": "term", "key": "shafaah", "label": "shafa'ah (intercession)", "labels": ["shafa'ah (intercession)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:shafaqa", "type": "term", "key": "shafaqa", "label": "shafaqa (compassion)", "labels": ["shafaqa (compassion)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:shafii", "type": "term", "key": "shafii", "label": "Shafi'i school", "labels": ["Shafi'i school"], "segments": 11, "recordings": 11, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "term:shahadat-al-sibyan", "type": "term", "key": "shahadat-al-sibyan", "label": "shahadat al-sibyan (testimony of children)", "labels": ["shahadat al-sibyan (testimony of children)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sharia", "type": "term", "key": "sharia", "label": "Sharia", "labels": ["Sharia"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:shariah", "type": "term", "key": "shariah", "label": "Sharia", "labels": ["Shari'ah", "Sharia"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:sharif", "type": "term", "key": "sharif", "label": "sharif", "labels": ["sharif"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:shaytan", "type": "term", "key": "shaytan", "label": "Shaytan", "labels": ["Iblis (Shaytan)", "Shaytan", "Shaytan (the devil)", "shaytan"], "segments": 17, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "term:shia", "type": "term", "key": "shia", "label": "Shia", "labels": ["Shia", "Twelver Shia"], "segments": 52, "recordings": 37, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 11, "2020": 16, "2021": 15, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 52}}, {"id": "term:shifa", "type": "term", "key": "shifa", "label": "shifa (cure)", "labels": ["shifa (cure)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:shirk", "type": "term", "key": "shirk", "label": "shirk", "labels": ["mushrik (polytheist), as used by the person he quotes", "shirk"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:shukr", "type": "term", "key": "shukr", "label": "shukr (gratitude)", "labels": ["shukr (gratitude)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:shura", "type": "term", "key": "shura", "label": "shura", "labels": ["shura"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sidrat-al-muntaha", "type": "term", "key": "sidrat-al-muntaha", "label": "Sidrat al-Muntaha (the lote tree)", "labels": ["Sidrat al-Muntaha (the lote tree)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sifat", "type": "term", "key": "sifat", "label": "sifat (the divine attributes)", "labels": ["sifat (the divine attributes)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:sihr", "type": "term", "key": "sihr", "label": "sihr (magic)", "labels": ["sihr (magic)"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:sijjin", "type": "term", "key": "sijjin", "label": "Sijjin", "labels": ["Sijjin"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "type": "term", "key": "silsilat-al-dhahab", "label": "silsilat al-dhahab (the golden chain)", "labels": ["silsilat al-dhahab (the golden chain)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:sirah", "type": "term", "key": "sirah", "label": "sirah", "labels": ["sirah"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:soma", "type": "term", "key": "soma", "label": "soma (haoma)", "labels": ["soma (haoma)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:stoned-ape-theory", "type": "term", "key": "stoned-ape-theory", "label": "stoned ape theory [?]", "labels": ["stoned ape theory [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:sufi", "type": "term", "key": "sufi", "label": "Sufi", "labels": ["Sufi", "Sufi wandering mystics"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 5, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:sujud", "type": "term", "key": "sujud", "label": "sujud", "labels": ["sujud"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:sujud-al-sahw", "type": "term", "key": "sujud-al-sahw", "label": "sujud al-sahw (prostration of forgetfulness)", "labels": ["sujud al-sahw (prostration of forgetfulness)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:sunnah", "type": "term", "key": "sunnah", "label": "sunnah", "labels": ["Sunnah", "proto-Sunnah (the early living tradition)", "sunnah", "sunnah (recommended act)"], "segments": 21, "recordings": 20, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 6, "2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "term:sunnat-allah", "type": "term", "key": "sunnat-allah", "label": "sunnat Allah (God's unchanging way)", "labels": ["sunnat Allah (God's unchanging way)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:sunni", "type": "term", "key": "sunni", "label": "Sunni", "labels": ["Sunni"], "segments": 14, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "term:tabiun", "type": "term", "key": "tabiun", "label": "tabi'un", "labels": ["Tabi'un", "tabi'un"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:tabut", "type": "term", "key": "tabut", "label": "tabut (the Ark)", "labels": ["tabut (the Ark)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tadlis", "type": "term", "key": "tadlis", "label": "tadlis (mudallis)", "labels": ["tadlis", "tadlis (mudallis)", "tadlis (not stating that one heard a report)"], "segments": 15, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 11, "2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "term:tafliya", "type": "term", "key": "tafliya", "label": "tafliya (going through the hair for lice)", "labels": ["tafliya (going through the hair for lice)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tafsir", "type": "term", "key": "tafsir", "label": "tafsir", "labels": ["tafsir"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tahajjud", "type": "term", "key": "tahajjud", "label": "tahajjud", "labels": ["tahajjud"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "type": "term", "key": "tahiyyat-al-masjid", "label": "tahiyyat al-masjid (prayer on entering the mosque)", "labels": ["tahiyyat al-masjid (prayer on entering the mosque)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tajsim", "type": "term", "key": "tajsim", "label": "tajsim (anthropomorphism)", "labels": ["tajsim (anthropomorphism)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:takbir", "type": "term", "key": "takbir", "label": "takbir", "labels": ["takbir"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:takfir", "type": "term", "key": "takfir", "label": "takfir", "labels": ["takfir"], "segments": 16, "recordings": 9, "years": {"2015": 2, "2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}}, {"id": "term:taklif", "type": "term", "key": "taklif", "label": "taklif", "labels": ["taklif"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:talaq", "type": "term", "key": "talaq", "label": "talaq", "labels": ["talaq", "talaq (conditional divorce oaths)", "talaq (divorce)", "triple talaq"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 7, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:taqlid", "type": "term", "key": "taqlid", "label": "taqlid", "labels": ["taqlid", "taqlid (blind following)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:taqwa", "type": "term", "key": "taqwa", "label": "taqwa", "labels": ["taqwa"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:tarawih", "type": "term", "key": "tarawih", "label": "tarawih", "labels": ["tarawih"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:tariqah", "type": "term", "key": "tariqah", "label": "tariqah (Sufi order)", "labels": ["tariqa (Sufi order)", "tariqah (Sufi order)"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:tasawwuf", "type": "term", "key": "tasawwuf", "label": "tasawwuf", "labels": ["tasawwuf"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:tashahhud", "type": "term", "key": "tashahhud", "label": "tashahhud", "labels": ["tashahhud"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tawaf", "type": "term", "key": "tawaf", "label": "tawaf", "labels": ["tawaf"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tawakkul", "type": "term", "key": "tawakkul", "label": "tawakkul (reliance on God)", "labels": ["tawakkul (reliance on God)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tawbah", "type": "term", "key": "tawbah", "label": "tawbah (repentance)", "labels": ["tawbah (repentance)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tawhid", "type": "term", "key": "tawhid", "label": "tawhid", "labels": ["tawhid", "tawhid ('the land of tawhid')"], "segments": 8, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 6, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "term:tawiz", "type": "term", "key": "tawiz", "label": "ta'wiz (amulet) [?]", "labels": ["ta'wiz (amulet) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:tayammum", "type": "term", "key": "tayammum", "label": "tayammum", "labels": ["tayammum"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tayf", "type": "term", "key": "tayf", "label": "tayf (the night apparition of the beloved) [?]", "labels": ["tayf (the night apparition of the beloved) [?]"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:thawb", "type": "term", "key": "thawb", "label": "thawb", "labels": ["thawb"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:tiyara", "type": "term", "key": "tiyara", "label": "tiyara (belief in omens)", "labels": ["tiyara (belief in omens)", "tiyara (belief in omens) [?]"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:trinity", "type": "term", "key": "trinity", "label": "the Trinity", "labels": ["the Trinity"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:twelve-imams", "type": "term", "key": "twelve-imams", "label": "the twelve imams", "labels": ["the twelve imams"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:two-state-solution", "type": "term", "key": "two-state-solution", "label": "two-state solution", "labels": ["two-state solution"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:udhiyah", "type": "term", "key": "udhiyah", "label": "udhiyah (qurbani)", "labels": ["udhiyah (qurbani)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:ulama", "type": "term", "key": "ulama", "label": "ulama", "labels": ["ulama"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:umm-al-qura", "type": "term", "key": "umm-al-qura", "label": "Umm al-Qura (mother of settlements)", "labels": ["Umm al-Qura (mother of settlements)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:umrah", "type": "term", "key": "umrah", "label": "'umrah", "labels": ["'umrah"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:urf", "type": "term", "key": "urf", "label": "urfi marriage (marriage by custom)", "labels": ["urf (custom)", "urfi marriage (marriage by custom)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "type": "term", "key": "usul-al-fiqh", "label": "usul al-fiqh", "labels": ["usul al-fiqh"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:virgin-birth", "type": "term", "key": "virgin-birth", "label": "the virgin birth", "labels": ["the virgin birth"], "segments": 5, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "term:wahhabi", "type": "term", "key": "wahhabi", "label": "Wahhabi", "labels": ["Wahhabi"], "segments": 19, "recordings": 12, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 8, "2020": 3, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "term:wahi", "type": "term", "key": "wahi", "label": "wahi (revelation)", "labels": ["wahi (revelation)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:wahy", "type": "term", "key": "wahy", "label": "wahy (revelation)", "labels": ["wahy (revelation)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:wajib", "type": "term", "key": "wajib", "label": "wajib", "labels": ["wajib"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:wali", "type": "term", "key": "wali", "label": "wali (saint)", "labels": ["wali (marriage guardian)", "wali (saint)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:waqf", "type": "term", "key": "waqf", "label": "waqf (endowment)", "labels": ["waqf (endowment)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:waswasa", "type": "term", "key": "waswasa", "label": "waswasa (whispering)", "labels": ["waswasa (whispering)"], "segments": 3, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "term:wijada", "type": "term", "key": "wijada", "label": "wijada (a found manuscript)", "labels": ["wijada (a found manuscript)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:wudu", "type": "term", "key": "wudu", "label": "wudu", "labels": ["wudu"], "segments": 9, "recordings": 8, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 5, "2022": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "term:yahweh", "type": "term", "key": "yahweh", "label": "Yahweh", "labels": ["Yahweh"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "type": "term", "key": "yajuj-and-majuj", "label": "Yajuj and Majuj", "labels": ["Ya'juj and Ma'juj (Gog and Magog)", "Yajuj and Majuj"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "type": "term", "key": "yajuj-wa-majuj", "label": "Ya'juj and Ma'juj (Gog and Magog)", "labels": ["Ya'juj and Ma'juj (Gog and Magog)"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:yaqin", "type": "term", "key": "yaqin", "label": "yaqin (certainty)", "labels": ["yaqin (certainty)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:yataarrad", "type": "term", "key": "yataarrad", "label": "yata'arrad (to deal with, to be exposed to)", "labels": ["yata'arrad (to deal with, to be exposed to)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zahir-al-riwaya", "type": "term", "key": "zahir-al-riwaya", "label": "zahir al-riwaya (the six mother texts of the Hanafi madhhab)", "labels": ["zahir al-riwaya (the six mother texts of the Hanafi madhhab)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zahiri", "type": "term", "key": "zahiri", "label": "Zahiri school", "labels": ["Zahiri school"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zakat", "type": "term", "key": "zakat", "label": "zakat", "labels": ["zakah", "zakat"], "segments": 7, "recordings": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "term:zakat-al-fitr", "type": "term", "key": "zakat-al-fitr", "label": "zakat al-fitr", "labels": ["zakat al-fitr"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zamzam", "type": "term", "key": "zamzam", "label": "Zamzam", "labels": ["Zamzam"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zanni", "type": "term", "key": "zanni", "label": "zanni (probable)", "labels": ["zanni (probable)"], "segments": 2, "recordings": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "term:zaqqum", "type": "term", "key": "zaqqum", "label": "zaqqum (the tree of Jahannam)", "labels": ["zaqqum (the tree of Jahannam)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zaydi", "type": "term", "key": "zaydi", "label": "Zaydi", "labels": ["Zaydi"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zifaf", "type": "term", "key": "zifaf", "label": "zifaf (the wedding night)", "labels": ["zifaf (the wedding night)"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zina", "type": "term", "key": "zina", "label": "zina", "labels": ["zina"], "segments": 6, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "term:zindiq", "type": "term", "key": "zindiq", "label": "zindiq", "labels": ["zindiq", "zindiq (pl. zanadiqa)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "term:zoroastrianism", "type": "term", "key": "zoroastrianism", "label": "Zoroastrianism", "labels": ["Zoroastrianism"], "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "term:zuhd", "type": "term", "key": "zuhd", "label": "zuhd (asceticism)", "labels": ["zuhd", "zuhd (asceticism)"], "segments": 4, "recordings": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "type": "recording", "key": "--OJasWltLU", "label": "Explanation: Are uneven (such as faded) haircuts haram?", "date": "20150505", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--OJasWltLU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "type": "recording", "key": "--PntsaR8ck", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #202| Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210216", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--PntsaR8ck", "tier": "machine", "segments": 57, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 57}, "tiers": {"machine": 57}}, {"id": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "type": "recording", "key": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "label": "A Reply to Dan Gibson: \"Why The Early Qiblas Faced Petra?\" | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191217", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JYtKJ9z1cw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "type": "recording", "key": "-lbZ11113SU", "label": "How to memorise the Quran- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20140118", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lbZ11113SU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "type": "recording", "key": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "label": "Between Authenticity & Paganism: The Black Stone and Safa & Marwa -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190708", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oPJEZ12NQ8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "type": "recording", "key": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "label": "Q: Can I brush my teeth with toothpaste whilst Fasting? Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170517", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0BOmiPpDvgo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "type": "recording", "key": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "label": "The Beard in Islam & Arab Culture | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191217", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ln_viR6LnI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "type": "recording", "key": "0oVIsExS4cA", "label": "Age of Aisha (ra)- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170111", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0oVIsExS4cA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 18, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 18}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "recording:143df7icoYU", "type": "recording", "key": "143df7icoYU", "label": "Is the Quran corrupted? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190914", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=143df7icoYU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "type": "recording", "key": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "label": "What Are You Thoughts About The Channel Marvelous Quran? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220219", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ybpO86BP8Y", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "type": "recording", "key": "1zgHntbMPis", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #197 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210112", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zgHntbMPis", "tier": "machine", "segments": 43, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 43}, "tiers": {"machine": 43}}, {"id": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "type": "recording", "key": "2AxJjFrnD20", "label": "Did Jesus (a.s.) Speak in the Cradle? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190223", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AxJjFrnD20", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:2EnVV2NUehw", "type": "recording", "key": "2EnVV2NUehw", "label": "Funny Fatwa: Football is more haram the gambling & alcohol | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201216", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EnVV2NUehw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "type": "recording", "key": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "label": "Can we use nicotine packs or smoke/vape while fasting? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190525", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HeZQyp_S4M", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "type": "recording", "key": "2cei2vnTjes", "label": "My Thoughts on Sheikh Imran Hosein | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191109", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cei2vnTjes", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "type": "recording", "key": "2kQbnCU09YM", "label": "Mut'ah From The Sunni Point Of View Today? | Differing Opinions | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220319", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2kQbnCU09YM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "type": "recording", "key": "31RnFwtYbwU", "label": "Mufti's engagements with the Shia | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190802", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31RnFwtYbwU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "type": "recording", "key": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "label": "My thoughts on Dan Gibson's Petra research | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190719", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Ux_bLoLSf8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "type": "recording", "key": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "label": "Intoxicants: Imam Abu Hanifa vs the rest | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210305", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rPUgpmWEp0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "type": "recording", "key": "3tQUslWseTo", "label": "Moon Sighting issues in the UK- Should we follow Saudi Arabia? Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170517", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tQUslWseTo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:47ghxXHtlN8", "type": "recording", "key": "47ghxXHtlN8", "label": "Why I look & dress the way I do? - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180308", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47ghxXHtlN8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "type": "recording", "key": "49_S1uD7UTk", "label": "Hypocrisy of scholars regarding awrah of free women & slave women | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210509", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=49_S1uD7UTk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "type": "recording", "key": "4PESNMaHO20", "label": "What Islam says about '72 Virgins' in Paradise -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181008", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PESNMaHO20", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "type": "recording", "key": "4URwiwu3X7o", "label": "Why criticize Bukhari but not the Muwatta of Imam Malik? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201021", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4URwiwu3X7o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "type": "recording", "key": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "label": "Response to Abdullah al Andalusi", "date": "20180903", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4WUwTJQAmx0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "type": "recording", "key": "51Qevhjqnt4", "label": "Fadak between Fatima (r) & Abu Bakr (r) Detailed Overview | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200228", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51Qevhjqnt4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "type": "recording", "key": "5is8qPu5lLU", "label": "Sex Slaves: Concubines and Collective Consciousness -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200428", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5is8qPu5lLU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "type": "recording", "key": "5phyGJpJMMw", "label": "Hadith Analysis: Does drinking alcohol or doing drugs invalidate your prayer or fast for 40 days?", "date": "20190524", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5phyGJpJMMw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "type": "recording", "key": "626JfCE_j_8", "label": "Sheikh Asrar Was In Hospital | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20211129", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=626JfCE_j_8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "type": "recording", "key": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "label": "Propaganda against Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170929", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_dmOJl-_bI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 13, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "type": "recording", "key": "6aPj1fuMN24", "label": "There is no jinn possession in Islam (reply to Sh Omar Suleiman's video) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201121", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aPj1fuMN24", "tier": "machine", "segments": 10, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "type": "recording", "key": "7CYLT19GX5k", "label": "A Reply to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181020", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CYLT19GX5k", "tier": "machine", "segments": 15, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "type": "recording", "key": "7EER9UKa1eA", "label": "Responding to Qadiani Trolls | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200331", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EER9UKa1eA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "type": "recording", "key": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "label": "Reply to Sunni (Wahhabi) Defence Pt. IV -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180803", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IMg-l3vbcY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "type": "recording", "key": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "label": "Sajdah Mark on Forehead | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191011", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7NAjZrtcNZ0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "type": "recording", "key": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "label": "Psychedelics are NOT haram | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201017", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7SkyPhQZdY8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 8, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "type": "recording", "key": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "label": "Insights to a personal journey: An interview with Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20140702", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UXKLQH8-ig", "tier": "machine", "segments": 8, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "type": "recording", "key": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "label": "Jinn Possessions: Myth and Reality in Islam by Sh. Akram Nadwi & Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170920", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7z8yu8Kr83Y", "tier": "machine", "segments": 25, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 25}, "tiers": {"machine": 25}}, {"id": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "type": "recording", "key": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "label": "Ruling on DMT | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200114", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JX1u0qQYAE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "type": "recording", "key": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "label": "Reply to Sunni (Wahhabi) Defence Pt.I -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180221", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U9-ASlyrzE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "type": "recording", "key": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #210 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210413", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XuHMCz2N3U", "tier": "machine", "segments": 50, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 50}, "tiers": {"machine": 50}}, {"id": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "type": "recording", "key": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "label": "Saudi Arabia & Sahih Al-Bukhari | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210419", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zY0NDQvL2U", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "type": "recording", "key": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "label": "Sahih hadith criteria: Cannot go against reason | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201009", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cYDToRoy7Q", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "type": "recording", "key": "9kK28jhdcA8", "label": "Zakir Naik - New revelations on masturbation | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201211", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9kK28jhdcA8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "type": "recording", "key": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "label": "Do I need to follow a Madhhab?- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20140312", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tHI3gcIiCk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "type": "recording", "key": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "label": "On Shaykh Yasir Qadhi \"How not to do controversy!\" | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200617", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATcN8aUo8oc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "type": "recording", "key": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "label": "In Depth: Is Music allowed in Islam? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190918", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AXXuB9lxFoc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 12, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "type": "recording", "key": "AZJBapbSjDo", "label": "Thoughts on Mufti Menk | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191018", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZJBapbSjDo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "type": "recording", "key": "AhTy-xxH79g", "label": "Can we criticise the companions of the Prophet (s) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190919", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhTy-xxH79g", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "type": "recording", "key": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "label": "Banning Mutah? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191104", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwhVA-P9rTo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "type": "recording", "key": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "label": "A Brief Foreword @ My Mum's Khatm - Lessons from Life & Death - Ghamkol Mosque", "date": "20230602", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwxuMQnPbw0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "type": "recording", "key": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "label": "A response to Hamza Maqbool (Deobandi/Maliki) - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180228", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BC8qsIOFAwE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ", "type": "recording", "key": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "label": "Thoughts on Shaykh Hamza Yusuf | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201105", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPBiF_hAKgQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "type": "recording", "key": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "label": "Why converting the Hagia Sophia to a mosque is a mistake | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200716", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bgsfy-UmSA4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "type": "recording", "key": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "label": "How to Pray Salah According to the Maliki Madhhab- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170402", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiN9UQPOpMA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 13, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "recording:C-9MCspQqwE", "type": "recording", "key": "C-9MCspQqwE", "label": "The Secret To Abundance - Quranic Gems - #Shorts #Perspective #MALM", "date": "20240305", "kind": "short", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-9MCspQqwE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "type": "recording", "key": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "label": "5 MEO DMT \"The God Molecule\" #Shorts #MALM", "date": "20210830", "kind": "short", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIPm_CHV0Kw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo", "type": "recording", "key": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "label": "Reply to Sheikh Assim on Having Non-Muslim Friend | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210310", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnwAjt1i9Bo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "type": "recording", "key": "Cz26by1mMns", "label": "Reply to Sunni (Wahhabi) Defence Pt. III -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180708", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cz26by1mMns", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "type": "recording", "key": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "label": "The War-Wager Hadith Paradox (Debunking Dogmatism) -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180920", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAVFpkd1ECo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:DYnuJS-DTMU", "type": "recording", "key": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "label": "Thoughts on Muawiyah? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210213", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYnuJS-DTMU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "type": "recording", "key": "DhKc0LO1e18", "label": "Not Praying, The Bigger Sin? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20221216", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhKc0LO1e18", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "type": "recording", "key": "DnueaKQQZXY", "label": "Engineer Muhammad Mirza's Methods | Hadith Vs Sunnah | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230206", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnueaKQQZXY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "type": "recording", "key": "ETWstnCMgZA", "label": "Pakistan arresting Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200529", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETWstnCMgZA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "type": "recording", "key": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "label": "Don't let people bully you into beliefs | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190821", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWmBN7JV9Dk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "type": "recording", "key": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "label": "Drinking Camel Urine? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200216", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcabHd3Hf6U", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "type": "recording", "key": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "label": "What is the Beast of the Earth? What did Ibn Aashour really say? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180529", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoQ_mXafx5o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "type": "recording", "key": "FNtMxwadPAc", "label": "Memoirs of a Mufti: Deceitful Imams Disrespecting Islam -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180831", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNtMxwadPAc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "type": "recording", "key": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "label": "Birth Of Islamic Orthodoxy And Institutionalisation | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230213", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_4jnUA3ARQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:Fiq59Zcj9KU", "type": "recording", "key": "Fiq59Zcj9KU", "label": "Inappropriate Names | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191106", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fiq59Zcj9KU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Fko_FZwwNbA", "type": "recording", "key": "Fko_FZwwNbA", "label": "Take A Chance On Yourself #Shorts #Perspective #MALM", "date": "20240304", "kind": "short", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fko_FZwwNbA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "type": "recording", "key": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "label": "The differences between the Ashari & Athari School | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191105", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fz6mtRfzUDI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "type": "recording", "key": "G0iGieTCklk", "label": "If you have missed prayers? & not to obsess over punishments - Mufti Abu Layth Al-Maliki", "date": "20180213", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0iGieTCklk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "type": "recording", "key": "GAm6NYtozDg", "label": "Maulana Tariq Jamil on Media, Modesty & Women | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200428", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAm6NYtozDg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "type": "recording", "key": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "label": "Who is Uzair in the Quran? Ezra or Osiris? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191229", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdlCbTkYHgM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "type": "recording", "key": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "label": "Hadith on The Moon Splitting | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191018", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Grh2ZU4awQI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:H4IXL17jyEU", "type": "recording", "key": "H4IXL17jyEU", "label": "How NOT to respond to Covid-19 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200330", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4IXL17jyEU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "type": "recording", "key": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "label": "Hadith Analysis: Why men and women CAN shake hands -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180504", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H8SXk-2-W-4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "type": "recording", "key": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "label": "Discussion on Miracles: A fallacy against God | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201013", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIU1GJSzg1E", "tier": "machine", "segments": 14, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "type": "recording", "key": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "label": "Hypocrisy in the Sunni Hadith Methodology | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210215", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLHgB2tyt-c", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "type": "recording", "key": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #198 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210119", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hv-BlBVTr4M", "tier": "machine", "segments": 41, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 41}, "tiers": {"machine": 41}}, {"id": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "type": "recording", "key": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "label": "\"I don't want to pray salah\" | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200525", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXSyLbrg6A0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "type": "recording", "key": "IijbMTxUEOw", "label": "BukhariGate Part 2: Sahih Bukhari is NOT so Sahih -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180901", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IijbMTxUEOw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 10, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "type": "recording", "key": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "label": "Why Ibn Taymiyyah was in jail? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210112", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9NB1eLQ56Y", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:JP-vZ7g-UW0", "type": "recording", "key": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "label": "Reply to Mufti Abdurrahman Ibn Yusuf on Ear Piercing | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210310", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JP-vZ7g-UW0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "type": "recording", "key": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "label": "Should women wear the Niqab? - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180308", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQMaIJJJVoI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "type": "recording", "key": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "label": "In Depth: The Sanaʽa Manuscript -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190301", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6fAZ7xW53Y", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:K8VL17CEZW0", "type": "recording", "key": "K8VL17CEZW0", "label": "Maulana Limbada & Coronavirus Dream | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200322", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8VL17CEZW0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "type": "recording", "key": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #179 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200824", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KWmtt2TQAO0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 40, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 40}, "tiers": {"machine": 40}}, {"id": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "type": "recording", "key": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "label": "Ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan Misquoting Hadith & Invite Challenge | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210222", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrIGi3OmJD4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "type": "recording", "key": "KsQKsrXndNw", "label": "Shaykh Dr. Shabir Ally | Juxtaposing the Quran, Jumbling Aisha's age & Jinn Possession | MindTrap#16", "date": "20200422", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KsQKsrXndNw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 23, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 23}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "type": "recording", "key": "KuSevqg0low", "label": "Daniel Haqiqatjou and Women praying in the Wardrobe -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190504", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuSevqg0low", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "type": "recording", "key": "LJpCQXiII98", "label": "Does the Quran say how many Prayers? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190724", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJpCQXiII98", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "type": "recording", "key": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "label": "Jinn: Myth and Reality in Islam by Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180415", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LeXzvtf9YGA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 17, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 17}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "recording:LnOAQLLkvNo", "type": "recording", "key": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "label": "Who's behind Bro Hajji's account? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210108", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnOAQLLkvNo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "type": "recording", "key": "LyZCk5dygJk", "label": "Can Hudood Punishments change? Mufti Abu Layth & Shaykh Akram Nadwi", "date": "20170914", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyZCk5dygJk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "type": "recording", "key": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "label": "Israel's war crimes, UAE ties & possible solutions? (full context) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210517", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6R6PNmTG0w", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "type": "recording", "key": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "label": "Reply to Sunni (Wahhabi) Defence Pt. II -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180708", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGz8JO6O0f4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "type": "recording", "key": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "label": "PRELUDE: Why There Is NO 2nd Coming Of Jesus (as) In Islam- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180313", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHzYu3BKBWE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 41, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 41}, "tiers": {"machine": 41}}, {"id": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "type": "recording", "key": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "label": "Genetics and marrying relatives | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200308", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIVZcdJxC2o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "type": "recording", "key": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "label": "Sunni & Shia differences on Mutah, theological or political? - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180721", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3SO0Hmtatc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:OCiapHX4cGI", "type": "recording", "key": "OCiapHX4cGI", "label": "Old me? Why did I change? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200620", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCiapHX4cGI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "type": "recording", "key": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "label": "Br Muhammad MFG | Quranist Only Belief - A Dialogue | MindTrap #82 - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20251018", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONzjD7XMDhE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 32, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2025": 32}, "tiers": {"machine": 32}}, {"id": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "type": "recording", "key": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "label": "Fatwa on Tattoos - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180305", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Opl3bF6wzAs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "type": "recording", "key": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "label": "A Reply to Shaykh Muhammad Al-Yaqoubi on Sahih Al-Bukhari| Mufti Abu layth", "date": "20190821", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtQqc3K4HWA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 8, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}}, {"id": "recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4", "type": "recording", "key": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "label": "Can we eat non halal burgers? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210126", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4QG7Z3O8k4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "type": "recording", "key": "PhrSS-NiR30", "label": "Why don't sunni imams transmit from Imam Jafar? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201206", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PhrSS-NiR30", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "type": "recording", "key": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "label": "Magic: Myth and Reality in Islam by Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180415", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiFqxkWyrwg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "type": "recording", "key": "PkP3itoSKJc", "label": "Did the Staff of Moses (AS) really turn into a snake? - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180420", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkP3itoSKJc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "type": "recording", "key": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "label": "Caller runs off from the debate - Will Jesus Return | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210214", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QAXeuR-UXvo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "type": "recording", "key": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "label": "Islam in the 21st Century | Mufti Abu Layth | Ha Meem Foundation", "date": "20161221", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QBvWBHOIzW4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 10, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "type": "recording", "key": "R7s1DcClcwU", "label": "Reply to Abu Ibraheem (Salafi)- By Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180102", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7s1DcClcwU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "type": "recording", "key": "RJe0SL67QzM", "label": "Neanderthals, Sapiens & Adam (a.s.) - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181110", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJe0SL67QzM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "type": "recording", "key": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "label": "Hadiths on Prophetic Miracles and Responding to Claims of Blasphemy - Mufti Abu Layth al Maliki", "date": "20180209", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RM4jHsWJ_uM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "type": "recording", "key": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "label": "Imam Abu Hanifa and The Young Drunkard | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20150307", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNWtaWHPx3A", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "type": "recording", "key": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "label": "A Reply to Abdullah Sameer's Allegation: The Quran Teaches Paedophilia | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190725", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-X4Lyns2vE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "type": "recording", "key": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "label": "Salman Rushdie & The Satanic Verses | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220819", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0pHQRNJjBY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 21, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}}, {"id": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "type": "recording", "key": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "label": "Hadith Analysis: Did the Prophet ﷺ Refer to Women as Lacking Intellect and Faith?", "date": "20180729", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFZo7S3T_8o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "type": "recording", "key": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "label": "Why Tattoos are NOT Haram by Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180503", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPH6TdXXLh4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "type": "recording", "key": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "label": "Reply to Yasir Qadhi's False Claims on 2nd Coming of Jesus | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210314", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TR3NSX3UFy8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 30, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 30}, "tiers": {"machine": 30}}, {"id": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "type": "recording", "key": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth #176   *Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted!* 🤣", "date": "20200804", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TR4-gh0qEZ4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 31, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 31}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}}, {"id": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "type": "recording", "key": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "label": "Verse in Surah Al-Nur about the Hijab | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191103", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRR4o2JZIZc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:TgaNlc0x_iI", "type": "recording", "key": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "label": "Thoughts on Shaykh Dedew Al-Shanqiti | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210316", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgaNlc0x_iI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "type": "recording", "key": "TincZqdQpgs", "label": "Arabization of Indo-Pak Islam | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191219", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TincZqdQpgs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "type": "recording", "key": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "label": "Why did I Choose Maliki Fiqh? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190322", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiXtl3PQP-Q", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "type": "recording", "key": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "label": "The Role Of Reason In Religion - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180409", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UuLDZkLvxvo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 19, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 19}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}}, {"id": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "type": "recording", "key": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "label": "Thoughts on Ibadism | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210316", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRYy1_gzEUs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "type": "recording", "key": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "label": "Unanswered Questions- An interview with Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20150406", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZRrlX3lIVk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 15, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}}, {"id": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "type": "recording", "key": "VhqVM47pNS0", "label": "The Legendary Imam Malik Ibn Anas | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230310", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhqVM47pNS0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 14, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}}, {"id": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "type": "recording", "key": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "label": "Apostasy has NO punishment in Islam: A Qur'an & Sunnah Analysis by Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180510", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyAwDWTHPa4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 13, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "type": "recording", "key": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "label": "Shaykh Aslam & Sectarian Jealousy of the Molvis | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210427", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCgxQDwCHKs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "type": "recording", "key": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "label": "Farid Gangu Teli leaking Yasir Qadhi's emails | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200819", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WDD_GyzI9Dg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "type": "recording", "key": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "label": "Innovation in Islam? | Mufti Abu Layth alMaliki", "date": "20150303", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIrT3DXSvd8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "type": "recording", "key": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "label": "The Maulana/Madrassa crisis & Why my views appear to be different? - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180215", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl7wIKke16Q", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "type": "recording", "key": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "label": "Why isn't Mufti from the Mu'tazilah? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210315", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmzC28PLYSQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "type": "recording", "key": "WnchZwuZtf4", "label": "Is urinating whilst standing allowed? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190917", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WnchZwuZtf4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "type": "recording", "key": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "label": "Are tattoos haram? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201001", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoYX5hIFSVg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "type": "recording", "key": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "label": "The Prophet Noah (a.s.)  Did Not Live for 950 Years -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180811", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wpqa8rxaI-U", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "type": "recording", "key": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "label": "Thoughts on Farhan Al-Maliki from Saudi Arabia? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200609", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X27ZZBCSEyg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "type": "recording", "key": "X6SfFYRljeY", "label": "BukhariGate Part 1: Sahih Bukhari is NOT so Sahih -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180830", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X6SfFYRljeY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 17, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 17}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}}, {"id": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "type": "recording", "key": "XttbK-raL6A", "label": "Messiah, Masri & Misquotations | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210202", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XttbK-raL6A", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "type": "recording", "key": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "label": "Umm Abdullah & Hasanat Scandal | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190801", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPFQpHdSbGg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "type": "recording", "key": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "label": "The Evil Eye has no reality in Islam - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180213", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yd3ehW0VTls", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "type": "recording", "key": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "label": "Dr Javad T. Hashmi | Axis of Morality & Archetypal Myths in the Quran | MindTrap 46 |Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201211", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAsz48lX_WI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 36, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 36}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "type": "recording", "key": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "label": "Reflections on Sh. Hassan Ali's video of Jesus Christ's 2nd coming - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180401", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMSmkLdEgSo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "type": "recording", "key": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "label": "Giving rulings based on minority opinions- Shaykh Akram Nadwi & Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170906", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZOo6W9bfn7I", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "type": "recording", "key": "ZmIrskjob4o", "label": "Prof. Edip Yuksel | Rejecting Hadith, Rashad Khalifa & Realizing '19' | MindTrap with Mufti #27", "date": "20200626", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmIrskjob4o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 36, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 36}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "type": "recording", "key": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "label": "Zina, Marriage and Relationships - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180305", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zs1rLN2Djss", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "type": "recording", "key": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "label": "A Response to Yasir Qadhi: \"Islam was spread by the sword\" | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191216", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_dSMPIAR0BM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "type": "recording", "key": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "label": "Quranist/Quran-Only Muslims?  Hadith Relativists Vs Hadith Absolutists | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20211120", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "type": "recording", "key": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "label": "Was Prophet Yunus (a.s.) Swallowed by a Whale? Is that Possible in Nature? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180526", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-CIW2-K4Y0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "type": "recording", "key": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "label": "False Hadith: Abu Huraira & the Thieving Devil who taught us Islam", "date": "20180812", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3i0x1A5CFw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "type": "recording", "key": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth 173", "date": "20200714", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6H5lYE4MN8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 42, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 42}, "tiers": {"machine": 42}}, {"id": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "type": "recording", "key": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "label": "Cartoons of The Prophet & Boycotting France | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201029", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNLFdEEOH5Y", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "type": "recording", "key": "awbO9rHPvpU", "label": "Do I have to wear my trousers above my ankles? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20150320", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awbO9rHPvpU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "type": "recording", "key": "b1OOltqtPTw", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #204 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210302", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1OOltqtPTw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 45, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 45}, "tiers": {"machine": 45}}, {"id": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "type": "recording", "key": "bO72u9ThuK8", "label": "On Women Wearing Perfume: Debunking Weak and Blasphemous Hadith -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180504", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bO72u9ThuK8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "type": "recording", "key": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "label": "Q: Is Taraweeh 8 or 20 Raka'at? Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170517", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bU0XXOk5oIU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:bY3zp-4lYFI", "type": "recording", "key": "bY3zp-4lYFI", "label": "Mufti's thoughts on Mufti Muhammad ibn Munir? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201012", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bY3zp-4lYFI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "type": "recording", "key": "c8fjy8MceZM", "label": "Can a Nikah with a Non-Muslim be valid? - Mufti Abu Layth Al-Maliki", "date": "20190510", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8fjy8MceZM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "type": "recording", "key": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "label": "A reply to Asadulah Al-Andalusi on the age of Aisha (r) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190919", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9vke9Rpq9o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "type": "recording", "key": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "label": "Dr Edip Yuksel & the Quran only methodology | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200828", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAjsGNs9EiY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:cHVPqWZ6BeE", "type": "recording", "key": "cHVPqWZ6BeE", "label": "A Fate Worse Than Death - #Shorts #Perspective #MALM", "date": "20240228", "kind": "short", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHVPqWZ6BeE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "type": "recording", "key": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "label": "Shaykh Omar Suleiman & the Yaqeen Institutes On Age of Aisha (r.a.) -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181130", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHyxRI7Trnk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "type": "recording", "key": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "label": "A Reply To Zakaullah Saleem (Salafi)- By Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180114", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKWRLHtBYgo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "type": "recording", "key": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "label": "Debate challenge to any salafi scholar on aqeedah | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201117", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cV8ZMcMyPk0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "type": "recording", "key": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "label": "Does the Quran Mention a Virgin Birth for Jesus (a.s.)? - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181025", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVGwFnbQv0Q", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "type": "recording", "key": "d95_pYj6NiA", "label": "Cutting-edge Perspective: Trimming the beard in Islam (pt 1)- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20140412", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95_pYj6NiA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "type": "recording", "key": "dECxAg9D9g8", "label": "A Reply to False Messiahs: Mirza Ghulam Qadiani! -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190115", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dECxAg9D9g8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "type": "recording", "key": "dROSEctL_tQ", "label": "The Story Explained: Did Musa & Khidr (a.s.) Kill a Child?  -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181224", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dROSEctL_tQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "type": "recording", "key": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "label": "The Story of Safiyya: the Prophet's Jewish wife -Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180221", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpeR6Y4MGwA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "type": "recording", "key": "e6jWtFf8smw", "label": "The Quran and Evolution -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181206", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6jWtFf8smw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "type": "recording", "key": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "label": "Why are homosexual activities forbidden? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190802", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJS0IBhhPg0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "type": "recording", "key": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "label": "Masala Segment: Mufti Abdul Qavi & Alcohol | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200629", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eR1bDjDv0l0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "type": "recording", "key": "eo90sV4JVHo", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #196 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210105", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eo90sV4JVHo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 35, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 35}, "tiers": {"machine": 35}}, {"id": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "type": "recording", "key": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #199 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210126", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eoKcNwGGIBA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 36, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 36}, "tiers": {"machine": 36}}, {"id": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "type": "recording", "key": "f2BcGWatU5g", "label": "Dr. Shehzad Saleem | the Preservation of the Quran & the Problem of Qira'at | MindTrap with Mufti#26", "date": "20200619", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2BcGWatU5g", "tier": "machine", "segments": 25, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 25}, "tiers": {"machine": 25}}, {"id": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "type": "recording", "key": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "label": "Why it is Not Haram for Men to Wear Gold or Silk -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180710", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4R0NXnYmpc", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "type": "recording", "key": "foIzotT_sog", "label": "Why do the salafis struggle with the Muwatta? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200823", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foIzotT_sog", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "type": "recording", "key": "g57BdMdAUKM", "label": "Thoughts on Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahab? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200419", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g57BdMdAUKM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "type": "recording", "key": "gCid83kRA2I", "label": "False Hadith: The Prophet ﷺ Was Poisoned Before He Died", "date": "20180917", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gCid83kRA2I", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "type": "recording", "key": "gV69XFzFuEk", "label": "Can Women  Pray in Bikinis? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190304", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gV69XFzFuEk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "type": "recording", "key": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "label": "Did the angels assist in the Battle of Badr? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191231", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXBZY_ph7Bg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "type": "recording", "key": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "label": "On the David Wood and Muhammad Hijab Debate: Reflections & Review -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20181224", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyRfZZZcA8g", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "type": "recording", "key": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "label": "Is there a benefit to Praying Salah? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220416", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzKvxYPY-GI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "type": "recording", "key": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "label": "Chechnya's grand mufti having women remove their niqab? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210105", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hE3WjiQoxAA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "type": "recording", "key": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "label": "Deen of Hope NOT Hate - Mufti Tariq Masood | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20240929", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMUrvU2c9YQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2024": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "type": "recording", "key": "hOusirOkBVU", "label": "Shaykh Kashif Khan | Policing thought, Pornography & Pandora's box | MindTrap with Mufti #15", "date": "20200419", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOusirOkBVU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 35, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 35}, "tiers": {"machine": 35}}, {"id": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "type": "recording", "key": "hcscudhD8bU", "label": "Mufti Abu Layth & Ustadh AbdusShakur Brooks: A discussion on Maliki Fiqh", "date": "20140509", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hcscudhD8bU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "type": "recording", "key": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "label": "Should We Debate Quranists? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20211025", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ht0qJv5Om9o", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "type": "recording", "key": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "label": "A response to Shadee Elmasry - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180315", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCr0sV2UrcU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "type": "recording", "key": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "label": "Should Muslims Establish Khilafah - Shaykh Akram Nadwi & Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170909", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJ2ml87pTrs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "type": "recording", "key": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "label": "Reply to Daniel Haqiqatjou on Mufti Menk | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200117", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQVd5_ag6DE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "type": "recording", "key": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "label": "Karbala & it's precursors | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201016", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaBL5ViS3Rg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 18, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 18}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}}, {"id": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "type": "recording", "key": "ijwBevcC6o8", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #200| Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210202", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijwBevcC6o8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 27, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 27}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "type": "recording", "key": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "label": "Thoughts on Muhammad Hijab's talk on Liberalism & Islam | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190804", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6pXWGpnWd0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "type": "recording", "key": "jTYEM-eEe78", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #183 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200922", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTYEM-eEe78", "tier": "machine", "segments": 29, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 29}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}}, {"id": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "type": "recording", "key": "jp8GjvVONMs", "label": "Hadith Analysis & Fatwa: Women Can Travel Without a Mahram  - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180422", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jp8GjvVONMs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:k9V9aM16G1k", "type": "recording", "key": "k9V9aM16G1k", "label": "Is Music Haram? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190804", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k9V9aM16G1k", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "type": "recording", "key": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "label": "Jannah & Jahannum: Their Reality Between Literalism and Symbolism -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180702", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kDSBNnTRJKo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "type": "recording", "key": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "label": "Cutting-edge Perspective: Trimming the beard in Islam (pt 2)- Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20140412", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkjqsRxJ3KM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "type": "recording", "key": "l4n4wD2jjps", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #201| Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210209", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4n4wD2jjps", "tier": "machine", "segments": 37, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 37}, "tiers": {"machine": 37}}, {"id": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "type": "recording", "key": "llllbKdGrA4", "label": "What does Islam say about Gender Dysphoria? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190814", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llllbKdGrA4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "type": "recording", "key": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "label": "People Attacking Shaykh Muhammad Al-Yaqoubi | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200406", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLNpcjXYpqM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "type": "recording", "key": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "label": "Muslim Scholars Allying With LGBTQ Community ? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230222", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOfS_0uGn4E", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "type": "recording", "key": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "label": "There is NO evil eye in Islam (Detailed Overview) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201115", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnpGDvjs2nk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:nZdIoI1JWwM", "type": "recording", "key": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "label": "What is My Mission? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180423", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZdIoI1JWwM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "type": "recording", "key": "nndcs2uHoqE", "label": "Does criticising Hadith transmission mean criticising the Quran tranmssion? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190928", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nndcs2uHoqE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "type": "recording", "key": "noE0Z72gUbs", "label": "My thoughts on Imam Suyuti's book on sex | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190718", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noE0Z72gUbs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "type": "recording", "key": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "label": "Converts And The YouTube Dawah Scene | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230509", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAG-F3hxCDY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "type": "recording", "key": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "label": "My Thoughts on Mohammed Hijab & His Approach | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191212", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXTsV9fn3zE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "type": "recording", "key": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "label": "Lupe Fiasco | Stardom, Semiotics & Soul-searching | MindTrap#56 | Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki  MALM", "date": "20210426", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYiiPEhuiHA", "tier": "machine", "segments": 27, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 27}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}}, {"id": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "type": "recording", "key": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "label": "Holistic Overview: Can Men Wear Earrings? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190724", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkjtq8AXGRE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 10, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}}, {"id": "recording:psuMMzjvfRI", "type": "recording", "key": "psuMMzjvfRI", "label": "Can I hug friends of a different gender? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191010", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psuMMzjvfRI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "type": "recording", "key": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "label": "In Islam is salvation possible for a non-muslim? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200819", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyI4TBAjCMI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "type": "recording", "key": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "label": "Amena Khan (Pearl Daisy) Removes Hijab | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200702", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qdIQiwiz1mY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:r196CQ7qkaY", "type": "recording", "key": "r196CQ7qkaY", "label": "Is it mandatory for Muslims to go to Jummah | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210107", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r196CQ7qkaY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "type": "recording", "key": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "label": "Shaykh Atabek Shukurov | Mortgages, Madhabs & Molvi-ism | MindTrap 48 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210129", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtwyWCa2-pQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 22, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 22}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}}, {"id": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "type": "recording", "key": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "label": "Imam Abu Hanifa | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20221210", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-Vm6mgbLl8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 12, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}}, {"id": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "type": "recording", "key": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "label": "Debate challenge to Shadee Elmasry on Maliki Fiqh | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201112", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9JKA9ZjI28", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "type": "recording", "key": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "label": "A Response to Yasir Qadhi on Miracles | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20191103", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMOOcEVIGDE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 11, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}}, {"id": "recording:sgwylUg7XU0", "type": "recording", "key": "sgwylUg7XU0", "label": "Why Do Muslims have Trouble with Romance? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190228", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgwylUg7XU0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "type": "recording", "key": "t9EI_hrzL84", "label": "They Invaded My Home", "date": "20210518", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t9EI_hrzL84", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "type": "recording", "key": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "label": "Thoughts on Shaykh Ramadan Al-Bouti | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200303", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZNGKXyIaxU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "type": "recording", "key": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "label": "Yasir Qadhi's reply to Jay Smith & ultracrepidarian | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201210", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttQ_CXlVaso", "tier": "machine", "segments": 5, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}}, {"id": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "type": "recording", "key": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "label": "Why the Anti-Christ (Dajjal)? Concept is problematic in Islam - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180409", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBbLk0EhDGk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "type": "recording", "key": "uMKu_OCFTes", "label": "The Palestinian Plight & Israeli Injustice | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210515", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMKu_OCFTes", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "type": "recording", "key": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "label": "Fatwa: Can men wear earrings? - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180305", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uVRr1jjbLEs", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "type": "recording", "key": "ucdrbLyGY70", "label": "Are Mortgages & Bank Loans Haram? - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20171019", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ucdrbLyGY70", "tier": "machine", "segments": 13, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}}, {"id": "recording:udJveM_S0sY", "type": "recording", "key": "udJveM_S0sY", "label": "Aisha was not a child Her age at the time of Marriage | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201012", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udJveM_S0sY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:udmzRAYYgfI", "type": "recording", "key": "udmzRAYYgfI", "label": "Dawahman I Have Wronged Him | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220108", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udmzRAYYgfI", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "type": "recording", "key": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "label": "Fatwa on saying Merry Christmas - Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20151227", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ueCmAZD-LXw", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "type": "recording", "key": "umPepYIsc_g", "label": "Feeling bad about wanting to be rich? #Shorts", "date": "20210704", "kind": "short", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umPepYIsc_g", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "type": "recording", "key": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "label": "Why people run from the Bukhari debate? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201020", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-1HD1uAMBM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "type": "recording", "key": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "label": "My Thoughts on Shaykh Saqib Shaami | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190817", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8pLoq2vpUY", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "type": "recording", "key": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "label": "Do You Have to Grow a Beard? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20180612", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vF5yuEYz9Vo", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "type": "recording", "key": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "label": "Jonathan Brown, Daniel Haqiqatjou & the mushkil of mushkil | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200902", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGoAxXEHpHk", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "type": "recording", "key": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "label": "Neanderthals And Denisovans & The Islamic Narrative | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20220119", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voxmwEQ6rz4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "type": "recording", "key": "vrR5CWw8asg", "label": "12 Shia Imams According To Sunni Islam? | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20211222", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vrR5CWw8asg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "type": "recording", "key": "w6TqWuUumCg", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #188 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201027", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6TqWuUumCg", "tier": "machine", "segments": 33, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 33}, "tiers": {"machine": 33}}, {"id": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "type": "recording", "key": "wCe73zqCi_I", "label": "Shaykh Omar Baloch | Cynicism, Consumerism & the Catch 22 of Riba | Mindtrap with Mufti #30", "date": "20200710", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCe73zqCi_I", "tier": "machine", "segments": 38, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 38}, "tiers": {"machine": 38}}, {"id": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "type": "recording", "key": "wkhoro-Qb20", "label": "Thoughts on Hamza Ali Abbasi's discussion with Harris Sultan | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200112", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkhoro-Qb20", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "type": "recording", "key": "xznXIYp0B5s", "label": "Prof. Dr Khalil Andani | The Oral Text & the Ontology of The Quran | Mindtrap with Mufti #28", "date": "20200703", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xznXIYp0B5s", "tier": "machine", "segments": 23, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 23}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}}, {"id": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "type": "recording", "key": "y-JDMojFGnU", "label": "Before my Mum's Burial - Final Farewell #Duas #LoveYouMum الله يرحمك  ❤️🙏🏽", "date": "20230526", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-JDMojFGnU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "type": "recording", "key": "y9P342Tx6T0", "label": "A mufti, a convert & hanky panky! | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200601", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9P342Tx6T0", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "type": "recording", "key": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "label": "Homosexuality and Islam -Mufti  Abu Layth", "date": "20181220", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFeJ-QkS-kM", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "type": "recording", "key": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "label": "Is It Haram to Kiss in Public? -Mufti Abu Layhth", "date": "20191212", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJGrP8cVk-M", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "type": "recording", "key": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "label": "\"God did NOT ask Abraham to sacrifice his son\" | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201028", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRuC09ajKEQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "type": "recording", "key": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "label": "Yasir Qadhi on Masturbation | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210104", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZrVPdcKjxQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 3, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}}, {"id": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "type": "recording", "key": "yy74XfRo_E4", "label": "Who Was Khidr (a.s.)? -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190114", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yy74XfRo_E4", "tier": "machine", "segments": 6, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}}, {"id": "recording:z06drwxqxGE", "type": "recording", "key": "z06drwxqxGE", "label": "Reaction to Yasir Qadhi on mens jewellery | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20201209", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z06drwxqxGE", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "type": "recording", "key": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "label": "Sunnah vs Hadith (Case Study: Hands in Salah) | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20211006", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z6Ay73O7Dug", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}, {"id": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "type": "recording", "key": "zN1-WlBys2I", "label": "Imam Abu Hanifa was deemed a heretic/deviant by his contemporaries - Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki", "date": "20180420", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zN1-WlBys2I", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "type": "recording", "key": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "label": "In Depth: Sulaiman (a.s.), the Throne of Sheba, and Miracles in the Quran -Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20190108", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOTvTgdUMV8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 9, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2019": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}}, {"id": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "type": "recording", "key": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "label": "Monday Nights with Mufti #209 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20210406", "kind": "live_stream", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZ85AUzeK5w", "tier": "machine", "segments": 39, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2021": 39}, "tiers": {"machine": 39}}, {"id": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "type": "recording", "key": "z__38zt8FlQ", "label": "Misrepresenting Mufti | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20200407", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z__38zt8FlQ", "tier": "machine", "segments": 4, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}}, {"id": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "type": "recording", "key": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "label": "Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan & Mufti Abu Layth - A Discussion on Contemporary Issues", "date": "20160315", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbyA7rqfyRU", "tier": "machine", "segments": 7, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2016": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}}, {"id": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "type": "recording", "key": "zkklciv1TK8", "label": "The Methodology Of Imam Malik | How To Treat Hadith | Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20230419", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zkklciv1TK8", "tier": "machine", "segments": 2, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}}, {"id": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "type": "recording", "key": "zlXm19MtE2A", "label": "Q: Does Masturbation Invalidate the Fast? Mufti Abu Layth", "date": "20170517", "kind": "video", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlXm19MtE2A", "tier": "machine", "segments": 1, "recordings": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}}], "edges": [{"id": "cited_on|book:adab-al-muallimin|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:adab-al-muallimin", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:adab-al-muallimin|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:adab-al-muallimin", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:adab-al-muallimin|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:adab-al-muallimin", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ahkam-al-quran|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ahkam-al-quran|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ahkam-al-quran|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ahkam-al-quran|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ahkam-al-quran|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aina-kamalat-i-islam|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aina-kamalat-i-islam", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aina-kamalat-i-islam|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aina-kamalat-i-islam", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ansab|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ansab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ansab|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ansab", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ashmawiyyah|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ashmawiyyah", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ashmawiyyah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ashmawiyyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ashmawiyyah|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ashmawiyyah", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fazl|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fazl", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fazl|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fazl", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fiqh-al-akbar|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fiqh-al-akbar|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fiqh-al-akbar|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hamasa|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hamasa", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hamasa|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hamasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hamasa|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hamasa", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hidayah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hidayah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-hidayah|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-hidayah", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ilal-ahmad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ilal-ahmad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ilal-ahmad|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ilal-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ilal-ahmad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ilal-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-itisam|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-itisam", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-itisam|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-itisam", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-itisam|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-itisam", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kashshaf|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kashshaf", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kashshaf|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kashshaf", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kashshaf|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kashshaf", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kitab-sibawayh|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kitab-sibawayh", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-kitab-sibawayh|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-kitab-sibawayh", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mabsut|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mabsut", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mabsut|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mabsut", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mabsut|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mabsut", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mabsut|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mabsut", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mudawwana|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mudawwana", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muhalla|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muhalla", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mujam-al-awsat|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mujam-al-awsat", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mujam-al-awsat|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mujam-al-awsat", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-murshid-al-muin|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-murshid-al-muin", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-murshid-al-muin|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-murshid-al-muin", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-mustadrak|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-mustadrak", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muwafaqat|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muwafaqat", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muwafaqat|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muwafaqat", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muwafaqat|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muwafaqat", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-muwafaqat|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-muwafaqat", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-risalah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-risalah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shamail|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shamail", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shamail|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shamail", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shamail|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shamail", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-shifa|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-shifa", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-sultaniyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-sultaniyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-sultaniyya|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-sultaniyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-sultaniyya|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-sultaniyya", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-sultaniyya|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-sultaniyya", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-sultaniyya|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-sultaniyya", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tabsira|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tabsira", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tabsira|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tabsira", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ulama-al-uzzab|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ulama-al-uzzab|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-ulama-al-uzzab|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-utbiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-utbiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-utbiyya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-utbiyya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-utbiyya|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-utbiyya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-yuniniyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-yuniniyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-yuniniyya|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-yuniniyya", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:al-yuniniyya|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:al-yuniniyya", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aqidah-tahawiyya|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:asas-al-balagha|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:asas-al-balagha", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:asas-al-balagha|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:asas-al-balagha", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:asas-al-balagha|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:asas-al-balagha", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:avesta|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:avesta", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:avesta|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:avesta", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:avesta|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:avesta", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:banat-suad|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:banat-suad", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:banat-suad|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:banat-suad", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bible|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bible", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bidayat-al-mujtahid|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bidayat-al-mujtahid|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bidayat-al-mujtahid|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-isaiah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-isaiah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-isaiah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-isaiah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-isaiah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-isaiah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-jeremiah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-jeremiah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-jeremiah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-jeremiah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-jeremiah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-jeremiah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-judges|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-judges", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-judges|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-judges", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:book-of-judges|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:book-of-judges", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bulugh-al-maram|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bulugh-al-maram", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bulugh-al-maram|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bulugh-al-maram", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:bulugh-al-maram|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:bulugh-al-maram", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:code-of-hammurabi|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:code-of-hammurabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:code-of-hammurabi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:code-of-hammurabi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:code-of-hammurabi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:code-of-hammurabi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:consciousness-beyond-life|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:consciousness-beyond-life", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:consciousness-beyond-life|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:consciousness-beyond-life", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:darwins-cathedral|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:darwins-cathedral", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:darwins-cathedral|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:darwins-cathedral", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:darwins-cathedral|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:darwins-cathedral", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:deuteronomy|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:deuteronomy", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:early-inquisitions-in-islam|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:early-inquisitions-in-islam", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:early-inquisitions-in-islam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:early-inquisitions-in-islam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:early-islamic-qiblas|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:early-islamic-qiblas|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:early-islamic-qiblas|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:fath-al-bari|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:fath-al-bari", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gharami-sahih|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gharami-sahih", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gharami-sahih|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gharami-sahih", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gharami-sahih|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gharami-sahih", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-john|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-john", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-john|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-john", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-john|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-john", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-luke|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-luke", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-mark|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-mark", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-mark|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-mark", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-mark|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-mark", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-matthew|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-matthew|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-matthew|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-thomas|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-thomas|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-thomas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:gospel-of-thomas|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:guru-granth-sahib|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:guru-granth-sahib", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:guru-granth-sahib|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:guru-granth-sahib", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:guru-granth-sahib|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:guru-granth-sahib", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:in-gods-path|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:in-gods-path", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:in-gods-path|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:in-gods-path", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:in-gods-path|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:in-gods-path", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:injil|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:injil", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:injil|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:injil", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:injil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:injil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:injil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:injil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kashti-nuh|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kashti-nuh", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kashti-nuh|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kashti-nuh", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kashti-nuh|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kashti-nuh", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-bariyya|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-bariyya", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-bariyya|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-bariyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-tawhid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-tawhid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-tawhid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-tawhid|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-tawhid", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-tawwabin|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-tawwabin", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-tawwabin|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-tawwabin", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-zahra|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-zahra", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:kitab-al-zahra|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:kitab-al-zahra", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maa-al-nas|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maa-al-nas", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maa-al-nas|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maa-al-nas", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:majmu-al-fatawa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:majmu-al-fatawa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:majmu-al-fatawa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:majmu-al-fatawa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:majmu-al-fatawa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:majmu-al-fatawa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maratib-al-ijma|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maratib-al-ijma", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maratib-al-ijma|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maratib-al-ijma", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:maratib-al-ijma|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:maratib-al-ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mathnawi|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mathnawi", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mathnawi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mathnawi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mathnawi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mathnawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:midnights-children|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:midnights-children", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:midnights-children|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:midnights-children", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mizan-al-itidal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mizan-al-itidal|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mizan-al-itidal|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mizan-al-itidal|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:mukhtasar-khalil|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muntaqa-al-akhbar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muntaqa-al-akhbar|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muntaqa-al-akhbar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muqaddimah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muqaddimah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muqaddimah|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muqaddimah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muqaddimah|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muqaddimah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-abi-yala|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-abi-yala|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-abi-yala|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-abi-yala|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-abi-yala|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-ahmad|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-ahmad", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-bazzar|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:muwatta|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:muwatta", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nasb-al-majaniq|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nasb-al-majaniq|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nasb-al-majaniq|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nasb-al-majaniq|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nayl-al-awtar|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nuskhat-ibn-saada|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nuskhat-ibn-saada|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:nuskhat-ibn-saada|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:old-testament|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:old-testament", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:old-testament|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:old-testament", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:old-testament|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:old-testament", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:old-testament|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:old-testament", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:old-testament|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:old-testament", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:on-the-genealogy-of-morals|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:on-the-genealogy-of-morals", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:plato-republic|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:plato-republic", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:plato-republic|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:plato-republic", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:plato-republic|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:plato-republic", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:puranas|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:puranas", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:puranas|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:puranas", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:puranas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:puranas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:quranic-geography|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:quranic-geography", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:quranic-geography|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:quranic-geography", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:quranic-geography|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:quranic-geography", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:qut-al-qulub|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:qut-al-qulub", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:qut-al-qulub|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:qut-al-qulub", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:qut-al-qulub|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:qut-al-qulub", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:qut-al-qulub|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:qut-al-qulub", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:qut-al-qulub|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:qut-al-qulub", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:rig-veda|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:rig-veda", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:rig-veda|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:rig-veda", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:rig-veda|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:rig-veda", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ruhani-khazain|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ruhani-khazain", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:ruhani-khazain|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:ruhani-khazain", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 4, "2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 19, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2018": 17, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 69, "years": {"2017": 5, "2018": 37, "2019": 4, "2020": 4, "2021": 17, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 69}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 6, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 10, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 5, "2018": 5, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 6, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-al-bukhari|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2017": 5, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 8, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2014": 2, "2017": 4, "2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2017": 3, "2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sahih-muslim|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sahih-muslim", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sapiens|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sapiens", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sapiens|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sapiens", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-al-umda|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-al-umda", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-al-umda|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-al-umda", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-al-umda|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-al-umda", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sinaat-al-fatwa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sinaat-al-fatwa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sinaat-al-fatwa|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-abi-dawud|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-darimi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-nasai|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-ibn-majah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-manar|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-manar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-manar|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-manar", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-manar|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-manar", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-mazhari|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-mazhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-mazhari|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-samani|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-samani", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-samani|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-samani", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-samani|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-samani", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-tabari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-tabari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-tabari|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-tabari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tafsir-al-tabari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tafsir-al-tabari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahafut-al-falasifa|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahafut-al-falasifa", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahafut-al-falasifa|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahafut-al-falasifa", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahafut-al-tahafut|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahafut-al-tahafut", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahafut-al-tahafut|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahafut-al-tahafut", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tartib-al-madarik|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:tawq-al-hamama|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-cosmic-serpent|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-cosmic-serpent", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-cosmic-serpent|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-cosmic-serpent", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-cosmic-serpent|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-cosmic-serpent", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-foundations-of-islam|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-foundations-of-islam", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-foundations-of-islam|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-foundations-of-islam", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-foundations-of-islam|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-foundations-of-islam", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-future-of-an-illusion|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-future-of-an-illusion", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-future-of-an-illusion|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-future-of-an-illusion", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-knowledge-illusion|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-knowledge-illusion", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-knowledge-illusion|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-knowledge-illusion", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-knowledge-illusion|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-knowledge-illusion", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-sanaa-palimpsest|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-sanaa-palimpsest", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-sanaa-palimpsest|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-sanaa-palimpsest", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2022": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-satanic-verses|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-satanic-verses", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-study-quran|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-study-quran", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-study-quran|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-study-quran", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-study-quran|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-study-quran", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-third-chimpanzee|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-third-chimpanzee|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-third-chimpanzee|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-third-chimpanzee|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-wealth-of-nations|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-wealth-of-nations", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-wealth-of-nations|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-wealth-of-nations", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:the-wealth-of-nations|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:the-wealth-of-nations", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:torah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:torah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:torah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:torah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:torah|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:torah", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:torah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:torah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:torah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:torah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:urwat-al-wuthqa|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:urwat-al-wuthqa|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:urwat-al-wuthqa|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:urwat-al-wuthqa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:urwat-al-wuthqa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:zabur|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:zabur", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:zabur|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:zabur", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|book:zabur|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "book:zabur", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:assassination-of-uthman|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:assassination-of-uthman|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:assassination-of-uthman|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:assassination-of-uthman|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babri-masjid-dispute|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babri-masjid-dispute|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babri-masjid-dispute|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babylonian-exile|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babylonian-exile", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babylonian-exile|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babylonian-exile", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babylonian-exile|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babylonian-exile", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babylonian-exile|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babylonian-exile", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:babylonian-exile|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:babylonian-exile", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:banu-qurayza|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:banu-qurayza", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:banu-qurayza|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:banu-qurayza", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-al-harrah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-al-harrah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-al-harrah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-awtas|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-awtas", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-awtas|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-awtas", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-badr|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-badr", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-khaybar|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-siffin|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-siffin", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-siffin|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-siffin", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-camel|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-camel", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-the-trench|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:battle-of-uhud|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:battle-of-uhud", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:bayat-al-ridwan|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:bayat-al-ridwan", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:bayat-al-ridwan|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:bayat-al-ridwan", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:bayat-al-ridwan|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:bayat-al-ridwan", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:birmingham-quran-manuscript|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:birmingham-quran-manuscript|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:birmingham-quran-manuscript|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:black-death|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:black-death", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:black-death|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:black-death", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:black-death|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:black-death", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-raj|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-raj", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-raj|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-raj", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:british-raj|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:british-raj", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-constantinople|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-makkah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-makkah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-makkah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:conquest-of-makkah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:council-of-nicaea-325|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:council-of-nicaea-325|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:council-of-nicaea-325|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:council-of-nicaea-325|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:council-of-nicaea-325|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:covid-19-pandemic|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:eleusinian-mysteries|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:eleusinian-mysteries", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:eleusinian-mysteries|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:eleusinian-mysteries", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:eleusinian-mysteries|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:eleusinian-mysteries", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:european-colonialism|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:european-colonialism", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:european-colonialism|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:european-colonialism", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:european-colonialism|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:european-colonialism", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:exodus|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:exodus", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:exodus|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:exodus", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:exodus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:exodus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:exodus|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:exodus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:farewell-pilgrimage|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:farewell-pilgrimage", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:farewell-pilgrimage|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:farewell-pilgrimage", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:founding-of-baghdad|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:founding-of-baghdad", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:founding-of-baghdad|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:founding-of-baghdad", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:golden-calf|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:golden-calf", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:golden-calf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:golden-calf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:golden-calf|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:golden-calf", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:golden-calf|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:golden-calf", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:golden-calf|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:golden-calf", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:great-flood|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:great-flood", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:great-flood|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:great-flood", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:great-flood|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:great-flood", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:great-flood|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:great-flood", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2020": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2020": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hijrah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hurricane-katrina-2005|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hurricane-katrina-2005", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:hurricane-katrina-2005|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:hurricane-katrina-2005", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:incident-of-the-ifk|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:incident-of-the-ifk", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:incident-of-the-ifk|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:incident-of-the-ifk", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:industrial-revolution|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:industrial-revolution", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:isra-and-miraj|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:karbala|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:karbala", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:migration-to-abyssinia|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:migration-to-abyssinia", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:migration-to-abyssinia|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:migration-to-abyssinia", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:migration-to-abyssinia|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:migration-to-abyssinia", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mihna|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mihna", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mongol-invasions|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mongol-invasions", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:oj-simpson-trial-1995|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:oj-simpson-trial-1995", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:oj-simpson-trial-1995|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:oj-simpson-trial-1995", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:pagan-gate-2020|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:pagan-gate-2020", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:pagan-gate-2020|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:pagan-gate-2020", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:pagan-gate-2020|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:pagan-gate-2020", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:palestinian-crisis-2021|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peacock-throne|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peacock-throne", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peacock-throne|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peacock-throne", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peacock-throne|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peacock-throne", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:protestant-reformation|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:protestant-reformation", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:reconquista|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:reconquista", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:ridda-wars|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:ridda-wars", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:ridda-wars|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:ridda-wars", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:ridda-wars|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:ridda-wars", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rohingya-genocide-2017|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rohingya-genocide-2017|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:rohingya-genocide-2017|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sack-of-madinah|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sack-of-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sack-of-madinah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sack-of-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sack-of-madinah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sack-of-madinah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:salem-witch-trials|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:salem-witch-trials", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:salem-witch-trials|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:salem-witch-trials", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:salem-witch-trials|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:salem-witch-trials", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:saqifa-of-banu-saida|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:saqifa-of-banu-saida", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:saqifa-of-banu-saida|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:saqifa-of-banu-saida", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:september-11-attacks|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:september-11-attacks", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:september-11-attacks|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:september-11-attacks", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:siege-of-madinah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:siege-of-madinah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:siege-of-madinah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:siege-of-madinah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:siege-of-madinah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:siege-of-madinah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:silk-road|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:silk-road", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:silk-road|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:silk-road", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:soviet-afghan-war|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:soviet-afghan-war", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:soviet-afghan-war|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:soviet-afghan-war", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:soviet-afghan-war|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:soviet-afghan-war", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:spanish-inquisition|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:spanish-inquisition", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:splitting-of-the-moon|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:splitting-of-the-moon", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:splitting-of-the-moon|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:splitting-of-the-moon", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:splitting-of-the-moon|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:splitting-of-the-moon", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:taif-journey|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:taif-journey", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:trojan-horse-affair-2014|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:trojan-horse-affair-2014|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:trojan-horse-affair-2014|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:year-of-sorrow|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:year-of-sorrow", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:year-of-sorrow|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:year-of-sorrow", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:year-of-sorrow|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:year-of-sorrow", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:younger-dryas|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:younger-dryas", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|event:younger-dryas|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "event:younger-dryas", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:137|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:137", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:137|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:137", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:137|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:137", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2655|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2655", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2655|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2655", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2655|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2655", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2819|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2819", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2819|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2819", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:2819|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:2819", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3093|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3093", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3093|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3093", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3093|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3093", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3104|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3104", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3104|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3104", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3104|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3104", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3242|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3242", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3242|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3242", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3242|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3242", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3431|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3431", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3431|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3431", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3431|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3431", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:364|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:364", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:364|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:364", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:364|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:364", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3663|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3663", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3663|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3663", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:3663|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:3663", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4428|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4428|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4428|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4428|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4428|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4431|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4431", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4431|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4431", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4431|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4431", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4594|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4594", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4594|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4594", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4594|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4594", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4725|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4725", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:4725|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:4725", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5127|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5127", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5127|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5127", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5127|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5127", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5133|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5133", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5133|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5133", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5133|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5133", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5136|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5136", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5136|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5136", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5136|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5136", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5255|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5255|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5255|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5255|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5255|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5492|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5492", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5492|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5492", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5765|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5765", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5765|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5765", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:5765|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:5765", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6639|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6639", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6639|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6639", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6639|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6639", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6830|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6830|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6830|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6830|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:6830|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:7517|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:7517", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:7517|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:7517", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:bukhari:7517|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:bukhari:7517", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0058fc99|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0058fc99", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0058fc99|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0058fc99", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:03b390a1|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:03b390a1", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:03b390a1|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:03b390a1", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:03b390a1|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:03b390a1", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:04750067|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:04750067", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:04750067|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:04750067", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0508e283|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0508e283", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0508e283|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0508e283", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:054ae057|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:054ae057", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:054ae057|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:054ae057", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0576bb02|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0576bb02", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0576bb02|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0576bb02", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0607111e|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0607111e|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0607111e|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0607111e|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0607111e|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:061599d0|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:061599d0", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:061599d0|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:061599d0", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:06746893|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:06746893", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:06746893|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:06746893", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0783df04|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07a1c5d0|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07a1c5d0|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07a1c5d0|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07d42a1a|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07f4ecd1|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07f4ecd1|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:07f4ecd1|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:085f3d75|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:085f3d75|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:085f3d75|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:085f3d75|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:08774c1f|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:08774c1f", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:087f9cf3|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:087f9cf3", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:087f9cf3|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:087f9cf3", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:091fe423|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:091fe423", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:091fe423|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:091fe423", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a236306|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a86cf97|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a86cf97|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0a86cf97|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0adfcf34|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0adfcf34", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0adfcf34|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0adfcf34", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0da2986c|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0da2986c", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0da2986c|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0da2986c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0daa52d4|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0daa52d4|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0daa52d4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0e110483|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0e110483", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0e110483|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0e110483", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0e110483|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0e110483", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0e6517d3|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0e6517d3", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0e6517d3|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0e6517d3", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0ef3fb30|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0ef3fb30|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:0ef3fb30|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:10e8ca76|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:10e8ca76|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:10e8ca76|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:11191dca|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:11191dca", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:11191dca|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:11191dca", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1153b02b|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1153b02b|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1153b02b|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:116de08d|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:116de08d", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:116de08d|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:116de08d", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:11824c16|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:11824c16", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:11824c16|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:11824c16", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:11824c16|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:11824c16", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:127763c2|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:127763c2", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:127763c2|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:127763c2", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:127763c2|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:127763c2", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:13ca57c0|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:13ca57c0|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:13ca57c0|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:144726cc|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:144726cc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:144726cc|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:144726cc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:144726cc|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:144726cc", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:14945522|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:14945522", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:14945522|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:14945522", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:14945522|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:14945522", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1652a026|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1652a026", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1652a026|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1652a026", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1652a026|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1652a026", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16737f93|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16737f93", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16737f93|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16737f93", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16737f93|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16737f93", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16ab3584|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16ab3584|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16ab3584|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:16ab3584|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17a84e78|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17a84e78", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17a84e78|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17a84e78", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17a84e78|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17a84e78", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17da26fe|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17da26fe", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17da26fe|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17da26fe", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17da26fe|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17da26fe", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17fbddbc|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17fbddbc|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:17fbddbc|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:185e7f9a|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:185e7f9a", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:185e7f9a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:185e7f9a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1903b957|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1903b957", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1903b957|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1903b957", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b27380|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b27380", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b27380|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b27380", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b27380|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b27380", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b3f804|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b3f804", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b3f804|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b3f804", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:19b3f804|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:19b3f804", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1a24a8a4|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1a24a8a4|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1a24a8a4|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1bc19689|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1bc19689", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1bc19689|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1bc19689", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1dc479f7|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1dc479f7|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1dc479f7|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1fd6f410|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1fd6f410|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1fd6f410|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1fd6f410|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:1fd6f410|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:206b1939|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:206b1939", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:206b1939|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:206b1939", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:20a83804|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:20a83804", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:20a83804|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:20a83804", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:20a83804|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:20a83804", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2154cd27|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2154cd27", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2154cd27|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2154cd27", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:21c47c81|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:21c47c81", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:21c47c81|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:21c47c81", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:21c47c81|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:21c47c81", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24232b79|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24469dbc|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24469dbc", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24469dbc|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24469dbc", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:246187ac|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:246187ac|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:246187ac|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:246187ac|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24eaf1ba|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24eaf1ba|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:24eaf1ba|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25681cd0|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25681cd0", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25681cd0|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25681cd0", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25953135|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25953135", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25953135|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25953135", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25953135|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25953135", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25dd70c6|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25dd70c6|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:25dd70c6|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:266d2083|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:266d2083", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:266d2083|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:266d2083", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:266d2083|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:266d2083", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2741e4cd|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2741e4cd|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2741e4cd|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2741e4cd|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2741e4cd|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:27af0dd7|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:27af0dd7|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:27af0dd7|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:29cf1793|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:29cf1793", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:29cf1793|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:29cf1793", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:29cf1793|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:29cf1793", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:29d1db38|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:29d1db38", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:29d1db38|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:29d1db38", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2a4080d4|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2a4080d4|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2a4080d4|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2a4080d4|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2a4080d4|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2b141ddc|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2b141ddc|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2b141ddc|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2c98b2b9|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2c98b2b9|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2c98b2b9|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2ea15ea5|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2ea15ea5", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2ea15ea5|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2ea15ea5", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2f256513|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2f256513", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2f256513|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2f256513", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:2f256513|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:2f256513", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:309a93b6|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:309a93b6", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:309a93b6|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:309a93b6", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:309a93b6|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:309a93b6", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:32d192a5|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:32d192a5|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:32d192a5|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:32d192a5|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:336fe573|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:336fe573", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:336fe573|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:336fe573", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:336fe573|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:336fe573", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:34e916d2|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:34e916d2", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:34e916d2|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:34e916d2", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3530749e|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3530749e", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3530749e|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3530749e", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3530749e|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3530749e", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:35db4e1f|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:35db4e1f", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:35db4e1f|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:35db4e1f", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3635d5d3|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3635d5d3|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3635d5d3|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37195d28|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37195d28", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37195d28|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37195d28", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37195d28|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37195d28", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37b7d106|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37b7d106", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37b7d106|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37b7d106", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:37b7d106|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:37b7d106", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:386fa7b1|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:386fa7b1|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:386fa7b1|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:38a17c20|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:38a17c20", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:38a17c20|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:38a17c20", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:38a17c20|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:38a17c20", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3a3f2709|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3a3f2709|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3a3f2709|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3b2452f7|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3b2452f7", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3b2452f7|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3b2452f7", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3b47a683|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3b47a683", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3b47a683|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3b47a683", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3b47a683|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3b47a683", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c0ad21e|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c0ad21e|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c0ad21e|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c5e20fc|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c5e20fc|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c5e20fc|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c7da8ed|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c7da8ed", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3c7da8ed|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3c7da8ed", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3cceb4d9|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3cceb4d9", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3cceb4d9|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3cceb4d9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e31381a|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e965d16|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e965d16", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e965d16|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e965d16", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3e965d16|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3e965d16", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3ec20135|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3ec20135", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3ec20135|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3ec20135", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3ec20135|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3ec20135", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3efddf38|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3efddf38", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3efddf38|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3efddf38", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3efddf38|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3efddf38", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3fce18c1|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3ff18220|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3ff18220", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:3ff18220|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:3ff18220", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:40f60e96|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:40f60e96", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:40f60e96|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:40f60e96", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:41c0b9f9|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:41c0b9f9|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:41c0b9f9|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:428fe918|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:428fe918", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:428fe918|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:428fe918", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:428fe918|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:428fe918", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:42fd73b8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:42fd73b8|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:42fd73b8|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:42fd73b8|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:42fd73b8|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b54f5f|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b54f5f|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b54f5f|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b54f5f|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b54f5f|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b7f583|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b7f583", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b7f583|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b7f583", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:43b7f583|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:43b7f583", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:444310bc|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:444310bc", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:444310bc|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:444310bc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:444310bc|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:444310bc", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:46d4d9c4|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:46d4d9c4|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:46d4d9c4|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47a536df|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47a536df", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47a536df|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47a536df", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47a536df|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47a536df", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47be092d|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47be092d", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47be092d|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47be092d", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:47be092d|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:47be092d", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:48d2fb97|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:48d2fb97", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:48d2fb97|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:48d2fb97", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:49364277|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:49364277", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:49364277|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:49364277", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:49364277|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:49364277", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4a9d4173|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4a9d4173", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4a9d4173|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4a9d4173", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4abab576|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4abab576", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4abab576|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4abab576", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4accedcd|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4accedcd|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4accedcd|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4aee676f|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4aee676f", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4aee676f|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4aee676f", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4aee676f|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4aee676f", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4bbbe027|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4c9707e2|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4c9707e2", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 41, "start": 9070, "end": 9265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d5b5008|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d5b5008|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d5b5008|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d5b5008|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d734d1d|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d734d1d|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d734d1d|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4d734d1d|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4e196f83|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4e196f83", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4e196f83|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4e196f83", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:4e196f83|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:4e196f83", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:517e74fc|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:517e74fc|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:517e74fc|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:517e74fc|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:51d6c137|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:51d6c137", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:51d6c137|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:51d6c137", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:51d6c137|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:51d6c137", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:526d7260|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:526d7260", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:526d7260|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:526d7260", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5334d346|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5334d346", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5334d346|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5334d346", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:54f5da0f|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:54f5da0f", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:54f5da0f|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:54f5da0f", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:55c8a02f|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:55c8a02f|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:55c8a02f|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:563127df|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:563127df", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:563127df|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:563127df", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:563127df|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:563127df", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:566be7a1|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:566be7a1", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:566be7a1|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:566be7a1", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:566be7a1|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:566be7a1", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:57dd2ee7|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:57dd2ee7", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:57dd2ee7|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:57dd2ee7", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:58780d20|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:58780d20", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:58780d20|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:58780d20", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:58c43d93|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:58c43d93", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:58c43d93|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:58c43d93", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:59b6539e|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:59b6539e", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:59b6539e|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:59b6539e", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:59b6539e|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:59b6539e", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5aa3d58c|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5aa3d58c|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5aa3d58c|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5aa3d58c|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5cfe6af1|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5cfe6af1|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5cfe6af1|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5d1281b0|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5d1281b0|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5d1281b0|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5eee3c4d|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5eee3c4d|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5eee3c4d|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5faffb9e|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5faffb9e|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:5faffb9e|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:60bcb4ee|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:60bcb4ee|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:60bcb4ee|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:613960b2|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:613960b2", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:613960b2|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:613960b2", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:615032d4|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:615032d4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:615032d4|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:615032d4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:615032d4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:615032d4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:61e009d9|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:61e009d9", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:61e009d9|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:61e009d9", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:61e009d9|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:61e009d9", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:620896d2|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:620896d2", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:620896d2|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:620896d2", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:620896d2|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:620896d2", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6214b4e1|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6214b4e1|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6214b4e1|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:62207cac|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:62207cac", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:62207cac|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:62207cac", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:623f97e7|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:623f97e7", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:623f97e7|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:623f97e7", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:623f97e7|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:623f97e7", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6271346a|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6271346a|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6271346a|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:63460405|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:63460405", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:63460405|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:63460405", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:63460405|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:63460405", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64e37134|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64e37134", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64e37134|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64e37134", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64e37134|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64e37134", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64f7a13d|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64f7a13d|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:64f7a13d|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6546db09|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6546db09|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6546db09|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6546db09|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6546db09|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:65670e76|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:65670e76", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:65670e76|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:65670e76", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:65670e76|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:65670e76", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:65d7a81e|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:65d7a81e", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:65d7a81e|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:65d7a81e", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:664cc2c3|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:664cc2c3|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:664cc2c3|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6897f8ca|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6897f8ca", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6897f8ca|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6897f8ca", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:68a420f4|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:68a420f4", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:68a420f4|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:68a420f4", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:68a420f4|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:68a420f4", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:695244ce|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:695244ce", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:695244ce|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:695244ce", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69859410|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69859410", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69859410|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69859410", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69859410|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69859410", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:69a65512|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6b3b4416|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6b3b4416|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6b3b4416|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6b3b4416|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6b3b4416|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6cc10484|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6cc10484", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6cc10484|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6cc10484", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6db69aaf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6db69aaf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6db69aaf|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6dede3f3|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6dede3f3|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6dede3f3|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e606353|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e606353", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e606353|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e606353", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e606353|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e606353", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ef44327|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ef44327", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ef44327|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ef44327", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ef44327|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ef44327", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6efd403c|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6efd403c", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6efd403c|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6efd403c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:700a667a|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:700a667a", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:700a667a|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:700a667a", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:706285e0|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:706285e0|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:706285e0|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:706285e0|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:71fcade0|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:71fcade0", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:71fcade0|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:71fcade0", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:71fcade0|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:71fcade0", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72540d63|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72540d63|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72540d63|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72540d63|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72d55de9|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72d55de9", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72d55de9|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72d55de9", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:72d55de9|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:72d55de9", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74385080|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74385080", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74385080|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74385080", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74385080|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74385080", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74b1d15f|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74b1d15f|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74b1d15f|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:74b1d15f|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:75de6857|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:75de6857", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:75de6857|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:75de6857", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:75de6857|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:75de6857", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:76d23e12|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:76d23e12", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:76d23e12|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:76d23e12", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:773e83d8|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:773e83d8", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:773e83d8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:773e83d8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:773e83d8|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:773e83d8", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:77e47ac0|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:77e47ac0|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:77e47ac0|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:77e47ac0|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:77e47ac0|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:79be7eb2|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:79be7eb2|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:79be7eb2|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7a70bdbe|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7a70bdbe", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7a70bdbe|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7a70bdbe", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7a76ff4c|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7a76ff4c|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7a76ff4c|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b34dd38|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b9f7f05|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b9f7f05|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7b9f7f05|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7cef7cb5|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7cef7cb5|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7cef7cb5|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7dfd2715|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7dfd2715", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7dfd2715|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7dfd2715", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:80b1af85|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:80b1af85", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:80b1af85|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:80b1af85", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:80ebd445|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:80ebd445", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:80ebd445|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:80ebd445", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:814474b9|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:814474b9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:814474b9|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:814474b9", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:838663a8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:838663a8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:838663a8|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:838663a8", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:838663a8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:838663a8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:871f66b9|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:871f66b9", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:871f66b9|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:871f66b9", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8737fe17|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8737fe17", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8737fe17|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8737fe17", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8737fe17|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8737fe17", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:87a6618e|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:87a6618e", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:87a6618e|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:87a6618e", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:89fbbe22|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:89fbbe22|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:89fbbe22|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a304df1|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a304df1", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a304df1|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a304df1", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a99943b|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a99943b", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a99943b|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a99943b", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8a99943b|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8a99943b", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8b0c9176|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8b0c9176|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8b0c9176|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ba24dc2|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ba24dc2|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ba24dc2|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ba24dc2|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8c289e7a|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8c289e7a", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8c289e7a|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8c289e7a", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8e1abb62|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8e1abb62|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:8e1abb62|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:904edb83|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:904edb83", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:904edb83|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:904edb83", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:90dd1daf|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:90dd1daf", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:90dd1daf|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:90dd1daf", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:90dfbb22|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:90dfbb22|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91926944|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91926944", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91926944|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91926944", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91a4639f|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91a4639f", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91a4639f|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91a4639f", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91a4639f|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91a4639f", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91d7502c|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91e93693|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91e93693", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91e93693|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91e93693", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:91e93693|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:91e93693", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:92ce9938|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:92ce9938", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:92ce9938|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:92ce9938", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:92ce9938|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:92ce9938", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94283449|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94283449", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94283449|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94283449", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94283449|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94283449", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94283449|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94283449", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94283449|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94283449", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:943d2716|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:943d2716", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:943d2716|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:943d2716", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94440e0b|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94440e0b", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94440e0b|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94440e0b", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94440e0b|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94440e0b", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94531d95|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94531d95|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94531d95|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94531d95|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:94531d95|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:955dafe4|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:955dafe4", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:955dafe4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:955dafe4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:955dafe4|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:955dafe4", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:95ed3e02|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:95ed3e02|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:95ed3e02|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9780ca35|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9780ca35", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9780ca35|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9780ca35", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9780ca35|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9780ca35", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:97a63e0b|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:97a63e0b|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:97a63e0b|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:97a63e0b|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:97a63e0b|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6d7eff|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6d7eff|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6d7eff|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6e8d05|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6e8d05|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9a6e8d05|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ac3373f|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ac3373f|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ac3373f|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ac3373f|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ae25c07|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ae25c07|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ae25c07|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9ae25c07|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9b193bf2|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9b193bf2|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9b193bf2|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9bbc1d36|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9bbc1d36|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9bbc1d36|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9d01b67f|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9d01b67f|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:9d01b67f|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a15c3e92|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a15c3e92", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a15c3e92|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a15c3e92", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a1bd50ab|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a1bd50ab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a1bd50ab|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a44612d9|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a44612d9", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a44612d9|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a44612d9", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a58d8940|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a58d8940", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a58d8940|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a58d8940", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a58d8940|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a58d8940", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a5cdcded|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a5cdcded", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a5cdcded|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a5cdcded", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a63dafe9|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a63dafe9", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a63dafe9|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a63dafe9", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a66e3532|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a66e3532", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a66e3532|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a66e3532", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a6bf32eb|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a6bf32eb|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a6bf32eb|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a72ed1ed|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a72ed1ed", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a72ed1ed|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a72ed1ed", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8af5be2|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8af5be2", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8c001c0|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8c001c0", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8c001c0|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8c001c0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a9513bc7|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a9513bc7", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:a9513bc7|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:a9513bc7", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aabca51a|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aabca51a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aabca51a|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aabca51a|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aabca51a|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aca4730d|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aca4730d", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aca4730d|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aca4730d", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ace50479|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ace50479", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ace50479|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ace50479", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ace50479|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ace50479", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aea19cc5|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aea19cc5|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aea19cc5|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aebb3191|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aebb3191", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aebb3191|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aebb3191", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:aebb3191|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:aebb3191", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:afa4bcd9|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:afa4bcd9", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:afa4bcd9|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:afa4bcd9", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b0a8648b|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b0a8648b|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b0a8648b|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b0a8648b|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b0a8648b|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b192ec8e|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b192ec8e|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b192ec8e|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b192ec8e|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b192ec8e|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b339bf83|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b339bf83|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b339bf83|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b339bf83|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b339bf83|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3bd592a|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3bd592a|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3bd592a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3e70d55|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3e70d55|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b3e70d55|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b517bd19|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b517bd19", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b517bd19|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b517bd19", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b6104c86|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b6104c86", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b6104c86|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b6104c86", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b6561480|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b6561480", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b6561480|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b6561480", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b6561480|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b6561480", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b802c2a5|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b802c2a5", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b802c2a5|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b802c2a5", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b97a2c7f|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b97a2c7f|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b97a2c7f|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b98a5cc4|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b98a5cc4", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b98a5cc4|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b98a5cc4", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b9d6a17d|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b9d6a17d|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:b9d6a17d|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bb5fdb57|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bb5fdb57", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bb5fdb57|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bb5fdb57", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bbe9b820|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bbe9b820", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bbe9b820|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bbe9b820", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bca2b93a|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bca2b93a", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bca2b93a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bca2b93a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bd89c283|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bd89c283", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bd89c283|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bd89c283", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bd89c283|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bd89c283", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be25f934|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be25f934", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be25f934|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be25f934", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be25f934|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be25f934", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be4605d1|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be4605d1|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:be4605d1|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bef7f59e|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bef7f59e", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bef7f59e|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bef7f59e", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bf23b2da|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bf23b2da|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:bf23b2da|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c0b608bd|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c0b608bd|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c0b608bd|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c0b608bd|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c1643a4a|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c1643a4a|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c1643a4a|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c26c7d53|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c26c7d53", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c26c7d53|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c26c7d53", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c2ba830a|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c2ba830a|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c2ba830a|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c3087e67|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c39d4ab5|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c39d4ab5|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c39d4ab5|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c485a5bc|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c485a5bc|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c485a5bc|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c538564d|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c538564d", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c538564d|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c538564d", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c538564d|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c538564d", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c54df7f0|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c54df7f0", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c54df7f0|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c54df7f0", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c55bd513|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c55bd513", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c55bd513|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c55bd513", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c55bd513|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c55bd513", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c61312ab|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c61312ab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c61312ab|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c61312ab", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c61312ab|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c61312ab", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c731c3f4|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c731c3f4|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c731c3f4|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c8516683|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c8516683", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c8516683|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c8516683", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c92486c9|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c92486c9", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c92486c9|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c92486c9", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:c92486c9|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:c92486c9", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ca03ed2b|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ca03ed2b|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ca03ed2b|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cd7aae33|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cdce764b|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cdce764b", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cdce764b|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cdce764b", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cdce764b|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cdce764b", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ced425d4|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ced425d4", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ced425d4|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ced425d4", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ced425d4|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ced425d4", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf08cbd1|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf08cbd1|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf08cbd1|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf232df3|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf232df3", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf232df3|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf232df3", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cf232df3|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cf232df3", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cfd72a49|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cfd72a49|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:cfd72a49|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d00cf9c1|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d00cf9c1", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d056a27c|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d056a27c", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d056a27c|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d056a27c", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d333f073|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d333f073", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d333f073|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d333f073", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d333f073|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d333f073", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d490f6bb|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d490f6bb|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d490f6bb|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d4e2def8|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d4e2def8", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d4e2def8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d4e2def8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d4f7745a|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d4f7745a", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d4f7745a|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d4f7745a", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d574a07a|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d574a07a", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d574a07a|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d574a07a", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d574a07a|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d574a07a", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d6df088f|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d6df088f", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d6df088f|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d6df088f", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d6df088f|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d6df088f", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d760391a|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d760391a", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d760391a|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d760391a", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d760391a|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d760391a", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d938d7f6|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d938d7f6", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:d938d7f6|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:d938d7f6", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:da54f8d2|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:da54f8d2", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:da54f8d2|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:da54f8d2", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:da792624|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:da792624", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:da792624|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:da792624", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:db4e34c0|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:db4e34c0|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:db4e34c0|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dd36e1dd|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dd36e1dd|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:dd36e1dd|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:de76def6|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:de76def6", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:de76def6|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:de76def6", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:de76def6|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:de76def6", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df71d13f|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df71d13f", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df71d13f|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df71d13f", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df71d13f|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df71d13f", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df734495|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df734495", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df734495|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df734495", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:df734495|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:df734495", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e02d6353|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e02d6353", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e02d6353|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e02d6353", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e02d6353|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e02d6353", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e142e95b|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e142e95b", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e142e95b|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e142e95b", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e16705ba|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e16705ba", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e16705ba|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e16705ba", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e16705ba|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e16705ba", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e17cbcb0|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e17cbcb0", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e17cbcb0|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e17cbcb0", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e180f02c|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e180f02c", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e180f02c|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e180f02c", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4357cc0|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4357cc0|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4357cc0|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4357cc0|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4777bc0|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4777bc0|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4777bc0|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4df847f|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4df847f", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4df847f|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4df847f", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e4df847f|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e4df847f", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e592ec95|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e668f0cc|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e668f0cc", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e668f0cc|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e668f0cc", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e7000a50|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e7000a50", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e7000a50|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e7000a50", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e7000a50|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e7000a50", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:e92689a3|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ea6d7eac|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ea6d7eac|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ea6d7eac|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ea6d857b|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ea6d857b", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ea6d857b|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ea6d857b", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eaaebf3c|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eaaebf3c|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eaaebf3c|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb4693f0|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb4693f0|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb4693f0|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb88e4e6|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb88e4e6|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:eb88e4e6|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ebce1887|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ebce1887", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ebce1887|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ebce1887", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ecbe3efd|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ecbe3efd|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ecbe3efd|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ef524ec4|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ef524ec4", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:ef524ec4|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:ef524ec4", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f204a3cd|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f204a3cd|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f204a3cd|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f45113be|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f45113be", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f45113be|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f45113be", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f5b8c382|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f5b8c382|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f5b8c382|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f6cdbddf|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f6cdbddf|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f6cdbddf|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f942d247|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f942d247|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f942d247|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f942d247|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f942d247|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9b6111f|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9b6111f", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9b6111f|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9b6111f", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9e49159|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9e49159", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9e49159|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9e49159", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9e49159|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9e49159", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9eac639|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9eac639", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9eac639|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9eac639", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:f9eac639|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:f9eac639", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fb13a1a4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fb13a1a4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fb13a1a4|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fb13a1a4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:5pillars|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:5pillars", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:5pillars|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:5pillars", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:5pillars|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:5pillars", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:5pillars|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:5pillars", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2022": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:abbasids|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:abbasids", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ahmadiyya|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ahmadiyya", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-azhar|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-azhar", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 17, "start": 5548, "end": 6501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-maghrib-institute|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-maghrib-institute", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-maghrib-institute|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-maghrib-institute", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-mahdi-institute|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-mahdi-institute|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-mahdi-institute|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-qaeda|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-qaeda", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-qaeda|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-qaeda", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-qaeda|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-qaeda", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-saud|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-saud", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-saud|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-saud", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-saud|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-saud", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-zaytuna|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-zaytuna", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-zaytuna|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-zaytuna", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-zaytuna|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-zaytuna", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-zaytuna|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-zaytuna", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:al-zaytuna|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:al-zaytuna", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:almohads|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:almohads", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:almohads|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:almohads", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:almoravids|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:almoravids", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:almoravids|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:almoravids", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ansar|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ansar", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ansar|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ansar", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-hashim|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-hashim", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-nadir|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-nadir", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-nadir|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-nadir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-nadir|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-nadir", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-nadir|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-nadir", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-tamim|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-tamim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-tamim|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-tamim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-tamim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-tamim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-tamim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-tamim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-tamim|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-tamim", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-udhra|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-udhra", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:banu-udhra|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:banu-udhra", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bayt-al-hikma|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bayt-al-hikma", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bayt-al-hikma|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bayt-al-hikma", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bayt-al-hikma|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bayt-al-hikma", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bjp|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bjp", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bjp|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bjp", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:bjp|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:bjp", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:boko-haram|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:boko-haram", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:boko-haram|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:boko-haram", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:boko-haram|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:boko-haram", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:boko-haram|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:boko-haram", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:british-empire|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:british-empire", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:byzantine-empire|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:byzantine-empire", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:catholic-church|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:catholic-church", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:catholic-church|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:catholic-church", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:catholic-church|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:catholic-church", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:catholic-church|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:catholic-church", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:catholic-church|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:catholic-church", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charity-commission|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charity-commission", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charity-commission|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charity-commission", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charity-commission|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charity-commission", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charlie-hebdo|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charlie-hebdo", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charlie-hebdo|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charlie-hebdo", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:charlie-hebdo|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:charlie-hebdo", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:chishti-order|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:chishti-order", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:chishti-order|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:chishti-order", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:cia|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:cia", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:cia|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:cia", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:cia|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:cia", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:cia|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:cia", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:dar-al-mustafa|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:dar-al-mustafa", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:darussalam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:darussalam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:darussalam|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:darussalam", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:darussalam|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:darussalam", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:fatimids|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:fatimids", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:fatimids|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:fatimids", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:fatimids|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:fatimids", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:fatimids|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:fatimids", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ghassanids|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ghassanids", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ghassanids|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ghassanids", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ghassanids|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ghassanids", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ghassanids|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ghassanids", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ghassanids|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ghassanids", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:green-lane-masjid|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:green-lane-masjid", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:green-lane-masjid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:green-lane-masjid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:green-lane-masjid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:green-lane-masjid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hamas|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hamas", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hamas|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hamas", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:harvard-university|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:harvard-university", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:harvard-university|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:harvard-university", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:harvard-university|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:harvard-university", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:harvard-university|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:harvard-university", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:harvard-university|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:harvard-university", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:himyar|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:himyar", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 29, "start": 8107, "end": 8456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:hizb-ut-tahrir|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:house-of-karen|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:house-of-karen", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:house-of-karen|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:house-of-karen", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ipci|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ipci", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ipci|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ipci", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ipci|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ipci", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2015": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:isis|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:isis", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:islamic-university-of-madinah|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamaat-e-islami|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamaat-e-islami", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamaat-e-islami|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamaat-e-islami", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-binoria|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-binoria", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-binoria|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-binoria", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-binoria|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-binoria", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-faruqiya|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-faruqiya", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-faruqiya|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-faruqiya", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:jamia-faruqiya|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:jamia-faruqiya", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:khuzaa|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:khuzaa", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:khuzaa|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:khuzaa", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:kingdom-of-aksum|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:kingdom-of-aksum", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:kingdom-of-aksum|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:kingdom-of-aksum", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:kingdom-of-aksum|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:kingdom-of-aksum", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:knowledge-revival|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:knowledge-revival", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:knowledge-revival|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:knowledge-revival", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:lakhmids|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:lakhmids", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:lakhmids|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:lakhmids", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:lakhmids|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:lakhmids", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:lakhmids|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:lakhmids", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:lakhmids|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:lakhmids", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:levites|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:levites", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:levites|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:levites", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:loreal|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:loreal", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:loreal|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:loreal", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:loreal|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:loreal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:metropolitan-police|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:metropolitan-police", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:metropolitan-police|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:metropolitan-police", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:mossad|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:mossad", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:mossad|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:mossad", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:mughal-empire|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:mughal-empire", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:mughal-empire|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:mughal-empire", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:mughal-empire|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:mughal-empire", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:nabataeans|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:nabataeans", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:naqshbandi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:naqshbandi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:open-university|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:open-university", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:open-university|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:open-university", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:open-university|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:open-university", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ottoman-empire|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ottoman-empire", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:pharisees|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:pharisees", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:pharisees|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:pharisees", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:pharisees|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:pharisees", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:prevent-programme|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:prevent-programme", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:prevent-programme|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:prevent-programme", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:prevent-programme|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:prevent-programme", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:qaramita|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:qaramita", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:qaramita|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:qaramita", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:quraysh|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:quraysh", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:roman-empire|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:roman-empire", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:roman-empire|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:roman-empire", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ruet-e-hilal-committee|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ruet-e-hilal-committee|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ruet-e-hilal-committee|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sasanians|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sasanians", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sasanians|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sasanians", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sasanians|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sasanians", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sasanians|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sasanians", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sharia-councils-uk|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sharia-councils-uk|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sharia-councils-uk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sharia-councils-uk|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sharia-councils-uk|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sipah-e-sahaba|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sipah-e-sahaba", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sipah-e-sahaba|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sipah-e-sahaba", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sipah-e-sahaba|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sipah-e-sahaba", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:skt|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:skt", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:skt|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:skt", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:skt|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:skt", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 18, "years": {"2018": 17, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:sunni-defence|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:sunni-defence", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:tablighi-jamaat|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:taliban|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:taliban", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:the-mad-mamluks|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:the-mad-mamluks", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:the-mad-mamluks|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:the-mad-mamluks", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:twitter|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:twitter", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ubaydids|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ubaydids", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ubaydids|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ubaydids", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:ubaydids|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:ubaydids", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:umayyads|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:umayyads", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations-security-council|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations-security-council", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations-security-council|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations-security-council", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:united-nations-security-council|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:united-nations-security-council", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:wayfair|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:wayfair", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:wayfair|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:wayfair", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:wuhan-institute-of-virology|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:wuhan-institute-of-virology|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 5, "start": 1138, "end": 1294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:yaqeen-institute|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:yaqeen-institute", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:yaqeen-institute|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:yaqeen-institute", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:yaqeen-institute|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:yaqeen-institute", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:yaqeen-institute|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:yaqeen-institute", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:yaqeen-institute|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:yaqeen-institute", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zanata|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zanata", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zanata|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zanata", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zanata|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zanata", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zaytuna-college|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zaytuna-college", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zaytuna-college|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zaytuna-college", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|org:zaytuna-college|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "org:zaytuna-college", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-iii|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-iii", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abd-al-rahman-iii|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abd-al-rahman-iii", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdul-hameed-adam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdul-hameed-adam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-al-andalusi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-ibad|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-ibad", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-ibad|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-ibad", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-salam|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-salam|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-salam|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-kunde|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-kunde", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-kunde|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-kunde", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-sameer|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-sameer", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-sameer|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-sameer", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-sameer|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-sameer", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-sameer|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-sameer", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-sameer|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-sameer", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-yusuf-ali|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-yusuf-ali|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abdullah-yusuf-ali|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abla|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abla", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abla|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abla", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abla|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abla", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abraha|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abraha", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abraha|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abraha", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-hurayra|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-hurayra", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jafar-al-mansur|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jafar-al-mansur|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jafar-al-mansur|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-jahl|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-jahl", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-musa-al-ashari|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-nuwas|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-nuwas", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-nuwas|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-nuwas", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-nuwas|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-nuwas", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-said-al-khudri|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-sufyan|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-sufyan", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-talib|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-talib|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-talib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-talib|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-talib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-talib|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-talib", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-tammam|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-tammam", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-tammam|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-tammam", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-tammam|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-tammam", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 6, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam-smith|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam-smith", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam-smith|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam-smith", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam-smith|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam-smith", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adam-smith|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adam-smith", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adi-ibn-hatim|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adi-ibn-hatim", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adi-ibn-hatim|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adi-ibn-hatim", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adnan|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adnan", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adolf-hitler|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adolf-hitler", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adolf-hitler|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adolf-hitler", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:adolf-hitler|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:adolf-hitler", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ahmad-faraz|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ahmad-faraz", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 34, "start": 7118, "end": 7301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 18, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 2, "2020": 6, "2021": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 20, "start": 5593, "end": 5783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aisha|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aisha", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akbar-allahabadi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akbar-allahabadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akbar-allahabadi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akbar-allahabadi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akbar-allahabadi|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akhenaten|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akhenaten", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:akhenaten|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:akhenaten", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-amin|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-amin", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-amin|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-amin", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-asha|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-asha", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-asha|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-asha", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-asha|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-asha", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-farazdaq|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-farazdaq", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mamun|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mamun", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mutanabbi|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mutanabbi", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:al-mutanabbi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:al-mutanabbi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:albert-einstein|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:albert-einstein", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:albert-einstein|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:albert-einstein", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:albert-einstein|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:albert-einstein", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amena-khan|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amena-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amena-khan|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amena-khan", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amena-khan|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amena-khan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amir-ibn-rabia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amir-ibn-rabia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amir-ibn-rabia|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amir-ibn-rabia", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amir-ibn-rabia|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amir-ibn-rabia", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amir-khan|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amir-khan", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amir-khan|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amir-khan", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amr-ibn-al-as|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amr-ibn-al-as|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amr-ibn-al-as|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amr-ibn-al-as|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:amr-ibn-al-as|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anas-ibn-malik|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anil-kapoor|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anil-kapoor", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anil-kapoor|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anil-kapoor", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anis-ahmed-rushdie|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anis-ahmed-rushdie|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anis-ahmed-rushdie|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:anis-ahmed-rushdie|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:antara-ibn-shaddad|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:antara-ibn-shaddad|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:antara-ibn-shaddad|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:aristotle|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:aristotle", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:arthur-c-clarke|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:arthur-c-clarke", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:arthur-c-clarke|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:arthur-c-clarke", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asadullah-al-andalusi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asadullah-al-andalusi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asadullah-al-andalusi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asadullah-al-andalusi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asim-qureshi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asim-qureshi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asim-qureshi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asim-qureshi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asim-qureshi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asim-qureshi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ayyub|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ayyub", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ayyub|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ayyub", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ayyub|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ayyub", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ayyub|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ayyub", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:barack-obama|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:barack-obama", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:barack-obama|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:barack-obama", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:basil-mitchell|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:basil-mitchell", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:basil-mitchell|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:basil-mitchell", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:basil-mitchell|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:basil-mitchell", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:benjamin-netanyahu|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:benjamin-netanyahu", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:benjamin-netanyahu|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:benjamin-netanyahu", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:benjamin-netanyahu|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:benjamin-netanyahu", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bertrand-russell|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bertrand-russell", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bertrand-russell|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bertrand-russell", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bilal-ibn-rabah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bilal-ibn-rabah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bilal-ibn-rabah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bilal-ibn-rabah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:binyamin|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:binyamin", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:binyamin|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:binyamin", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:binyamin|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:binyamin", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:blaise-pascal|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:blaise-pascal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:blaise-pascal|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:blaise-pascal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:blaise-pascal|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:blaise-pascal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:boris-johnson|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:boris-johnson", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:boris-johnson|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:boris-johnson", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:boris-johnson|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:boris-johnson", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:boris-johnson|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:boris-johnson", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:boris-johnson|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:boris-johnson", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:buddha|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:buddha", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:buddha|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:buddha", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:buddha|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:buddha", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:burayda|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:burayda", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:burayda|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:burayda", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:burayda|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:burayda", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charlemagne|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charlemagne", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charlemagne|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charlemagne", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-darwin|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-darwin", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-darwin|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-darwin", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-darwin|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-darwin", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-darwin|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-darwin", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-darwin|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-darwin", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-martel|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-martel", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:charles-martel|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:charles-martel", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:christopher-hitchens|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:christopher-hitchens", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:christopher-hitchens|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:christopher-hitchens", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:christopher-hitchens|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:christopher-hitchens", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:colin-humphreys|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:colin-humphreys", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:colin-humphreys|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:colin-humphreys", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:confucius|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:confucius", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:confucius|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:confucius", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:conor-mcgregor|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:conor-mcgregor", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:conor-mcgregor|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:conor-mcgregor", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dagh-dehlvi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dagh-dehlvi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dagh-dehlvi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dagh-dehlvi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dal-babu|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dal-babu", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dal-babu|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dal-babu", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dan-gibson|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dan-gibson", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-brubaker|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-brubaker", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-brubaker|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-brubaker", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-brubaker|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-brubaker", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:daniel-haqiqatjou|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dante-alighieri|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dante-alighieri", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dante-alighieri|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dante-alighieri", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dante-alighieri|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dante-alighieri", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dave-chappelle|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dave-chappelle", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dave-chappelle|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dave-chappelle", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-ray-griffin|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-ray-griffin", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-ray-griffin|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-ray-griffin", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-sloan-wilson|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-sloan-wilson", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-sloan-wilson|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-sloan-wilson", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-sloan-wilson|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-sloan-wilson", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:david-wood|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:david-wood", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawah-man|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawah-man", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dawud|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dawud", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:derren-brown|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:derren-brown", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dihya-al-kalbi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dihya-al-kalbi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dihya-al-kalbi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:dihya-al-kalbi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:diogenes|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:diogenes", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:donald-trump|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:donald-trump", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:elon-musk|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:elon-musk", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:elon-musk|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:elon-musk", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:emile-durkheim|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:emile-durkheim", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:emile-durkheim|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:emile-durkheim", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:emile-durkheim|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:emile-durkheim", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:emmanuel-macron|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:emmanuel-macron", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:emmanuel-macron|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:emmanuel-macron", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:erik-erikson|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:erik-erikson", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:erik-erikson|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:erik-erikson", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezekiel|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezekiel", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezekiel|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezekiel", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezekiel|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezekiel", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezra|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezra", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezra|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezra", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezra|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezra", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ezra|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ezra", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 38, "start": 10039, "end": 10497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:farid|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:farid", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima-bint-malik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima-bint-malik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:fatima-bint-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:fatima-bint-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firas-zahabi|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firas-zahabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firas-zahabi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firas-zahabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:firawn|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:firawn", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:francis-bacon|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:francis-bacon", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:francis-bacon|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:francis-bacon", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:francis-bacon|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:francis-bacon", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frans-de-waal|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frans-de-waal", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frans-de-waal|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frans-de-waal", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frans-de-waal|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frans-de-waal", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frederic-bartlett|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frederic-bartlett", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frederic-bartlett|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frederic-bartlett", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:frederic-bartlett|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:frederic-bartlett", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:friedrich-nietzsche|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:friedrich-nietzsche", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:friedrich-nietzsche|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:friedrich-nietzsche", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:galileo-galilei|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:galileo-galilei", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:galileo-galilei|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:galileo-galilei", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:galileo-galilei|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:galileo-galilei", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:george-w-bush|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:george-w-bush", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:george-w-bush|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:george-w-bush", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ghislaine-maxwell|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ghislaine-maxwell", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ghislaine-maxwell|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ghislaine-maxwell", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:gilgamesh|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:gilgamesh", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:gilgamesh|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:gilgamesh", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:gordon-wasson|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:gordon-wasson", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:gordon-wasson|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:gordon-wasson", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:gordon-wasson|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:gordon-wasson", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:graham-hancock|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:graham-hancock", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:graham-hancock|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:graham-hancock", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:graham-hancock|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:graham-hancock", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:graham-hancock|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:graham-hancock", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:graham-hancock|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:graham-hancock", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:habil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:habil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:habil|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:habil", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hajar|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hajar|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hajar", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hajar|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hajar", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ali-abbasi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ali-abbasi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ali-abbasi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-tzortzis|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-tzortzis|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-tzortzis|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-tzortzis|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hamza-tzortzis|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hani-ibn-thubayt|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hani-ibn-thubayt|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hani-ibn-thubayt|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hani-ibn-urwa|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hani-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harris-sultan|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harris-sultan", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harris-sultan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harris-sultan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harris-sultan|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harris-sultan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-al-rashid|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-al-rashid", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-yahya|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-yahya", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-yahya|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-yahya", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:harun-yahya|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:harun-yahya", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hasan-ibn-ali|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hawwa|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hawwa", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hawwa|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hawwa", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hawwa|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hawwa", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hawwa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hawwa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:heraclius|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:heraclius", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:heraclius|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:heraclius", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:heraclius|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:heraclius", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:herod-the-great|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:herod-the-great", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:herod-the-great|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:herod-the-great", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:husayn-ibn-ali|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-abbas|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-abbas", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-al-awwam|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-al-awwam", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-al-awwam|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-al-awwam", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-al-awwam|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-al-awwam", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-al-haytham|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-al-haytham", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-al-haytham|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-al-haytham", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-masud|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-masud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-muljam|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-muljam", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-muljam|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-muljam", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-muljam|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-muljam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-muljam|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-muljam", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-sayyad|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-sayyad", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibn-umar|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibn-umar", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ilyas|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ilyas", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ilyas|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ilyas", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ilyas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ilyas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:immanuel-kant|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:immanuel-kant", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-ibn-husayn|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-ibn-husayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-ibn-husayn|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-ibn-husayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-khan|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-khan|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-khan", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-khan|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-khan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-khan|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-khan", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imran-khan|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imran-khan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imru-al-qais|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imru-al-qais", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imru-al-qais|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imru-al-qais", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imru-al-qais|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imru-al-qais", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imru-al-qais|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imru-al-qais", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:imru-al-qais|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:imru-al-qais", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 31, "years": {"2018": 12, "2020": 3, "2021": 16}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 5, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 5, "2020": 2, "2021": 10, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:isa|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:isa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ishaq|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ishaq", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ishaq|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ishaq", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ishaq|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ishaq", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ismail|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ismail", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jalal-al-din-akbar|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jalal-al-din-akbar|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jalal-al-din-akbar|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jared-diamond|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jared-diamond", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jared-diamond|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jared-diamond", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jared-diamond|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jared-diamond", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jay-smith|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jay-smith", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jean-jacques-rousseau|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jean-jacques-rousseau", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jean-jacques-rousseau|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jean-jacques-rousseau", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeffrey-epstein|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeffrey-epstein", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeffrey-epstein|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeffrey-epstein", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeffrey-lang|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeffrey-lang", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeffrey-lang|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeffrey-lang", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeffrey-lang|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeffrey-lang", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jephthah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jephthah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jephthah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jephthah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jephthah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jephthah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeremy-bentham|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeremy-bentham", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jeremy-bentham|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jeremy-bentham", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jethro|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jethro", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jethro|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jethro", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jibril|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jibril", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-biden|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-biden", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-biden|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-biden", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-biden|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-biden", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-biden|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-biden", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joe-rogan|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joe-rogan", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:john-cobb|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:john-cobb", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:john-cobb|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:john-cobb", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:john-locke|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:john-locke", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:john-locke|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:john-locke", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:john-locke|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:john-locke", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jordan-peterson|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jordan-peterson", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joseph-husband-of-mary|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joseph-husband-of-mary", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:joseph-husband-of-mary|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:joseph-husband-of-mary", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juan-cole|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juan-cole", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juha|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juha", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juha|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juha", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juha|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juha", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juhayman-al-utaybi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juhayman-al-utaybi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:juhayman-al-utaybi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:junaid-jamshed|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:junaid-jamshed", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:junaid-jamshed|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:junaid-jamshed", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:justinian-i|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:justinian-i", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:justinian-i|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:justinian-i", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kab-al-ahbar|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kab-al-ahbar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kab-al-ahbar|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kab-al-ahbar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kab-al-ahbar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kab-al-ahbar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kab-ibn-zuhayr|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kab-ibn-zuhayr", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kab-ibn-zuhayr|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kab-ibn-zuhayr", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kanye-west|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kanye-west", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:karl-popper|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:karl-popper", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:karl-popper|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:karl-popper", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kawthar|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kawthar", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kawthar|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kawthar", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khabib-nurmagomedov|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khabib-nurmagomedov", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khabib-nurmagomedov|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khabib-nurmagomedov", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadijah|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadijah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khawla-bint-hakim|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khawla-bint-hakim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khawla-bint-hakim|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khawla-bint-hakim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:khidr|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:khidr", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kilab-ibn-murra|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kilab-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kilab-ibn-murra|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kilab-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lawrence-krauss|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lawrence-krauss", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:leo-tolstoy|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:leo-tolstoy", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:leonardo-da-vinci|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:leonardo-da-vinci", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:leonardo-da-vinci|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:leonardo-da-vinci", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lilith|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lilith", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lilith|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lilith", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lupe-fiasco|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lupe-fiasco", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 24, "start": 6648, "end": 6706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lupe-fiasco|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lupe-fiasco", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lut|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lut", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lut|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lut", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lut|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lut", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:lut|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:lut", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahira-khan|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahira-khan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahmud-ibn-maslama|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahmud-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mahmud-ibn-maslama|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mahmud-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:manu|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:manu", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:manu|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:manu", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:manu|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:manu", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:martin-luther|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:martin-luther", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:martin-luther|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:martin-luther", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 4, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:maryam|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:maryam", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-hancock|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-hancock", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-hancock|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-hancock", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-walsh|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-walsh", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-walsh|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-walsh", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-walsh|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-walsh", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-walsh|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-walsh", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:matt-walsh|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:matt-walsh", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mehmed-ii|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mehmed-ii", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mehmed-ii|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mehmed-ii", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mehmed-ii|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mehmed-ii", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mehmed-ii|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mehmed-ii", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:michael-cook|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:michael-cook", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:michael-cook|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:michael-cook", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mike-tyson|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mike-tyson", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mike-tyson|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mike-tyson", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mike-tyson|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mike-tyson", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mir-faizal|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mir-faizal", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mir-faizal|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mir-faizal", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mir-faizal|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mir-faizal", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mir-taqi-mir|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mir-taqi-mir", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mir-taqi-mir|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mir-taqi-mir", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mirza-ghalib|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mirza-ghalib", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mirza-ghalib|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mirza-ghalib", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mirza-ghalib|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mirza-ghalib", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 915, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mohammed-hijab|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mohammed-hijab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ali-jinnah|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ali-jinnah|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ali-jinnah|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-from-god|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-from-god", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-malik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-maslama|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-maslama|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-maslama|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammad-ibn-maslama|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammadi-begum|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammadi-begum", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muhammadi-begum|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muhammadi-begum", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mullah-omar|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mullah-omar", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mullah-omar|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mullah-omar", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:mullah-omar|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:mullah-omar", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 4, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 18, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 6, "2021": 5, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musa|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musaylima|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musaylima", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:musaylima|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:musaylima", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muslim-ibn-aqil|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muslim-ibn-aqil", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:muslim-ibn-aqil|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:muslim-ibn-aqil", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nadr-ibn-anas|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nadr-ibn-anas", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nadr-ibn-anas|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nadr-ibn-anas", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawf-al-bikali|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawf-al-bikali", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawf-al-bikali|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawf-al-bikali", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawwas-ibn-saman|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawwas-ibn-saman|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawwas-ibn-saman|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nawwas-ibn-saman|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nelson-mandela|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nelson-mandela", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nelson-mandela|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nelson-mandela", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nicolaus-copernicus|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nicolaus-copernicus|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nicolaus-copernicus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nicolaus-copernicus|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nicolaus-copernicus|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:noam-chomsky|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:noam-chomsky", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:noam-chomsky|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:noam-chomsky", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:noam-chomsky|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:noam-chomsky", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:noam-chomsky|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:noam-chomsky", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:noam-chomsky|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:noam-chomsky", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:norman-finkelstein|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:norman-finkelstein", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:norman-finkelstein|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:norman-finkelstein", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:nuh|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:nuh", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:numan-ibn-bashir|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:numan-ibn-bashir", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:numan-ibn-bashir|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:numan-ibn-bashir", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:oliver-sacks|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:oliver-sacks", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:oliver-sacks|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:oliver-sacks", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:oliver-sacks|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:oliver-sacks", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osama-bin-laden|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osama-bin-laden", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osama-bin-laden|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osama-bin-laden", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osama-bin-laden|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osama-bin-laden", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osama-bin-laden|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osama-bin-laden", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osiris|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osiris", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osiris|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osiris", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:osiris|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:osiris", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:pandora|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:pandora", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:pandora|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:pandora", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:pandora|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:pandora", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:patricia-crone|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:patricia-crone", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:paul|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:paul", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:paul|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:paul", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:paul|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:paul", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:pervez-hoodbhoy|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:pervez-hoodbhoy", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:pervez-hoodbhoy|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:pervez-hoodbhoy", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:piri-reis|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:piri-reis", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:piri-reis|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:piri-reis", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plato|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plato", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plotinus|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plotinus", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:plotinus|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:plotinus", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:prince-andrew|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:prince-andrew", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:prince-andrew|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:prince-andrew", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:prometheus|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:prometheus", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:prometheus|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:prometheus", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:prometheus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:prometheus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ptolemy|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ptolemy", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ptolemy|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ptolemy", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qabil|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qabil", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qabil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qabil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qabil|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qabil", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qaboos-bin-said|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qaboos-bin-said", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qaboos-bin-said|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qaboos-bin-said", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qahtan|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qahtan", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qandeel-baloch|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qandeel-baloch", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qandeel-baloch|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qandeel-baloch", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qandeel-baloch|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qandeel-baloch", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:queen-of-sheba|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:queen-of-sheba", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:rabia-ibn-haram|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:rabia-ibn-haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:rabia-ibn-haram|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:rabia-ibn-haram", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:raja-dahir|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:raja-dahir", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:raja-dahir|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:raja-dahir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:rene-descartes|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:rene-descartes", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:rene-descartes|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:rene-descartes", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:rene-descartes|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:rene-descartes", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:richard-dawkins|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:richard-dawkins", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:robert-hoyland|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:robert-hoyland", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:robert-hoyland|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:robert-hoyland", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:robert-hoyland|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:robert-hoyland", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ruqayya|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ruqayya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ruqayya|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ruqayya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ruqayya|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ruqayya", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahl-ibn-hunayf|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahl-ibn-hunayf|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahl-ibn-hunayf|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahla-bint-suhayl|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahla-bint-suhayl|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sahla-bint-suhayl|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:saint-george|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:saint-george", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:saint-george|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:saint-george", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:saint-george|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:saint-george", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sajah|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sajah", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sajah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sajah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-al-farisi|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-al-farisi", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-al-farisi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-al-farisi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2022": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-rushdie|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-rushdie", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-taseer|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-taseer", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-taseer|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-taseer", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:salman-taseer|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:salman-taseer", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:samuel-paty|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:samuel-paty", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:samuel-paty|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:samuel-paty", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:samuel-paty|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:samuel-paty", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sana-khan|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sana-khan", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sana-khan|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sana-khan", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sathya-sai-baba|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sathya-sai-baba", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sathya-sai-baba|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sathya-sai-baba", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sathya-sai-baba|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sathya-sai-baba", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:satya-sai-baba|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:satya-sai-baba", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:satya-sai-baba|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:satya-sai-baba", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sawda-bint-zama|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sawda-bint-zama", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sawda-bint-zama|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sawda-bint-zama", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shabbir-ahmed|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shabbir-ahmed", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shabbir-ahmed|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shabbir-ahmed", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shady-nasser|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shady-nasser", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shady-nasser|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shady-nasser", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shady-nasser|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shady-nasser", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shah-rukh-khan|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shah-rukh-khan|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shah-rukh-khan|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shah-rukh-khan|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shuayb|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shuayb", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:shuayb|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:shuayb", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sigmund-freud|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sigmund-freud", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sigmund-freud|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sigmund-freud", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sigmund-freud|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sigmund-freud", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sigmund-freud|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sigmund-freud", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:socrates|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:socrates", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sonny-bill-williams|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sonny-bill-williams", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sonny-bill-williams|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sonny-bill-williams", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sulayman|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sulayman", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:suleiman-the-magnificent|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:suleiman-the-magnificent", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:suleiman-the-magnificent|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:suleiman-the-magnificent", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sultan-qaboos|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sultan-qaboos", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:sultan-qaboos|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:sultan-qaboos", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:t-e-lawrence|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:t-e-lawrence", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:t-e-lawrence|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:t-e-lawrence", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:t-e-lawrence|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:t-e-lawrence", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:talut|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:talut", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:talut|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:talut", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tamim-al-dari|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tamim-al-dari", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tariq-ramadan|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tariq-ramadan", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tariq-ramadan|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tariq-ramadan", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tariq-ramadan|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tariq-ramadan", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ted-kaptchuk|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ted-kaptchuk|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ted-kaptchuk|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ted-kaptchuk|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thomas-aquinas|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thomas-aquinas", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thomas-aquinas|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thomas-aquinas", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thomas-hobbes|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thomas-hobbes", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thomas-hobbes|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thomas-hobbes", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thomas-hobbes|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thomas-hobbes", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:thrasymachus|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:thrasymachus", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tommy-robinson|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tommy-robinson", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tommy-robinson|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tommy-robinson", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tommy-robinson|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tommy-robinson", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:tommy-robinson|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:tommy-robinson", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ubayy-ibn-kab|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-abi-salama|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-abi-salama", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-abi-salama|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-abi-salama", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-sad|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umar-ibn-sad|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umar-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-aban|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-aban", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-aban|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-aban", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-aban|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-aban", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-atiyya|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-atiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-atiyya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-atiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-atiyya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-atiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-haram-bint-milhan|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-haram-bint-milhan|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-haram-bint-milhan|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-haram-bint-milhan|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-humayd|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-humayd", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-humayd|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-humayd", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-salama|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-salama", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-salama|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-salama", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-sulaym|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-sulaym", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:umm-sulaym|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:umm-sulaym", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:usama-ibn-zayd|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:usama-ibn-zayd", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:usama-ibn-zayd|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:usama-ibn-zayd", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:uthman-ibn-affan|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vasco-da-gama|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vasco-da-gama", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vasco-da-gama|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vasco-da-gama", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vasco-da-gama|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vasco-da-gama", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vishnu|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vishnu", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vishnu|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vishnu", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:vishnu|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:vishnu", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:william-shakespeare|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:william-shakespeare", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:william-shakespeare|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:william-shakespeare", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yahya|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yahya", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yahya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yahya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yahya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yahya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yahya-ibn-malik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yahya-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yahya-ibn-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yahya-ibn-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yala-ibn-murra|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yala-ibn-murra|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yala-ibn-murra|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yala-ibn-murra|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub-al-mansur|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub-al-mansur|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub-al-mansur|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yaqub-al-mansur|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yunus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yunus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusha-ibn-nun|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusha-ibn-nun|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusha-ibn-nun|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusha-ibn-nun|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusha-ibn-nun|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yusuf|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yusuf", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yuval-noah-harari|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yuval-noah-harari", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:yuval-noah-harari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:yuval-noah-harari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zakariyya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zakariyya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zarathustra|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zarathustra", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-ali|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-ali|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-ali|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-haritha|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-haritha|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-haritha|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-thabit|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-thabit", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zayd-ibn-thabit|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zayd-ibn-thabit", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-muhammad|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-muhammad", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zaynab-bint-muhammad|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zaynab-bint-muhammad", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zeus|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zeus", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zeus|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zeus", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zeus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zeus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ziyad-ibn-abihi|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ziyad-ibn-abihi", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:ziyad-ibn-abihi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:ziyad-ibn-abihi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zuhra-ibn-kilab|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zuhra-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|person:zuhra-ibn-kilab|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "person:zuhra-ibn-kilab", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:build-on-certainty|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:build-on-certainty", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consent|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consent", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:context-of-revelation|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:context-of-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:context-of-revelation|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:context-of-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:context-of-revelation|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:context-of-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:context-of-revelation|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:context-of-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:context-of-revelation|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:context-of-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:critical-review-of-tradition|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:critical-review-of-tradition", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:critical-review-of-tradition|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:critical-review-of-tradition", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:criticism-is-not-insult|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:criticism-is-not-insult", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:criticism-is-not-insult|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:criticism-is-not-insult", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:culture-versus-religion|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:custom-and-convention|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:custom-and-convention", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:custom-and-convention|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:custom-and-convention", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:custom-and-convention|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:custom-and-convention", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:default-permissibility|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:default-permissibility", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:faith-not-creed|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:faith-not-creed", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:faith-not-creed|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:faith-not-creed", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:faith-not-creed|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:faith-not-creed", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:faith-not-creed|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:faith-not-creed", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-absolutism|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 11, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hadith-relativism|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hadith-relativism", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:historical-context-of-hadith|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:historical-context-of-hadith|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:historical-context-of-hadith|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:living-tradition-as-source|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:matn-criticism|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:matn-criticism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:might-is-right|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:might-is-right", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-declares-haram|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-declares-haram|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-declares-haram|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-declares-haram|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:only-allah-declares-haram|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ontology-of-religion|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ontology-of-religion|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ontology-of-religion|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ontology-of-religion|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ontology-of-religion|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:prevention-of-harm|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:prevention-of-harm", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:prevention-of-harm|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:prevention-of-harm", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sources-of-knowledge|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sources-of-knowledge", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sources-of-knowledge|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sources-of-knowledge", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sources-of-knowledge|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sources-of-knowledge", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 3, "2023": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:105:1|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:105:1", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:105:1|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:105:1", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:109:1-6|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:109:1-6", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:109:1-6|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:109:1-6", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:109:2-5|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:109:2-5", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:109:2-5|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:109:2-5", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:57|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:57", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:57|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:57", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:57|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:57", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:99|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:99", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:99|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:99", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:99|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:99", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:99|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:99", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:10:99|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:10:99", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:112:1-4|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:112:1-4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:112:1-4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:112:1-4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:112:1-4|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:112:1-4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:1-5|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:1-5", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:1-5|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:1-5", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:1-5|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:1-5", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:4|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:113:4|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:113:4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:114:1-6|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:114:1-6", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:114:1-6|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:114:1-6", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:114:1-6|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:114:1-6", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:11:44|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:11:44", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:11:44|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:11:44", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:11:44|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:11:44", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:11:7|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:11:7", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:11:7|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:11:7", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:2|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:2", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:2|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:2", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:2|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:2", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:2|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:2", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:3|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:3", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:3|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:3", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:3|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:3", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:31|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:31", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:41|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:41", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:41|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:41", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:41|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:41", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:58-68|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:58-68", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:58-68|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:58-68", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:58-68|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:58-68", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:76|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:76", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:76|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:76", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:76|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:76", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:12:76|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:12:76", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:22|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:22", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:4|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:4", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:4|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:4", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:7|topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:7", "target": "topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:14:7|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:14:7", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:15:27|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:15:27", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:15:27|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:15:27", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:15:27|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:15:27", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:15:27|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:15:27", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:116|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:116", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:116|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:116", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:89|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:89", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:89|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:89", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:89|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:89", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:89|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:89", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:16:89|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:16:89", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:47|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:47", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:47|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:47", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:47|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:47", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:82|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:82", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:82|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:82", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:17:90-93|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:17:90-93", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:29|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:29", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:29|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:29", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:29|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:29", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:29|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:29", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:46|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:46", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:46|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:46", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:50|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:50", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:50|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:50", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:50|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:50", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60-82|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60-82", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60-82|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60-82", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60-82|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60-82", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:60-82|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:60-82", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:18:77|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:18:77", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:16-22|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:16-22", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:16-22|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:16-22", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:16-22|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:16-22", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:27-33|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:27-33", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:27-33|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:27-33", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:27-33|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:27-33", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:27-33|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:27-33", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:29|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:29", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:5-6|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:5-6", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:5-6|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:5-6", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:19:5-6|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:19:5-6", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:115|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:115", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:115|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:115", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:115|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:115", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:17-18|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:17-18", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:17-18|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:17-18", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:17-18|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:17-18", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:5|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:5", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:5|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:5", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:59|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:59", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:59|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:59", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:59|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:59", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:66|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:66", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:66|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:66", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:66|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:66", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:67|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:67", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:20:67|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:20:67", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:107|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:107", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:30|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:30", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:30|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:30", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:30|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:30", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:30|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:30", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:34|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:34", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:68-71|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:68-71", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:68-71|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:68-71", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:68-71|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:68-71", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:76-77|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:76-77", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:76-77|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:76-77", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:76-77|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:76-77", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:96|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:96", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:21:96|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:21:96", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:32|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:32", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:32|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:32", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:32|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:32", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:37|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:37", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:37|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:37", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:40-41|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:40-41", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:46|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:46", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:22:52|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:22:52", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-13|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-13", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-13|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-13", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-13|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-13", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-13|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-13", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-14|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-14", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-14|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-14", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-14|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-14", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:23:12-14|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:23:12-14", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:11-20|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:11-20", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:11-20|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:11-20", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:31|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:31", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:31|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:31", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:31|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:31", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:31|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:31", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:35|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:35", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:4|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:24:4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:24:4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:16|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:16", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:16|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:16", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:16|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:16", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:18|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:18", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:18|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:18", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:18|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:18", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:20-21|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:20-21", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:20-21|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:20-21", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:20-21|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:20-21", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:22-24|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:22-24", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:22-24|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:22-24", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:22-24|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:22-24", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:23|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:23", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:23|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:23", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:27|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:27", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:27|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:27", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:27|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:27", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:34|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:34", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:34|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:34", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:34|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:34", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:38-39|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:38-39", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:38-39|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:38-39", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:38-39|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:38-39", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:40|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:40", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:40|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:40", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:41|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:41", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:41|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:41", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:42|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:42", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:42|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:42", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:44|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:44", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:44|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:44", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:80-84|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:80-84", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:80-84|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:80-84", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:82|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:82", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:27:82|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:27:82", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:14|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:14", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:14|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:14", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:14|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:14", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:20|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:20", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:20|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:20", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:20|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:20", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:41|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:41", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:41|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:41", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:29:41|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:29:41", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:102|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:102", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:102|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:102", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:102|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:102", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:102|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:102", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:102|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:102", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:127|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:127", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:127|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:127", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:127|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:127", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:158|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:158", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:158|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:158", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:158|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:158", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:158|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:158", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:177|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:177", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:177|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:177", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:184|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:184", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:184|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:184", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:184|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:184", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:221|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:221", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:221|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:221", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:229|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:229", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:234|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:234", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:234|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:234", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:234|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:234", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:234|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:234", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:248|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:248", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:248|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:248", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:253|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:253", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:253|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:253", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:253|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:253", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:255|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:255", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:255|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:255", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:255|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:255", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:256|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:256", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:26|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:26", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:26|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:26", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:26|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:26", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:260|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:260", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:260|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:260", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:260|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:260", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:260|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:260", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:260|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:260", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:275|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:275", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:276|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:276", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:276|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:276", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:279|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:279", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:279|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:279", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:279|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:279", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:282|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:282", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:282|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:282", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:282|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:282", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:282|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:282", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:282|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:282", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:29|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:29", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:29|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:29", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:29|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:29", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:30|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:30", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:30|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:30", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:30|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:30", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:30|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:30", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:87|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:87", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:87|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:87", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:2:87|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:2:87", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:30:41|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:30:41", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:30:41|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:30:41", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:21|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:21", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:21|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:21", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:21|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:21", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:28-29|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:28-29", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:28-29|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:28-29", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:28-29|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:28-29", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:40|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:40", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:40|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:40", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:53|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:53", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:56|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:56", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:56|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:56", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:56|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:56", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:33:6|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:33:6", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:35:43|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:35:43", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:35:43|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:35:43", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:35:43|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:35:43", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:36:1-83|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:36:1-83", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:36:1-83|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:36:1-83", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:36:68|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:36:68", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:36:68|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:36:68", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:36:68|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:36:68", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:102|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:102", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:102|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:102", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:102|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:102", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:103-107|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:103-107", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:103-107|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:103-107", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:103-107|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:103-107", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:142|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:142", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:142|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:142", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:145|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:145", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:145|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:145", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:65|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:65", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:65|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:65", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:37:65|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:37:65", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:38:41|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:38:41", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:38:41|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:38:41", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:38:41|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:38:41", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:14|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:14", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:14|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:14", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:155|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:155", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:155|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:155", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:173|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:173", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:173|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:173", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:173|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:173", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:185|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:185", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:185|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:185", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:185|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:185", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:45|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:45", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:45|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:45", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:45|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:45", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:46|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:46", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:50|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:50", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:50|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:50", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:50|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:50", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:55|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:55", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:55|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:55", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:55|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:55", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:55|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:55", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:55|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:55", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:59|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:59", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:64|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:64", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:64|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:64", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:7|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:7", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:7|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:7", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:93|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:93", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:97|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:97", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:97|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:97", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:3:97|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:3:97", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:41:53|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:41:53", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:41:53|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:41:53", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:59|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:59", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:59|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:59", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:59|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:59", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:61|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:61", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:61|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:61", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:61|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:61", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:61|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:61", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:43:61|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:43:61", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:45:32|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:45:32", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:45:32|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:45:32", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:45:32|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:45:32", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:47:19|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:47:19", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:47:19|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:47:19", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:48:10|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:48:10", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:48:10|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:48:10", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:48:10|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:48:10", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:48:29|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:48:29", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:48:29|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:48:29", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:49:13|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:49:13", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:49:13|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:49:13", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:49:17|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:49:17", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:49:17|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:49:17", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:1|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:1", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:1|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:1", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:1|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:1", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:11|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:11", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:11|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:11", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:11|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:11", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:129|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:129", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:129|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:129", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:157-158|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:157-158", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:157-158|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:157-158", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:157-158|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:157-158", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:157-158|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:157-158", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:159|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:159", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:159|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:159", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:159|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:159", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:159|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:159", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:171|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:171", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:171|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:171", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:171|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:171", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:19|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:19", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:19|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:19", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:19|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:19", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:24|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:24", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:24|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:24", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:24|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:24", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:28|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:28", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:28|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:28", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:28|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:28", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:3|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:3", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:3|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:3", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:43|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:43", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:43|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:43", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:43|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:43", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:6|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:6", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:6|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:6", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:6|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:6", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:82|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:82", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:82|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:82", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:86|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:86", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:86|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:86", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:4:86|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:4:86", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:50:19|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:50:19", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:50:19|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:50:19", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:50:22|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:50:22", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:50:22|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:50:22", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:49|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:49", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:49|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:49", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:49|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:49", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:56|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:56", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:56|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:56", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:51:56|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:51:56", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:1-4|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:1-4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:1-4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:1-4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:1-4|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:1-4", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:1-4|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:1-4", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:1-4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:1-4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:19-20|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:19-20", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:19-20|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:19-20", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:19-20|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:19-20", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:8|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:8", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:8|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:53:8|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:53:8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:54:1|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:54:1", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:54:1|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:54:1", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:54:1|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:54:1", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:57:13|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:57:13", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:57:13|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:57:13", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:57:16|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:57:16", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:57:16|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:57:16", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:58:22|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:58:22", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:58:22|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:58:22", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:58:22|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:58:22", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:58:22|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:58:22", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:58:22|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:58:22", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:6-7|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:6-7", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:6-7|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:6-7", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:6-7|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:6-7", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:7|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:7", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:7|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:7", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:59:7|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:59:7", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:110|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:110", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:112-115|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:112-115", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:112-115|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:112-115", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:112-115|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:112-115", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:112-115|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:112-115", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:112-115|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:112-115", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:116-118|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:116-118", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:116-118|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:116-118", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:116-118|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:116-118", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:117|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:117", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:117|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:117", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:117|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:117", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:117|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:117", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:2|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:2", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:2|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:2", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:27-31|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:27-31", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:27-31|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:27-31", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:31|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:31", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:31|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:31", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:32|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:32", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:32|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:32", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:33|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:33", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:33|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:33", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:33|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:33", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:38|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:38", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:38|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:38", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:4-5|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:4-5", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:4-5|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:4-5", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:45|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:45", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:45|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:45", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:45|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:45", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:5|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:5", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:5|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:5", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:5|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:5", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:67|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:67", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:67|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:67", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:67|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:67", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:67|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:67", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:67|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:67", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:75|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:75", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:75|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:75", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:75|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:75", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:96|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:96", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:5:96|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:5:96", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:60:10|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:60:10", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:60:10|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:60:10", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:60:10|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:60:10", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:63:1-11|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:63:1-11", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:1|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:1", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:2|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:2", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:2|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:2", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:2|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:2", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:3|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:3", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:3|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:3", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:3|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:3", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:65:4|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:65:4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:66:1|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:66:1", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:66:1|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:66:1", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:66:12|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:66:12", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:66:12|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:66:12", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:66:12|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:66:12", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:67:2|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:67:2", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:67:2|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:67:2", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:67:2|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:67:2", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:4|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:51|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:51", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:68:51|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:68:51", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:69:44-46|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:69:44-46", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:69:44-46|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:69:44-46", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:69:44-46|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:69:44-46", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:69:44-46|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:69:44-46", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:69:44-46|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:69:44-46", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:101|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:101", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:101|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:101", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:101|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:101", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:145|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:145", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:145|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:145", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:145|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:145", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:158|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:158", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:158|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:158", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:38|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:38", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:38|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:38", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:38|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:38", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:38|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:38", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:85-87|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:85-87", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:85-87|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:85-87", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:6:85-87|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:6:85-87", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:14|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:14", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:14|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:14", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:14|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:14", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:14|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:14", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:17|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:17", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:17|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:17", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:17|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:17", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:71:17|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:71:17", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:74:42-46|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:74:42-46", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:74:42-46|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:74:42-46", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:74:42-46|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:74:42-46", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:116|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:116", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:116|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:116", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:116|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:116", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:138|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:138", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:138|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:138", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:138|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:138", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:189-190|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:189-190", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:189-190|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:189-190", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:189-190|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:189-190", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:189-190|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:189-190", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:43|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:43", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:43|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:43", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:7:43|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:7:43", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:88:17-18|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:88:17-18", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:88:17-18|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:88:17-18", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:88:17-18|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:88:17-18", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:88:17-20|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:88:17-20", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:89:27-30|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:89:27-30", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:89:27-30|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:89:27-30", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:89:27-30|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:89:27-30", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:94:4|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:94:4", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:94:4|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:94:4", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:94:4|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:94:4", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:94:4|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:94:4", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:94:4|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:94:4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:96:15|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:96:15", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:96:15|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:96:15", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:96:15|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:96:15", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:96:15|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:96:15", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:96:15|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:96:15", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:1-3|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:1-3", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:1-3|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:1-3", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:30|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:30", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:30|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:30", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:30|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:30", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:30|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:30", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:31|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:31", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:31|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:31", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:31|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:31", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:37|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:37", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:37|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:37", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:38|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:38", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:38|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:38", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:38|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:38", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:92|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:92", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:92|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:92", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:97-99|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:97-99", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|quran:9:97-99|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "quran:9:97-99", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-karim-athari|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-majid|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-majid", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-majid|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-majid", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-majid|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-majid", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-qavi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-qavi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-qavi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-qavi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-qavi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-qavi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-al-judai|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-al-judai|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-al-judai|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-al-judai|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-al-judai|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-aliya|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-aliya", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-aliya|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-aliya", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-aliya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-aliya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-darda|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-darda", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-darda|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-darda", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-suud|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-suud", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-suud|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-suud", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-suud|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-suud", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-yaman|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-yaman|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-yaman|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-yaman|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-amr-al-dani|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-amr-al-dani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-amr-al-dani|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 1, "2018": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 27, "years": {"2015": 2, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 6, "2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 27}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2022": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hanifa|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibrahim|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibrahim|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibrahim|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibrahim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ibrahim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-mushir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-mushir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-mushir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-mushir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-mushir|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-mushir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-salih|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-salih", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-salih|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-salih", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala-al-farra|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala-al-farra|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala-al-farra|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-yusuf|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zahra|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zahra", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abu-zura|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abu-zura", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abul-kalam-azad|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abul-kalam-azad|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:abul-kalam-azad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adis-duderija|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adis-duderija", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adis-duderija|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adis-duderija", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adis-duderija|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adis-duderija", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:adnan-ibrahim|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-amin|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-amin", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 2, "2021": 5, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-shakir|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-shakir|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-shakir|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-shakir|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-shakir|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmed-deedat|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmed-deedat", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmed-deedat|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmed-deedat", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ahmed-deedat|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ahmed-deedat", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:aisha-bewley|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:aisha-bewley", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:aisha-bewley|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:aisha-bewley", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:akram-nadwi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-abhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-abhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-abhari|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-abhari", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-albani|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-albani", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-alusi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-alusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-alusi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-alusi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-alusi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-alusi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-amash|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-amash", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-asili|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-asili", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-asili|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-asili", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-asili|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-asili", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-asili|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-asili", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-asili|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-asili", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awni|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awni", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awni|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awni", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awni|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awni", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awzai|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awzai", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awzai|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awzai", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awzai|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awzai", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awzai|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awzai", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-awzai|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-awzai", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baghawi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baghawi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baji|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baji", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bajuri|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bajuri", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bajuri|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bajuri", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baqillani|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baqillani", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-barzanji|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-barzanji", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-barzanji|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-barzanji", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-barzanji|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-barzanji", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baydawi|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baydawi", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-baydawi|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-baydawi", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bayhaqi|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bazdawi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bazdawi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bazdawi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bazdawi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2018": 11, "2020": 1, "2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2016": 2, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-bukhari|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-bukhari", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-burzuli|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-burzuli", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dahhak|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dahhak", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dahhak|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dahhak", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dahhak|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dahhak", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daraqutni|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-darimi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-darimi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-darimi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-darimi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dasuqi|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dasuqi", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dasuqi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dasuqi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dasuqi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dasuqi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dawudi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dawudi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dawudi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dawudi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dawudi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dawudi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dawudi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dawudi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dawudi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dawudi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daylami|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daylami", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daylami|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daylami", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-daylami|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-daylami", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 7, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dhahabi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dimyati|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dimyati", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dimyati|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dimyati", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-dimyati|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-dimyati", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fakihani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fakihani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fakihani|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fakihani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fakihani|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fakihani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fakihani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fakihani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-fakihani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-fakihani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-farabi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-farabi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-firabri|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-firabri", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-firabri|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-firabri", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-firabri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-firabri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ghazali|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ghazali", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakam|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakam", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakam|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakam|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakam", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hallaj|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hallaj", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hallaj|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hallaj", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hallaj|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hallaj", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-harawi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-harawi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-harawi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-harawi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jahiz|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jahiz", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jayyani|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jayyani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jayyani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jayyani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jayyani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jayyani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jurjani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jurjani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-jurjani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-jurjani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-juwayni|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-juwayni", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-juwayni|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-juwayni", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-juwayni|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-juwayni", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kasani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kasani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kasani|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kasani", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kasani|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kasani", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khattabi|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khattabi", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khattabi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khattabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khattabi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khattabi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khattabi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khattabi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-khattabi|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-khattabi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kindi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kindi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kindi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kindi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kindi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kindi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kindi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kindi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kindi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kindi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kushmihani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kushmihani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-kushmihani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-kushmihani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-lakhmi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-maraghi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-maraghi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-maraghi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-maraghi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-maraghi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-maraghi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-marwazi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-marwazi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-marwazi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-marwazi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazari|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazari", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazini|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazini", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mazini|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mazini", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustaghfiri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustaghfiri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustaghfiri|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustaghfiri", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-mustamli|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-mustamli", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasafi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasafi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasafi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasafi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasafi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasafi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nasai|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nasai", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nawawi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nawawi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nuwayri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nuwayri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-nuwayri|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-nuwayri", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qabisi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qabisi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qabisi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qabisi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qabisi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qabisi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qabisi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qabisi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qabisi|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qabisi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qaffal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qaffal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qaffal|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qaffal", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qaffal|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qaffal", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qarafi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qarafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qarafi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qarafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qarafi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qarafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qarafi|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qarafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qastallani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qastallani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qastallani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qastallani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qastallani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qastallani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qurtubi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qushayri|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qushayri", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qushayri|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qushayri", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-qushayri|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-qushayri", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ruyani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ruyani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ruyani|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ruyani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-ruyani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-ruyani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sadafi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sadafi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sadafi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sadafi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-safarini|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-safarini", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-safarini|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-safarini", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-safarini|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-safarini", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-safarini|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-safarini", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-safarini|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-safarini", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-saghani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-saghani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-saghani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-saghani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-saghani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-saghani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sakhawi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sakhawi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sakhawi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-samarqandi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-samarqandi|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-samarqandi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-samarqandi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-samarqandi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sarakhsi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shabi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shabi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shabi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2015": 2, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shafii|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shafii", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sharawi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sharawi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sharawi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sharawi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sharawi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sharawi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-sharawi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-sharawi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 12, "start": 3044, "end": 3090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shatibi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shatibi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-shawkani|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-shawkani", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-suyuti|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-suyuti", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabarani|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabarani", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tabari|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tabari", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tahawi|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tahawi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-thaalibi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-thaalibi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-thaalibi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-thaalibi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-thalabi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-thalabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-thalabi|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-thalabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-thalabi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-thalabi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tibi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tibi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-tirmidhi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zamakhshari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zamakhshari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zamakhshari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zamakhshari|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zamakhshari|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zanati|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zanati", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zanati|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zanati", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zanati|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zanati", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 16, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 1, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:al-zuhri|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:al-zuhri", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-asim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-asim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-ibn-asim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-khamenei|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-khamenei", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-khamenei|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-khamenei", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-laraki|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-laraki", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ali-laraki|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ali-laraki", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ammar-nakshawani|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ammar-nakshawani", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ammar-nakshawani|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ammar-nakshawani", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:arif-abdulhussain|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:arif-abdulhussain|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:arif-abdulhussain|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asma-hilali|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asma-hilali", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asma-hilali|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asma-hilali", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asma-hilali|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asma-hilali", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:asrar-rashid|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:assim-al-hakeem|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:assim-al-hakeem", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 23, "start": 9393, "end": 9928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bakr-abu-zayd|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bakr-abu-zayd|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bakr-abu-zayd|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:behnam-sadeghi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:behnam-sadeghi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:behnam-sadeghi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:busr-ibn-said|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:busr-ibn-said", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:busr-ibn-said|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:busr-ibn-said", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:busr-ibn-said|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:busr-ibn-said", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:dawud-al-zahiri|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:dawud-al-zahiri", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:dawud-al-zahiri|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:dawud-al-zahiri", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:edip-yuksel|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:edip-yuksel", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:edip-yuksel|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:edip-yuksel", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:edip-yuksel|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:edip-yuksel", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:elisabeth-puin|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:elisabeth-puin", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:elisabeth-puin|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:elisabeth-puin", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:elisabeth-puin|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:elisabeth-puin", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 10, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:farabri|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:farabri", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:faruq-khan|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:faruq-khan", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:faruq-khan|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:faruq-khan", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fethullah-gulen|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fethullah-gulen", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:fethullah-gulen|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:fethullah-gulen", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:gerd-puin|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:gerd-puin", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:gerd-puin|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:gerd-puin", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-salama|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-salama|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-salama|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-al-kattani|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-al-kattani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-al-kattani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-maqbool|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hamza-yusuf|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-al-basri|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hassan-ali|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hassan-ali", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:humayd-al-tawil|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:humayd-al-tawil|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:humayd-al-tawil|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 14, "start": 4254, "end": 4482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-dhib|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-dhib", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-dhib|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-dhib", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-layla|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-layla", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-layla|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-layla", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-shayba|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-shayba|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-shayba|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-abidin|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-adi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-adi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-humam|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-humam|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-humam|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-humam|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jallab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jallab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jallab|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jallab", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jarud|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jarud|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jarud|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-jazari|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-jazari", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qasim|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qattan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qattan|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qattan|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-sakan|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-sakan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-sakan|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-sakan|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-al-salah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arabi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arafa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arafa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-arafa|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-arafa", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ashur|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-atiyya|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-azraq|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-azraq", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-azraq|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-azraq", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-azraq|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-azraq", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-bashkuwal|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-bashkuwal|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-bashkuwal|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-baz|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-baz", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-faris|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-faris", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-faris|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-faris", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghalbun|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghalbun|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghalbun|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghanim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghanim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghanim|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghanim", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ghanim|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ghanim", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 6, "2021": 4, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hazm|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hibban|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hurmuz|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hurmuz", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-hurmuz|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-hurmuz", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ishaq|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-jurayj|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-kathir|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khaldun|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-khuzayma|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-lubaba|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-lubaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-lubaba|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-lubaba", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-lubaba|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-lubaba", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-main|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-main", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-main|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-main", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-main|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-main", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-main|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-main", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-main|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-main", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-makula|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-makula", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-makula|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-makula", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-malik|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-malik|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-mujahid|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-mujahid", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-mujahid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-mujahid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-mujahid|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-mujahid", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-qudama|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-qudama|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-qudama|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-qudama|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-qudama|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushayd|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushayd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushayd|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushayd", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushayd|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushayd", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sina|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sina", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sina|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sina", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sina|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sina", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sina|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sina", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-sirin|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tahir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tahir|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tahir|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tahir|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tahir|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-taymiyya|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tufayl|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tufayl", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tufayl|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tufayl", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-tufayl|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-tufayl", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ulayya|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ulayya", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-ulayya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-ulayya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-uthaymin|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-uthaymin|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-uthaymin|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-waddah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-waddah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-waddah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-waddah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-wahb|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ikrima|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ikrima", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 6, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 7, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 2, "2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2019": 5, "2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2014": 4, "2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 28, "years": {"2014": 2, "2015": 2, "2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 4, "2021": 7, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 4, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2018": 7, "2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 9, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 20, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 6, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2014": 2, "2017": 3, "2018": 7, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 6, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 5, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 24, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 3, "2023": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 24}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-malik|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-malik", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imam-muslim|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imam-muslim", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-hosein|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-hosein", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-hosein|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-hosein", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-hosein|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-hosein", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-hosein|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-hosein", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:inayatullah-athari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:inayatullah-athari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:inayatullah-athari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:inayatullah-athari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:inayatullah-athari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:inayatullah-athari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:islam-al-buhayri|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:islam-al-buhayri", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:islam-al-buhayri|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:islam-al-buhayri", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-al-qadi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-al-qadi|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-al-qadi|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-patel|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-patel", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ismail-patel|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ismail-patel", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:israil-ibn-yunus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:israil-ibn-yunus|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:israil-ibn-yunus|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jamal-al-banna|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jamal-al-banna", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jamal-al-banna|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jamal-al-banna", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jaun-elia|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jaun-elia", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:jonathan-brown|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:joseph-lumbard|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:joseph-lumbard", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:joseph-lumbard|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:joseph-lumbard", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:joseph-lumbard|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:joseph-lumbard", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalid-al-jundi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalid-al-jundi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalid-al-jundi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalid-al-jundi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalid-al-madaini|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalid-al-madaini|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalid-al-madaini|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-ashur|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-ashur|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-ashur", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-ashur|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-ashur", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mahmud-shaltut|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:maimonides|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:maimonides", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:maimonides|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:maimonides", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:maimonides|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:maimonides", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mayyara|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mayyara", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mayyara|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mayyara", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mayyara|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mayyara", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 5, "2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 6, "start": 1270, "end": 1448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohamed-fizazi|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohamed-fizazi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohamed-fizazi|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohsen-goudarzi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohsen-goudarzi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mohsen-goudarzi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mufti-menk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mufti-menk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mufti-menk|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mufti-menk", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mufti-menk|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mufti-menk", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mufti-menk|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mufti-menk", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-abduh|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 6, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 4, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-iqbal|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-iqbal|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-iqbal|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-iqbal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-iqbal|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-naeem|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-naeem", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-naeem|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-naeem", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muhammad-naeem|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muhammad-naeem", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mujahid|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mujahid", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muqbil-al-wadii|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muqbil-al-wadii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muqbil-al-wadii|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:musab-al-zubayri|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:musab-al-zubayri", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:musab-al-zubayri|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:musab-al-zubayri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:mustafa-bin-hamza|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:mustafa-bin-hamza", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nafi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nafi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nafi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nafi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nafi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nafi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nafi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nafi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nafi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nouman-ali-khan|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nuh-keller|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nuh-keller", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nuh-keller|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nuh-keller", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:nuh-keller|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:nuh-keller", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 6, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:omar-suleiman|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-iyad|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-khan|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-khan|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qadi-khan|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qadi-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qatada|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qatada", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rabia-al-ray|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rami-nsour|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rami-nsour", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rami-nsour|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rami-nsour", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashad-khalifa|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashad-khalifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashad-khalifa|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashad-khalifa", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashad-khalifa|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashad-khalifa", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rashid-rida|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rashid-rida", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:rumi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:rumi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sahnun|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sahnun", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sahnun|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sahnun", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sahnun|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sahnun", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:salek-bin-siddina|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:salek-bin-siddina|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:salek-bin-siddina|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sanaullah-amritsari|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sanaullah-amritsari", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sanaullah-amritsari|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sanaullah-amritsari", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:saqib-shaami|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shabir-ally|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shabir-ally", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shabir-ally|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shabir-ally", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shabir-ally|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shabir-ally", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shabir-ally|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shabir-ally", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shadee-elmasry|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shady-nasser|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shady-nasser", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shady-nasser|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shady-nasser", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shah-wali-allah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shah-wali-allah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shah-wali-allah|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shah-wali-allah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shah-wali-allah|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shehzad-saleem|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shehzad-saleem", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shehzad-saleem|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shehzad-saleem", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sherman-jackson|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:shuba|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:shuba", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sibawayh|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sibawayh", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2016": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:suhaib-webb|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:suhaib-webb", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:suhaib-webb|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:suhaib-webb", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tamanna-imadi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tamanna-imadi|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tamanna-imadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tamanna-imadi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tamanna-imadi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:taqi-usmani|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:taqi-usmani", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:taqi-usmani|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:taqi-usmani", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:taqi-usmani|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:taqi-usmani", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-jamil|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-jamil|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-jamil|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-jamil|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-masood|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-masood", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-masood|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-masood", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-masood|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-masood", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-masood|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-masood", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tariq-masood|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tariq-masood", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:tawus|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:tawus", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:thabit-al-bunani|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:thabit-al-bunani|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:thabit-al-bunani|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:thabit-ibn-umara|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:thabit-ibn-umara", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:thabit-ibn-umara|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:thabit-ibn-umara", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:usama-canon|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:usama-canon", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:usama-canon|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:usama-canon", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:usama-canon|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:usama-canon", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-adam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-adam|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-adam|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 49, "years": {"2018": 16, "2019": 9, "2020": 11, "2021": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 49}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 1, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasir-qadhi|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasmin-amin|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasmin-amin", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasser-al-habib|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasser-al-habib", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasser-al-habib|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasser-al-habib", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yasser-al-habib|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yasser-al-habib", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunini|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunini", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunini|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunini", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunini|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunini", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zaid-shakir|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zaid-shakir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zaid-shakir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zaid-shakir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakaullah-saleem|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakaullah-saleem|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakaullah-saleem|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zakir-naik|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zakir-naik", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zayn-al-abidin|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zufar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zufar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|scholar:zufar|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "scholar:zufar", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 27, "start": 10196, "end": 10262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adab|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adalat-al-sahaba|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adalat-al-sahaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adalat-al-sahaba|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adalat-al-sahaba", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adalat-al-sahaba|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adalat-al-sahaba", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhab|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhab", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhab|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhab", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhab|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhab", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:adhan|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:adhan", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahad|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahad", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahd-dhihni|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahd-dhihni", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahd-dhihni|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahd-dhihni", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahd-dhihni|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahd-dhihni", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-bayt|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-hadith|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-hadith", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-hadith|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-hadith|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-hadith", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-kitab|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-kitab|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-kitab|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-kitab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-kitab|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-ray|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-ray", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-ray|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-ray", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-sunnah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-sunnah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ahl-al-sunnah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ahl-al-sunnah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:akhirah|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:akhirah", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-andalus|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-andalus", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-ayn|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-ayn", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-ayn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-ayn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-ayn|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-ayn", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-ayn|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-ayn", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-insan-madani|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-insan-madani", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-insan-madani|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-insan-madani", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-kitab|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-kitab", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-kitab|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-kitab", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-lat|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-lat", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-lat|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-lat", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-rahman-al-rahim|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-rahman-al-rahim", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 18, "start": 4055, "end": 4213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-razzaq|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-razzaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-razzaq|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-razzaq", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-wala-wal-bara|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-wala-wal-bara", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:al-wala-wal-bara|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:al-wala-wal-bara", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:almah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:almah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:almah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:almah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:almah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:almah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:am|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:am", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:am|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:am", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:am|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:am", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amah|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amah|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amanita-muscaria|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amanita-muscaria", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amanita-muscaria|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amanita-muscaria", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amanita-muscaria|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amanita-muscaria", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ambiguous-picture-effect|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ambiguous-picture-effect|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ambiguous-picture-effect|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amir-al-muminin|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amir-al-muminin", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:amir-al-muminin|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:amir-al-muminin", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ansar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ansar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ansar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ansar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ansar|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ansar", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aphantasia|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aphantasia", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aphantasia|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aphantasia", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aphantasia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aphantasia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqidah|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqidah", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqiqah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqiqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqiqah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqiqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqiqah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqiqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqiqah|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqiqah", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aqiqah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aqiqah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:aql|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:aql", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:arafah|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:arafah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:arafah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:arafah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:arafah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:arafah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:asbab|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:asbab", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:asbab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:asbab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:asbab-al-nuzul|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:asbab-al-nuzul", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:asbab-al-nuzul|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:asbab-al-nuzul", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:asbab-al-nuzul|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:asbab-al-nuzul", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashari|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashari", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashrat-al-saah|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashrat-al-saah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashrat-al-saah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashrat-al-saah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashura|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashura", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ashura|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ashura", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:athari|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:athari", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:athari|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:athari", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:athari|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:athari", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:athari|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:athari", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:athari|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:athari", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:awrah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:awrah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayahuasca|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayahuasca", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayahuasca|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayahuasca", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayahuasca|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayahuasca", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayat-al-kursi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayat-al-kursi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayat-al-kursi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayat-al-kursi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ayat-al-kursi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ayat-al-kursi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:azariqa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:azariqa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:azariqa|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:azariqa", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:baalshamin|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:baalshamin", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:baalshamin|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:baalshamin", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:backfire-effect|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:backfire-effect", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:backfire-effect|topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:backfire-effect", "target": "topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bala|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bala", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bala|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bala", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bala|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bala", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:balagha|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:balagha", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:balagha|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:balagha", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:balagha|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:balagha", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:balagha|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:balagha", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:balagha|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:balagha", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bani-israil|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bani-israil", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bara|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bara", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bara|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bara", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barakah|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barakah", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barakah|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barakah", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barakah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barakah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barakah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barakah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barakah|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barakah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barelvi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barelvi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barzakh|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barzakh", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barzakh|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barzakh", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:barzakh|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:barzakh", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bashar|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bashar", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bashar|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bashar", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bashar|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bashar", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:batil-and-fasid|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:batil-and-fasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:batil-and-fasid|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:batil-and-fasid", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayt-al-mal|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayt-al-mal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayt-al-mal|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayt-al-mal", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bayt-al-mal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bayt-al-mal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 4, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bidah|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bidah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bimaristan|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bimaristan", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bimaristan|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bimaristan", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bimaristan|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bimaristan", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bismillah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bismillah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bismillah|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bismillah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:bismillah|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:bismillah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:cannabis|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:cannabis", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 53, "start": 11148, "end": 11303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:cannabis|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:cannabis", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:cannabis|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:cannabis", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:capgras-delusion|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:capgras-delusion", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:capgras-delusion|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:capgras-delusion", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:capgras-delusion|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:capgras-delusion", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:charles-bonnet-syndrome|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:charles-bonnet-syndrome|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:charles-bonnet-syndrome|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:collective-consciousness|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:collective-consciousness", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:daif|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:daif", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 7, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dajjal|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dajjal", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-harb|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-harb", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-harb|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-harb", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-harb|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-harb", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-harb|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-harb", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-harb|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-harb", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-ifta|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-ifta", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-ifta|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-ifta", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-islam|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-islam", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dar-al-islam|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dar-al-islam", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dawah|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dawah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deen|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deen", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 24, "start": 7205, "end": 7365, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:deobandi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:deobandi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhabiha|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhabiha", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhabiha|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhabiha", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhabiha|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhabiha", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhabiha|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhabiha", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhikr|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhikr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhul-qarnayn|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhul-qarnayn|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dhul-qarnayn|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 21, "start": 4472, "end": 4500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dinar|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dinar", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dinar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dinar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dirham|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dirham", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dirham|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dirham", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dissociative-identity-disorder|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dissociative-identity-disorder|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dissociative-identity-disorder|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:diya|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:diya", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:diya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:diya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:diya|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:diya", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dmt|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dmt", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dome-of-the-rock|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dome-of-the-rock", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dome-of-the-rock|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dome-of-the-rock", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dome-of-the-rock|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dome-of-the-rock", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dua|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dua", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dunya|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dunya", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dunya|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dunya", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dunya|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dunya", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dushara|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dushara", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:dushara|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:dushara", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:el|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:el", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:el|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:el", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:el|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:el", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:electromagnetic-spectrum|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:electromagnetic-spectrum", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:electromagnetic-spectrum|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:electromagnetic-spectrum", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:entheogen|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:entheogen", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:entheogen|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:entheogen", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:entheogen|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:entheogen", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:entheogen|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:entheogen", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:entheogen|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:entheogen", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ergot|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ergot", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ergot|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ergot", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ergot|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ergot", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:evolution|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:evolution", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:evolution|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:evolution", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:evolution|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:evolution", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fadak|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fadak", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fajr|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fajr", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fajr|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fajr", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fajr|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fajr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fana|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fana", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fana|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fana", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fana|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fana", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:faqih|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:faqih", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:faqih|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:faqih", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fard-kifayah|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fard-kifayah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatayat|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatayat", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatayat|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatayat", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatayat|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatayat", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fatwa|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fatwa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fay|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fay", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fay|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fay", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fay|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fay", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fay|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fay", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:female-genital-mutilation|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:female-genital-mutilation", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:female-genital-mutilation|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:female-genital-mutilation", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:female-genital-mutilation|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:female-genital-mutilation", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fidya|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fidya", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fidya|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fidya", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fidya|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fidya", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fiqh|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fiqh", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitnah|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitnah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitrah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:fitrah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:fitrah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:foreign-accent-syndrome|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:foreign-accent-syndrome|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:foreign-accent-syndrome|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:gharaniq|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:gharaniq", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghayb|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghayb", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghayb|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghayb", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghayb|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghayb", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghina|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghina", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghina|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghina", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghina|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghina", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghuluw|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghuluw", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghuluw|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghuluw", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghuluw|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghuluw", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghusl|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghusl", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghusl|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghusl", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ghusl|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ghusl", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:god-of-the-gaps|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:god-of-the-gaps", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:god-of-the-gaps|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:god-of-the-gaps", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:god-of-the-gaps|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:god-of-the-gaps", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadith|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadith|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadith", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadith|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadiyya|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadiyya|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadiyya|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadiyya", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadra|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadra", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadra|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadra", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hadra|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hadra", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajar-al-aswad|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajar-al-aswad", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajar-al-aswad|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajar-al-aswad", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajar-al-aswad|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajar-al-aswad", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hajj|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hajj", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halal|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halal", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halala|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halala", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halala|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halala", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:halala|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:halala", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanafi|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanafi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hanbali|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hanbali", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2014": 2, "2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2019": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haram|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haram", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:harmala|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:harmala", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hasad|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hasad", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hasad|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hasad", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hasad|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hasad", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hasad|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hasad", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:haya|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:haya", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hayd|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hayd", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hayd|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hayd", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hayd|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hayd", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hayd|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hayd", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hayd|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hayd", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:heisenberg-uncertainty-principle|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:heisenberg-uncertainty-principle", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hemispatial-neglect|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hemispatial-neglect", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hemispatial-neglect|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hemispatial-neglect", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hemispatial-neglect|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hemispatial-neglect", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hifz|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hifz", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijab|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijama|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijama", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijama|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijama", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hijrah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hijrah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hikmah|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hikmah", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hinduism|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hinduism", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hinduism|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hinduism", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hinduism|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hinduism", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hinduism|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hinduism", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hinduism|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hinduism", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hirz|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hirz", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hirz|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hirz", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hisbah|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hisbah", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hiyal|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hiyal", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hubal|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hubal", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hubal|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hubal", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudhud|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudhud", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudhud|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudhud", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudhud|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudhud", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudhud|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudhud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hudud|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hudud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hunafa|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hunafa", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:hunafa|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:hunafa", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibadi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibadi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibaha|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibaha|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibaha|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibaha|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ibaha|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ibaha", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iddah|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iddah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idraj|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idraj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idraj|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idraj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idraj|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idraj", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:idtirab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:idtirab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ifrit|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ifrit", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ifrit|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ifrit", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ifrit|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ifrit", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihram|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihram", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihram|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihram", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihram|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihram", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihtimal|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihtimal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihtimal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihtimal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ihtimal|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ihtimal", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijazah|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijazah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijma|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijma", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ijtihad|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ijtihad", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ikhtilaf|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ikhtilaf", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilal|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilal|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilal", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilal|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilal", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilgha|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilgha", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ilgha|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ilgha", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:illah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:illah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:illah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:illah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:illiyyin|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:illiyyin", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:illiyyin|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:illiyyin", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:imam|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:imam", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:imam|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:imam", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:imamah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:imamah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:imamah|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:imamah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:imamah|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:imamah", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iman|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iman", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:insan|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:insan", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:insan|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:insan", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:insan|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:insan", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:insan|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:insan", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:insan|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:insan", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iradah|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iradah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iradah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iradah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:iradah|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:iradah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isaf-and-naila|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isaf-and-naila", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isaf-and-naila|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isaf-and-naila", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isbal|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isbal|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isbal|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isbal|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isbal", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isha|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isha", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isha|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isha", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isha|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isha", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ismaili|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ismaili", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isnad|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isnad", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isra|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isra", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isra|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isra", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:isra|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:isra", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:israiliyyat|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:israiliyyat", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istikhara|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istikhara", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istikhara|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istikhara", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istikhara|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istikhara", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istikhara|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istikhara", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istikhara|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istikhara", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istishab|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istishab", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istishab|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istishab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istitabah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istitabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istitabah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istitabah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istitabah|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istitabah", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:istitabah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:istitabah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:izar|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:izar", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahannam|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahannam", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahannam|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahannam", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahannam|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahannam", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahil|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahil", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahil|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahil", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahil|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahil", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahil|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahil", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahil|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahil", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jahiliyya|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jahiliyya", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jam|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jam", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jam|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jam", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jam|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jam", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:janazah|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:janazah", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:janazah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:janazah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:janazah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:janazah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:janazah|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:janazah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:janazah|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:janazah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}, {"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jannah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jannah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jarh-wa-tadil|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jarh-wa-tadil|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jarh-wa-tadil|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jarh-wa-tadil|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jarh-wa-tadil|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jariyah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jariyah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jayb|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jayb", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jayb|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jayb", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jihad|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jihad", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jihad|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jihad", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jihad|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jihad", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jihad|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jihad", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jihad|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jihad", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 19, "years": {"2017": 9, "2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jinn|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jinn", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jizya|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jizya", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jubbah|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jubbah", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jubbah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jubbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:jumuah|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:jumuah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:juz|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:juz", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:juz|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:juz", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:juz|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:juz", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:juz|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:juz", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:juz|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:juz", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaaba|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaaba", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaffarah|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaffarah", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kaffarah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kaffarah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kafir|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kafir", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kahl|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kahl", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-allah|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-allah", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-lafzi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-lafzi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-lafzi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-lafzi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-lafzi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-lafzi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-nafsi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-nafsi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-nafsi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-nafsi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalam-nafsi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalam-nafsi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalimat-allah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalimat-allah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalimat-allah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalimat-allah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalimat-allah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalimat-allah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kalimat-allah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kalimat-allah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:karamah|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:karamah", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:karamah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:karamah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:karamah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:karamah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:karamah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:karamah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kashmir|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kashmir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kashmir|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kashmir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khalifah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khalifah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2016": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khamr|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khamr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khars|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khars", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khars|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khars", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khars|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khars", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatm-al-nubuwwa|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatm-al-nubuwwa|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khatm-al-nubuwwa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khawarij|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khawarij", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khazz|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khazz", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khazz|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khazz", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khimar|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khimar", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khimar|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khimar", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khul|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khul", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuntha|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuntha", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khususiyya|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khususiyya", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khususiyya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khususiyya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khususiyya|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khususiyya", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khutbah|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khutbah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuyala|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuyala", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuyala|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuyala", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:khuyala|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:khuyala", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kibr|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kibr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kibr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kibr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kibr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kibr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kohl|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kohl", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kohl|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kohl", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kohl|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kohl", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kohl|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kohl", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kufr|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kufr", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kun-fayakun|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kun-fayakun", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kun-fayakun|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kun-fayakun", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kun-fayakun|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kun-fayakun", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kunya|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kunya", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kunya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kunya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kunya|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kunya", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kunya|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kunya", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kunya|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kunya", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kutub-al-sittah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kutub-al-sittah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kutub-al-sittah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kutub-al-sittah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:kutub-al-sittah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:kutub-al-sittah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lataif|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lataif", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lataif|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lataif", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lataif|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lataif", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lihyah|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lihyah", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lsd|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lsd", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lsd|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lsd", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:lsd|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:lsd", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:luti|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:luti", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:luti|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:luti", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:luti|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:luti", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ma-malakat-aymanukum|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ma-malakat-aymanukum|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ma-malakat-aymanukum|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ma-malakat-aymanukum|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maazif|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maazif", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2014": 4, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madhhab|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madhhab", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madinah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madinah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madinah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madinah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:madrasa|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:madrasa", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahdi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahdi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahid|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahid", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahid|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahid", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahid|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahid", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahr|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahr", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mahram|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mahram", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majhul|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majhul", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majhul|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majhul", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majhul|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majhul", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majhul|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majhul", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majhul|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majhul", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:majus|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:majus", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhda|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhda", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhda|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhda", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhda|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhda", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhda|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhda", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhluq|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhluq", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhluq|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhluq", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makhluq|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makhluq", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makkah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makkah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makkah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makkah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 2, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}, {"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2015": 4, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 3, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:makruh|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:makruh", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:malaika|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:malaika", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:malaika|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:malaika", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 3, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2014": 3, "2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 31, "years": {"2014": 5, "2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 4, "2019": 3, "2020": 6, "2021": 8, "2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}, {"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 3, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maliki|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maliki", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mandub|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mandub", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mandub|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mandub", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mao-inhibitor|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mao-inhibitor", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mao-inhibitor|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mao-inhibitor", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mao-inhibitor|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mao-inhibitor", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maqasid|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maqasid", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:marja|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:marja", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:marja|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:marja", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masala|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masala", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masala|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masala", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masala|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masala", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-aqsa|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-haram|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-haram", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-haram|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-haram", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-nabawi|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-nabawi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-nabawi|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-nabawi|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:masjid-al-nabawi|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maslaha|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maslaha", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matam|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matam", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matam|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matam", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matn|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matn", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matn|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matn", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matn|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matn", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:matn|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:matn", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maturidi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maturidi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maulana|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maulana", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maulana|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maulana", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maulana|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maulana", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maulana|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maulana", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawadda|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawadda", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawadda|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawadda", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawadda|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawadda", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawali|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawali", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawali|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawali", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawali|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawali", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawdu|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawdu", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawdu|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawdu", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawlid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawlid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawlid|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawlid|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawlid|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mawlid|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mawlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maysir|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maysir", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:maysir|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:maysir", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:minbar|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:minbar", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:minbar|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:minbar", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:minbar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:minbar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:minbar|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:minbar", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:minbar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:minbar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mirath|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mirath", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mirath|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mirath", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mirath|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mirath", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:miswak|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:miswak", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:miswak|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:miswak", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muallaqat|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muallaqat", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muallaqat|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muallaqat", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muallaqat|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muallaqat", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muallaqat|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muallaqat", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muallaqat|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muallaqat", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muawwidhatayn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muawwidhatayn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muawwidhatayn|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muawwidhatayn", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muawwidhatayn|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muawwidhatayn", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muawwidhatayn|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muawwidhatayn", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muawwidhatayn|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muawwidhatayn", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mubahala|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mubahala", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mubahala|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mubahala", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mubham|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mubham", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mubham|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mubham", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mubham|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mubham", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufassirun|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufassirun", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mufti|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mufti", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhajirun|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhajirun", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhajirun|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhajirun", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhajirun|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhajirun", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhdath|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhdath", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhdath|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhdath", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhdath|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhdath", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhdath|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhdath", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:muhdath|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:muhdath", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mujizah|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mujizah", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mujizah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mujizah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mukallaf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mukallaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mukallaf|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mukallaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munafiqun|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munafiqun", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munkar|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munkar", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munkar|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munkar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munkar|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munkar", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munkar|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munkar", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:munkar|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:munkar", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murid|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murid", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murid|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murid", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murid|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murid", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murjia|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murjia", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murjia|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murjia", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:murjia|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:murjia", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mursal|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mursal", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushaf|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushaf", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushkil|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushkil", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushkil|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushkil", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushkil|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushkil", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mushrikin|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mushrikin", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutakallimun|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutakallimun", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutakallimun|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutakallimun", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutakallimun|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutakallimun", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutashabih|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutashabih", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutashabih|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutashabih", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutashabih|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutashabih", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutashabih|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutashabih", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 7, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutawatir|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutawatir", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 5, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:mutazila|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:mutazila", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabi|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabi", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabi|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabi", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nabidh|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nabidh", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafl|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafl", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafs", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafs|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafs", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nafs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nafs", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:najasa|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:najasa", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nasi|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nasi", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nasi|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nasi", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:naskh|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:naskh", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nawazil|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nawazil", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nawazil|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nawazil", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nazar|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nazar", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nazar|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nazar", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nazar|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nazar", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nazar|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nazar", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nazar|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nazar", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neo-traditionalism|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neo-traditionalism", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neo-traditionalism|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neo-traditionalism", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neo-traditionalism|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neo-traditionalism", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neo-traditionalism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neo-traditionalism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neo-traditionalism|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neo-traditionalism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neoplatonism|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neoplatonism", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:neoplatonism|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:neoplatonism", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ney|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ney", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ney|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ney", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ney|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ney", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nifas|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nifas", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nifas|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nifas", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nifas|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nifas", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 16, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 2, "2018": 4, "2019": 6, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-misyar|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-misyar", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nikah-misyar|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nikah-misyar", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:niqab|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:niqab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisa|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisab|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisab", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nisab|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nisab", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nocebo-effect|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nocebo-effect", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nocebo-effect|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nocebo-effect", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nocebo-effect|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nocebo-effect", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:non-propositional-faith|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:non-propositional-faith", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:non-propositional-faith|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:non-propositional-faith", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:non-propositional-faith|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:non-propositional-faith", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nun-al-tawkid|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nun-al-tawkid", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:nun-al-tawkid|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:nun-al-tawkid", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:oppositional-defiant-disorder|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:oppositional-defiant-disorder", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:oppositional-defiant-disorder|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:oppositional-defiant-disorder", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:palimpsest|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:palimpsest", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:palimpsest|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:palimpsest", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 8, "start": 1327, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:palinopsia|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:palinopsia", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:palinopsia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:palinopsia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:palinopsia|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:palinopsia", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:petra-thesis|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:petra-thesis", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:petra-thesis|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:petra-thesis", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:petra-thesis|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:petra-thesis", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:petra-thesis|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:petra-thesis", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:phantom-pregnancy|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:phantom-pregnancy", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:phantom-pregnancy|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:phantom-pregnancy", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:phantom-pregnancy|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:phantom-pregnancy", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:pir|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:pir", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:pir|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:pir", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:pir|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:pir", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:pir|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:pir", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:pir|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:pir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:placebo-effect|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:placebo-effect", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:placebo-effect|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:placebo-effect", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:placebo-effect|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:placebo-effect", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 15, "start": 5381, "end": 5461, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:polygamy|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:polygamy", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:propinquity-effect|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:propinquity-effect", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:propinquity-effect|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:propinquity-effect", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:propinquity-effect|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:propinquity-effect", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:prosopagnosia|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:prosopagnosia", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:prosopagnosia|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:prosopagnosia", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:prosopagnosia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:prosopagnosia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:prosopagnosia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:prosopagnosia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:prosopagnosia|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:prosopagnosia", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:psilocybin|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:psilocybin", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:psilocybin|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:psilocybin", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:psilocybin|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:psilocybin", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:psilocybin|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:psilocybin", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qabd|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qabd", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qabd|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qabd", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qabd|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qabd", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qada|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qada", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qada|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qada", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qada|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qada", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qada|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qada", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qada|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qada", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadar|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadar", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadhf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadhf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadhf|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadhf", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadhf|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadhf", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qadi|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qadi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qati|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qati", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qaza|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qaza", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qaza|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qaza", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiblah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiblah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiraat|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiraat", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiraat|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiraat", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiraat|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiraat", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiraat|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiraat", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiyas|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiyas", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qiyas|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qiyas", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qunut|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qunut", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qunut|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qunut", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qura|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qura", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qura|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qura", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:qura|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:qura", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quran|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quran", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quran|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quran", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quran|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quran", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 4, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:quranist|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:quranist", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rabb|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rabb", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rabb|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rabb", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rabb|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rabb", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rada|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rada", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rada|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rada", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rada|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rada", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rada|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rada", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rada|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rada", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raf-al-yadayn|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rakah|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rakah", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rakah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rakah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rakah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rakah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rakah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rakah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ramadan|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ramadan", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ramadan|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ramadan", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raqi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raqi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raqi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raqi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raqi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raqi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raqi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raqi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:raqi|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:raqi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rashidun|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rashidun", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rashidun|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rashidun", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rashidun|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rashidun", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rashidun|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rashidun", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rasm-uthmani|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rasm-uthmani", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rasm-uthmani|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rasm-uthmani", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rasm-uthmani|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rasm-uthmani", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rasm-uthmani|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rasm-uthmani", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 16, "years": {"2017": 12, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 124, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 8, "start": 1852, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-fadl|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-fadl", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-fadl|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-fadl", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-fadl|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-fadl", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-jahiliyyah|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-jahiliyyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-jahiliyyah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-jahiliyyah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-nasia|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-nasia", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-nasia|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-nasia", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riba-al-nasia|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riba-al-nasia", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riddah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riddah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riddah|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riddah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riddah|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riddah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riddah|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riddah", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rijal|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rijal", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rijal|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rijal", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rijal|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rijal", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riwaya-bil-mana|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riwaya-bil-mana|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riwaya-bil-mana|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riwaya-bil-mana|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:riwaya-bil-mana|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rizq|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rizq", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh-al-qudus|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh-al-qudus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh-al-qudus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruh-al-qudus|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:rukhsah|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:rukhsah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 4, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruqya|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruqya", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruya|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruya", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruya|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruya", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruya|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruya", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruya|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruya", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ruya|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ruya", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadaqah|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadaqah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadl|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadl", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadl|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadl", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadl|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadl", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadl|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadl", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sadl|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sadl", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahaba|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahaba", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahabah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahabah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sahih|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sahih", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sakinah|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sakinah", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sakinah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sakinah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salaf|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salaf", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 29, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 5, "2020": 8, "2021": 9, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 29}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 14, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salafi|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salafi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:salah|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:salah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sama|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sama", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sama|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sama", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sana|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sana", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sana|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sana", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sana|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sana", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sard-al-hadith|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sard-al-hadith", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sard-al-hadith|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sard-al-hadith", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sard-al-hadith|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sard-al-hadith", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sarih|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sarih", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sarih|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sarih", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sawm|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sawm", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 10, "start": 2082, "end": 2232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sawm|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sawm", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sawm|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sawm", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sawm|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sawm", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafaah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafaah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafaah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafaah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafaah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafaah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafaqa|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafaqa", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafaqa|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafaqa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shafii|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shafii", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shahadat-al-sibyan|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shahadat-al-sibyan", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shahadat-al-sibyan|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shahadat-al-sibyan", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sharia|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sharia", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sharia|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sharia", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sharia|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sharia", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shariah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shariah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sharif|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sharif", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 13, "start": 2540, "end": 2698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3, "2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shaytan|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shaytan", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 4, "2020": 7, "2021": 8, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shia|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shia", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shifa|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shifa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shirk|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shirk", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shukr|topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shukr", "target": "topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shukr|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shukr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shura|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shura", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:shura|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:shura", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sidrat-al-muntaha|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sidrat-al-muntaha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sidrat-al-muntaha|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sidrat-al-muntaha", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sifat|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sifat", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sifat|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sifat", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sifat|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sifat", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sifat|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sifat", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sifat|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sifat", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sihr|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sihr", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sijjin|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sijjin", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sijjin|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sijjin", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:silsilat-al-dhahab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:silsilat-al-dhahab|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:silsilat-al-dhahab|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:silsilat-al-dhahab|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:silsilat-al-dhahab|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sirah|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sirah", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sirah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sirah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sirah|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sirah", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:soma|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:soma", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:soma|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:soma", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:soma|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:soma", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:stoned-ape-theory|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:stoned-ape-theory", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:stoned-ape-theory|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:stoned-ape-theory", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:stoned-ape-theory|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:stoned-ape-theory", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sufi|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sufi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud-al-sahw|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud-al-sahw", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sujud-al-sahw|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sujud-al-sahw", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 2, "2023": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnah|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnat-allah|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnat-allah", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnat-allah|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnat-allah", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnat-allah|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnat-allah", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunnat-allah|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunnat-allah", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:sunni|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:sunni", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabiun|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabiun", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabut|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabut", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tabut|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tabut", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 11, "2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tadlis|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tadlis", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafliya|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafliya", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafliya|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafliya", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafliya|topic:history/companions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafliya", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafsir|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafsir", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafsir|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafsir", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafsir|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafsir", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafsir|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafsir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tafsir|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tafsir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahajjud|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahajjud", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahajjud|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahajjud", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahajjud|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahajjud", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahajjud|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahajjud", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahiyyat-al-masjid|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahiyyat-al-masjid|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tahiyyat-al-masjid|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tajsim|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tajsim", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takbir|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takbir", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takbir|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takbir", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takbir|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takbir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2015": 2, "2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:takfir|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:takfir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taklif|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taklif", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taklif|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taklif", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taklif|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taklif", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taklif|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taklif", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taklif|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taklif", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 6, "start": 1428, "end": 1506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:talaq|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:talaq", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqlid|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqlid", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:taqwa|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:taqwa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tarawih|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tarawih", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tariqah|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tariqah", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tariqah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tariqah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tariqah|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tariqah", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tariqah|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tariqah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tasawwuf|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tasawwuf", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tashahhud|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tashahhud", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tashahhud|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tashahhud", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawaf|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawaf|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawaf", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawakkul|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawakkul", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawakkul|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawakkul", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawakkul|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawakkul", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawakkul|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawakkul", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawakkul|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawakkul", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawbah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawbah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawbah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawbah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawbah|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawbah", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawbah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawbah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawhid|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawhid", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawiz|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawiz", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tawiz|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tawiz", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tayammum|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tayammum", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tayammum|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tayammum", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tayf|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tayf", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tayf|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tayf", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tayf|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tayf", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:thawb|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:thawb", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:thawb|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:thawb", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:thawb|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:thawb", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:thawb|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:thawb", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tiyara|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tiyara", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tiyara|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tiyara", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:tiyara|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:tiyara", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:trinity|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:trinity", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:twelve-imams|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:twelve-imams", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:twelve-imams|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:twelve-imams", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:twelve-imams|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:twelve-imams", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:two-state-solution|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:two-state-solution", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 26, "start": 6556, "end": 6869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:udhiyah|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:udhiyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:udhiyah|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:udhiyah", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:ulama|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:ulama", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umm-al-qura|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umm-al-qura", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umm-al-qura|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umm-al-qura", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umrah|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umrah", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umrah|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umrah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umrah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umrah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umrah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:umrah|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:umrah", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:urf|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:urf", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:urf|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:urf", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:urf|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:urf", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:urf|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:urf", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:urf|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:urf", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:usul-al-fiqh|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:virgin-birth|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:virgin-birth", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahhabi|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahhabi", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wahy|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wahy", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wajib|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wajib", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wajib|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wajib", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wali|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wali", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waqf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waqf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waqf|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waqf", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waqf|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waqf", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:waswasa|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:waswasa", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wijada|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wijada", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wijada|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wijada", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 12, "start": 2310, "end": 2427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:wudu|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:wudu", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yahweh|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yahweh", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yahweh|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yahweh", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yahweh|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yahweh", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yahweh|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yahweh", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yahweh|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yahweh", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-and-majuj|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-and-majuj|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-and-majuj|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-and-majuj|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yajuj-wa-majuj|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yaqin|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yaqin", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yaqin|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yaqin", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yataarrad|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yataarrad", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yataarrad|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yataarrad", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:yataarrad|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:yataarrad", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zahir-al-riwaya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zahir-al-riwaya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zahir-al-riwaya|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zahir-al-riwaya", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zahiri|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zahiri", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zahiri|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zahiri", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zahiri|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zahiri", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 32, "start": 9037, "end": 9187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat-al-fitr|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat-al-fitr", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat-al-fitr|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat-al-fitr", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zakat-al-fitr|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zakat-al-fitr", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zamzam|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zamzam", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zamzam|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zamzam", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zamzam|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zamzam", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zanni|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zanni", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zanni|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zanni", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zanni|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zanni", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zanni|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zanni", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zanni|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zanni", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaqqum|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaqqum", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaqqum|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaqqum", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaqqum|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaqqum", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaydi|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaydi", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaydi|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaydi", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zaydi|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zaydi", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zifaf|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zifaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zifaf|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zifaf", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zifaf|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zifaf", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zina|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zina", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zindiq|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zindiq", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zoroastrianism|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zoroastrianism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zoroastrianism|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zoroastrianism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cited_on|term:zuhd|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "cited_on", "source": "term:zuhd", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|book:sunan-al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|hadith:fp:0058fc99", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "hadith:fp:0058fc99", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|hadith:fp:185e7f9a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "hadith:fp:185e7f9a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|hadith:fp:e180f02c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "hadith:fp:e180f02c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|person:zayd-ibn-thabit", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "person:zayd-ibn-thabit", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|scholar:al-qasim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "scholar:al-qasim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|scholar:nafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "scholar:nafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|scholar:ubaydullah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "scholar:ubaydullah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|term:ibaha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "term:ibaha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--OJasWltLU|term:qaza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "term:qaza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "book:al-jami-al-sahih-ibadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|book:al-muwafaqat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "book:al-muwafaqat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|book:on-the-genealogy-of-morals", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "book:on-the-genealogy-of-morals", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|book:the-formation-of-the-sunni-schools-of-law", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "book:the-formation-of-the-sunni-schools-of-law", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 44, "start": 8926, "end": 9031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|event:battle-of-the-trench", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|event:mihna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "event:mihna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|event:spanish-inquisition", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "event:spanish-inquisition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|org:british-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "org:british-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|org:fatimids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "org:fatimids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|org:naqshbandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "org:naqshbandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-sad-ibn-abi-sarh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:al-mamun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:al-mamun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:diogenes", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:diogenes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:friedrich-nietzsche", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:friedrich-nietzsche", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:hamza-tzortzis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:harun-yahya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:harun-yahya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 40, "start": 8401, "end": 8588, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:hasan-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:jeffrey-lang", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:jeffrey-lang", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 44, "start": 8926, "end": 9031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:lawrence-krauss", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:lawrence-krauss", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:mir-faizal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:mir-faizal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:mir-taqi-mir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:mir-taqi-mir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:qaboos-bin-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:qaboos-bin-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|person:raja-dahir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "person:raja-dahir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:109:2-5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:109:2-5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:12:31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:12:31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:18:77", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:18:77", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:24:35", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:24:35", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:2:102", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:2:102", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:33:40", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:33:40", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|quran:3:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "quran:3:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-abhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-abhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-baqillani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-baqillani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-farabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-farabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-jahiz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-jahiz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-kindi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-kindi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:asrar-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:assim-al-hakeem", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:assim-al-hakeem", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:christopher-melchert", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:christopher-melchert", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 44, "start": 8926, "end": 9031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:fethullah-gulen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:fethullah-gulen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ibn-al-jallab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jallab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|scholar:shadee-elmasry", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:al-insan-madani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:al-insan-madani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:balagha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:balagha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:bani-israil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:bani-israil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:cannabis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:cannabis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 53, "start": 11148, "end": 11303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:dhul-qarnayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 21, "start": 4472, "end": 4500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:ibadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:ibadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:ismaili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:ismaili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 40, "start": 8401, "end": 8588, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:kalam-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:kalam-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:kalam-lafzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:kalam-lafzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:kalam-nafsi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:kalam-nafsi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:lsd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:lsd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:makhluq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:makhluq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:mufassirun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:mufassirun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:muhdath", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:muhdath", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:petra-thesis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:petra-thesis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:psilocybin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:psilocybin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:qadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:qadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:riddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:riddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:sahabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:sahabah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:shafaqa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:shafaqa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:shahadat-al-sibyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:shahadat-al-sibyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 13, "start": 2540, "end": 2698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:sidrat-al-muntaha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:sidrat-al-muntaha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:tafsir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:tariqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:tariqah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:trinity", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:trinity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:virgin-birth", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:virgin-birth", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 11, "start": 2230, "end": 2394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:--PntsaR8ck|term:yajuj-and-majuj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|book:early-islamic-qiblas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|event:younger-dryas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "event:younger-dryas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|org:banu-udhra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "org:banu-udhra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|org:khuzaa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "org:khuzaa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|org:nabataeans", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "org:nabataeans", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:dan-gibson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:dan-gibson", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:graham-hancock", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:graham-hancock", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:kilab-ibn-murra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:kilab-ibn-murra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:michael-cook", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:michael-cook", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:patricia-crone", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:patricia-crone", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:piri-reis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:piri-reis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:ptolemy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:ptolemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:rabia-ibn-haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:rabia-ibn-haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|person:zuhra-ibn-kilab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "person:zuhra-ibn-kilab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|principle:critical-review-of-tradition", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "principle:critical-review-of-tradition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|term:qiblah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "term:qiblah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|term:umm-al-qura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "term:umm-al-qura", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-lbZ11113SU|hadith:fp:16ab3584", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "hadith:fp:16ab3584", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-lbZ11113SU|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-lbZ11113SU|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-lbZ11113SU|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-lbZ11113SU|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|hadith:fp:e142e95b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "hadith:fp:e142e95b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:ansar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:ansar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:ghassanids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:ghassanids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:lakhmids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:lakhmids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:nabataeans", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:nabataeans", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:qaramita", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:qaramita", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|person:abraha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "person:abraha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|person:hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "person:hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|person:ismail", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "person:ismail", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|quran:105:1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "quran:105:1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|quran:2:127", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "quran:2:127", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|quran:2:158", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "quran:2:158", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:al-lat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:al-lat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:arafah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:arafah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:baalshamin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:baalshamin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:dushara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:dushara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:hajar-al-aswad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:hajar-al-aswad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:hubal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:hubal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:isaf-and-naila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:isaf-and-naila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:qiblah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:qiblah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:sahabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:sahabah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:tawaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:tawaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:umrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:umrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|term:zamzam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "term:zamzam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|hadith:fp:087f9cf3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "hadith:fp:087f9cf3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|term:miswak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "term:miswak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|term:ramadan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "term:ramadan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|term:sawm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "term:sawm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|event:british-raj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "event:british-raj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|hadith:fp:3e31381a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|person:abu-jahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "person:abu-jahl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|term:lihyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "term:lihyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2017": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:battle-of-badr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:battle-of-badr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:battle-of-uhud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:battle-of-uhud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:migration-to-abyssinia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:migration-to-abyssinia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:siege-of-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:siege-of-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:taif-journey", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:taif-journey", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|event:year-of-sorrow", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "event:year-of-sorrow", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:14945522", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:14945522", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:1dc479f7", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:21c47c81", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:21c47c81", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:25dd70c6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:27af0dd7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:3c5e20fc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:49364277", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:49364277", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:4aee676f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:4aee676f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:55c8a02f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:69859410", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:69859410", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:8a8fcaa3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:8ba24dc2", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:91d7502c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:afa4bcd9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:afa4bcd9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:b3e70d55", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:b98a5cc4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:b98a5cc4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:bf23b2da", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:c61312ab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:c61312ab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:dbe8e4ae", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:e7000a50", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:e7000a50", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "hadith:fp:ea6d7eac", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:consent", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:consent", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:hadith-absolutism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:hadith-relativism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:hadith-relativism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:matn-criticism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:matn-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:prevention-of-harm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:prevention-of-harm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|quran:4:6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "quran:4:6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-al-zinad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:al-dawudi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:al-dawudi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:faruq-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:faruq-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:habib-al-rahman-kandhlawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:ibn-shihab-al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:khalid-al-jundi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:khalid-al-jundi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "scholar:salah-al-din-al-idlibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:ijazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:ijazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:jariyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:jariyah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:kalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:kalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:mahr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:mahr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:naskh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:naskh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|term:tasawwuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "term:tasawwuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:code-of-hammurabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:code-of-hammurabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:gospel-of-thomas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:injil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:injil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:torah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:torah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|book:zabur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "book:zabur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|event:babylonian-exile", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "event:babylonian-exile", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|event:council-of-nicaea-325", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|event:protestant-reformation", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "event:protestant-reformation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|person:daniel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "person:daniel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|person:ezekiel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "person:ezekiel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|quran:12:2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "quran:12:2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|quran:3:50", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "quran:3:50", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|quran:5:45", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "quran:5:45", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|term:bani-israil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "term:bani-israil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|term:quran", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "term:quran", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:143df7icoYU|term:wahy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "term:wahy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|person:yahya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "person:yahya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|person:zakariya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "person:zakariya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 1, "start": 25, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|book:sapiens", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "book:sapiens", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|event:hurricane-katrina-2005", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "event:hurricane-katrina-2005", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|event:isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "event:isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:bukhari:7517", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:bukhari:7517", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:0508e283", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:0508e283", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:19b27380", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:19b27380", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:1a24a8a4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:34e916d2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:34e916d2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:35db4e1f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:35db4e1f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:386fa7b1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:871f66b9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:871f66b9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|hadith:fp:a72ed1ed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "hadith:fp:a72ed1ed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:dar-al-mustafa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:dar-al-mustafa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:ipci", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:ipci", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:tablighi-jamaat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|org:twitter", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "org:twitter", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:barack-obama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:barack-obama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:buddha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:buddha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:confucius", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:confucius", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:david-ray-griffin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:david-ray-griffin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:harun-yahya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:harun-yahya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 14, "start": 3576, "end": 3786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:joe-biden", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:joe-biden", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:john-cobb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:john-cobb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:jordan-peterson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:jordan-peterson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:karl-popper", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:karl-popper", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:lut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:lut", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 14, "start": 3576, "end": 3786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:osama-bin-laden", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:osama-bin-laden", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:yuval-noah-harari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:yuval-noah-harari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|person:zarathustra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "person:zarathustra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:11:7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:11:7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:12:2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:12:2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:20:5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:20:5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:36:1-83", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:36:1-83", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:4:82", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:4:82", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:53:8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:53:8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:5:38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:5:38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:63:1-11", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:63:1-11", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|quran:6:145", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "quran:6:145", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:abd-al-haqq-al-ishbili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:ahmed-deedat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:ahmed-deedat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-burzuli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-burzuli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-khattabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-khattabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-sharawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-sharawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 12, "start": 3044, "end": 3090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:mishrah-ibn-haan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:shehzad-saleem", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:shehzad-saleem", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|scholar:zakir-naik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "scholar:zakir-naik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:adhan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:adhan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:al-ayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:al-ayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:al-kitab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:al-kitab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:hayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:hayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:imam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:imam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:khatam-al-nabiyyin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:munafiqun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:munafiqun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:nawazil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:nawazil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:tahajjud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:tahajjud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:wahy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:wahy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:1zgHntbMPis|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|book:gospel-of-thomas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "book:gospel-of-thomas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "book:infancy-gospel-of-thomas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|person:harun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "person:harun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|person:paul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "person:paul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|quran:19:27-33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "quran:19:27-33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|quran:3:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "quran:3:46", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|term:kalimat-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "term:kalimat-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|term:ruh-al-qudus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|scholar:jamal-al-banna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "scholar:jamal-al-banna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-aziz-juayt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|term:sawm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "term:sawm", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2cei2vnTjes|hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2cei2vnTjes|hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "hadith:fp:6ed8eaaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2cei2vnTjes|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2cei2vnTjes|scholar:imran-hosein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "scholar:imran-hosein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2cei2vnTjes|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|book:al-hidayah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "book:al-hidayah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|person:imran-ibn-husayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "person:imran-ibn-husayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "scholar:majd-al-din-ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|scholar:shah-wali-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|book:early-islamic-qiblas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "book:early-islamic-qiblas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|book:quranic-geography", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "book:quranic-geography", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|person:dan-gibson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "person:dan-gibson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|person:patricia-crone", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "person:patricia-crone", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|term:qiblah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "term:qiblah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3tQUslWseTo|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3tQUslWseTo|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3tQUslWseTo|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:3tQUslWseTo|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:47ghxXHtlN8|term:jubbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:47ghxXHtlN8", "target": "term:jubbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:amah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:amah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:awrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:awrah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4PESNMaHO20|hadith:fp:3ff18220", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "target": "hadith:fp:3ff18220", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4PESNMaHO20|hadith:fp:40f60e96", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "target": "hadith:fp:40f60e96", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4PESNMaHO20|term:jannah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "target": "term:jannah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "event:crusader-conquest-of-jerusalem-1099", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "hadith:fp:a1bd50ab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|hadith:fp:d6df088f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "hadith:fp:d6df088f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:abdullah-al-andalusi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:abu-bakr-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:abu-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:abu-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:heraclius", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:heraclius", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|person:vasco-da-gama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "person:vasco-da-gama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|scholar:nuh-keller", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "scholar:nuh-keller", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:ansar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:ansar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:dar-al-harb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:dar-al-harb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:dar-al-islam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:dar-al-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:jizya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:jizya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:muhajirun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:muhajirun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|term:tasawwuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "term:tasawwuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|event:ridda-wars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "event:ridda-wars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|hadith:fp:0adfcf34", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "hadith:fp:0adfcf34", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|hadith:fp:8c289e7a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "hadith:fp:8c289e7a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|hadith:fp:d056a27c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "hadith:fp:d056a27c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|org:al-mahdi-institute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:al-mamun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:al-mamun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:marwan-ibn-al-hakam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:usama-ibn-zayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:usama-ibn-zayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|person:zakariya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "person:zakariya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|quran:19:5-6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "quran:19:5-6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|quran:27:16", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "quran:27:16", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|quran:4:11", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "quran:4:11", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|quran:59:6-7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "quran:59:6-7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:fadak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:fadak", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:fay", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:fay", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:mirath", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:mirath", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 8, "start": 1852, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:ruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:ruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|org:united-nations", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "org:united-nations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|person:emile-durkheim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "person:emile-durkheim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|scholar:jonathan-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:ambiguous-picture-effect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:collective-consciousness", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:collective-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:ma-malakat-aymanukum", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|book:sunan-al-darimi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|book:sunan-al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|book:sunan-ibn-majah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "hadith:fp:13ca57c0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:626JfCE_j_8|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:626JfCE_j_8|term:shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "target": "term:shifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|book:tawq-al-hamama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "event:nouman-ali-khan-allegations-2017", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "event:rohingya-genocide-2017", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "hadith:fp:24eaf1ba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "hadith:fp:7b9f7f05", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "hadith:fp:9c7f9d0b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|hadith:fp:aabca51a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|hadith:fp:bd89c283", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "hadith:fp:bd89c283", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "person:al-fadl-ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "person:al-mughira-ibn-shuba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|person:hasan-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|person:khadijah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "person:khadijah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|person:mahira-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "person:mahira-khan", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|quran:22:32", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "quran:22:32", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:diya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:diya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:hisbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:hisbah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:propinquity-effect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:propinquity-effect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "book:al-fisal-fi-al-milal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "book:al-kamil-fi-duafa-al-rijal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|book:sunan-ibn-majah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|hadith:fp:1153b02b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "hadith:fp:64f7a13d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|hadith:fp:94283449", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "hadith:fp:94283449", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|hadith:fp:be4605d1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|person:ayyub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "person:ayyub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|person:yala-ibn-murra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|quran:14:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "quran:14:22", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|quran:2:275", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "quran:2:275", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|quran:37:65", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "quran:37:65", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|quran:38:41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "quran:38:41", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:al-bayhaqi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:al-jahiz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:al-jahiz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:ibn-adi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:ibn-adi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abdullah-al-ansari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|scholar:omar-suleiman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:iradah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:iradah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:mufti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:mufti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:rukhsah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:rukhsah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:ruqya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:ruqya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:taklif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:taklif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|term:waswasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "term:waswasa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:al-qawaid-al-arbaa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:gospel-of-john", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:gospel-of-john", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:gospel-of-mark", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:gospel-of-mark", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:gospel-of-matthew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:kitab-al-tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:kitab-al-tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|hadith:fp:2f256513", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "hadith:fp:2f256513", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|hadith:fp:59b6539e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "hadith:fp:59b6539e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|hadith:fp:72540d63", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "hadith:fp:72540d63", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|org:catholic-church", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "org:catholic-church", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "org:islamic-university-of-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|org:taliban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "org:taliban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|person:abdul-hameed-adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "person:abdul-hameed-adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:11:44", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:11:44", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:19:16-22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:19:16-22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:21:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:21:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:21:68-71", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:21:68-71", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:21:76-77", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:21:76-77", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:23:12-13", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:23:12-13", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:2:253", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:2:253", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:2:260", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:2:260", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:2:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:2:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:2:87", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:2:87", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:3:45", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:3:45", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:3:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:3:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:4:1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:4:1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:4:171", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:4:171", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:4:24", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:4:24", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:58:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:58:22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:5:112-115", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:5:112-115", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:66:12", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:66:12", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:6:101", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:6:101", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:6:85-87", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:6:85-87", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:71:14", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:71:14", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:71:17", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:71:17", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|quran:7:189-190", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "quran:7:189-190", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:abu-muslim-al-isfahani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:bakr-abu-zayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:ibn-baz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:ibn-baz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:jaun-elia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:jaun-elia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:mujahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:mujahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:tamanna-imadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 14, "years": {"2018": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 15, "start": 5181, "end": 5210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:athari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:insan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:insan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:kalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:kalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:kalimat-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:kalimat-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:madhhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:madhhab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:maturidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:maturidi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:nafs", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:nafs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:ruh-al-qudus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|person:muhammadi-begum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "person:muhammadi-begum", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 6, "start": 1270, "end": 1448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|term:shirk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "term:shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|term:yaqin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "term:yaqin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|book:al-sultaniyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "book:al-sultaniyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|book:al-yuniniyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "book:al-yuniniyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|hadith:fp:11824c16", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "hadith:fp:11824c16", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|hadith:fp:e592ec95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|person:farid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "person:farid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-mustamli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-mustamli", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-qastallani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-qastallani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:al-saghani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:al-saghani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:farabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:farabri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|scholar:yunini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "scholar:yunini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|term:ilal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "term:ilal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|hadith:fp:d4e2def8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "hadith:fp:d4e2def8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|quran:48:29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "quran:48:29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|scholar:al-qurtubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|term:sujud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "term:sujud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|book:avesta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "book:avesta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|book:mathnawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "book:mathnawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|book:rig-veda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "book:rig-veda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|event:eleusinian-mysteries", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "event:eleusinian-mysteries", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|event:salem-witch-trials", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "event:salem-witch-trials", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|hadith:fp:623f97e7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "hadith:fp:623f97e7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|hadith:fp:9780ca35", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "hadith:fp:9780ca35", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:abdullah-yusuf-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:boris-johnson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:boris-johnson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:gordon-wasson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:gordon-wasson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:graham-hancock", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:graham-hancock", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:ibn-al-awwam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:ibn-al-awwam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:joe-rogan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:joe-rogan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|quran:24:35", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "quran:24:35", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:al-hallaj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:al-hallaj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:ibn-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:ibn-bashkuwal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:junayd-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|scholar:rumi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "scholar:rumi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:amanita-muscaria", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:amanita-muscaria", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:electromagnetic-spectrum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:electromagnetic-spectrum", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:entheogen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:entheogen", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:ergot", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:ergot", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:harmala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:harmala", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:mao-inhibitor", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:mao-inhibitor", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:nabidh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:nabidh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:ney", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:ney", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:psilocybin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:psilocybin", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|term:soma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "term:soma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|org:al-zaytuna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "org:al-zaytuna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|person:abd-al-rahman-iii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "person:abd-al-rahman-iii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:hifz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:hifz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:lihyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:lihyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|book:sunan-ibn-majah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:0daa52d4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:3b47a683", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:3b47a683", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:615032d4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:615032d4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:94440e0b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:94440e0b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|hadith:fp:d938d7f6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "hadith:fp:d938d7f6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|org:harvard-university", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "org:harvard-university", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:basil-mitchell", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:basil-mitchell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:oliver-sacks", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:oliver-sacks", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:satya-sai-baba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:satya-sai-baba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:ted-kaptchuk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|person:yala-ibn-murra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "principle:god-of-the-gaps-fallacy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|principle:sources-of-knowledge", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "principle:sources-of-knowledge", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|quran:10:57", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "quran:10:57", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|quran:15:27", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "quran:15:27", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|quran:2:275", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "quran:2:275", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|quran:37:65", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "quran:37:65", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|quran:88:17-18", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "quran:88:17-18", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:abu-yala-al-farra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:al-baqillani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:al-baqillani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:ibn-atiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:kalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:kalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:non-propositional-faith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:non-propositional-faith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:raf-al-yadayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:raqi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:raqi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:ruqya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:ruqya", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:tiyara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:tiyara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|term:ulama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "term:ulama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|term:entheogen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "term:entheogen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|term:psilocybin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "term:psilocybin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|term:ruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "term:ruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|book:al-ilal-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "book:al-ilal-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "book:al-munfaridat-wal-wuhdan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|book:mizan-al-itidal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "book:sharh-ilal-al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "hadith:fp:f204a3cd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:consent", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:consent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:narrator-criticism-is-a-human-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:sunnah-distinguished-from-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:abu-zura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:abu-zura", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-daraqutni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-asim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ayyub-al-sakhtiyani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:hammad-ibn-salama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:humayd-al-tawil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-adi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-adi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-hibban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-jurayj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-main", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-main", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:imam-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:imam-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:israil-ibn-yunus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:shuba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:shuba", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:thabit-al-bunani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:yahya-ibn-adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "scholar:yahya-ibn-said-al-qattan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:ahl-al-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:ahl-al-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:asbab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:asbab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:ihram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:ihram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:ilal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:ilal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:jarh-wa-tadil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:majhul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:majhul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:maturidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:maturidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:munkar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:munkar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "book:kitab-al-hujja-ala-ahl-al-madina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|hadith:fp:116de08d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "hadith:fp:116de08d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "hadith:fp:3c0ad21e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|hadith:fp:58780d20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "hadith:fp:58780d20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|hadith:fp:65d7a81e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "hadith:fp:65d7a81e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|org:twitter", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "org:twitter", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 3, "start": 734, "end": 893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:charles-darwin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:charles-darwin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:christopher-hitchens", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:christopher-hitchens", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:immanuel-kant", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:immanuel-kant", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:khidr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:khidr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:lut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:lut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:rene-descartes", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:rene-descartes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:shah-rukh-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|person:sigmund-freud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "person:sigmund-freud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|principle:default-permissibility", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "principle:default-permissibility", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|principle:hadith-absolutism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|quran:2:184", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "quran:2:184", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|quran:4:159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "quran:4:159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 3, "start": 734, "end": 893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|quran:9:37", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "quran:9:37", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:akram-nadwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:al-firabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:al-firabri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:ibn-abi-dhib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-dhib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:al-rahman-al-rahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:al-rahman-al-rahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 18, "start": 4055, "end": 4213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:collective-consciousness", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:collective-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:dalk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:dalk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:dhikr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:dhikr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:dunya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:dunya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:fidya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:fidya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:halal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:halal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:lataif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:lataif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:madrasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:madrasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:nasi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:nasi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:qada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:qada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:qati", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:qati", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:rizq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:rizq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:ruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:ruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:sapir-whorf-hypothesis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:shariah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:shariah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:stoned-ape-theory", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:stoned-ape-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:tawakkul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:tawakkul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|term:zanni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "term:zanni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:0a236306", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:46d4d9c4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:5d1281b0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:e592ec95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:asim-qureshi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:asim-qureshi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:farid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:farid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:ibrahim-ibn-muhammad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|quran:33:6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "quran:33:6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|scholar:ikrima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "scholar:ikrima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|principle:matn-criticism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "principle:matn-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|term:jarh-wa-tadil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|org:5pillars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "org:5pillars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|scholar:zakir-naik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "scholar:zakir-naik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "principle:compare-hadith-with-hadith-not-imam-with-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:madhhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:madhhab", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:masala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:masala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:oppositional-defiant-disorder", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:oppositional-defiant-disorder", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:sahabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:sahabah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|term:wajib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "term:wajib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|person:jay-smith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "person:jay-smith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|term:mushaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "term:mushaf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:ahkam-al-quran", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:al-hamasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:al-hamasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:al-ulama-al-uzzab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:banat-suad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:banat-suad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:nayl-al-awtar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:qut-al-qulub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:qut-al-qulub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|book:tartib-al-madarik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:0e6517d3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:0e6517d3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:29cf1793", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:29cf1793", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:620896d2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:620896d2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:6ef44327", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:6ef44327", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:8ca2f04b", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:9ac3373f", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:aebb3191", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:aebb3191", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "hadith:fp:c485a5bc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|org:open-university", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "org:open-university", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:abu-nuwas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:abu-nuwas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:abu-tammam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:abu-tammam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:imru-al-qais", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:imru-al-qais", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:kab-ibn-zuhayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:kab-ibn-zuhayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "person:zuhayr-ibn-abi-sulma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|principle:build-on-certainty", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "principle:build-on-certainty", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|principle:default-permissibility", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "principle:default-permissibility", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|principle:ontology-of-religion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "principle:ontology-of-religion", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|quran:16:116", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "quran:16:116", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|quran:2:29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "quran:2:29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:abd-al-fattah-abu-ghudda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:abu-al-faraj-al-isfahani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-bayhaqi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-bayhaqi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-daylami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-daylami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-fakihani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-fakihani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-juwayni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-juwayni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-minhal-ibn-amr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-qaffal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-qaffal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-ruyani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-ruyani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-al-dunya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:ibn-khuwayz-mindad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:ibn-tahir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:shuba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:shuba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:tawus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:tawus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:bimaristan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:bimaristan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:ghina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:ghina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:halal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:halal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:ibaha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:ibaha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:maazif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:maazif", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:madrasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:madrasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:minbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:minbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:muallaqat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:muallaqat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:qati", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:qati", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:sarih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:sarih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:taqlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:taqlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:usul-al-fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:zahiri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:zahiri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:zanni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:zanni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|term:zuhd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "term:zuhd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|event:great-flood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "event:great-flood", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|person:nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "person:nuh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|scholar:mufti-menk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "scholar:mufti-menk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|scholar:asrar-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|term:adalat-al-sahaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "term:adalat-al-sahaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|term:sahaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "term:sahaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "scholar:mohamed-fizazi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:nikah-bi-niyyat-al-talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwxuMQnPbw0|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "target": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:AwxuMQnPbw0|quran:36:68", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "target": "quran:36:68", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "book:al-jami-li-masail-al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|hadith:fp:a58d8940", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "hadith:fp:a58d8940", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|org:twitter", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "org:twitter", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|person:dagh-dehlvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "person:dagh-dehlvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|person:t-e-lawrence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "person:t-e-lawrence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:al-lakhmi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:hamza-maqbool", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:ibn-wahb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:ibn-yunus-al-siqilli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:khalil-ibn-ishaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-wahhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ|term:neo-traditionalism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ", "target": "term:neo-traditionalism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|event:babri-masjid-dispute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|event:conquest-of-constantinople", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|org:ottoman-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "org:ottoman-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:imran-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:imran-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:justinian-i", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:justinian-i", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:mehmed-ii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:mehmed-ii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:thrasymachus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:thrasymachus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|principle:might-is-right", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "principle:might-is-right", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|quran:22:40-41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "quran:22:40-41", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:adhan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:adhan", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:amir-al-muminin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:amir-al-muminin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:shirk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|term:waqf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "term:waqf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|hadith:fp:80b1af85", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "hadith:fp:80b1af85", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|hadith:fp:a5cdcded", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "hadith:fp:a5cdcded", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|hadith:fp:a8af5be2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "hadith:fp:a8af5be2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|hadith:fp:b517bd19", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "hadith:fp:b517bd19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|hadith:fp:c54df7f0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "hadith:fp:c54df7f0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|principle:build-on-certainty", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "principle:build-on-certainty", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|principle:custom-and-convention", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "principle:custom-and-convention", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:awrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:awrah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:ilgha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:ilgha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:isbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:isbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:izar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:izar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:nafl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:nafl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:qabd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:qabd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:rakah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:rakah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:sadl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:sadl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:sujud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:sujud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:sujud-al-sahw", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:sujud-al-sahw", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|term:tashahhud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "term:tashahhud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:C-9MCspQqwE|quran:14:7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:C-9MCspQqwE", "target": "quran:14:7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:C-9MCspQqwE|term:shukr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:C-9MCspQqwE", "target": "term:shukr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|person:joe-rogan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "person:joe-rogan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|person:mike-tyson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "person:mike-tyson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|scholar:ibn-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|term:fana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "term:fana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|hadith:fp:bb5fdb57", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "hadith:fp:bb5fdb57", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|hadith:fp:f942d247", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|quran:2:229", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "quran:2:229", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|quran:4:19", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "quran:4:19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|scholar:al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Cz26by1mMns|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|book:sunan-al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|hadith:fp:65670e76", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "hadith:fp:65670e76", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "hadith:fp:9ae25c07", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|person:burayda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "person:burayda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-huwayni", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:isnad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:isnad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:jizya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:jizya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:kafir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:kafir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:mushrikin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:mushrikin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DYnuJS-DTMU|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DYnuJS-DTMU", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DYnuJS-DTMU|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DYnuJS-DTMU", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|hadith:fp:6efd403c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "hadith:fp:6efd403c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|hadith:fp:a8c001c0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "hadith:fp:a8c001c0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|quran:2:177", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "quran:2:177", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|term:qiblah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "term:qiblah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|principle:hadith-absolutism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "principle:hadith-absolutism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|principle:hadith-relativism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "principle:hadith-relativism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "event:arrest-of-muhammad-ali-mirza-2020", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|org:pharisees", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "org:pharisees", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ali-mirza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "hadith:fp:c731c3f4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|org:5pillars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "org:5pillars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|person:abdullah-kunde", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "person:abdullah-kunde", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|principle:faith-not-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "principle:faith-not-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|quran:24:35", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "quran:24:35", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|scholar:ibn-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|scholar:usama-canon", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "scholar:usama-canon", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|term:adhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "term:adhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "hadith:fp:eb4693f0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|term:matn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "term:matn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|quran:27:80-84", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "quran:27:80-84", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|quran:27:82", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "quran:27:82", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|quran:6:158", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "quran:6:158", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|scholar:al-qurtubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|scholar:al-tibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "scholar:al-tibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|term:ashrat-al-saah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "term:ashrat-al-saah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|term:hifz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "term:hifz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|term:juz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "term:juz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|term:tarawih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "term:tarawih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|event:mihna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "event:mihna", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|person:dave-chappelle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "person:dave-chappelle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:ahl-al-sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:ahl-al-sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:kalam-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:kalam-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:rukhsah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:rukhsah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:sifat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:sifat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:tayammum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:tayammum", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|term:athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "term:athari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|hadith:fp:f9eac639", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "hadith:fp:f9eac639", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|term:bismillah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "term:bismillah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|term:fajr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "term:fajr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|term:fard", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "term:fard", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:G0iGieTCklk|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|org:taliban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "org:taliban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|scholar:tariq-jamil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "scholar:tariq-jamil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|term:haya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "term:haya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|term:rizq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "term:rizq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|book:torah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "book:torah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|event:babylonian-exile", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "event:babylonian-exile", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|event:exodus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "event:exodus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|person:ezra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "person:ezra", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|person:osiris", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "person:osiris", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|quran:20:17-18", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "quran:20:17-18", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|quran:7:138", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "quran:7:138", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|quran:9:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "quran:9:30", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|term:hinduism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "term:hinduism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|term:tafsir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "term:tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|event:splitting-of-the-moon", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "event:splitting-of-the-moon", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|hadith:fp:16737f93", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "hadith:fp:16737f93", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|quran:54:1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "quran:54:1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|book:al-shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "book:al-shifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|book:musnad-al-bazzar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "event:france-handshake-citizenship-case-2018", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:20a83804", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:20a83804", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:566be7a1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:566be7a1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:74b1d15f", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:773e83d8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:773e83d8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:d8ee1bfe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|hadith:fp:da792624", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "hadith:fp:da792624", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "org:european-council-for-fatwa-and-research", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|person:umm-atiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "person:umm-atiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "person:umm-haram-bint-milhan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|quran:4:43", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "quran:4:43", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|quran:4:86", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "quran:4:86", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:ahmad-al-tayyib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:al-dimyati", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:al-dimyati", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:ibn-hibban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:mahmud-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:mahmud-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:khususiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:khususiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:mahram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:mahram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|term:tafliya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "term:tafliya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|org:byzantine-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "org:byzantine-empire", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|org:kingdom-of-aksum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "org:kingdom-of-aksum", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:charles-darwin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:charles-darwin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:joseph-husband-of-mary", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:joseph-husband-of-mary", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:nuh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|person:yunus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "person:yunus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:21:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:21:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:23:12-14", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:23:12-14", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:3:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:3:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:3:64", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:3:64", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:49:13", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:49:13", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:4:171", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:4:171", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|quran:6:101", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "quran:6:101", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:akhirah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:akhirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:barzakh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:barzakh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:evolution", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:ghayb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:ghayb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:heisenberg-uncertainty-principle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:heisenberg-uncertainty-principle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:insan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:insan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:kun-fayakun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:kun-fayakun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:malaika", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:malaika", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:qadar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:qadar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:ruh-al-qudus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:sunnat-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:sunnat-allah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:trinity", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:trinity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|term:virgin-birth", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "term:virgin-birth", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|person:ibn-muljam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "person:ibn-muljam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:bidayat-al-mujtahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:plato-republic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:plato-republic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:tahafut-al-falasifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:tahafut-al-falasifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|book:tahafut-al-tahafut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "book:tahafut-al-tahafut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|event:exodus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "event:exodus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|event:september-11-attacks", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "event:september-11-attacks", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|hadith:fp:206b1939", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "hadith:fp:206b1939", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|hadith:fp:5334d346", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "hadith:fp:5334d346", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|hadith:fp:a66e3532", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "hadith:fp:a66e3532", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|org:ahmadiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "org:ahmadiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|org:zaytuna-college", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "org:zaytuna-college", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:ayyub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:ayyub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:boris-johnson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:boris-johnson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:colin-humphreys", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:colin-humphreys", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:firawn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:firawn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:george-w-bush", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:george-w-bush", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:matt-hancock", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:matt-hancock", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:plotinus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:plotinus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:umar-ibn-abi-salama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:umar-ibn-abi-salama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:umm-salama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:umm-salama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:yaqub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:yaqub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:yaqub-al-mansur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:yaqub-al-mansur", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:yunus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:yunus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|person:yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "person:yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|quran:2:248", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "quran:2:248", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|quran:3:55", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "quran:3:55", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|quran:4:157-158", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "quran:4:157-158", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|quran:5:117", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "quran:5:117", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:al-farabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:al-farabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-faris", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-faris", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-sina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-sina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:ibn-tufayl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:ibn-tufayl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:imran-hosein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:imran-hosein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:maimonides", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:maimonides", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|scholar:saqib-shaami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:adab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:adab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:neoplatonism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:neoplatonism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:sadaqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:sadaqah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:sakinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:sakinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:sawm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:sawm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 10, "start": 2082, "end": 2232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:tabut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:tabut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 12, "start": 2310, "end": 2427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 32, "start": 9037, "end": 9187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|term:zina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "term:zina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "person:safwan-ibn-al-muattal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "scholar:sayf-al-din-al-amidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|term:jam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "term:jam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:137", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:137", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:2655", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:2655", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:2819", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:2819", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:3104", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:3104", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:3242", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:3242", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:3431", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:3431", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:364", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:364", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:3663", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:3663", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:4431", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:4431", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|hadith:bukhari:6830", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:frederic-bartlett", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:frederic-bartlett", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:abu-al-yaman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:abu-al-yaman", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:farabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:farabri", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:nafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:nafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "scholar:shuayb-ibn-abi-hamza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:izar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:izar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "hadith:fp:5eee3c4d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:kufr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:kufr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:masjid-al-aqsa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|hadith:fp:336fe573", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "hadith:fp:336fe573", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|quran:33:28-29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "quran:33:28-29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|quran:33:53", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "quran:33:53", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|quran:33:6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "quran:33:6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|scholar:al-dasuqi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "scholar:al-dasuqi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|term:ghuluw", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "term:ghuluw", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|term:niqab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "term:niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|book:the-sanaa-palimpsest", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "book:the-sanaa-palimpsest", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "event:birmingham-quran-manuscript", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|event:discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "event:discovery-of-the-sanaa-manuscripts", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|hadith:fp:48d2fb97", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "hadith:fp:48d2fb97", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|scholar:asma-hilali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "scholar:asma-hilali", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "scholar:behnam-sadeghi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|scholar:elisabeth-puin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "scholar:elisabeth-puin", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|scholar:gerd-puin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "scholar:gerd-puin", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "scholar:mohsen-goudarzi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|term:muawwidhatayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "term:muawwidhatayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|term:mushaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "term:mushaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|term:palimpsest", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "term:palimpsest", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 8, "start": 1327, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|term:qiraat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "term:qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|term:qunut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "term:qunut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|book:adab-al-muallimin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "book:adab-al-muallimin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|book:al-mustadrak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "book:al-mustadrak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "event:battle-of-banu-al-mustaliq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|event:incident-of-the-ifk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "event:incident-of-the-ifk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:08774c1f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:08774c1f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:309a93b6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:309a93b6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:6546db09", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:69a65512", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:d00cf9c1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:d00cf9c1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:d760391a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:d760391a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|hadith:fp:da54f8d2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "hadith:fp:da54f8d2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:ahmadiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:ahmadiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:byzantine-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:byzantine-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:hamas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:hamas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:twitter", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:twitter", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|org:united-nations", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "org:united-nations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:abu-muslim-al-khurasani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:al-mutanabbi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:al-mutanabbi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 40, "start": 10632, "end": 10867, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:david-wood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:david-wood", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:farid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:farid", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 38, "start": 10039, "end": 10497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:noam-chomsky", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:noam-chomsky", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:norman-finkelstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:norman-finkelstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|quran:16:89", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "quran:16:89", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|quran:24:11-20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "quran:24:11-20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|quran:3:93", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "quran:3:93", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:ahmad-amin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:ahmad-amin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:ibn-azraq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:ibn-azraq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-sahnun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|scholar:yasmin-amin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "scholar:yasmin-amin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:ahl-al-kitab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:ayahuasca", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:ayahuasca", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:bani-israil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:bani-israil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:dinar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:dinar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:dirham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:dirham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:dome-of-the-rock", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:dome-of-the-rock", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:entheogen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:entheogen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:hifz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:hifz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:jahannam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:jahannam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:kashmir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:kashmir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:khars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:khars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:khul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:khul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:masjid-al-aqsa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:nabidh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:nabidh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:nisab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:nisab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:qiyas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:qiyas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:sadaqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:sadaqah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 6, "start": 1428, "end": 1506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:two-state-solution", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:two-state-solution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 26, "start": 6556, "end": 6869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:zindiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:zindiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|term:zuhd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "term:zuhd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|org:twitter", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "org:twitter", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|book:al-muhalla", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "book:al-muhalla", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:1903b957", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:1903b957", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:5aa3d58c", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:613960b2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:613960b2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:7a70bdbe", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:7a70bdbe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:80ebd445", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:80ebd445", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:90dd1daf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:90dd1daf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:91a4639f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:91a4639f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:aca4730d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:aca4730d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:b6104c86", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:b6104c86", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|hadith:fp:cf232df3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "hadith:fp:cf232df3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|org:darussalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "org:darussalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|org:harvard-university", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "org:harvard-university", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|org:taliban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "org:taliban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:musaylima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:musaylima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:sajah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:sajah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|person:umm-humayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "person:umm-humayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:ibn-hibban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:ibn-hibban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|term:makhda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "term:makhda", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|term:masjid-al-nabawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:KuSevqg0low|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|term:ibadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "term:ibadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LJpCQXiII98|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:1153b02b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:1153b02b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:94283449", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:94283449", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:9b193bf2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:be4605d1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:be4605d1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:cf08cbd1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:de76def6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:de76def6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "hadith:fp:eaaebf3c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:basil-mitchell", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:basil-mitchell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:oliver-sacks", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:oliver-sacks", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:sathya-sai-baba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:sathya-sai-baba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:ted-kaptchuk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:ted-kaptchuk", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:umm-aban", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:umm-aban", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-abi-al-as", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|person:yala-ibn-murra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "person:yala-ibn-murra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|quran:10:57", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "quran:10:57", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|quran:15:27", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "quran:15:27", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|quran:2:275", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "quran:2:275", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|quran:37:65", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "quran:37:65", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:abu-yala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:abu-yala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:akram-nadwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:al-baqillani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:al-baqillani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:ibn-atiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:aphantasia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:aphantasia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:capgras-delusion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:capgras-delusion", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:charles-bonnet-syndrome", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:dissociative-identity-disorder", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:foreign-accent-syndrome", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:god-of-the-gaps", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:god-of-the-gaps", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:hemispatial-neglect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:hemispatial-neglect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:kibr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:kibr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:mutakallimun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:mutakallimun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:nocebo-effect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:nocebo-effect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:non-propositional-faith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:non-propositional-faith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:palinopsia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:palinopsia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:placebo-effect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:placebo-effect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:prosopagnosia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:prosopagnosia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:raf-al-yadayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:ruqya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:ruqya", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:shifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:tiyara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:tiyara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:ulama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:ulama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:waswasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:waswasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|term:zaqqum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "term:zaqqum", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LnOAQLLkvNo|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LnOAQLLkvNo", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LnOAQLLkvNo|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LnOAQLLkvNo", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|person:suleiman-the-magnificent", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "person:suleiman-the-magnificent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|scholar:al-burzuli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "scholar:al-burzuli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|term:tawbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "term:tawbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "event:uae-israel-normalisation-2020", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|hadith:fp:aabca51a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "hadith:fp:aabca51a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|hadith:fp:f9b6111f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "hadith:fp:f9b6111f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|org:hamas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "org:hamas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|org:united-nations", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "org:united-nations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|person:noam-chomsky", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "person:noam-chomsky", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|person:norman-finkelstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "person:norman-finkelstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|term:masjid-al-aqsa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|hadith:fp:f942d247", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "hadith:fp:f942d247", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|principle:matn-criticism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "principle:matn-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:abu-salih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:abu-salih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|scholar:shuba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "scholar:shuba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|term:matn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "term:matn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:al-itisam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:al-itisam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:muqaddimah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:muqaddimah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:tafsir-al-manar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:tafsir-al-manar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "book:tahqiqat-wa-anzar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:assassination-of-uthman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:conquest-of-constantinople", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:karbala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:karbala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:mehdi-hasan-richard-dawkins-debate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:rashid-rida-visit-to-india", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|event:sack-of-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "event:sack-of-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:1652a026", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:1652a026", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:24232b79", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:246187ac", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:4c9707e2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:4c9707e2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 41, "start": 9070, "end": 9265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:4d734d1d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:64e37134", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:64e37134", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:6b3b4416", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:6db69aaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:706285e0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:9a6d7eff", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:a15c3e92", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:a15c3e92", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:b0a8648b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:b6561480", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:b6561480", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:b97a2c7f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:b9d6a17d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:bd2ddd7d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:c3087e67", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|hadith:fp:f45113be", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "hadith:fp:f45113be", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:12:76", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:12:76", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:3:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:3:46", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:43:61", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:43:61", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:4:159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:4:159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:7:43", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:7:43", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|quran:9:31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "quran:9:31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abu-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:abu-zahra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:abu-zahra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-awni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-awni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-maraghi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-maraghi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-qurtubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-sakhawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-sharawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-sharawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:anwar-shah-kashmiri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:asrar-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:hamza-maqbool", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-baz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-baz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-khaldun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-qudama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-sirin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-uthaymin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibn-wahb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:ibrahim-al-halabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:mujahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:mujahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:rashid-rida", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:rashid-rida", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:salek-bin-siddina", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:shadee-elmasry", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:siddiq-hasan-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|scholar:zaid-shakir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "scholar:zaid-shakir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:hadra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:hadra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:idraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:idraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:israiliyyat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:israiliyyat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:kahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:kahl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:mawlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:mawlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:taklif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:taklif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|term:taqlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "term:taqlid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NIVZcdJxC2o|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "target": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:NIVZcdJxC2o|term:wali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "target": "term:wali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|person:erik-erikson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "person:erik-erikson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:nikah-misyar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:nikah-misyar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|hadith:fp:3ec20135", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "hadith:fp:3ec20135", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|person:muhammad-from-god", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "person:muhammad-from-god", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 2, "start": 95, "end": 292, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|scholar:al-mazari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "scholar:al-mazari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|scholar:al-qarafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "scholar:al-qarafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|book:al-sultaniyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "book:al-sultaniyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|org:charity-commission", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "org:charity-commission", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|org:skt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "org:skt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|person:thrasymachus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "person:thrasymachus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:murid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:murid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:pir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:pir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|term:tariqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "term:tariqah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4|term:dhabiha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4", "target": "term:dhabiha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4|term:halal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4", "target": "term:halal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|term:ahl-al-bayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|term:dawah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "term:dawah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|term:ismaili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "term:ismaili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|term:twelve-imams", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "term:twelve-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "book:al-fiqh-al-akbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|event:battle-of-uhud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "event:battle-of-uhud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|event:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "event:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|hadith:fp:0607111e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|hadith:fp:bbe9b820", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "hadith:fp:bbe9b820", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|org:banu-nadir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "org:banu-nadir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:arthur-c-clarke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:arthur-c-clarke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:derren-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:derren-brown", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:firawn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:firawn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:17:47", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:17:47", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:20:66", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:20:66", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:20:67", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:20:67", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:2:102", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:2:102", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:5:67", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:5:67", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|quran:7:116", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "quran:7:116", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:akram-nadwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:al-mazari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:al-mazari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:ibn-khaldun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:mustafa-bin-hamza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:mustafa-bin-hamza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:halala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:halala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:raf-al-yadayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|person:firawn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "person:firawn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|person:thrasymachus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "person:thrasymachus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|principle:might-is-right", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "principle:might-is-right", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|quran:20:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "quran:20:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|quran:20:66", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "quran:20:66", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|quran:7:116", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "quran:7:116", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|scholar:ibn-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|hadith:fp:c3087e67", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "hadith:fp:c3087e67", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|term:taqlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "term:taqlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|book:tartib-al-madarik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:4d5b5008", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:526d7260", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:526d7260", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:695244ce", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:695244ce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:7dfd2715", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:7dfd2715", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:904edb83", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:904edb83", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:c26c7d53", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:c26c7d53", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:d4f7745a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:d4f7745a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:e17cbcb0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:e17cbcb0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|hadith:fp:fb13a1a4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "hadith:fp:fb13a1a4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|person:akbar-allahabadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|person:imru-al-qais", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "person:imru-al-qais", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "principle:commanding-good-and-forbidding-evil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|principle:default-permissibility", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "principle:default-permissibility", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|quran:14:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "quran:14:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|quran:57:16", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "quran:57:16", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:al-mazari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:al-mazari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:imam-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:imam-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:dhikr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:dhikr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:ijtihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:ijtihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:jahiliyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:jahiliyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:sharia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:sharia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:ahkam-al-quran", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:ahkam-al-quran", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:bulugh-al-maram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:bulugh-al-maram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:early-inquisitions-in-islam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:early-inquisitions-in-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:muntaqa-al-akhbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:nayl-al-awtar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:qut-al-qulub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:qut-al-qulub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|event:mihna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "event:mihna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:24469dbc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:24469dbc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:25681cd0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:25681cd0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:3efddf38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:3efddf38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:77e47ac0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:7cef7cb5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:8a304df1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:8a304df1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:df734495", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:df734495", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|hadith:fp:e02d6353", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "hadith:fp:e02d6353", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|person:al-mamun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "person:al-mamun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "principle:refutation-requires-categorical-evidence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "principle:truth-not-decided-by-numbers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|quran:12:76", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "quran:12:76", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|quran:17:82", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "quran:17:82", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:abu-ibraheem-husnayn", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:abu-talib-al-makki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:al-asili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:al-asili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:al-fakihani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:al-fakihani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:ibn-baz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:ibn-baz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:ibn-tahir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:ibn-tahir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:khuzayma-ibn-thabit", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:sad-ibn-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:tawus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:tawus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:daif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:daif", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:kalam-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:kalam-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:mursal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:mursal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:ruqya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:ruqya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|term:shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "term:shifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|book:the-knowledge-illusion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "book:the-knowledge-illusion", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|hadith:fp:e592ec95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "hadith:fp:ecbe3efd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:jabir-ibn-abdullah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:tommy-robinson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:tommy-robinson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:abd-al-hamid-ibn-abi-uways", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ibn-main", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ibn-main", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:imam-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:imam-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|term:minbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "term:minbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "hadith:fp:5faffb9e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|person:mirza-ghalib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "person:mirza-ghalib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|term:qadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "term:qadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|hadith:fp:0a236306", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|person:abdullah-sameer", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "person:abdullah-sameer", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|person:amr-ibn-al-as", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|person:muawiya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "person:muawiya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "principle:clear-text-overrides-ambiguous", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "principle:what-set-right-the-first-of-the-umma-sets-right-its-last", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|quran:65:1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "quran:65:1", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|quran:65:2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "quran:65:2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|quran:65:3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "quran:65:3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|quran:65:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "quran:65:4", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:abu-al-suud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:abu-al-suud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:abu-hayyan-al-andalusi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:al-alusi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:al-alusi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:al-qurtubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:al-qurtubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:al-samarqandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:al-samarqandi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:al-thalabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:al-thalabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:ibn-atiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:ibn-atiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:ikrima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:ikrima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:adab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:adab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:asbab-al-nuzul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:asbab-al-nuzul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:fatayat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:fatayat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:jariyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:jariyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:juz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:juz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:mahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:mahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:mutashabih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:mutashabih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:nisa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:nisa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:rijal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:rijal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:sahaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:sahaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:tawakkul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:tawakkul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|term:usul-al-fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:al-shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:al-shifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:majmu-al-fatawa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:majmu-al-fatawa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:midnights-children", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:midnights-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:nasb-al-majaniq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:nasb-al-majaniq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:tafsir-al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:tafsir-al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:the-future-of-an-illusion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:the-future-of-an-illusion", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|book:the-satanic-verses", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "book:the-satanic-verses", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2022": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "event:attack-on-salman-rushdie-2022", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "event:khomeini-fatwa-against-rushdie-1989", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|hadith:fp:085f3d75", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "hadith:fp:085f3d75", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "hadith:fp:4bbbe027", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "hadith:fp:cfd72a49", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|org:ottoman-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "org:ottoman-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:anis-ahmed-rushdie", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:imran-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:imran-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:nelson-mandela", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:nelson-mandela", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:nicolaus-copernicus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:salman-rushdie", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:salman-rushdie", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 10, "start": 3164, "end": 3322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|person:sigmund-freud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "person:sigmund-freud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|principle:criticism-is-not-insult", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "principle:criticism-is-not-insult", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "principle:everyone-accepted-and-rejected-except-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|quran:14:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "quran:14:22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|quran:22:52", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "quran:22:52", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|quran:53:1-4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "quran:53:1-4", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|quran:53:19-20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "quran:53:19-20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|quran:69:44-46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "quran:69:44-46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2022": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-khuzayma", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2022": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:gharaniq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:gharaniq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:isnad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:isnad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:mursal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:mursal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:mushrikin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:mushrikin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:sujud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:sujud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 10, "start": 3164, "end": 3322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|term:zindiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "term:zindiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|event:farewell-pilgrimage", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "event:farewell-pilgrimage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "hadith:fp:3fce18c1", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|hadith:fp:47a536df", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "hadith:fp:47a536df", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|person:abu-said-al-khudri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|person:bilal-ibn-rabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "person:bilal-ibn-rabah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|quran:20:115", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "quran:20:115", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|quran:4:28", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "quran:4:28", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|term:hayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "term:hayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|term:idtirab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "term:idtirab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|term:rukhsah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "term:rukhsah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|book:al-risalah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "book:al-risalah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "hadith:fp:60bcb4ee", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|hadith:fp:838663a8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "hadith:fp:838663a8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "principle:historical-context-of-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|scholar:al-qarafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "scholar:al-qarafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:4accedcd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:6271346a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:21:34", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:21:34", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:3:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:3:46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:3:55", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:3:55", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:43:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:43:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:43:61", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:43:61", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:4:159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:4:159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:5:116-118", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:5:116-118", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|quran:5:75", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "quran:5:75", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:abu-mushir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:abu-mushir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:abu-zura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:abu-zura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-baghawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-baghawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-jayyani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-jayyani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-adi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-adi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2021": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:idraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:idraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:kalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:kalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:mubham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:mubham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:mursal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:mursal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "event:peshawar-courtroom-killing-2020", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|event:ridda-wars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "event:ridda-wars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "hadith:fp:0a86cf97", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|hadith:fp:62207cac", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "hadith:fp:62207cac", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|hadith:fp:91926944", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "hadith:fp:91926944", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|org:ahmadiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "org:ahmadiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 20, "start": 5593, "end": 5783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|person:dan-gibson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "person:dan-gibson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|quran:22:37", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "quran:22:37", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:abdal-hakim-murad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 14, "start": 4254, "end": 4482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 24, "start": 7205, "end": 7365, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:hijama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:hijama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:ibadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:ibadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:isnad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:isnad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:jarh-wa-tadil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:madrasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:madrasa", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:mawlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:mawlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:nabidh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:nabidh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:petra-thesis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:petra-thesis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:udhiyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:udhiyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|term:zaydi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "term:zaydi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|hadith:fp:32d192a5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|principle:context-of-revelation", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "principle:context-of-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|quran:24:31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "quran:24:31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|term:jayb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "term:jayb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|term:khimar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "term:khimar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TgaNlc0x_iI|scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TgaNlc0x_iI", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-hasan-al-dedew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TgaNlc0x_iI|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TgaNlc0x_iI", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|org:mughal-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "org:mughal-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|org:ottoman-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "org:ottoman-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "person:jalal-al-din-akbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-qasim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:TincZqdQpgs|principle:culture-versus-religion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:madhhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:madhhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|term:shariah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "term:shariah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:al-shifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:al-shifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:musnad-abi-yala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:musnad-al-bazzar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:musnad-al-bazzar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|book:tartib-al-madarik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "book:tartib-al-madarik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "hadith:fp:2c98b2b9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "hadith:fp:95ed3e02", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "hadith:fp:b192ec8e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "hadith:fp:e4777bc0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "hadith:fp:ee4de6d9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|org:bayt-al-hikma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "org:bayt-al-hikma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|org:ubaydids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "org:ubaydids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-hudhafa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:harun-al-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:harun-al-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "principle:one-standard-for-all-religions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "principle:only-allah-and-his-messenger-are-authorities", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:22:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:22:46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:29:20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:29:20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:29:41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:29:41", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:2:260", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:2:260", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:47:19", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:47:19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|quran:51:49", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "quran:51:49", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-farabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-farabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-kindi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-kindi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-safarini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-safarini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:ibn-sina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:ibn-sina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:sherman-jackson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|scholar:zakir-naik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "scholar:zakir-naik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:hikmah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:hikmah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:nazar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:nazar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|term:taqlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "term:taqlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "book:musnad-al-rabi-ibn-habib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "person:abd-al-rahman-al-dakhil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|person:abdullah-ibn-ibad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-ibad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|person:sultan-qaboos", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "person:sultan-qaboos", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "scholar:jabir-ibn-zayd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:azariqa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:azariqa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:ibadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:ibadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:sadl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:sadl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|book:al-ashmawiyyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "book:al-ashmawiyyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|book:al-risalah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "book:al-risalah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|book:gharami-sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "book:gharami-sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|book:the-foundations-of-islam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "book:the-foundations-of-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "event:british-imams-fatwa-against-isis-2014", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "event:trojan-horse-affair-2014", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "hadith:fp:2b141ddc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|org:boko-haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "org:boko-haram", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|org:metropolitan-police", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "org:metropolitan-police", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|org:prevent-programme", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "org:prevent-programme", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|person:adolf-hitler", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "person:adolf-hitler", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|person:dal-babu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "person:dal-babu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:ijazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:ijazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:jihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:jihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:sirah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|term:ulama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "term:ulama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|event:karbala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "event:karbala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "hadith:fp:41c0b9f9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|hadith:fp:4e196f83", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "hadith:fp:4e196f83", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "hadith:fp:e4357cc0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|org:himyar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "org:himyar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:adnan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:adnan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:fatima-bint-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:fatima-bint-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:ismail", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:ismail", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:matt-walsh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:matt-walsh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:muhammad-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:muhammad-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:nadr-ibn-anas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:nadr-ibn-anas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:qahtan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:qahtan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|person:yahya-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "person:yahya-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|quran:2:282", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "quran:2:282", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|quran:3:173", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "quran:3:173", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|quran:45:32", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "quran:45:32", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:ibn-hurmuz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:ibn-hurmuz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:ibn-wahb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:ibn-wahb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 14, "years": {"2023": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:rabia-al-ray", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:kutub-al-sittah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:kutub-al-sittah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:makkah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:makkah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:maslaha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:maslaha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:nafl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:nafl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:nifas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:nifas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:phantom-pregnancy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:phantom-pregnancy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|term:zuhd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "term:zuhd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:al-mabsut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:al-mabsut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:al-muwafaqat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:al-muwafaqat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:maqasid-al-shariah-al-islamiyyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:nayl-al-awtar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sharh-mushkil-al-athar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sinaat-al-fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sunan-al-darimi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sunan-al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|book:sunan-ibn-majah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|event:conquest-of-makkah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:0a236306", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:2ea15ea5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:2ea15ea5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:3cceb4d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:3cceb4d9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:428fe918", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:428fe918", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:58c43d93", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:58c43d93", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:63460405", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:63460405", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:6546db09", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:6546db09", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:72d55de9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:72d55de9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:ae3e7bbf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:b802c2a5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:b802c2a5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:c39d4ab5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|hadith:fp:df71d13f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "hadith:fp:df71d13f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|org:bjp", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "org:bjp", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-ubayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abdullah-ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:hamza-ibn-amr-al-aslami", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:ibn-sayyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:ibn-sayyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|principle:build-on-certainty", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "principle:build-on-certainty", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:109:1-6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:109:1-6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:10:99", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:10:99", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:18:29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:18:29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:5:32", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:5:32", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|quran:5:33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "quran:5:33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:abd-al-samad-ibn-abd-al-warith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:akram-nadwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-kasani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-kasani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-qasim-ibn-muhammad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-rabi-ibn-sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-sarakhsi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibn-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibn-al-humam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibn-jurayj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibn-sirin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:ikrima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:ikrima", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:mujahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:mujahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:musab-al-zubayri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:musab-al-zubayri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:qatada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:qatada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:sulayman-ibn-yasar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:illah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:illah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:istitabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:istitabah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:janazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:janazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:jizya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:jizya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:kufr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:kufr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:naskh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:naskh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:nazar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:nazar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:qati", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:qati", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:riddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:riddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|term:tawbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "term:tawbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|scholar:ibn-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|org:knowledge-revival", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "org:knowledge-revival", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|person:farid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "person:farid", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|person:mullah-omar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "person:mullah-omar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|scholar:ismail-patel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "scholar:ismail-patel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|book:mukhtasar-khalil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|event:black-death", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "event:black-death", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|org:almohads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "org:almohads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|org:almoravids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "org:almoravids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|quran:5:2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "quran:5:2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:al-izz-ibn-abd-al-salam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:al-qarafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:al-qarafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:ibn-arafa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:ibn-arafa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:ibn-waddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:ibn-waddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:al-andalus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:al-andalus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2015": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:istikhara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:istikhara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:mandub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:mandub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:nafl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:nafl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "term:tahiyyat-al-masjid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:dar-al-ifta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:dar-al-ifta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:madrasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:madrasa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:maulana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:maulana", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:mufti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:mufti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|term:ulama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "term:ulama", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|org:catholic-church", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "org:catholic-church", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|org:fatimids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "org:fatimids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|person:hasan-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|scholar:al-farabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "scholar:al-farabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|scholar:al-kindi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "scholar:al-kindi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:ahl-al-bayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:ismaili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:ismaili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WnchZwuZtf4|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WnchZwuZtf4|term:izar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "target": "term:izar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WnchZwuZtf4|term:najasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "target": "term:najasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|book:al-risalah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "book:al-risalah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|org:zanata", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "org:zanata", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|scholar:al-qarafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "scholar:al-qarafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|scholar:al-zanati", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "scholar:al-zanati", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|book:old-testament", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "book:old-testament", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|event:great-flood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "event:great-flood", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|person:gilgamesh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "person:gilgamesh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|person:nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "person:nuh", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|person:yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "person:yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|quran:29:14", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "quran:29:14", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|term:am", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "term:am", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|term:sana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "term:sana", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "scholar:hasan-farhan-al-maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:al-ansab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:al-ansab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:mizan-al-itidal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:mizan-al-itidal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:sunan-ibn-majah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:sunan-ibn-majah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "book:sunan-said-ibn-mansur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:3093", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:3093", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:4594", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:4594", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:5133", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5133", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:5136", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5136", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:5255", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:5492", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5492", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:5765", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5765", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:bukhari:6639", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:bukhari:6639", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:061599d0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:061599d0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:06746893", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:06746893", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:0a236306", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:0a236306", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:57dd2ee7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:57dd2ee7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:5bbe2f3e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:69a65512", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:69a65512", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:814474b9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:814474b9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:8e1abb62", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|hadith:fp:c92486c9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "hadith:fp:c92486c9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "principle:transmission-is-not-endorsement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|quran:10:99", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "quran:10:99", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|quran:18:29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "quran:18:29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|quran:5:96", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "quran:5:96", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abd-al-karim-ibn-abi-al-mukhariq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abu-al-darda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abu-al-darda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-al-samani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:abu-sad-al-samani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-asili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-asili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-bazdawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-bazdawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-daraqutni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-harawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-harawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-jurjani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-jurjani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-khattabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-khattabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-kushmihani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-kushmihani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-marwazi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-marwazi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-mustaghfiri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-mustaghfiri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-mustamli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-mustamli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-nuwayri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-nuwayri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-qabisi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-qabisi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-sadafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-sadafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-sarakhsi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:farabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:farabri", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:hammad-ibn-shakir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-adi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-adi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-makula", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-makula", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibn-rushayd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushayd", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ibrahim-ibn-maqil-al-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ikrima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ikrima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:imam-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:imam-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:islam-al-buhayri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:islam-al-buhayri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:jaun-elia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:jaun-elia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:jonathan-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:ludwig-wittgenstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:sibawayh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:sibawayh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|scholar:yunini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "scholar:yunini", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:isra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:isra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:riwaya-bil-mana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:sama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:sama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|term:wijada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "term:wijada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|book:al-utbiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "book:al-utbiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|quran:3:55", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "quran:3:55", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|quran:4:157-158", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "quran:4:157-158", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|quran:5:117", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "quran:5:117", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|scholar:shadee-elmasry", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|term:ihtimal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "term:ihtimal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:XttbK-raL6A|term:yataarrad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "term:yataarrad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|term:ruqya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "term:ruqya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|hadith:fp:517e74fc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|quran:112:1-4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "quran:112:1-4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|quran:113:1-5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "quran:113:1-5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|quran:113:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "quran:113:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|quran:114:1-6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "quran:114:1-6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|quran:2:102", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "quran:2:102", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|scholar:akram-nadwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "scholar:akram-nadwi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:al-ayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:al-ayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:hasad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:hasad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:istikhara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:istikhara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:muawwidhatayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:muawwidhatayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:97a63e0b", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:ace50479", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:ace50479", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:aea19cc5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:b339bf83", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:be25f934", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:be25f934", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "hadith:fp:d490f6bb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|org:banu-tamim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "org:banu-tamim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-salam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:kab-al-ahbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:kab-al-ahbar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:mariya-al-qibtiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:hassan-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:hassan-ali", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-shayba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:ijtihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:ijtihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:isnad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:isnad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:mash-ala-al-khuffayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:maturidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:maturidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:sard-al-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:sard-al-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:usul-al-fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:usul-al-fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:yajuj-and-majuj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:yajuj-and-majuj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|term:zakat-al-fitr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "term:zakat-al-fitr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|scholar:sherman-jackson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|term:ijtihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "term:ijtihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|term:ulama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "term:ulama", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|term:zina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "term:zina", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|event:silk-road", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "event:silk-road", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|org:roman-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "org:roman-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|term:hinduism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "term:hinduism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|principle:hadith-relativism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "principle:hadith-relativism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|person:yunus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "person:yunus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|quran:37:142", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "quran:37:142", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|quran:37:145", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "quran:37:145", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "hadith:fp:9d01b67f", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "principle:deen-taught-only-by-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|quran:2:255", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "quran:2:255", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|term:ayat-al-kursi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "term:ayat-al-kursi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|term:bayt-al-mal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "term:bayt-al-mal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|book:al-kashshaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "book:al-kashshaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|book:asas-al-balagha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "book:asas-al-balagha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "book:hujjat-allah-al-baligha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|book:the-satanic-verses", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "book:the-satanic-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|event:babri-masjid-dispute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "event:babri-masjid-dispute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|event:conquest-of-constantinople", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "event:hagia-sophia-reconversion-to-mosque", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 1, "start": 39, "end": 593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "event:islamabad-hindu-temple-controversy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 1, "start": 39, "end": 593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "event:sudan-legal-reforms-2020", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "hadith:fp:0ef3fb30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|hadith:fp:4a9d4173", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "hadith:fp:4a9d4173", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|hadith:fp:76d23e12", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "hadith:fp:76d23e12", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "hadith:fp:90dfbb22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|hadith:fp:92ce9938", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "hadith:fp:92ce9938", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|org:cia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "org:cia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|org:mossad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "org:mossad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|org:ottoman-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "org:ottoman-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|org:sharia-councils-uk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "org:sharia-councils-uk", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|org:wayfair", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "org:wayfair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:abla", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:abla", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:ahmad-faraz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:ahmad-faraz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 34, "start": 7118, "end": 7301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:antara-ibn-shaddad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:ghislaine-maxwell", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:ghislaine-maxwell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:imran-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:imran-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:jeffrey-epstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:jeffrey-epstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:joe-rogan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:joe-rogan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:justinian-i", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:justinian-i", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:kanye-west", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:kanye-west", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:mehmed-ii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:mehmed-ii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:prince-andrew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:prince-andrew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:recep-tayyip-erdogan", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:shabbir-ahmed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:shabbir-ahmed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:thrasymachus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:thrasymachus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|principle:might-is-right", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "principle:might-is-right", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|quran:22:40-41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "quran:22:40-41", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|quran:24:31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "quran:24:31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|quran:2:26", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "quran:2:26", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|quran:33:53", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "quran:33:53", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|quran:6:145", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "quran:6:145", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sudais", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:abu-al-hasan-al-ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:al-jahiz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:al-jahiz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:al-zamakhshari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:jonathan-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:qadi-abd-al-jabbar", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:rabia-al-ray", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:shah-wali-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:shah-wali-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|scholar:yasser-al-habib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "scholar:yasser-al-habib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:adhan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:adhan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:amir-al-muminin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:amir-al-muminin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:awrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:awrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:balagha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:balagha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:female-genital-mutilation", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:female-genital-mutilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:halal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:halal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:haya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:haya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:hikmah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:hikmah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:idtirab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:idtirab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:illiyyin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:illiyyin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:imamah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:imamah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:jihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:jihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:masjid-al-aqsa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:muallaqat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:muallaqat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:mufassirun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:mufassirun", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:mushrikin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:mushrikin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:najasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:najasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:sijjin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:sijjin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:tayf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:tayf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|term:waqf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "term:waqf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|event:european-colonialism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "event:european-colonialism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|org:charlie-hebdo", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "org:charlie-hebdo", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|person:emmanuel-macron", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "person:emmanuel-macron", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 915, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|person:samuel-paty", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "person:samuel-paty", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|book:al-risalah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "book:al-risalah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|book:sharh-al-umda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "book:sharh-al-umda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "hadith:fp:6dede3f3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|hadith:fp:955dafe4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "hadith:fp:955dafe4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:isbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:isbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:izar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:izar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:khuyala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:khuyala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|term:thawb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "term:thawb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:al-aqida-al-wasitiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:maratib-al-ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:maratib-al-ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:tafsir-al-mazhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|book:tawq-al-hamama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:black-death", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:black-death", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:european-colonialism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:european-colonialism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:industrial-revolution", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:industrial-revolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:mongol-invasions", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:mongol-invasions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:mongol-sack-of-baghdad-1258", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|event:reconquista", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "event:reconquista", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:17a84e78", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:17a84e78", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:4accedcd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:4accedcd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:6271346a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:6271346a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:7ef9c7d8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:8b0c9176", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "hadith:fp:c2ba830a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|org:banu-hashim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "org:banu-hashim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|org:levites", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "org:levites", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-abi-sarh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:akhenaten", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:akhenaten", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:al-asha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:al-asha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:charlemagne", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:charlemagne", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:charles-martel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:charles-martel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:harun-al-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:harun-al-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 45, "start": 12830, "end": 12910, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:nawwas-ibn-saman", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:qusayy-ibn-kilab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:sahla-bint-suhayl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:salah-al-din-al-ayyubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:salim-mawla-abi-hudhayfa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:21:34", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:21:34", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:33:21", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:33:21", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:3:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:3:46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:3:55", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:3:55", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:43:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:43:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:43:61", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:43:61", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:4:159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:4:159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:5:116-118", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:5:116-118", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:5:75", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:5:75", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|quran:94:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "quran:94:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:abu-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud-al-tayalisi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:abu-mushir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:abu-mushir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-baghawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-baghawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-hakim-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-hasan-al-halwani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-husayn-ibn-al-fadl-al-bajali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-khatib-al-baghdadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-layth-ibn-sad", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-walid-ibn-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ali-ibn-al-madini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:harmala-ibn-yahya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-adi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-adi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-jurayj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-rajab-al-hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:khalid-al-madaini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-yahya-al-dhuhli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:muhammad-nizami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:muhammad-nizami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:qutayba-ibn-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:rumi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:rumi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2021": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 45, "start": 12830, "end": 12910, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:yazid-ibn-abi-ziyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid-al-ayli", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:barakah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:barakah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:idraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:idraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:kahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:kahl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:kalam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:kalam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:mahram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:mahram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:masjid-al-nabawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:masjid-al-nabawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:mubham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:mubham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:mursal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:mursal", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:rada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:rada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:wahy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:wahy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sunan-al-darimi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sunan-al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sunan-al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "book:sunan-al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:0783df04", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:0783df04", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:127763c2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:127763c2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:51d6c137", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:51d6c137", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:6cc10484", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:6cc10484", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:89fbbe22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|hadith:fp:91e93693", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "hadith:fp:91e93693", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:abu-musa-al-ashari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:ibn-masud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:ibn-masud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:talut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:talut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "person:zaynab-al-thaqafiyya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|quran:24:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "quran:24:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|quran:68:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "quran:68:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:abu-asim-al-nabil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:abu-zura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:abu-zura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:al-darimi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:al-darimi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:asim-ibn-ubaydullah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:busr-ibn-said", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:busr-ibn-said", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ghunaym-ibn-qays", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-hatim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qattan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:thabit-ibn-umara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:thabit-ibn-umara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "scholar:ubayd-mawla-abi-ruhm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:ghusl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:ghusl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:isha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:isha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:jarh-wa-tadil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:jarh-wa-tadil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:majhul", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:majhul", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:munkar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:munkar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:qadhf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:qadhf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:sahabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:sahabah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|term:zina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "term:zina", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:abd-al-malik-ibn-habib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:al-lakhmi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:taqi-al-din-al-subki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|term:madhhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "term:madhhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|term:nafl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "term:nafl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|term:rakah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "term:rakah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|term:tahajjud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "term:tahajjud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|term:tarawih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "term:tarawih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|event:battle-of-awtas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "event:battle-of-awtas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|hadith:bukhari:5127", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5127", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|hadith:fp:1bc19689", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "hadith:fp:1bc19689", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|hadith:fp:a63dafe9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "hadith:fp:a63dafe9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:abu-al-as-ibn-al-rabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:hudhayfa-ibn-al-yaman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:qurayba-bint-abi-umayya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:umm-kulthum-bint-jarwal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|person:zaynab-bint-muhammad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "person:zaynab-bint-muhammad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "principle:trajectory-hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|quran:2:221", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "quran:2:221", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|quran:5:4-5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "quran:5:4-5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|quran:60:10", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "quran:60:10", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:abdullah-al-judai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:ahmad-umar-hashim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:al-sarakhsi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:al-sarakhsi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:tawus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:tawus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:yusuf-al-qaradawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:ahl-al-kitab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:jahiliyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:jahiliyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:mahr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:mahr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:majus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:majus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|term:urf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "term:urf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|org:yaqeen-institute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "org:yaqeen-institute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:asadullah-al-andalusi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:harris-sultan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:harris-sultan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|quran:49:17", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "quran:49:17", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:abu-ishaq-al-sabii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:al-amash", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:al-amash", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:omar-suleiman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|term:jariyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "term:jariyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|hadith:fp:68a420f4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "hadith:fp:68a420f4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|person:yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "person:yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|quran:12:41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "quran:12:41", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|scholar:edip-yuksel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "scholar:edip-yuksel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|scholar:rashad-khalifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "scholar:rashad-khalifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|term:rabb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "term:rabb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|event:battle-of-badr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "event:battle-of-badr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|event:battle-of-uhud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "event:battle-of-uhud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|event:year-of-sorrow", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "event:year-of-sorrow", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "hadith:fp:6ff2ecf8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "hadith:fp:7b34dd38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "hadith:fp:cd7aae33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|org:yaqeen-institute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "org:yaqeen-institute", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:abu-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:abu-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:jubayr-ibn-mutim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:khadijah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:khadijah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:khawla-bint-hakim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:khawla-bint-hakim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|person:sawda-bint-zama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "person:sawda-bint-zama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|scholar:omar-suleiman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|term:dar-al-harb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "term:dar-al-harb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|term:jariyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "term:jariyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|org:green-lane-masjid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "org:green-lane-masjid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "scholar:zakaullah-saleem", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:jahil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:jahil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:khutbah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:khutbah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:mufti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:mufti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|book:gospel-of-john", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "book:gospel-of-john", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|book:gospel-of-mark", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "book:gospel-of-mark", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|book:gospel-of-matthew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|org:catholic-church", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "org:catholic-church", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|person:zakariya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "person:zakariya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:19:16-22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:19:16-22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:2:253", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:2:253", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:2:87", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:2:87", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:3:45", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:3:45", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:4:171", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:4:171", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:4:24", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:4:24", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:58:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:58:22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:5:110", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:5:110", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:5:112-115", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:5:112-115", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:66:12", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:66:12", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:6:101", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:6:101", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|quran:6:85-87", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "quran:6:85-87", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|scholar:inayatullah-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "scholar:inayatullah-athari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|scholar:tamanna-imadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|term:almah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "term:almah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|term:kalimat-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "term:kalimat-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|term:ruh-al-qudus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "term:ruh-al-qudus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|hadith:fp:3e31381a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|hadith:fp:8737fe17", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "hadith:fp:8737fe17", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "hadith:fp:b3bd592a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "principle:resemblance-to-non-muslim-religious-practice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|scholar:abu-zahra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "scholar:abu-zahra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "scholar:hamza-al-kattani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:faqih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:faqih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:ikhtilaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:ikhtilaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:lihyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:lihyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:majus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:majus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|book:aina-kamalat-i-islam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "book:aina-kamalat-i-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|book:al-fazl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "book:al-fazl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|book:kashti-nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "book:kashti-nuh", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|book:kitab-al-bariyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "book:kitab-al-bariyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|book:ruhani-khazain", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "book:ruhani-khazain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|event:isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "event:isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|quran:94:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "quran:94:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:abul-kalam-azad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:mahmud-shaltut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:mirza-bashir-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:mirza-bashiruddin-mahmud-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:mustafa-al-maraghi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:rashid-rida", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:rashid-rida", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:sanaullah-amritsari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:sanaullah-amritsari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|term:mubahala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "term:mubahala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|term:nabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "term:nabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|event:golden-calf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "event:golden-calf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|hadith:bukhari:4725", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "hadith:bukhari:4725", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:khidr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:khidr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|person:yusha-ibn-nun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|quran:18:60", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "quran:18:60", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|term:bani-israil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "term:bani-israil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|event:banu-qurayza", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "event:banu-qurayza", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|event:siege-of-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "event:siege-of-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:38a17c20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:38a17c20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:87a6618e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:87a6618e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:943d2716", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:943d2716", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:94531d95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:94531d95", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:a44612d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:a44612d9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:c1643a4a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|hadith:fp:ebce1887", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "hadith:fp:ebce1887", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|org:banu-nadir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "org:banu-nadir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:abu-yasir-ibn-akhtab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:albert-einstein", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:albert-einstein", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:asma-bint-abi-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:dihya-al-kalbi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:dihya-al-kalbi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:huyayy-ibn-akhtab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:kinana-ibn-al-rabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:mahmud-ibn-maslama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:mahmud-ibn-maslama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:muhammad-ibn-maslama", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:tommy-robinson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:tommy-robinson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|person:umm-sulaym", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "person:umm-sulaym", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|principle:consent", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "principle:consent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|principle:matn-criticism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "principle:matn-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "principle:no-taqlid-in-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|quran:2:234", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "quran:2:234", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|quran:2:256", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "quran:2:256", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|scholar:ibn-ishaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|term:idtirab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "term:idtirab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|term:riwaya-bil-mana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "term:riwaya-bil-mana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|person:hawwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "person:hawwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:21:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:21:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:23:12-13", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:23:12-13", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:2:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:2:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:3:59", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:3:59", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:71:14", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:71:14", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:71:17", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:71:17", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|quran:7:189-190", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "quran:7:189-190", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "scholar:abd-al-sabur-shahin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|scholar:al-tabari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "scholar:al-tabari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|term:shirk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "term:shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "book:aridat-al-ahwadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:khuntha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:khuntha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:sahih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:sahih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|term:shariah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "term:shariah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "org:ruet-e-hilal-committee", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|person:qandeel-baloch", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "person:qandeel-baloch", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|scholar:abdul-qavi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "scholar:abdul-qavi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|term:nabidh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "term:nabidh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:al-muqaddimat-al-mumahhidat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:book-of-isaiah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:book-of-isaiah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:bukhari:5255", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:bukhari:5255", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:25953135", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:25953135", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:32d192a5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:32d192a5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:563127df", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:563127df", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:6e606353", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:6e606353", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:71fcade0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:71fcade0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:91d7502c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:a8f03a5c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|hadith:fp:ea6d857b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "hadith:fp:ea6d857b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|org:al-mahdi-institute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "org:al-mahdi-institute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|org:banu-hashim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "org:banu-hashim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:dan-gibson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:dan-gibson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:firas-zahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:firas-zahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:hamza-tzortzis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:hawwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:hawwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:juha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:juha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:lilith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:lilith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:lupe-fiasco", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:lupe-fiasco", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 24, "start": 6648, "end": 6706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:pervez-hoodbhoy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:pervez-hoodbhoy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:richard-dawkins", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:richard-dawkins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:zayd-ibn-haritha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|quran:17:90-93", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "quran:17:90-93", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|quran:88:17-20", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "quran:88:17-20", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:al-mazari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:al-mazari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:al-mazini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:al-mazini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:ammar-nakshawani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:ammar-nakshawani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:arif-abdulhussain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:nouman-ali-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:shady-nasser", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:shady-nasser", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:fadak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:fadak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:hunafa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:hunafa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:karamah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:karamah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:mujizah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:mujizah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:najasa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:najasa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:rashidun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:rashidun", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|term:wali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "term:wali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:al-muhalla", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:al-muhalla", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:al-mustadrak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:al-mustadrak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:darwins-cathedral", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:darwins-cathedral", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:nuskhat-ibn-saada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|event:battle-of-badr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "event:battle-of-badr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:07f4ecd1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:144726cc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:144726cc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:5cfe6af1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:75de6857", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:75de6857", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:a9513bc7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:a9513bc7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:b339bf83", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:b339bf83", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|hadith:fp:e592ec95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|org:sunni-defence", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "org:sunni-defence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "org:wuhan-institute-of-virology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 5, "start": 1138, "end": 1294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|org:zaytuna-college", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "org:zaytuna-college", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:aziz-mian", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:aziz-mian", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 30, "start": 8865, "end": 9022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:david-sloan-wilson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:david-sloan-wilson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 1, "start": 22, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:farid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:farid", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:frans-de-waal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:frans-de-waal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:jethro", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:jethro", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:jordan-peterson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:jordan-peterson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:nusrat-fateh-ali-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:nusrat-fateh-ali-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 30, "start": 8865, "end": 9022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:richard-dawkins", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:richard-dawkins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:ruqayya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:ruqayya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:sana-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:sana-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:shuayb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:shuayb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|principle:default-permissibility", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "principle:default-permissibility", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|quran:19:29", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "quran:19:29", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|quran:2:282", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "quran:2:282", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|quran:66:1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "quran:66:1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:abdalqadir-as-sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:abdullah-abdul-majid", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 1, "start": 22, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ahmad-shakir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ahmad-shakir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:al-qabisi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:al-qabisi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:bashar-awwad-maruf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:farabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:farabri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qasim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-sakan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-ghanim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-ghanim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:ibn-jurayj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:ibn-jurayj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:pir-naseeruddin-naseer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:rashid-rida", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:rashid-rida", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:sahnun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:sahnun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "scholar:umar-faruq-abdullah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 1, "start": 22, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:bayah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:bayah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:imam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:imam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:istishab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:istishab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:mahr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:mahr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:mutah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 4, "start": 981, "end": 1138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:tayammum", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:tayammum", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|term:zindiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "term:zindiq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|book:nayl-al-awtar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "book:nayl-al-awtar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|hadith:fp:3b2452f7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "hadith:fp:3b2452f7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|hadith:fp:bef7f59e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "hadith:fp:bef7f59e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|hadith:fp:e668f0cc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "hadith:fp:e668f0cc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|person:anas-ibn-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "person:anas-ibn-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-ibn-awf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "scholar:al-bara-ibn-azib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "scholar:al-zubayr-ibn-al-awwam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|term:khazz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "term:khazz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|term:makruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "term:makruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:foIzotT_sog|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:foIzotT_sog|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:foIzotT_sog|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|org:al-saud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "org:al-saud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|term:shirk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "term:shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|book:sunan-al-darimi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "book:sunan-al-darimi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|hadith:bukhari:4428", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "hadith:bukhari:4428", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|hadith:fp:0607111e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "hadith:fp:0607111e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|hadith:fp:91d7502c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "hadith:fp:91d7502c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|hadith:fp:e16705ba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "hadith:fp:e16705ba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "person:bishr-ibn-al-bara", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "principle:quran-takes-precedence-over-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|quran:5:67", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "quran:5:67", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|quran:69:44-46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "quran:69:44-46", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:abu-zura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:abu-zura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:al-nasai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:al-nasai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "scholar:yunus-ibn-yazid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gCid83kRA2I|term:tadlis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "term:tadlis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "scholar:ismail-al-qadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|term:awrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "term:awrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|term:fard", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "term:fard", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|event:battle-of-badr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "event:battle-of-badr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|event:bayat-al-ridwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "event:bayat-al-ridwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "hadith:fp:7a76ff4c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|org:byzantine-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "org:byzantine-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|org:house-of-karen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "org:house-of-karen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|org:sasanians", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "org:sasanians", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|person:salman-al-farisi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "person:salman-al-farisi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|quran:48:10", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "quran:48:10", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|event:council-of-nicaea-325", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "event:council-of-nicaea-325", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|hadith:fp:37195d28", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "hadith:fp:37195d28", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|person:david-wood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "person:david-wood", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|principle:faith-not-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "principle:faith-not-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "principle:miracles-do-not-defy-natural-law", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|quran:33:56", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "quran:33:56", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|scholar:shabir-ally", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "scholar:shabir-ally", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:adab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:adab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:kalam-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:kalam-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:shafaah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:shafaah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:sifat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:sifat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:tajsim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:tajsim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:takbir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:takbir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|term:trinity", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "term:trinity", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|hadith:fp:d333f073", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "hadith:fp:d333f073", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|person:blaise-pascal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "person:blaise-pascal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|person:jordan-peterson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "person:jordan-peterson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|quran:74:42-46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "quran:74:42-46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|term:rizq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "term:rizq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:mahram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:mahram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:niqab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|book:al-kitab-sibawayh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "book:al-kitab-sibawayh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "hadith:fp:10e8ca76", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|hadith:fp:c55bd513", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "hadith:fp:c55bd513", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|hadith:fp:f9e49159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "hadith:fp:f9e49159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|person:abu-jahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "person:abu-jahl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|person:salman-taseer", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "person:salman-taseer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|quran:21:107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "quran:21:107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|quran:68:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "quran:68:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|quran:96:15", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "quran:96:15", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "scholar:al-khalil-ibn-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|scholar:sibawayh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "scholar:sibawayh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|scholar:tariq-masood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "scholar:tariq-masood", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|term:kufr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "term:kufr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|term:mushaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "term:mushaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|term:nun-al-tawkid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "term:nun-al-tawkid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|term:rasm-uthmani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "term:rasm-uthmani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|hadith:fp:61e009d9", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "hadith:fp:61e009d9", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|org:jamaat-e-islami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "org:jamaat-e-islami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|scholar:al-tirmidhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "scholar:al-tirmidhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:akhirah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:akhirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:quranist", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:quranist", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "book:aqidah-tahawiyya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|event:conquest-of-constantinople", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "event:conquest-of-constantinople", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:3a3f2709", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:444310bc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:444310bc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:db4e34c0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:dd36e1dd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:f5b8c382", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|person:akbar-allahabadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "person:akbar-allahabadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "principle:hadith-must-not-contradict-reason-quran-or-principles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "principle:khabar-wahid-not-creed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "principle:no-takfir-of-ahl-al-qibla", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|quran:3:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "quran:3:46", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|quran:43:61", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "quran:43:61", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|quran:4:159", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "quran:4:159", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-barzanji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-barzanji", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-dahhak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-dahhak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-fadl-ibn-al-husayn-al-naysaburi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-safarini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-safarini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-sakhawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-sakhawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:al-tahawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:al-tahawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:fakhr-al-din-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:hamza-maqbool", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar-al-haytami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:mujahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:mujahid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|scholar:shadee-elmasry", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:ahad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:ahad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:aqidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:aqidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:kahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:kahl", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:mutawatir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:mutawatir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:qiraat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|hadith:fp:e4df847f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "hadith:fp:e4df847f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|person:anil-kapoor", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "person:anil-kapoor", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|scholar:mufti-menk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "scholar:mufti-menk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|term:sunnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "term:sunnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:assassination-of-uthman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:battle-of-al-harrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:battle-of-siffin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:battle-of-siffin", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:battle-of-the-camel", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:battle-of-the-camel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:conquest-of-makkah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:conquest-of-makkah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:karbala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:karbala", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|event:saqifa-of-banu-saida", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "event:saqifa-of-banu-saida", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|hadith:bukhari:6830", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "hadith:bukhari:6830", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|hadith:fp:ef524ec4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "hadith:fp:ef524ec4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:banu-hashim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:banu-hashim", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:banu-tamim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:banu-tamim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:byzantine-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:byzantine-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:ghassanids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:ghassanids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:lakhmids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:lakhmids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:sasanians", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:sasanians", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-abi-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:abu-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:abu-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:al-farazdaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:al-farazdaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:amr-ibn-al-as", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:amr-ibn-al-as", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:hani-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:hani-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:hasan-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2020": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:muslim-ibn-aqil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:muslim-ibn-aqil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:numan-ibn-bashir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:numan-ibn-bashir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:ubaydullah-ibn-ziyad", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:umar-ibn-sad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:umar-ibn-sad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|person:ziyad-ibn-abihi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "person:ziyad-ibn-abihi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|scholar:ali-khamenei", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "scholar:ali-khamenei", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "scholar:ruhollah-khomeini", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:ashura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:ashura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:bayah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:bayah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:marja", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:marja", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:matam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:matam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|term:shura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "term:shura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|book:consciousness-beyond-life", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "book:consciousness-beyond-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|book:torah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "book:torah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|event:battle-of-the-trench", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|event:covid-19-pandemic", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "event:covid-19-pandemic", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 2, "start": 742, "end": 995, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|hadith:fp:04750067", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "hadith:fp:04750067", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|hadith:fp:c8516683", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "hadith:fp:c8516683", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|org:al-azhar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "org:al-azhar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 17, "start": 5548, "end": 6501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|org:banu-hashim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "org:banu-hashim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:abbas-ibn-abd-al-muttalib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:abu-jafar-al-mansur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:elon-musk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:elon-musk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:habil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:habil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:qabil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:qabil", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "principle:prohibition-tied-to-circumstances-of-the-time", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|quran:5:27-31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "quran:5:27-31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|quran:5:31", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "quran:5:31", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 23, "start": 9393, "end": 9928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 27, "start": 11043, "end": 11201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "scholar:urwa-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:ashrat-al-saah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:ashrat-al-saah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:hifz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:hifz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:ijazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:ijazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:maysir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:maysir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:neo-traditionalism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:neo-traditionalism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 15, "start": 5381, "end": 5461, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:psilocybin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:psilocybin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|book:the-third-chimpanzee", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|org:united-nations", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "org:united-nations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:aristotle", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:aristotle", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:bertrand-russell", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:bertrand-russell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:immanuel-kant", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:immanuel-kant", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:jared-diamond", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:jared-diamond", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:jean-jacques-rousseau", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:jean-jacques-rousseau", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:jeremy-bentham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:jeremy-bentham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:john-locke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:john-locke", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:plato", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:plato", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:socrates", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:socrates", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|person:thomas-hobbes", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "person:thomas-hobbes", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:raf-al-yadayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:raf-al-yadayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:riddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:riddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|book:guru-granth-sahib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "book:guru-granth-sahib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|book:in-gods-path", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "book:in-gods-path", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|event:pagan-gate-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "event:pagan-gate-2020", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|hadith:fp:03b390a1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "hadith:fp:03b390a1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|hadith:fp:37b7d106", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "hadith:fp:37b7d106", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "hadith:fp:eb88e4e6", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|org:al-maghrib-institute", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "org:al-maghrib-institute", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|org:byzantine-empire", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "org:byzantine-empire", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:hamza-tzortzis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:hamza-tzortzis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 29, "start": 10613, "end": 10754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:immanuel-kant", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:immanuel-kant", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:jay-smith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:jay-smith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:patricia-crone", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:patricia-crone", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|person:robert-hoyland", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "person:robert-hoyland", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|quran:16:89", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "quran:16:89", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|quran:2:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "quran:2:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|quran:51:56", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "quran:51:56", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|quran:6:38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "quran:6:38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:ibn-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 3, "start": 1494, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 3, "start": 1494, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:jonathan-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:omar-suleiman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:ahl-al-kitab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:ahl-al-kitab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:batil-and-fasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:batil-and-fasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:jahil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:jahil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:jannah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:jannah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:majus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:majus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:mawali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:mawali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:murjia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:murjia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:qura", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:qura", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:ruh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:ruh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:shariah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:shariah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:shirk", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:umrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:umrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|event:battle-of-the-trench", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "event:battle-of-the-trench", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "event:treaty-of-hudaybiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|hadith:fp:2154cd27", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "hadith:fp:2154cd27", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "hadith:fp:43b54f5f", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "hadith:fp:8bb1ef7b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "org:saudi-permanent-committee-for-fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|person:abu-said-al-khudri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "person:abu-said-al-khudri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|person:adi-ibn-hatim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "person:adi-ibn-hatim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|person:ibn-umar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "person:ibn-umar", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|quran:3:97", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "quran:3:97", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:ibn-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:ibn-al-humam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-humam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:ibn-baz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:ibn-baz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:ibn-sirin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:ibn-sirin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|scholar:suhaib-webb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "scholar:suhaib-webb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:hajj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:hajj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:kunya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:kunya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:mahram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:mahram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:rada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:rada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:k9V9aM16G1k|term:bimaristan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:k9V9aM16G1k", "target": "term:bimaristan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|hadith:fp:4abab576", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "hadith:fp:4abab576", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "principle:quran-addresses-the-imagination", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|quran:3:7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "quran:3:7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|term:jannah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "term:jannah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|term:mutashabih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "term:mutashabih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|book:musnad-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "book:musnad-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|hadith:fp:091fe423", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "hadith:fp:091fe423", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|hadith:fp:3e31381a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|hadith:fp:700a667a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "hadith:fp:700a667a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|scholar:al-baji", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "scholar:al-baji", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "scholar:mustafa-al-zarqa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|term:fitrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "term:fitrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|term:lihyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "term:lihyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "book:al-munqidh-min-al-dalal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|event:oj-simpson-trial-1995", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "event:oj-simpson-trial-1995", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|event:soviet-afghan-war", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "event:soviet-afghan-war", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|hadith:fp:0576bb02", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "hadith:fp:0576bb02", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "hadith:fp:2a4080d4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:al-qaeda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:al-qaeda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:cia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:cia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:hizb-ut-tahrir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 29, "start": 8107, "end": 8456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:jamia-binoria", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:jamia-binoria", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:jamia-faruqiya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:jamia-faruqiya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:sipah-e-sahaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:sipah-e-sahaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|org:tablighi-jamaat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:buddha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:buddha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:khadim-hussain-rizvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:leo-tolstoy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:leo-tolstoy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:muhammad-ali-jinnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:noam-chomsky", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:noam-chomsky", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|person:osama-bin-laden", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "person:osama-bin-laden", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|quran:30:41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "quran:30:41", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|quran:41:53", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "quran:41:53", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|quran:50:19", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "quran:50:19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|quran:50:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "quran:50:22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|quran:9:38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "quran:9:38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:abdul-rahman-hassan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-al-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:al-burzuli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:al-burzuli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:farabri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:farabri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:ibn-lubaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:ibn-lubaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:jaun-elia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:jaun-elia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:mayyara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:mayyara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:muhammad-naeem", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:muhammad-naeem", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|scholar:shabir-ally", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "scholar:shabir-ally", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:cannabis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:cannabis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:dmt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:dmt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:hikmah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:hikmah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:psilocybin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:psilocybin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|term:zuhd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "term:zuhd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|book:al-shamail", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "book:al-shamail", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|book:the-study-quran", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "book:the-study-quran", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "org:board-for-protecting-sunni-beliefs-bradford", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:abdullah-bin-bayyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:ashraf-ali-thanwi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:saqib-shaami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|scholar:taqi-usmani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "scholar:taqi-usmani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:karamah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:karamah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|term:tariqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "term:tariqah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|book:the-third-chimpanzee", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|person:jared-diamond", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "person:jared-diamond", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|person:lut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "person:lut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|person:matt-walsh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "person:matt-walsh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|scholar:omar-suleiman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "scholar:omar-suleiman", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|term:dawah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "term:dawah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|term:majus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "term:majus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "book:al-tahrir-wa-al-tanwir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|book:deuteronomy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "book:deuteronomy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|hadith:fp:517e74fc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "hadith:fp:517e74fc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:amir-ibn-rabia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:amir-ibn-rabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:binyamin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:binyamin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:dante-alighieri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:dante-alighieri", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:francis-bacon", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:francis-bacon", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:ibn-al-haytham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:ibn-al-haytham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:leonardo-da-vinci", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:leonardo-da-vinci", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:martin-luther", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:martin-luther", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:sahl-ibn-hunayf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:thomas-aquinas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:thomas-aquinas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:william-shakespeare", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:william-shakespeare", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:yaqub", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:yaqub", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|person:yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "person:yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|quran:113:1-5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "quran:113:1-5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|quran:12:58-68", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "quran:12:58-68", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|quran:3:155", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "quran:3:155", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|quran:68:51", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "quran:68:51", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|quran:6:38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "quran:6:38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-sanani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:abu-al-muzaffar-al-samani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:abu-hatim-al-razi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:al-daraqutni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:al-daraqutni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:al-thaalibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:al-thaalibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:al-zamakhshari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:al-zamakhshari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:hassan-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:hassan-ali", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:ibn-khaldun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:ibn-khaldun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:mamar-ibn-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:muslim-ibn-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "scholar:wuhayb-ibn-khalid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|term:al-ayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "term:al-ayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|term:ghayb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "term:ghayb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|term:hasad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "term:hasad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nZdIoI1JWwM|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nZdIoI1JWwM", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "scholar:umar-ibn-abd-al-aziz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:gharaniq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:gharaniq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:ijazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:ijazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:isnad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:isnad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:mawdu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:mawdu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|term:tarawih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "term:tarawih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:noE0Z72gUbs|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:noE0Z72gUbs|scholar:al-suyuti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "target": "scholar:al-suyuti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:noE0Z72gUbs|term:jannah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "target": "term:jannah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|hadith:fp:3530749e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "hadith:fp:3530749e", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|hadith:fp:cdce764b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "hadith:fp:cdce764b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|term:backfire-effect", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "term:backfire-effect", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|term:dawah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "term:dawah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|principle:context-of-revelation", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "principle:context-of-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|quran:58:22", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "quran:58:22", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|quran:9:1-3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "quran:9:1-3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-abd-al-wahhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:al-wala-wal-bara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:al-wala-wal-bara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:bara", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:bara", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:bidah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:bidah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:dawah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:dawah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:maturidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:maturidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:mawadda", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:mawadda", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:al-bayan-wa-al-tahsil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:al-mujam-al-awsat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:al-mujam-al-awsat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:al-tabsira", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:al-tabsira", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:fath-al-bari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:fath-al-bari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:kitab-al-tawwabin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:kitab-al-tawwabin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:musnad-abi-yala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:musnad-abi-yala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "book:siyar-alam-al-nubala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|event:golden-calf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "event:golden-calf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|event:karbala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "event:karbala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:0e110483", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:0e110483", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:11191dca", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:11191dca", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:17fbddbc", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:29d1db38", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:29d1db38", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:3c7da8ed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:3c7da8ed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:664cc2c3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|hadith:fp:6897f8ca", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "hadith:fp:6897f8ca", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:hani-ibn-thubayt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:harun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:harun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:hasan-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:hasan-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:ibn-muljam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:ibn-muljam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|principle:culture-versus-religion", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "principle:culture-versus-religion", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:abd-al-ghani-al-daqr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:abu-yala-al-mawsili", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:al-lakhmi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:al-lakhmi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:al-tabarani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:al-tabarani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:amr-ibn-dinar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-zayd-al-qayrawani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:ibn-hajar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:ibn-hajar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:ibn-qudama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:ibn-qudama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd-al-jadd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:imran-ibn-hittan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-baqir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:qadi-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:qadi-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:rabia-al-ray", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:rabia-al-ray", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:sibawayh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:sibawayh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:sufyan-ibn-uyayna", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "scholar:zayn-al-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:aqiqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:aqiqah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:hirz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:hirz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:jahiliyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:jahiliyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:kohl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:kohl", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:mukallaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:mukallaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:sahabah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:sahabah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:psuMMzjvfRI|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:psuMMzjvfRI", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "hadith:fp:bc9a2ac5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|quran:57:13", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "quran:57:13", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|scholar:al-baydawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "scholar:al-baydawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|scholar:ibn-rushd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "scholar:ibn-rushd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:adhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:adhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:ijtihad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:ijtihad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:kafir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:kafir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:maturidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:maturidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|org:loreal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "org:loreal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|person:amena-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "person:amena-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:r196CQ7qkaY|term:fard-kifayah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:r196CQ7qkaY", "target": "term:fard-kifayah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:r196CQ7qkaY|term:jumuah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:r196CQ7qkaY", "target": "term:jumuah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|book:al-mabsut", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "book:al-mabsut", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|event:founding-of-baghdad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "event:founding-of-baghdad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "hadith:fp:07a1c5d0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "person:ibrahim-ibn-abd-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|person:zayd-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:al-awzai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:al-awzai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:al-shabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:al-shabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:hammad-ibn-abi-sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:ibn-abi-layla", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:ibn-abi-layla", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-al-hasan-al-shaybani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:sherman-jackson", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:sherman-jackson", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|scholar:zufar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "scholar:zufar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:ahl-al-bayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:ahl-al-ray", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:ahl-al-ray", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:hiyal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:hiyal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:khamr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:khamr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:kunya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:kunya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:madhhab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:madhhab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:nabidh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:nabidh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:nikah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:nikah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:tabiun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:tabiun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:talaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:talaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:taqlid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:taqlid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:zahir-al-riwaya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:zahir-al-riwaya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|term:zifaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "term:zifaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s9JKA9ZjI28|book:mukhtasar-khalil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "target": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s9JKA9ZjI28|scholar:shadee-elmasry", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "target": "scholar:shadee-elmasry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:s9JKA9ZjI28|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|book:book-of-isaiah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "book:book-of-isaiah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|book:gospel-of-matthew", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "book:gospel-of-matthew", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "event:seizure-of-the-grand-mosque-1979", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "org:al-jamaa-al-salafiyya-al-muhtasiba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|org:the-mad-mamluks", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "org:the-mad-mamluks", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:juhayman-al-utaybi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|person:zakariyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "person:zakariyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|quran:21:96", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "quran:21:96", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:abd-al-rahman-al-sadi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:abu-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:abu-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:ibn-baz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:ibn-baz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:muqbil-al-wadii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:tamanna-imadi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:tamanna-imadi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:aql", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:aql", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:dhul-qarnayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:dhul-qarnayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:kafir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:kafir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:manzila-bayn-al-manzilatayn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:mutazila", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:mutazila", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:wahhabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:wahhabi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "term:yajuj-wa-majuj", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "event:break-in-at-the-hosts-home-2021", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "hadith:fp:6e8a4bfd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|term:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "term:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|term:takfir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "term:takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|book:maa-al-nas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "book:maa-al-nas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "scholar:muhammad-al-yaqoubi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "scholar:said-ramadan-al-buti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|term:jannah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "term:jannah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|event:battle-of-badr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "event:battle-of-badr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|org:nabataeans", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "org:nabataeans", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:abu-bakr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:abu-bakr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:abu-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:abu-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:daniel-brubaker", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:daniel-brubaker", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:david-wood", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:david-wood", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:jay-smith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:jay-smith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:jibril", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:jibril", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:muawiya-ibn-abi-sufyan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:patricia-crone", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:patricia-crone", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:shady-nasser", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:shady-nasser", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:abu-amr-al-dani", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:al-bajuri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:al-bajuri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:al-baqillani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:al-baqillani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:al-qasim-al-shatibi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:ibn-al-jazari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jazari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:ibn-ghalbun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:ibn-mujahid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:ibn-mujahid", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|term:ashari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "term:ashari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|term:kalam-allah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "term:kalam-allah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|term:qiraat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "term:qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|term:rasm-uthmani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "term:rasm-uthmani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|term:rukhsah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "term:rukhsah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|book:old-testament", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "book:old-testament", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "hadith:fp:ca03ed2b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "event:birmingham-road-blockade-protest-2021", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|event:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "event:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|event:isra-and-miraj", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "event:isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "event:palestinian-crisis-2021", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|org:united-nations-security-council", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "org:united-nations-security-council", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:abd-al-malik-ibn-marwan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:benjamin-netanyahu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:benjamin-netanyahu", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:joe-biden", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:joe-biden", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|term:hijrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "term:hijrah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|term:masjid-al-aqsa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "term:masjid-al-aqsa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|term:qiblah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "term:qiblah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uVRr1jjbLEs|hadith:fp:54f5da0f", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "target": "hadith:fp:54f5da0f", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uVRr1jjbLEs|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:uVRr1jjbLEs|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|book:the-wealth-of-nations", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "book:the-wealth-of-nations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|hadith:fp:17da26fe", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "hadith:fp:17da26fe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|hadith:fp:74385080", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "hadith:fp:74385080", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "hadith:fp:9a6e8d05", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|hadith:fp:bca2b93a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "hadith:fp:bca2b93a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|person:adam-smith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "person:adam-smith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "principle:ruling-lapses-with-its-cause", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|quran:2:229", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "quran:2:229", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|quran:2:275", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "quran:2:275", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|quran:2:276", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "quran:2:276", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|quran:2:279", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "quran:2:279", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|quran:59:7", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "quran:59:7", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|scholar:ibn-ulayya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "scholar:ibn-ulayya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:ahd-dhihni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:ahd-dhihni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:barakah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:barakah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:hadiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:hadiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:hiyal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:hiyal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:jizya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:jizya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:khars", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:khars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2017": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 124, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:riba-al-fadl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:riba-al-fadl", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:riba-al-jahiliyyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:riba-al-jahiliyyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:riba-al-nasia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:riba-al-nasia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:sadaqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:sadaqah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:udmzRAYYgfI|person:dawah-man", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:udmzRAYYgfI", "target": "person:dawah-man", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:udmzRAYYgfI|term:dawah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:udmzRAYYgfI", "target": "term:dawah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|quran:5:5", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "quran:5:5", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|term:iman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "term:iman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|term:tawhid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "term:tawhid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:umPepYIsc_g|hadith:fp:0da2986c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "hadith:fp:0da2986c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:umPepYIsc_g|term:al-razzaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "term:al-razzaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:umPepYIsc_g|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:umPepYIsc_g|term:dunya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "term:dunya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|org:chishti-order", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "org:chishti-order", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|scholar:saqib-shaami", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "scholar:saqib-shaami", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|term:pir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "term:pir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|term:tariqah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "term:tariqah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|term:tasawwuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "term:tasawwuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "hadith:fp:1fd6f410", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|hadith:fp:3e31381a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "hadith:fp:3e31381a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "hadith:fp:42fd73b8", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|org:quraysh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "org:quraysh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "principle:consistency-in-applying-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|term:lihyah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "term:lihyah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|term:urf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "term:urf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "person:daniel-haqiqatjou", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|scholar:jonathan-brown", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "scholar:jonathan-brown", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|term:khuntha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "term:khuntha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|term:mushkil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "term:mushkil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|quran:2:30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "quran:2:30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|term:bashar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "term:bashar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|term:khalifah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "term:khalifah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "scholar:jafar-al-sadiq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|term:ahl-al-bayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|term:sufi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "term:sufi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|term:twelve-imams", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "term:twelve-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|event:assassination-of-uthman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "event:assassination-of-uthman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|event:battle-of-al-harrah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "event:battle-of-al-harrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|event:karbala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "event:karbala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "event:murder-of-samuel-paty-2020", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|hadith:fp:054ae057", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "hadith:fp:054ae057", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "hadith:fp:3635d5d3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|org:abbasids", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "org:abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|org:ahmadiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "org:ahmadiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|org:charlie-hebdo", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "org:charlie-hebdo", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:abd-al-rahman-ibn-al-ashath", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:abdullah-ibn-al-zubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:abu-jahl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:abu-jahl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:abu-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:abu-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:al-hajjaj-ibn-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:amir-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:amir-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:conor-mcgregor", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:conor-mcgregor", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:donald-trump", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:donald-trump", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:emmanuel-macron", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:emmanuel-macron", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 1, "start": 27, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:fatima", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:fatima", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:husayn-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:husayn-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:joe-biden", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:joe-biden", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:juan-cole", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:juan-cole", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:khabib-nurmagomedov", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:khabib-nurmagomedov", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 1, "start": 27, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:mohammed-hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:mohammed-hijab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:richard-dawkins", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:richard-dawkins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:samuel-paty", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:samuel-paty", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 1, "start": 27, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:sonny-bill-williams", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:sonny-bill-williams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:uthman-ibn-affan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:uthman-ibn-affan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:yazid-ibn-muawiya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|person:zayd-ibn-ali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "person:zayd-ibn-ali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|quran:27:18", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "quran:27:18", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|quran:4:129", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "quran:4:129", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|quran:4:3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "quran:4:3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|quran:9:97-99", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "quran:9:97-99", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:adnan-ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:hisham-ibn-urwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:javed-ahmad-ghamidi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:mirza-ghulam-ahmad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:rumi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:rumi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:adab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:adab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 27, "start": 10196, "end": 10262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:ahl-al-bayt", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:ahl-al-bayt", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:collective-consciousness", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:collective-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:dhabiha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:dhabiha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:fitnah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:fitnah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:halal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:halal", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:harmala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:harmala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:hiyal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:hiyal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:kaaba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:kaaba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:khatm-al-nubuwwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:maqasid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:maqasid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:maslaha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:maslaha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:niqab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:polygamy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:polygamy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:riba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:riba", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:shariah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:shariah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:sharif", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:sharif", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:sunni", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:sunni", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:thawb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:thawb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:zakat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:zakat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|term:zoroastrianism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "term:zoroastrianism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "person:hamza-ali-abbasi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|person:harris-sultan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "person:harris-sultan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|person:junaid-jamshed", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "person:junaid-jamshed", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|person:shah-rukh-khan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "person:shah-rukh-khan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|hadith:fp:43b7f583", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "hadith:fp:43b7f583", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "hadith:fp:6214b4e1", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|quran:3:185", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "quran:3:185", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|quran:67:2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "quran:67:2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|quran:89:27-30", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "quran:89:27-30", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|term:janazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "term:janazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|term:sihr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "term:sihr", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|term:tawiz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "term:tawiz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|book:kitab-al-zahra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "book:kitab-al-zahra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|book:sunan-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "book:sunan-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|book:tawq-al-hamama", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "book:tawq-al-hamama", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|event:mihna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "event:mihna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "hadith:fp:79be7eb2", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "hadith:fp:9bbc1d36", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|org:isis", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "org:isis", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:al-amin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:al-amin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:al-mamun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:al-mamun", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:harun-al-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:harun-al-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:kawthar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:kawthar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "person:muhammad-ibn-jami-al-saydalani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "principle:hudud-change-with-the-age", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|quran:18:46", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "quran:18:46", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|quran:3:14", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "quran:3:14", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:al-burzuli", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:al-burzuli", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:al-dhahabi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:al-dhahabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:al-hakam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:al-hakam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:dawud-al-zahiri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:dawud-al-zahiri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-qayyim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:ibrahim-al-nakhai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:muhammad-ibn-dawud-al-zahiri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "scholar:yahya-ibn-aktham", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:deen", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:deen", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:hudud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:hudud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:ijma", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:ijma", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:luti", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:luti", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|term:zina", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "term:zina", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yJGrP8cVk-M|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yJGrP8cVk-M|term:mahram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "target": "term:mahram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yJGrP8cVk-M|term:masjid-al-haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "target": "term:masjid-al-haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "book:al-muharrar-al-wajiz", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|book:bible", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "book:bible", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|book:book-of-jeremiah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "book:book-of-jeremiah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|book:book-of-judges", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "book:book-of-judges", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|book:tafsir-al-samani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "book:tafsir-al-samani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|person:ishaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "person:ishaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|person:ismail", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "person:ismail", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|person:jephthah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "person:jephthah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|quran:37:102", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "quran:37:102", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|quran:37:103-107", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "quran:37:103-107", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:bala", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:bala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:el", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:el", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:israiliyyat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:israiliyyat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:naskh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:naskh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:ruya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:ruya", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|term:yahweh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "term:yahweh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|scholar:zakir-naik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "scholar:zakir-naik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|term:hanbali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "term:hanbali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|term:salafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "term:salafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|term:wahi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "term:wahi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "book:al-hadhar-fi-amr-al-khadir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|book:al-mustadrak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "book:al-mustadrak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|event:golden-calf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "event:golden-calf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|hadith:bukhari:4725", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "hadith:bukhari:4725", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "hadith:fp:5f1d2c6c", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:firawn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:firawn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:ibn-abbas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:ibn-abbas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:ilyas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:ilyas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:khidr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:khidr", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:nawf-al-bikali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:nawf-al-bikali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:saint-george", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:saint-george", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:ubayy-ibn-kab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|person:yusha-ibn-nun", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "person:yusha-ibn-nun", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|quran:18:60-82", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "quran:18:60-82", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|quran:21:34", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "quran:21:34", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:abd-al-razzaq-al-kashani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:abdullah-ibn-al-mubarak", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:abu-al-aliya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:abu-al-aliya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:al-baghawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:al-baghawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:al-ghazali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:al-ghazali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:al-nawawi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:al-nawawi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:al-qushayri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:al-qushayri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jawzi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:ibn-al-salah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-salah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:ibn-ishaq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:ibn-ishaq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:ibn-kathir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:ibn-kathir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:ibrahim-al-harbi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:mulla-ali-al-qari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|term:salaf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "term:salaf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|term:wali", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "term:wali", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "book:al-kafi-fi-fiqh-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|hadith:fp:ced425d4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "hadith:fp:ced425d4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|org:umayyads", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "org:umayyads", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "person:ali-ibn-abi-talib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:hasan-al-basri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:hasan-al-basri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:ismail-ibn-abi-uways", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:said-ibn-al-musayyib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "scholar:said-ibn-jubayr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:khawarij", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:khawarij", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:qabd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:qabd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:sadl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:sadl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|term:tarawih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "term:tarawih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|quran:68:4", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "quran:68:4", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:abu-bakr-ibn-abi-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:abu-dawud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:abu-dawud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:ahmad-ibn-hanbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:al-awzai", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:al-awzai", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:al-hasan-ibn-salih", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:al-shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:al-shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:ibn-abd-al-barr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:ibn-al-jarud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "scholar:sufyan-al-thawri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|term:adab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "term:adab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|term:shafii", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "term:shafii", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|book:gospel-of-luke", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "book:gospel-of-luke", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|book:puranas", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "book:puranas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "book:urwat-al-wuthqa", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|event:peacock-throne", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "event:peacock-throne", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:adam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:adam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:herod-the-great", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:herod-the-great", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:ibrahim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:ibrahim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:manu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:manu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:maryam", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:maryam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:nuh", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:pandora", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:pandora", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:prometheus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:prometheus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:queen-of-sheba", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:queen-of-sheba", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:sulayman", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:sulayman", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:vishnu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:vishnu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|person:zeus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "person:zeus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:12:3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:12:3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:18:50", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:18:50", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:19:27-33", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:19:27-33", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:20-21", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:20-21", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:22-24", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:22-24", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:23", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:23", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:27", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:27", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:34", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:34", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:38-39", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:38-39", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:40", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:40", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:41", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:41", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:42", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:42", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:27:44", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:27:44", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:35:43", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:35:43", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|quran:9:92", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "quran:9:92", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "scholar:abdul-karim-athari", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|term:hudhud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "term:hudhud", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|term:ifrit", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "term:ifrit", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|term:jinn", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "term:jinn", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|term:shaytan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "term:shaytan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|term:trinity", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "term:trinity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:al-mudawwana", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:al-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:al-murshid-al-muin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:al-murshid-al-muin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:mukhtasar-khalil", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:mukhtasar-khalil", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:sahih-muslim", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:sahih-muslim", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:the-cosmic-serpent", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:the-cosmic-serpent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|book:the-third-chimpanzee", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "book:the-third-chimpanzee", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "event:black-lives-matter-protests-2020", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "event:france-headscarf-ban-for-minors-2021", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "event:reddit-hedge-fund-battle-2021", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:07d42a1a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:19b3f804", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:19b3f804", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:24232b79", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:24232b79", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:246187ac", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:246187ac", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:266d2083", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:266d2083", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:2741e4cd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:3e965d16", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:3e965d16", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:47be092d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:47be092d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:706285e0", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:706285e0", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:8a99943b", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:8a99943b", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:a6bf32eb", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:c0b608bd", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:c538564d", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:c538564d", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:f6cdbddf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "hadith:fp:fbb17a0e", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|org:al-zaytuna", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "org:al-zaytuna", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|org:tablighi-jamaat", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "org:tablighi-jamaat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:abu-hurayra", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:abu-hurayra", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:galileo-galilei", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:galileo-galilei", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:ibn-sayyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:ibn-sayyad", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:isa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:isa", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:lupe-fiasco", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:lupe-fiasco", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:michel-foucault", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:michel-foucault", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 15, "start": 5472, "end": 5656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:muhammad-al-nafs-al-zakiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:muhammad-ibn-al-hanafiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:mukhtar-al-thaqafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:nicolaus-copernicus", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:nicolaus-copernicus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:tamim-al-dari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:tamim-al-dari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:tariq-ramadan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:tariq-ramadan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "person:umar-ibn-al-khattab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "principle:only-allah-declares-haram", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|quran:6:145", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "quran:6:145", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:abdalhaqq-bewley", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:abu-hanifa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:abu-hanifa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:adis-duderija", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:adis-duderija", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 1, "start": 32, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:aisha-bewley", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:aisha-bewley", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:al-zuhri", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:al-zuhri", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:ali-laraki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:ali-laraki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:atabek-shukurov-nasafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:hamza-maqbool", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:hamza-maqbool", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:hamza-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:hamza-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:ibn-abidin", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:ibn-abidin", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:ibn-ashur", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:ibn-ashur", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:joseph-lumbard", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:joseph-lumbard", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:muhammad-abduh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:muhammad-abduh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:muhammad-iqbal", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:rami-nsour", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:rami-nsour", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:ubaydullah-sindhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|scholar:yasir-qadhi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "scholar:yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 4, "start": 1176, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:barelvi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:barelvi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:dajjal", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:dajjal", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 4, "start": 1176, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:deobandi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:deobandi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:dhabiha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:dhabiha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:dhikr", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:dhikr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:dua", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:dua", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:fatwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:fatwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:fiqh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:fiqh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:haram", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:haram", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:hijab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:hijab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:ijazah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:ijazah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:mahdi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:mahdi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 4, "start": 1176, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 4, "start": 1176, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:nafl", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:nafl", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:shia", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:shia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:sujud", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:sujud", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:taqwa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:taqwa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|term:wudu", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "term:wudu", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|book:sahih-al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "book:sahih-al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|event:battle-of-khaybar", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "event:battle-of-khaybar", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|hadith:fp:d574a07a", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "hadith:fp:d574a07a", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|hadith:fp:e592ec95", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "hadith:fp:e592ec95", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|hadith:fp:e92689a3", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "hadith:fp:e92689a3", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|person:aisha", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "person:aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|person:musa", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "person:musa", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|person:nuh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "person:nuh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "person:safiyya-bint-huyayy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "person:zaynab-bint-jahsh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|scholar:asrar-rashid", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "scholar:asrar-rashid", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|term:iddah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "term:iddah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|term:kafir", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "term:kafir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|book:muwatta", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "book:muwatta", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|principle:hadith-relativism", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "principle:hadith-relativism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|principle:living-tradition-as-source", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "principle:living-tradition-as-source", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "principle:sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|scholar:abu-yusuf", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "scholar:abu-yusuf", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|scholar:al-bukhari", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "scholar:al-bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "scholar:ibn-taymiyya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|scholar:imam-malik", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "scholar:imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|scholar:qadi-iyad", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "scholar:qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|term:adhan", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "term:adhan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "term:amal-ahl-al-madinah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|term:gharaniq", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "term:gharaniq", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|term:maliki", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "term:maliki", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zkklciv1TK8|term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "term:silsilat-al-dhahab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|scholar:al-albani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "scholar:al-albani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|scholar:al-shawkani", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "scholar:al-shawkani", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|scholar:ibn-hazm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "scholar:ibn-hazm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|term:hanafi", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "term:hanafi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|term:kaffarah", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "term:kaffarah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|term:qada", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "term:qada", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "cites|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|term:sawm", "kind": "cites", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "term:sawm", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 40, "start": 11390, "end": 11541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 10, "start": 3320, "end": 3802, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/book-lounge|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/book-lounge|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/book-lounge|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/film-and-popular-culture|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/film-and-popular-culture", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 23, "start": 6905, "end": 7205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 25, "start": 7289, "end": 7484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 10, "start": 2387, "end": 2597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 11, "start": 2597, "end": 2861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 13, "start": 2992, "end": 3238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 16, "start": 5022, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 5, "start": 1142, "end": 1525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 6, "start": 1525, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 7, "start": 1993, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 16, "start": 5656, "end": 5740, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 9, "start": 2895, "end": 3128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/urdu-poetry|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 2, "start": 531, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/urdu-poetry|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/urdu-poetry|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/urdu-poetry|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:arts/urdu-poetry|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 19, "start": 4555, "end": 4823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 31, "start": 7144, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 28, "start": 10262, "end": 10339, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 33, "start": 9187, "end": 9268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 44, "start": 10771, "end": 10928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 15, "start": 4202, "end": 4844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 21, "start": 5811, "end": 5918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 5, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 3, "2020": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 9, "start": 2384, "end": 2784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 18, "start": 4826, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 11, "start": 3031, "end": 3153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 10, "start": 2784, "end": 3031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 36, "start": 11777, "end": 12163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 17, "start": 3744, "end": 3936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 7, "2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 25, "start": 6809, "end": 7056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 13, "start": 2996, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 42, "start": 10920, "end": 11481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 26, "start": 6077, "end": 6234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 14, "years": {"2018": 8, "2020": 2, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 22, "years": {"2021": 22}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 19, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 16}, "tiers": {"machine": 19}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 9, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 15, "start": 3012, "end": 3169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 16, "start": 4844, "end": 5044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 17, "start": 5044, "end": 5325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 25, "start": 10109, "end": 10229, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 22, "start": 5918, "end": 6008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/god-and-attributes|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fko_FZwwNbA", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240304"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 6, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 24, "start": 5942, "end": 6145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 10, "2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 12, "start": 3153, "end": 3450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 29, "start": 10339, "end": 10439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2017": 4, "2018": 6, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2016": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 7, "start": 1481, "end": 1638, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 4, "start": 700, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 30, "start": 6679, "end": 6758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 9, "start": 2537, "end": 2615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 36, "start": 8335, "end": 8650, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 28, "start": 8062, "end": 8107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 3, "start": 471, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 3, "start": 508, "end": 1059, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 30, "start": 11208, "end": 11456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 909, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 21, "start": 4593, "end": 4866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2020": 7, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3736, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHVPqWZ6BeE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 2, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 24, "start": 8706, "end": 8821, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 26, "start": 9231, "end": 9541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 23, "start": 6337, "end": 6746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 10, "start": 2801, "end": 3337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2017": 5, "2018": 3, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 5, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 35, "start": 9664, "end": 10070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 3, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2017": 10, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 26, "start": 10229, "end": 11043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 6, "start": 1160, "end": 1455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 21, "start": 6688, "end": 6801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 31, "start": 9022, "end": 9653, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 37, "start": 8724, "end": 8840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 10, "start": 2615, "end": 3154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 36, "start": 8532, "end": 8724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 34, "start": 10791, "end": 11151, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 8, "start": 2842, "end": 2949, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 20, "start": 5065, "end": 5301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 34, "start": 8545, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 3, "start": 230, "end": 578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 19, "start": 6263, "end": 6531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 6, "start": 1402, "end": 1873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 4, "start": 694, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2020": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 5, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 16, "years": {"2020": 3, "2025": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 20, "start": 7324, "end": 7483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 15, "start": 3504, "end": 3743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 21, "years": {"2020": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 2, "start": 176, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3778, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 1, "2025": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 2, "start": 194, "end": 412, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 1, "start": 35, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 10, "start": 2173, "end": 2327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 377, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 34, "start": 10443, "end": 10911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 2, "start": 181, "end": 408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 2, "start": 217, "end": 404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 3, "start": 377, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 34, "start": 9914, "end": 10150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 18, "start": 3936, "end": 4130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 24, "start": 7070, "end": 7289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 4, "start": 875, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 2, "start": 220, "end": 457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 51, "start": 10462, "end": 10788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 33, "start": 10088, "end": 10791, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 4, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 32, "start": 11487, "end": 11766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 38, "start": 13506, "end": 13970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 8, "start": 2977, "end": 3198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 33, "start": 8950, "end": 9507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 6, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 6, "start": 1148, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 3, "start": 620, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 13, "start": 3026, "end": 3264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 7, "start": 1579, "end": 1656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 15, "start": 3304, "end": 3453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 10, "start": 2164, "end": 2401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 25, "start": 5573, "end": 5968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 23, "start": 6880, "end": 7070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 32, "start": 9932, "end": 10088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "OCiapHX4cGI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 1079, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200620"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 26, "start": 10002, "end": 10196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 25, "start": 6244, "end": 6549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 13, "start": 4029, "end": 4212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 36, "start": 6785, "end": 7250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2EnVV2NUehw", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 9, "start": 2378, "end": 2809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 30, "start": 9503, "end": 9617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 14, "start": 3654, "end": 4031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 4, "start": 557, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 35, "start": 10760, "end": 11153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 5, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}, {"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "bY3zp-4lYFI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 27, "start": 8369, "end": 8598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 3, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 9, "start": 1793, "end": 2082, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/divorce|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 16, "start": 3758, "end": 3972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 20, "start": 7510, "end": 7616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 20, "start": 6531, "end": 6688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 13, "start": 3736, "end": 4204, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 26, "start": 7484, "end": 7600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 23, "start": 6333, "end": 6648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 28, "start": 6413, "end": 6643, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 33, "start": 7571, "end": 7953, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 34, "start": 7953, "end": 8341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 26, "start": 6010, "end": 6087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 24, "start": 5171, "end": 5443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/food|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/food", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 3, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/inheritance|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 16, "start": 4379, "end": 4583, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2014": 3, "2017": 2, "2018": 2, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2015": 3, "2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 3, "2019": 2, "2020": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/legal-theory|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2014": 5, "2015": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 21, "start": 5301, "end": 5549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 15, "start": 4264, "end": 4379, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2015": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 3, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 10, "start": 2809, "end": 3040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 11, "start": 3040, "end": 3279, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 17, "start": 4583, "end": 4826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2015": 1, "2017": 8, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 8, "start": 2260, "end": 2363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2021": 1, "2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 1, "2015": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 2, "2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 33, "start": 7313, "end": 7550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2025": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 10, "start": 2007, "end": 2086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 14, "years": {"2020": 13, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 11, "start": 3154, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/purification|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/purification", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 2, "start": 380, "end": 534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 3, "2018": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 12, "start": 3279, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 8, "2019": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": false, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 10, "2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 4, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 13, "start": 3450, "end": 3788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2018": 6, "2020": 1, "2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 8, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/bukhari|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 7, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 2, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 2, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 14, "start": 3788, "end": 4202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 1, "2017": 1, "2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": false, "count": 12, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 5, "2021": 2, "2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 11, "years": {"2020": 7, "2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 28, "start": 8816, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 26, "start": 8509, "end": 8664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:history/companions", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 2, "2020": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 27, "start": 8664, "end": 8816, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/companions|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/companions", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/human-origins|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/human-origins", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/human-origins|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/human-origins", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/human-origins|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/human-origins", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/human-origins|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/human-origins", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/human-origins|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/human-origins", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 20, "start": 4364, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 6, "start": 1168, "end": 1359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 5, "start": 872, "end": 1296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 19, "start": 4244, "end": 4632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 5, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/strength-in-stories|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/strength-in-stories|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/subcontinent|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/subcontinent", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 6, "start": 1356, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 1, "2020": 3, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 6, "start": 1016, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/arabic-language|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 6, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 4, "start": 779, "end": 1198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 7, "start": 1678, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 20, "start": 5702, "end": 5811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 17, "years": {"2018": 3, "2019": 5, "2020": 7, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 18, "start": 4387, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 20, "start": 4823, "end": 5092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 33, "start": 8743, "end": 9188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2020": 4, "2021": 1, "2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/hermeneutics|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 3, "2020": 3, "2021": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 1, "2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 2, "2019": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 14, "start": 3017, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 22, "start": 4866, "end": 5060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/love-and-romance|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 1, "2018": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 40, "start": 8455, "end": 8835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 2, "start": 311, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 31, "start": 9238, "end": 9932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 8, "start": 1468, "end": 1860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 8, "start": 2160, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 3, "start": 731, "end": 1562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 2, "start": 427, "end": 663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": false, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 4, "2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 3, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 38, "start": 7970, "end": 8272, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 11, "start": 2327, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 16, "start": 3511, "end": 3744, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 3, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 9, "start": 1993, "end": 2173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 12, "start": 2479, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/britain|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 4, "start": 909, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/britain|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/britain|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 4, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/covid-19|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/covid-19|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/covid-19|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": false, "count": 10, "years": {"2020": 2, "2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 3, "start": 477, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/pakistan|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/pakistan|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 2, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/pakistan|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/pakistan|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/palestine|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/current-events/palestine|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 1, "2019": 1, "2021": 1, "2022": 1, "2023": 3, "2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 9, "start": 2407, "end": 2562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 5, "start": 1258, "end": 1348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture|topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "target": "topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 3, "start": 404, "end": 605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 8, "start": 1537, "end": 1793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": false, "count": 3, "years": {"2015": 2, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 2, "start": 168, "end": 323, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/islam-and-modernity|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 1, "2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/islam-and-modernity|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/islam-and-modernity|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 19, "start": 4130, "end": 4364, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/race-and-identity|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/race-and-identity|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/technology-and-media|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/women-and-gender|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:society/women-and-gender|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 25, "start": 9856, "end": 10002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 28, "start": 6361, "end": 6520, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 1, "2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}, {"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}, {"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 18, "start": 5795, "end": 6263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": false, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 1, "2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 35, "start": 8974, "end": 9510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "co_occurs|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "co_occurs", "source": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": false, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 5, "start": 2027, "end": 2578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--OJasWltLU|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--OJasWltLU|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--OJasWltLU", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 4, "start": 666, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 13, "start": 2540, "end": 2698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 51, "start": 10462, "end": 10788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 2, "start": 296, "end": 450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 6, "start": 1298, "end": 1414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 27, "start": 5103, "end": 5180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 57, "start": 11860, "end": 11906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 36, "start": 6785, "end": 7250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 36, "start": 6785, "end": 7250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 51, "start": 10462, "end": 10788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 53, "start": 11148, "end": 11303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 21, "start": 4472, "end": 4500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:--PntsaR8ck|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:--PntsaR8ck", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-JYtKJ9z1cw", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-lbZ11113SU|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-lbZ11113SU|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-lbZ11113SU|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-lbZ11113SU|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-lbZ11113SU", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:-oPJEZ12NQ8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0BOmiPpDvgo|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0BOmiPpDvgo", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0Ln_viR6LnI|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0Ln_viR6LnI", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2017": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:0oVIsExS4cA|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:0oVIsExS4cA", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:143df7icoYU|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:143df7icoYU|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:143df7icoYU|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:143df7icoYU|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:143df7icoYU|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:143df7icoYU", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1ybpO86BP8Y|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1ybpO86BP8Y", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 15, "start": 3786, "end": 4012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 42, "start": 10920, "end": 11481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 34, "start": 8545, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 34, "start": 8545, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 12, "start": 3044, "end": 3090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 26, "start": 6010, "end": 6087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 26, "start": 6010, "end": 6087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 42, "start": 10920, "end": 11481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 4, "start": 1297, "end": 1546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 22, "start": 5293, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 35, "start": 8974, "end": 9510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 36, "start": 9510, "end": 10131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:1zgHntbMPis|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:1zgHntbMPis", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 35, "start": 8974, "end": 9510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2AxJjFrnD20|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2AxJjFrnD20", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2EnVV2NUehw|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2EnVV2NUehw", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2EnVV2NUehw", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2EnVV2NUehw|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2EnVV2NUehw", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2EnVV2NUehw", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2HeZQyp_S4M|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2HeZQyp_S4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2cei2vnTjes|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2cei2vnTjes|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2cei2vnTjes|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2cei2vnTjes", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:2kQbnCU09YM|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:2kQbnCU09YM", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:31RnFwtYbwU|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:31RnFwtYbwU", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3Ux_bLoLSf8", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3rPUgpmWEp0|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3rPUgpmWEp0", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3tQUslWseTo|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:3tQUslWseTo|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:3tQUslWseTo", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:47ghxXHtlN8|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:47ghxXHtlN8", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:47ghxXHtlN8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:47ghxXHtlN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:49_S1uD7UTk|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:49_S1uD7UTk", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4PESNMaHO20|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4PESNMaHO20|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4PESNMaHO20", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4URwiwu3X7o|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4URwiwu3X7o", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:4WUwTJQAmx0|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:4WUwTJQAmx0", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 8, "start": 1852, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:fiqh/inheritance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:fiqh/inheritance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 10, "start": 2007, "end": 2086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:51Qevhjqnt4|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:51Qevhjqnt4", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 10, "start": 2007, "end": 2086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5is8qPu5lLU|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5is8qPu5lLU", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:5phyGJpJMMw|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:5phyGJpJMMw", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:626JfCE_j_8|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:626JfCE_j_8|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:626JfCE_j_8|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:626JfCE_j_8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2017": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6_dmOJl-_bI|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6_dmOJl-_bI", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:6aPj1fuMN24|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:6aPj1fuMN24", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 14, "years": {"2018": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7CYLT19GX5k|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7CYLT19GX5k", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 81, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 6, "start": 1270, "end": 1448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7EER9UKa1eA|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7EER9UKa1eA", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7IMg-l3vbcY|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7IMg-l3vbcY", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7NAjZrtcNZ0", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:arts/persian-and-sufi-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7SkyPhQZdY8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7SkyPhQZdY8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 3, "start": 620, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 6, "start": 1148, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 6, "start": 1148, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 3, "start": 620, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7UXKLQH8-ig|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7UXKLQH8-ig", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2017": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 25, "years": {"2017": 25}, "tiers": {"machine": 25}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2017": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:7z8yu8Kr83Y", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8JX1u0qQYAE|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8JX1u0qQYAE", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8U9-ASlyrzE|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8U9-ASlyrzE", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 44, "start": 10771, "end": 10928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 18, "start": 4055, "end": 4213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 30, "start": 6679, "end": 6758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 36, "start": 8335, "end": 8650, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 4, "start": 893, "end": 1287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 8, "start": 1927, "end": 2006, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 10, "start": 2164, "end": 2401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 13, "start": 3026, "end": 3264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 25, "start": 5573, "end": 5968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 36, "start": 8335, "end": 8650, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/exemptions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/making-up-fidya-kaffarah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/times-and-moon-sighting", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 2, "start": 656, "end": 734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 33, "start": 7313, "end": 7550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 33, "start": 7313, "end": 7550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 13, "start": 3026, "end": 3264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 30, "start": 6679, "end": 6758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 10, "start": 2164, "end": 2401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 25, "start": 5573, "end": 5968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 28, "start": 6361, "end": 6520, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 28, "start": 6361, "end": 6520, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 44, "start": 10771, "end": 10928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8XuHMCz2N3U|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8XuHMCz2N3U", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:8zY0NDQvL2U|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:8zY0NDQvL2U", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9cYDToRoy7Q|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9cYDToRoy7Q", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9kK28jhdcA8|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9kK28jhdcA8", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:9tHI3gcIiCk|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:9tHI3gcIiCk", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ATcN8aUo8oc|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ATcN8aUo8oc", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 9, "start": 2895, "end": 3128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2019": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 9, "start": 2895, "end": 3128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AXXuB9lxFoc|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AXXuB9lxFoc", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AZJBapbSjDo|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AZJBapbSjDo", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AhTy-xxH79g|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AhTy-xxH79g", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwhVA-P9rTo|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwhVA-P9rTo", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwxuMQnPbw0|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwxuMQnPbw0|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:AwxuMQnPbw0|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:AwxuMQnPbw0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BC8qsIOFAwE|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BC8qsIOFAwE", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BPBiF_hAKgQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Bgsfy-UmSA4", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2017": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 8, "start": 2260, "end": 2363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 13, "years": {"2017": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 8, "start": 2260, "end": 2363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:BiN9UQPOpMA|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:BiN9UQPOpMA", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:C-9MCspQqwE|topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:C-9MCspQqwE", "target": "topic:quran/quranic-guidance-for-living", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:C-9MCspQqwE|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:C-9MCspQqwE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "topic:belief/sufism/ibn-arabi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CIPm_CHV0Kw", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:CnwAjt1i9Bo", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Cz26by1mMns|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Cz26by1mMns|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Cz26by1mMns|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Cz26by1mMns|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Cz26by1mMns", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DAVFpkd1ECo|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DAVFpkd1ECo", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DYnuJS-DTMU|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DYnuJS-DTMU", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DYnuJS-DTMU|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DYnuJS-DTMU", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DhKc0LO1e18|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DhKc0LO1e18", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:DnueaKQQZXY|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:DnueaKQQZXY", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ETWstnCMgZA|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ETWstnCMgZA", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EWmBN7JV9Dk", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EcabHd3Hf6U|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EcabHd3Hf6U", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:EoQ_mXafx5o|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:EoQ_mXafx5o", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:FNtMxwadPAc|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:FNtMxwadPAc", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:F_4jnUA3ARQ", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fiq59Zcj9KU|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fiq59Zcj9KU", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fiq59Zcj9KU", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191106"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fko_FZwwNbA|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fko_FZwwNbA", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fko_FZwwNbA", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240304"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fko_FZwwNbA|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fko_FZwwNbA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fko_FZwwNbA", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240304"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Fz6mtRfzUDI", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:G0iGieTCklk|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:G0iGieTCklk|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:G0iGieTCklk|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:G0iGieTCklk", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GAm6NYtozDg|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GAm6NYtozDg", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:GdlCbTkYHgM|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:GdlCbTkYHgM", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Grh2ZU4awQI|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Grh2ZU4awQI", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H4IXL17jyEU|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H4IXL17jyEU", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H4IXL17jyEU|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H4IXL17jyEU", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H4IXL17jyEU|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H4IXL17jyEU", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:H8SXk-2-W-4|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:H8SXk-2-W-4", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 4, "start": 700, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 4, "start": 700, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HIU1GJSzg1E|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HIU1GJSzg1E", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:HLHgB2tyt-c|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:HLHgB2tyt-c", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 40, "start": 11390, "end": 11541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 21, "start": 5529, "end": 5607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 33, "start": 9187, "end": 9268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 909, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 33, "start": 9187, "end": 9268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 909, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 25, "start": 6244, "end": 6549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 9, "start": 1793, "end": 2082, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 16, "start": 3758, "end": 3972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 11, "start": 2232, "end": 2310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 10, "start": 2082, "end": 2232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 12, "start": 2310, "end": 2427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 16, "start": 3758, "end": 3972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 32, "start": 9037, "end": 9187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 40, "start": 11390, "end": 11541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 39, "start": 11266, "end": 11390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 4, "start": 909, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 4, "start": 909, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 8, "start": 1537, "end": 1793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 8, "start": 1537, "end": 1793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 9, "start": 1793, "end": 2082, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Hv-BlBVTr4M", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 25, "start": 6244, "end": 6549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IXSyLbrg6A0|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IXSyLbrg6A0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2018": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:IijbMTxUEOw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:IijbMTxUEOw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:J9NB1eLQ56Y", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:JP-vZ7g-UW0|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:JP-vZ7g-UW0", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 2, "start": 220, "end": 457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:JP-vZ7g-UW0|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:JP-vZ7g-UW0", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 2, "start": 220, "end": 457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:JQMaIJJJVoI|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:JQMaIJJJVoI", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 6, "start": 1016, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K6fAZ7xW53Y", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2019": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 6, "start": 1016, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 8, "start": 1327, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K8VL17CEZW0|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K8VL17CEZW0", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K8VL17CEZW0|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K8VL17CEZW0", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:K8VL17CEZW0|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:K8VL17CEZW0", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:arts/poetry-and-the-mind", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:arts/poetry-and-the-mind", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 21, "start": 4976, "end": 5241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 38, "start": 10039, "end": 10497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 14, "start": 2927, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 6, "start": 1428, "end": 1506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 19, "start": 4244, "end": 4632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 8, "start": 1616, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 26, "start": 6556, "end": 6869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 19, "start": 4244, "end": 4632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KWmtt2TQAO0|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KWmtt2TQAO0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KrIGi3OmJD4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KrIGi3OmJD4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 7, "start": 1481, "end": 1638, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 20, "years": {"2020": 20}, "tiers": {"machine": 20}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 4, "start": 694, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 7, "start": 1481, "end": 1638, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 4, "start": 694, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KsQKsrXndNw|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KsQKsrXndNw", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:KuSevqg0low|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:KuSevqg0low", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LJpCQXiII98|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LJpCQXiII98|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LJpCQXiII98|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LJpCQXiII98", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 17, "years": {"2018": 17}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/difficult-parents", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LeXzvtf9YGA|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LeXzvtf9YGA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LnOAQLLkvNo|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LnOAQLLkvNo", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LnOAQLLkvNo|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LnOAQLLkvNo", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:LyZCk5dygJk|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:LyZCk5dygJk", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 3, "start": 477, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:M6R6PNmTG0w|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:M6R6PNmTG0w", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 3, "start": 477, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NGz8JO6O0f4|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NGz8JO6O0f4", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 23, "years": {"2018": 23}, "tiers": {"machine": 23}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 15, "start": 3012, "end": 3169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 26, "start": 6077, "end": 6234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 41, "start": 9070, "end": 9265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 26, "start": 6077, "end": 6234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2018": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 15, "start": 3012, "end": 3169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NHzYu3BKBWE|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NHzYu3BKBWE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NIVZcdJxC2o|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NIVZcdJxC2o|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:NIVZcdJxC2o|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:NIVZcdJxC2o", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}, {"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:O3SO0Hmtatc|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:O3SO0Hmtatc", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OCiapHX4cGI|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OCiapHX4cGI", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OCiapHX4cGI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 1079, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200620"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OCiapHX4cGI|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OCiapHX4cGI", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OCiapHX4cGI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 1079, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200620"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2025": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 14, "years": {"2025": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2025": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 28, "years": {"2025": 28}, "tiers": {"machine": 28}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2025": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2025": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2025": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2025": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ONzjD7XMDhE|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ONzjD7XMDhE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2025": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Opl3bF6wzAs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Opl3bF6wzAs", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:OtQqc3K4HWA|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:OtQqc3K4HWA", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:P4QG7Z3O8k4", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PhrSS-NiR30|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PhrSS-NiR30", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PiFqxkWyrwg|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PiFqxkWyrwg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:PkP3itoSKJc|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:PkP3itoSKJc", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QAXeuR-UXvo|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QAXeuR-UXvo", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2016": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2016": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:QBvWBHOIzW4|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:QBvWBHOIzW4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:R7s1DcClcwU|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:R7s1DcClcwU", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RJe0SL67QzM|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RJe0SL67QzM", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RM4jHsWJ_uM", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:RNWtaWHPx3A|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:RNWtaWHPx3A", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T-X4Lyns2vE|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T-X4Lyns2vE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2022": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2022": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:T0pHQRNJjBY|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:T0pHQRNJjBY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TFZo7S3T_8o|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TFZo7S3T_8o", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TPH6TdXXLh4|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TPH6TdXXLh4", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 13, "start": 2996, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 21, "years": {"2021": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 18, "years": {"2021": 18}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 13, "start": 2996, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR3NSX3UFy8|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR3NSX3UFy8", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:arts/film-and-popular-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:arts/film-and-popular-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 23, "start": 6905, "end": 7205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 2, "start": 296, "end": 490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 7, "start": 1604, "end": 2192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 14, "start": 4254, "end": 4482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 18, "start": 5248, "end": 5419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 24, "start": 7205, "end": 7365, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 27, "start": 8369, "end": 8598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 30, "start": 9503, "end": 9617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 23, "start": 6905, "end": 7205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 9, "start": 2479, "end": 2755, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 30, "start": 9503, "end": 9617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 27, "start": 8369, "end": 8598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 20, "start": 5593, "end": 5783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4|topic:wellbeing/health-and-fitness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TR4-gh0qEZ4", "target": "topic:wellbeing/health-and-fitness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 11, "start": 2865, "end": 3101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TRR4o2JZIZc|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TRR4o2JZIZc", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TgaNlc0x_iI|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TgaNlc0x_iI", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TincZqdQpgs|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TincZqdQpgs|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:TincZqdQpgs|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:TincZqdQpgs", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UiXtl3PQP-Q", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/grave-and-barzakh", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 15, "years": {"2018": 15}, "tiers": {"machine": 15}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 560, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:UuLDZkLvxvo|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:UuLDZkLvxvo", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VRYy1_gzEUs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VRYy1_gzEUs", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 7, "start": 1579, "end": 1656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 15, "start": 3304, "end": 3453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:history/foundations-of-islam-qadi-iyad", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 7, "start": 1579, "end": 1656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2015": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 2, "start": 168, "end": 323, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 15, "start": 3304, "end": 3453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VZRrlX3lIVk|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VZRrlX3lIVk", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2015": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 2, "start": 168, "end": 323, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2023": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 14, "years": {"2023": 14}, "tiers": {"machine": 14}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VhqVM47pNS0|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VhqVM47pNS0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 13, "years": {"2018": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:VyAwDWTHPa4|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:VyAwDWTHPa4", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WCgxQDwCHKs|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WCgxQDwCHKs", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WDD_GyzI9Dg", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2015": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2015": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WIrT3DXSvd8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WIrT3DXSvd8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wl7wIKke16Q|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wl7wIKke16Q", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WmzC28PLYSQ|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WmzC28PLYSQ", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WnchZwuZtf4|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WnchZwuZtf4|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WnchZwuZtf4", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:WoYX5hIFSVg|topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:WoYX5hIFSVg", "target": "topic:fiqh/work-and-study-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Wpqa8rxaI-U", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X27ZZBCSEyg|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X27ZZBCSEyg", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 16, "years": {"2018": 16}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:X6SfFYRljeY|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:X6SfFYRljeY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:XttbK-raL6A|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:XttbK-raL6A", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2019": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:YPFQpHdSbGg|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:YPFQpHdSbGg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Yd3ehW0VTls|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Yd3ehW0VTls", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 10, "start": 2387, "end": 2597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 11, "start": 2597, "end": 2861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 13, "start": 2992, "end": 3238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 19, "start": 4555, "end": 4823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 10, "start": 2387, "end": 2597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 24, "start": 5942, "end": 6145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 35, "start": 9664, "end": 10070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 2, "start": 217, "end": 404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 15, "start": 3504, "end": 3743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 36, "start": 10070, "end": 10444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 11, "start": 2597, "end": 2861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 6, "start": 1168, "end": 1359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 24, "start": 5942, "end": 6145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 16, "years": {"2020": 16}, "tiers": {"machine": 16}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 15, "start": 3504, "end": 3743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 18, "start": 4387, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 19, "start": 4555, "end": 4823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 20, "start": 4823, "end": 5092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 33, "start": 8743, "end": 9188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 35, "start": 9664, "end": 10070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 13, "start": 2992, "end": 3238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 18, "start": 4387, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 20, "start": 4823, "end": 5092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 33, "start": 8743, "end": 9188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 3, "start": 404, "end": 605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 2, "start": 217, "end": 404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 3, "start": 404, "end": 605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZAsz48lX_WI|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZAsz48lX_WI", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 6, "start": 1168, "end": 1359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZMSmkLdEgSo", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZOo6W9bfn7I", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 1, "start": 35, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 20, "start": 7324, "end": 7483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 34, "start": 9914, "end": 10150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 21, "years": {"2020": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 26, "start": 8509, "end": 8664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 28, "start": 8816, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 27, "start": 8664, "end": 8816, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 20, "start": 7324, "end": 7483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 28, "start": 8816, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 26, "start": 8509, "end": 8664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 27, "start": 8664, "end": 8816, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/abuse-and-marital-rape", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 1, "start": 35, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 34, "start": 9914, "end": 10150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ZmIrskjob4o|topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ZmIrskjob4o", "target": "topic:wellbeing/mindfulness-and-presence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:Zs1rLN2Djss|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:Zs1rLN2Djss", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:_dSMPIAR0BM|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:_dSMPIAR0BM", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a-CIW2-K4Y0", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a3i0x1A5CFw|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a3i0x1A5CFw", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 34, "start": 7118, "end": 7301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 40, "start": 8455, "end": 8835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 38, "start": 7970, "end": 8272, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 40, "start": 8455, "end": 8835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 38, "start": 7970, "end": 8272, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 41, "start": 8835, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 37, "start": 7828, "end": 7970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:a6H5lYE4MN8|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:a6H5lYE4MN8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 915, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:aNLFdEEOH5Y", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:awbO9rHPvpU|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:awbO9rHPvpU", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/primers-risalah-and-ashmawiya", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2021": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 25, "start": 6809, "end": 7056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 21, "years": {"2021": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 10, "start": 2801, "end": 3337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 18, "years": {"2021": 18}, "tiers": {"machine": 18}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 25, "start": 6809, "end": 7056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 10, "start": 2801, "end": 3337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 2, "start": 776, "end": 922, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance/classical-love-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:b1OOltqtPTw|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:b1OOltqtPTw", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bO72u9ThuK8|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bO72u9ThuK8", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/night-worship-and-laylat-al-qadr", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bU0XXOk5oIU|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bU0XXOk5oIU", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bY3zp-4lYFI|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bY3zp-4lYFI", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bY3zp-4lYFI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:bY3zp-4lYFI|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:bY3zp-4lYFI", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "bY3zp-4lYFI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2019": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c8fjy8MceZM|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c8fjy8MceZM", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 6, "start": 1160, "end": 1455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:c9vke9Rpq9o|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:c9vke9Rpq9o", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 6, "start": 1160, "end": 1455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cAjsGNs9EiY|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cAjsGNs9EiY", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHVPqWZ6BeE|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHVPqWZ6BeE", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHVPqWZ6BeE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHVPqWZ6BeE|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHVPqWZ6BeE", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHVPqWZ6BeE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cHyxRI7Trnk|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cHyxRI7Trnk", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cKWRLHtBYgo|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cKWRLHtBYgo", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cV8ZMcMyPk0", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:cVGwFnbQv0Q", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2014": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:d95_pYj6NiA|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:d95_pYj6NiA", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2019": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dECxAg9D9g8|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dECxAg9D9g8", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dROSEctL_tQ|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dROSEctL_tQ", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2018": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2018": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:dpeR6Y4MGwA", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:e6jWtFf8smw|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:e6jWtFf8smw", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eJS0IBhhPg0|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eJS0IBhhPg0", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eR1bDjDv0l0|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eR1bDjDv0l0", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 33, "start": 8950, "end": 9507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 24, "start": 6648, "end": 6706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 14, "start": 3654, "end": 4031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/animals-and-pets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 22, "start": 6275, "end": 6333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 23, "start": 6333, "end": 6648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 14, "start": 3654, "end": 4031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/missed-prayers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 33, "start": 8950, "end": 9507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 23, "start": 6333, "end": 6648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:relationships/parents-and-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 8, "start": 1468, "end": 1860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 8, "start": 1468, "end": 1860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:wellbeing/negative-thoughts-and-mindset", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eo90sV4JVHo|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eo90sV4JVHo", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 23, "start": 6337, "end": 6746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 31, "start": 9022, "end": 9653, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 23, "start": 6337, "end": 6746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 35, "start": 10760, "end": 11153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 31, "start": 9022, "end": 9653, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 35, "start": 10760, "end": 11153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 8, "start": 2160, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 2, "start": 427, "end": 663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 3, "start": 663, "end": 981, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 5, "start": 1138, "end": 1294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 8, "start": 2160, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 2, "start": 427, "end": 663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:eoKcNwGGIBA|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:eoKcNwGGIBA", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 21, "years": {"2020": 21}, "tiers": {"machine": 21}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 2, "start": 176, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3778, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 22, "years": {"2020": 22}, "tiers": {"machine": 22}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 2, "start": 176, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3778, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f2BcGWatU5g|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f2BcGWatU5g", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:f4R0NXnYmpc|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:f4R0NXnYmpc", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:foIzotT_sog|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:foIzotT_sog|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:foIzotT_sog|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:foIzotT_sog", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:g57BdMdAUKM|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:g57BdMdAUKM", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gCid83kRA2I|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gCid83kRA2I", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gV69XFzFuEk|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gV69XFzFuEk", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gXBZY_ph7Bg", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2018": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2018": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gyRfZZZcA8g|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gyRfZZZcA8g", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:gzKvxYPY-GI|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:gzKvxYPY-GI", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hE3WjiQoxAA|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hE3WjiQoxAA", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2024": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2024": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 5, "start": 1258, "end": 1348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hMUrvU2c9YQ", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2024": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 5, "start": 1258, "end": 1348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 3, "start": 508, "end": 1059, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 31, "years": {"2020": 31}, "tiers": {"machine": 31}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 1, "start": 40, "end": 196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 3, "start": 508, "end": 1059, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 34, "start": 10443, "end": 10911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 35, "start": 10911, "end": 11032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 17, "years": {"2020": 17}, "tiers": {"machine": 17}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:fiqh/zakat-and-charity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 34, "start": 10443, "end": 10911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hOusirOkBVU|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hOusirOkBVU", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2014": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2014": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2014": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:hcscudhD8bU|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:hcscudhD8bU", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "topic:hadith/quran-only-movement", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ht0qJv5Om9o|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ht0qJv5Om9o", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2018": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iCr0sV2UrcU|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iCr0sV2UrcU", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2017": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2017": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iJ2ml87pTrs|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iJ2ml87pTrs", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iQVd5_ag6DE|topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iQVd5_ag6DE", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender/women-in-worship-and-mosques", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/caliphate", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": true, "count": 11, "years": {"2020": 11}, "tiers": {"machine": 11}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:iaBL5ViS3Rg", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 10, "start": 3320, "end": 3802, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 24, "start": 9928, "end": 10109, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 20, "start": 7808, "end": 8098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 25, "start": 10109, "end": 10229, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 26, "start": 10229, "end": 11043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 8, "start": 2842, "end": 2949, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 8, "start": 2842, "end": 2949, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 23, "start": 9393, "end": 9928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 25, "start": 10109, "end": 10229, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 15, "start": 5381, "end": 5461, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/al-andalus-and-the-maghrib", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 10, "start": 3320, "end": 3802, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 26, "start": 10229, "end": 11043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ijwBevcC6o8|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ijwBevcC6o8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 17, "start": 5548, "end": 6501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2019": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:j6pXWGpnWd0|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:j6pXWGpnWd0", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:arts/book-lounge", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:arts/book-lounge", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 2, "start": 531, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/free-will-and-destiny", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 2, "start": 531, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/problem-of-evil-and-suffering", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 24, "start": 8706, "end": 8821, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 26, "start": 9231, "end": 9541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 24, "start": 8706, "end": 8821, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 26, "start": 9231, "end": 9541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 20, "start": 7510, "end": 7616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 20, "start": 7510, "end": 7616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jTYEM-eEe78|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jTYEM-eEe78", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2018": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:fiqh/hajj-and-umrah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:jp8GjvVONMs|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:jp8GjvVONMs", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:k9V9aM16G1k|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:k9V9aM16G1k", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:k9V9aM16G1k|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:k9V9aM16G1k", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:kDSBNnTRJKo|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:kDSBNnTRJKo", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:kkjqsRxJ3KM", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2014": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 3, "start": 1202, "end": 1430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 36, "start": 11777, "end": 12163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 28, "start": 8062, "end": 8107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 17, "start": 5270, "end": 5346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 34, "start": 10791, "end": 11151, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 29, "start": 8107, "end": 8456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 33, "start": 10088, "end": 10791, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 34, "start": 10791, "end": 11151, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 8, "start": 2977, "end": 3198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 8, "start": 2977, "end": 3198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 13, "start": 4029, "end": 4212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 32, "start": 9932, "end": 10088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/entertainment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 10, "start": 3390, "end": 3467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 23, "start": 6878, "end": 6956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 33, "start": 10088, "end": 10791, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 16, "start": 4939, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 36, "start": 11777, "end": 12163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 28, "start": 8062, "end": 8107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 31, "start": 9238, "end": 9932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/current-events/india-and-hindutva", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 30, "start": 8456, "end": 9238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 31, "start": 9238, "end": 9932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 32, "start": 9932, "end": 10088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:wellbeing/gratitude-giving-and-contentment", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:l4n4wD2jjps|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:l4n4wD2jjps", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 13, "start": 4029, "end": 4212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:llllbKdGrA4|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:llllbKdGrA4|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 2, "start": 311, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:llllbKdGrA4|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:llllbKdGrA4|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:llllbKdGrA4|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:llllbKdGrA4", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 2, "start": 311, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 3, "start": 471, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 3, "start": 471, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mLNpcjXYpqM|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mLNpcjXYpqM", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:belief/tawhid-and-shirk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:fiqh/medical-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2023": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2023": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 9, "start": 2407, "end": 2562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mOfS_0uGn4E|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mOfS_0uGn4E", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 9, "start": 2407, "end": 2562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2020": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:mnpGDvjs2nk|topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:mnpGDvjs2nk", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/short-surahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nZdIoI1JWwM|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nZdIoI1JWwM", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nZdIoI1JWwM|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nZdIoI1JWwM", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nZdIoI1JWwM|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nZdIoI1JWwM", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:hadith/mutawatir-and-epistemology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:nndcs2uHoqE|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:nndcs2uHoqE", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:noE0Z72gUbs|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:noE0Z72gUbs|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:noE0Z72gUbs", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2023": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/resilience-and-hardship", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/self-esteem-ego-and-confidence", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oAG-F3hxCDY|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oAG-F3hxCDY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oXTsV9fn3zE|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oXTsV9fn3zE", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 16, "start": 5022, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 25, "start": 7289, "end": 7484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/language-and-semiotics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 5, "start": 1142, "end": 1525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 6, "start": 1525, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 7, "start": 1993, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 25, "start": 7289, "end": 7484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 9, "start": 2537, "end": 2615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 7, "start": 1993, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3736, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/jinn-possession", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 10, "start": 2615, "end": 3154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 21, "start": 6688, "end": 6801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2021": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 2, "start": 194, "end": 412, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 4, "start": 875, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 5, "start": 1142, "end": 1525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 19, "start": 6263, "end": 6531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 22, "start": 6801, "end": 6880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 24, "start": 7070, "end": 7289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 23, "start": 6880, "end": 7070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2021": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 13, "start": 3736, "end": 4204, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 19, "start": 6263, "end": 6531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 20, "start": 6531, "end": 6688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 21, "start": 6688, "end": 6801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 26, "start": 7484, "end": 7600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances/psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3736, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 11, "start": 3154, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:society/converts-and-newcomers", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 2, "start": 194, "end": 412, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:society/current-events/covid-19", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 26, "start": 7484, "end": 7600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 10, "start": 2615, "end": 3154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 11, "start": 3154, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 20, "start": 6531, "end": 6688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 13, "start": 3736, "end": 4204, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 16, "start": 5022, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 23, "start": 6880, "end": 7070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/depression-and-anxiety", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 18, "start": 5795, "end": 6263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 6, "start": 1525, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 9, "start": 2537, "end": 2615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 18, "start": 5795, "end": 6263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose/goals-and-habits", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 24, "start": 7070, "end": 7289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 4, "start": 875, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:oYiiPEhuiHA|topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:oYiiPEhuiHA", "target": "topic:wellbeing/religious-guilt-and-scrupulosity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2019": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife/karbala", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pkjtq8AXGRE|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pkjtq8AXGRE", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:psuMMzjvfRI|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:psuMMzjvfRI", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:psuMMzjvfRI|topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:psuMMzjvfRI", "target": "topic:relationships/friendship-and-social-life", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:pyI4TBAjCMI|topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:pyI4TBAjCMI", "target": "topic:belief/salvation-and-non-muslims", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:qdIQiwiz1mY|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:qdIQiwiz1mY", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:r196CQ7qkaY|topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:r196CQ7qkaY", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/congregation-and-jumuah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 18, "start": 4826, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 20, "start": 5065, "end": 5301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 377, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 3, "start": 377, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 6, "start": 1402, "end": 1873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 9, "start": 2378, "end": 2809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 6, "start": 1402, "end": 1873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 7, "start": 1873, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 9, "start": 2378, "end": 2809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 16, "start": 4379, "end": 4583, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2021": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 10, "start": 2809, "end": 3040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 11, "start": 3040, "end": 3279, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 15, "start": 4264, "end": 4379, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 16, "start": 4379, "end": 4583, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 17, "start": 4583, "end": 4826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 21, "start": 5301, "end": 5549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 20, "start": 5065, "end": 5301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 21, "start": 5301, "end": 5549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/apostasy-and-blasphemy", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 15, "start": 4264, "end": 4379, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 12, "start": 3279, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:hadith/collections-and-compilation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 12, "start": 3279, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 10, "start": 2809, "end": 3040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 11, "start": 3040, "end": 3279, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 17, "start": 4583, "end": 4826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 18, "start": 4826, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:history/subcontinent", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:history/subcontinent", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 377, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:rtwyWCa2-pQ", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 3, "start": 377, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/divorce", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/divorce", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 12, "years": {"2022": 12}, "tiers": {"machine": 12}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/marriage-contracts", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:history/strength-in-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:history/strength-in-stories", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2022": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s-Vm6mgbLl8", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2022": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s9JKA9ZjI28|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:s9JKA9ZjI28|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:s9JKA9ZjI28", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 9, "years": {"2019": 9}, "tiers": {"machine": 9}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sMOOcEVIGDE|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sMOOcEVIGDE", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sgwylUg7XU0|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sgwylUg7XU0", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sgwylUg7XU0|topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sgwylUg7XU0", "target": "topic:relationships/love-and-romance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:sgwylUg7XU0|topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:sgwylUg7XU0", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/choosing-a-spouse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:t9EI_hrzL84|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:t9EI_hrzL84", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:tZNGKXyIaxU|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:tZNGKXyIaxU", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ttQ_CXlVaso|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ttQ_CXlVaso", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 5, "years": {"2020": 5}, "tiers": {"machine": 5}, "evidence": [{"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uBbLk0EhDGk|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uBbLk0EhDGk", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:history/sirah/isra-and-miraj", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:society/current-events/palestine", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:society/current-events/palestine", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uMKu_OCFTes|topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uMKu_OCFTes", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media/social-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uVRr1jjbLEs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:uVRr1jjbLEs|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:uVRr1jjbLEs", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 13, "years": {"2017": 13}, "tiers": {"machine": 13}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 124, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2017": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ucdrbLyGY70|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ucdrbLyGY70", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2017": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:udJveM_S0sY|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:udJveM_S0sY", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:udJveM_S0sY|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:udJveM_S0sY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:udJveM_S0sY|topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:udJveM_S0sY", "target": "topic:history/sirah/wives-of-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:udmzRAYYgfI|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:udmzRAYYgfI", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:udmzRAYYgfI|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:udmzRAYYgfI", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "topic:fiqh/festivals-and-greetings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:ueCmAZD-LXw|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:ueCmAZD-LXw", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2015": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:umPepYIsc_g|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:umPepYIsc_g|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:umPepYIsc_g", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:hadith/bukhari", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:hadith/bukhari", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v-1HD1uAMBM|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v-1HD1uAMBM", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:v8pLoq2vpUY|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:v8pLoq2vpUY", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vF5yuEYz9Vo", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2020": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 4, "start": 557, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 4, "start": 557, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vGoAxXEHpHk|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vGoAxXEHpHk", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2022": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 2, "start": 496, "end": 610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 3, "start": 610, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 4, "start": 836, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science/evolution", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:voxmwEQ6rz4|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:voxmwEQ6rz4", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/adam-and-creation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2022": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:vrR5CWw8asg|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:vrR5CWw8asg", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/ahmadiyya-and-false-messiahs", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/atheism-and-the-existence-of-god", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 28, "start": 10262, "end": 10339, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 29, "start": 10339, "end": 10439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 28, "start": 10262, "end": 10339, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:dialogue/debate-challenges-and-reviews", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 32, "start": 11487, "end": 11766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 26, "start": 10002, "end": 10196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/beard-and-hair", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/intoxicants-and-substances", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:fiqh/polygamy-and-mutah", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:history/early-succession-and-civil-strife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:history/pre-islamic-arabia", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:quran/memorisation-and-recitation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 27, "start": 10196, "end": 10262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 32, "start": 11487, "end": 11766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 24, "start": 9359, "end": 9856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:relationships/parents-and-children/raising-children", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 3, "start": 731, "end": 1562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:society/blasphemy-and-free-speech", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:society/dawah-and-debate-culture", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 25, "start": 9856, "end": 10002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 25, "start": 9856, "end": 10002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/islamic-psychology", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 29, "start": 10339, "end": 10439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/personal-stories", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 5, "start": 2027, "end": 2578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 26, "start": 10002, "end": 10196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/tawakkul-and-trust", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 5, "start": 2027, "end": 2578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:w6TqWuUumCg|topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:w6TqWuUumCg", "target": "topic:wellbeing/trauma-and-healing", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 3, "start": 731, "end": 1562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife/paradise-and-hell", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 31, "start": 7144, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 32, "start": 7453, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:belief/eschatology", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 17, "start": 3744, "end": 3936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:belief/soul-nafs-and-consciousness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 21, "start": 4593, "end": 4866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 36, "start": 8532, "end": 8724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 37, "start": 8724, "end": 8840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 3, "start": 230, "end": 578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 10, "start": 2173, "end": 2327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 18, "start": 3936, "end": 4130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:dialogue/views-on-contemporary-scholars", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 3, "start": 230, "end": 578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 28, "start": 6413, "end": 6643, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 33, "start": 7571, "end": 7953, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 34, "start": 7953, "end": 8341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance/riba-and-mortgages", "directed": true, "count": 10, "years": {"2020": 10}, "tiers": {"machine": 10}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 23, "start": 5060, "end": 5171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 24, "start": 5171, "end": 5443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 25, "start": 5443, "end": 5753, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 26, "start": 5753, "end": 6139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 27, "start": 6139, "end": 6413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 28, "start": 6413, "end": 6643, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 29, "start": 6643, "end": 6910, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 30, "start": 6910, "end": 7144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 33, "start": 7571, "end": 7953, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 35, "start": 8341, "end": 8532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 34, "start": 7953, "end": 8341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 20, "start": 4364, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 5, "start": 872, "end": 1296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 5, "start": 872, "end": 1296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 14, "start": 3017, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 17, "start": 3744, "end": 3936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 22, "start": 4866, "end": 5060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 7, "start": 1375, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 9, "start": 1993, "end": 2173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 10, "start": 2173, "end": 2327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 11, "start": 2327, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 12, "start": 2479, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 16, "start": 3511, "end": 3744, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/current-events/britain", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/current-events/britain", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 24, "start": 5171, "end": 5443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/current-events/middle-east-and-world", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 37, "start": 8724, "end": 8840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 36, "start": 8532, "end": 8724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/extremism-crime-and-justice", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 11, "start": 2327, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 14, "start": 3017, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 15, "start": 3167, "end": 3511, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 16, "start": 3511, "end": 3744, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 18, "start": 3936, "end": 4130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 19, "start": 4130, "end": 4364, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 20, "start": 4364, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 21, "start": 4593, "end": 4866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 22, "start": 4866, "end": 5060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/race-and-identity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/race-and-identity", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 9, "start": 1993, "end": 2173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 12, "start": 2479, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:society/technology-and-media", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:society/technology-and-media", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 13, "start": 2788, "end": 3017, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 19, "start": 4130, "end": 4364, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wCe73zqCi_I|topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wCe73zqCi_I", "target": "topic:wellbeing/motivation-and-purpose", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 31, "start": 7144, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "topic:dialogue/atheists-and-polemicists", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "topic:society/current-events/pakistan", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:wkhoro-Qb20|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:wkhoro-Qb20", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 9, "start": 2384, "end": 2784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 10, "start": 2784, "end": 3031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 11, "start": 3031, "end": 3153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 15, "start": 4202, "end": 4844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 21, "start": 5811, "end": 5918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 15, "start": 4202, "end": 4844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 16, "start": 4844, "end": 5044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 17, "start": 5044, "end": 5325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 21, "start": 5811, "end": 5918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 22, "start": 5918, "end": 6008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 12, "start": 3153, "end": 3450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 9, "start": 2384, "end": 2784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 16, "start": 4844, "end": 5044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 17, "start": 5044, "end": 5325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 2, "start": 181, "end": 408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:dialogue/sunni-shia-dialogue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 13, "start": 3450, "end": 3788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:hadith/individual-hadith-explained", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 14, "start": 3788, "end": 4202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:history/sirah", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:history/sirah", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 13, "start": 3450, "end": 3788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 6, "start": 1356, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 11, "start": 3031, "end": 3153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2020": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 4, "start": 779, "end": 1198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 6, "start": 1356, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 7, "start": 1678, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 12, "start": 3153, "end": 3450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 20, "start": 5702, "end": 5811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:quran/preservation-and-qiraat", "directed": true, "count": 6, "years": {"2020": 6}, "tiers": {"machine": 6}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 4, "start": 779, "end": 1198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 7, "start": 1678, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 10, "start": 2784, "end": 3031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 14, "start": 3788, "end": 4202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 20, "start": 5702, "end": 5811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir/contested-verses", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 22, "start": 5918, "end": 6008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:xznXIYp0B5s|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:xznXIYp0B5s", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 2, "start": 181, "end": 408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "topic:fiqh/funerals-and-burial", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "topic:wellbeing/death-and-mortality", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y-JDMojFGnU|topic:wellbeing/grief", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y-JDMojFGnU", "target": "topic:wellbeing/grief", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "topic:arts/arabic-poetry-and-letters", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 2, "start": 380, "end": 534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:y9P342Tx6T0|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:y9P342Tx6T0", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 2, "start": 380, "end": 534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2018": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|topic:hadith/authentication", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "topic:history/umayyads-and-abbasids", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yFeJ-QkS-kM", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2018": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yJGrP8cVk-M|topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "target": "topic:fiqh/gender-interaction", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yJGrP8cVk-M|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yJGrP8cVk-M", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2020": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 8, "years": {"2020": 8}, "tiers": {"machine": 8}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yRuC09ajKEQ|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yRuC09ajKEQ", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yZrVPdcKjxQ", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:belief/dreams-and-visions", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:belief/sufism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:belief/sufism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings/magic-evil-eye-and-superstition", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2019": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2019": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:yy74XfRo_E4|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:yy74XfRo_E4", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z06drwxqxGE|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z06drwxqxGE", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z06drwxqxGE|topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z06drwxqxGE", "target": "topic:fiqh/dress-and-appearance/jewellery-gold-and-silk", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z06drwxqxGE|topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z06drwxqxGE", "target": "topic:relationships/masculinity-and-gender-roles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|topic:fiqh/prayer", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z6Ay73O7Dug|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z6Ay73O7Dug", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zN1-WlBys2I|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zN1-WlBys2I", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2018": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas/narrative-and-story", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:belief/unseen-beings", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:belief/unseen-beings", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:quran/arabic-language", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:quran/arabic-language", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2019": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zOTvTgdUMV8|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zOTvTgdUMV8", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2019": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:arts/science-and-the-universe", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 16, "start": 5656, "end": 5740, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:arts/urdu-poetry", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 3, "start": 757, "end": 1176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/afterlife", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/afterlife", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 16, "start": 5656, "end": 5740, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/creed-and-kalam-schools", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/dajjal-mahdi-and-signs", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/eschatology/second-coming-of-jesus", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/god-and-attributes", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir/salafism-and-wahhabism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 30, "start": 11208, "end": 11456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:belief/spiritual-experience-and-psychedelics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:dialogue/christians-and-other-faiths", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2021": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 30, "start": 11208, "end": 11456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 38, "start": 13506, "end": 13970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics/yasir-qadhi", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 4, "years": {"2021": 4}, "tiers": {"machine": 4}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/entertainment/music", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/fasting", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/food", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/food", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/hijab-and-niqab", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/madhhabs-and-following/hanafi-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/prayer/conditions-and-validity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance/hudud-and-punishments", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/purification", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/purification", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:fiqh/speech-and-everyday-conduct", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/text-criticism-and-reason", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:hadith/false-and-fabricated/about-women", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:history/ancient-near-east-and-scripture", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 2, "start": 494, "end": 757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:history/modern-reformers-and-movements", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:quran/hermeneutics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:quran/hermeneutics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/jesus", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets/moses", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:relationships/marriage", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:relationships/marriage/intimacy", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:relationships/sexuality-and-orientation", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:society/cults-and-religious-abuse", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2021": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:society/current-events", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:society/current-events", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2021": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 14, "start": 5335, "end": 5472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:society/education-and-madrasas/how-to-study-islam", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:wellbeing/anger-and-forgiveness", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 38, "start": 13506, "end": 13970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zZ85AUzeK5w|topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zZ85AUzeK5w", "target": "topic:wellbeing/character-and-virtue", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2021": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:belief/prophethood-and-miracles", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:belief/sectarianism-and-takfir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/responses-to-critics", "directed": true, "count": 3, "years": {"2020": 3}, "tiers": {"machine": 3}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:dialogue/the-mufti-and-the-channel", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:history/sirah/age-of-aisha", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:history/sirah/defending-the-prophet", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:z__38zt8FlQ|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:z__38zt8FlQ", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2020": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:arts/philosophy-and-ideas", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:belief/reason-and-revelation", "directed": true, "count": 2, "years": {"2016": 2}, "tiers": {"machine": 2}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:dialogue/guest-conversations", "directed": true, "count": 7, "years": {"2016": 7}, "tiers": {"machine": 7}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:fiqh/finance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:fiqh/finance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:fiqh/legal-theory", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:fiqh/public-law-and-governance", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:history/companions", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:history/companions", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:history/human-origins", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:history/human-origins", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:history/orthodoxy-and-how-islam-spread", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:quran/quran-and-science", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:quran/quran-and-science", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:quran/stories-of-the-prophets", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:quran/tafsir", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:quran/tafsir", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:society/islam-and-modernity", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zbyA7rqfyRU|topic:society/women-and-gender", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zbyA7rqfyRU", "target": "topic:society/women-and-gender", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2016": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:fiqh/maliki-school/muwatta-and-mudawwana", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:hadith/authentication/narrator-criticism", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:hadith/hadith-in-legal-reasoning", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:hadith/sunnah-versus-hadith", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zkklciv1TK8|topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zkklciv1TK8", "target": "topic:history/scholars-and-imams/imam-malik", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2023": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "topic:fiqh/fasting/what-breaks-the-fast", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}, {"id": "discusses|recording:zlXm19MtE2A|topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "kind": "discusses", "source": "recording:zlXm19MtE2A", "target": "topic:fiqh/sexual-ethics", "directed": true, "count": 1, "years": {"2017": 1}, "tiers": {"machine": 1}, "evidence": [{"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517"}]}], "segments": [{"video": "--OJasWltLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150505", "title": "Is a short back and sides or faded haircut haram?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Opening: sound check, greetings and quick replies to the chat"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 2, "start": 296, "end": 450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Will you give talks in Mirpuri?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 3, "start": 450, "end": 666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Tonight's clips under the microscope, and a project coming soon"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 4, "start": 666, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "An Urdu poem: if anyone asks who I am, say nobody special"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is celebrating Valentine's Day haram?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 6, "start": 1298, "end": 1414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Where are most of the Mufti's viewers from?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 7, "start": 1414, "end": 1480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Islam in Malaysia and Indonesia?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 8, "start": 1480, "end": 1672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Why didn't the Prophet explain every verse of the Quran himself?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 9, "start": 1672, "end": 2010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does the Quran really say Jesus had no father?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 10, "start": 2010, "end": 2230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "What does the Mufti think of liberal Islam?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 11, "start": 2230, "end": 2394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Chat remarks: an unclear music question and a jibe about his earring"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 12, "start": 2394, "end": 2540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did the companions actually see the angel Jibril?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 13, "start": 2540, "end": 2698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is the devil a real creature or a symbol of bad impulses?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 14, "start": 2698, "end": 3106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Why isn't the Mufti a Mu'tazili?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 15, "start": 3106, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Were the Mu'tazila really defined by their use of reason?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 16, "start": 3528, "end": 3597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Fethullah Gulen?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 17, "start": 3597, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Do Ash'aris believe the Quran is created?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 18, "start": 3751, "end": 4243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did Imam Ahmad really refuse to say the Quran is created?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 19, "start": 4243, "end": 4319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does the Quran say Jesus was raised up alive?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 20, "start": 4319, "end": 4472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did the Prophet order a scribe killed for leaving Islam?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 21, "start": 4472, "end": 4500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does the story of Dhul Qarnayn mean the earth is flat?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 22, "start": 4500, "end": 4577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does Quran 33:40 mean the Prophet's descendants cannot rule?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 23, "start": 4577, "end": 4645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is following the Sunnah like believing in the Trinity?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 24, "start": 4645, "end": 4892, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Why does Surah al-Kafirun say 'ma' (what) instead of 'man' (who) for God?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 25, "start": 4892, "end": 4998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Why does the Quran focus so much on the Israelites?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 26, "start": 4998, "end": 5103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Who is the Mufti's favourite Western philosopher?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 27, "start": 5103, "end": 5180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "A prospective MindTrap guest who has gone quiet"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 28, "start": 5180, "end": 5570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did the Prophet tell people to drink camel urine as medicine?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 29, "start": 5570, "end": 5917, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Why is quoting science to defend hadith like camel urine risky?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 30, "start": 5917, "end": 6143, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Was Islam spread by the sword?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 31, "start": 6143, "end": 6411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Can atheism explain consciousness?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 32, "start": 6411, "end": 6523, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did all prophets after Abraham come from his family?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 33, "start": 6523, "end": 6600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is Sidrat al-Muntaha a real tree?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 34, "start": 6600, "end": 6709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "How did the Maliki school spread to North Africa and Spain?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 35, "start": 6709, "end": 6785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is playing chess haram?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 36, "start": 6785, "end": 7250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "A mufti's clip on ear piercing: 'decency', 'manipulation' and muthla"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 37, "start": 7250, "end": 7580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Can a Muslim have a close non-Muslim friend?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 38, "start": 7580, "end": 8217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did the Prophet say he would kill the first Khariji's descendants?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 39, "start": 8217, "end": 8401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "An open challenge: defend Salafi aqidah from the Quran alone"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 40, "start": 8401, "end": 8588, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Chat banter: jinn-obsessed people, a 'space gun' and Harun Yahya's sentence"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 41, "start": 8588, "end": 8665, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "What does the Mufti think of the Naqshbandi Sufi order?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 42, "start": 8665, "end": 8810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Shaykh Dedew, and did Imam Ahmad dislike Abu Hanifa?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 43, "start": 8810, "end": 8926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does Islam teach us to show affection?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 44, "start": 8926, "end": 9031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "A missed Jeffrey Lang question, Melchert's book, and a joke about 'protection'"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 45, "start": 9031, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Was Adam's garden on earth or in heaven?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 46, "start": 9070, "end": 9452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Who are the Ibadis and what does the Mufti think of them?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 47, "start": 9452, "end": 9490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Can I pray in my car if I don't feel safe praying outside?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 48, "start": 9490, "end": 9599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Are children held accountable in Islam for bullying or hurting others?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 49, "start": 9599, "end": 9717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does an Islamic judge always give the maximum punishment for theft?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 50, "start": 9717, "end": 10462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Did Abu Hanifa allow nabidh only as medicine?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 51, "start": 10462, "end": 10788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is cannabis an intoxicant like alcohol in Islam?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 52, "start": 10788, "end": 11148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "The preacher on DMT: 'no proof of the unseen', and tahajjud instead"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 53, "start": 11148, "end": 11303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is smoking marijuana haram?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 54, "start": 11303, "end": 11459, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Are DMT and magic mushrooms haram?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 55, "start": 11459, "end": 11674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Is drinking poison haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 56, "start": 11674, "end": 11860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Does the Quran use metaphors, like calling people angels?"}, {"video": "--PntsaR8ck", "n": 57, "start": 11860, "end": 11906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210216", "title": "Sign-off: subscribe, the Discord coming soon, take the chance"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Was pre-Islamic Makkah really a significant city?"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "What is Dan Gibson's Petra theory and are his measurements trustworthy?"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Who was Qusayy ibn Kilab and where was he raised?"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Why do early Islamic books call the Ka'bah 'the Shami Ka'bah'?"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 5, "start": 866, "end": 1101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Did ancient civilisations have knowledge that was later lost?"}, {"video": "-JYtKJ9z1cw", "n": 6, "start": 1101, "end": 1312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Why did the earliest mosques face Petra instead of Makkah?"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118", "title": "How do I start memorising the Quran?"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118", "title": "What is the dua for memorising the Quran and how do I perform it?"}, {"video": "-lbZ11113SU", "n": 3, "start": 480, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140118", "title": "What practical techniques help me memorise the Quran?"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708", "title": "Why did God stop Abraha's army but let the Qaramita steal the Black Stone?"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 2, "start": 938, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708", "title": "Is the story of Hajar running seven times between Safa and Marwa true?"}, {"video": "-oPJEZ12NQ8", "n": 3, "start": 1486, "end": 1602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190708", "title": "Did the Prophet restore the original rituals of Ibrahim at the Kaaba?"}, {"video": "0BOmiPpDvgo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 536, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517", "title": "Can I brush my teeth with toothpaste or use mouthwash while fasting?"}, {"video": "0Ln_viR6LnI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191217", "title": "Is growing a beard compulsory in Islam?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 78, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Opening: a response to a question on the age of Aisha"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 2, "start": 78, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth's credentials and course of study"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "The question, Mufti Abu Layth's thesis and premise one: dating in an oral culture"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 4, "start": 1018, "end": 1800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Premise two: hadith absolutism versus hadith relativism"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 5, "start": 1800, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Unacceptable reports in the Sahihayn and judging a hadith by its content"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 6, "start": 2038, "end": 2826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "The reality: the year of sorrow and the proposal to Aisha"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 7, "start": 2826, "end": 3457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "The reports: Bukhari's six and nine against three other Bukhari reports"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 8, "start": 3457, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "The reports: Hisham's Iraqi transmission, Madinan silence and Asma's age"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 9, "start": 3769, "end": 4478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "The ramifications: jurists on marrying a minor, and the conclusion"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 10, "start": 4478, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Which books argue that Aisha was in her late teens when she married the Prophet?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 11, "start": 4636, "end": 5261, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Why is Aisha's age only being questioned now, and is it just to appease the West?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 12, "start": 5261, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Why is the report that Aisha was six and nine so much better known than the others?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 13, "start": 5734, "end": 5893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "If ethics change over time, how can today's ethics judge the Prophet's marriage?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 14, "start": 5893, "end": 6128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Doesn't the hadith about Aisha playing with dolls show she was a child?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 15, "start": 6128, "end": 6598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Can an ordinary Muslim reject a hadith that seems irrational?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 16, "start": 6598, "end": 6911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Is judging hadith by their content a modern invention of jurists rather than hadith scholars?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 17, "start": 6911, "end": 7223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "If Aisha's age is a problem, aren't polygamy and the Prophet's wars problems too?"}, {"video": "0oVIsExS4cA", "n": 18, "start": 7223, "end": 7770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170111", "title": "Why did jurists like Imam Malik let a father marry off his young daughter without her consent?"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914", "title": "How do I answer Christians who say the Quran could be corrupted like the Bible?"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 2, "start": 497, "end": 681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914", "title": "Is the Bible corrupted?"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 3, "start": 681, "end": 796, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914", "title": "If God knew earlier scriptures would change, why not send the Quran first?"}, {"video": "143df7icoYU", "n": 4, "start": 796, "end": 932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190914", "title": "Is today's Bible the same one Christians and Jews read in the Prophet's time?"}, {"video": "1ybpO86BP8Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220219", "title": "What do you think of the rational readings of the Quran on the Marvelous Quran channel?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 1, "start": 25, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Opening: sound check, how he is feeling, and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "The storming of the US Capitol and Trump's 'go home, we love you' video"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 3, "start": 809, "end": 1297, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Not just Trump: why he sees the Capitol riot as reflective of the United States"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 4, "start": 1297, "end": 1546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Is America really as wild as you say?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 5, "start": 1546, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Chat round: Trump's Twitter ban, Surah Ya Sin in the morning, and banter"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 6, "start": 1807, "end": 1960, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What do you think of a particular Salafi preacher?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 7, "start": 1960, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Has the Salafi movement done more good or harm?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 8, "start": 2108, "end": 2358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Has Islam become more polarised between puritans and liberals?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 9, "start": 2358, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Do I have to be in a state of purity to say verses of the Quran?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 10, "start": 2672, "end": 2968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Are king prawns halal?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 11, "start": 2968, "end": 3044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Who is Surah al-Munafiqun about?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 12, "start": 3044, "end": 3090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What do you think of Shaykh al-Sha'rawi?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 13, "start": 3090, "end": 3576, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What do you think of Harun Yahya and his books?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 14, "start": 3576, "end": 3786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Super chats read out: bitcoin, an escort question, prophethood and the story of Lut"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 15, "start": 3786, "end": 4012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Poetry: a ghazal on love, beauty and patience"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 16, "start": 4012, "end": 4381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why can't there be any prophets after Muhammad?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 17, "start": 4381, "end": 4499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Will you critique Sahih Muslim like you did al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 18, "start": 4499, "end": 4617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why would God stop sending revelation?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 19, "start": 4617, "end": 4842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why wasn't the Quran compiled as a book in the Prophet's time?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 20, "start": 4842, "end": 5072, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Does the Quran clearly forbid homosexuality?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 21, "start": 5072, "end": 5293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Should I study at Dar al-Mustafa in Yemen or at al-Azhar?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 22, "start": 5293, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Staying positive: the 'Super Mario effect' and Pogba's advice"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 23, "start": 5441, "end": 5684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Announcement: a Mind Trap discussion with Dr Abdullah Abdul Majid on BukhariGate"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 24, "start": 5684, "end": 5869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Can a woman lead the prayer or give the khutbah?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 25, "start": 5869, "end": 6010, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Am I doing wrong if I follow a minority opinion?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 26, "start": 6010, "end": 6087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Can I work as a recruiter if some of the jobs are in banking?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 27, "start": 6087, "end": 6392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why do you call yourself a Maliki?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 28, "start": 6392, "end": 6622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "If you deny the evil eye, why do you cite scholars who believed in it?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 29, "start": 6622, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Could Socrates or the Buddha have been prophets?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 30, "start": 6698, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why do clever preachers stay stuck in dogmatism?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 31, "start": 7113, "end": 7868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Does Sahih al-Bukhari really say God dangled in front of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 32, "start": 7868, "end": 8353, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Will you invite Javed Ahmad Ghamidi onto Mind Trap?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 33, "start": 8353, "end": 8545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What do you think of a particular online activist?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 34, "start": 8545, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Mind Trap guest suggestions and the 'blacklisting' mentality"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 35, "start": 8974, "end": 9510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What was the hardest time of your life?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 36, "start": 9510, "end": 10131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Two to three months in prison: learning, poetry and the humanity of inmates"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 37, "start": 10131, "end": 10282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Is process theology compatible with the Quran?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 38, "start": 10282, "end": 10359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "What does Islamic law say about the harms of social media?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 39, "start": 10359, "end": 10477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Is it unfair that some are born Muslim, and is God's throne literal?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 40, "start": 10477, "end": 10594, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Is tahajjud the best way to get close to God?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 41, "start": 10594, "end": 10920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Is the hadith 'if there were a prophet after me it would be Umar' authentic?"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 42, "start": 10920, "end": 11481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "A preacher's 'discoveries': Gog and Magog in Kyrgyzstan and Noah's ark at al-Judi"}, {"video": "1zgHntbMPis", "n": 43, "start": 11481, "end": 11567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Sign-off: subscribe, Patreon sessions, and Instagram for contact"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223", "title": "Did Jesus really speak as a baby in the cradle?"}, {"video": "2AxJjFrnD20", "n": 2, "start": 837, "end": 1054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190223", "title": "What does it mean that Jesus spoke to people in the cradle and in old age?"}, {"video": "2EnVV2NUehw", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201216", "title": "Is football really more haram than alcohol and gambling?"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525", "title": "Does a nicotine patch or vaping break my fast?"}, {"video": "2HeZQyp_S4M", "n": 2, "start": 269, "end": 516, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190525", "title": "Does smoking break my fast?"}, {"video": "2cei2vnTjes", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191109", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Shaykh Imran Hosein?"}, {"video": "2kQbnCU09YM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 542, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220319", "title": "Is mut'ah (temporary marriage) haram for Sunni Muslims?"}, {"video": "31RnFwtYbwU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802", "title": "Rumours of a Sunni-Shia debate, and building bridges with the Shia"}, {"video": "3Ux_bLoLSf8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190719", "title": "Was the first qibla really Petra, as Dan Gibson claims?"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305", "title": "What counts as khamr, and is a drink with very little alcohol haram?"}, {"video": "3rPUgpmWEp0", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210305", "title": "Why did Imam Malik say nothing between spouses is haram and only pork is forbidden to eat?"}, {"video": "3tQUslWseTo", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517", "title": "Should Muslims in the UK follow Saudi Arabia for moon sighting?"}, {"video": "47ghxXHtlN8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308", "title": "Why do you dress in a t-shirt and joke around while teaching Islam?"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509", "title": "Why did scholars say a slave woman's awrah is the same as a man's?"}, {"video": "49_S1uD7UTk", "n": 2, "start": 424, "end": 722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210509", "title": "Did scholars let slave women uncover more than free women?"}, {"video": "4PESNMaHO20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181008", "title": "Do Muslims really get 72 virgins in Paradise?"}, {"video": "4URwiwu3X7o", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 83, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201021", "title": "Why criticise Sahih al-Bukhari but not Imam Malik's Muwatta?"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903", "title": "Reply to Abdullah al-Andalusi: the 'white saviour' and the caliphate"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903", "title": "Is the world today dar al-harb, the land of war?"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 3, "start": 724, "end": 882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903", "title": "Are the hadith about the khilafah authentic?"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 4, "start": 882, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903", "title": "Did al-Ghazali say Muslims must establish a caliphate?"}, {"video": "4WUwTJQAmx0", "n": 5, "start": 1111, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180903", "title": "Who should I listen to about political ideas in Islam?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "A visit to the Al-Mahdi Institute symposium on Fadak"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 2, "start": 273, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "What was Fadak and why did it matter?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 999, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Why did Abu Bakr refuse to give Fadak to Fatima?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 4, "start": 999, "end": 1192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Who was right about Fadak, Fatima or Abu Bakr?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 5, "start": 1192, "end": 1505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Why didn't Ali take back Fadak when he became caliph?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 6, "start": 1505, "end": 1699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Why might Abu Bakr have refused Fatima's claim so quickly?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 7, "start": 1699, "end": 1852, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Was Abu Bakr wrong to refuse Fatima Fadak?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 8, "start": 1852, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Is it halal to buy bad loans and foreclose on people's homes?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Do Muslims believe in reincarnation?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 10, "start": 2007, "end": 2086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "Should election campaigns only be publicly funded?"}, {"video": "51Qevhjqnt4", "n": 11, "start": 2086, "end": 2178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200228", "title": "What did Mufti Abu Layth think of Mu'awiya?"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "Is slavery haram in Islam, and did Muslim scholars ban it before the UN?"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "How could men in early Islam have sex with their female slaves?"}, {"video": "5is8qPu5lLU", "n": 3, "start": 708, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "Why did Islam not abolish slavery outright?"}, {"video": "5phyGJpJMMw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 657, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190524", "title": "If I drank alcohol, are my prayers and fasts rejected for 40 days?"}, {"video": "626JfCE_j_8", "n": 1, "start": 14, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211129", "title": "Is it wrong to joke about people who are seriously ill with covid?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "What happened with Nouman Ali Khan and Mahira Khan online?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Was it wrong to publish the allegations against Nouman Ali Khan?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "What arguments were used to justify exposing Nouman Ali Khan?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 4, "start": 630, "end": 784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "If a religious figure does something wrong, should people expose him online?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 5, "start": 784, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Who has the right to tell other Muslims off for doing something haram?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 6, "start": 941, "end": 1177, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Is it Islamic to name and shame someone for a sin?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 7, "start": 1177, "end": 1413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Should religious leaders be held to a higher standard than everyone else?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 8, "start": 1413, "end": 1570, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Is a relationship between a leader and a follower automatically abuse?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 9, "start": 1570, "end": 1807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Is it wrong to be attracted to someone because of their status or position?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 10, "start": 1807, "end": 1963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Did great scholars like Ibn Hajar have private lives that would be condemned today?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 11, "start": 1963, "end": 2197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Why does it matter that the word 'abuse' was used about Nouman Ali Khan?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 12, "start": 2197, "end": 2431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Do Muslims online have the right to demand evidence about a scholar's private life?"}, {"video": "6_dmOJl-_bI", "n": 13, "start": 2431, "end": 2807, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170929", "title": "Is cyberbullying and attacking someone's honour haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Why do popular preachers promote belief in jinn possession?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "The clip: Omar Suleiman on jinn possession, the riba verse and disobedience"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 3, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Can there be a balanced view on whether jinn possess people?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "What would jinn gain by possessing people, and what follows if they could?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 5, "start": 1025, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Does the riba verse prove that jinn can possess people?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 6, "start": 1258, "end": 1574, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "If a jinn could possess me, how could I be blamed for anything?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 7, "start": 1574, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "What did classical scholars say about whether jinn can harm or possess people?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 8, "start": 2040, "end": 2592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Do any authentic hadith prove jinn possession?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 9, "start": 2592, "end": 2989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Is the jinn exorcism and ruqya industry a fraud?"}, {"video": "6aPj1fuMN24", "n": 10, "start": 2989, "end": 3256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201121", "title": "Is Omar Suleiman trained as a scholar, and will anyone debate Mufti Abu Layth on jinn possession?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Introduction: Yasir Qadhi's khutbah on orthodoxy and why he is replying"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "What are the three points of Yasir Qadhi's khutbah on orthodoxy, and is hadith certain knowledge?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 3, "start": 626, "end": 862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Is Yasir Qadhi's case for reading the Quran literally consistent?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 4, "start": 862, "end": 1491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "What is Yasir Qadhi's background, and where does the Salafi movement come from?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 5, "start": 1491, "end": 1730, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "What did Yasir Qadhi write in the leaked emails about the Quran's preservation and the theological schools?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 6, "start": 1730, "end": 1887, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Are the Salafis themselves orthodox by their own standard?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 7, "start": 1887, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Does the Quran say Ibrahim was thrown into the fire, or that the table was sent down to Jesus's disciples?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 8, "start": 2591, "end": 2987, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Why does the Quran call Jesus the Word of God and speak of the Holy Spirit?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 9, "start": 2987, "end": 3298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Does the Quran say Jesus was born of a virgin?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 10, "start": 3298, "end": 3769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Which verses are used to argue that Jesus had a father, and does the Quran rule it out?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 11, "start": 3769, "end": 4398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Is evolution compatible with the Quran?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 12, "start": 4398, "end": 4793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Is hadith the same as the sunnah, and is hadith certain knowledge?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 13, "start": 4793, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Is a new interpretation of the Quran the same as claiming to be a new prophet?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 14, "start": 5022, "end": 5181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "When is a hadith set aside, and is rejecting hadith acceptable?"}, {"video": "7CYLT19GX5k", "n": 15, "start": 5181, "end": 5210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181020", "title": "Sign-off"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 81, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "Introduction: a map of Qadian and another Qadiani video"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 2, "start": 81, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "Does Abul Kalam Azad praising Mirza Ghulam Ahmad prove anything?"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 3, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "The caller from Canada: trolling, the word Qadiani, and pictures of Mirza"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "What was the purpose of God sending Mirza Ghulam Ahmad as a prophet?"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 5, "start": 954, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "What was Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's prophecy about Muhammadi Begum and did it come true?"}, {"video": "7EER9UKa1eA", "n": 6, "start": 1270, "end": 1448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200331", "title": "Mirza's death from cholera, closing jokes and sign-off"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth call the Sunni Defence channel blasphemous?"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 2, "start": 230, "end": 545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803", "title": "Is there an authentic hadith that a wife may never refuse her husband sex?"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 3, "start": 545, "end": 935, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803", "title": "Can Sahih al-Bukhari be proven to go back to Imam al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "7IMg-l3vbcY", "n": 4, "start": 935, "end": 1141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180803", "title": "How should Muslims decide which hadith to accept and which to reject?"}, {"video": "7NAjZrtcNZ0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 250, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191011", "title": "Is a prayer mark on the forehead a sign of piety in Islam?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "Are psychedelics haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 446, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "How does Mufti Abu Layth explain what psychedelics do to consciousness?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 3, "start": 446, "end": 701, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "Did the Sufi saints have psychedelic experiences without knowing it?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 4, "start": 701, "end": 1104, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "Did Rumi use harmala seed and a DMT-containing reed flute?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 5, "start": 1104, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "What were soma and haoma in the Hindu and Persian traditions?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 6, "start": 1327, "end": 1788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "What is the hadith of the night of the jinn, and was it a psychoactive experience?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 7, "start": 1788, "end": 2161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "Does the verse of light describe an expanded state of consciousness?"}, {"video": "7SkyPhQZdY8", "n": 8, "start": 2161, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201017", "title": "Does the Quran or Sunnah say anything against psychedelics?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 1, "start": 11, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "How did Mufti Abu Layth become a mufti?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 2, "start": 387, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "Why did Mufti Abu Layth choose the Maliki madhhab?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 3, "start": 620, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "What is Mufti Abu Layth's favourite Islamic science?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 4, "start": 773, "end": 1112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "Why is al-Andalus so important to Muslims?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 5, "start": 1112, "end": 1148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "Is difference of opinion in Islam a mercy?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 6, "start": 1148, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth not dress like a traditional mufti?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 7, "start": 1333, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "Does Islam require a particular dress or beard style for scholars?"}, {"video": "7UXKLQH8-ig", "n": 8, "start": 1493, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140702", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth hope to achieve?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 473, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "What are the jinn and what can Shaytan actually do to people?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 2, "start": 473, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Does the Quran say that Shaytan or the jinn can possess or control a person?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 3, "start": 786, "end": 1180, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Is there any sound hadith that a jinn possessed someone?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 4, "start": 1180, "end": 1386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "If doctors cannot explain an illness, could it be a jinn?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 5, "start": 1386, "end": 1859, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Which classical scholars denied that jinn can possess people?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 6, "start": 1859, "end": 2095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Did Ibn Taymiyya believe in jinn possession, and does his view have proof?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 7, "start": 2095, "end": 2331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Why does the guest warn women never to go to exorcists?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 8, "start": 2331, "end": 2649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Did the Prophet use ruqya or doctors when he was ill?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 9, "start": 2649, "end": 2963, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Why do jinn seem to afflict only people who believe in them?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 10, "start": 2963, "end": 3201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "What do people mean when they say someone is possessed by a jinn?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 11, "start": 3201, "end": 3515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Why did Muslim scholars of the past accept the idea of jinn possession?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 12, "start": 3515, "end": 3751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Does the Quran's verse about the touch of Shaytan prove that jinn possess people?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 13, "start": 3751, "end": 4142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Are there authentic hadith of the Prophet casting a jinn out of someone?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 14, "start": 4142, "end": 4534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Does the hadith that Shaytan flows in a person's blood prove possession?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 15, "start": 4534, "end": 4768, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "People I know have seen jinn possession; does that not prove it?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 16, "start": 4768, "end": 5086, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "How do we know mental illnesses are not really jinn possessions?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 17, "start": 5086, "end": 5245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "What harm does belief in jinn possession do?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 18, "start": 5245, "end": 5480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Could seeing figures or faces that are not there be a brain condition rather than a jinn?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 19, "start": 5480, "end": 5716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "If someone got better after ruqya or an exorcism, does that prove it worked?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 20, "start": 5716, "end": 5872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "If jinn do not possess people, what is ruqya for?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 21, "start": 5872, "end": 6348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Could strange symptoms blamed on jinn have medical explanations?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 22, "start": 6348, "end": 6505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Why are so many 'possessed' people in the community women?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 23, "start": 6505, "end": 6662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Could a jinn fall in love with my spouse and break up my marriage?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 24, "start": 6662, "end": 6974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "How does Mufti Abu Layth explain an exorcist who speaks as his own jinn?"}, {"video": "7z8yu8Kr83Y", "n": 25, "start": 6974, "end": 7089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170920", "title": "Why not treat jinn possession as just a difference of opinion among scholars?"}, {"video": "8JX1u0qQYAE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200114", "title": "Is DMT haram?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Introduction: the Sunni Defence live session and its charge of an 'attack on the Sunnah'"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Why does he reject the hadith of the tree crying for the Prophet?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 3, "start": 470, "end": 629, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Does he believe in miracles?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 4, "start": 629, "end": 863, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "How does he view the Salafi movement, and is hadith narrator criticism a divine science?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 5, "start": 863, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Is it acceptable to criticise a hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 6, "start": 1023, "end": 1181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Does the Maliki school distinguish between hadith and Sunnah, and did Imam Malik ever reject a hadith?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 7, "start": 1181, "end": 1482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Can a hadith narrated by Jabir alone be mutawatir?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 8, "start": 1482, "end": 1875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Is the chain Hammad ibn Salama from Thabit from Anas for the crying-tree hadith sound?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 9, "start": 1875, "end": 2188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Are the Jabir chains for the crying-tree hadith through Isra'il, Abd al-Razzaq and Ibn Jurayj sound?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 10, "start": 2188, "end": 2419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Did Ibn Ma'in consider Isma'il ibn Abi Uways and his family reliable?"}, {"video": "8U9-ASlyrzE", "n": 11, "start": 2419, "end": 2793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "What does he say to critics who accept that the Prophet was impotent, married a nine-year-old or was bewitched into clumsiness?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Opening: unwell and late, the last Monday Night before Ramadan, plans for a get-together"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 2, "start": 656, "end": 734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Does a community gathering have to be gender segregated?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 3, "start": 734, "end": 893, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Questions noted for later: fasting at work, a hadith on Quran 4:159"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 4, "start": 893, "end": 1287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Responding to viewers' love: a grown-up child, and haters as a measure of impact"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 5, "start": 1287, "end": 1448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Setting up the supporters' messages; technical trouble"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 6, "start": 1448, "end": 1769, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Reading supporters' messages: ease of deen, the Bukhari series, apostasy"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 7, "start": 1769, "end": 1927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Should my faith make me happy?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 8, "start": 1927, "end": 2006, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Humour as a natural gift"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 9, "start": 2006, "end": 2164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Should Muslims judge their own sources by the standards they apply to other religions?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 10, "start": 2164, "end": 2401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "How has the internet changed who gets to speak about Islam?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 11, "start": 2401, "end": 2870, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Are there answers to the hardest ethical questions about stories in the Quran?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 12, "start": 2870, "end": 3026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Are the stories in the Quran true but not historical, like the story of Adam?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 13, "start": 3026, "end": 3264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Why are some clerics so hostile to Mufti Abu Layth?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 14, "start": 3264, "end": 3660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is it obligatory for Muslims to establish a caliphate?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 15, "start": 3660, "end": 3819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Will traditional religious institutions survive if they do not adapt?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 16, "start": 3819, "end": 3976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is everything halal unless proven haram?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 17, "start": 3976, "end": 4055, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Do I need a religious authority to own my faith?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 18, "start": 4055, "end": 4213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is God someone I should mainly be afraid of?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 19, "start": 4213, "end": 4451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Why do some religious people dislike laughter?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 20, "start": 4451, "end": 4689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "More messages: a middle path between Salafism and Quranism, and 'God is not dumb'"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 21, "start": 4689, "end": 4943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is Mufti Abu Layth against Salafis?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 22, "start": 4943, "end": 5021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Apologies for the equipment, and no Monday Nights during Ramadan"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 23, "start": 5021, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Why does Ramadan fall in different seasons each year?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 24, "start": 5335, "end": 5573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Why is Salafi content so dominant online?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 25, "start": 5573, "end": 5968, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "How should I deal with online hate preachers?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 26, "start": 5968, "end": 6125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Where are the answers to the questions on the Jesus debate?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 27, "start": 6125, "end": 6361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Can critics cancel an independent preacher?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 28, "start": 6361, "end": 6520, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "What is the most important thing to get right in life?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 29, "start": 6520, "end": 6679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Will Mufti Abu Layth invite his critics onto MindTrap?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 30, "start": 6679, "end": 6758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Will religious dogmatism ever disappear?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 31, "start": 6758, "end": 7155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Did Dr Abdul Majid refute Mufti Abu Layth's BukhariGate arguments?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 32, "start": 7155, "end": 7313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Adnan Ibrahim?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 33, "start": 7313, "end": 7550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is child marriage legal in Western countries?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 34, "start": 7550, "end": 7788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Calling for Facebook questions; shout-outs and a guest suggestion"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 35, "start": 7788, "end": 8335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "When should reason take priority over religious texts?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 36, "start": 8335, "end": 8650, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Can I pray for a non-Muslim who has died?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 37, "start": 8650, "end": 9200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Can the soul travel into the spiritual world through meditation or dhikr?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 38, "start": 9200, "end": 9357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Did one of al-Bukhari's teachers call Imam Malik a disbeliever?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 39, "start": 9357, "end": 9748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "What did Ibn Rushd mean by the 'double truth' of religion and philosophy?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 40, "start": 9748, "end": 9827, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "What was the real crime of the people of Lut?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 41, "start": 9827, "end": 10378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Are many people's frustrations really about unmet sexual needs?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 42, "start": 10378, "end": 10691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "How can I be sure my reason is not wrong?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 43, "start": 10691, "end": 10771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Are the devils really chained up during Ramadan?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 44, "start": 10771, "end": 10928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is the pursuit of knowledge a deeper drive than sex?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 45, "start": 10928, "end": 11164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of al-Shaybani's critique of the Madinan school?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 46, "start": 11164, "end": 11322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Was Adam a real person?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 47, "start": 11322, "end": 12110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Is it wrong for a Muslim to want to make money?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 48, "start": 12110, "end": 12501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Can I fast for a fixed 12 hours when the days are very long?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 49, "start": 12501, "end": 12899, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "Can I skip fasting because of work, exams or health, and what do I do instead?"}, {"video": "8XuHMCz2N3U", "n": 50, "start": 12899, "end": 13057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210413", "title": "I don't feel spiritual in Ramadan; am I a bad Muslim?"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 485, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419", "title": "Why do Mufti Abu Layth's critics defend Bukhari reports that demean the Prophet?"}, {"video": "8zY0NDQvL2U", "n": 2, "start": 485, "end": 507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210419", "title": "Sign-off: wrapping up a late, extended stream"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009", "title": "Can a hadith be rejected because it goes against reason?"}, {"video": "9cYDToRoy7Q", "n": 2, "start": 253, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201009", "title": "If a reliable narrator reports from someone, does that make the source reliable?"}, {"video": "9kK28jhdcA8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Did Zakir Naik say masturbation is not haram?"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312", "title": "Do I have to follow a madhhab?"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312", "title": "Do I have to stick to one madhhab, or can I question its positions?"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312", "title": "If the madhhabs differ so much, how can they all be valid?"}, {"video": "9tHI3gcIiCk", "n": 4, "start": 706, "end": 854, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140312", "title": "How should I choose which madhhab to follow?"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617", "title": "What did Yasir Qadhi say to Mohammed Hijab about the preservation of the Quran?"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617", "title": "How did Mohammed Hijab react after his interview with Yasir Qadhi backfired?"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 3, "start": 387, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617", "title": "Why does he say the backlash against Yasir Qadhi is his own doing?"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 4, "start": 624, "end": 1008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617", "title": "What should Yasir Qadhi have said about the preservation of the Quran?"}, {"video": "ATcN8aUo8oc", "n": 5, "start": 1008, "end": 1149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200617", "title": "What does he think will happen to Yasir Qadhi and Mohammed Hijab after this controversy?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Is the hadith that singing breeds hypocrisy in the heart authentic?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Which scholars held that music is permissible, and what did Imam Malik's school say?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 947, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Is listening to music haram?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 4, "start": 947, "end": 1341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Is music with explicit or violent lyrics haram?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 5, "start": 1341, "end": 1569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Who has the authority to declare music haram if God has not?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 6, "start": 1569, "end": 1808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Is it haram to write or sing lyrics about alcohol?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 7, "start": 1808, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Why is everything permissible by default in Islamic law unless proven haram?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 8, "start": 2203, "end": 2895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "If obscene lyrics make music haram, what about the classical Arabic poetry taught in madrasas?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 9, "start": 2895, "end": 3128, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Does sound exist if nobody hears it?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 10, "start": 3128, "end": 3602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Why do people assume music must be haram before looking at any evidence?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 11, "start": 3602, "end": 3992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "Why is celibacy praised despite a hadith against it while music is condemned without one?"}, {"video": "AXXuB9lxFoc", "n": 12, "start": 3992, "end": 4274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190918", "title": "What is Mufti Abu Layth's final verdict on whether music is haram?"}, {"video": "AZJBapbSjDo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Mufti Menk?"}, {"video": "AhTy-xxH79g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "Is it okay to criticise the companions of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "AwhVA-P9rTo", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 530, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191104", "title": "Is mut'ah (temporary marriage) haram?"}, {"video": "AwxuMQnPbw0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230602", "title": "What can the death of a parent teach us?"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 148, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228", "title": "Reactions to his Safiyya narrative, and the parable of the wife who is never pleased"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 2, "start": 148, "end": 306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228", "title": "Did the Prophet marry Safiyya on the same night she was captured?"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 3, "start": 306, "end": 540, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228", "title": "Are witnesses required for a nikah in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 4, "start": 540, "end": 1091, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228", "title": "What do the classical Maliki books say about witnesses in a marriage?"}, {"video": "BC8qsIOFAwE", "n": 5, "start": 1091, "end": 1515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180228", "title": "Is it fair to say Mufti Abu Layth has no knowledge of the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "BPBiF_hAKgQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201105", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Shaykh Hamza Yusuf?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "What is the Hagia Sophia and what did Turkey decide about it?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 2, "start": 163, "end": 478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Does Islam allow converting churches and other places of worship into mosques?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 3, "start": 478, "end": 635, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Was it haram for Muslims to turn the Hagia Sophia into a mosque after the conquest?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 4, "start": 635, "end": 793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Is it wrong to turn the Hagia Sophia back into a mosque?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 5, "start": 793, "end": 948, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Were the Ottomans the representatives of Islam?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 6, "start": 948, "end": 1106, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Does Istanbul need the Hagia Sophia as a mosque?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 7, "start": 1106, "end": 1342, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "If Muslims can reconvert the Hagia Sophia, can Israel or India reconvert mosques too?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 8, "start": 1342, "end": 1580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Can a waqf never be overturned, as the argument for the Hagia Sophia claims?"}, {"video": "Bgsfy-UmSA4", "n": 9, "start": 1580, "end": 1828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200716", "title": "Should Pakistan allow a Hindu temple to be built in Islamabad?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 1, "start": 16, "end": 171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Introduction: why learn the Maliki salah, rak'ah counts and naturalness"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 2, "start": 171, "end": 936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Demonstration of the Maliki salah from takbir to salam"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 3, "start": 936, "end": 1050, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Introduction to sujud al-sahw, the prostration of forgetfulness"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 4, "start": 1050, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Five common types of mistakes in salah and how each is treated"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 2074, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Demonstration of sujud al-sahw before and after the salam, and cancellation"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 6, "start": 2074, "end": 2190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Do women pray differently from men in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 7, "start": 2190, "end": 2260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Can I pray Fajr at sunrise if I woke up late?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 8, "start": 2260, "end": 2363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "How should I stand in congregational prayer, and should my feet touch my neighbour's?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 9, "start": 2363, "end": 2487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "What do I do if I forgot to perform sujud al-sahw after my prayer?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 10, "start": 2487, "end": 2633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Can I pray in a t-shirt or vest, or in clothes with a picture on them?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 11, "start": 2633, "end": 2756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Can I pray with my trousers below my ankles, or in tight jeans?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 12, "start": 2756, "end": 2855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Do men need to cover their head to pray, and can I pray in shorts?"}, {"video": "BiN9UQPOpMA", "n": 13, "start": 2855, "end": 3016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170402", "title": "Is my prayer valid if my trousers slip and part of my backside shows for a moment in sujud?"}, {"video": "C-9MCspQqwE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240305", "title": "Which verse of the Quran promises more blessings for being grateful?"}, {"video": "CIPm_CHV0Kw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210830", "title": "Is a DMT ego death the same as the Sufi idea of fana?"}, {"video": "CnwAjt1i9Bo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 321, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310", "title": "Can I have a close non-Muslim friend and answer his salam?"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Is it rape if a husband uses religion to pressure his wife into sex?"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 2, "start": 192, "end": 420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Do the angels curse a wife who refuses her husband in bed?"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 3, "start": 420, "end": 754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Thanks for the correction, but the chain is still flawed"}, {"video": "Cz26by1mMns", "n": 4, "start": 754, "end": 1152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Critics silent on marital rape, and a story about research and conclusions"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 474, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920", "title": "What is the war-wager hadith paradox?"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 2, "start": 474, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920", "title": "If a mutawatir hadith has to be reinterpreted, what does that say about hadith transmission?"}, {"video": "DAVFpkd1ECo", "n": 3, "start": 943, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180920", "title": "Why does hadith dogmatism fail, according to the war-wager paradox?"}, {"video": "DYnuJS-DTMU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210213", "title": "What do you think of Mu'awiya?"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216", "title": "Is someone who prays but commits major sins better than someone who doesn't pray?"}, {"video": "DhKc0LO1e18", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221216", "title": "Is worship or how I treat people the real sign of faith?"}, {"video": "DnueaKQQZXY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230206", "title": "Is Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza consistent in how he criticises hadith?"}, {"video": "ETWstnCMgZA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200529", "title": "Was the arrest of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza justified?"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "5Pillars' coverage of Mufti Abu Layth and its article claiming he denies the afterlife"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Is the Quran's description of paradise and hell literal or symbolic?"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 3, "start": 550, "end": 941, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "How should I deal with religious circles that pressure me into beliefs?"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 4, "start": 941, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Did the Prophet teach a formal creed of what Muslims must believe?"}, {"video": "EWmBN7JV9Dk", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Closing: build bridges, talk to everyone, and an invitation to Daniel Haqiqatjou"}, {"video": "EcabHd3Hf6U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200216", "title": "Is it Sunnah to drink camel urine as medicine?"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Accused of misquoting Ibn Ashur on the beast of the earth"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 2, "start": 235, "end": 425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "What does the Quran say about the beast of the earth?"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 3, "start": 425, "end": 581, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Will a beast really appear at the end of times?"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 4, "start": 581, "end": 659, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Do the signs of the Hour have to come before the Hour?"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 5, "start": 659, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Does Ibn Ashur say the beast comes before the Day of Judgment?"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 6, "start": 930, "end": 1165, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Ibn Ashur: the creature speaks to the deniers at the gathering"}, {"video": "EoQ_mXafx5o", "n": 7, "start": 1165, "end": 1298, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180529", "title": "Calling it a misquotation is poor scholarship"}, {"video": "FNtMxwadPAc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180831", "title": "An imam faking his tarawih recitation: a memory from Mufti Abu Layth's hifz days"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "The birth of orthodoxy: a nameless main body and the hadith project"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 2, "start": 346, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "Apophatic definition: the early main body defined by what it was not"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 3, "start": 649, "end": 1150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "The created Quran controversy and the birth of a creedal checklist"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 4, "start": 1150, "end": 1577, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "Orthodoxy and power: adding to the checklist, ijma and cancel culture"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 5, "start": 1577, "end": 1809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "Language embeds power: 'inconvenience' versus 'hardship' in tayammum"}, {"video": "F_4jnUA3ARQ", "n": 6, "start": 1809, "end": 2048, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230213", "title": "Why orthodoxy took hold, and who wrote the checklist"}, {"video": "Fiq59Zcj9KU", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191106", "title": "What should I think about when choosing a name for my child?"}, {"video": "Fko_FZwwNbA", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 62, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240304", "title": "How much does Allah love me?"}, {"video": "Fz6mtRfzUDI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191105", "title": "What is the difference between the Ash'ari and Athari (Hanbali) creeds?"}, {"video": "G0iGieTCklk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213", "title": "What happens if I miss a prayer?"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "The backlash to Maulana Tariq Jamil's dua on media, modesty and the pandemic, and the clip"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 2, "start": 359, "end": 592, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "Did Maulana Tariq Jamil blame women for the coronavirus?"}, {"video": "GAm6NYtozDg", "n": 3, "start": 592, "end": 732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200428", "title": "Is it wrong to preach modesty to society?"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229", "title": "Who is Uzair mentioned in the Quran?"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 2, "start": 345, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229", "title": "Could Uzair in the Quran be the Egyptian figure Osiris?"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 3, "start": 686, "end": 869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229", "title": "Why did the Israelites ask Moses for an idol after leaving Egypt?"}, {"video": "GdlCbTkYHgM", "n": 4, "start": 869, "end": 1164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191229", "title": "Why did Moses carry a staff?"}, {"video": "Grh2ZU4awQI", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191018", "title": "Did the Prophet really split the moon in half?"}, {"video": "H4IXL17jyEU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200330", "title": "Should we recite Sahih al-Bukhari to protect ourselves from the coronavirus?"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Is it haram for men and women to shake hands?"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Which scholars say men and women may shake hands, and what about 'I do not shake hands with women'?"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "What evidence do scholars use to allow men and women to shake hands?"}, {"video": "H8SXk-2-W-4", "n": 4, "start": 550, "end": 746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Should I refuse to shake hands with the opposite sex where it is the custom?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth hold views that most scholars disagree with?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Was Iblis condemned for using his reason?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 3, "start": 428, "end": 700, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth not believe Jesus will return?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 4, "start": 700, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Does questioning religion with reason destroy faith?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 1189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Was Jesus born without a father according to the Quran?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 6, "start": 1189, "end": 1299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Why do most Muslims believe in the virgin birth?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 7, "start": 1299, "end": 1876, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Does evolution contradict the Quran's account of Adam?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 8, "start": 1876, "end": 2240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "If God made the laws of nature, can He break them?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 9, "start": 2240, "end": 2586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "If humans evolved, why are there still chimpanzees?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 10, "start": 2586, "end": 3036, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Why do some Muslims struggle to accept that Adam might have had parents?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 11, "start": 3036, "end": 3300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Does the Quran say Adam was made from clay or from a drop of sperm?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 12, "start": 3300, "end": 3451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "Why doesn't the Quran clearly deny the virgin birth?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 13, "start": 3451, "end": 3873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "If human reason is limited, why rely on it in religion?"}, {"video": "HIU1GJSzg1E", "n": 14, "start": 3873, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201013", "title": "If I commit a crime, was it my free will or my destiny?"}, {"video": "HLHgB2tyt-c", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 213, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210215", "title": "Why does Bukhari accept a narrator who praised Ali's killer while Shia narrators are rejected?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Opening: a near-sabotaged stream, a birthday treat and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 2, "start": 477, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "A classical Arabic love poem on how the prophets' attributes are shared out"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 909, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Will you discuss reincarnation with a guest on Mind Trap?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 4, "start": 909, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Clip: Matt Hancock pressed on voting against free school meals"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1249, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why are British politicians so bad at interviews?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 6, "start": 1249, "end": 1470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Will you ever do a Mind Trap with Mohammed Hijab?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 7, "start": 1470, "end": 1537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Does a bald woman have to wear hijab?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 8, "start": 1537, "end": 1793, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "What do you think of the Muslim community in Birmingham?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 9, "start": 1793, "end": 2082, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Does joking and laughing a lot mean I lack high aspiration?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 10, "start": 2082, "end": 2232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Under the microscope: a text on the fast breaking through a 'direct channel'"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 11, "start": 2232, "end": 2310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Are video games haram?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 12, "start": 2310, "end": 2427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Does smoking break my wudu?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 13, "start": 2427, "end": 2878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "If money was earned in a haram way, is it haram for whoever receives it?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 14, "start": 2878, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Who is Dr Abdul Majid, your Mind Trap guest?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "A debater, Saqib Shaami's crew and a conference on the finality of prophethood"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 16, "start": 3758, "end": 3972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Will I go to hell for not shaving my pubic hair?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 17, "start": 3972, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "What is the Ark of the Covenant in Islam?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 18, "start": 4242, "end": 4626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Is it halal to perform music or dance at concerts for a living?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 19, "start": 4626, "end": 5077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "What can I do if I can't afford to marry but want to avoid zina?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 20, "start": 5077, "end": 5529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why is it so hard to find real, honest people?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 21, "start": 5529, "end": 5607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why does Islam describe Paradise in such sensual terms?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 22, "start": 5607, "end": 5676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "How do I find the true Sunnah in the hadith books?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 23, "start": 5676, "end": 5864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why don't you open an Islamic academy?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 24, "start": 5864, "end": 6244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Has Zaytuna College limited what Hamza Yusuf can say?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 25, "start": 6244, "end": 6549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "People are cruel: complaints used to try to stop a retreat he spoke at"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 26, "start": 6549, "end": 6973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "'Danny Boy's' Telegram post calling female academics 'snarling witches'"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 27, "start": 6973, "end": 7739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Who was Ibn Rushd (Averroes)?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 28, "start": 7739, "end": 8197, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why did Ibn Rushd fall from favour with the caliph?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 29, "start": 8197, "end": 8429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "How did Ibn Rushd answer al-Ghazali's attack on the philosophers?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 30, "start": 8429, "end": 8844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "What did Ibn Rushd say about women's abilities?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 31, "start": 8844, "end": 9037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "How does Ibn Rushd compare to other critical-minded scholars?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 32, "start": 9037, "end": 9187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Do I pay zakat again on savings that haven't grown?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 33, "start": 9187, "end": 9268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "How do I explain to someone why believing in God matters?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 34, "start": 9268, "end": 9410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Can I say Prophet Yusuf was more handsome than Prophet Muhammad?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 35, "start": 9410, "end": 9800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Is it haram to eat with my left hand?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 36, "start": 9800, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Why did Moses have to strike the sea with his staff for it to part?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 37, "start": 9911, "end": 10684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Did Ibn Ashur say Jesus was raised alive and will return?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 38, "start": 10684, "end": 11266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Does the Quran say nothing against Jesus' second coming?"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 39, "start": 11266, "end": 11390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Reaction to a niqabi's clip using driving as a metaphor for sex"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 40, "start": 11390, "end": 11541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "A risque proverb from al-Andalus: 'the nerves are connected'"}, {"video": "Hv-BlBVTr4M", "n": 41, "start": 11541, "end": 11670, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210119", "title": "Closing: subscribe, thanks to patrons, and this week's Mind Trap"}, {"video": "IXSyLbrg6A0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200525", "title": "I stopped praying because it feels mechanical and forced; will I go to hell?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What is BukhariGate and why does Mufti Abu Layth say Sahih al-Bukhari is not reliable?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 623, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "Does Sahih al-Bukhari say the Prophet forgot verses of the Quran and that there was a verse of stoning?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 3, "start": 623, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth say about the Bukhari report of the Prophet falling unconscious when he uncovered himself?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What is the Bukhari report about the Prophet seeing a woman beside Umar's palace in paradise?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 5, "start": 938, "end": 1095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What is the Bukhari deathbed report in which the companions ask whether the Prophet is delirious?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 6, "start": 1095, "end": 1330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth reject the Bukhari report of Sulayman and the hundred women?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 7, "start": 1330, "end": 1565, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth say about the Bukhari report of the wolf and the cow that spoke?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 8, "start": 1565, "end": 1723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "What does the Bukhari report that Shaytan touches every newborn except Mary and Jesus mean?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 9, "start": 1723, "end": 1803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "Does Sahih al-Bukhari say the Prophet pointed to Aisha's house as the source of fitna?"}, {"video": "IijbMTxUEOw", "n": 10, "start": 1803, "end": 1961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180901", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say BukhariGate matters?"}, {"video": "J9NB1eLQ56Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210112", "title": "Why was Ibn Taymiyya put in prison?"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310", "title": "Reply to Mufti Mangera on ear piercing: who defines normal and decent?"}, {"video": "JP-vZ7g-UW0", "n": 2, "start": 220, "end": 457, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210310", "title": "Reply to Mufti Mangera: does the ban on muthla forbid piercing?"}, {"video": "JQMaIJJJVoI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180308", "title": "Do Muslim women have to wear the niqab?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "What are the Sana'a manuscripts and how were they discovered?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Why does the Sana'a manuscript have two layers of text?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 3, "start": 310, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Who has studied the Sana'a palimpsest and what is the controversy about?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 4, "start": 467, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Does the Sana'a manuscript show that the Quran was changed?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 5, "start": 782, "end": 1016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Did the companions ever read or understand the Quran differently from each other?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 6, "start": 1016, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Why might an early Arab have written a Quranic word differently?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 7, "start": 1174, "end": 1327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Was the Sana'a palimpsest an official copy of the Quran or someone's personal notes?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 8, "start": 1327, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "What are the differences between the Sana'a lower text and today's Quran?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 9, "start": 1483, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "How did Uthman standardise the Quran, and does that explain the Sana'a text?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 10, "start": 1719, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Does the Sana'a manuscript prove the Quran evolved over time?"}, {"video": "K6fAZ7xW53Y", "n": 11, "start": 1955, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190301", "title": "Does the Sana'a manuscript support or undermine the Muslim account of the Quran's history?"}, {"video": "K8VL17CEZW0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200322", "title": "Abdul Raheem Limbada and the dream of the coronavirus as a man"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 1, "start": 24, "end": 428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Opening: a Sunday-night stream past midnight and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 2, "start": 428, "end": 654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is music allowed in Islam?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 3, "start": 654, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is it a virtue for a scholar never to hold an original position?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 4, "start": 880, "end": 1277, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Why isn't bank interest riba?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 5, "start": 1277, "end": 1428, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is my divorce automatic if my husband has been unreachable for over a year?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 6, "start": 1428, "end": 1506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Does a civil divorce count as an Islamic divorce?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 7, "start": 1506, "end": 1616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Were the hadith about the black flags against the Abbasids?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 8, "start": 1616, "end": 1719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Soul mates and twin flames: a question laughed off"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 9, "start": 1719, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Doesn't the practice of Medina show that music is haram?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 10, "start": 1797, "end": 2391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Are psychedelics like DMT haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 11, "start": 2391, "end": 2500, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "If alcohol is haram, aren't drugs like DMT haram too?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 12, "start": 2500, "end": 2808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is it OK for Quran teachers to beat students?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 13, "start": 2808, "end": 2927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Can I hit my children if they don't pray?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 14, "start": 2927, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Chat asides: an edited comedy appearance and a podcast invitation"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 15, "start": 2996, "end": 3491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Should the zakat threshold be different in each country?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 16, "start": 3491, "end": 3609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Does paying taxes count as paying zakat?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 17, "start": 3609, "end": 3801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Does giving charity protect me from bad things happening?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 18, "start": 3801, "end": 4244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is it a problem that Muslim scholars today have no secular education?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 19, "start": 4244, "end": 4632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Doesn't Aisha's marriage age justify child marriage?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 20, "start": 4632, "end": 4976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is the hadith that Aisha was married at six authentic?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 21, "start": 4976, "end": 5241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Music interlude and a remark on poets"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 22, "start": 5241, "end": 5734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "How should Muslims react when someone tears or burns the Quran?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 23, "start": 5734, "end": 6070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is it right to attack critics of Islam personally?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 24, "start": 6070, "end": 6340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Are Abdullah bin Bayyah and Hamza Yusuf to blame for the UAE-Israel deal?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 25, "start": 6340, "end": 6556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Will the UAE-Israel deal bring peace to Palestine?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 26, "start": 6556, "end": 6869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "What is the solution for the Palestinians in Gaza?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 27, "start": 6869, "end": 7026, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is al-Aqsa really in Jerusalem?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 28, "start": 7026, "end": 7413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is defending the holy land worth Palestinian lives?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 29, "start": 7413, "end": 7609, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "What is the solution to the Kashmir conflict?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 30, "start": 7609, "end": 8254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Did the Prophet really order Jews and Christians expelled from Arabia?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 31, "start": 8254, "end": 8436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "If Muslims focus too much on the beard, what deserves more focus?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 32, "start": 8436, "end": 8554, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "A misspelt comment read as a question about the saxophone"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 33, "start": 8554, "end": 8785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Is a secret nikah allowed?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 34, "start": 8785, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Was the ifk in Surat al-Nur really about Aisha?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 35, "start": 9154, "end": 9313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Why did only Mariya bear the Prophet a child in Medina?"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 36, "start": 9313, "end": 9580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "The critic he nicknames Gangu Teli and his Twitter meltdown"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 37, "start": 9580, "end": 10039, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "An offer to discuss Sahih al-Bukhari live, and a demand for a moderated debate"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 38, "start": 10039, "end": 10497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "'How I destroyed his career': mocking the critic's response video"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 39, "start": 10497, "end": 10632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "A closing clip of advice against riding three on a motorbike"}, {"video": "KWmtt2TQAO0", "n": 40, "start": 10632, "end": 10867, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200824", "title": "Sign-off: Ali not named in the Quran, Patreon, and farewell"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 330, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222", "title": "Abdul Rahman Hassan's clip: the first Khariji, protest, and never criticising rulers"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 2, "start": 330, "end": 601, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222", "title": "Did the Prophet say he would kill the lineage of the first Khariji?"}, {"video": "KrIGi3OmJD4", "n": 3, "start": 601, "end": 803, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210222", "title": "An invitation to MindTrap on aqidah and Bukhari, and an open challenge to Salafi imams"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 1, "start": 22, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Opening: welcoming back the guest and sharing the stream"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Have Muslims moved towards giving the Quran primacy over hadith?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 3, "start": 380, "end": 694, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Does the Quran prescribe stoning for adultery?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 4, "start": 694, "end": 851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Does the Quran prescribe a punishment for apostasy?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 5, "start": 851, "end": 1088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Why did earlier scholars not see what reform-minded scholars see today?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 6, "start": 1088, "end": 1481, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Can hudud punishments such as stoning or hand-cutting change with the times?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 7, "start": 1481, "end": 1638, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Is using reason to interpret Islam just preferring my own intellect over revelation?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 8, "start": 1638, "end": 1954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Why do Muslims treat reason as the enemy of tradition?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 9, "start": 1954, "end": 2489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "How old was Aisha when she married the Prophet?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 10, "start": 2489, "end": 2883, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Why do the circumstances of the Prophet's marriage rule out a six-year-old Aisha?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 11, "start": 2883, "end": 3273, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Is questioning Aisha's age just an attempt to please non-Muslims?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 12, "start": 3273, "end": 3666, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Can a hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari be questioned?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 13, "start": 3666, "end": 3905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Can Sahih al-Bukhari be proven to be the book Imam al-Bukhari wrote?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 14, "start": 3905, "end": 4296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "How should hadith be evaluated, and did the companions ever misreport the Prophet?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 15, "start": 4296, "end": 4532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Is criticising Sahih al-Bukhari an attack on Imam al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 16, "start": 4532, "end": 4845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Does Islam teach that jinn can possess people?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 17, "start": 4845, "end": 5140, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Does the Quran support the idea that Shaytan or jinn can control a person?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 18, "start": 5140, "end": 5376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Was Jesus born of a virgin, and how could a jinn father a child?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 19, "start": 5376, "end": 5611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "If possession were real, why is there no sahih hadith of the Prophet casting out a jinn?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 20, "start": 5611, "end": 6004, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Is belief in magic spells and jinn possession part of Islam?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 21, "start": 6004, "end": 6162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Does Surat al-Falaq confirm that black magic is real?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 22, "start": 6162, "end": 6595, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "What does the Quran mean by 'what your right hands possess', and did the Prophet have a concubine?"}, {"video": "KsQKsrXndNw", "n": 23, "start": 6595, "end": 6797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200422", "title": "Closing: thanks, the guest's apology for a short Q&A, and his Facebook live the next day"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Daniel Haqiqatjou's post that praying in a closet is a Sunnah for women"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 2, "start": 333, "end": 566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Does a hadith tell women to pray in a closet?"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 3, "start": 566, "end": 911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Musaylima, Sajah and the poem that shows what makhda' means"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 4, "start": 911, "end": 1400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Is it better for women to pray at home than in the mosque?"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 5, "start": 1402, "end": 1904, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Is the hadith about women praying in the darkest part of the house authentic?"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 6, "start": 1904, "end": 2286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Have Muslims really kept women out of mosques for 1,400 years?"}, {"video": "KuSevqg0low", "n": 7, "start": 2286, "end": 2469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190504", "title": "Is Islam meant to be applied the same rigid way everywhere?"}, {"video": "LJpCQXiII98", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Does the Quran say there are three or five daily prayers?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 232, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Does jinn possession exist in Islam?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 2, "start": 232, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Why did religious scholars end up explaining things like illness and the mind?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 3, "start": 467, "end": 783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Does the Quran's riba verse prove that Satan can possess people?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 4, "start": 783, "end": 1174, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Are there authentic hadith showing the Prophet casting out jinn?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 5, "start": 1174, "end": 1329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Should I believe something just because people say the Quran or hadith say so?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 6, "start": 1329, "end": 1488, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "What does the hadith 'Satan flows through the son of Adam like blood' mean?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 7, "start": 1488, "end": 1726, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Why do only believers in jinn possession seem to experience it?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 8, "start": 1726, "end": 2040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "How do we know mental illness is not really jinn possession?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 9, "start": 2040, "end": 2199, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Why does it matter whether people believe in jinn possession?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 10, "start": 2199, "end": 2437, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "What medical conditions could have been mistaken for possession in the past?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 11, "start": 2437, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "If exorcisms and ruqya sometimes work, does that prove possession is real?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 12, "start": 2673, "end": 2908, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "If jinn do not possess people, what is ruqya for?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 13, "start": 2908, "end": 3302, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "What is the 'jinn of the gaps'?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 14, "start": 3302, "end": 3537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Why do cases of 'possession' in Muslim communities so often involve women with trauma?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 15, "start": 3537, "end": 3695, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Can a jinn fall in love with someone or break up a marriage?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 16, "start": 3695, "end": 3931, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "How does Mufti Abu Layth explain an exorcist who says he is possessed by a jinn?"}, {"video": "LeXzvtf9YGA", "n": 17, "start": 3931, "end": 4058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Is jinn possession just a difference of opinion among scholars?"}, {"video": "LnOAQLLkvNo", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210108", "title": "Rumours that Mufti Abu Layth is behind a social media preacher"}, {"video": "LyZCk5dygJk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170914", "title": "Can Islamic punishments like stoning and cutting off hands change with time?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "Are Bin Bayyah and Hamza Yusuf to blame for the UAE's deal with Israel?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "Has the UAE's recognition of Israel brought any peace?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 3, "start": 477, "end": 794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think should happen to the Palestinians in Gaza?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 4, "start": 794, "end": 951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "Is Jerusalem really a holy city in Islam?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 5, "start": 951, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "Should Palestinians stay and defend the holy land at the cost of their lives?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 6, "start": 1110, "end": 1347, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth compare the Palestinian situation to facing a knife?"}, {"video": "M6R6PNmTG0w", "n": 7, "start": 1347, "end": 1508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210517", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think the solution for Kashmir is?"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Is it haram to pressure a wife into sex by saying God will be angry?"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 2, "start": 265, "end": 833, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "Was al-A'mash a reliable hadith narrator?"}, {"video": "NGz8JO6O0f4", "n": 3, "start": 833, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180708", "title": "What is the point of checking a hadith's chain of narrators?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Opening: unwell but live, Facebook sharing and greetings"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 2, "start": 234, "end": 624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why the second-coming debate blew up and what tonight's prelude covers"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 3, "start": 624, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Reply to Abu Ibrahim's post and Hizb ut-Tahrir's double standard"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 4, "start": 856, "end": 1061, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Critics sharing clips of al-Dedew and al-Awni: double standards in scholarship"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 5, "start": 1061, "end": 1220, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why make a big deal of whether Jesus returns, and who is the message for?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 6, "start": 1220, "end": 1532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Two camps of religion: tribal mythology versus religion that must make sense"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 7, "start": 1532, "end": 1763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Calling to the Quran and Sunnah, not hadith; the winged horse on national television"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 8, "start": 1763, "end": 1920, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "We are all seeking the truth: disagree without takfir"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 9, "start": 1920, "end": 2078, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why do other scholars not see what Mufti Abu Layth sees about the return of Jesus?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 10, "start": 2078, "end": 2235, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Stop obsessing about the end times: the hadith of Jibril and the planting hadith"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 11, "start": 2235, "end": 2392, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "A Christian belief that crept into Islam; creed cannot be blind-followed"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 12, "start": 2392, "end": 2538, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "The second coming as a central Christian doctrine: Jesus returns as judge"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 13, "start": 2538, "end": 2853, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why would Jesus need to return if the Prophet Muhammad completed the religion?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 14, "start": 2853, "end": 3012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "If Jesus comes down from the sky, what is the point of faith after that?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 15, "start": 3012, "end": 3169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "If faith is no longer valid, why a judge? Psychology of testimony and detail"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 16, "start": 3169, "end": 3483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "The details of the Jesus hadith against the Quran: sword, judge, Jews, world peace"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 17, "start": 3483, "end": 3951, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "What Imam Malik transmitted: no return of Jesus, Zuhri's reports, the pig passed in peace"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 18, "start": 3951, "end": 4345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "What about the Dajjal? Doesn't Jesus have to return to kill him?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 19, "start": 4345, "end": 4661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "The white minaret of Damascus: places that did not exist in the Prophet's time"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 20, "start": 4661, "end": 4819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Israiliyyat in hadith: man in God's image and creation on the Sabbath"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 21, "start": 4819, "end": 4977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Three conditions for accepting a hadith; Ibn Uthaymin and the Jassasa report"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 22, "start": 4977, "end": 5212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "How could fabricated hadith have crept into mainstream Islam?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 23, "start": 5212, "end": 5606, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why hadith, not the Quran or fiqh, was corrupted: Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz, Zuhri and forged chains"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 24, "start": 5606, "end": 5840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Isn't the return of Jesus established by ijma and mutawatir hadith?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 25, "start": 5840, "end": 6077, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Zuhri's reports: Fatima's anger, the attempted suicide, and half the Jesus hadith"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 26, "start": 6077, "end": 6234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "A belief that changed nothing for the dead; the hadith on his teacher's wall"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 27, "start": 6234, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Give glad tidings, make things easy: the hadith behind his approach; do not intimidate"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 28, "start": 6470, "end": 6628, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Anwar Shah Kashmiri's claim of ijma, and the scholars who rejected the return"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 29, "start": 6628, "end": 6784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Rashid Rida at Deoband: how scholars disagree with adab"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 30, "start": 6784, "end": 7019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Shawkani against claimed consensus: music, following a madhhab, four wives, raf' al-yadayn"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 31, "start": 7019, "end": 7256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Everyone picks and chooses: later scholars on mawlid, shrines, hadra and the Jesus hadith"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 32, "start": 7256, "end": 7414, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Ibn Ashur, al-Shatibi and Ibn Khaldun on the Mahdi: a discussion within Islam"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 33, "start": 7414, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Reply to Shadee Elmasry and Hamza Maqbool: 'probably an apostate'"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 34, "start": 7571, "end": 7729, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "The Creed of Tahawi is not the Quran; Ash'aris do not make takfir of ahl al-qiblah"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 35, "start": 7729, "end": 7885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Verse 3:46 and the meaning of kahl: al-Razi and the origin of the second-coming reading"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 36, "start": 7885, "end": 8121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Verses 4:159 and 43:61: 'before his death' and 'knowledge of the hour'"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 37, "start": 8121, "end": 8356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Why would Jesus need to come back at all?"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 38, "start": 8356, "end": 8515, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Summary of the case against a second coming; Ibn Hazm on hadith against reason"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 39, "start": 8515, "end": 8754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Stop calling Bukhari the most authentic book after the Quran; fiqh preserved the living Sunnah"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 40, "start": 8754, "end": 9070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Shaykh Abdul Majid's civility; the 'Mufti' remark clarified; music in front of one's daughters"}, {"video": "NHzYu3BKBWE", "n": 41, "start": 9070, "end": 9265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180313", "title": "Close: miracles and reason to come, follow the pages, closing prayer"}, {"video": "NIVZcdJxC2o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200308", "title": "Did the Prophet marry his cousin?"}, {"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 195, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721", "title": "Is mut'ah a matter of belief that divides Sunnis and Shia?"}, {"video": "O3SO0Hmtatc", "n": 2, "start": 195, "end": 357, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180721", "title": "Do any Sunni scholars say mut'ah is not haram?"}, {"video": "OCiapHX4cGI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 1079, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200620", "title": "Why did Mufti Abu Layth change from how he looked and spoke in his old videos?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 95, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Opening: music and sharing the link with the guest"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 2, "start": 95, "end": 292, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Apology for the delay and how the dialogue was scheduled"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 3, "start": 292, "end": 452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "How the dialogue came about: a guest who waited two hours at the last meetup"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 4, "start": 452, "end": 644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth see the Quran-only movement as a reaction of anger?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 5, "start": 644, "end": 938, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is there a middle way between rejecting all hadith and accepting every hadith?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 6, "start": 938, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is the Quran-only position an argument from epistemology or from principle?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 7, "start": 1349, "end": 1662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Do Quranists accept any Sunnah of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 8, "start": 1662, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is the Prophet Muhammad the most beloved of creation and a mercy to the worlds?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 9, "start": 1962, "end": 2616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does 'we sent you only as a mercy' (21:107) describe the Prophet or the act of sending him?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 10, "start": 2616, "end": 3049, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why did Mufti Abu Layth challenge hadith in BukhariGate, and can the Prophet be called the most beloved of creation?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 11, "start": 3049, "end": 3400, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "What is the 'wisdom' the Prophet teaches alongside the Book in 2:129?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 12, "start": 3400, "end": 3684, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does 16:44 mean the Prophet explains the Quran, or that the Quran clarifies earlier scriptures?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 13, "start": 3684, "end": 4092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is the 'light' that came with the clear book in 5:15 the Prophet or the Quran itself?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 14, "start": 4092, "end": 4633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Can 'light' in 5:15 refer to the Prophet, or only to guidance and the book?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 15, "start": 4633, "end": 4798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "How do Quranists perform Hajj and apply Islam without the fiqh tradition?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 16, "start": 4798, "end": 5178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "How does a Quranist pray salah?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 17, "start": 5178, "end": 5469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "How do Muslims know how to pray if the Quran does not spell it out?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 18, "start": 5469, "end": 5814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does the Quranist prayer have any set structure?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 19, "start": 5814, "end": 6121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why does the guest's prayer have no fixed number of units, and what counts as wudu?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 20, "start": 6121, "end": 6386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does the Quran alone say what breaks the fast?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 21, "start": 6386, "end": 6602, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Can the Quran be used to call the Prophet the best of creation?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 22, "start": 6602, "end": 6937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is the daytime ban on eating and intimacy in Ramadan stated in the Quran or inferred?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 23, "start": 6937, "end": 7113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "If reason helps us understand the Quran, does the reasoning of earlier scholars matter too?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 24, "start": 7113, "end": 7479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does 3:188 mean everyone who likes praise will be punished?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 25, "start": 7479, "end": 7846, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Is it a sin to enjoy being praised?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 26, "start": 7846, "end": 8040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "If most people love praise and are punished, how is God the most merciful?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 27, "start": 8040, "end": 8331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why did Mufti Abu Layth bring up 3:188 against the Quran-only position?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 28, "start": 8331, "end": 8641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "What is Mufti Abu Layth's case for keeping the Islamic scholarly tradition?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 29, "start": 8641, "end": 9069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why do Quranists reject the Islamic tradition as a whole?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 30, "start": 9069, "end": 9681, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Why are two of the daily prayers recited silently when 17:110 says not to be silent?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 31, "start": 9681, "end": 9986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "Does the Muwatta show that the Companions' practice had already changed by Malik's time?"}, {"video": "ONzjD7XMDhE", "n": 32, "start": 9986, "end": 10164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20251018", "title": "How should Muslims engage people with very different views of the religion?"}, {"video": "Opl3bF6wzAs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 55, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Are tattoos haram?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Opening: al-Yaqoubi's heated public remarks about Mufti Abu Layth, and the title 'His Eminence'"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Shaykh Muhammad al-Yaqoubi?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 3, "start": 396, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "How did Shaykh al-Yaqoubi become so influential in the UK?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Does Mufti Abu Layth regard Sufi tariqahs led by pirs as cults?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 5, "start": 789, "end": 1019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Did Mufti Abu Layth mock Imam al-Nawawi?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 6, "start": 1019, "end": 1254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Why did medieval scholars like al-Nawawi write that boys are prettier than women?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 7, "start": 1254, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Is al-Yaqoubi's edition of Sahih al-Bukhari really the most authentic copy on earth?"}, {"video": "OtQqc3K4HWA", "n": 8, "start": 1489, "end": 1624, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190821", "title": "Would Mufti Abu Layth debate Shaykh al-Yaqoubi on Sahih al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "P4QG7Z3O8k4", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 210, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Is it haram to eat meat that is not halal-slaughtered, like a non-halal burger?"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206", "title": "Why don't Sunni imams like Malik and Abu Hanifa transmit from Imam Jafar al-Sadiq?"}, {"video": "PhrSS-NiR30", "n": 2, "start": 397, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201206", "title": "Did Imam Malik and Abu Hanifa study under Imam Jafar al-Sadiq, and what did they learn from him?"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "What magic means: fantasy magic versus illusion, and the Arabic sihr"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Three kinds of what was called magic: mind control, potions and illusion"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 3, "start": 613, "end": 923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Magic in the Quran: Musa and Pharaoh's magicians, an illusion"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 4, "start": 923, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Was magic done on the Prophet? Why he rejects the report"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Where the story came from: polemic, the poisoning report and the ajwa dates"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 6, "start": 1812, "end": 2424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Why great scholars accepted it: sectarian turf war with the Mu'tazila"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 7, "start": 2424, "end": 2618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Harut and Marut, and how magic 'splits' people"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 8, "start": 2618, "end": 2775, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "The seven ajwa dates hadith as hyperbole"}, {"video": "PiFqxkWyrwg", "n": 9, "start": 2775, "end": 3081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180415", "title": "Exploitation by 'babas', and the solution: proper help and mental health"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 376, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420", "title": "Did Musa's staff really turn into a snake?"}, {"video": "PkP3itoSKJc", "n": 2, "start": 376, "end": 812, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420", "title": "Did Musa beat Pharaoh's magicians with stronger magic?"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 493, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214", "title": "Do Muslims have to believe that Jesus will come back?"}, {"video": "QAXeuR-UXvo", "n": 2, "start": 493, "end": 830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210214", "title": "Can I blindly follow scholars in matters of belief?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Opening reflection on everyday miracles and an introduction of Mufti Abu Layth"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "What is the reward of sitting in a gathering of remembrance?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 3, "start": 492, "end": 725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Is Islam still relevant in today's confusing times?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 4, "start": 725, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Why do so many young Muslims feel confused or embarrassed about Islam today?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Where will the answers to Muslims' problems today come from?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 6, "start": 1918, "end": 2405, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Should religious Muslims focus on avoiding sin or on doing good?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 7, "start": 2405, "end": 2714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "How can young Muslims be made interested in their faith?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 8, "start": 2714, "end": 3286, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Abu Hanifa and Sufyan al-Thawri on the swapped brides of Kufa"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 9, "start": 3286, "end": 3742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "Is it wrong to watch Bollywood films and TV series?"}, {"video": "QBvWBHOIzW4", "n": 10, "start": 3742, "end": 4362, "tier": "machine", "date": "20161221", "title": "How can I help someone stop drinking without pushing them away?"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 236, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Introduction: the critic's video and the charges it makes"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 2, "start": 236, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Is the Quran created or uncreated? Why he calls the debate absurd"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 3, "start": 631, "end": 864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Shaving the beard: Qadi Iyad's view and the demand for one hadith"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 4, "start": 864, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Music: the hadith on singing and hypocrisy, and scholars who permitted music"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 2203, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Anal intercourse: the difference of opinion and the chains of the critic's hadith"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 6, "start": 2203, "end": 2438, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Refute me with sahih evidence: lying about the Prophet and the charge of misguidance"}, {"video": "R7s1DcClcwU", "n": 7, "start": 2438, "end": 2758, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180102", "title": "Ruqya and the Quran as a cure: spiritual diseases, not cancer"}, {"video": "RJe0SL67QzM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181110", "title": "Did Adam come from Neanderthals?"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "Viral claims that Mufti Abu Layth insulted the companions"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "Is every hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari authentic?"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 3, "start": 458, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "Is the hadith of the crying tree trunk authentic?"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 4, "start": 990, "end": 1121, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "Is it blasphemy to say some companions exaggerated out of love for the Prophet?"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 5, "start": 1121, "end": 1582, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "Are some hadith about the Prophet actually blasphemous?"}, {"video": "RM4jHsWJ_uM", "n": 6, "start": 1582, "end": 1732, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180209", "title": "How old was Aisha when she married the Prophet?"}, {"video": "RNWtaWHPx3A", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150307", "title": "How did Abu Hanifa deal with his drunkard neighbour?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 307, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Who transmitted the hadith 'whoever changes his religion, kill him', and does the Quran punish apostasy?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 2, "start": 307, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "How should Muslims respond to an ex-Muslim who criticises the Quran?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "What is the iddah after divorce and why does the Quran require it?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 4, "start": 620, "end": 933, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "What does the Quran say about how a divorce should end and about a divorced woman's future?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 5, "start": 933, "end": 1089, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "What does Quran 65:4 say about the waiting period for women whose periods have stopped?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 6, "start": 1089, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Does 'those who have not menstruated' in Quran 65:4 refer to little girls?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 7, "start": 1326, "end": 1483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Did classical scholars really say Quran 65:4 includes little girls?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 8, "start": 1483, "end": 1639, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Does the word 'women' in Surah al-Talaq rule out children?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 9, "start": 1639, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Did Imam Malik allow marriage to be consummated with a girl who was not yet nubile?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 10, "start": 1798, "end": 1956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "How does the rule that a clear verse overrides an ambiguous one apply to Quran 65:4?"}, {"video": "T-X4Lyns2vE", "n": 11, "start": 1956, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190725", "title": "Is forcing your wife to have sex a sin in Islam?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 317, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Does Islam allow attacking Salman Rushdie?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 2, "start": 317, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Salman Rushdie as a person?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 3, "start": 558, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What was Salman Rushdie's family background?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What made Salman Rushdie so hostile to Islam?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 5, "start": 1503, "end": 1661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Identity, Midnight's Children, the fatwa and the years in hiding"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 6, "start": 1661, "end": 1977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Is there a difference between criticising Islam and insulting it?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 7, "start": 1977, "end": 2528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What is The Satanic Verses actually about?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 8, "start": 2528, "end": 2688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Is The Satanic Verses a critique of Islam or an insult?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 9, "start": 2688, "end": 3164, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Why did Salman Rushdie write The Satanic Verses?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 10, "start": 3164, "end": 3322, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Jokes about Rushdie's hairline and a mock hair-transplant offer"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 11, "start": 3322, "end": 3401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Should all religions be free to compete without state backing?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 12, "start": 3401, "end": 3637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What does holding on to bitterness do to a person?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 13, "start": 3637, "end": 4162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What are the satanic verses in Islamic history?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 14, "start": 4162, "end": 4480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Is Quran 22:52 about the satanic verses incident?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 15, "start": 4480, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What did the classical Maliki scholars say about the satanic verses story?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 16, "start": 4720, "end": 5189, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Why did Ibn Hajar say the satanic verses story has some basis?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 17, "start": 5189, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What does the Quran say against the satanic verses story?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 18, "start": 5660, "end": 6130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Which scholars accepted the satanic verses story and which rejected it?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 19, "start": 6130, "end": 6444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Ibn Taymiyya and Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 20, "start": 6444, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Should loyalty to a scholar ever come before the honour of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "T0pHQRNJjBY", "n": 21, "start": 6765, "end": 7134, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220819", "title": "Recap: the novel, insult versus critique, and the false story summarised"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Did the Prophet say women lack intellect and faith?"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 773, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Does the Quran say most people in hell are women?"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 3, "start": 773, "end": 1001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Why do the versions of the 'women in hell' hadith contradict each other?"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 4, "start": 1001, "end": 1424, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Do women really curse more than men, as the hadith says?"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 5, "start": 1424, "end": 1842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Is not praying during menstruation a sign of weak faith?"}, {"video": "TFZo7S3T_8o", "n": 6, "start": 1842, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180729", "title": "Are the chains of the 'women lack intellect' hadith sound?"}, {"video": "TPH6TdXXLh4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180503", "title": "Are tattoos haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Opening: Qadhi's post on the drama of refutations and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 2, "start": 166, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Which Quranic verses does Yasir Qadhi say point to the return of Jesus?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 3, "start": 634, "end": 950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What does Yasir Qadhi claim about the hadith on Jesus's return being mutawatir?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 4, "start": 950, "end": 1345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Who does Yasir Qadhi say first denied the return of Jesus, and what is the Ahmadiyya connection?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 5, "start": 1345, "end": 1578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Do those who deny Jesus's return reject the unseen, as Yasir Qadhi claims?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 6, "start": 1578, "end": 1817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is distinguishing the Sunnah from hadith a modernist invention?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 7, "start": 1817, "end": 1971, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What does Yasir Qadhi say about the claim that the return of Jesus came from Judeo-Christian sources?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 8, "start": 1971, "end": 2130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "How does Yasir Qadhi answer the objection that Jesus killing pigs and refusing jizya makes no sense?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 9, "start": 2130, "end": 2287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Was Yasir Qadhi's video on the return of Jesus an academic discussion?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 10, "start": 2287, "end": 2604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What did Yasir Qadhi himself say about problematic signs of the Hour such as Gog and Magog?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 11, "start": 2604, "end": 2839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Does the Muslim account of the Mahdi, Jesus and Gog and Magog parallel Jewish messianic literature?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 12, "start": 2839, "end": 2996, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Did Yasir Qadhi himself say a hadith came into Islam from Jewish sources through Abu Hurayra?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 13, "start": 2996, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What is Yasir Qadhi's zombie theory about Gog and Magog?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 14, "start": 3319, "end": 3479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is Yasir Qadhi consistent about whether Gog and Magog could be hidden underground?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 15, "start": 3479, "end": 3717, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What has Yasir Qadhi said about challenging the giants of the Islamic tradition?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 16, "start": 3717, "end": 3954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Did Yasir Qadhi say that majority scholarly opinion rests on socio-political factors?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 17, "start": 3954, "end": 4188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Does Yasir Qadhi hold that even positions in aqidah lie within a spectrum of opinion?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 18, "start": 4188, "end": 4501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is there really ijma that Jesus will return, and did Muhammad Abduh invent the denial?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 19, "start": 4501, "end": 4813, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is separating hadith from the Sunnah a Hanafi and Maliki principle, and what does Mufti Abu Layth say about Salafi creed?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 20, "start": 4813, "end": 5127, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Does 'he will speak to people in maturity' or 'before his death' prove that Jesus will return?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 21, "start": 5127, "end": 5441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Which Quranic verses count against Jesus returning?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 22, "start": 5441, "end": 5756, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Does the Quran say Jesus died, and how did the Prophet understand the verse 'when you took me'?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 23, "start": 5756, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say the Bukhari chain for Jesus's descent is unreliable?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 24, "start": 6314, "end": 6630, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What problems does Mufti Abu Layth find in the Sahih Muslim chains for Jesus's return?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 25, "start": 6630, "end": 7022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Who are the problematic narrators in the Sahih Muslim reports on Jesus's return?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 26, "start": 7022, "end": 7335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is there a single hadith on Jesus's return with an unproblematic chain?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 27, "start": 7335, "end": 7644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Is the hadith of Aisha about Jesus and the Dajjal reliable?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 28, "start": 7644, "end": 7882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth say about the Ibn Mas'ud hadith on the end of time and Jesus's return?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 29, "start": 7882, "end": 8038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Who was the blind narrator of the return hadith who relied on his slave girl?"}, {"video": "TR3NSX3UFy8", "n": 30, "start": 8038, "end": 8266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210314", "title": "Can the hadith on Jesus's return be questioned, and how many of them depend on Abu Hurayra?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 1, "start": 30, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Opening: sound check, technical trouble and the children say hello"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 2, "start": 296, "end": 490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Opening poetry: a clip from a female poet, and Eid greetings"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 3, "start": 490, "end": 855, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "A vegan qurbani joke, and one sacrifice for a whole village"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 4, "start": 855, "end": 990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Preview of the night: the masala segment, a Peshawar killing and a Netflix show"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 5, "start": 990, "end": 1206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Is it haram to sit at a table where people are drinking alcohol?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 6, "start": 1206, "end": 1604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Will there be a video on the Zaydi and Ibadi sects?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 7, "start": 1604, "end": 2192, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Chat replies, Urdu couplets from an anthology and a backlog of Eid messages"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 8, "start": 2192, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Was Aisha a feminist?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 9, "start": 2479, "end": 2755, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Mocking a reported fatwa permitting a kiss without lust, and chat banter"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 10, "start": 2755, "end": 2865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Is it okay to celebrate the Mawlid?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 11, "start": 2865, "end": 3101, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Back at the gym, Quran preservation, a Salafi joke and a clip"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 12, "start": 3101, "end": 3858, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Should I give up my career plans to study full time at a madrasa?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 13, "start": 3858, "end": 4254, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Can I learn Islam properly on my own alongside a degree?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 14, "start": 4254, "end": 4482, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "A dream of Ibn Abd al-Barr dressed like a professor"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 15, "start": 4482, "end": 5015, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "How common is sexual abuse in madrasas?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 16, "start": 5015, "end": 5069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Will there be a discussion with someone from Hizb ut-Tahrir?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 17, "start": 5069, "end": 5248, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Is hijama (cupping) a sunnah I should practise?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 18, "start": 5248, "end": 5419, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "A Birmingham mosque, meeting Mufti, and the new Patreon"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 19, "start": 5419, "end": 5593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Don't madrasas expel students for sexual abuse?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 20, "start": 5593, "end": 5783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "A viral picture of 'Aisha's sewing machine'"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 21, "start": 5783, "end": 6469, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "The Peshawar courtroom killing of an Ahmadi accused of blasphemy"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 22, "start": 6469, "end": 6905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Does Abu Bakr's war on Musaylima justify killing someone who claims prophethood?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 23, "start": 6905, "end": 7205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Is it haram to show the Prophet in a movie?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 24, "start": 7205, "end": 7365, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of a young Leicester mufti?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 25, "start": 7365, "end": 7980, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Why did Imam Malik prefer the practice of Medina over hadith chains?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 26, "start": 7980, "end": 8369, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "How did hadith scholars know narrators who died a century earlier were reliable?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 27, "start": 8369, "end": 8598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of preachers linked to extremism?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 28, "start": 8598, "end": 8794, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Do the Hanafis allow beer?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 29, "start": 8794, "end": 9503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Masala segment: mockery over who leaked Yasir Qadhi's 2016 emails"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 30, "start": 9503, "end": 9617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Is it haram to shake hands with women?"}, {"video": "TR4-gh0qEZ4", "n": 31, "start": 9617, "end": 9784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200804", "title": "Sign-off: subscribe, Patreon and plans for the week"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Does the Quran actually tell women to cover their hair, or only their chest?"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 2, "start": 550, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Is it a sin for a Muslim woman not to cover her hair?"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 1022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Can a husband or father force a woman to wear hijab?"}, {"video": "TRR4o2JZIZc", "n": 4, "start": 1022, "end": 1123, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Is Islam supposed to feel like a burden?"}, {"video": "TgaNlc0x_iI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Shaykh Dedew?"}, {"video": "TincZqdQpgs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 334, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191219", "title": "Why are Indo-Pak Muslims adopting Gulf Arab culture?"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322", "title": "What is fiqh, and is it the same as Shari'ah?"}, {"video": "UiXtl3PQP-Q", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190322", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth follow the Maliki school rather than the Hanafi?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "What does reason mean in religion, and what does the Quran say about it?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 560, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Why do Muslims need reason if they already have the Quran and Sunnah?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 3, "start": 560, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "How do Muslims know Islam is true and other religions are not?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 4, "start": 954, "end": 1421, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Is blind faith (taqlid) in creed acceptable in Islam?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 5, "start": 1421, "end": 1725, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Why are so many Muslims and scholars opposed to using reason in religion?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 6, "start": 1725, "end": 2193, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "How do we know the Quran is the word of God, if not by reason?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 7, "start": 2193, "end": 2507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Does Islam stand the test of reason, and why should Muslims not fear examining it?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 8, "start": 2507, "end": 2739, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Was Zakir Naik right to dismiss evolution as 'just a theory'?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 9, "start": 2739, "end": 2973, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Does the Quran have to mention something for it to be true?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 10, "start": 2973, "end": 3368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Why did Muslims become hostile to reason?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 11, "start": 3368, "end": 3524, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "How did the Golden Age backlash and the clergy contribute to Muslim hostility to reason?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 12, "start": 3524, "end": 3680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Will using reason make me lose my faith?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 13, "start": 3680, "end": 3916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Does Ali's saying about wiping the socks prove that religion is not based on reason?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 14, "start": 3916, "end": 4152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Do miracles in the Quran break the laws of nature?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 15, "start": 4152, "end": 4464, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "When should a hadith be rejected, and can a Muslim refuse a religious command that makes no sense?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 16, "start": 4464, "end": 4622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "If reason judges religion, whose reason counts, and what about rituals?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 17, "start": 4622, "end": 4779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Did a tree really cry for the Prophet, and why does Mufti Abu Layth reject the hadith?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 18, "start": 4779, "end": 5016, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "If Mufti Abu Layth admires Qadi Iyad, must he accept everything in al-Shifa?"}, {"video": "UuLDZkLvxvo", "n": 19, "start": 5016, "end": 5167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Should loyalty to Sahih al-Bukhari outweigh how a report presents the Prophet?"}, {"video": "VRYy1_gzEUs", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210316", "title": "Who are the Ibadis and what do you think of Ibadism?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Why was Mufti Abu Layth sent to prison?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 2, "start": 168, "end": 323, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "What was Mufti Abu Layth's time in prison like?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 3, "start": 323, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Should Muslims engage with the Prevent programme?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 4, "start": 480, "end": 1029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "What did Mufti Abu Layth actually do as a Prevent mentor?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 5, "start": 1029, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Is working with the government or Prevent a form of serving false gods?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 6, "start": 1266, "end": 1579, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Did Mufti Abu Layth call a Birmingham school the Trojan Horse school?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 7, "start": 1579, "end": 1656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Why did some Islamophobic journalists defend Mufti Abu Layth?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 8, "start": 1656, "end": 1890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of ISIS?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 9, "start": 1890, "end": 2125, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Should Muslims deny that jihad exists in Islam to counter extremism?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 10, "start": 2125, "end": 2361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Is extremism among Muslims really on the rise?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 11, "start": 2361, "end": 2672, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Is Mufti Abu Layth a modernist?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 12, "start": 2672, "end": 2830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "Why is Islamophobia rising?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 13, "start": 2830, "end": 2986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "How should Muslims respond to Islamophobia?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 14, "start": 2986, "end": 3304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "What is Mufti Abu Layth currently teaching?"}, {"video": "VZRrlX3lIVk", "n": 15, "start": 3304, "end": 3453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150406", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth plan to do next?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Who was Imam Malik and where did he come from?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 2, "start": 336, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Can a pregnancy last for years, as was said of Imam Malik's birth?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Is it haram for men to wear earrings?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 4, "start": 1060, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "How did Imam Malik come to study religion?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 5, "start": 1332, "end": 1407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "What did Imam Malik's teachers teach him about hadith and Sunnah?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 6, "start": 1407, "end": 1561, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Was Imam Malik an ascetic?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 7, "start": 1561, "end": 1862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Is the Muwatta of Imam Malik more authentic than Sahih al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 8, "start": 1862, "end": 2244, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Why did Imam Malik sometimes reject authentic hadith?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 9, "start": 2244, "end": 2545, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "What is the difference between a hadith and the Sunnah in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 10, "start": 2545, "end": 2804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Is studying religious knowledge better than voluntary prayer?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 11, "start": 2804, "end": 2998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Why did Imam Malik never leave Madinah?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 12, "start": 2998, "end": 3447, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Why was Imam Malik flogged?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 13, "start": 3447, "end": 3737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Can we ever be completely certain about religious answers?"}, {"video": "VhqVM47pNS0", "n": 14, "start": 3737, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230310", "title": "Who carried on Imam Malik's teaching after him?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Does Islam punish someone for leaving the faith?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 2, "start": 316, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Does the sanctity of life in Islam rule out killing apostates?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 3, "start": 472, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Why did some classical scholars rule that apostates be executed?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 4, "start": 709, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Did the Prophet ever execute anyone for leaving Islam?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 5, "start": 942, "end": 1408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Were apostates punished for disbelief or for fighting against Muslims?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 6, "start": 1408, "end": 1566, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Which hadith are used to justify killing apostates, and were the scholars who used them right?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 7, "start": 1566, "end": 1722, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "What is the context of the hadith 'whoever changes his religion, kill him'?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 8, "start": 1722, "end": 2116, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Is Ikrima, the narrator of the apostasy hadith, reliable?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 9, "start": 2116, "end": 2354, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Is the chain of the apostasy hadith through Anas reliable?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 10, "start": 2354, "end": 2591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Are the Abu Hurayra and Hamza al-Aslami narrations on apostasy authentic?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 11, "start": 2591, "end": 2905, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Why would an apostate deserve death, and what about the three days to repent?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 12, "start": 2905, "end": 3222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "Can a life be taken on the basis of a doubtful hadith?"}, {"video": "VyAwDWTHPa4", "n": 13, "start": 3222, "end": 3617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180510", "title": "How should Muslims treat people who leave Islam?"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427", "title": "Does today's Hanafi madhhab reflect Imam Abu Hanifa?"}, {"video": "WCgxQDwCHKs", "n": 2, "start": 263, "end": 741, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210427", "title": "Can I pray while carrying my child?"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819", "title": "Introduction: the Quran-preservation debacle and a leaked 2016 email"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819", "title": "Who leaked the emails: the missing link revealed"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819", "title": "Ismail Patel's published exchange: the apology and the 'academic' consulted"}, {"video": "WDD_GyzI9Dg", "n": 4, "start": 526, "end": 713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819", "title": "What did the leak of Yasir Qadhi's emails on the Quran's preservation lead to?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "Is there such a thing as good bid'ah?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 2, "start": 118, "end": 386, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "What did Imam Malik say about bid'ah?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 3, "start": 386, "end": 771, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "Is making group dua after every salah a bid'ah?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 4, "start": 771, "end": 1427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "Is it a bid'ah to pray extra prayers on a fixed day every week?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 5, "start": 1427, "end": 1811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "Do Maliki scholars accept good bid'ah?"}, {"video": "WIrT3DXSvd8", "n": 6, "start": 1811, "end": 2069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150303", "title": "Should I avoid practices that people call good bid'ah?"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 338, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215", "title": "Why don't most scholars say what Mufti Abu Layth says?"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 2, "start": 338, "end": 916, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215", "title": "Why do so many maulanas think the way they do?"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 3, "start": 916, "end": 1070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215", "title": "Is it worth studying at a madrasa?"}, {"video": "Wl7wIKke16Q", "n": 4, "start": 1070, "end": 1111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180215", "title": "Does a mufti have to be appointed by the government?"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315", "title": "Is Mufti Abu Layth a Mu'tazili?"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 2, "start": 144, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315", "title": "What actually separates Sunnis and Shia, and is mut'ah really a Shia thing?"}, {"video": "WmzC28PLYSQ", "n": 3, "start": 418, "end": 845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210315", "title": "Does using reason in Islam make someone a Mu'tazili?"}, {"video": "WnchZwuZtf4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 358, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190917", "title": "Is it a sin to pee standing up?"}, {"video": "WoYX5hIFSVg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 498, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201001", "title": "Are tattoos haram, and can I work as a tattoo artist?"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 233, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811", "title": "Did the Prophet Nuh really live for 950 years?"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 2, "start": 233, "end": 549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811", "title": "Why do ancient texts say people lived for hundreds or thousands of years?"}, {"video": "Wpqa8rxaI-U", "n": 3, "start": 549, "end": 737, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180811", "title": "Why does the Quran call the ruler in Yusuf's story a king but Musa's a Pharaoh?"}, {"video": "X27ZZBCSEyg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200609", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Hasan Farhan al-Maliki?"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Backdrop to BukhariGate: a widespread debate, his training, and transparency"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "The first problem: Bukhari's semi-divine status above the Quran in practice"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 3, "start": 710, "end": 1103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "The third problem: can Bukhari be traced to its author? The bullet points"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 4, "start": 1103, "end": 1682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Problematic reports in Bukhari: the Isra, Moses and the rock, magic on the Prophet"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 5, "start": 1682, "end": 1923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Solomon's ninety women, the rich held back from paradise, Fatima angry with Abu Bakr"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 6, "start": 1923, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Nonsensical Arabic in hadith 5492: the alcohol slaughtered by fish and sun"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "The marriage to Aisha at six: consent, and the command to pray at seven"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "More troubling reports: Umar's stoning verse, the adulterous monkeys, women in hellfire"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 9, "start": 2871, "end": 3509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Imam Bukhari's own practice: transmission by meaning, hidden names, a Khariji narrator"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 10, "start": 3509, "end": 3746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Bukhari's persecution and why his book reaches us through one transmitter"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 11, "start": 3746, "end": 4218, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Bukhari in his own chain, and the other students whose copies did not reach us"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 12, "start": 4218, "end": 4611, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Ibn Hajar and Ibn Rushayd on the transmissions: Farabri alone, found copies not taught"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 13, "start": 4611, "end": 5163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Who vouched for Farabri? Baji, Sam'ani and whether transmission implies reliability"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 14, "start": 5163, "end": 5564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Farabri's incomplete copy, the differing student copies and the manuscript patchwork"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 15, "start": 5564, "end": 6037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Summing up: judge Bukhari like any other book; the deen comes through living practice"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 16, "start": 6037, "end": 6514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Replies to critics: Jonathan Brown, academic dialogue, going public, the Aisha debate"}, {"video": "X6SfFYRljeY", "n": 17, "start": 6514, "end": 6546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180830", "title": "Sign-off and where to follow the page"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 480, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did Ibn Ashur say Muslims must believe Jesus was raised alive?"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 2, "start": 480, "end": 800, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did Ibn Ashur believe Jesus died?"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 3, "start": 800, "end": 1270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did Ibn Ashur say nothing in the Quran goes against the second coming of Jesus?"}, {"video": "XttbK-raL6A", "n": 4, "start": 1270, "end": 1383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did Shadee Elmasry mistranslate Ibn Ashur on purpose?"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801", "title": "Introducing the controversy over a famous Instagram 'couple goals' pair"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 2, "start": 266, "end": 645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801", "title": "Why is it harmful when religious influencers present a fake perfect life?"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 3, "start": 645, "end": 988, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801", "title": "Is it wrong to judge someone who has become an atheist or left Islam?"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 4, "start": 988, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801", "title": "Is it right to condemn people for being in a polygamous marriage?"}, {"video": "YPFQpHdSbGg", "n": 5, "start": 1517, "end": 1884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190801", "title": "Do you need to appear perfectly pious to be a good Muslim?"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 410, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213", "title": "Is the evil eye real in Islam?"}, {"video": "Yd3ehW0VTls", "n": 2, "start": 410, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180213", "title": "Did someone really do magic on the Prophet?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why did a medical doctor choose to study religion at Harvard?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 2, "start": 217, "end": 404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Is it better to study Islam at a madrasa or at a Western university?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 3, "start": 404, "end": 605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Should I go to Madinah University or a madrasa to study Islam?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 4, "start": 605, "end": 930, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Are madrasas failing their students?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 5, "start": 930, "end": 1168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why don't madrasas teach the Islamic philosophers and the Mu'tazila?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 6, "start": 1168, "end": 1359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Does traditional orthodoxy lead to extremism?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 7, "start": 1359, "end": 1782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "If blind following in faith is forbidden, why must I accept a school's creed without question?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 8, "start": 1782, "end": 2038, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Isn't reason subjective, and is something good only because God commands it?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 9, "start": 2038, "end": 2387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Where does morality come from if not from God?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 10, "start": 2387, "end": 2597, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Is morality an instinct God put in us?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 11, "start": 2597, "end": 2861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "If morality is universal, why was slavery accepted for so long?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 12, "start": 2861, "end": 2992, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Does God's morality change over time?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 13, "start": 2992, "end": 3238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Do animals have morality, and does that mean morality just evolved?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 14, "start": 3238, "end": 3504, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "If we all recognise harm, why do people still do terrible things?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 15, "start": 3504, "end": 3743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "How should the stories in the Quran be read?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 16, "start": 3743, "end": 4161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Are the stories in the Quran meant to be literal history?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 17, "start": 4161, "end": 4387, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Can I accept evolution and still take the Quran's stories as true?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 18, "start": 4387, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Does the Quran speak in symbols and metaphors?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 19, "start": 4555, "end": 4823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Are paradise and hell in the Quran meant literally?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 20, "start": 4823, "end": 5092, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why does the Quran tell the same story in different ways?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 21, "start": 5092, "end": 5429, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Did Jesus really speak in the cradle, and did the earlier prophets exist?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 22, "start": 5429, "end": 5696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Did the Prophet Muhammad perform miracles?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 23, "start": 5696, "end": 5942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Did angels really fight at the battle of Badr?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 24, "start": 5942, "end": 6145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Who were the riders seen at Badr?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 25, "start": 6145, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Should archaeology worry believers about the Quran's stories?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 26, "start": 6337, "end": 6765, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Is the story of Adam in the Quran a myth?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 27, "start": 6765, "end": 6972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Does the Quran treat every human life as sacred, even in war?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 28, "start": 6972, "end": 7315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Does the Quran actually say the miracles happened?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 29, "start": 7315, "end": 7610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Who was Dhul Qarnayn, and who are Gog and Magog?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 30, "start": 7610, "end": 7884, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Is the Dhul Qarnayn story based on the legend of Alexander?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 31, "start": 7884, "end": 8224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why does the Quran tell the story of Dhul Qarnayn so briefly?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 32, "start": 8224, "end": 8743, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "What do the unusual words in the Dhul Qarnayn verses mean?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 33, "start": 8743, "end": 9188, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why does the Quran give so little detail about some prophets?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 34, "start": 9188, "end": 9664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Why does the guest criticise Yasir Qadhi's views on jinn and evolution?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 35, "start": 9664, "end": 10070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Are the jinn real, or a symbol?"}, {"video": "ZAsz48lX_WI", "n": 36, "start": 10070, "end": 10444, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201211", "title": "Closing: the guest's projects, his statement of faith, and a safe space for views"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "Introduction: reflections on Shaykh Hassan Ali's video, and respect for him"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "Is the second coming of Jesus proven by the Quran or by the fact that most Muslims believe it?"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "Does it matter that the second coming of Jesus is the majority opinion and Mufti Abu Layth's view a minority one?"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 4, "start": 626, "end": 1097, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "Why do almost all the hadith about Jesus returning come through Abu Hurayra?"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 5, "start": 1097, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "On what principles can a hadith in Bukhari be rejected, and may ordinary Muslims do so?"}, {"video": "ZMSmkLdEgSo", "n": 6, "start": 1332, "end": 1644, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180401", "title": "If I doubt one hadith in Bukhari, will I end up doubting the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906", "title": "Should scholars give fatwas based on minority opinions if it makes life easier?"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 2, "start": 327, "end": 487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906", "title": "Is it wrong to choose the easier opinion in Islam?"}, {"video": "ZOo6W9bfn7I", "n": 3, "start": 487, "end": 748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170906", "title": "Is choosing the easier scholarly opinion just following my desires?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 1, "start": 35, "end": 268, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Opening: introducing Edip Yuksel, who refuses titles and insists all are equal"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 2, "start": 268, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "The guest's background: languages, translations, books, Beltways and a constitution for Turkey"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 3, "start": 777, "end": 1289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Why did Edip Yuksel write a reformist translation of the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 4, "start": 1289, "end": 1679, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Was the hadith literature a conspiracy against the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 5, "start": 1679, "end": 1913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the guest think every hadith is fabricated?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 6, "start": 1913, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Were the Prophet's judgements meant to bind Muslims after his death?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Can Muslims do ijtihad from the Quran alone?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 8, "start": 2460, "end": 2937, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Are any hadith genuine, and what about reports confirmed by history?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 9, "start": 2937, "end": 3170, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Can hadith be sifted with criteria, or must the whole corpus be rejected?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 10, "start": 3170, "end": 3567, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does any hadith actually explain the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 11, "start": 3567, "end": 4119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the Quran abrogate its own verses?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 12, "start": 4119, "end": 4748, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the Quran ban slavery, and what does 'what your right hand possesses' mean?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 13, "start": 4748, "end": 5219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "If the Quran abolished slavery, why is there no explicit verse saying so?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 14, "start": 5219, "end": 5613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "What is the miracle of the number 19 in the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 15, "start": 5613, "end": 5924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "What numerical patterns does the guest find in the Quran's word counts?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 16, "start": 5924, "end": 6314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "How does the guest's number 19 differ from Bible numerics, and how does he read 74:29-31?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 17, "start": 6314, "end": 6777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Could the number 19 patterns in the Quran be a coincidence or a human habit?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 18, "start": 6777, "end": 7012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Did Rashad Khalifa claim to be a messenger of God?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 19, "start": 7012, "end": 7324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Why was Rashad Khalifa assassinated?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 20, "start": 7324, "end": 7483, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Did the number 19 appear in the guest's life before he discovered it in the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 21, "start": 7483, "end": 7952, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the Quran allow a husband to hit his wife?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 22, "start": 7952, "end": 8190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "How does the guest translate the verses on cutting off the thief's hand, jizya and polygamy?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 23, "start": 8190, "end": 8270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does khatam al-nabiyyin mean the last prophet or the best prophet?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 24, "start": 8270, "end": 8430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Is seeing the number 19 everywhere a sign or a superstition?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 25, "start": 8430, "end": 8509, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "What is Mufti Abu Layth's own position on hadith compared with the Quran-only view?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 26, "start": 8509, "end": 8664, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the number 19 structure work in all the readings of the Quran?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 27, "start": 8664, "end": 8816, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does the Quran say the Israelites were slaves in Egypt?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 28, "start": 8816, "end": 8974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "What does Edip Yuksel think of Sam Gerrans?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 29, "start": 8974, "end": 9131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Is al-kitab the same book given to every prophet?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 30, "start": 9131, "end": 9366, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "If you reject all hadith, how do you know how to pray?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 31, "start": 9366, "end": 9526, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Why were the Israelites told to sacrifice a heifer, and what does it teach about religious detail?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 32, "start": 9526, "end": 9760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "What does the word salat mean in the Quran according to the Quran-only view?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 33, "start": 9760, "end": 9914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Does prayer have to be physical, or is remembering God enough?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 34, "start": 9914, "end": 10150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Closing: how to reach the guest, conferences, peace with Sunnis and Shias, and parliamentary speeches"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 35, "start": 10150, "end": 10385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Should social media companies be allowed to censor people as the new public square?"}, {"video": "ZmIrskjob4o", "n": 36, "start": 10385, "end": 10856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200626", "title": "Is consciousness in the brain, or is the brain a receiver for the soul?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Is zina today the same issue it was in the past?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 2, "start": 310, "end": 625, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Why is it so hard for young Muslims to marry, and what are they supposed to do about desire?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 3, "start": 625, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Does an exclusive boyfriend-girlfriend relationship count as a nikah?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 4, "start": 782, "end": 1090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Should I register my nikah as a civil marriage?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 5, "start": 1090, "end": 1326, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "What should a couple agree before marriage about registering and money?"}, {"video": "Zs1rLN2Djss", "n": 6, "start": 1326, "end": 1440, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Rapid-round replies: steroids, state control and prenuptial agreements"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 191, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216", "title": "Was Islam spread by the sword?"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 2, "start": 191, "end": 495, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216", "title": "Why did people in the past convert to new religions so readily?"}, {"video": "_dSMPIAR0BM", "n": 3, "start": 495, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191216", "title": "If Islam was not forced on people, why did so many convert?"}, {"video": "_lwqZ9dM5Zs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 122, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211120", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Quran-only Muslims?"}, {"video": "a-CIW2-K4Y0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180526", "title": "Is it possible for Prophet Yunus to have survived inside a whale?"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 314, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812", "title": "What is the hadith about Abu Hurayra, the thief and Ayat al-Kursi?"}, {"video": "a3i0x1A5CFw", "n": 2, "start": 314, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180812", "title": "Did Abu Hurayra learn to recite Ayat al-Kursi at bedtime from a devil?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 1, "start": 39, "end": 593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Opening: sound checks, chat greetings and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 2, "start": 593, "end": 1023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "The week's chatter: a podcast plug, Kanye West for president and a viral video"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 3, "start": 1023, "end": 1431, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is wearing my hijab turban-style allowed?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 4, "start": 1431, "end": 1850, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What do you think of the Wayfair trafficking rumours and Epstein?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 5, "start": 1850, "end": 2002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What do you think of Shah Wali Allah?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 6, "start": 2002, "end": 2304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What parts of the body count as 'awrah for men and women?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 7, "start": 2304, "end": 2456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What do Illiyyin and Sijjin mean in the Quran?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 8, "start": 2456, "end": 2569, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Did the Prophet Muhammad ever kill anyone himself?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 9, "start": 2569, "end": 2721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What do you think of the scholars on Mohammed Hijab's podcast?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 10, "start": 2721, "end": 2985, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is al-Zamakhshari's tafsir al-Kashshaf worth reading?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 11, "start": 2985, "end": 3139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What was al-Ash'ari's argument against the Mu'tazila about God always doing what is best?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 12, "start": 3139, "end": 3284, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Was Aisha really 48 when she married the Prophet?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 13, "start": 3284, "end": 3543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Where did the idea that Aisha was six or nine come from?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 14, "start": 3543, "end": 3661, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Does 'leave what makes you doubt' mean I should always follow the strictest opinion?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 15, "start": 3661, "end": 3814, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "How do I make sense of the hadith that the Prophet banned mut'ah?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 16, "start": 3814, "end": 3998, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Was Aisha Abu Bakr's sister rather than his daughter?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 17, "start": 3998, "end": 4409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Why does the Quran talk about something as small as the Prophet's dinner guests?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 18, "start": 4409, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What happened with the Hagia Sophia?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 19, "start": 4636, "end": 4945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Does Islam allow turning churches into mosques?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 20, "start": 4945, "end": 5100, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Was it haram for the Ottomans to turn the Hagia Sophia into a mosque?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 21, "start": 5100, "end": 5253, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is it wrong to turn the Hagia Sophia back into a mosque?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 22, "start": 5253, "end": 5406, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Were the Ottomans representatives of Islam?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 23, "start": 5406, "end": 5599, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Does Istanbul need the Hagia Sophia as a mosque?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 24, "start": 5599, "end": 5829, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "If Turkey can reconvert the Hagia Sophia, can Israel or India reconvert mosques too?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 25, "start": 5829, "end": 6022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Can a mosque that was once a waqf never be anything else?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 26, "start": 6022, "end": 6289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Should Pakistan allow a Hindu temple in Islamabad?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 27, "start": 6289, "end": 6363, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Why follow hadith if the Quran is complete?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 28, "start": 6363, "end": 6439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is the hadith about conquering Constantinople authentic?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 29, "start": 6439, "end": 6478, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Are there Sharia courts in the UK?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 30, "start": 6478, "end": 6634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Isn't the Prophet clearing the Kaaba of idols a precedent for the Hagia Sophia?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 31, "start": 6634, "end": 6750, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Can I wear perfume that contains alcohol?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 32, "start": 6750, "end": 6896, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is it halal to eat crocodile?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 33, "start": 6896, "end": 7118, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Is it haram to eat dog meat?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 34, "start": 7118, "end": 7301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "An Urdu poem by Ahmad Faraz: the enemy of my life was once dearer than life"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 35, "start": 7301, "end": 7680, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Arabic poetry: Antara ibn Shaddad's love for Abla"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 36, "start": 7680, "end": 7828, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Was Sudan right to drop its alcohol and apostasy laws and end flogging?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 37, "start": 7828, "end": 7970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Does Islam want me to sacrifice sleep?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 38, "start": 7970, "end": 8272, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "What are the allegations against the Quran reciter on Twitter?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 39, "start": 8272, "end": 8455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Should Muslims expose the private lives of religious figures?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 40, "start": 8455, "end": 8835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "How do some imams use religion to exploit young women?"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 41, "start": 8835, "end": 9154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "A viral clip of a preacher who rarely leaves home because of women"}, {"video": "a6H5lYE4MN8", "n": 42, "start": 9154, "end": 9278, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200714", "title": "Sign-off: subscribe, daily videos and next week's mind traps"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 115, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029", "title": "How should Muslims respond to cartoons of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 2, "start": 115, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029", "title": "Does Islam justify killing someone for showing cartoons of the Prophet?"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 3, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029", "title": "Was it right for the French government to display the cartoons?"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 4, "start": 546, "end": 818, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029", "title": "Do I have to boycott French products?"}, {"video": "aNLFdEEOH5Y", "n": 5, "start": 818, "end": 915, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201029", "title": "Light-hearted replies to viewers about what to boycott"}, {"video": "awbO9rHPvpU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20150320", "title": "Do I have to wear my trousers above my ankles?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 1, "start": 21, "end": 776, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Opening: tonight's plan, the Disclosure series, a Twitter storm and a song"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 2, "start": 776, "end": 922, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is Cardano going to shoot up in value?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 3, "start": 922, "end": 1309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Was Ali born inside the Kaaba?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 4, "start": 1309, "end": 1466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Do I have to believe Umar and Uthman were better than Ali?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 5, "start": 1466, "end": 1689, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Without colonialism and the Mongols, would the Muslim world have had its own enlightenment?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 6, "start": 1689, "end": 2234, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Does Ibn Hazm contradict himself in The Ring of the Dove?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 7, "start": 2234, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Was the Prophet Moses actually the pharaoh Akhenaten?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 8, "start": 2383, "end": 2612, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Do Muslims whitewash their own historical heroes?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 9, "start": 2612, "end": 2801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Can the revelation of the Quran be explained without the supernatural?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 10, "start": 2801, "end": 3337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is the great love Muslims have for the Prophet a kind of prophet worship?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 11, "start": 3337, "end": 3598, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Has Islam become a religion about Muhammad rather than the religion he brought?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 12, "start": 3598, "end": 3831, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Why did Abdullah ibn Abi Sarh leave Islam for a time?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 13, "start": 3831, "end": 3989, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Qadhi's post on the 'drama of refutations', and tonight's reply"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 14, "start": 3989, "end": 4436, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Which Quranic verses does Yasir Qadhi say point to Jesus coming back?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 15, "start": 4436, "end": 4780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Are the hadith about Jesus's return mutawatir, as Yasir Qadhi claims?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 16, "start": 4780, "end": 5168, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Was Muhammad Abduh the first Muslim to deny the return of Jesus?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 17, "start": 5168, "end": 5355, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Do people who deny Jesus's return reject the unseen?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 18, "start": 5355, "end": 5627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is distinguishing the Sunnah from hadith a modernist invention?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 19, "start": 5627, "end": 5790, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "What does Yasir Qadhi say about the return of Jesus coming from Jewish and Christian sources?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 20, "start": 5790, "end": 5946, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "How does Yasir Qadhi answer the objection that Jesus killing pigs makes no sense?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 21, "start": 5946, "end": 6126, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Was Yasir Qadhi's lecture on Jesus's return really academic?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 22, "start": 6126, "end": 6396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is Yasir Qadhi giving the whole picture on the Maliki scholars and Jesus's return?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 23, "start": 6396, "end": 6626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Do Muslim beliefs about the Mahdi, Jesus and Gog and Magog mirror Jewish messianic texts?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 24, "start": 6626, "end": 6809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Did Yasir Qadhi himself say a hadith came into Islam from Jewish lore?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 25, "start": 6809, "end": 7056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "What is Yasir Qadhi's zombie theory of Gog and Magog?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 26, "start": 7056, "end": 7309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Has Yasir Qadhi been consistent about whether Gog and Magog could be hidden underground?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 27, "start": 7309, "end": 7505, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Has Yasir Qadhi said that the views of great scholars should not bind a researcher?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 28, "start": 7505, "end": 7754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Does the majority of scholars holding a view make it right?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 29, "start": 7754, "end": 7972, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Can positions in aqidah fall within a range of scholarly opinion?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 30, "start": 7972, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is there really scholarly consensus that Jesus will return?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8596, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is separating hadith from the Sunnah a Hanafi and Maliki principle?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 32, "start": 8596, "end": 8889, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Does the verse about Jesus speaking 'in maturity' mean he will come back?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 33, "start": 8889, "end": 9239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Which verses of the Quran count against Jesus coming back?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 34, "start": 9239, "end": 9535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Does the Quran say that Jesus died?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 35, "start": 9535, "end": 10108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is the hadith in Bukhari about Jesus coming down reliable?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 36, "start": 10108, "end": 10450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "What is wrong with the other Bukhari and Muslim chains on Jesus's return?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 37, "start": 10450, "end": 10824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Are the Sahih Muslim reports about Jesus's return reliable?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 38, "start": 10824, "end": 11173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is there a single hadith on Jesus's return with a flawless chain?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 39, "start": 11173, "end": 11442, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is the hadith of Aisha about Jesus and the Dajjal reliable?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 40, "start": 11442, "end": 11687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "What does the Ibn Mas'ud hadith about the end of time say, and is it reliable?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 41, "start": 11687, "end": 11869, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Who was the blind narrator of the return hadith who relied on his slave girl?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 42, "start": 11869, "end": 12090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Can the hadith about Jesus's return be questioned?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 43, "start": 12090, "end": 12450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is the hadith about a woman breastfeeding the adult Salim authentic?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 44, "start": 12450, "end": 12830, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Is Mohammed Hijab breaking away from the Salafis?"}, {"video": "b1OOltqtPTw", "n": 45, "start": 12830, "end": 12910, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210302", "title": "Sign-off: a recap of the night"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Is there a hadith that says a woman who wears perfume outside is a zaniya?"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 2, "start": 159, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Is the hadith about women wearing perfume being zaniya authentic?"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Would the Prophet really call a woman wearing perfume a fornicator?"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 4, "start": 1187, "end": 1420, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Doesn't the hadith of Zaynab forbid women from wearing perfume to the mosque?"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 5, "start": 1420, "end": 1575, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Is a woman's prayer rejected if she wears perfume to the mosque?"}, {"video": "bO72u9ThuK8", "n": 6, "start": 1575, "end": 1683, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180504", "title": "Can women wear perfume when they go out?"}, {"video": "bU0XXOk5oIU", "n": 1, "start": 20, "end": 296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517", "title": "Should I pray 8 or 20 rak'ahs of tarawih?"}, {"video": "bY3zp-4lYFI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012", "title": "Is the preacher Muhammad ibn Munir actually a qualified mufti?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 309, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "I converted to Islam but my husband didn't. Do I have to leave him?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 2, "start": 309, "end": 537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "What does the word nikah actually mean?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 3, "start": 537, "end": 925, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Do converts have to redo their marriage after becoming Muslim?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 4, "start": 925, "end": 1224, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Did Islam invent marriage?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 5, "start": 1224, "end": 1637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Which verses forbid or allow marrying non-Muslims?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 6, "start": 1637, "end": 1983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Did any early scholars allow marrying Zoroastrians or idol worshippers?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 7, "start": 1983, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Does Quran 60:10 mean a marriage to a non-Muslim is automatically void?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 8, "start": 2219, "end": 2448, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "As a convert, should I try to convert my spouse or family?"}, {"video": "c8fjy8MceZM", "n": 9, "start": 2448, "end": 2841, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190510", "title": "Is a marriage between a Muslim and a non-Muslim valid?"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 150, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "Should Muslims build bridges with ex-Muslims?"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 2, "start": 150, "end": 417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "How old was Aisha when she married the Prophet?"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 3, "start": 417, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "Are the hadith about Aisha's young age authentic?"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 4, "start": 787, "end": 982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "Islamic institutes, preachers' depth of learning, and passionate converts"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 5, "start": 982, "end": 1160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "Converts who start teaching at once, with lines of Urdu poetry"}, {"video": "c9vke9Rpq9o", "n": 6, "start": 1160, "end": 1455, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190919", "title": "How should Muslims respond to ex-Muslims who hate God?"}, {"video": "cAjsGNs9EiY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200828", "title": "Does Edip Yuksel believe in praying five times a day?"}, {"video": "cHVPqWZ6BeE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 60, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240228", "title": "A fate worse than death: each of us is a mirror for divine potential"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130", "title": "Was Aisha really nine, as Yaqeen Institute concluded?"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 627, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130", "title": "Why was a marriage suggested to the Prophet after the year of sorrow?"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 3, "start": 627, "end": 943, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130", "title": "What evidence suggests Aisha was older than nine when she married?"}, {"video": "cHyxRI7Trnk", "n": 4, "start": 943, "end": 1219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181130", "title": "Why do some scholars still insist Aisha was nine?"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 329, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114", "title": "What did the Green Lane Masjid khutbah say about Mufti Abu Layth?"}, {"video": "cKWRLHtBYgo", "n": 2, "start": 329, "end": 617, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180114", "title": "Can the detailed aqidah taught today be proven from the Quran and Sunnah alone?"}, {"video": "cV8ZMcMyPk0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 166, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201117", "title": "Would the Mufti debate a Salafi scholar on aqidah?"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025", "title": "Why does the Quran call Jesus the Word of God and mention the Holy Spirit with him?"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025", "title": "Does the Quran actually say Mary had a virgin birth?"}, {"video": "cVGwFnbQv0Q", "n": 3, "start": 703, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181025", "title": "What verses do Muslims use to argue Jesus had a natural birth with a father?"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 241, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412", "title": "Can I trim my beard short or to a goatee, below a fist's length?"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 2, "start": 241, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412", "title": "Which scholars have allowed trimming or shaving the beard?"}, {"video": "d95_pYj6NiA", "n": 3, "start": 556, "end": 798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412", "title": "What do the sound hadith about the beard actually say?"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Backdrop: trolling by Ahmadis and the video that prompted the reply"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 2, "start": 393, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Who Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was and the claim that God spoke to him in Punjabi"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 3, "start": 872, "end": 1266, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's developing claims: reformer, messiah, prophet, Krishna"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 4, "start": 1266, "end": 1663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Early denials, the second coming, revelations in English and claims of divinity"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 5, "start": 1663, "end": 2137, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's unfulfilled prophecies, the mubahala oaths and his death"}, {"video": "dECxAg9D9g8", "n": 6, "start": 2137, "end": 2453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190115", "title": "Final thoughts: mental health, persecution, free speech and the victim card"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "The story of Musa and the servant of Allah in Surah al-Kahf and al-Bukhari"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 2, "start": 331, "end": 682, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Did the journey of Musa and Khidr really happen, or was it a vision?"}, {"video": "dROSEctL_tQ", "n": 3, "start": 682, "end": 1000, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Why did Khidr kill the boy in Surah al-Kahf?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Did the Prophet take Safiyya the night her husband was killed, as the Tommy Robinson clip claims?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 546, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Who was Safiyya and why did the Muslims march on Khaybar?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 3, "start": 546, "end": 697, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "What is the common story about how the Prophet married Safiyya?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 4, "start": 697, "end": 1169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Why do the hadith about Safiyya's marriage contradict each other?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 5, "start": 1169, "end": 1484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Could the Prophet have married Safiyya right after Khaybar?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 6, "start": 1484, "end": 1641, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Why was Safiyya bruised when she came to the Prophet after Khaybar?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 7, "start": 1641, "end": 1797, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Why did Safiyya ride with the Prophet on the way back from Khaybar?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 8, "start": 1797, "end": 1955, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "Where did Safiyya live when she first came to Madinah?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 9, "start": 1955, "end": 2113, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "When and how did Safiyya actually marry the Prophet?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 10, "start": 2113, "end": 2425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "How should Muslims judge hadith that say the Prophet took Safiyya on the night of Khaybar?"}, {"video": "dpeR6Y4MGwA", "n": 11, "start": 2425, "end": 2734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180221", "title": "If the Safiyya story is in Sahih al-Bukhari, why question it?"}, {"video": "e6jWtFf8smw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 589, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181206", "title": "Does the Quran support human evolution?"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802", "title": "Why does Islam forbid homosexual activity?"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802", "title": "How did classical scholars treat intersex people (khuntha) and their right to marry?"}, {"video": "eJS0IBhhPg0", "n": 3, "start": 702, "end": 1044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190802", "title": "What did Ibn al-Arabi write about a classmate who was both bearded and breasted?"}, {"video": "eR1bDjDv0l0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 280, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200629", "title": "Is alcohol under forty percent permissible, as a Pakistani mufti reportedly said?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 1, "start": 10, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Opening: sound check, Covid recovery, a spoof of the lockdown announcement"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 2, "start": 502, "end": 615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "If I sleep late and wake up at asr, can I pray the missed prayers together then?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 3, "start": 615, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Dr Abdul Majid's response to BukhariGate, and an invitation to Mind Trap"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 974, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is the great reset or a depopulation plot real?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 5, "start": 974, "end": 1041, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Banter: what he is drinking, and a shout-out"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 6, "start": 1041, "end": 1222, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Which hadith book is the most authentic?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 7, "start": 1222, "end": 1468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Can we call coronavirus the UK virus?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 8, "start": 1468, "end": 1860, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is it haram for a mother to kiss her child on the lips?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 9, "start": 1860, "end": 2182, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "How do I deal with toxic people and negativity around me?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 10, "start": 2182, "end": 2404, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Can I take a mortgage, and can I urinate standing up?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 11, "start": 2404, "end": 2911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Do I lose good deeds if I keep a dog as a pet?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 12, "start": 2911, "end": 3269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Was the woman who refused the Prophet in Bukhari's divorce chapter his wife?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 13, "start": 3269, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "How can we stop Salafi ideas from dominating how people see Islam?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 14, "start": 3654, "end": 4031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Dawah Man on pigs, wife-sharing and handshakes, played and mocked"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 15, "start": 4031, "end": 4458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Who was Lilith in Jewish legend?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 16, "start": 4458, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is the story of Lilith in the Bible?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 17, "start": 4593, "end": 5056, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Do you believe in miracles?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 18, "start": 5056, "end": 5398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is the Quran a miracle that proves Islam to everyone?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 19, "start": 5398, "end": 5580, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "If miracles don't break nature's laws, what is the point of miracles?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 20, "start": 5580, "end": 5751, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Will Hamza Tzortzis or Nouman Ali Khan come on Mind Trap?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 21, "start": 5751, "end": 6275, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "How can I make the new year a more positive one?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 22, "start": 6275, "end": 6333, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "As an actor, are there scenes that would be haram for me to perform?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 23, "start": 6333, "end": 6648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is it haram to celebrate my birthday?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 24, "start": 6648, "end": 6706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Will Lupe Fiasco come on Mind Trap?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 25, "start": 6706, "end": 7028, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Can a Christian really speak with God?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 26, "start": 7028, "end": 7512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "What does rightly guided caliph mean, and did Muawiya see Ali as one?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 27, "start": 7512, "end": 8001, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Did early Muslims really not count Ali as the fourth rightly guided caliph?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 28, "start": 8001, "end": 8081, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Was Christianity still a true religion until Muhammad's first revelation?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 29, "start": 8081, "end": 8227, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Do Shia scholars treat ordinary people better than Salafi scholars do?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 30, "start": 8227, "end": 8293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "What miracle do you have as a saint?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 31, "start": 8293, "end": 8502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "A preacher's video on masturbation: would you do it in front of your parents?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 32, "start": 8502, "end": 8950, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is anal intercourse with my wife haram?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 33, "start": 8950, "end": 9507, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Why is Yasir Qadhi saying the Prophet was infatuated with Zaynab?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 34, "start": 9507, "end": 9927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Did the Prophet fall in love with Zaynab bint Jahsh?"}, {"video": "eo90sV4JVHo", "n": 35, "start": 9927, "end": 10032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Closing: subscribe, a DNA result next week, Patreon sessions"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 1, "start": 22, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Opening: greetings and the night's agenda"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 2, "start": 427, "end": 663, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "A clip on parent titles for LGBTQIA+ families, and gender-neutral language"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 3, "start": 663, "end": 981, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Was Covid-19 made in a lab?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 4, "start": 981, "end": 1138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Perfumes, quick chat replies and gym injuries"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 5, "start": 1138, "end": 1294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Did Covid-19 come from the Wuhan lab?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 6, "start": 1294, "end": 1845, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Why does the Quran seem focused on men, and why are two women witnesses needed?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 7, "start": 1845, "end": 2160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Will the Mufti open an academy to train muftis?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 8, "start": 2160, "end": 2395, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "At what age should children start learning about Islam, and what should they learn?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 9, "start": 2395, "end": 2472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Can I do tayammum instead of wudu if water makes my cough worse?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 10, "start": 2472, "end": 2711, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "If the Prophet couldn't forbid what Allah allowed, how can scholars issue fatwas?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 11, "start": 2711, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Is Prophet Shu'ayb the same as Jethro in the Bible?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 12, "start": 2788, "end": 3021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "If a lot of anything can intoxicate, does that make tiny amounts of alcohol haram?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 13, "start": 3021, "end": 3179, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Can a woman be an imam and lead the prayer?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 14, "start": 3179, "end": 3417, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Do creation myths in other cultures share a source with the Islamic account?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 15, "start": 3417, "end": 3970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Can a woman become a mufti?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 16, "start": 3970, "end": 4525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "How should I deal with the misogynistic things some scholars wrote about women?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 17, "start": 4525, "end": 4605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Pir Naseeruddin Naseer?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 18, "start": 4605, "end": 4919, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Did the debate with Dr Abdullah Abdul Majid answer the BukhariGate challenge?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 19, "start": 4919, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "How did the BukhariGate discussion go on manuscripts and problematic hadith?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 20, "start": 5548, "end": 5865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Is Mufti Abu Layth against Imam Bukhari?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 21, "start": 5865, "end": 6257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "An invitation to Sunni Defence, bad blood with Farid, and interrupting in debates"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 22, "start": 6257, "end": 6337, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Quick chat: Mufti Abu Layth's height and diet"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 23, "start": 6337, "end": 6746, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "The snowman fatwas: building a snowman as an idol, or permitted by the dolls hadith"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 24, "start": 6746, "end": 6982, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Would the Mufti make peace with Farid?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 25, "start": 6982, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "If a hadith is also in other books besides Bukhari, does that confirm it?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 26, "start": 7453, "end": 7923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "How could hadith chains and texts have been standardised over time?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 27, "start": 7923, "end": 8551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Could the hadith tradition evolve like a living organism?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 28, "start": 8551, "end": 8708, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Should we throw away hadith altogether?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 29, "start": 8708, "end": 8865, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Quick chat: LSD, paratha and nihari, and jinn as microbes"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 30, "start": 8865, "end": 9022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Quick chat: Mufti Abu Layth's taste in music"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 31, "start": 9022, "end": 9653, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Was docetism about someone else being crucified in Jesus's place?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 32, "start": 9653, "end": 10046, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Dr Umar Faruq Abdullah?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 33, "start": 10046, "end": 10205, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Did Jesus really speak as a newborn baby in the Quran?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 34, "start": 10205, "end": 10760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "How could Abu Hurayra narrate 5,000 hadith after only two years with the Prophet?"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 35, "start": 10760, "end": 11153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Dawah Man on intimacy positions, citing Ibn al-Qayyim, played and mocked"}, {"video": "eoKcNwGGIBA", "n": 36, "start": 11153, "end": 11345, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210126", "title": "Sign-off: subscribers, Patreon, Discord and next MindTrap"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 1, "start": 18, "end": 176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Opening: audio check and introducing Dr Shehzad Saleem"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 2, "start": 176, "end": 632, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "How did Dr Shehzad Saleem come to research the history of the Quran?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 3, "start": 632, "end": 1025, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Is the Quran preserved exactly as it was revealed?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 4, "start": 1025, "end": 1260, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "How was the Quran preserved: by memory or in writing?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 5, "start": 1260, "end": 1497, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Did the Prophet leave a written Quran, and what did the caliphs really do?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 6, "start": 1497, "end": 1734, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Where do the variant readings of the Quran come from?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 7, "start": 1734, "end": 2207, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "How did the earlier recitation and other readings get mixed up with the Quran?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 8, "start": 2207, "end": 2519, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Is the hadith that the Quran was revealed in seven ahruf authentic, and what does it mean?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 9, "start": 2519, "end": 2835, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Why did Muslim scholars record disagreements about the Quran's text rather than hide them?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 10, "start": 2835, "end": 3149, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "What was the qira'a al-'amma, and why does Morocco recite a different reading?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 11, "start": 3149, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "How did the seven canonical readings of the Quran come about?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3778, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Why did the reading of Hafs from Asim become the standard Quran?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 13, "start": 3778, "end": 4169, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "If Quraysh did not pronounce the hamza, why does the Hafs reading of the Quran?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 14, "start": 4169, "end": 4559, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Do the early manuscripts with different words undermine the preservation of the Quran?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 15, "start": 4559, "end": 4871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Isn't it too convenient that the one preserved reading is exactly the Hafs Quran we have?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 16, "start": 4871, "end": 5080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Where does the claim that the Quran is preserved to the very dot come from?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 17, "start": 5080, "end": 5237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Is the guest's approach to the Quran's history just confirmation bias?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 18, "start": 5237, "end": 5471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "If Allah promised to preserve the Quran, why are there variant readings at all?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 19, "start": 5471, "end": 5785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Was there ever a verse of stoning in the Quran, and does stoning still apply?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 20, "start": 5785, "end": 5851, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Does a reciter's chain of teachers back to the Prophet prove the Quran's text?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 21, "start": 5851, "end": 6088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Was Ibn Mas'ud's Quran different from the Quran we have?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 22, "start": 6088, "end": 6167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Did the variant readings of the Quran come from missing dots and vowel marks?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 23, "start": 6167, "end": 6403, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "In what sense is the Quran a miracle?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 24, "start": 6403, "end": 6696, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Which reading of the Quran reached India, Malaysia and Indonesia, and why?"}, {"video": "f2BcGWatU5g", "n": 25, "start": 6696, "end": 7226, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200619", "title": "Closing: thanks, where to find the book, the guest's contact details and his final message on critical thinking"}, {"video": "f4R0NXnYmpc", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 913, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180710", "title": "Is it haram for men to wear gold or silk?"}, {"video": "foIzotT_sog", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 85, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200823", "title": "Why do Salafis ignore Imam Malik's Muwatta?"}, {"video": "g57BdMdAUKM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 209, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab?"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917", "title": "Was the Prophet Muhammad poisoned, and did he die from it?"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 2, "start": 206, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917", "title": "Is the chain of the hadith that the Prophet died of poison reliable?"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 3, "start": 409, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917", "title": "How can the same poison kill one companion at once and the Prophet three years later?"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 4, "start": 631, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917", "title": "Does the hadith that the Prophet died of poison contradict the Quran?"}, {"video": "gCid83kRA2I", "n": 5, "start": 767, "end": 1131, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180917", "title": "Why should Muslims reject the hadith that the Prophet died of poison?"}, {"video": "gV69XFzFuEk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 618, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190304", "title": "Is my prayer valid if I pray in a bikini or swimwear?"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 462, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231", "title": "Did angels really fight at the Battle of Badr?"}, {"video": "gXBZY_ph7Bg", "n": 2, "start": 462, "end": 906, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191231", "title": "Were the angels at Badr actually Persian knights?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Who won the David Wood versus Mohammed Hijab debate on Tawhid and the Trinity?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 2, "start": 158, "end": 315, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Did the topic of Tawhid versus the Trinity favour the Muslim side, and how well prepared was Hijab?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 3, "start": 315, "end": 551, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "What was Hijab's main argument against the Trinity, and did Wood answer it?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 4, "start": 551, "end": 676, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "What does it mean that Allah performs salah upon the Prophet?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 5, "start": 676, "end": 914, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Do Muslims accept doctrines as irrational as the Trinity, such as the uncreated Quran?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 6, "start": 914, "end": 1058, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "If Muslims accept miracles that defy reason, can they still object that the Trinity is irrational?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 7, "start": 1058, "end": 1282, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Did the Prophet teach a creed about God's attributes, and when did the Muslim creed emerge?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 8, "start": 1282, "end": 1673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "Was Hijab right to show David Wood no respect in the debate?"}, {"video": "gyRfZZZcA8g", "n": 9, "start": 1673, "end": 1900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181224", "title": "What should Muslims learn from the Wood versus Hijab debate?"}, {"video": "gzKvxYPY-GI", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220416", "title": "Am I only praying because I fear God will punish me?"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 391, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Is the niqab required, and is it right to make women take it off?"}, {"video": "hE3WjiQoxAA", "n": 2, "start": 391, "end": 631, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210105", "title": "Why do some women feel they must wear the niqab?"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929", "title": "Mufti Tariq Masood's remark on scribal errors, and Islam as a deen of mercy"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 2, "start": 312, "end": 586, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929", "title": "Is someone who says something wrong about the Prophet guilty of blasphemy?"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 3, "start": 586, "end": 891, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929", "title": "How scholars' rhetoric fed Pakistan's blasphemy killings, in Mufti Abu Layth's view"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 4, "start": 891, "end": 1258, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929", "title": "Why is lanasfa'an in Quran 96:15 written with an alif, and is it a mistake?"}, {"video": "hMUrvU2c9YQ", "n": 5, "start": 1258, "end": 1348, "tier": "machine", "date": "20240929", "title": "Spread love, and take account of the damage our words have done"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 1, "start": 40, "end": 196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Opening: welcoming Shaykh Kashif Khan from Australia and an audio check"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 2, "start": 196, "end": 508, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Where did Shaykh Kashif Khan study, and what is the difference between Salafi and Ahl al-Hadith?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 3, "start": 508, "end": 1059, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "How did Shaykh Kashif Khan become religious, and does he regret his zealous phase?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 4, "start": 1059, "end": 1212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Why did clerics in Pakistan insist on reopening mosques during the coronavirus lockdown?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 5, "start": 1212, "end": 1517, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Do religious scholars lose their independence when they depend on donations?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 6, "start": 1517, "end": 1754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is it haram for medical students to dissect dead bodies?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 7, "start": 1754, "end": 2145, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Can women be stopped from going to the mosque because of fitnah?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 8, "start": 2145, "end": 2541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is a woman on her period ritually impure?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 9, "start": 2541, "end": 2849, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "How clearly was zakah defined in the Prophet's lifetime?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 10, "start": 2849, "end": 3316, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Were the people who refused zakah after the Prophet's death apostates?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 11, "start": 3316, "end": 3864, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is it haram for a husband to drink his wife's breast milk?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 12, "start": 3864, "end": 4021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Do some muftis use lenient rulings for themselves but give strict ones to others?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 13, "start": 4021, "end": 4411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Can a past relationship or an accidental touch make my spouse haram for me?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 14, "start": 4411, "end": 4757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does a triple talaq count as one divorce or three?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 15, "start": 4757, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Why do people react so strongly when a scholar challenges established views?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 16, "start": 4990, "end": 5303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is a marriage between a Muslim and a non-Muslim valid?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 17, "start": 5303, "end": 5543, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is looking at an image of a naked person the same as looking at a real one in Islamic law?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 18, "start": 5543, "end": 6019, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does lowering the gaze apply to images and screens?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 19, "start": 6019, "end": 6256, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Do non-Muslim women in a Muslim country have to cover up?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 20, "start": 6256, "end": 6470, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "If pornography is not called haram, does that mean it is encouraged?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 21, "start": 6470, "end": 6698, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is masturbation haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 22, "start": 6698, "end": 7014, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Did classical scholars permit masturbation, and for women too?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 23, "start": 7014, "end": 7325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is pornography today like the concubines of the past?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 24, "start": 7325, "end": 7699, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Doesn't the Islamic teaching on modesty make pornography haram?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 25, "start": 7699, "end": 8007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does masturbation or other sexual activity break the fast?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 26, "start": 8007, "end": 8468, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Why do people get so upset about Islamic rulings on sex?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 27, "start": 8468, "end": 8620, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Is oral sex between spouses haram because the private parts are impure?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 28, "start": 8620, "end": 8934, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Why talk publicly about permissive opinions if it might encourage people?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 29, "start": 8934, "end": 9217, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Did Abu Hanifa hold that there is no hadd punishment for sodomy?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 30, "start": 9217, "end": 9360, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Isn't it better to feel guilty when sinning so that you repent?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 31, "start": 9360, "end": 9674, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does Islam teach us to feel guilty?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 32, "start": 9674, "end": 9911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does making people feel guilty about pornography make things worse?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 33, "start": 9911, "end": 10443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Does watching porn fuel sex trafficking?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 34, "start": 10443, "end": 10911, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "How should someone approach studying Islam with an open mind?"}, {"video": "hOusirOkBVU", "n": 35, "start": 10911, "end": 11032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200419", "title": "Sign-off: thanks, more sessions to come, and how to reach the guest"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Is the face part of a woman's 'awrah in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 2, "start": 390, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Must a young woman cover her face because of fitnah?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 3, "start": 691, "end": 1190, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Did Imam Malik allow a woman to show her face to her husband's friends?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 4, "start": 1190, "end": 1346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Is Imam Malik's own fatwa the Maliki madhhab?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 5, "start": 1346, "end": 1658, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Can a woman go out of the house without a need?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 6, "start": 1658, "end": 2300, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "Is it haram for a woman to go out for a walk?"}, {"video": "hcscudhD8bU", "n": 7, "start": 2300, "end": 2383, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140509", "title": "A last point on praying behind an imam, and farewell"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025", "title": "Will Allah judge someone who follows only the Quran by the Quran alone?"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 2, "start": 270, "end": 427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025", "title": "Did Muslims learn how to pray from hadith books?"}, {"video": "ht0qJv5Om9o", "n": 3, "start": 427, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211025", "title": "Should I debate Quranists?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 156, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Reaction to being called a probable kafir by Shadee Elmasry and others"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 2, "start": 156, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Is someone who denies a line of al-Tahawi's creed a kafir?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 3, "start": 313, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Does the verse about Jesus speaking as a kahl prove he will return?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 4, "start": 471, "end": 626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Does 'before his death' in Quran 4:159 refer to the return of Jesus?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 5, "start": 626, "end": 782, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Does Quran 43:61 say Jesus is the sign of the hour?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 6, "start": 782, "end": 942, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "Why would Jesus need to come back at all?"}, {"video": "iCr0sV2UrcU", "n": 7, "start": 942, "end": 1069, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180315", "title": "What are the main problems with the hadith about Jesus returning?"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909", "title": "Are Muslims obliged to establish an Islamic state or khilafah?"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 2, "start": 130, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909", "title": "Did the Prophet migrate to Madinah to set up a state, and when did the khilafah end?"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 529, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909", "title": "Why is the call to restore the khilafah dangerous for young Muslims?"}, {"video": "iJ2ml87pTrs", "n": 4, "start": 529, "end": 749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170909", "title": "If Muslims want a khilafah, why not first establish Islam in the countries they already have?"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 305, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117", "title": "Reaction to Daniel Haqiqatjou's post about Mufti Menk writing 'Almighty' instead of 'Allah'"}, {"video": "iQVd5_ag6DE", "n": 2, "start": 305, "end": 449, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200117", "title": "Is it a Sunnah for women to pray in a wardrobe or the innermost room?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "What is the Sunni view of Karbala?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 2, "start": 110, "end": 385, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Who were the Shia who invited Husayn to Kufa?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 3, "start": 385, "end": 640, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Where did the rivalry between Banu Umayya and Banu Hashim come from?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 4, "start": 640, "end": 900, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "How was Abu Bakr chosen as leader after the Prophet died?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 5, "start": 900, "end": 1293, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did Uthman appoint his relatives as governors?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 6, "start": 1293, "end": 1458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did the Muslims fight each other at Siffin?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 7, "start": 1458, "end": 1660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did Hasan ibn Ali give up the caliphate to Muawiya?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 8, "start": 1660, "end": 1783, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Was Muawiya a good ruler?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 9, "start": 1783, "end": 1924, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did Muawiya make Yazid his heir?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 10, "start": 1924, "end": 2111, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth admire Muawiya?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 11, "start": 2111, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "What kind of ruler was Yazid?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 12, "start": 2451, "end": 2710, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did Husayn go to Kufa when he was warned not to?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 13, "start": 2710, "end": 3020, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Why did the army at Karbala not let Husayn go back?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 14, "start": 3020, "end": 3295, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Are the stories that Husayn's family was denied water at Karbala true?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 15, "start": 3295, "end": 3411, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Should Muslims mourn Husayn every year on Ashura?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 16, "start": 3411, "end": 3600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Was Yazid a kafir, and is it right to curse him?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 17, "start": 3600, "end": 3713, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Who was really responsible for the killing of Husayn at Karbala?"}, {"video": "iaBL5ViS3Rg", "n": 18, "start": 3713, "end": 3843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201016", "title": "Is it right to curse the companions or beat oneself in mourning for Husayn?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 1, "start": 23, "end": 742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Opening: travel declarations, the 200th session and plans for the channel"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 2, "start": 742, "end": 995, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Tonight's plan: the raven of Cain and Abel, and Reddit versus Wall Street"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 3, "start": 995, "end": 1171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Can men wear gold?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 4, "start": 1171, "end": 1573, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did the early Muslims respect the Torah and Bible, and are they corrupted?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 5, "start": 1573, "end": 1894, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Are near-death experiences real or just chemicals in the brain?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 6, "start": 1894, "end": 2265, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Is rejecting embarrassing hadith about the Prophet just whitewashing history?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 7, "start": 2265, "end": 2842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Umayyad, Abbasid and Zubayrid politics behind the recording of history"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 8, "start": 2842, "end": 2949, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Why not invite your critics to give their side of Islamic history?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 9, "start": 2949, "end": 3320, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Is it haram to have an anal swab test for COVID?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 10, "start": 3320, "end": 3802, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "A modern Arabic love poem: choosing honour over a friend's wife"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 11, "start": 3802, "end": 4037, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "What do you think of Abdur Rahman Mangera?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 12, "start": 4037, "end": 4637, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Damascus, 1998: the two people who inspired Mufti Abu Layth to memorise the Quran"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 13, "start": 4637, "end": 4804, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "What do you think of Imam al-Shatibi?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 14, "start": 4804, "end": 5381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "If the hijab has become sexualised, should scholars still push it?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 15, "start": 5381, "end": 5461, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Does being fair to two wives mean treating them exactly the same?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 16, "start": 5461, "end": 5548, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Is the hadith that nobody will believe in Allah at the end of time authentic?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 17, "start": 5548, "end": 6501, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Kidnapped in Cairo: Mufti Abu Layth and the Egyptian police"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 18, "start": 6501, "end": 7024, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "What does the raven in the story of Cain and Abel mean?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 19, "start": 7024, "end": 7808, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Did Cain invent burial after watching the raven?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 20, "start": 7808, "end": 8098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Clip: a raven mimicking human speech"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 21, "start": 8098, "end": 8890, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "What happened with GameStop, Reddit and Wall Street?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 22, "start": 8890, "end": 9393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Is trading stocks, crypto or on margin halal?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 23, "start": 9393, "end": 9928, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Chat interlude: short sellers buying back, new moderators and Shaykh Atabek on Mind Trap"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 24, "start": 9928, "end": 10109, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Why names intrigue Mufti Abu Layth: a name that sounds rude in Urdu"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 25, "start": 10109, "end": 10229, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "How can God be timeless and still perceive time?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 26, "start": 10229, "end": 11043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Is jinn possession real?"}, {"video": "ijwBevcC6o8", "n": 27, "start": 11043, "end": 11201, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210202", "title": "Sign-off: Mind Trap or meetup this week, and thanks to patrons"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Mohammed Hijab's liberalism lecture argues like a sectarian polemic"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 2, "start": 384, "end": 763, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "What is liberalism, and do liberals have to follow John Locke?"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 3, "start": 763, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Should Muslims campaign against LGBTQ people, and is homosexuality unnatural?"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 4, "start": 1142, "end": 1486, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Can people be moral without religion?"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 5, "start": 1486, "end": 1792, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Ethics evolve: slavery, human agency and the genetic fallacy"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 6, "start": 1792, "end": 2237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Is capital punishment, including for apostasy, justified?"}, {"video": "j6pXWGpnWd0", "n": 7, "start": 2237, "end": 2605, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "'Islam gave these rights first' and blinding people with jargon"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 1, "start": 29, "end": 531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Opening: sound check, a UK curfew and tonight's plan"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 2, "start": 531, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Mir Taqi Mir's death anniversary: Mufti Abu Layth reads his Urdu poetry"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 3, "start": 1494, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Forms of intoxication, and a word on the latest Mind Trap"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 4, "start": 1678, "end": 1874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Was Adam's garden of Eden on earth?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 5, "start": 1874, "end": 2290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Do brain chemicals shape my personality?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 6, "start": 2290, "end": 2441, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Can we appreciate good in paradise if there is no evil there?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 7, "start": 2441, "end": 2634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Doesn't the Quran say Adam was created in heaven?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 8, "start": 2634, "end": 2673, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Can I take back a promise I made to Allah?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 9, "start": 2673, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Do women have to cover their wrists and ankles in prayer?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 10, "start": 3167, "end": 3476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "How do I stop being obsessive and fearful about prayer?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 11, "start": 3476, "end": 3898, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Are there enemies of Islam today?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 12, "start": 3898, "end": 4477, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Can a Muslim woman marry a non-Muslim man?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 13, "start": 4477, "end": 4636, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Is it right to build very elaborate mosques?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 14, "start": 4636, "end": 4705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Did Patricia Crone accept that the Prophet Muhammad existed?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 15, "start": 4705, "end": 5090, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Who were the Murji'a and why do Salafis talk about them so much?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 16, "start": 5090, "end": 5817, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "What does Robert Hoyland's In God's Path say about how Islam spread?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 17, "start": 5817, "end": 6158, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Are Sharia rules brand new, or based on what people already did?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 18, "start": 6158, "end": 7075, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Is drawing lots or playing the lottery haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 19, "start": 7075, "end": 7510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "A Hanbali opinion on women's sexual desire, and Dawah Man quoting Ibn al-Qayyim"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 20, "start": 7510, "end": 7616, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Is buying a scratch card or lottery ticket haram?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 21, "start": 7616, "end": 8023, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "What do you think of the Mu'tazila?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 22, "start": 8023, "end": 8510, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Is a skin fade haircut haram?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 23, "start": 8510, "end": 8706, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth rates Dawah Man's video marketing"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 24, "start": 8706, "end": 8821, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Clip: a Dawah Man and Daniel Haqiqatjou interview that calls Omar Suleiman a fasiq"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 25, "start": 8821, "end": 9231, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "What is the Pagan-gate row about Omar Suleiman?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 26, "start": 9231, "end": 9541, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Clip: Daniel Haqiqatjou's video on the libation ritual"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 27, "start": 9541, "end": 10144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Did the scholars now attacking Daniel Haqiqatjou once promote him?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 28, "start": 10144, "end": 10613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Is it haram to take part in another religion's rituals, like eating prasad at a gurdwara?"}, {"video": "jTYEM-eEe78", "n": 29, "start": 10613, "end": 10754, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200922", "title": "Closing: Hamza Tzortzis on Mind Trap, the September meet-up and sign-off"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Can a woman travel without a mahram?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 2, "start": 571, "end": 723, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Can a woman go on Hajj without a mahram?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 3, "start": 723, "end": 945, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Must a kidnapped woman have a mahram to escape?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 4, "start": 945, "end": 1178, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Is it haram for a woman to travel more than 48 miles alone?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 5, "start": 1178, "end": 1381, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "What do Saudi scholars say about women travelling without a mahram?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 6, "start": 1381, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Why did the Prophet say women should not travel without a mahram?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 7, "start": 1648, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Did the Prophet foresee women travelling alone safely?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 8, "start": 1839, "end": 2107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "What did the Maliki scholars say about women travelling with a safe group?"}, {"video": "jp8GjvVONMs", "n": 9, "start": 2107, "end": 2294, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180422", "title": "Is it safe and allowed for a woman to fly alone?"}, {"video": "k9V9aM16G1k", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 159, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190804", "title": "Is music haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "kDSBNnTRJKo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 303, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180702", "title": "Are the descriptions of paradise in the Quran meant literally?"}, {"video": "kkjqsRxJ3KM", "n": 1, "start": 4, "end": 772, "tier": "machine", "date": "20140412", "title": "Is it haram to trim my beard shorter than a fist's length?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 1, "start": 15, "end": 460, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Opening: sound check, a lockdown haircut and a news story"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 2, "start": 460, "end": 1202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Perfume reviews, a joke question and the Dogecoin rally"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 3, "start": 1202, "end": 1430, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "A sung Andalusian Arabic poem shared from YouTube"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 4, "start": 1430, "end": 1799, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What counts as khamr, and is a drink with a little alcohol haram?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 5, "start": 1799, "end": 2063, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is pork the only meat that is haram in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 6, "start": 2063, "end": 2824, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Was al-Ghazali against science and philosophy?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 7, "start": 2824, "end": 2977, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Were some of the great imams autistic?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 8, "start": 2977, "end": 3198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Yasir Qadhi's mugs and Bollywood lines: do his critics watch him?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 9, "start": 3198, "end": 3390, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Losing muscle in lockdown and a members' Discord server"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 10, "start": 3390, "end": 3467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is it haram to watch Netflix?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 11, "start": 3467, "end": 3654, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Can al-Firabri, the transmitter of Sahih al-Bukhari, be trusted?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 12, "start": 3654, "end": 4029, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is the Quran's verse about the stupor of death talking about DMT?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 13, "start": 4029, "end": 4212, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What qualifications does Mufti Abu Layth have?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 14, "start": 4212, "end": 4361, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Did the companions really see the angel Jibril as a man?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 15, "start": 4361, "end": 4939, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Debate invitations to Abdul Rahman Hassan and 'Danny boy'"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 16, "start": 4939, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Should I use water or toilet paper after going to the toilet?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 17, "start": 5270, "end": 5346, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is it haram to use a sensory deprivation tank or meditation to hallucinate?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 18, "start": 5346, "end": 5719, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What is Birmingham really like for Muslims?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 19, "start": 5719, "end": 5886, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Why does Birmingham have so many different Muslim sects?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 20, "start": 5886, "end": 6080, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What accent does Mufti Abu Layth have?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 21, "start": 6080, "end": 6226, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Chat banter about embarrassing names"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 22, "start": 6226, "end": 6878, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is it wrong in Islam to want to be rich?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 23, "start": 6878, "end": 6956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is trading covered calls on stocks halal?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 24, "start": 6956, "end": 7452, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Why is Pakistan so full of religious extremism?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 25, "start": 7452, "end": 7532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Why does every spiritual awakening story have a time of withdrawal?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 26, "start": 7532, "end": 7839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What was Mufti Abu Layth's madrasa in Pakistan like?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 27, "start": 7839, "end": 8062, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is it haram to hit someone in the face in boxing or MMA training?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 28, "start": 8062, "end": 8107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Are the Prophet's parents in heaven or hell?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 29, "start": 8107, "end": 8456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What happened between Mufti Abu Layth and a Moroccan shaykh?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 30, "start": 8456, "end": 9238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Who is right in India's farmers' protests?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 31, "start": 9238, "end": 9932, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "What does Islam say about the red pill movement?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 32, "start": 9932, "end": 10088, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is Mufti Abu Layth a feminist?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 33, "start": 10088, "end": 10791, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Clips: three critics' videos attacking Shabir Ally"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 34, "start": 10791, "end": 11151, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Why do critics keep attacking Shabir Ally?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 35, "start": 11151, "end": 11777, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Did Maliki scholars really allow fines instead of hudud punishments?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 36, "start": 11777, "end": 12163, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Is it haram to flip a coin to make a decision?"}, {"video": "l4n4wD2jjps", "n": 37, "start": 12163, "end": 12427, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210209", "title": "Closing: the members' Discord, a tractor story and sign-off"}, {"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814", "title": "Does Islam allow gender transition for someone diagnosed with gender dysphoria?"}, {"video": "llllbKdGrA4", "n": 2, "start": 311, "end": 703, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190814", "title": "Supporting women's rights while rejecting hostility to masculinity"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Shaykh Muhammad al-Yaqoubi?"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 471, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406", "title": "What was in the letter attacking Shaykh al-Yaqoubi, and who sent it?"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 3, "start": 471, "end": 691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406", "title": "The letter's attack on Shaykh Akram Nadwi, and a played debate clip: 'one, two, three, kufr'"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 4, "start": 691, "end": 927, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say both the attackers and the admirers of Shaykh al-Yaqoubi need balance?"}, {"video": "mLNpcjXYpqM", "n": 5, "start": 927, "end": 1012, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200406", "title": "Why is demanding that a scholar make takfir a form of bullying?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 535, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Should scholars publicly condemn a scholar said to have joined in a libation ritual?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 2, "start": 535, "end": 880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Should Muslims tell gay people what the Quran says about homosexuality?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 3, "start": 880, "end": 1223, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Did some Muslim scholars say homosexuality is not haram?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 4, "start": 1223, "end": 1490, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Is there an LGBTQ push in media and schools?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 5, "start": 1490, "end": 1721, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Will gay people around us make Muslims gay?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 6, "start": 1721, "end": 2108, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Is it okay for adults or children to change gender?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 7, "start": 2108, "end": 2262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Should Sunnis preach to Shia Muslims about what they get wrong?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 8, "start": 2262, "end": 2407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "Is it my duty as a Muslim to preach to others?"}, {"video": "mOfS_0uGn4E", "n": 9, "start": 2407, "end": 2562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230222", "title": "What should Muslims focus on in confusing times?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 161, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "A clip of Shaykh Hassan Ali on the evil eye from loved ones"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 2, "start": 161, "end": 564, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Does the Quran mention the evil eye?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 3, "start": 564, "end": 1064, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "If the evil eye is real, why doesn't the Quran mention it?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 4, "start": 1064, "end": 1712, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Why did so many cultures believe in the evil eye?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 5, "start": 1712, "end": 2466, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Is the evil eye based on science?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 6, "start": 2466, "end": 2668, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Confirmation bias: reading the evil eye into the Quran"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 7, "start": 2668, "end": 3367, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Does Surah Yusuf prove the evil eye is real?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 8, "start": 3367, "end": 4098, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Are the hadith about the evil eye authentic?"}, {"video": "mnpGDvjs2nk", "n": 9, "start": 4098, "end": 4331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201115", "title": "Is Surat al-Falaq about protection from the evil eye?"}, {"video": "nZdIoI1JWwM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180423", "title": "Who is Mufti Abu Layth's message aimed at?"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 458, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928", "title": "If some hadith are unreliable, doesn't that make the Quran unreliable too?"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 2, "start": 458, "end": 767, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928", "title": "Why people fabricated hadith: good intentions, false memories, money and politics"}, {"video": "nndcs2uHoqE", "n": 3, "start": 767, "end": 1426, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190928", "title": "Why the Quran could not be corrupted like hadith, and the fashion for chains"}, {"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 152, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718", "title": "What is al-Suyuti's book about sex?"}, {"video": "noE0Z72gUbs", "n": 2, "start": 152, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190718", "title": "Banter with the chat after the al-Suyuti answer"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509", "title": "I'm a new Muslim and my faith has crashed after the first high. What should I do?"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 2, "start": 378, "end": 604, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509", "title": "Was the Prophet harsh with people?"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 3, "start": 604, "end": 789, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509", "title": "How did the Prophet balance gentleness and strength?"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 4, "start": 789, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509", "title": "Why do religious debates make people so defensive?"}, {"video": "oAG-F3hxCDY", "n": 5, "start": 1173, "end": 1373, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230509", "title": "How do I stop worrying about the ups and downs of my faith?"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 160, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Mohammed Hijab's aggressive debating style?"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 2, "start": 160, "end": 393, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212", "title": "Does the Quran forbid Muslims from being friends with non-Muslims who challenge Islam?"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 3, "start": 393, "end": 472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say Salafis cannot debate atheists without borrowing Ash'ari arguments?"}, {"video": "oXTsV9fn3zE", "n": 4, "start": 472, "end": 649, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212", "title": "Is al-wala wal-bara, loving and hating for the sake of Allah, part of Islam?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 194, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Opening: sound trouble and welcoming Lupe Fiasco to MindTrap"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 2, "start": 194, "end": 412, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What does Lupe Fiasco's name Wasalu mean, and how was he raised?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 3, "start": 412, "end": 875, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What was Lupe Fiasco's childhood like?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 4, "start": 875, "end": 1142, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "How did Lupe Fiasco go from science to rap?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 5, "start": 1142, "end": 1525, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Did Lupe Fiasco's way with words come naturally?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 6, "start": 1525, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Do we think in words or in images?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 7, "start": 1993, "end": 2187, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Is the soul the same thing as consciousness?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 8, "start": 2187, "end": 2537, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What does Lupe Fiasco think the soul is?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 9, "start": 2537, "end": 2615, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Is it normal for faith to keep changing over a lifetime?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 10, "start": 2615, "end": 3154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "How does the Chinese state deal with religion?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 11, "start": 3154, "end": 3465, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Why does China try to control who becomes the Dalai Lama?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 12, "start": 3465, "end": 3736, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Are psychedelics like mushrooms and DMT haram?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 13, "start": 3736, "end": 4204, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Can a Muslim work in the music industry and keep their faith?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 14, "start": 4204, "end": 4555, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Did everyone at the time of the Prophet accept Islam without questions?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 15, "start": 4555, "end": 5022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What inspired the story of Lupe Fiasco's album The Cool?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 16, "start": 5022, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Is humanity becoming more or less moral?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 17, "start": 5335, "end": 5795, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Do obscene or blasphemous thoughts during prayer ruin my salah?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 18, "start": 5795, "end": 6263, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Are young people today facing an existential crisis?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 19, "start": 6263, "end": 6531, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What is Lupe Fiasco's view of Kanye West's religious rebirth?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 20, "start": 6531, "end": 6688, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What inspired Lupe Fiasco's song Words I Never Said?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 21, "start": 6688, "end": 6801, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "What does Lupe Fiasco think of Killah Priest's song B.I.B.L.E.?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 22, "start": 6801, "end": 6880, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Did Lupe Fiasco know DMX?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 23, "start": 6880, "end": 7070, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "How did Lupe Fiasco discover Mufti Abu Layth?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 24, "start": 7070, "end": 7289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Is Lupe Fiasco retiring from music?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 25, "start": 7289, "end": 7484, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Is life just a dream in the mind of God?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 26, "start": 7484, "end": 7600, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "How is Lupe Fiasco finding Ramadan during Covid?"}, {"video": "oYiiPEhuiHA", "n": 27, "start": 7600, "end": 7881, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210426", "title": "Closing: thanks, the guest's message and sign-off"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Can men wear earrings in Islam?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 622, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Have men historically worn earrings, or is it a recent fashion?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 3, "start": 622, "end": 780, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Did men and boys wear earrings in the time of the Prophet and the early Muslims?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 4, "start": 780, "end": 1018, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Did Hasan and Husayn wear earrings?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 5, "start": 1018, "end": 1173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Did early Sunni hadith scholars such as Sufyan ibn Uyayna wear earrings?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 6, "start": 1173, "end": 1332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Did Imam Malik wear an earring?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 7, "start": 1332, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "What did Imam Malik and the Maliki jurists say about boys wearing earrings?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1882, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Is a man wearing an earring imitating women or harmful?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 9, "start": 1882, "end": 2198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Can reports from Shia sources about Hasan and Husayn be trusted?"}, {"video": "pkjtq8AXGRE", "n": 10, "start": 2198, "end": 2340, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190724", "title": "Is it haram for a man to wear an earring?"}, {"video": "psuMMzjvfRI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 141, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191010", "title": "Can I hug my female friends?"}, {"video": "pyI4TBAjCMI", "n": 1, "start": 3, "end": 290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200819", "title": "Can non-Muslims be saved according to Sunni scholars?"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702", "title": "Is it wrong for a hijabi YouTuber to take off her hijab?"}, {"video": "qdIQiwiz1mY", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 512, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200702", "title": "Why are people angry at a hijabi influencer who removed her hijab if it is her choice?"}, {"video": "r196CQ7qkaY", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 138, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210107", "title": "Do I have to go to jumu'ah every Friday if I live in a non-Muslim country?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Opening: welcoming Shaykh Atabek Shukurov and an audio check"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 377, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "What is Shaykh Atabek Shukurov working on, and why does he teach principles before rulings?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 3, "start": 377, "end": 786, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "How did Shaykh Atabek Shukurov become a scholar?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 4, "start": 786, "end": 1057, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "How do people react when a scholar from Uzbekistan challenges subcontinent scholars?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 5, "start": 1057, "end": 1402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Is growing a beard obligatory in the Hanafi school?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 6, "start": 1402, "end": 1873, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Is a mortgage riba?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 7, "start": 1873, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Isn't calling a mortgage agency just a loophole for interest?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2378, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "What happened when Shaykh Atabek wrote to Mufti Taqi Usmani about mortgages?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 9, "start": 2378, "end": 2809, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Could a senior scholar ever publicly change his fatwa on mortgages?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 10, "start": 2809, "end": 3040, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Why does Shaykh Atabek want to restore the early Hanafi school?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 11, "start": 3040, "end": 3279, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Was there a power struggle in the early Hanafi school?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 12, "start": 3279, "end": 3528, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Is the Musnad really Imam Ahmad's book, and is it authentic?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 13, "start": 3528, "end": 3986, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Why do Hanafis defend Sahih al-Bukhari when their school differs from it?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 14, "start": 3986, "end": 4264, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "What is wijada, and why does it matter for the hadith on killing apostates?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 15, "start": 4264, "end": 4379, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Did the early Hanafis hold that apostates should be killed?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 16, "start": 4379, "end": 4583, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Did Abu Hanifa allow drinks with a little alcohol?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 17, "start": 4583, "end": 4826, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Who was Abu Hanifa's most trusted student?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 18, "start": 4826, "end": 4990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Did Abu Hanifa really write al-Fiqh al-Akbar?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 19, "start": 4990, "end": 5065, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "The guest's laptop battery runs low; viewers' questions deferred"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 20, "start": 5065, "end": 5301, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "What does Shaykh Atabek think of his debate on the Isha time?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 21, "start": 5301, "end": 5549, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "When should I pray Isha in the UK summer when it never gets fully dark?"}, {"video": "rtwyWCa2-pQ", "n": 22, "start": 5549, "end": 5660, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210129", "title": "Closing: thanks, a promised follow-up and the guest's book on Hanafi principles"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 396, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "Who was Imam Abu Hanifa and where did he come from?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 2, "start": 396, "end": 785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "How did Abu Hanifa become a scholar after starting out as a merchant?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 3, "start": 785, "end": 1021, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "Why was Abu Hanifa criticised so much in his own time?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 4, "start": 1021, "end": 1336, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "Why did Abu Hanifa allow things like praying in Persian?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 5, "start": 1336, "end": 1492, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "Was Abu Hanifa involved in politics?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 6, "start": 1492, "end": 1728, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "How did the Hanafi school develop from Abu Hanifa's teaching?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 7, "start": 1728, "end": 1962, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "Did Abu Hanifa allow wudu with nabidh when there was no water?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 8, "start": 1962, "end": 2514, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "How did Abu Hanifa solve the case of two brides sent to the wrong grooms?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 9, "start": 2514, "end": 2749, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "How did Abu Hanifa die, and what was he known for among people?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 10, "start": 2749, "end": 3384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "What did Abu Hanifa do about his neighbour who drank and sang at night?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 11, "start": 3384, "end": 4095, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "What is the story of the woman who tricked Abu Hanifa into a marriage proposal?"}, {"video": "s-Vm6mgbLl8", "n": 12, "start": 4095, "end": 4242, "tier": "machine", "date": "20221210", "title": "What did Abu Hanifa say about Imam Malik?"}, {"video": "s9JKA9ZjI28", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 92, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201112", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth challenges Shadee Elmasry to debate Maliki fiqh"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 154, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Moving to Yasir Qadhi, by way of an Urdu couplet on Moses at Sinai"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 2, "start": 154, "end": 382, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Why is Mufti Abu Layth responding to Yasir Qadhi?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 3, "start": 382, "end": 720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "What are Ya'juj and Ma'juj (Gog and Magog), and could they be zombies?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 4, "start": 720, "end": 1007, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Can Yasir Qadhi's zombie theory of Gog and Magog be defended?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 5, "start": 1007, "end": 1349, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "What did Yasir Qadhi say about Mufti Abu Layth on the Mad Mamluks podcast?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 6, "start": 1349, "end": 1533, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Do most Sunnis consider Wahhabis and Salafis to be Sunni?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 7, "start": 1533, "end": 1687, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Who were the Mu'tazila and what did they believe?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 8, "start": 1687, "end": 1990, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Does the Quran say Jesus was born of a virgin?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 9, "start": 1990, "end": 2439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Is it inconsistent to reinterpret Gog and Magog by geography but not other beliefs by science?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 10, "start": 2439, "end": 2819, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Did the Salafi movement play a part in producing modern extremism?"}, {"video": "sMOOcEVIGDE", "n": 11, "start": 2819, "end": 2926, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191103", "title": "Can old interpretations of the Quran be revisited, and what role does reason play?"}, {"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 299, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228", "title": "Why is it so hard for Muslims to find a partner?"}, {"video": "sgwylUg7XU0", "n": 2, "start": 299, "end": 544, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190228", "title": "Plans for a live Q&A, contact details and sign-off"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 1, "start": 8, "end": 89, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518", "title": "Statement on the break-in at Mufti Abu Layth's home"}, {"video": "t9EI_hrzL84", "n": 2, "start": 89, "end": 547, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210518", "title": "Response to accusations over Palestine remarks and claims he is not Muslim"}, {"video": "tZNGKXyIaxU", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 84, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200303", "title": "What does the Mufti think of Shaykh Ramadan al-Buti?"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 418, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210", "title": "Yasir Qadhi's reply to Jay Smith over 'holes in the standard narrative'"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 2, "start": 418, "end": 837, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210", "title": "Is Jay Smith a reliable critic of the Quran's preservation?"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 3, "start": 837, "end": 1183, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210", "title": "Yasir Qadhi still has not explained his 'holes in the narrative'"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 4, "start": 1183, "end": 1714, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210", "title": "Was the Quran always fixed word for word, or was it flexible at first?"}, {"video": "ttQ_CXlVaso", "n": 5, "start": 1714, "end": 2099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201210", "title": "Can we substitute words of the Quran today as the companions did?"}, {"video": "uBbLk0EhDGk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 372, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180409", "title": "Does the Dajjal (Antichrist) exist in Islam?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 394, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "What are the layers behind the Palestinian crisis of May 2021?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 2, "start": 394, "end": 709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "What can ordinary people do about the Palestinian crisis, and do social-media posts help?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 3, "start": 709, "end": 866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "Do protests help Palestine, and was blocking the roads in Birmingham justified?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 4, "start": 866, "end": 1099, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "What solutions are possible for Palestine?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 5, "start": 1099, "end": 1257, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "Is the Gaza conflict a war or a genocide, and who is egging Palestinians on?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 6, "start": 1257, "end": 1489, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "Is there archaeological evidence for David's kingdom, and how did Jerusalem become holy for Muslims?"}, {"video": "uMKu_OCFTes", "n": 7, "start": 1489, "end": 1868, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210515", "title": "What can people realistically do for Palestine, and is migration an option?"}, {"video": "uVRr1jjbLEs", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 66, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180305", "title": "Is it haram for men to wear earrings?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 124, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Opening: riba as a complex, over-claimed and symbolic subject"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 2, "start": 124, "end": 331, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say riba has become a symbol rather than something people understand?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 3, "start": 331, "end": 556, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "What was the riba of the jahiliyyah that the Quran condemned?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 4, "start": 556, "end": 856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "What is riba al-fadl and what does the hadith on gold, silver, wheat, barley, dates and salt say?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 5, "start": 856, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Does the Quran forbid every kind of excess when it forbids riba?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1306, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Did the scholars ever agree on what counts as riba?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 7, "start": 1306, "end": 1785, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Are mortgages and bank loans the riba forbidden in the Quran?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 8, "start": 1785, "end": 2219, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "How was the economy of the Prophet's time different from today's?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 9, "start": 2219, "end": 2499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "How did Adam Smith and industrialisation change attitudes to greed and lending?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 10, "start": 2499, "end": 2843, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "How can a bank lend out more money than it has?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 11, "start": 2843, "end": 3105, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Why did the Quran declare war on riba?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 12, "start": 3105, "end": 3402, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Is an Islamic mortgage any different from a conventional mortgage?"}, {"video": "ucdrbLyGY70", "n": 13, "start": 3402, "end": 3607, "tier": "machine", "date": "20171019", "title": "Are student loans, car finance and mortgages haram?"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 313, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012", "title": "Why the circumstances of the marriage rule out a six-year-old Aisha"}, {"video": "udJveM_S0sY", "n": 2, "start": 313, "end": 558, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201012", "title": "Writers who place Aisha in her teens, and how narrators exaggerated ages"}, {"video": "udmzRAYYgfI", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 245, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220108", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say he wronged Dawah Man?"}, {"video": "ueCmAZD-LXw", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 200, "tier": "machine", "date": "20151227", "title": "Can I say Merry Christmas to non-Muslims?"}, {"video": "umPepYIsc_g", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 59, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210704", "title": "Is it wrong to want to be rich?"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 239, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020", "title": "Why do critics refuse to debate the authenticity of Sahih al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 2, "start": 239, "end": 397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020", "title": "Who vouched for al-Farabri, the transmitter of Sahih al-Bukhari?"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 3, "start": 397, "end": 633, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020", "title": "Why do preachers attack views in public that they tolerate in private?"}, {"video": "v-1HD1uAMBM", "n": 4, "start": 633, "end": 787, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201020", "title": "Why do scholars avoid showing unity across Barelvi, Deobandi and Salafi lines?"}, {"video": "v8pLoq2vpUY", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 287, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190817", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of Shaykh Saqib Shaami?"}, {"video": "vF5yuEYz9Vo", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 274, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180612", "title": "Do I have to grow a beard?"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 157, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902", "title": "What did Daniel Haqiqatjou say about Yasir Qadhi calling verses mushkil?"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 2, "start": 157, "end": 311, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902", "title": "What is the background to the feud between Daniel Haqiqatjou and Jonathan Brown?"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 3, "start": 311, "end": 557, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902", "title": "Does mushkil mean ambiguous or problematic?"}, {"video": "vGoAxXEHpHk", "n": 4, "start": 557, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200902", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth make of the Brown and Haqiqatjou dispute over mushkil?"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 496, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119", "title": "Where do Neanderthals fit in the Islamic story of Adam?"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 2, "start": 496, "end": 610, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119", "title": "Neanderthals were more intelligent than people think"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 3, "start": 610, "end": 836, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119", "title": "Did humans and Neanderthals interbreed?"}, {"video": "voxmwEQ6rz4", "n": 4, "start": 836, "end": 954, "tier": "machine", "date": "20220119", "title": "Is it true that Africans have no Neanderthal DNA?"}, {"video": "vrR5CWw8asg", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211222", "title": "What do Sunni Muslims think of the twelve Shia imams?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 1, "start": 27, "end": 467, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth opens the stream and lists tonight's topics"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 2, "start": 467, "end": 731, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Which civil war did early Muslims mean by 'the fitnah'?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 3, "start": 731, "end": 1562, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "How do I heal my inner child, and how should I raise my children?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 4, "start": 1562, "end": 2027, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Why don't scholars like Yasir Qadhi come on Mind Trap with you?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 5, "start": 2027, "end": 2578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth's sixth-form story: walking out and landing a college place by mistake"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 6, "start": 2578, "end": 2815, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Who do you think will win the US election?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 7, "start": 2815, "end": 3022, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth's chat round: answering critics, soft drinks and Syrian rue"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 8, "start": 3022, "end": 3613, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "What does 'justice' mean in the Quran's verse on marrying more than one wife?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 9, "start": 3613, "end": 4206, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Is Sharia-compliant investing really different from normal investing?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 10, "start": 4206, "end": 4332, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth's chat round: Sunni and Maliki, beards and quick answers"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 11, "start": 4332, "end": 4720, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Does God really care whether I have a beard?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 12, "start": 4720, "end": 4872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Did the Prophet forbid Ali from taking a second wife?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 13, "start": 4872, "end": 5270, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Why do imams in the West wear 'Islamic' robes?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 14, "start": 5270, "end": 5626, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Are there other narrations of Aisha's age besides Bukhari's?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 15, "start": 5626, "end": 6117, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Are jinn just archetypes in our unconscious mind?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 16, "start": 6117, "end": 6691, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Why is Khabib such a hero to Muslims?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 17, "start": 6813, "end": 7662, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Should Muslims boycott France over the cartoons?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 18, "start": 7662, "end": 7742, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Would you debate Mohammed Hijab or talk with Richard Dawkins?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 19, "start": 7742, "end": 8310, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Was it right to slap someone for insulting Islam?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 20, "start": 8310, "end": 8491, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Would you debate a Salafi scholar?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 21, "start": 8491, "end": 8862, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Who were the Bedouin Arabs criticised in Surah al-Tawbah?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 22, "start": 8862, "end": 9087, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Can a non-Muslim descendant of the Prophet claim sharif status?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 23, "start": 9087, "end": 9359, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Is non-halal chicken and beef actually haram?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 24, "start": 9359, "end": 9856, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "What do you think about men who 'simp' for women?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 25, "start": 9856, "end": 10002, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "How do I stop hating people who hurt me?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 26, "start": 10002, "end": 10196, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth's chat round: Birmingham over London and channel housekeeping"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 27, "start": 10196, "end": 10262, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Can I recite the Quran in the shower?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 28, "start": 10262, "end": 10339, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Why do you believe in God and that the Quran is from God?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 29, "start": 10339, "end": 10439, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Do people with schizophrenia have real religious insight?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 30, "start": 10439, "end": 10820, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Is the second coming of Jesus the right answer to the Qadianis?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 31, "start": 10820, "end": 11487, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Did Imam Malik say that Jesus died?"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 32, "start": 11487, "end": 11766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth mocks a critic's clip on intimacy and slit bedsheets"}, {"video": "w6TqWuUumCg", "n": 33, "start": 11766, "end": 11871, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201027", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth closes the stream and announces Mind Trap"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 1, "start": 7, "end": 119, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Opening: sound check, and Facebook stars now visible"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 2, "start": 119, "end": 230, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Mufti Abu Layth introduces his guest, Shaykh Omar Baloch"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 3, "start": 230, "end": 578, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Who did Shaykh Omar Baloch study with?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 4, "start": 578, "end": 872, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "What is Imran Hosein's approach, and why did he disagree with Israr Ahmed?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 5, "start": 872, "end": 1296, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is there an order and coherence to the surahs of the Quran?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 6, "start": 1296, "end": 1375, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "The stream drops and comes back"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 7, "start": 1375, "end": 1645, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is America losing its place in the world?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 8, "start": 1645, "end": 1993, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Why do so many people admire Trump's style?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 9, "start": 1993, "end": 2173, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Are mosques in America at risk from far-right anger?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 10, "start": 2173, "end": 2327, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Will people's better judgement win out over hatred?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 11, "start": 2327, "end": 2479, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "What does defunding the police mean in practice?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 12, "start": 2479, "end": 2788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Why is America so polarised?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 13, "start": 2788, "end": 3017, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Will AI destroy jobs or create new ones?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 14, "start": 3017, "end": 3167, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Does the Quran predict that modern industrial society will collapse?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 15, "start": 3167, "end": 3511, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is humanity better off today than ever before?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 16, "start": 3511, "end": 3744, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Have nuclear weapons made the world more peaceful?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 17, "start": 3744, "end": 3936, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Does the Quran say every city will be destroyed before Judgement Day?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 18, "start": 3936, "end": 4130, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is the world getting better or worse?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 19, "start": 4130, "end": 4364, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Are people basically good, or is the system the problem?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 20, "start": 4364, "end": 4593, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "How did Iqbal see Western civilisation?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 21, "start": 4593, "end": 4866, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is Western culture uniquely shallow?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 22, "start": 4866, "end": 5060, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "What is the main theme of Surah al-Kahf?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 23, "start": 5060, "end": 5171, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Why is lending money for profit considered wrong in Islam?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 24, "start": 5171, "end": 5443, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Can the bank take my whole house if I default near the end of my mortgage?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 25, "start": 5443, "end": 5753, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is it better to rent or to take a mortgage?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 26, "start": 5753, "end": 6139, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is bank interest the same as the riba forbidden in the Quran?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 27, "start": 6139, "end": 6413, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Why might the Quran's ban on riba not apply to modern loans?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 28, "start": 6413, "end": 6643, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Does bank lending help society prosper?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 29, "start": 6643, "end": 6910, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is investing as a partner better than lending at interest?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 30, "start": 6910, "end": 7144, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is it wrong to expect something back when you lend money?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 31, "start": 7144, "end": 7453, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Does the Quran motivate people through self-interest?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 32, "start": 7453, "end": 7571, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Are the descriptions of paradise in the Quran literal?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 33, "start": 7571, "end": 7953, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Are Islamic mortgages really different from normal mortgages?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 34, "start": 7953, "end": 8341, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is an Islamic economic system realistic or utopian?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 35, "start": 8341, "end": 8532, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Is bank interest the riba that the Quran forbids?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 36, "start": 8532, "end": 8724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Should Pakistan allow a Hindu temple to be built in Islamabad?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 37, "start": 8724, "end": 8840, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Was it right for Turkey to turn the Hagia Sophia back into a mosque?"}, {"video": "wCe73zqCi_I", "n": 38, "start": 8840, "end": 8923, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200710", "title": "Closing: a promised episode on Dhul-Qarnayn, and goodbyes"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 112, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112", "title": "How did Hamza Ali Abbasi do in his debate with Harris Sultan?"}, {"video": "wkhoro-Qb20", "n": 2, "start": 112, "end": 318, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200112", "title": "Is it good that Hamza Ali Abbasi left showbiz for religion?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 1, "start": 54, "end": 181, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Opening: welcoming Dr Khalil Andani to MindTrap"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 2, "start": 181, "end": 408, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Who is Dr Khalil Andani and how did he come to study Islam academically?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 3, "start": 408, "end": 779, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Did Muslims always see the Quran as God's word in the form of a book?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 4, "start": 779, "end": 1198, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "What difference does it make that the Quran was first oral and only later written down?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 5, "start": 1198, "end": 1356, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Did revelation end with the Prophet, or does inspiration continue?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 6, "start": 1356, "end": 1678, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Does 'Kitab' in the Quran mean a book?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 7, "start": 1678, "end": 2033, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Is the 'Book of Allah' the same thing as the written Quran?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 8, "start": 2033, "end": 2384, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Do Ash'aris and Maturidis believe the Arabic Quran is God's eternal speech?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 9, "start": 2384, "end": 2784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Why do so many Muslims think God speaks Arabic if their scholars said otherwise?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 10, "start": 2784, "end": 3031, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Is the Ash'ari view of God's speech really different from the Mu'tazili view?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 11, "start": 3031, "end": 3153, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Is Arabic an eternal, divine language?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 12, "start": 3153, "end": 3450, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Was revelation words dictated by Gabriel, or inspiration the Prophet put into words?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 13, "start": 3450, "end": 3788, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "How reliable is the story of the first revelation in the cave?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 14, "start": 3788, "end": 4202, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Were the companions allowed to change words of the Quran, and was that only a temporary concession?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 15, "start": 4202, "end": 4844, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "How did Muslim theologians reconcile God being one with his many names and attributes?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 16, "start": 4844, "end": 5044, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Do Salafis believe God has a body?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 17, "start": 5044, "end": 5325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Where do anthropomorphic ideas of God in Islam come from?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 18, "start": 5325, "end": 5590, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Viewer questions begin; the guest's connection drops"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 19, "start": 5590, "end": 5702, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Is love one of God's attributes in Islam?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 20, "start": 5702, "end": 5811, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "If the Quran wasn't a book, why is it on a heavenly tablet?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 21, "start": 5811, "end": 5918, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Is the Quran eternal, or was it created?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 22, "start": 5918, "end": 6008, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Does God not love non-believers?"}, {"video": "xznXIYp0B5s", "n": 23, "start": 6008, "end": 6103, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200703", "title": "Closing: where to find the guest, and sign-off"}, {"video": "y-JDMojFGnU", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230526", "title": "What is the funeral prayer and what do you say in it?"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 380, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601", "title": "If a religious teacher seduces someone, is the other person also to blame?"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 2, "start": 380, "end": 534, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601", "title": "Is it worse to use religion as a cover for wrongdoing?"}, {"video": "y9P342Tx6T0", "n": 3, "start": 534, "end": 634, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200601", "title": "Should a person accused of magic be killed?"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 476, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220", "title": "Does Islam say homosexuals should be thrown off buildings or executed?"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 2, "start": 476, "end": 1107, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220", "title": "Were there Muslim scholars and caliphs in history known to be homosexual?"}, {"video": "yFeJ-QkS-kM", "n": 3, "start": 1107, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20181220", "title": "Is homosexuality haram in Islam, and why were the people of Lut destroyed?"}, {"video": "yJGrP8cVk-M", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 304, "tier": "machine", "date": "20191212", "title": "Is it haram to kiss my wife in public?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 238, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Did God really command Ibrahim to sacrifice his son?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 2, "start": 238, "end": 475, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Where did the idea of sacrificing a son come from in Ibrahim's time?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 3, "start": 475, "end": 715, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Does the Quran say the sacrifice of Ibrahim's son was a test from God?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 4, "start": 715, "end": 874, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Why did most commentators say God commanded the sacrifice?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 5, "start": 874, "end": 1032, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Is it wrong to believe that God asked Ibrahim to kill his son?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 6, "start": 1032, "end": 1269, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Why does the biblical tradition say God commanded Abraham to sacrifice his son?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 7, "start": 1269, "end": 1425, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Did the classical scholars ever question whether God would command Ibrahim to kill his son?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 8, "start": 1425, "end": 1503, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "Are Muslims who believe God commanded the sacrifice guilty of blasphemy?"}, {"video": "yRuC09ajKEQ", "n": 9, "start": 1503, "end": 1798, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201028", "title": "If God never commanded the sacrifice, why do the early sources all say he did?"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 1, "start": 2, "end": 240, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104", "title": "Is masturbation haram in Islam?"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 2, "start": 240, "end": 398, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104", "title": "Reaction to the clip: Qadhi joins Zakir Naik in calling it not haram, with jokes about 'the nobility'"}, {"video": "yZrVPdcKjxQ", "n": 3, "start": 398, "end": 760, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210104", "title": "Why are Salafi scholars now saying masturbation is not a sin after years of calling it haram?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 155, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "Who was al-Khidr and why is he called the green one?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 2, "start": 155, "end": 502, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "What happened between Musa and al-Khidr in Surat al-Kahf?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 3, "start": 502, "end": 842, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "Was the story of Musa and al-Khidr a dream?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 4, "start": 842, "end": 1368, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "Is al-Khidr a prophet, and is he still alive?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 5, "start": 1368, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "Is al-Khidr a real person who is still alive?"}, {"video": "yy74XfRo_E4", "n": 6, "start": 1747, "end": 1839, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190114", "title": "Closing: removing the cobwebs of folklore, and sign-off"}, {"video": "z06drwxqxGE", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 518, "tier": "machine", "date": "20201209", "title": "Is it haram for men to wear necklaces, rings or earrings?"}, {"video": "z6Ay73O7Dug", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 591, "tier": "machine", "date": "20211006", "title": "Is there a sahih hadith on where to put my hands in salah?"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 237, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420", "title": "Was Abu Hanifa considered a deviant by the scholars of his time?"}, {"video": "zN1-WlBys2I", "n": 2, "start": 237, "end": 350, "tier": "machine", "date": "20180420", "title": "Can people with very different religious views still talk with respect?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 572, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "How should Muslims read the stories in the Quran?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 2, "start": 572, "end": 958, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "If God can do anything, why not take the miracles in Quranic stories literally?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 3, "start": 958, "end": 1110, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "Does the Quran criticise the Queen of Sheba for ruling over men?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 4, "start": 1110, "end": 1494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "Was the hoopoe in the story of Sulayman really a bird?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 5, "start": 1494, "end": 1648, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "What does the Quran say about kings in the story of Sheba?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 6, "start": 1648, "end": 2034, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "Did a jinn really bring the Queen of Sheba's throne to Sulayman?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 7, "start": 2034, "end": 2451, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "Did Prophet Sulayman steal the Queen of Sheba's throne?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 8, "start": 2451, "end": 2709, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "What happened when the Queen of Sheba came to Sulayman?"}, {"video": "zOTvTgdUMV8", "n": 9, "start": 2709, "end": 3319, "tier": "machine", "date": "20190108", "title": "Did Jesus really speak as a baby in the cradle?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 1, "start": 32, "end": 494, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Opening: sound check, a critic's reaction video, the Peak District and the latest MindTrap"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 2, "start": 494, "end": 757, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "News clip: the Pharaohs' Golden Parade in Cairo, and the Amenhotep III theory"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 3, "start": 757, "end": 1176, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "An Urdu poem of living on after the beloved"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 4, "start": 1176, "end": 1271, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Preview of tonight's continued response to Yasir Qadhi"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 5, "start": 1271, "end": 1397, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Is forex trading halal or haram?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 6, "start": 1397, "end": 2162, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Can I carry a child while I pray?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 7, "start": 2162, "end": 2550, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Jealousy, entitlement and the critics who resent his following"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 8, "start": 2550, "end": 2994, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Perfume reviews: his top two fragrances"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 9, "start": 2994, "end": 3289, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did the Prophet say a wife should prostrate to her husband?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 10, "start": 3289, "end": 3861, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did Mufti Abu Layth say incest is natural, and is homosexuality unnatural?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 11, "start": 3861, "end": 4371, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Are disgusting sexual fetishes between spouses haram?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 12, "start": 4371, "end": 4895, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Why are some clerics so harsh in their rulings on women?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 13, "start": 4895, "end": 5335, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "What does Mufti Abu Layth think of France banning the hijab for girls under 18?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 14, "start": 5335, "end": 5472, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Is the age of consent in France really 13?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 15, "start": 5472, "end": 5656, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Quick chat items: critics seeking attention, a claim about Foucault, steroids and a joke question"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 16, "start": 5656, "end": 5740, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Is it haram to believe the universe will never end?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 17, "start": 5740, "end": 6114, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "How often does Mufti Abu Layth change his views, and is that a weakness?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 18, "start": 6114, "end": 6603, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "How was Mufti Abu Layth's video on Aisha's age received?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 19, "start": 6603, "end": 6770, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Where can I learn the Maliki school in English?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 20, "start": 6770, "end": 7374, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Are insects haram to eat in the Maliki school?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 21, "start": 7374, "end": 7823, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "How can I nourish my soul this Ramadan?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 22, "start": 7823, "end": 7983, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Does Allah love everybody?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 23, "start": 7983, "end": 8243, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "What does Yasir Qadhi argue about Malikis and the return of Jesus?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 24, "start": 8243, "end": 8705, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did Imam Malik believe Jesus will return?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 25, "start": 8705, "end": 9054, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Why does the Muwatta contain hadith that Imam Malik did not follow?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 26, "start": 9054, "end": 9810, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did the Prophet really spy on a boy he thought was the Dajjal?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 27, "start": 9810, "end": 10290, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Where does the belief in the Mahdi come from?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 28, "start": 10290, "end": 10716, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Are the signs of the Hour part of Islamic creed?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 29, "start": 10716, "end": 11208, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Why does Mufti Abu Layth say it is not a huge claim that Imam Malik denied the second coming?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 30, "start": 11208, "end": 11456, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "A critic's reaction video: the Wahhabi jibe and the setup"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 31, "start": 11456, "end": 11686, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Does Mufti Abu Layth have any scholarly precedent for his views?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 32, "start": 11686, "end": 11956, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did Noah really live 950 years?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 33, "start": 11956, "end": 12401, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did Abraham really cut up birds that came back to life?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 34, "start": 12401, "end": 12784, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did the parting of the sea have a natural explanation?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 35, "start": 12784, "end": 12961, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Was the murdered man in the story of the cow brought back to life?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 36, "start": 12961, "end": 13228, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Was Solomon's hudhud really a bird?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 37, "start": 13228, "end": 13506, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Did Jesus survive the crucifixion?"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 38, "start": 13506, "end": 13970, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Donors, deathbed remarks and 'no hatred': an invitation to the critic"}, {"video": "zZ85AUzeK5w", "n": 39, "start": 13970, "end": 14312, "tier": "machine", "date": "20210406", "title": "Closing: super chats, a session before Ramadan, and a revolution of hearts and minds"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 1, "start": 0, "end": 79, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407", "title": "Instructions to moderators: block haters, not provocative questions"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 2, "start": 79, "end": 499, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407", "title": "Do the prophets' bodies decay in the grave?"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 3, "start": 499, "end": 766, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407", "title": "Does the Mufti teach disrespect for the Prophet?"}, {"video": "z__38zt8FlQ", "n": 4, "start": 766, "end": 959, "tier": "machine", "date": "20200407", "title": "Message to critics: criticise truthfully, not with lies"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 1, "start": 6, "end": 325, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Apostasy: execution as divine policy, tribal loyalty and treason in wartime"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 2, "start": 325, "end": 407, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "The verse on men having a degree over women, read in its passage"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 3, "start": 415, "end": 885, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Western human rights, unquestioned presuppositions and the labels liberal and conservative"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 4, "start": 885, "end": 1043, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Riba and Ibn Abbas: his disagreement on riba and his combining of prayers"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 5, "start": 1043, "end": 1435, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Is morality innate? Language acquisition, divine command, and insecurity in faith"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 6, "start": 1435, "end": 1747, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Ritualisation of the deen and the angels' question about Adam: can believers ask?"}, {"video": "zbyA7rqfyRU", "n": 7, "start": 1747, "end": 1976, "tier": "machine", "date": "20160315", "title": "Creation before Adam: Neanderthals, bashar and insan, and the formation of man"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 1, "start": 1, "end": 409, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419", "title": "Did Imam Malik reject the hadith he did not act on?"}, {"video": "zkklciv1TK8", "n": 2, "start": 409, "end": 724, "tier": "machine", "date": "20230419", "title": "Why does the practice of Madinah matter more than a single hadith?"}, {"video": "zlXm19MtE2A", "n": 1, "start": 5, "end": 324, "tier": "machine", "date": "20170517", "title": "Does masturbation break my fast?"}]}